Page 1
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Index
Critical Concepts ................................................................................................ page 2
Novel .................................................................................................................. page 14
Drama ................................................................................................................. page 24
Poetry ................................................................................................................. page 33
Bibliography ...................................................................................................... page 48
1
Page 2
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
CRITICAL CONCEPTS
DISCOURSE
Discourse begins with Post-structuralism and Michael Foucalt. Structuralism was started by
Ferdinand Saussure, a linguistic. He said that language is compose by signs. Language creates
reality. Signs are shared by a community of speakers in order to be understood and every sign has
two parts: a significant and a signifier.
The signifier is not forever, that is, a lack of meaning does not imply the no existance of it.
If a meaning is lost another will come. Here is where Foucalt appears with post-structuralism.
Foucalt explains the reasons why meanings change.
Discourse is the set of rules established by language. There are a variety of discourses. The
interactions among those discourses change language. This constant interaction allows the
significant to change its meaning, and with those changes new realities can be born.
Some discourses are: medical, religious, psychological, media, legal, etc.
The term discourse is used in a number of different ways. Widely speaking it describes
“how” a text is written, not the content. Basically, it is a language which is understood as utterance
and thus involves subjects who speak and write. Discourse has an object and is directed to or at an
object.
(Critical Concepts I, 1)
Used specifically, (1) the thoughts, statements, or dialogue of individuals, especially of
characters in a literary work; (2) the words in, or text of, a narrative as opposed to its story line; or
(3) a “strand” within a given value system (...) More generally, discourse refers to the language in
which a subject or area of knowledge is discussed.
(Murfin, Ray, 89)
“Basically, it is a language which is understood as utterance and thus involves subjects who
speak and write”
(Cuddon, 228)
2
Page 3
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
CONVENTION
“A literary convention is a feature of a text which is in evidence in a large number of texts.”
(Critical Concepts I, 1)
For instance, a convention is the structure of a sonnet: poetic composition of 14 lines. The
first on use it was Petrarca. The content is about love. This became a convention.
A second sense is a general agreement on how world works.
“A literary device, usage, style, situation, or form so widely employed that it has become
accepted and even expected by knowledgeable readers or audiences.”
(Murfin, Ray, 61)
“In literature, a device, principle, procedure or form which is generally accepted and trough
which there is an agreement between the writer and his or her readers (or audience) which allows
various freedoms and restriction. The term is especially relevant to drama.”
(Cuddon, 178)
TEXT
A text is anything with a meaning. We can see also intertextuality, which alludes a text in
other text. For instance, a can of tomato of Campbell's.
“a term that may be defined in a number of ways. Some critics restrict its use to the written
word”
(Murfin, Ray, 398)
A number of meanings may be distinguished: (a) the actual words of a book in their original
form or any form they have been transmitted in or transmuted to; (b) a book of such words; (c) the
main body of matter in a book - apart from notes , commentary, glosses, index, appendices, etc.; (d)
a short passage taken from the Bible as the theme or subject or a sermon.
(Cuddon, 907)
3
Page 4
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
CANON
Applied to literature the term has two uses. The first, narrow, use is where we apply it to
works by, for instance, Shakespeare: the Shakespeare canon consists of those works accepted as
genuinely written by Shakespeare. In its wider use, the term literary canon has come to refer to
those authors who, by tradition and by consensus, have been regarded as major or great; they are the
classics.
(Critical Concepts I, 3)
A canon is a measure. To be in the canon is to be studied as a writer in the American
University. To be canonial is to be selected and exclusive.
A term used since the fourth century to refer to those books of the Bible that the Christian
church accepts as being Holy Scripture (...) More recently, it has been employed to refer to the body
of works generally attributed by scholars to a particular author (...) Canon may also refer more
generally to those literary works that are “privileged”, or given special status, by a culture.
(Murfin, Ray, 37-38)
A body of writings established as authentic. The term usually refers to biblical writings
accepted as authorized (...) The term can also apply to an author's works which are accepted as
genuine.
(Cuddon, 108)
FORM AND CONTENT
Content is what is said, and form is the way in which it is said. They are connected to the
conventions and between them. But sometimes this connection is a problem. For example,
Alexander Pope is a poet of 18th century. He wrote The Rape of the Lock, in which a lover dares to
cut a lock of his lover girl (in that century the women's hair was untouchable). This work has a
content which is not serious in an epic form. This problematize the connection between content and
form.
4
Page 5
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
About form:
The unique structure of a literary work. When used synonymously with general type, or
genre, it refers to the categories according to which literary works are commonly classified (...) and
may imply a set of conventions (...) Form can be also used generally to refer to rhyme patterns,
metrical arrangements (...) The term is often used more specifically, however, to refer to the
singular structure of a particular work.
(Murfin, Ray, 131-132)
When we speak of the form of a literary work we refer to its shape and structure and to the
manner in which it is made (...) as opposed to its substance or what it is about. Form and substance
are inseparable, but they be analysed and assessed separately.
As secondary meaning of form is the kind of work (...) to which it belongs. Thus sonner,
short story, essay, etc.
(Cuddon, 327)
LANGUAGE AND STYLE
The difference between a literary text and another is not the language but the style.
About style:
“Used generally, the way in which a literary work is written, the devices the author uses to
express his or her thoughts and convey work's subject matter. (...) Style, however, is as elusive to
define as it is to identify and analyze in a particular work or a group of works.”
(Murfin, Ray, 385)
The characteristic manner of expression in prose or verse; how a particular writer says
things. The analysis and assessment of style involves examination of a writer's choice of words, his
figures of speech, the devices (rhetorical and otherwise), the shape of his sentences (whether they
be loose or periodic), the shape of his paragraphs – indeed, of every conceivable aspect of his
language and the way in which he uses it.
(Cuddon, 872)
5
Page 6
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
MOTIF AND THEME
“The theme of a work is the large idea or concept it is dealing with. (...) A motif is much
smaller: it is one of the dominant ideas in a work of literature; a part
of the main theme.”
(Critical Concepts I, 5)
The theme is the main idea of the work while the motif is a secondary theme, that is
something that is important to understand the main theme. There are some motifs around the main
theme that helps the reader to understand it.
Not simply the subject of a literary work, but rather a statement that the text seems to be
making about that subject. (...) Theme is distinguished from motif, a term that usually refers to a
unifying element in an artistic work, especially any current image, symbol, theme, character type,
subject, or narrative detail.
(Murfin, Ray, 400)
“Properly speaking, the theme of a work is not its subject but rather its central idea,which
may be stated directly or indirectly.”
(Cuddon, 913)
A motif is one of the dominant ideas in a work of literature; a part of the main theme. It may
consist of a character, a recurrent image or a verbal pattern.
(Cuddon, 522)
STRUCTURE
“The structure of a text is its overall shape and pattern. This is sometimes referred to
as its form, though strictly speaking form is a more inclusive tem which embraces every
aspect of the work’s technique.”
(Critical Concepts I, 5)
6
Page 7
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
There are two types of structures: an imposed form (a pre-existing format) and an organic
form.
When equated with form, a term that refers to the arrangement of material in a work, that is,
the ordering of its component parts or the design devised by the author to convey content and
meaning. In a poem, for instance, structure encompasses the division of the material into stanzas.
Some critics extend the use of the term to include arrangement of ideas or images. In a play,
structure refers to the division of the material into acts and scenes as well as to the logical
progression of the action. (...) In discussing novels, critics typically use the term to refer to plot (the
ordering of the events that make up the story).
