Top Banner
RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader Mechanical Engineering Joshua Baker Mechanical Engineering Victoria Schoennagel Mechanical Engineering Aimee Lemieux Mechanical Engineering Aaron Grilly Mechanical Engineering Tzu-Chie Fu Computer Engineering Cuong Le Computer Engineering David Hein Mechanical Engineering Atul Phadnis Electrical Engineering J.E.D. Hess Mechanical Engineering Dr. Jeffrey Kozak Team Advisor Mechanical Engineering
61

Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

Jun 26, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

RIT Micro Air VehiclePreliminary Design Presentation

Brian Gillis

Team Leader

Mechanical Engineering

Joshua Baker

Mechanical Engineering

Victoria Schoennagel

Mechanical Engineering

Aimee Lemieux

Mechanical Engineering

Aaron Grilly

Mechanical Engineering

Tzu-Chie Fu

Computer Engineering

Cuong Le

Computer Engineering

David Hein

Mechanical Engineering

Atul Phadnis

Electrical Engineering

J.E.D. Hess

Mechanical Engineering

Dr. Jeffrey Kozak

Team Advisor

Mechanical Engineering

Page 2: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

OutlineI. BackgroundII. Design ObjectivesIII. Work TimelineIV. Airframe SelectionV. Electronics SelectionVI. Propulsion Selection MAV Team

05-001

Airframe Electronics Propulsion

Joshua BakerAaron GrillyDavid HeinJED Hess

Cuong LeTzu-Chie FuAtul Phadnis

Aimee LemieuxVictoria Schoennagel

Page 3: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Background• According to DARPA, a Micro

Air Vehicle (MAV) has a maximum linear dimension of 6 inches.

• Primarily being researched for surveillance and reconnaissance operations.

• Other possible uses include forest fire detection, Bio-Chemical detection, etc.

• Annual MAV competition where various teams compete in surveillance missions and flight performance tests.

Page 4: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Design Objectives• Vehicle with a minimum linear dimension of 15 inches• Vehicle can be scaled down in size and still produce

acceptable flight• Vehicle must be a new design, not rely on last year’s design• Airframe should be built out of composite materials if deemed

reasonable• Vehicle must have GPS navigation capabilities along with

video surveillance• Performance Goals

– 15 Minutes of flight time– 600 Meter range

• Attend International MAV Competition in Seoul, Korea• Remain within $3,000 budget (excluding travel funding)

Page 5: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Work Timeline

Page 6: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Work Timeline

Page 7: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe Selection

Page 8: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe Main Objectives

1. Flying Wing Configuration2. Modular Design3. Maximum Linear Dimension of 15 Inches4. Research and Test Unconventional Ideas5. Scalable Platform Upon Which to Base

Future Designs

Page 9: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe - Airfoils• E174• E186• EH2012• EH3012• FX63-137• GOE417a• M10• M12• M14

• MH46• RAF6• S1210• S2027• S4022• S4083• S5010• S5020• SD7080

• E174• E186• EH2012• EH3012• FX63-137• GOE417a• M10• M12• M14

• MH46• RAF6• S1210• S2027• S4022• S4083• S5010• S5020• SD7080

• GOE417a

• S1210

• S4022• S4083

To Be Tested in the Wind TunnelSurvived First Round of CutsXFLR5 Testing (Computer Simulation)

Page 10: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

S1210

S4022

S4083

GOE417a

Page 11: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cl vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-1.00

-0.50

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cl (

Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

GOE417a, 100,000

S1210, 100,000

S4022, 100,000

S4083, 100,000

Page 12: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

A irfo il S40

83

S12

10

S40

22

GO

E41

7a

N o rm alized S co re 100% 94% 91% 79% R ela tiv e R an k 1 2 3 4

Evaluation of each concept against the baseline: 1 = much worse than baseline 2 = worse than baseline 3 = same as baseline 4 = better than baseline 5= much better than baseline

