Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso Facultad de Filosofía y Educación Instituto de Literatura y Ciencias del Lenguaje Developing critical thinking through speaking using video-based advertisement An elective workshop for 10 th graders TRABAJO DE TITULACIÓN Para optar al grado de Licenciado en Educación y al Título de Profesor de Inglés Estudiante: Catalina Pavez Piña Profesora guía: Mónica S. Cárdenas-Claros Segundo Semestre 2015
61
Embed
Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso …opac.pucv.cl/pucv_txt/Txt-3500/UCD3958_01.pdfadvertisement is used as a content carrier throughout the project. Students are expected
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso
Facultad de Filosofía y Educación
Instituto de Literatura y Ciencias del Lenguaje
Developing critical thinking through speaking using video-based advertisement
An elective workshop for 10th graders
TRABAJO DE TITULACIÓN
Para optar al grado de Licenciado en Educación y al Título de Profesor de Inglés
Estudiante: Catalina Pavez Piña
Profesora guía: Mónica S. Cárdenas-Claros
Segundo Semestre
2015
2
Acknowledgements
To the most important people in my life, my family. Thanks to my mother, María Eugenia,
for loving me, being my unconditional supporter and for spending the last 22 years taking
care of me and working hard to give me the opportunities I have had. Also, I would like to
thank my grandmother, Adriana, who has been a second mother for me and who has given
me her support and love. I would also like to dedicate this work to my great-grandmother
who passed away two years ago and who was the most loving and caring person I have ever
known. Since then, I know I have had an angel looking after me. I love you all and I will
always be thankful of the beautiful family I have. I hope I can compensate in some way all
you have done for me because I could not be here if it was not for you.
Secondly, I would like to thank all the people that have given me their friendship
throughout these years. To my best friends from high school María Fernanda and Camila
for being the most supportive and caring friends I could have, even though distance does
not allow us to meet so often. To my roommate Alejandra, for being the most loyal friend
since first day at university and for all the moments we have had together in this stage,
especially during these two years being roommates. To Sebastián for his unconditional
friendship and for his constant support throughout these years. I love you all.
To all the teachers that have been part of this stage in my life, especially to the ones that
have had an important role in this stage. To Ms Oyanedel, who has been supportive and has
offered me her help since the moment I met her in English II. To Ms Cárdenas, for her help,
guidance and support, for questioning this project since day one, for helping me understand
my own project, and for believing in this project. I could not have done it without your
help.
3
Abstract
This graduation project analyses the relevance of developing critical thinking in the second
language classroom and provides a set of guidelines to develop students higher order
thinking skills that are operationalized as a sequence of sample lessons. Accordingly,
advertisement is used as a content carrier throughout the project. Students are expected to
develop their speaking skills along with their critical thinking skills, in order for them to be
able to critically assess video-based advertisement in a round table discussion.
Each generation needs to be more educated than the one that preceded it because people
live in a rapidly changing world that introduces more complex and technical situations to
their lives and people need to have the right skills to be able to cope with these changes
(Halpern, 2003). This situation is not different for second language (L2) learners as they are
expected to develop higher order thinking skills in the L2 in order to be proficient in it
because higher order thinking skills lead to higher order learning skills, which have as an
outcome a higher level of language proficiency (Liaw, 2007).
Developing critical thinking skills becomes important when we think in the society people
live in. Being able to discriminate true information, evaluate what people see in their
everyday lives and determine whether or not it is important for them should be important
tools for people to possess when they face society in their adulthood considering all the
responsibilities this implies. As media and technology are now at reach of most people, it is
important for people not to fall for everything they hear or see. Maybe society should
question themselves, should critical thinking be taught at school? Is it important to apply
them in the foreign language context?