(Murfin, Ray, 384)
“The sum of the relationships of the parts to each other; thus, the whole. (...) we can speak of
the structure of a word, a sentence, a paragraph, a chapter, a book, and so forth.”
(Cuddon, 871)
SYNTAX
Syntax is sometimes used loosely to mean ‘grammar’. However, ‘grammar’ is a much wider
term than syntax, involving the study of every aspect of the system of language. Syntax, on the
other hand, is concerned with the placing and relationship of the units of language within sentences.
More simply, syntax refers to the way in which word order affects meaning.
(Critical Concepts I, 6)
An author, when writes, can use the correct English syntax or not. For instance, John Milton
in Paradise Lost uses epic English syntax, he does not use average English syntax, he moves latin
syntax into English. He uses Paradise Lost to educate society, he has a serious theme and he uses a
serious epic syntax. In this case form and content is fixed.
“Syntax is the arrangement – the ordering, grouping, and placement – of words within a
sentence. (...) Syntax is a component of grammar, thought it is often used – incorrectly – as a
synonym for grammar.”
(Murfin, Ray, 395)
7
Page 8
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“Syntax is the sentence construction.”
(Cuddon, 892)
IRONY
Irony is a way of writing in which what is meant is contrary to what the words appear to say.
(Critical Concepts I, 7)
It is the difference between what we expect to happen, and what actually does happen. It is
often used to add suspense and interest and it is also used to keep the reader thinking about the
moral of the story. There three types of irony:
Verbal irony
This is done intentionally by the speaker. It is the simplest kind of irony. We use it everyday
when we say one thing and really means another. It is often similar to a sarcastic response.
Mock on someone wanting to hurt.
Situational irony
Occurs when a situation turns out to be the opposite of what you thought it would be.
Dramatic irony
Occurs when the audience knows something that the characters in the story, on the screen, or
on the stage do not know. It is like the audience is more aware of what is going on than the
people in the production. This is used to engage the audience and keep them actively
involved in the story line.
“Irony is a contradiction or incongruity between appearance or expectation and reality.”
(Murfin, Ray, 176)
8
Page 9
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
It seems fairly clear that most forms of irony involved the perception or awareness of a
discrepancy or incongruity between words and their meaning, or between actions and their results,
or between appearance and reality. In all cases there may be an element of the absurd and the
paradoxical.
(Cuddon, 430)
SATIRE
“Satire is a mode of writing in which social affectation and vice are ridiculed. The
satirist mocks errant individuals and the folly of society, the purpose being to correct
conduct.”
(Critical Concepts I, 8)
Is a novelty genre or sub-genre. It tends to teach society. There are three types of satire:
Direct satire
Author clearly show that the work is a satire.
Indirect satire
The satire is not stated directly but implied.
Estates satire
A literary genre popular at Medieval times first common among French poets in which the
speaker lists various occupations among the three estates and depicts them in a manner that
shows how short they fall from the ideal of that occupation. Later in England, estates satire
was use to mock on representatives of various classes and occupations from the monarch
down who are portrayed with a particular emphasis on their vices and abuses commonly
associated with each calling.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 377-378)
9
Page 10
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“A literary genre that uses irony, wit, and sometimes sarcasm to expose humanity's vices and
foibles, giving impetus to change or reform through ridicule. The satirist reduces the vaunted worth
of someone or something to its real – and decidedly lower – worth.”
(Murfin, Ray, 357)
“The satirist is thus a kind of self-appointed guardian of standards, ideals and truth; of moral
as well as aesthetic values. (...) Thus satire is a kind of protest, a sublimation and refinement of
anger and indignation.”
(Cuddon, 780)
METAPHOR
“A figure of speech in which one thing is described in terms of another; it identifies one
thing with another.”
(Critical Concepts I, 9)
There different parts of a metaphor: the metaphor comes in two main parts, the tenor and the
vehicle, which are connected by a verb.
Tenor
The tenor is the original subject, that is, the real thing which we are talking about.
Vehicle
The vehicle is both the words and concepts that are invoked by the words.
Connecting verb
The tenor and the vehicle are generally connected by a verb that equates them.
Dimension
10
Page 11
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
The vehicle has dimensions, attributes or variables which can be transferred to onto the
tenor.
There are three types of metaphor:
Dead metaphor
A metaphor that has been so overused that its original metaphorical impact has been lost.
Extended metaphor
A metaphor that is developed at length and that involves several points of comparison.
Sustained metaphor
A metaphor that does not necessarily develop in meaning but is referred to several times in a
literary work.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 370)
A figure of speech (more specifically a trope) that associates two unlike things; the
representation of one thing by another. The image (or activity or concept) used to represent or
“figure” something else is known as the vehicle of metaphor; the thing represented is called the
tenor.
(Murfin, Ray, 210)
“A figure of speech in which one thing is described in terms of another. The basic figure in
poetry. A comparison is usually implicit; whereas in simile it is explicit.”
(Cuddon, 507)
11
Page 12
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
ALLEGORY
An allegory is a story that alludes to other literary works or comments on common
conditions of life. When a work or its passages are allegorical, they are similar to an event,
character or setting in a story that is universally known: a fable, a parable in the Bible, or a Greek
myth. Allegories have two levels of narration occurring at the same time: the actual events,
characters and setting presented in the story, and the ideas they are intended to convey or the
significance they bear.
(Critical Concepts I, 10)
For instance the Statue of New York is allegorical, because it has more than one meaning
and they are unmistakable.
There are three literary forms that we might use when discussing allegory:
Fable
A short history which characters are animals and which have a moral sense.
Parable
Short narratives used by Jesus Christ in His teachings.
Myth
Stories related to religion or philosophy which contain the moral values of the society.
There are two types of allegory we can see in a history:
S ustained allegory
The whole work is allegorical.
12
Page 13
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Episodic allegory
Allegory appears in one or some parts of the work.
There are two main types of allegory: historical and political.
The typical allegory is a narrative – whether in prose, verse, or drama – that has at least two
levels of meaning. The first is the surface-level story line, which can be summed up by stating who
did what to whom and when. Although allegories have coherent plot, their authors expect readers to
recognize the existence of a second and deeper level of meaning, which may be moral, political,
philosophical, or religious. (...) sometimes characters even bear the names of the qualities or ideas
the author wishes to represent. (Personification is a device common to many allegories).
(Murfin, Ray, 8)
“As a rule, an allegory is a story in verse or prose with a double meaning: a primary or
surface meaning; and a secondary or under-the-surface meaning. It is a story, therefore, that can be
read, understood and interpreted at two levels (and in some cases at three or four levels).”
(Cuddon, 20)
13
Page 14
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
THE NOVEL
Although there are earlier novels, the history of the English novel really begins with the
publication of Daniel Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe in 1719. The late arrival of the novel on the literary
scene tells us something important about the genre: it is, above all else, a form of literature which
looks at people in society. (...) Most novels are concerned with ordinary people and their problems
in the societies in which they find themselves. (...) Novels do not, however, present a documentary
picture of life. Alongside the fact that novels look at people in society, the other major
characteristics of the genre is that novels tell a story. (...) So, in thinking about a novel, try to see
this informing structure: a society, and characters who are in some ways at odds with this society.
Do not, however, make the mistake of believing that the novel is written to put across a point. (...)
Novels, however, are long works with a great amount of detail on every page. They, thus present all
the complicating facts need to be taken into account before we can reach any sort of judgement. The
effect of this detail is that we come to recognise the complex reality of a character or event in the
story. (...) As readers, our real interest lies in the complications the novelist creates within the
familiar pattern of characters at odds with their society that enable us to gain a vivid sense of what it
is like for particular individuals to be caught in certain events.