E17

4

E18

6

EH

2012

EH

3012

FX63

137

GO

E41

7a

M10

M12

M14

MH

46

RA

F6

S12

10

S20

27

S40

22

S40

83

S50

10

S50

20

SD

7080

RR

ee llaa tt

ii vvee

WWee ii

gg hhtt

LLooww RReeyynnoollddss nnuummbbeerr aaiirrffooiill 3.0 3.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 5.0 3.5 1.0 2.0 3.0 1.0 5.0 3.0 5.0 5.0 4.0 5.0 4.0 8%

KKnnoowwnn pprriioorr uussee oonn aann MMAAVV 1.0 1.0 3.0 3.0 1.0 5.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 4.0 1.0 5.0 1.0 4.0 5.0 4.0 4.0 3.0 11%

MMaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg eeaassee aanndd aaccccuurraaccyy 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 5.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 4.0 4.5 3.0 4.5 4.0 4.0 3.5 4.0 6%

MMaannuuffaaccttuurriinngg ttiimmee 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 0%

RReeaassoonnaabbllee ccaammbbeerr ((11%%--88%%)) 3.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 4.0 1.0 1.0 3.0 2.5 1.0 5.0 2.0 4.0 5.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 11%

SSoommee rreefflleexx iinn ddeessiiggnn 1.0 4.0 3.0 3.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 4.5 2.0 14%

RReeaassoonnaabbllee,, llooggiiccaall ggrraapphhss ((XXFFLLRR55)) 3.5 3.0 3.5 3.5 3.0 2.0 2.0 3.5 3.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 3.0 3.0 4.0 19%

CCll//CCdd 3.5 3.0 3.0 3.0 4.8 5.0 2.0 2.8 3.2 3.0 3.0 5.0 3.5 5.0 4.8 3.0 3.0 3.0 19%

CCmm 3.0 1.0 3.0 2.0 4.9 3.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 2.5 3.0 3.0 4.6 5.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 11% WWeeiigghhtteedd SSccoorree 2.7 2.5 2.9 2.7 2.7 3.7 2.1 2.3 2.7 3.1 2.3 4.3 2.6 4.2 4.6 3.1 3.4 3.1

NNoorrmmaalliizzeedd SSccoorree 58% 53% 62% 58% 58% 79% 45% 50% 59% 66% 50% 94% 57% 91% 100% 68% 74% 67%

Airfoil Feasibility Assessment

Page 13: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe - Planform

• Rectangular• Zimmerman• Inverse Zimmerman• Circle/Elliptical• Modified Inverse

Zimmerman

• Most Likely Design: Straight Leading Edge Approximation of the Inverse Zimmerman Planform

Page 14: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe - Composition• Balsa Wood with Canvas• Foam (Polystyrene)• Foam with Single Fiberglass

Layer• Carbon Fiber• Carbon Fiber with Lightening

Holes• Composite (Kevlar, Fiberglass)

• Foam and Fiberglass Combination will be Used for Testing, Composition of Final MAV Airframe Still to be Determined

Page 15: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe – Pod Location

• Mounted Above Wing• Mounted Below Wing• Between Bi-Wing• Suspended Below Wing

• Most Likely Design: Mounted Below Wing

Page 16: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe – Control Surfaces• Options Considered

– Vertical Tail (and Elevator)• Single (High or Low Orientation Possible)• Double (High or Low Orientation Possible)• Angled Vertical Tail

– Winglets• Vertical Winglets• Angled Winglets

– Canards– Elevators– Ailerons– Elevons

• Current Approach: V-Tail Protruding from Pod, Extending Beneath Wing. Elevator to be Integrated if Necessary

Page 17: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Future Analysis

• Test Airfoils• Control Surface

Sizing and Location• Airframe Prototype

(March 14th)• Refine Design• Evaluate and Test

Radical Ideas

Page 18: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Electronics Selection

Page 19: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Full System Design

Page 20: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Components• Onboard RF Controller/Receiver• Onboard Speed Controller• Onboard Servos (Actuators)• Onboard Video System

– Video Transceiver & Camera• Passive Antenna Array• Onboard GPS System

– Onboard GPS Receiver– Onboard GPS Video Overlay Board

• Batteries

Page 21: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard RF Controller/Receiver• RF Controller Selected:

– Futaba 6YGE 72 MHz RF Controller• Onboard RF Receiver Selected:

– GWS NARO R-6NH/V Receiver• Channels: 6• Size: 20 x 30 x 9.5 (mm)• Weight: 8.8 g

We selected the GWS NARO R-6N receiver due to its 6 channel design. This allowed for improvements in the form of additional onboard feature/control devices.

