Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent. The IPTV Explosion: Who‟s Positioned for Success? Ron Westfall, Research Director, Access and Applications Yoav Schreiber, Senior Analyst, Digital Media Infrastructure Larry Hettick, Principal Analyst, Digital Home Services U. S. Bernt Ostergaard, Research Director, Telecom Services Europe Ben Tudor, Senior Analyst, Consumer Broadband Services Europe June 4th & 5th, 2008
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
The IPTV Explosion: Who‟s Positioned for Success?
Ron Westfall, Research Director, Access and Applications
Yoav Schreiber, Senior Analyst, Digital Media Infrastructure
Larry Hettick, Principal Analyst, Digital Home Services U. S.
Bernt Ostergaard, Research Director, Telecom Services Europe
Ben Tudor, Senior Analyst, Consumer Broadband Services Europe
June 4th & 5th, 2008
Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Section I: The Global IPTV and IP Video Infrastructure
Market and Competitive Terrain
Section II: The US IPTV Market and
Competitive Terrain
Section III: The European IPTV Market and
Competitive Terrain
Agenda: The IPTV Video Explosion: Who‟s Positioned for Success?
2
Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Section I: The Global IPTV and IP Video
Infrastructure Market and Competitive Terrain
3
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
The Major Drivers for the Overall IPTV and IP Video Market
Standards and Acceptance
Regulation
and
Competition
Back-Office and
Organization
Evolution
• MPEG-2/4• Open IPTV Forum• DOCSIS 3.0, tru2way • DLNA, Semantic Web • HD, PVR Mainstream• DVB-H
• SDP for Any Device, Any Content• Metadata Management/Semantic Web• Future IMS based services• Content and Workflow Mgmt
• EU Model Spur Content Innovation• Net Neutrality• Interactivity and Custom Ads• Regulators Need to Adapt
Applications and
Services
IP Video and
IPTV
• IP Video/IPTV• Any Play, Interactivity• PC TV, Mobile TV and OTT Video• Personal Ads• User-Generated Content
4
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
IPTV and IP Video Market Evolution
Significant Factors IPTV Impact on Ad Models
– Unicast content such as VoD, DVR/nPVR
– Long tail content, non-linear content
– User-generated and personal content
Networking and Home Wiring– May prove most challenging technical issue in U.S.
– Regions beyond U.S. = single TV households
IPTV Standardization Efforts– Some progress, but still open-ended
– Open IPTV forum and others
5
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
IPTV and IP Video Market Evolution (Continued)
Significant Factors IP Video and IPTV Business Case Evolution
– SD to HD = MPEG2 to MPEG4
– Pay models shifting
– MSOs already offering free VoD
– IPTV: a separate or bundled/hidden charge
IPTV Middleware Market Segment Fragmentation – Microsoft Mediaroom traction
– Wide variety of established players, independent players and
carrier-originated IPTV middleware
– Increased consolidation of players expected
6
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Current IPTV and IP Video Solutions Competitive Positioning Matrix
NSN Myrio Partners Partners Partners Some HE Assets
Lead Integrator Message Has Holes
Thomson Thales IPTVIPTV and Mobile
TV In-House Respectable Execution
Key
ZTE China Competitive Competitive In-House Decent Asia-PacThreat
Motorola CableCompetitive;
More Cohesion Though
Portfolio Streamlining
can Help
Cable Security, but
IPTV = Partners
Strong
New Re-Org = Many
Unanswered ?‟s
Positive
Neutral
Negative
Ratings Key
7
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
IPTV and IP Video Content Security
8
Four components: Conditional Access Systems (CAS)
Digital Rights Management (DRM)
Encryption
Watermarking
Content security solutions require agility (i.e., renewability via hardware or software) to enable business model flexibility for operatorsARPU growth enabled by securing interactivity (via middleware integration)Key goal = seamless content portability across devices and networks, and securing “whole home” convergence
Pirates focus on systems with large numbers To date, IPTV numbers are smaller than either cable or satellite
Largest software-downloadable content security: PCCW and
France Telecom
NDS has the largest 17 million customer license for smart cards
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
IPTV and IP Video Content Security Competitive Positioning Matrix
9
Vendor Footprint Technology Flexibility
End-to-end Strategy
Messaging & Vision
Overall Ranking
Irdeto1 billion+ devices &
apps secured; mostly cable/sat.
