Top Banner
PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring in Smart Grids
41

PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Mar 11, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques

Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEENational Chung Cheng University

TAIWAN

1

Panel SessionPower Quality Monitoring in Smart Grids

Page 2: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

2

Outline

• Introduction• Power Quality and Smart Grid• Issues of Power Quality Monitoring• Review of Power Quality Analysis andDisturbance Detection Techniques

• Case Studies• Conclusions

2

Page 3: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

3

Introduction• Enhancement of quality of supply voltage is a keyfunction of realizing the smart grid.

• By means of adopting advanced technologies forpower quality monitoring and metering, waveformcorrection devices, and condition monitoring, thepower quality for both customers and utilities can bemaintained.

• With judicious selections and applications ofdifferent key technologies for the smart grid, powerquality disturbances can be substantially mitigated.

3

Page 4: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

4

Issues of Power Quality Monitoring• Realization of Smart Meter with Advanced Power

Quality Analysis Functions• Wide‐area Power Quality Measurement• Realization of Mechanisms for Tracking Source of

Power Quality Disturbance and IdentificationAlgorithms via Robust Communication Network

• Integration of Real‐time Power Quality SignalAnalysis Methods

• Management of Measured Power Quality Data• Power Quality Standards•

4

Page 5: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Smart PQ Measurement Scheme

GenerationSystem

Distributed Generation

TransmissionSystem

DistributionSystem

User

PowerFlow

Two-WayCommunication

SCADAPQ Measurement System

(DB, Analysis, Analytics, GUI)

5

Page 6: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Smart PQ Measurement Scheme (cont.)

PQ Analysis &Algorithms

GUI

DatabaseDistributed Intelligent Sensors

Advanced PQ Meters

Zigbee, PLC, GPS, Ethernet etc.Cross-PlatformData Format

MeasurementSystem

6

Page 7: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

7

Review of Power Quality Analysis and Disturbance Detection Techniques

• To achieve the efficient and accurate powerquality measurement under the smart grid, itrequires more advanced analysis anddetection methods.

• The following gives an overview of thetechniques required to perform such analysesand detections.

7

Page 8: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

8

Procedure for Monitoring Power Quality

M easurem ent transducers

E lectrical input signal

Input signal under m easurem ent

A nalyzing m echanism

A nalysis results

D ata aggregation and evaluation

E valuation resu lts

8

Page 9: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Harmonics/InterharmonicsMeasurement

)295.418sin(15.0)225.299sin(2.0 )255.179sin(3.0)285.59sin()(

tttttv

)2553sin()2281sin( )2180sin()260sin(2)(

tttttv

Spectral Leakage Picket-Fence Effect

9

Page 10: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Harmonics/InterharmonicsMeasurement (cont.)

10

• Fast Fourier Transform‐based Methods• ESPRIT (estimation of signal parameters viarotational invariance technique)

• MUSIC (multiple signal classification )• Prony‐based Methods• ADALINE‐based Methods• Kalman Filtering• PLL‐based Methods• Artificial Neural Network Methods

Page 11: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

11Fig. 2. Classification of commonly used harmonic estimation methods.

11

Harmonics/InterharmonicsMeasurement (cont.)

Page 12: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

12

Fig. 3. Classification of commonly used interharmonics estimation methods.

Harmonics/InterharmonicsMeasurement (cont.)

Page 13: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Flicker Measurement• IEC Flickermeter• Squaring Demodulation Method• Discrete Wavelet Synchronous DetectionMethod

• ADALINE Detection Method• EPLL Detection Method• New Approaches

13

Page 14: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

14

Flicker Measurement (cont.)• In general, the voltage fluctuations can be expressedas the amplitude modulated (AM) signal as follows:

where and are amplitudes, angularfrequencies, and phase angles of the fundamentaland flicker components, respectively, and m is theexpected number of flicker signals.

)cos( 00

)00cos(

1)cos(

0)(

tAEn

tm

i fitfiiAAtv

,,,,, 000 fiiAA i

14

Page 15: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Flicker Measurement (cont.)

Fig. 3. Scheme of voltage envelope estimation.

Table I: Summary of Performance Comparisons

15

Method Squaring demodulation

Discrete wavelet

synchronousdetection

ADALINE EPLL

Leakages reduction with proper parameters Poor Fair Fair Good

Robustness to fundamental frequency

deviationFair Poor Fair Good

Practicability based on parametric settings Good Fair Fair Poor

Page 16: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

16

Voltage Sag Detections

• The analysis for voltage disturbance eventscan be roughly grouped into two categories:– Detection Process: it is designed to identify theoccurrences of events and trigger thecorresponding automation and protectionmechanisms.

– Classification Process: it is mainly used to identifythe types of events according to differentproperties of power quality disturbances.