Compatibility of the controller/receiver has been verified since both use the Futaba data transmission format.

Page 22: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Speed Controller

• Onboard Speed Controller Selected:– Phoenix-10

The Phoenix-10 speed controller is the leading candidate to be chosen due to its compatibility with the DC motor that is being recommended by the propulsion subgroup.

Page 23: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Servos (Actuators)

• Onboard Servos Selected:– Wes-Technik LS-2.0

• Time to Full Deflection (sec): 0.15• Max Output Force: 160 g• Dimensions (mm): 21 X 13 X 9• Load Current: < 100 mA• Weight: 2 g

The LS-2.0 is the suitable choice for this project since weight is considered to be one of the most important factors.

Page 24: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Video System• Video System Selected:

– Black Widow’s 200 mw Brown Bag Kit• 200 mw transmitter/receiver set• NTSC 5V Color CCD Camera• 8 dbi Circular Polarized Patch Antenna

The 200 mw transmitter/receiver set has been selected to increase the transmission range of the video signal from the MAV to the base station. This increase in range is a critical solution to a previous performance issue of signal propagation failure.

Page 25: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Passive Antenna Array

• Passive Antenna Array Selected:– Leading candidate Hyperlink

HG2414P• Horizontal/Vertical Beamwidth (deg): 30/30• Gain (Directivity): 14 dB

It is ideal to have an antenna that has a balance between the coverage area and the gain. Therefore, the HG2414P is chosen for its fairly good coverage area and an acceptable gain.

Page 26: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard GPS System• GPS System Selected:

– UNAV PICO-GPS-SS (GPS Receiver)

• Size: 1.8” x 1.25” x 0.6”• Weight: 28 g

– UNAV OSD-GPS (GPS Video Overlay Board)

• Size: 2.5” x 2.5” x 0.5”• Weight: 22.4 g

We selected the UNAV GPS system due to its small size and weight. Also, the UNAV GPS receiver is complimented by the UNAV video overlay board. These components have already been tested and represents a completely integrated system for GPS data acquisition.

Page 27: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Batteries• Onboard Battery Cells

– Leading Candidate Kokam SLPB433452• Capacity: 740 mAh• Voltage: 3.7 V• Dimensions (mm): 52 X 33.5 X 4.35• Volume (mm3): 7577.7• Weight: 15 g

We have selected the Kokam battery family to supply the onboard current and voltage requirements. Battery packs can be custom made in serial or parallel configurations based on power requirements. Once the total power needs are known, a final battery package can be selected.

Page 28: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Selection

Page 29: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Brainstorming

Power System Options• IC Engine

• Electric Motor

• Rocket Propulsion

Propeller Options• Off The Shelf Item

• Modified Off The Shelf

• In House Fabrication

Page 30: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Computation

eARd

dCddC

ddC

l

l

L

2

1801

πα

αα

+

=eARCCC L

DD π

2

0 +=L

D

CCWT =

vPT 97.101

=

Initial Values Revised Values

All Estimated ValuesVariables 2004 2005dC l /dα 0.1 0.1

AR 1.422 1.422S (m 2 ) 0.048 0.102b (m) 0.26 0.381

e 0.9 0.9dC L /dα 0.041 0.041

AOA (deg) 9 9C L 0.95 0.95

W (g) 97.9 202.35C D 0.243 0.252C D0 0.018 0.027T (g) 25 53.598

Based on Chosen ElectronicsVariables 2004 2005dC l /dα 0.1 0.1

AR 1.422 1.422S (m 2 ) 0.048 0.102b (m) 0.26 0.381

e 0.9 0.9dC L /dα 0.041 0.041

AOA (deg) 9 9C L 0.95 0.95

W (g) 97.9 198.48C D 0.243 0.252C D0 0.018 0.027T (g) 25 52.573

Page 31: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Feasibility AssessmentEvaluate each additional concept against the baseline, score each attribute as: 0 = much worse than baseline concept 1 = worse than