A general point we can make, however, is that, although our first response might be to think
that novelists are mainly interested in presenting an accurate picture of life, because novels also
involve a made-up thing, the story, the novelist can tilt the balance away from a direct picture of life
and make more of the fact that a story is being told.
(Critical Concepts II, 1-2)
A lengthy fictional prose narrative. The novel is distinguished from the novella, a shorter
fictional prose work that ranges from roughly fifty to one hundred pages in length, from which
many scholars have argued the novel developed. The greater length of the novel, especially as
compared with even briefer prose works such as the short story and the tale, permits authors to
develop one or more characters (characterization) and established their motivation, as well as to
construct intrincate plot. (...) the stories recounted in novels are usually and perhaps essentially
products of the imagination (...) some scholars trace the genre's roots back to classical times, to
narrative epics written in verse that tell a sustained story and feature a single protagonist.
(Murfin, Ray, 246-247)
14
Page 15
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Derived from Italian novella, “tale, piece of news”, and now applied to a wide variety of
writings whose only common attribute is that they are extended pieces of prose fiction. But
“extended” begs a number of questions. The length of novels varies greatly and there has been
much debate on how long a novel is or should be. (...) Broadly speaking, the term denoted a prose
narrative about characters and their actions in what recognizably everyday life and usually in the
present, with the emphasis on things being “new” or a “novelty”.
(Cuddon, 560-561)
A novel should have four qualities:
1.- length is generally one hundred pages or more
2.- emphasis is in character
3.- allows for more than one theme
4.- basically based on human experiences
CHARACTER
The people in a novel are referred to as characters. We asses them on the basis of what the
author tell us about them and on the basis of what they do and say. (...) a point to remember is that
the characters are part of a broader pattern: they are members of a society, and the author’s
distinctive view of how people relate to society will be reflected in the presentation of everyday
character. (...) In some novels, however, particularly comic novels, the characters are not
very substantial or credible. (...) Acting images are often used in comic novels, and there is an
emphasis on outward appearance.
(Critical Concepts II, 2-3)
Usually a novel has to main characters: a protagonist (a hero or heroine) and an antagonist (a
villain or villainess).
A character is a person or animal who takes part in the action of a literary work. Depending
on the work, it could be found the following types of characters:
15
Page 16
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Round / Dynamic
A multidimensional character changes/develops in the course of the story.
Flat / Static
Character does not change much or at all.
Misfit
Character whose values are at odds with the other characters.
Stock
Character type that occurs repeatedly in a literary genre
Stereotype
Fixed character with little individuality, often based on racial, social, sexist, or ethnic
prejudices.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 359)
In its most general literary sense, a character is a figure in a literary work. That figure need
not to be human, although most characters are. Characters may be nonhuman animals or even
nonliving entities, provided that the author characterizes them by giving them the attributes of a
human individual. Character also carries the nonliterary connotation of personality and even of
morality.
(Murfin, Ray, 43)
“Modern “charactery” to be the portrayal of individuals”
(Cuddon, 127)
16
Page 17
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
NARRATIVE STRUCTURE
Narrative is the organisation of a series of events into the form of a story. This is obviously
what we have in novels; what is less obvious is how similar the narrative structure is most novels.
(...) A novel usually begins with a description of a place or a character. (...) A character introduced
at the beginning of a novel will usually come into collision with society. (...) The novel will then
progress by taking the characters through a sequence of events extending over a certain time span.
Some conflict will always be in evidence (...) The novel will bring various characters into
confrontation and put characters into problematic situations. (...) The simple sequence of events in a
novel is the story. Plot is slightly different. To talk about the plot of a novel, then, we have to
provide a fuller description of the work, taking into account the nature of the characters and the
significance of events. By the end of the novel the character has either matured or at least
discovered something about himself or herself. (...) The story, however, is not there merely as a
starting-point for the novelist. A story suggests that events can be arranged into a meaningful order.
(Critical Concepts II, 3-4)
About plot:
The plot is the relationship between characters and what emerges of that.
The arrangement and interrelation of events in a narrative work, chosen and designed to
engage the reader's attention and interest (...) while also providing a framework for the exposition of
the author's message, or theme, and for other element such as characterization, symbol, and conflict.
Plot is distinguished from story, which refers to a narrative of events ordered chronologically, not
selectively, and with an emphasis on establishing causalty.
(Murfin, Ray, 286)
“The plan, design, scheme or pattern of events in a play, poem or work of fiction; and,
further, the organization of incident and character in such a way as to induce curiosity and suspense
in the spectator or reader.”
(Cuddon, 676)
17
Page 18
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
NARRATOR
The narrator tells the story in a novel. Novels contain simple stories which, in their telling,
become complicated. There are two overlapping ways by which the novelist can complicate
matters. One is by introducing complications in the content: the inclusion of a mass of details about
people, places and events makes the story seem substantial and real. The other way in which the
writer can complicate is by the way in which he or she chooses to narrate the story: a story can be
told in many ways, for every narrator will see things from a different point-of-view.
(Critical Concepts II, 6)
There are different types of narrator:
Objective narrator
The narrator just tells the story, he does not meddle in the thoughts of the spectator or reader
by including his own opinion or telling what the characters feel or think.
First person narrator
The narrator is the main character of the work, he or she tells the story from his or her own
point of view. It can be recognized by the use of pronouns I, me, us.
Third person narrator
The narrator tells the thoughts and feelings of characters but he is not a character in the
work. It can be recognized by the use of pronouns he, she, they.
Third person omniscient
The narrator does not participate in the story but he knows everything about characters and
the story.
18
Page 19
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Third person limited
The narrator does not participate in the story and he only knows the thoughts and feelings of
one character, his knowledge is limited.
“A speaker through whom an author presents a narrative, often but not always a character in
the work. Every narrative has a narrator; a work may even occasionally have multiple narrators or a
main narrator with sub-narrators.”
(Murfin, Ray, 233)
“Plato and Aristotle distinguished three basic kinds of narrator: (a) the speaker or poet (or
any kind of writer) who uses his own voice; (b) one who assumes the voice of another person or
people, and speaks in a voice not his own: (c) one who uses a mixture of his own voice and that of
others.”
(Cuddon, 535)
STYLE
Style is the way in which the author writes, the way in which he or she tells the story with a
personal stamp.
“Style means the writer’s characteristic manner of expression. What in the end distinguishes
one writer from another.”
(Critical Concepts II, 6)
“The modes and devices of expression in prose or verse. Thus diction, grammatical
constructions, figurative language, alliteration and other sound patterns all enter into style.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 379)
“Used generally, the way in which a literary work is written, the devices the author uses to
express his or her thoughts and convey the work's subject matter.”
(Murfin, Ray, 385)
19
Page 20
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
The characteristic manner of expression in prose or verse: how a particular writer says
things. The analysis and assessment of style involves examination of a writer's choice of words, his
figures of speech, the devices (rhetorical and otherwise), the shape if his sentences (whether they be
loose or periodic), the shape of his paragraphs – indeed, of every conceivable aspect of his language
and the way in which he uses it.
(Cuddon, 872)
APPENDIX: TYPES OF NOVEL
Allegory
The surface story, while a good read in itself, is but a means to an end of a deeper meaning.
Comic novels
These are about people caught in situations which draw out their own absurdities.
Educational
A character engages with a series of predicaments and learns something about him or
herself.