Smartcard + robust software
capabilities (Cloakware)
Subsidiaries: IDway
middleware & IBS Interprit B/OSS
Business Model Protection
Positioned to influence
converged market
Latens Few tier 1 accounts;
mostly telcoSoftware-based
Integrates own
ECOsystem
middleware
Integrated
CAS/DRM speeds
time-to-market
Lacks market
momentum
Nagravision78 million+ active
cards/devices; mostly
cable/sat
Primarily
smartcards;
chipset-based
software solution
Leverages content
management &
middleware from
sister companies
Securing content
aggregation,
delivery,
consumption
Can influence
hybrid market
NDS87 million+ active
devices; mostly
cable/sat
Primarily
smartcards, server-
based software
Owns middleware,
DVR & apps
Securing &
enabling content
Market leader in
scope and
influence
Secure Media Limited; primarily
telcoSoftware-based Relies on partners
Open platform
content protectionLacks influence
Verimatrix4 million+ screens
protected; 100+
customers; mostly
telco
Software-based
Layered security to
prevent cloning
(GeoAuthentication
& Quantum ID)
3-D content
security (multiple
networks, screens,
layers)
IPTV Leadership in
terms of system
scale and licenses
Viaccess13 million+ smart
cards shipped;
mostly cable/satellite
Primarily hardware;
has software offer
(Purple Box)
Turnkey offering
and acquired Orca
middleware
Securing digital
content
Still establishing
middleware
credentials
Widevine130 operator
accounts, few tier 1s;
mostly telco
Software –based;
has cable card
offering
Partner driven
strategy; multiple
SI relationships
Multi-format &
multi-platform
protection
Broad multi-
platform credibility
Positive
Neutral
Negative
Ratings Key
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Competitive Actions to Improve Market Positioning
10
Irdeto
Latens
Nagravision
NDS
Secure Media
Verimatrix
Viaccess
Widevine
Needs to focus on interactivity enablement as key differentiator, leveraging
middleware, DVR and apps; IPTV execution is key
Needs to build mobile DRM differentiator, and leverage installed base to win the
hybrid cable + IP market
Needs to expand customer base to demonstrate market viability of Encryptonite
One system
Needs to consolidate offerings and vision to solidify IPTV lead and extend to new
markets, (i.e., Internet, cable, mobile)
Needs to demonstrate Orca middleware acquisition synergy as key for IPTV success
Needs to gain Tier 1 customers to demonstrate system scale, and leverage multi-
platform/format leadership positioning
Needs more system integrator partners to drive penetration, and needs to
Needs to leverage integrated B/OSS capabilities for “whole-home” convergence and
Cloakware software as differentiators
Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Section II: The US IPTV Market and
Competitive Terrain
11
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.12
Service Provider Drivers and Trends
Universal Service Provider Drivers Increase ARPU
Decrease churn
U. S. Service Provider Trends A zero sum game
Telcos: add video
MSOs: add voice
Both: increased speed, video options
(HD+++, DVR, etc.)
Both: double play / triple play
Up to 85% of U. S. Homes Pay to Watch TV
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.13
Telcos Losing Wireline Voice to MSOs, Wireless SubstitutionTelcos Losing the ARPU Battle but Targeting 30% Video Market Share by 2010
MSOs Gaining on Targeted 30% Voice Share by 2010MSOs Losing Little Video Share to Date
Verizon FiOS Driving Broadband Speed as U. S. Competitive AdvantageSatellite TV Driving HD Channels as Competitive Advantage
Business Case Drivers: Competitive Pressures (U. S.)
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
U. S. Consumer Drivers and Trends
Consumer Demand Drivers More for less
A little more for a lot less
Current Monthly A La Carte Prices Voice: Unlimited Domestic
Calling (including loop)
~ $20 to $45
Broadband: Downstream
@ 1.5 / 3 Mbps to 50 Mbps;
$19.95 to $149.95
Video: ~ 200 Digital
Channels = ~ $45 - $65
Consumer Demand Trends $99 triple play (up to 60% for new
subscribers)
– Unlimited voice
– 200+ digital channels, 40+ HD
– 1.5 – 6Mbps broadband
$140-$160 Premium Triple Play Unlimited voice
+ HD, + DVR, + premium Video
10 – 20 Mbps broadband
14
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.15
IPTV Case Example: AT&T U-verse Service Delivery
Technical: Largely FTTN (FTTH for new
homes)
VDSL
IPTV/MPEG-4
Financial: Capex: $330 / home passed
CPE Cost / Sub ~ $550
APRU / sub: not disclosed,
however estimated
at > $115 / month
Subscribers: Q1 07: 13,000
Q1 08: 379,000
Source: AT&T
Washington DC / Paris All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Section III: The European IPTV Market
and Competitive Terrain
16
Split European Broadband Infrastructure Strategies
Infrastructure Build-out Strategies: FTTH with Active Ethernet or Passive Optical Network
– FTTB AE with copper in the building : B2 & Telenor Sweden (S)
– GPON: Neuf outside Paris & Orange (F), Energi Midt (DK)
HFC Hybrid Fiber/Coax to subscriber
– DOCSIS 2.0: The standard delivery
– DOCSIS 3.0: No commercial services. Trials at UPC (NL), Telenet
(B), Virgin Media (UK) and Cablecom (CH)
17
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.18
Need to drive up ARPU and justify heavy infrastructure investmentsTelcos Losing wireline voice to MSOs with wireless substitutionBroadband becoming commodityCable, MSOs, broadcasters and others offering triple play servicesFTTx rollouts gathering speed (France, Nordics)Advertisers looking for more detailed audience dataNeed to make services „sticky‟ – see BT
European Business Case Drivers: Competitive Pressures
Video Traffic is the Key Growth Factor – BUT:
Infrastructure investments cannot be justified by IPTV alone.