baseline 2 = same as baseline 3 = better than baselinePropeller

Thru

st

Cost

Wei

ght

Curr

ent

Volt

age

Add

itio

nal 1

Add

itio

nal 2

Wei

ghte

d Sc

ore

Nor

mal

ized

Sco

re

T = 105-130 g; C = $20-80; W = 15-20 g; I = 0.8-1 A; V = 7-9 V ----- 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2.00 94%

GW/EDP-50XC Direct Drive Power System with 2/EP-3020 EP3020 0 3 2 1 2 0 0 1.40 66%

GW/EDP-50XC Direct Drive Power System with 2/EP-3020 EP3020 0 3 2 2 3 0 0 1.60 75%

Feigao 1208430S 12x22mm Brushless Motor EP7060 2 2 3 1 2 0 0 2.13 100%

GW/EDP-150 Motor w/Capacitor & 2-Pin Black Motor Connector EP4530 1 3 0 1 3 0 0 1.27 59%

B2C Light Power System (GW/LPS-B2C-C) EP7035 0 3 3 3 2 0 0 1.93 91%

B2C Light Power System (GW/LPS-B2C-C) EP7060 0 3 3 2 3 0 0 1.87 88%

B2C Light Power System (GW/LPS-B2C-C) EP7060 0 3 3 2 2 0 0 1.80 84%

RXC Light Power System (GW/LPS-RXC-A) EP7060 0 3 1 2 3 0 0 1.33 63%

RXC Light Power System (GW/LPS-RXC-A) EP7060 0 3 1 1 3 0 0 1.20 56%

RXC Light Power System (GW/LPS-RXC-A) EP8043 1 3 1 1 3 0 0 1.53 72%

RXC Light Power System (GW/LPS-RXC-A) EP8060 0 3 1 2 3 0 0 1.33 63%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 V 14T Direct Drive Motor) 5.5 x 4 MAS 3 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.47 69%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 V 14T Direct Drive Motor) 5.5 x 4 MAS 3 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.47 69%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 G 14T Geared Motor) APC 9 x 6E 2 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.13 53%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 G 14T Geared Motor) APC 9 x 6E 3 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.47 69%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 G 14T Geared Motor) APC 10 x 7E 3 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.47 69%

Astro Mighty Micro Brushless 010 (801 G 14T Geared Motor) APC 10 x 7E 3 1 0 1 2 0 0 1.47 69%

Sensorless 16 mm dia, Brushless, 15 W (EC 16, 266523) Not Given 0 1 0 1 1 0 0 0.40 19%

Sensorless 22 mm dia, Brushless, 20 W (EC 22, 200858) Not Given 1 1 0 3 1 0 0 1.00 47%

16 mm dia, Graphite Brushes, 4.5 W (RE 16, 118730) Not Given 0 1 0 3 1 0 0 0.67 31%

25 mm dia, Precious Metal Brushes CLL, 10 W (RE 25, 118743) Not Given 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 0.53 25%

Feigao 1208436L 12x30mm Brushless Motor EP3020 1 2 2 1 2 0 0 1.53 72%

Relative Weight 33% 20% 27% 13% 7% 0% 0%

Page 32: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Static Testing1) Calibration of load cell

2) Static Propeller TestingThrust to Current Ratio

3) Static Motor TestingThrust to Current RatioMotor Body Temperature

Load Cell Calibration

y = 0.0056x + 0.9795R 2 = 1

0

0.2

0 .4

0 .6

0 .8

1

1 .2

1 .4

1 .6

1 .8

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Load ( grams)