Epistolary
These are in the form of letters or emails to and from people.
Feminist
Boundaries are challenged in the ordered male world. The categorising of male and female
as binary opposites is undermined, particularly the subordinate female.
Gothic
20
Page 21
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
This utopian related form of novel is often set in the past and perhaps in some far away land
of the trees, like Transylvania. The place of dilemma is not the location but in the mind,
however. The point about the fantastical world is not to seek perfection but to show the
fallacy of seeking perfection (e.g. everlasting life) or the evil involved in seeking it
immorally.
Ironic
It is the difference between how things seem and how they really exist. Often this is the
expression of views to those intended or otherwise existing, and through expressing them
creates the real meaning or situation desired.
Magic realism
Events usually are bizarre and even supernatural or mythical. Rationality is undermined for
the purpose or examining what may be more real than the rational.
Naturalism
Influenced by Darwin, this is a form of realism which stresses environment, the family line
(and advantages/ disadvantages) and something of a deterministic outcome.
Picaresque
A set up and denial of the romance, particularly a journey in search of an ideal, and shows
the characters to be foolish and in fact involved in no such thing other than attacking their
predicaments as they prove too powerful or complex to resolve.
Postmodern
A general category for those novels which deny realism, which are poststructural in
language, whose devices draw attention to the novel as a novel. These novels are reflexive.
21
Page 22
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Psychological
Either ordinary grammatical introspection can be used or a stream of consciousness. The
idea is to present at least part of the novel from the mind at a cost of easy to be followed
narrative.
Realism
Realistic novels are like looking glasses through which the reader sees an ordinary world
operate. This produces a story to get lost into, because the only interest is in the characters
as they work through the plot.
Reflexive
The fact that here is a novel is highlighted by devices both written and presented, and this
self-conscious, self referential, approach allows complexity to be better presented.
Romance
This form of novel goes beyond ordinary experience and social predicaments into make-
believe.
Satire
A form of comic novel which intends, by lampooning, to be in fact constructive in its
criticism because it wants things to be better.
Science fiction
A popular novel form which involves some utopian elements. The object is to reflect back
on how we are now, as well as to dream on the possible future where life has more potential.
Another object is to create an environment for moral discussion.
22
Page 23
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
Stream of conciousness
This is a method of writing that tries to locate predicaments in the mind of the person. Our
thoughts jump around and exhibit hopes and fears and the need for instant decisions on all
kinds of matters, with intrusions from all over the place.
Utopian
This is an extreme form of romantic novel because problems are eliminated. This make-
believe intends to point up what could be the case, with the possibilities of utopia, though
sometimes the characters may not be as perfect as the world they live in and some utopias
may collapse at some point within the story, exposing them as a sham or unavailable in
the real world.
Writerly
This kind of novel is usually beyond realism, forcing the reader to generate meaning actively
from the given text. It stands at first glance in binary opposition to being readerly.
23
Page 24
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
DRAMA
Most plays are not only entertaining to watch but also enjoyable to read. Studying a play,
however, is more demanding, for the student is obliged to work out a critical response, and this can
prove difficult. The easiest way of overcoming the problem would seem to be to concentrate on the
personalities of the main characters, saying that the play is about them. (...) Character study,
however, is not a completely satisfactory way of looking at drama, because it puts a false emphasis
on one strand in a play at the expense of the text’s larger significance. (...) A further complication is
that our discussion of dramatic themes should always go hand in hand with a discussion of dramatic
form. (...)
The basic point about all plays, both in formal and thematic terms, is that characters are
always caught up in some sort of crisis, dilemma, or confusion; they are always faced by some sort
of problem. (...) All plays employ the same basic structure of exposition, complication and
resolution. The first part of the play, its exposition stage, prepares the ground: some alteration in the
established pattern of life occurs which means that the existing social order of the play is going to
be thrown into confusion. In the central, and usually longest, stage of a play, we encounter the
complication that ensues from this change. (...)
It is at this point that we start to see how similar most plays are, and also how they differ
from novels or poems. (...) A play, then, is less concerned with the individual characters involved in
it than with questions about the whole basis and nature of social organisation and social order. This
is one reason why we have political plays but very few political poems or novels, for drama insists
upon this public debate about society. (...)
In brief, we can say that any play is about the order that has been created in society
and the awareness that social order is fragile –that all sorts of disruptive forces can intrude
at any moment. (...)
The pattern of drama we have been describing is very clearly in evidence in the two
dominant modes of drama: comedy and tragedy. In comedy, the disorder that threatens the
character’s lives and social concord is overcome and most comedies end either with marriage or a
dance, the traditional signs of harmony and order in society. In tragedy, on the other hand, what we
witness is the falling apart of all signs of order as we are confronted by the most shocking form of
disorder, death itself.
(Critical Concepts III, 1-2)
24
Page 25
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
In today's usage, a serious literary work usually intended for performance before an
audience. (...) The term drama originally encompassed all works, whether prose or verse, written to
be performed theatrically. (...) Although play is the most common synonym for drama, a play is a
drama intended for performance. Thus although all plays are, broadly speaking dramas, not all
dramas are plays.
(Murfin, Ray, 96)
“In general any work meant to be performed on a stage by actors. A more particular meaning
is a serious play; not necessarily tragedy.”
(Cuddon, 237)
ACT AND SCENE
A play is traditionally divided into acts and scenes. Most plays have five acts, but 19th and
20th century dramatists favour three acts.
About act:
A major division of the action of a play or drama. Acts are generally subdivided into scenes.
Acts and scenes were developed by ancient Roman dramatists, who normally divided their plays
into five acts. (...) Modern plays typically consist of two or three acts, but some playwrights have
dispensed with acts altogether in favor of serial scenes or episodes.
(Murfin, Ray, 3)
A major division in play. Each act may have one or more scenes. Greek plays were
performed as continuous wholes, with interpolated comment from Chorus. Horace appears to have
been the first to insist on a five-act structure. At some stage during the Renaissance the use of five
acts became standard practice among French dramatists. (...) Since early in the 20th century most
playwrights have preferred the three-act form, though the two-act play is not uncommon. In modern
productions, especially in the cases of five and four acts plays, there is only once curtain-drop and
interval. Many modern plays are written and presented in a sequence of scenes.
(Cuddon, 7-8)
25
Page 26
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
About scene:
“Traditionally, a subdivision of an act in drama. Today, however, many playwrights dispense
with acts and compose plays that involve a series of scenes.”
(Murfin, Ray, 359)
“A sub-division of an act in a play or an opera or other theatrical entertainment.”
(Cuddon, 788)
CHARACTER
The people in a play are referred to as dramatic characters. They are fictional devices. We
assess them on the basis of what they say and do, and what the other characters say about them.
This is important: we must avoid loose conjecture and base everything we say on the evidence of
the text. We only really understand the characters, however, when we relate them to the broader
themes of the play.
The main character is called the hero or protagonist. The term ‘hero’ does not mean someone
who is brave or noble: heroes may be good or evil, low- or high-born. Often opposing the hero is
the villain or antagonist (...) In some plays, however, particularly comedies, the characters are not
presented in such a credible way. This is because comedy presents people as familiar types acting
out familiar roles.
(Critical Concepts III, 3-4)
It is needed one character at least.
See Character in Novel in page .
