Top Banner
The state of the art in collecting, publishing and in fostering the use of Open Data at Prato City Council Paolo Boscolo: Resp. ICT Infrastructure Management & EU projects
39

Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

Feb 15, 2019

Download

Documents

hangoc
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

The state of the art in collecting, publishing and in fostering the use of Open Data at

Prato City Council

Paolo Boscolo:

Resp. ICT InfrastructureManagement & EU projects

Page 2: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

CITY PROFILE

• 192.000 inhabitants (250.000 Province area)

• Declining textile Industry

• Emerging ICT sector

• Strong immigration (Big Chinese community)

Page 3: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

CITY PROFILE / 2

• Partner in many eGov Projects (EU, National, Regional level)

• City Council IT infrastructure:

• 1.400 workplaces 1.400

• 25 sites spread in the city area 25

• Internal IT management

• Some Public companies (utilities) with their own ICT depts

Page 4: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council

• Governance

• Platform

• Achievements

• Issues

Page 5: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council

• Governance

• Platform

• Achievements

• Issues

Page 6: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council(The Governance / 1)

• The “Digital Adminstration Law” (rev. 2017)• Open License by default

• New SW have to be Open Data ready

• Open Data activity is part of performance evaluation for PA managers

• National Open Data repository (doati.gov.it)

• City Council deliberation 130/2014• Guidelines

• CC-BY License

Page 7: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council(The Governance)

• City Board deliberation 37/2014• Internal working group for Open Data publishing

• Participation to OpenDataNetwork initiative http://www.opendatanetwork.it

• Annual plan for Open Data publishing activity

• Working group activity and ICT dept• 2014 - set-up of open-data-network publishing platform

• 2015 - first set of 32 Open Data set published (http://odn.comune.prato.it)

• 2015 – kick-off of Route-to-Pa project (http://www.routetopa.eu)

• 2016-2017 – 137 Data set published

• 2016-2017 – Route-to-PA pilots

• 2017 – Data Set harvested by the National Open data Portal

Page 8: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council

• Governance

• Platform

• Achievements

• Issues

Page 9: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

THE OPEN DATA

• Multilateral agreement signed among LAs

• Creation of an multi-level Open data sharing infrastructure

• Based on a standard CKAN platform and Prato City Council GIS platform based on OpenGIS SW

Prato Province coordination initiative(OPENDATANETWORK)

Page 10: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Page 11: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

TOLOMEO Portal (OpenGIS based)

Page 12: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The Route-to-PA project

• 12 Partners

– Researchers,

– Industry,

– Pilot sites

• 6 Countries

• 3 M€ budget

• 3 Products

• 4 Research areas

Page 13: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The Route-to-PA platforms

Social Platform for Open Data

Toolkit for transparency Good practices and

recommendations

Page 14: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Social Platform for Open Data

Page 15: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The Route-to-PA platforms

• A social environment to collaborate over and co-create Open Data

• A “traditional” social platform (friends, etc.) +• An ecosystem of reusable components (datalets) for

visualizing Open Data, with an easy-to-use creation wizard• An Agorà of open rooms, where discussion is around

topics, with advanced visualizations• Co-creation private rooms (by invitation) where groups can

co-create data or knowledge documents• Blogs publicly accessible

Page 16: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

SPOD: the newsfeed

Page 17: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

SPOD: the Agora’

Page 18: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

SPOD: a room, with a datalet

Page 19: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The wizard for the datalet

Page 20: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Co-creation room

Page 21: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Public blog

Page 22: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

How SPOD addressesthe Open Pyramid

Page 23: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The full Prato platform features(Summary)

1. Master data publishing (CKAN/Geo-server of ODN)2. Route-to-PA

1. Indexing dataset through harvesting on TET2. Blogging and “Data Driven” discussions on SPOD3. Data set Co-creation on SPOD4. On-field Data collection App for SPOD co-creation