Vo

lta

ge

(V

)

Page 33: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Dynamic Testing• Drag of test setup

FD = FSG2 – FSG1

• Dynamic propeller testingDp = Dt – Dm – Dsetup

• Dynamic motor testingDm = Dt – Dp – Dsetup

T1 T2 T3 T1 T2 T3 T1 T2 T3 T1 T2 T3 T1 T2 T3 T1 T2 T305

1005

10: : :4 15 10

Voltage (V) Wind Speeds (m/s)

Propeller EP7060

4

T/W Ratio T/D RatioAOA (deg) Drag (g) Thrust (g) RPM

8

9

Current Draw (A)

Page 34: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Will it Buckle?

cmLcmycmx

gFgF

y

x

08.553.4145.20

458200

1

1

===

==

mNT −= 73.1mNq /56.3910 =

cmt 0508.02 =

55.4=FS

Page 35: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Questions?

Thank you for your time!

Page 36: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Sneaker Slides

Page 37: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Airframe - Concerns

• Location of Center-of-Gravity• Produce Required Lift• Reduce Drag

Page 38: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Master - Airfoil Data - Command Sheet

Choose Airframe(s)

CL 50,000 E174 CD 75,000 E186 Cm 100,000 EH2012 CL/CD 125,000 EH3012

150,000 FX63137175,000 GOE417a200,000 M10225,000 M12250,000 M14275,000 MH46

RAF6S1210S2027S4022S4083S5010S5020SD7080

Check One Characteristic Choose Reynolds Number Value(s)

Plot SelectedClear

Select All Re

Select All Airfoils

Page 39: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cl/Cd vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-50.00

0.00

50.00

100.00

150.00

200.00

250.00

300.00

350.00

400.00

450.00

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cl/C

d (D

imen

sion

less

)

GOE417a, 100,000

S1210, 100,000

S4022, 100,000

S4083, 100,000

Page 40: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cl vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-1.00

-0.50

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cl (

Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

GOE417a, 100,000

S1210, 100,000

S4022, 100,000

S4083, 100,000

Page 41: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cd vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

0.30

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cd

(Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

GOE417a, 100,000

S1210, 100,000

S4022, 100,000

S4083, 100,000

Page 42: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cm vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-0.30

-0.25

-0.20

-0.15

-0.10

-0.05

0.00

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cm

(Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

GOE417a, 100,000

S1210, 100,000

S4022, 100,000

S4083, 100,000

Page 43: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

GOE417a Data - Cl vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-0.60

-0.40

-0.20

0.00

0.20

0.40

0.60

0.80

1.00

1.20

1.40

1.60

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cl (

Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

100,000 - XFLR5

200,000 - XFLR5

99,500 - Experimental

198,500 - Experimental

Page 44: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

XFLR5 Data - Cl vs. Angle of Attack for Airfoils at Reynolds Numbers

-0.05

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

-10 -5 0 5 10 15 20

Angle of Attack (Degrees)

Cl (

Dim

ensi

onle

ss)

100,000 - XFLR5

200,000 - XFLR5

99,500 - Experimental

198,500 - Experimental

Page 45: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard RF Controller/Receiver

100.0%100.0%82.5%70.0%45%66.7%Normalized Normalized

ScoreScore

4.04.03.32.81.82.66666667Mean ScoreMean Score

332315RX RangeRX Range

333434Voltage NeededVoltage Needed

544312VolumeVolume

345311WeightWeight

553111Current NeededCurrent Needed

553343ChannelsChannels

GWSGWS--NARO NARO

RR--6N/H6N/H

GWSGWS--NARO NARO

RR--6N/V6N/V

GWSGWS--PICO R4PPICO R4P--

JSTJST(Last year)(Last year)

HitecHitecFeatherFeather

AirtronicsAirtronics92515Z92515Z

HitecHitecHFSHFS--04MG04MGFactors/Candidates

Page 46: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Speed Controller

72.7%100.0%90.9%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

2.02.82.5Mean ScoreMean Score

133Dimensions (mm):Dimensions (mm):