DRAMATIC STRUCTURE
All plays have the same basic structure of exposition, complication and resolution. The
exposition stage prepares the ground by showing us some sort of change taking place in the
character’s lives or the social order. In the central stage of the play the dramatist develops the
26
Page 27
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
complication that arises from this change as the characters seek to come to terms with the problems
that have developed so that a sense of disorder prevails. In the resolution, however, as the play
reaches its denouement or ending, order is reestablished, or the characters at least come to terms
with the new situation that has developed.
(Critical Concepts III, 4)
“In a play, structure refers to the division of the material into acts and scenes as well as to
the logical progression of the action.”
(Murfin, Ray, 384)
“The formal structure of a play consists of its acts and scenes and their interdependent
balance. The non-formal structure comprises the events and actions which take place.”
(Cuddon, 871)
GENRE
“Literary form, a recurring type of literature.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 366)
“From the French genre for “kind” or “type”, the classification of literary works on the basis
of their content, form, or technique.”
(Murfin, Ray, 146)
“A French term for kind, a literary type or class.”
(Cuddon, 342)
Types of plays: comedy, tragedy, tragicomedy, historical, farce.
PLOT
If we tell the story of a play we are constructing a simple account of what happens. ‘Plot’,
however, is a more inclusive term: it could be said to be fully developed version of the story. It
27
Page 28
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
takes account of the nature of the characters, the way in which events are related to each other and
their dramatic effect. In talking about the plot we are trying to talk about the overall significance of
the play.
Many plays, however, have not just one plot but two –that is, two fully developed stories
running side by side. The main plot focuses on the central character, the subplot on another set of
characters or events. This might seem to complicate matters, but in fact the subplot usually
illuminates the main plot. This is particularly the case when the subplot has close parallels with the
main plot.
Not all plays, however, have pots in the way that we conventionally use the word.
(Critical Concepts III, 5-6)
See Plot in Novel page .
SCRIPT
The script is the written words and directions of a play.
“There are five main meanings: (a) the characters used in a writing system; (b) handwriting;
(c) the text of a manuscript; (d) the text of a play or film ir television or radio broadcast; (e) to write
a script for a play or film.”
(Cuddon, 802)
SETTING
The setting is where the action takes place.
That combination of place, historical time, and social milieu that provides the general
background for the characters and plot of a literary work. (...) In drama, setting may refer to the
physical backdrop of the play, that is, the scenery and sometimes the props. Setting frequently plays
a crucial role in determining the atmosphere of a work.
(Murfin, Ray, 366)
28
Page 29
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“The where and when of a story or play; the locale. In drama the term may refer to the
scenery or props.”
(Cuddon, 812)
DIALOGUE, MONOLOGUE AND SOLILOQUY
Everything a character says is a speech. If there are two or more characters in the speech, we
have a dialogue. If the character is talking alone and the speech is long, we have a monologue. And
if the character is talking to himself or in a loud voice to the audience, we have a soliloquy.
About dialogue:
“Conversation between two or more characters in a literary work.”
(Murfin, Ray, 87)
“Two basic meanings may be distinguished: (a) the speech of characters in any kind of
narrative, story or play; (b) a literary genre in which “characters” discuss a subject at length.”
(Cuddon, 219)
About monologue:
“An extended narrative, whether oral or written, delivered uninterrupted and exclusively by
one person (although it may be heard or witnessed by others).”
(Murfin, Ray, 222)
“A term used in a number of senses, with the basic meaning of a single person speaking
alone.”
(Cuddon, 517)
About soliloquy:
“A soliloquy is a type of monologue performed onstage as part of a play in which a single
29
Page 30
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
speaker reveals his o her inner thoughts out loud but while alone.”
(Murfin, Ray, 222)
“A soliloquy is a speech, often of some length, in which a character, alone on the stage,
expresses his thoughts and feelings.”
(Cuddon, 838)
COMEDY
Comedy consists of laughing at people caught in difficult situations which we know will
usually be resolved; traditional comedy ends with marriage or a dance, the disorder that threatened
the social concord having been overcome. At the heart of comedy, however, lies something more
disturbing, for it is a way of looking at the world that regards the whole of social life as an elaborate
charade which is constantly disrupted by people’s folly. Comedy often shows us how people’s
irrational impulses, such as love or greed, or their absurd self-importance, undermine any claims of
society to be a rational, civilised order. The aim of the comic dramatist is not to correct behaviour,
for he or she is too aware of our irredeemable folly.
This could be a gloomy vision, but it emerges as funny because of the detached stance of the
comic writer. People are seen as types acting out familiar roles. The action is meant to strike us not
as real but as illustrative of human weakness, with everything being exaggerated. It is an alternative
perspective to that of tragedy, informed not by a sense of how complex the problems are that face
people, but by a sense of how ridiculously serious people are about themselves.
(Critical Concepts III, 6)
“A work, mainly a play, in which the materials, dialogues and scenes are selected and
managed primarily in order to interest, involve, and amuse and make an audience laugh.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 360)
“Broadly defined, any amusing and entertaining work; more narrowly defined, an amusing
and entertaining drama.”
(Murfin, Ray, 53)
30
Page 31
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
There are two types of comedy:
High comedy
Subject is serious, it provokes thoughtful laughter. It is also known as comedy of smiles. The
humor grows out the character. The plot is possible and probable. It is usually a realistic
portrayal of life.
Low comedy
Objective is riotous laughter. It is the comedy of the belly laugh. The plot is possible but not
probable. It is believable for the moment. Characters are dominated by the situation. It
requires little or no thought by the audience.
TRAGEDY
The simplest definition of tragedy is that it is a play that ends with the death of the main
character. There are two main types: the type written by Shakespeare and his contemporaries (and
by classical dramatists, such as Sophocles) in which we witness terrible disorder in a society, and a
narrower type of tragedy, established by Ibsen and Strindgerg in the 19th century, which focuses on
the breakdown of a family. It is the most ambitious from of drama. Indeed, because a tragedy can
carry such weight of meaning, students sometimes shy away from a particular tragedy’s full
implications, creating a simplified version of what the play is about. The most common reductive
approach is one which concentrates on the tragic hero or heroine, stressing his or her nobility in
suffering; this is a way of making sense of tragedy in reassuring and coherent human terms. The
fortitude of the hero or heroine is important, but far more central is the impression tragedy conveys
of how chaotic life becomes when the established social order is destroyed. Tragedies begin with
some alteration in the existing social order, and this change leads to a shocking destruction of
human life. Comedy laughs at the folly of people, but tragedy asks fundamental questions about the
nature and purpose of existence in a world where, if the conventional social bonds are broken, the
most appalling violence and vicious self-interest become dominant. It is the tragic heroes and
31
Page 32
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
heroines who usually pose these large questions about life in the speeches they make as they
experience the full horror of what the world can be like. (...)
What modern tragedy has in common with earlier tragedy is that it explores the painfulness
of a world where fictions of a rational social order can no longer be maintained. Yet there is a
difference. It has something to do with the fact that the central characters of modern tragedy are
fairly insignificant figures: they are antiheroes, meaning that they are just ordinary people as
opposed to the great men and women who feature in earlier tragedies.
(Critical Concepts III, 7-8)
“Literary, particularly dramatic, representations of serious and important actions which
culminate in a disastrous conclusion for the protagonist.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 381)
“A serious and often somber drama, written in prose or verse, that typically ends in disaster
and that focuses on a character who undergoes unexpected personal reversals.”
(Murfin, Ray, 403)
Tragic hero
The tragic hero is someone we, as an audience, look up to someone superior. The tragic hero
is nearly perfect and the audience feel identify with him or her.
The tragic flaw
The tragic hero is nearly perfect but he or she has one flaw or weakness.