3. Harvesting on ODN master web-site4. Harvesting on dati.gov.it5. Harvesting on dati.torscana.it (ongoing)

Page 24: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Just a look on the platform

http://odn.comune.prato.it

http://prato.routetopa.eu

Page 25: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council

• Governance

• Platform

• Achievements

• Issues

Page 26: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The Route-to-PA piloting

1. First round (2016-2017)1. Discussion on city WiFi infrastructure expansion

2. Second round (2017-2018)1. Tabernacle (using the SPOD App)2. Cuty Budget3. App

3. Free activities (2015-2018)1. Data set request collection2. Other discussions using published datasets

Page 27: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The WiFi pilot

Page 28: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The WiFi pilot – the decision tree

Page 29: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The pilot on Tabernacle mapping

Page 30: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The pilot on Tabernacle mapping

Page 31: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The pilot on Tabernacle mapping

• 5 classroom involved (middle school)• 270 tabernacle already mapped by students• 2 blogs already started on the topic

• The platform has been used by the University of Salerno (Route-to-PA coordinator) for other mapping activities in many other fields all related to the preservation of the cultural heritage

Page 32: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The pilot on City Budget• Planned from February 2018• Example of “Monitorial Democracy”• dataset supporting this pilot already published

• Forecast / Final Balance since 2010• Link to supporting material• List of City council contracts since 2012• Deliberations• …

Page 33: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

The pilot on City Budget / 2

• Politicians will prepare discussion material• Community manager will stimulate discussion• Stakeholders/citizens invited to contribute

• 1. Politicians: majority and opposition• 2. Organization of businesses• 3. Associations• 4. Schools (economic curriculum)

• Promotion of discussion on popular Social Network

Page 34: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Achievements

1. A significant initial number of Data set published2. Good interaction with other important Open Data portal3. Commitment at political level obtained4. Availability of a publishing platform with many feature5. Internal awareness of what Open Data are6. Involvement of external users 200+ registered users7. Some replicable usage of the platform identified8. New instrument for citizens participation available

Page 35: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Open Data at Prato City Council

• Governance

• Platform

• Achievements

• Issues

Page 36: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

• Scarce commitment in data publishing by employees• The Open Data publishing is seen ad an “overhead”• Difficulties in the identification of possible new data set• Reluctance of ICT analyst to consider Open Data interfaces in

SW packages• Lack of automatic publishing processes• Needs of ICT support in data “correction” & “adaptation”• Resistance to changes in data publishing procedures (new OD

platform)• Lack recognition of the value of Open Data publishing also by

politicians (just a “fashionable” activity)• Strong reluctance from census data specialists

Issues(the internal reaction)

Page 37: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

• The “audience” interested to Open Data seems smalls• No clear identification of largely requested data set• Underestimation of needed efforts in the Data Set requests• Lack of standard for contents, formats and semantics• Open Data users are (at moment) only curious ICT

specialists not businesses• Difficulties also for skilled user to ignite/participate in

discussions around Open Data - Better response on co-creation

• Incoherent reaction from Politicians: They need OD But don’t like free access/discussion to them

Issues(the external reaction)

Page 38: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Conclusions• Publishing platforms already mature (from the technical

point of view) but still difficult for “normal people”• Standard for Matadata still unclear (DCAT, INSPIRE, RNDT,.)

with dialects and local variants• Only de-facto standard API• Authoring and data updating problems• Licensing (CC-BY not always possible)• Lack of really impacting and convincing business cases• Lack of Open Data “plugs” in commercial SW• Huge efforts in publishing activity respect the measured

effects

• Open Data Publishing seen more as a legal obligation or fashionable activity than as “useful service”

Page 39: Prato Paolo Boscolo 2018-01-25 - majorcities.eu · 7kh vwdwh ri wkh duw lq froohfwlqj sxeolvklqj dqg lq irvwhulqj wkh xvh ri 2shq 'dwd dw 3udwr &lw\ &rxqflo 3dror %rvfror 5hvs ,&7

2018-01-25 Florence – MCE workshop

Thanks for your attention

Paolo Boscolo:

Resp. ICT InfrastructureManagement & EU projects

e-mail: [email protected]