511CompatibilityCompatibility

143Current NeededCurrent Needed

133WeightWeight

PhoenixPhoenix--1010WesWes--TechnikTechnik

YGEYGE--33(Last Year)(Last Year)

WesWes--TechnikTechnikYGEYGE--66Factors/Candidates

Page 47: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Servos (Actuators)

91.3%95.7%100.0%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

3.03.13.3Mean ScoreMean Score

325WeightWeight

333Load CurrentLoad Current

333DimensionsDimensions

333Operating VoltageOperating Voltage

453Max Output ForceMax Output Force

233Time to Full DeflectionTime to Full Deflection

333Max DeflectionMax Deflection

WesWes--TechnikTechnikLSLS--2.42.4

WesWes--TechnikTechnikLSLS--3.03.0

WesWes--TechnikTechnikLSLS--2.02.0Factors/Candidates

Page 48: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard Video System

100.0%95.2%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

3.02.857142857Mean ScoreMean Score

33DimensionsDimensions

23WeightWeight

23Current DrainCurrent Drain

33Operating VoltageOperating Voltage

33Number of ChannelsNumber of Channels

52Transmission PowerTransmission Power

33Operating FrequencyOperating Frequency

BWAV240200BWAV240200200 mw TX/RX200 mw TX/RX

BWAV240050BWAV24005050 mw TX/RX50 mw TX/RXFactor/Candidate

Page 49: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Passive Antenna Array

100.0%81.8%90.9%81.8%100.0%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

3.73.03.33.03.7Mean ScoreMean Score

15433Gain (Directivity)Gain (Directivity)

52334Vertical Vertical BeamwidthBeamwidth

52334Horizontal Horizontal BeamwidthBeamwidth

HG2409PHG2409PHG2424GHG2424G(Last Year)(Last Year)HG2416PHG2416PHG2414DHG2414DHG2414PHG2414PFactors/Candidates

Page 50: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Onboard GPS System

80.0%73.3%100.0%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

2.42.23.0Mean ScoreMean Score

213Current DrainCurrent Drain

233Operating VoltageOperating Voltage

223DimensionsDimensions

123WeightWeight

533AccuracyAccuracy

UNAVUNAVPICOPICO--GPSGPS--SSSS

SarantelSarantelSmart AntennaSmart Antenna

FurunoFurunoGHGH--7979Factors/Candidates

Page 51: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Batteries

57.1%71.4%100.0%85.7%Normalized ScoreNormalized Score

2.02.53.53.0Mean ScoreMean Score

3142WeightWeight

1153VolumeVolume

1333VoltageVoltage

3524CapacityCapacity

iRateiRateLP500LP500

KokamKokamSLPB523459SLPB523459

KokamKokamSLB452128SLB452128

KokamKokamSLPB433452SLPB433452Factors/Candidates

Page 52: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

ComputationVariables 2004 2005dC l /dα 0.1 0.1

AR 1.421697 1.421697 Assume same shape for both years so AR remains the sameS (m 2 ) 0.047549 0.102104 For 2004, assume 90% of 8" x 26 cm rectangular wing is remainingb (m) 0.26 0.381 For 2005, assume 15" wing span

e 0.9 0.9 Assume 0.9dC L /dα 0.041231 0.041231

AOA (deg) 9 9C L 0.95 0.95 @ 9 deg AOA, est. from Figure 33 on pg 46 of PDR

W (g) 97.9 202.35 Actually a Mass; 2004 from Table 16 on pg 73 of CDRC D 0.242594 0.251634C D0 0.018078 0.027117 2005 is about 1.5x the size of 2004 so increase CD0 by that muchT (g) 25 53.59796

eARd

dCddC

ddC

l

l

L

2

1801

πα

αα

+

=eARCCC L

DD π

2

0 +=L

D

CCWT =

vPT 97.101

=

Page 53: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Feasibility AssessmentPairwise Comparison:

Place an "R" if the row is more important. Place a "C" if the column is more

important Thru

stCo

stW

eigh

tCu

rren

tVo

ltag

eA

ddit

iona

l 1A

ddit

iona

l 2

Row

Tota

l

Colu

mn

Tota

l

1+Ro

w +

Colu

mn

Tota

l*

Rela

tive

Wei

ght

Thrust R R R R 4 0 5 33%

Cost C R R 2 0 3 20%

Weight R R 2 1 4 27%

Current R 1 0 2 13%

Voltage 0 0 1 7%

Additional 1 0 0 0 0%

Additional 2 0 0 0 0%

Column Total 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 15 100%

*Added 1 to each total to allow each parameter to have some percentage (except for undefined parameters)

Page 54: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Concept Development• Propulsion subsystem must produce enough thrust to accomplish our project goals.

• Weighted scale showed an electric motor is the best of the three power options for our MAV.

• Based on time limits, and lack of experience making precise molds, off the shelf propellers will be used.

• Off the shelf propellers will be tested with modified shapes and in original shapes to achieve the highest efficiency.

Once our team has a working MAV, we may return to propeller design.

Page 55: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Buckling CalculationsCalculations to determine t2

Variable Value Unit Value Unit Variable Value Unit Value UnitL 2 inches 5.08 cm X1 8.052 in 20.45 cmh 1 inch 2.54 cm Y1 16.35 in 41.53 cmt2 0.02 inch 0.0508 cm Fx 0.441 lbf 200 gramt1 0.125 inch 0.3175 cm Fy 1.010 lbf 458 gram

Acs 0.02 in^2 0.129 cm^2c 1.2 --- 1.2 ---E 10300000 psi 71 GPaSy 10000 psi 70 MPa

l/k 346.410(l/k)1 156.198

Pcr 20.331 lbs 90.434 N

t2 Sy (psi) l/k (l/k)1 Method0.03 10000 346.410 156.198 Euler0.03 30000 346.410 90.181 Euler

CalculationsM = T = 15.34 lbf-in 1.73 N-mqo 2.24 lbf/in 391.56 N/m

4.47 lbf 19.89 NFS = 4.55

Calculated values

Determining Buckling Method to use for Various Sy values

Force in compressed side =

Page 56: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Load Cell Mount Drawing

Page 57: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

New Back Upright Drawing

Page 58: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

New Front Upright Drawing

Page 59: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Strain Gage Box Drawing

Page 60: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

DC 6V EE Power Supply 5V +/- 12V Serial #EE1015

Load Cell SMD Sensor S250 1kg

100ohms

INA114 Instrumentation Amplifier Burr Brown w/ 100ohm Resistor

Oscilloscope TetronixSerial #B012473

Vc

Ref

Multimeter (// to Oscilloscope) Craftsman Serial #CCL02079157

DC 12V EE Power Supply 5V +/- 12V Serial #EE1015

25Kohm 25Kohm

25Kohm

25Kohm 25Kohm

25Kohm

DC 6V EE Power Supply 5V +/- 12V Serial #EE1015

Load Cell SMD Sensor S250 1kg

100ohms

INA114 Instrumentation Amplifier Burr Brown w/ 100ohm Resistor

Oscilloscope TetronixSerial #B012473

Vc

Ref

Multimeter (// to Oscilloscope) Craftsman Serial #CCL02079157

DC 12V EE Power Supply 5V +/- 12V Serial #EE1015

25Kohm 25Kohm

25Kohm

25Kohm 25Kohm

25Kohm

Propulsion Load Cell Calibration Electrical Schematic

Page 61: Preliminary Design Presentation - 123seminarsonly.com€¦ · RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005 RIT Micro Air Vehicle Preliminary Design Presentation Brian Gillis Team Leader

RIT MAV Team Project 05-001 2004-2005

Propulsion Motor Testing Electrical Schematic

+ -

R L

Motor

MPJA Multimeter Serial # CCL010412272

R1

Shenzhen Mastech DC Power Supply: HY3003-3

Note: R1 is dependent on the internal resistance (R) of the motor

T