Catharsis
Catharsis is the audience's purging of emotions trough pity and fear. The spectator is
purgued as a result of watching the hero fall.
32
Page 33
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
POETRY
The most common misunderstanding of poetry is the assumption that it is concerned with
esoteric, abstract matters remote from everyday experience. This is not the case. While poetry itself
is a complicated way of writing, its basic subject matter is usually far from complicated.
In theory a poem can be about anything. There are, however, certain topics that concern us
all and these are the recurrent themes of poetry. Love is a central experience in life, and it is not
surprising that love poems outnumber all others. Death is also a major concern to us all, and this
can be linked with religion: most people at some time wonder whether life ends with death or if
they are part of some greater pattern. Poets need not, however, concern themselves with such
weighty topics: they might wish to write about nature, or their families or some other domestic
matter. Poetry becomes less frightening if we realise that it is always concerned with ordinary
human concerns, with the daily matters of everybody’s life. (...) The central themes of poetry are
familiar topics from everyday experience: love death, nature, religion. What he poet does is take
one of these familiar themes and write about it in a striking way. (...)
Poets, however, can never be totally original. Like any artist they have to work within the
limits of their chosen art. In the case of poetry these limits are surprisingly narrow. We can, in fact,
reduce poetry to two basic types: narrative and lyric. A narrative poem is a poem that tells a story:
the main kinds are the epic, the ballad and the romance. The vast majority of poems, however, are
lyrics. A lyric is a poem in which the poet offers a direct response to some aspect of experience. (...)
A structure is in evidence in all lyric poetry and provides us with a simple way of getting
hold of what any poem is about. This will be the case even with those poems where we may feel
that very complex ideas are being advanced. (...)
There are many such poems where the meaning is found not in the poet’s ideas but rather in
the gap between the patterns the writer creates and life’s lack of pattern, in the gap between the
dream of order and the reality of life’s lack of order. Although this might seem a difficult idea to
grasp, it is not really so, because it takes us back to the main characteristic of poetry: that it is a
patterned response to that unpatterned thing – life.
(Critical Concepts IV, 1-3)
Generally said to be one of the three or four major literary genres, a term defined and
described in so many different ways that one might easily argue that there are as many ways to
33
Page 34
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
characterize it as there are people. However, there is general agreement about what poetry is not;
poetry is generally contrasted with prose and frequently distinguished from verse – broadly
speaking, any rhythmical or metrical composition. Poetry is a subset of verse, from which it is
distinguished (and to which it is superior) by virtue of its imaginative quality, intricate structure,
serious or lofty subject matter, or noble purpose.
(Murfin, Ray, 290)
“It is a comprehensive term which can be taken to cover any kind of metrical composition.
However, it is usually employed with reservations, and often in contradistinction to verse.”
(Cuddon, 682)
Poetry may be scheduled in three categories:
Narrative
Long history in a very long poem, it has characters, maybe a speaker, we do not have
narrator but speaker. For instance John Milton with Paradise Lost.
Lyric
What we usually called poems. They are short. We perhaps can talk about a speaker (usually
the writer) but not of characters (is rarely).
Balad (song)
Late middle ages (14th c.- 15th c.). Scottish tradition. William Blake returned this tradition
with Songs of Innocence & Songs of Experience.
ALLITERATION
“Repetition of the same letter (or, more precisely, sound) at the beginning of two or
more words in a line of poetry.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 4)
34
Page 35
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
The repetition of sounds, especially consonant sounds, within a passage of prose or poetry.
Unlikely, the repetition of vowel sounds is distinguished from alliteration and called assonance.
Consonance is a kind of alliteration in which a similar sequence of consonants varies by changing
vowel sound, as in top, tap, tip.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 355)
“The repetition of sounds in a sequence of words. Alliteration generally refers to repeated
consonant sounds (often initial consonant sounds or those at the beginning of stressed syllables) but
has also been used by some critics to refer to repeated vowel sounds.”
(Murfin, Ray, 9)
“A figure of speech in which consonants, especially at the beginning of words, or stressed
syllables, are repeated. It is very old device indeed in English verse (older than rhyme) and is
common in verse generally. It is used occasionally in prose.”
(Cuddon, 23)
ARCHAISM
“The use of old antiquated words in poetry.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 5)
“A word, expression, or phrase that has become obsolete. Archaism are sometimes used
intentionally to evoke images, sensations, and attitudes associated with the past.”
(Murfin, Ray, 22)
“This term denotes what is old or obsolete. It use was common in poetry until the end of the
19th c.”
(Cuddon, 52)
ASSONANCE
“Repetition of the same vowel sound in two or more words in a line of poetry.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 6)
35
Page 36
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“The repetition of vowel sounds in stressed syllables containing dissimilar consonant
sounds.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 357)
“The repetition of identical or similar vowel sounds, usually in stressed syllables, followed
by different consonant sounds in proximate words.”
(Murfin, Ray, 24)
“Sometimes called 'vocalic rhyme', it consists of the repetition of similar vowel sounds,
usually together, to achieve a particular effect of euphony.”
(Cuddon, 58)
BLANK VERSE
Unrhymed poetry, but a very disciplined verse form in that each line is an iambic pentameter
(a ten-syllable with five stresses). I t is close to the rhythm of speech, but stylised enough in its
regularity to be quite distinct from speech or prose. A poem in blank verse appears less formally
contrived than a poem that rhymes, and therefore our attention is not so forcibly drawn to the way
in which the poet is creating a pattern.
(Critical Concepts IV, 7)
“Poetry or poetic drama written in unrhymed iambic pentameter lines. It is one of the most
common kinds of verse in English.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 358)
“Broadly defined, any unrhymed verse but usually referring to unrhymed iambic
pentameter.”
(Murfin, Ray, 34)
“consists of unrhymed five-stress lines; properly, iambic pentameters”
(Cuddon, 89)
36
Page 37
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
ELEGY
A poem written on death of a friend of a poet. The ostensible purpose is to praise the friend,
but death prompts the writer to ask, ‘If death can intervene so cruelly in life, what is the point of
living?’ By the end of the poem, however, we can expect that the poet will have come to terms with
his or her grief.
(Critical Concepts IV, 7)
“A formal and sustained poetic lament (and usually consolation) for the death of a particular
person.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 363)
In Greek and Roman times, the term elegy was used to refer to any poem composed in
elegiac meter (alternating dactylic hexameter and pentameter lines). Since the seventeenth century,
elegy has typically been used to refer to reflective poems that lament the loss of something or
someone (or loss or death more generally).
(Murfin, Ray, 102)
In the elegy the speaker is a mourning with something or someone lost.
EPIC
The most ambitious kind of poem. An epic represents the great deeds of a heroic There is,
however, more to epic than just the story. The scope of epic is encyclopaedic: it is the big poem that
seeks to explain everything. The poet does not just focus on telling the story but attempts to include
all knowledge and the whole of human experience. The poems are made all-inclusive in various
ways, figure or group of figures.
(Critical Concepts IV, 8)
“Long narrative poem on a great or serious subject told in an elevated style and centred on a
heroic or quasi-divine figure on whose actions depends the fate of a tribe or nation.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 363)
37
Page 38
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“A long and formal narrative poem written in an elevated style that recounts the adventures
of a hero of almost mythic proportions, who often embodies the traits of a nation or people.”
(Murfin, Ray, 105)
“An epic is a long narrative poem, on a grand scale, about the deeds of warriors and heroes.
