Top Banner
Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs Steve Ashton, P.E., SECB
79

Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Mar 24, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard

Including:Practical Advice for Reviewing Software 

Generated Connection Designs

Steve Ashton, P.E., SECB

Page 2: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

2

Limit States that Changed

Page 3: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Bolt Limit States

3

Page 4: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Bolt Materials

Group A:  (Includes A325 and F1852)Fu = 120 ksi *

Group B:  (Includes A490 and F2280)Fu = 150 ksi

(* ‐ up to 1” diameter)

4

Page 5: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Allowable Shear Strength

1989 2005 2010A325N 21 ksi 24 ksi 27 ksiA325X 30 ksi 30 ksi 34 ksiA490N 28 ksi 30 ksi 34 ksiA490X 40 ksi 37.5 ksi 42 ksi

5

Page 6: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Table J3.2 ‐ 2005

6

Page 7: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Table J3.2 ‐ 2010

7

Page 8: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Bolt Limit States

8

Page 9: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Slip Critical Joints ‐ 2005 SpecificationRn = μDuhscTbNs (J3‐4)

Prevention of Slip is a Serviceability Limit StateLRFD:  = 1.00ASD:   = 1.50

Prevention of Slip at Required Strength LevelLRFD:  = 0.85ASD:   = 1.76

9

Page 10: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Rn = μDuhscTbNs (2005 ‐ J3‐4)

= 0.35 (Class A) = 0.50 (Class B)

Rn = μDuhfTbNs (2010 ‐ J3‐4)

= 0.30 (Class A) = 0.50 (Class B)

Slip Critical Joints

10

Page 11: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Rn = μDuhscTbNs (2005 ‐ J3‐4)

hsc = 1.00 (STD)hsc = 0.85 (OVS or SSL)hsc = 0.70 (LSL)

Rn = μDuhfTbNs (2010 ‐ J3‐4)

= 1.00 (STD) = 0.85 (OVS or SSL) = 0.70 (LSL)

Slip Critical Joints

11

Page 12: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Slip Critical Joints ‐ 2010 Specification

Rn = μDuhfTbNs (J3‐4)

hf = 1.00 (0 or 1 Filler)hf = 0.85 (2 or more Fillers)

12

Page 13: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Limit States

13

Page 14: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

New Section J4.5

14

Page 15: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Other 14th Ed. Changes• Prying Action• Single Plate Shear Connections (Shear Tabs)• Fillers• New Tables

15

Page 16: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Other 14th Ed. Changes

• Prying Action• Single Plate Shear Connections (Shear Tabs)• Fillers• New Tables

16

Page 17: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

17

Prying Action (ASD)

With prying action:

T = required strength per boltp = tributary length per bolt line ≤ 2b = 1‐ d’ / pd’ = width of hole along length of fitting

)'1('4

min

upF

Tbt

Page 18: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Prying Action Nomenclature

Page 19: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

19

Prying ActionDouble Angle Connection

Page 20: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Expanded Bolt Spacing

20

Page 21: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

21

Wide Gage

Page 22: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

22

Narrow Gage

Page 23: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

23

Narrow Gage and Expanded Bolt Spacing

Page 24: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Other 14th Ed. Changes

• Prying Action• Single Plate Connections (Shear Tabs)• Fillers• New Tables

24

Page 25: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Conventional Configuration

25

Page 26: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Conventional Configuration

26

Page 27: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Single‐Plate Connection

Conventional Configuration

13th Edition Manualtp or tw ≤ d/2 + 1/16”

14th Edition ManualNo requirement if n ≤ 5 and SSLT 

27

Page 28: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Single‐Plate Connection

Conventional Configuration

13th Edition ManualEccentricity can be ignored if:

n ≤ 9 and STD or n ≤ 12 and SSLT

14th Edition ManualEccentricity always considered per Table 10‐9

28

Page 29: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Other 14th Ed. Changes• Prying Action• Single Plate Shear Connections (Shear Tabs)• Fillers• New Tables

29

Page 30: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Fillers

30

Page 31: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Fillers:  J5 ‐ 2005

31

Page 32: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Fillers:  J5.2 ‐ 2010

32

Page 33: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Fillers:  J5 – 2010 Commentary

33

Page 34: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Other 14th Ed. Changes• Prying Action• Single Plate Shear Connections (Shear Tabs)• Fillers• New Tables

34

Page 35: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

14th Edition Manual

New Tools• Table 8‐12.  Approx. Number of Passes for Welds• Table 10‐13.  Min. Inside Radius for Cold‐Bending• Table 10‐14.  Clearances for Skewed Connections• Table 10‐15.  Seated Connections to HSS

35

Page 36: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

14th Edition Manual

New Tools• Table 8‐12.  Approx. Number of Passes for Welds• Table 10‐13.  Min. Inside Radius for Cold‐Bending• Table 10‐14.  Clearances for Skewed Connections• Table 10‐15.  Seated Connections to HSS

36

Page 37: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

37

Tables 10‐13 and 10‐14

Page 38: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

14th Edition Manual

New Tools• Table 8‐12.  Approx. Number of Passes for Welds• Table 10‐13.  Min. Inside Radius for Cold‐Bending• Table 10‐14.  Clearances for Skewed Connections• Table 10‐15.  Seated Connections to HSS

38

Page 39: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

39

Table 10‐15

Page 40: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard

Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated Connection 

Designs

Page 41: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Software Generated Calculations

Page 42: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

42

Page 43: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

43

Page 44: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

44

Page 45: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

45

Required StrengthsAISC COSP Section 3.1.2

Page 46: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

46

Transfer Forces

Page 47: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

47

Transfer Forces

Page 48: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

48

Transfer Forces

Page 49: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

49

Transfer Forces

Page 50: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

50

Transfer Forces

Page 51: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

51

Page 52: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

52

Load Path ‐ Uniform Force Method

Page 53: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

53

AISC Nomenclature

Page 54: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

54

Column Forces

Beam forces

Where

and

PreP

rV c

c cH

PreP

rH b

b bV

22bc eer

Uniform Force Method(Equations from Manual)

cb ee tantan

Page 55: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

55

Uniform Force Method (Traditional)

Page 56: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

56

Connection Calculations

Page 57: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

57

Uniform Force Method (Compact Gusset)

Page 58: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

58

Connection Calculations

Page 59: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

59

Workpoint Relocation (Special Case 1)

Page 60: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

60

Workpoint Relocation (Special Case 1)

Page 61: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

61

Workpoint Relocation (Special Case 1)

Page 62: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

62

Page 63: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

63

Calculating Capacity

Page 64: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

64

Calculating Capacity

Page 65: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

65

Calculating Capacity10 Numbers to Memorize (2010 ASD)

• 0.928• 27• 45• 1.25• 1.3• 3.4• 0.5• 0.6• 1.2• 1.5

Page 66: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Reviewing Software Generated Connection Designs

• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

66

Page 67: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 68: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 69: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 70: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 71: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 72: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 73: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Constructability

Page 74: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Connection Costs

Page 75: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Connection Costs

Page 76: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Connection Costs

Page 77: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

Connection Costs

Page 78: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

SummaryReviewing Software Generated Connection 

Designs• Look at Every Connection• Know the Required Strengths• Determine the Load Path• Estimate the Capacity

– See “Evaluating a Connection” Handout– Quick Hand Calculations (Numbers to Memorize)– Printed Calculations

• Evaluate Constructability!

78

Page 79: Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using …...Practical Steel Connection Software Design Using AISC 2010 Standard Including: Practical Advice for Reviewing Software Generated

79

Questions

Contact Info:

Steve Ashton816‐560‐2606

[email protected]