SPs need to evolve Video Related Services:
VoD, P2P video, video conferencing, Games and Apps sharing, Video
security services.
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Service Provider Drivers and Trends
19
Telco Priorities Add a revenue stream to flat-rate DSL
Staunch revenue losses to cable
Differentiate from discount ISPs
Stop revenue loss to content providers
Move up the value chain
Preparing for multi-screen delivery
Cable Operator Priorities Triple play services
Stay ahead in HD quality delivery
Enhance in home service delivery
Current Broadband Speeds / Prices vary wildly: Cheapest prices $5.80 in
Sweden, $33.38 in Czech
Republic (Source: OECD)
EU and Non-EU Europe Region
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.20
DTT and license financed „Free TV‟ shakes up
EU marketsFibre rollouts / xDSL evolution makes it easier to deliver IPTVConsumers conditioned by what‟s available in
their marketHuge appetite for catch-up TV, time shiftingVOD offerings from broadcasters enable new consumer behaviorsGames console penetration used to distribute content
European Consumer Drivers and Trends
Regulatory Issues:
- Infrastructure access and investment sharing
- Role of publicly-funded broadcasters
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.21
IPTV Case Example: Illiad FreeBox Service Delivery
Power line Connections for HDTV connections in-house
A fiber-connected Freebox home
Source: Free www.free.fr
Technical: Unbundled ADSL2+
FTTH in 80 cities
IPTV/MPEG-4
Financial: Capex: €70/€400
apartment/house
CPE Cost: €300
APRU / sub: not disclosed
Subscribers: Q1 07: 2,1 mill
Q1 08: 3,1 mill (400K FTTH
households passed)
Base subscription €29.99 per
month for both ADSL and
FTTH
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Free to view in the UKViewers can stream to browser, iPhone, Virgin Media STB or Wii75 million streams / downloads since Christmas 2007UK #3 ISP, Tiscali, complains about bandwidth costPlusNet: iPlayer traffic accounts for 6.3% of total downloads
Catch-up TV VOD case study – BBC iPlayer
22
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
IPTV Best Practice Revenue Models
Consumers pay for content, picture quality and ease of use Size (# of subscribers) critical for best content deals
Large flat screens ready for HD
Triple- & Quad SP are attractive, but bad customer experience can
hurt across all bundled services
There is zero customer loyalty – just varying degrees of vendor lock-in to delay churn to better, cheaper SP‟s
DTTs will set the bar
We are a long way from IPTV profitability If carriers want to avoid being bit carriers they have to stop thinking
like bit carriers
23
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.24
Global IPTV and IP Video Technology Drivers and Trends
Standards and Acceptance: GPON/VDSL2
and DOCSIS 3.0 standards and silicon
advances = fixed wireline BW per sub boosts to
further drive video and other BW-intensive apps
Regulation and Competition: Intermodal
competition realized among operators; Content
regulation still lagging
Back-office and Organizational Evolution: All-digital/IP upgrades, FMC architectures,
SDP/IMS and metadata management
enhancements = operator org. shifts
Applications and Services: Mobile TV, PC
TV, and OTT video fuel overall video demand
including Adobe Flash proliferation
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.25
Questions and Answers
All materials Copyright 1997-2008 Current Analysis, Inc. Reproduction or distribution prohibited without express written consent.
Recent Current Analysis Reports on IPTV
Our customers have been reading:
Netflix‟s Streaming Video Service Crosses Over to the TV via the New Roku Set-top Box Product Intelligence Report | Digital Home - U.S. [May 2008] Netflix’s new
broadband device can stream movies on a television for only $99 for the equipment with
no extra service fees. But there is no HD content and overall Netflix’s online selection is
skimpy compared to its vast DVD library.
The State of the UK IPTV Market Advisory Report | Consumer Broadband Services Europe [May 2008] The market for IPTV in the UK is driven by varying technical and
market conditions. Existing broadcasters are keen to bring their own products to market,
and existing broadband provisioning is currently not suited to mass IPTV adoption.
IPTV World Forum 2008 Round-up: A Wealth of Emerging Trends Worthy of Metadata Management Advisory Report | Digital Media Infrastructure [March
2008] The IPTV World Forum 2008 show indicated IPTV is now beyond the bleeding
edge of technical implementation and first generation service deployment, but some
cutting edge challenges and innovations are around the corner in 2008.