It is a polygonal, 'heroic' story incorporating myth, legend, folk tale and history. Epics are often
significance in the sense that they embody the history and aspirations of a nation in a lofty or
grandiose manner.
(Cuddon, 264)
Epic genre is a narrative poetry, character, speaker and plot. It deals with the deeds of a hero,
rhyme an rhythm.
FREE VERSE
“Poetry written in irregular lines and without any regular metre. To grasp the significance of
this we need to know that other forms of verse are based upon a regular metrical pattern.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 9)
“Poetry not written a regular, rhythmical pattern, or meter.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 366)
“From the French vers libre, literally meaning 'free verse', poetry that lacks a regular meter,
does not rhyme, and uses irregular (and sometimes very short) line lengths.”
(Murfin, Ray, 134)
“Called vers libre by the French, it has no regular meter or line length and depends on
natural speech rhythms and the counterpoint of stressed and unstressed syllables.”
(Cuddon, 331)
HEROIC COUPLET
38
Page 39
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“A pair of ten-syllable lines that rhyme: a poem as a whole can be written in a sequence of
heroic couplets.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 10)
“Iambic pentameter verse that rhymes in couplets (aa, bb, cc, ...) also known as heroic verse
from its use in epic poetry in English”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 367)
“A paired of rhymed lines written in iambic pentameter. Chaucer was the first to compose
verse using heroic couplets”
(Murfin, Ray, 156)
“It comprises rhymed decasyllables, nearly always in iambic pentameter rhymed in pairs,
one of the commonest metrical forms in English poetry but of uncertain origin. It is generally
thought that it developed with Chaucer”
(Cuddon, 378)
IMAGERY
When we read a poem there are several things we respond to. Initially we follow the
argument or the story, trying to decide what the poem is ‘about’. If we cannot immediately
see, it helps, to look for some structural opposition. Once we have got hold of the poem’s theme we
can then start to examine some of its subtleties and how it creates its effect upon the reader. One
aspect of this is how the poet orders the poem (his or her use of the stanza, rhyme and syntax to
create certain effects), but the most important thing we have to look at is what the pot does
with language. Terms such as ‘alliteration’ or ‘assonance’ cover the effects of the sounds
in a sequence of words, but much more important is the choice of individual words. The
most convenient way of describing the key words in a poem is to use the term ‘imagery’:
imagery covers every concrete object, action and feeling in a poem and also the use of
metaphors and similes.
(Critical Concepts IV, 11)
39
Page 40
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“The descriptive language used in literature to recreate sensory experiences.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 368)
“A term used to refer to: (1) the actual language that a writer uses to convey a visual picture
(...); and (2) the use of figures of speech, often to express abstract ideas in a vivid and innovative
way.”
(Murfin, Ray, 167)
“Imagery as a general term covers the use of language to represent object, actions, feelings,
thoughts, ideas, states of mind and any sensory or extra-sensory experience. An 'image' does not
necessarily mean a mental picture.”
(Cuddon, 413)
LYRIC
A poem in which the poet writes about his or her thoughts and feelings. The basic type is the
song, but we use the term to cover all poems that present the poet’s immediate response to life,
including sonnets, odes and elegies. Lyric poems can deal with any facet of experience, such as
love, death, nature or religion, or some domestic, social or political issue, but we are always offered
the poet’s direct response. Most poems are like this: indeed, the only other approaches a poet can
take are to write a narrative poem, in which ideas are explored through the medium of a story, or to
opt for a form borrowed from prose, such as the verse essay or epistle.
In essence the lyric is an attempt to confront and understand some aspect of our complex
experience of life. The poet tries to order and organise his or her feelings and impressions.
(Critical Concept IV, 13)
“A poem that expresses the observations and subjective feelings of a single speaker. Lyric is
distinguished from dramatic and narrative poetry. Although the boundaries are flexible, most lyric
poems are fairly short, and are often personal.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 369)
“Today, a brief melodic and imaginative poem (...), characterized by the fervent but
40
Page 41
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
structured expression of private thoughts and emotions by a single speaker who speaks in the first
person.”
(Murfin, Ray, 194)
METRE
Metre means the pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables in a line of poetry. The most
widely used line in English poetry is the iambic pentameter: this is a ten-syllable line with five
stresses or emphases. (...) Often, however, poets will disrupt this regular pattern on rhythm to
produce certain effects in their verse. The reason for this is that a poem written in a totally
predictable and regular pattern would become very mechanical. (...) We have called this pattern
both metre and rhythm. The difference between these, strictly speaking, is that metre is something
the poet imposes on the words, arranging them into a pattern. Rhythm, however, is something that
comes with the language itself because of the way we speak. In reading a poem it is the rhythm of
the language we hear, its movement and flow. Indeed, the only way to spot the stresses in a line of
poetry is to read it as you would normal prose, noticing which syllables you emphasise. Most of the
time the pattern of syllables will be straightforward. When it is not, then the poet will be
varying the metre to suit his or her theme. (...)
There are three technical terms related to prosody (prosody is the study of versification,
especially metre, rhyme, stanzas) which it can prove useful to know.
a) Caesura: a pause in a line of poetry, often marked by punctuation.
b) End-stopped lines: a pause at the end of a line of poetry, marked by punctuation.
c) Run-on lines: there is no pause at the end of a line. This running-over of the sense of one
line into the next is also called enjambement, meaning a striding over.
(Critical Concepts IV, 15-17)
“The rhythmical pattern of a poem, determined by the number and types of stresses, or
beats, in each line. Meter is usually described by giving both kind of feet and the number in each
verse.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 371)
41
Page 42
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“The more or less regular pattern of accented and unaccented syllables in poetry.”
(Murfin, Ray, 213)
“The term refers to the pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables in verse.”
(Cuddon, 509)
MOCK-HEROIC
A mock-heroic (or mock-epic) poem imitates the elaborate form and elevated style of epic
poetry, but applies it to some trivial subject matter. Epic is the most ambitious form of poetry,
presenting its protagonists in heroic encounters which can affect the whole destiny of the world.
When the style and conventions of epic are used to describe petty incidents the effects is comic and
satiric.
(Critical Concepts IV, 18)
A type of high burlesque, the mock epic is a lengthy poem written in the lofty and exalted
style of the epic but that deals with an utterly trivial subject. Mock epics are not generally intended
to mock the epic form or style, but rather to mock the subject by treating it with a dignity it does not
deserve.
(Murfin, Ray, 217)
“A work in verse which employs the lofty manner, the high and serious tone and
supernatural machinery of epic to treat of a trivial subject and theme such a way as to make both
subject and theme ridiculous.”
(Cuddon, 514)
NARRATIVE POETRY
“A poem that tells a story. The two basic types are epic and ballad”
(Critical Concepts IV, 19)
42
Page 43
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
ODE
An elaborate and elevated lyric poem, extending over quite a few stanzas, and addressed to a
person or thing or to an abstraction. In its more straightforward form it simply praises the subject,
but as it developed in the romantic period the typical ode became more hesitant and philosophical.
(...) In analysing an ode, look first at hoe elevated language is used to create a sense of something
that transcends the mundane. Then look for the opposing images that create a sense of the harsher
realities of life. The poem is likely to become complicated –with difficult ideas, an involved
argument and a variety of images in each stanza- as the poet attempts to convey his or her
awareness of being trapped in everyday difficulties, an awareness of the gap between an ideal and
the reality of life.