16

Page 17: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

17

Voltage Sag Detections (cont.)17

•Direct Estimation of RMS Value•ADALINE Detection Method•High‐pass Filtering•Autoregressive (AR), Moving‐Average (MA), andARMA Models

•Wavelet Analysis– Squaring Method– Shrinkage Method– Inter‐scale Dependency

•New Analysis Method

Residual Method

Page 18: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

18

Voltage Sag Detections

• Several parameters of power quality events are necessary to be identified:– Starting‐time localization of events– Ending‐time localization of events– Duration of events– Classification of events– Variation of events

18

Page 19: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

19

Voltage Sag DetectionsDirect Estimation of RMS Value

• For full cycle:

• For half cycle:

where N is the number of samples per cycle

N

kyrms

N

kf

1

0

2 )(

2/

)(12/

0

2

N

kyrms

N

kh

19

Page 20: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

20

Voltage Sag DetectionsADALINE Detection Method

22

212 mmm wwA

12

21tanm

mm w

w

1w

2w

3w

4w

1-2Nw

2Nw

1sin

1 cos

2sin

2 cos

Nsin

N cos

20

Page 21: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

21

Voltage Sag DetectionsADALINE Detection Method

21

Page 22: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

22

Voltage Sag DetectionsHigh‐Pass Filtering

22

Page 23: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

23

+

×

Unitdelay

×

Unitdelay

×

Unitdelay

e(n)

a1

y(n-1)

a2

y(n-2)

aP

y(n-P)

aPy(n-P)a2y(n-2)

a1y(n-1)

y(n)=a1y(n-1)+a2y(n-2)+…+aPy(n-P)+e(n)

Voltage Sag DetectionsAR, ARMA Processes

23

Page 24: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

24

Voltage Sag DetectionsWavelet Analysis

• Since the singular points are those samples wheresignal discontinuities are present, a significantsingular point is often associated with a suddenchange in the system.

• The wavelet analysis provided the multi‐resolution isa powerful tool for the localization for the singularsignals. With the dyadic analysis structure of wavelet,the singular signals can be separated from thosenormal ones.

24

Page 25: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

25

Voltage Sag Detections• Though the wavelet analysis is the widely usedtechnique in the recent years, it is suffered from theinterference of noise.

25

Page 26: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (Case 1)

Measured Adjustable Speed Motor Drive input current waveforms 

26

Page 27: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (cont.)FFT without corrections

IEC grouping method

New method

27

Page 28: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (Case 2)

New Method for Time‐Varying HarmonicsTracking

t = 1 sec t = 2.5 sec t = 4 sec

28

Page 29: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (cont.)

Traditional method

New method

29

Page 30: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Measurement/Analysis of Flicker (cont.)• IEC Standard 61000‐4‐15 provides bothfunctional and design specifications forflicker measurement and the flickermeterarchitecture is described by the followingblock diagram.

30

Page 31: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (Case 3)

Pst Case 1 Case 2 Case 3 Case 4 Case 5

IEC 61000-4-15 1.1325 6.5320 8.8694 9.2112 6.3733

Proposed Method 1.1102 6.3912 8.9557 9.1165 6.4136

Relative Error (%) 1.9691 2.1555 0.9730 1.0281 0.6323

Power System

45 MVAkV Y 4.11 / kV 161

33 MVAV 604 / kV 4.11

PCC

Electrical Arc Furnace

PQMeter

EAF Bus

Z = 12 % Z = 7.5 %

31

Page 32: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (cont.)

Other methods New method

32

Page 33: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

Case Studies (Case 4)33

Page 34: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

34

IEEE Std. 1159.3-based PQ Data Analysis System

Case Studies (Case 5)

Page 35: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

35

Three-phase voltage measurement by PQ Meter – Brand A Flicker measurement (delta V10) by PQ Meter – Brand B

Case Studies (cont.)

Page 36: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

36

PQDIF utility application andwaveform output based on PQ Meter –Brand A

Case Studies (cont.)

Page 37: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

37

PQDIF utility application and delta V10output based on PQ Meter – Brand B

Case Studies (cont.)

Page 38: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

38

LabVIEW-based GUI of PQ Data Analysis System

Page 39: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

More PQ Measurement IssuesMore Smart Grid PQ Measurement Issues

(1) Smart Meter with Advanced PQ Analysis Functions(2) Wide Area Monitoring Scheme with PQ Disturbance

Identification and Remedy(3) Integration of Measured PQ Data and Database Design(4) Tracking PQ Disturbances and Real-time PQ Analysis(5) Deployment of Advanced PQ Meters in Power Network(6) Embedding Advanced PQ Monitoring Functions

in Substation/Feeder Automations(7) Commutation Protocols for PQ Monitoring(8) PQ-related Standards Development(9) PQ Analytics

39

Page 40: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

40

Conclusions• Several commonly used signal processing techniquesfor analysis of harmonics, flickers, sags, swells, andinterruptions are introduced.

• The communication mechanism and information systemdeployment for power quality monitoring system becomecritical factors for the success of smart grid.

• The power quality measurement system shall record thedetail waveforms during the fault and rms values of voltageand current. To different venders of power quality meters,associated issues of interoperationability and relatedstandards must be taken into account.

40

Page 41: PQ Monitoring Analysis Techniques...PQ Monitoring & Analysis Techniques Gary W. Chang, Ph.D., P.E., FIEEE National Chung Cheng University TAIWAN 1 Panel Session Power Quality Monitoring

[email protected]

Thank You!