(Critical Concepts IV, 20)
A long lyric poem that is serious in subject and treatment, elevated in style, and elaborate in
its stanzaic structure. Odes are usually longish (a few pages), serious, and dignified. They could be
written into two different modes: the Horatian ode is regular – each stanza has the same form; and
the Pindaric ode is irregular – an inconsistent number of feet in each line, for instance, or variation
from stanza to stanza.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 372-373)
“A relatively long, serious, and usually meditative lyric poem that treats a noble or otherwise
elevated subject in a dignified and calm manner.”
(Murfin, Ray, 257)
“A lyric poem, usually of some length. The main features are an elaborate stanza-structure, a
marked formality and stateliness in tone and style (which make it ceremonious), and lofty
sentiments and thoughts. In short, an ode is a rather a grand poem; a full-dress poem.”
(Cuddon, 608)
RHYME
Identify of sound between two words, extending from the last fully stressed vowel to the end
43
Page 44
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
of the word (...).
There are technical terms for the different kinds of rhyme, which it can prove useful to
know:
a) End-rhyme occurs at the end of lines.
b) Internal rhyme occurs within lines.
c) Strong rhymes (also called masculine rhyme): a single stressed syllable –‘hill’ and ‘still’.
d) Weak rhymes (also called feminine rhyme): two rhyming syllables, a stressed one
followed by an unstressed one –‘hollow’ and ‘follow’.
e) Eye rhyme or courtesy rhyme: words spelt alike not actually rhyming –‘love’ and ‘prove’.
f) Imperfect rhyme (also called partial, near, slant or off-rhyme): words which do not quite
rhyme and so produce a sense of discordance –‘soul’ and ‘wall’.
g) Half-rhyme (also called ‘consonance’): repetition of the same consonant sounds before
and after different vowels –‘groaned’ and ‘groined’.
(Critical Concepts IV, 21-22)
“The repetition of identical or closely related sounds in the syllables of different words, most
often in concluding syllables at ends of lines.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 377)
“Generally, the repetition of identical vowel sounds in the stressed syllables of two or ore
words, as well as of all subsequent sounds after this vowel sound.”
(Murfin, Ray, 342)
RHYTHM
“Rhythm means the flow or movement of a line, whether it goes fast or slow, is cal or
troubled.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 22)
“From the Greek for 'flow', a term referring to a measured flow of words and signifying the
basic (though often varied) beat or pattern in language that is established by stressed syllables,
unaccented syllables, and pauses.”
(Murfin, Ray, 344)
44
Page 45
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
“In verse or prose, the movement or sense of movement communicated by the arrangement
of stressed and unstressed syllables and by the duration of the syllables. In verse the rhythm
depends on the metrical pattern. In verse the rhythm is regular, in prose it may or may not be
regular.”
(Cuddon, 753)
SONNET
A fourteen-line poem. There are two basic types: the Italian or Petrarchan has an octave (8
lines) and a sestet (6 lines) and rhymes abba abba cde cde. The English or Shakesperian sonnet is
made up of three quatrains (4 lines) and a couplet and rhymes abab cdcd efef gg. The metre is
iambic pentameter. A sonnet sequence is a series of sonnets on the same theme by the same poet:
there are three major sequences in English, by Shakespeare, Spenser and Sidney. All are about love.
The sonnet form, however, has been used by many poets to treat all manner of themes. The sonnet
appeals to poets because it is such a disciplined form: there is a challenge in confronting the
diffuseness of experience within such an ordered mould.
(Critical Concepts IV, 23)
A lyric poem consisting of a single stanza of fourteen iambic pentameter lines linked by an
intricate rhyme scheme; Elizabethan and Petrarchan being the predominant forms. The Italian (or
Petrarchan) sonnet can be broken into two parts, the octave (eight lines) and the sestet (six lines).
The octave typically rhymes abba abba; the sestet varies, sometimes cde cde, sometimes some
variant of that. The Shakespearean (or English) sonnet is instead three quatrains and a couplet:
typically abab cdcd efef gg.
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 378-379)
“From the Italian word sonnetto, meaning 'little song', a lyric poem that almost always
consists of fourteen lines (usually printed as a single stanza) and that typically follows one of
several conventional rhyme schemes.”
(Murfin, Ray, 372)
STANZA
45
Page 46
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
A sixteen-line poem might be divided into four equal units of four lines: these units of verse,
separated by a space in the printed text, are called stanzas. Four-line units (quatrains) are the most
common, but the term refers to any such group of lines. Each unit normally contains the same
number of lines, and usually the same rhyme scheme is employed. In long poems, where there are
divisions at irregular intervals, each unit of verse is referred to as a verse paragraph.
The logic informing the use of stanzas is simple, but always worth commenting on,
particularly if you feel that the stanza pattern falters at any stage in a poem, as this is an effective
way of enacting the difficulty the poet is having in ordering his or her view. Many stanzas have no
special name and often a poet will invent a stanza form for a particular poem. But there are some
patterns that are widely used:
a) Couplet: a pair of rhymed lines.
b) Heroic couplets: rhymed lines in iambic pentameter.
c) Tercet or triplet: three lines with a single rhyme.
d) Quatrain: a four-line stanza.
e) Rhyme royal: a seven-line stanza in iambic pentameter rhyming ababbcc.
f) Ottava rima: an eight-line stanza rhyming abababcc.
g) Spenserian stanza: a nine-line rhyming ababbcbcc; the first eight lines are iambic
pentameter, the ninth an alexandrine.
h) Sonnet: a fourteen-line poem in iambic pentameter. There are variations on the
sonnet, such as a shortened form invented by Hopkins called the curtal sonnet. This has
two separated stanzas, one of six lines, the other of four –with a halfline tail-piece.
i) Canto: a sub-division of a narrative poem.
(Critical Concepts IV, 24-25)
“A grouping of the verse-lines in a poem, set off by a space in the printed text. Common
stanza forms are quatrains, terza rima, rime royal, an the sonnet. Where the form of the stanza is
entirely irregular and the lengths of the stanzas vary, the term verse paragraph is sometimes used.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 379)
“A grouped set of lines in a poem, usually physically set off from other such clusters by an
46
Page 47
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
extra line of space. Stanzas in a given poem need not have the same rhyme scheme, and, technically
speaking, rhyme need not be present for a group of lines to be called a stanza.”
(Murfin, Ray, 377)
SYMBOL
“An object which stands for something else (e.g. a dove symbolises peace). In a poem it is a
word which, while signifying something specific, also signifies beyond itself.”
(Critical Concepts IV, 26)
“A specific word, idea, or object that may stand for ideas, values, persons, or ways of life.”
(Ceballos, Eizaga, 380)
A symbol may thus be defined as a metaphor in which the vehicle – the image, activity, or
concept used to represent something else – represents many related things (or tenors) or is broadly
suggestive. (...) Symbols are distinguished from both allegories and signs. Like symbols, allegories
present an abstract idea through more concrete means, but a symbol is an element of a work used to
suggest something else. (...) Symbols (...) have one or more particular significations. Symbols are
much more broadly suggestive than signs.
(Murfin, Ray, 391)
47
Page 48
Ana María Leal Oliva Portfolio of Commentary of texts
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ceballos, A. Critical Concepts
Ceballos, A. & Eizaga, B. English as a second Language and Its Literature. Cádiz: Grupo
Editorial Universitario, 2005
Cuddon, J. A. Dictionary of LITERARY TERMS & LITERARY THEORY. England: Penguin
Books, 1998
Murfin, R. & Ray, S. M. The Bedford Glossary of Critical and Literary Terms. The United
States of America: Bedford Books, 1997
48