Fairclough (1998) claims that “people cannot be effective citizens in a democratic society if
their education cuts them off from critical consciousness of key elements within their
physical or social environment” (p.6). This claim becomes clear when we think that people
face different types of messages every day through media. Being aware of the influence
those messages have on people becomes essential. Halpern (1998) criticizes schools for
asking students to learn, remember, and make decisions among other thinking skills,
without teaching them the process for doing it. Considering this author’s proposal, we need
to address a gap that she found in education, students are not prepared to do what they are
expected to do because they are not taught how to do it. When these students leave school,
society will expect them to have certain thinking skills and they may not be able to fulfill
these expectations. The question is, how would they be good thinkers if they have not been
trained on how to think?
6
Nowadays, society has a relatively easy access to media. Media provides people with huge
amounts of information. Advertisement has as its main channel media, since it is the most
effective way to get to most people. Either people turn on their TVs, log in on Facebook,
watch a video on Youtube or turn on their radios, there is no chance they are going to evade
advertisement. In Facebook, advertisement is at the right side of the page, if you want to
watch a video on Youtube, you are obliged to watch at least 5 seconds of an advertisement.
Newspapers, television, radio, the streets among others are covered in advertisement, so it
is easy for people to have access to it and also to be influenced by it (Cook, 2001).
Therefore advertisement represents a key tool to develop higher order thinking skills,
especially in students.
To realize the amount of time people spend in contact to media and, at the same time, to
advertisement it is useful to check some statistics. In Chile, people spend a substantial
amount of time in front of a television or using the internet. They spend on average almost
5 hours per day watching television (Ibophone, 2009). It was also found out that 63% of
people older than 15 declare to be able to search for information on the internet and 44% of
the Chilean houses had internet access (Censo, 2012).
This graduation project aims to develop second language learners’ critical thinking skills
through the use of video-based advertisement. It is designed for students in tenth grade in
high school. According to Programas de Estudio (Ministerio de Educación, 2011) students
at this level should be working on media in one of the units for the year. Also, high school
teachers are expected to use authentic materials, especially when working on listening
comprehension (MINEDUC, 2011). Despite the recognition of the use of authentic material
Programas de Estudios documents does not present concrete guidelines on how to include
authentic material in the L2 classroom.
Similar work has been done in the international field and, even though the results are not
conclusive, they demonstrate that critical thinking instruction in L2 learning setting may
increase L2 learners’ proficiency (Davidson and Dunham 1996; Liaw, 2007). In Liaw
(2007) study, the group that received instruction in critical thinking skills did better in the
evaluations than the one that did not receive the instruction. Davidson and Dunham (1996)
7
present a comparison between the beginning and the end of the course, where students
scored better after receiving critical thinking instruction.
In the Chilean context there has not been much work done in the critical thinking field,
especially related to L2 settings. Two previous graduation projects can be compared with
this one. Mora (2013) proposes to develop higher order thinking skills working with
intertextuality, focusing on reading and writing skills. Pacheco (2013) proposes to develop
media awareness using social identity as content carrier and having as an outcome a
planned speech activity. These proposal differ from this project because in various points.
First of all, this project considers speaking as a skill that needs to be developed since it is
the most likely ability to be used in a real setting. Second, it aims to develop critical
thinking, which should be useful in all aspects of life and not only when assessing media,
even though media plays an important role inside of this project. Finally, the expected
outcome on this project expects students to be prepared for planned and unplanned speech,
for making the outcome more real.
This graduation project is mainly divided into two sections: the Theoretical Framework and
the Pedagogical Proposal. The Theoretical Framework is divided into four main strands that
are thoroughly reviewed: Critical Thinking, Speaking, Advertisement and Task-based
syllabus. The second section, the Pedagogical Proposal, presents the design of a syllabus
and some sample lessons based on the theoretical framework and the needs analysis
presented in Appendix B.
8
Literature Review
Nowadays, education needs to provide students with tools for them to be able to face
society when they leave school. We are living in an era of information explosion and
education needs to address the topic of critical thinking inside the classroom (Halpern,
2003).
This literature review presents the four strands in which this pedagogical proposal will be
based: critical thinking, speaking, advertisement and task-based syllabus.
1. Critical Thinking
Critical thinking has been defined in different ways through the years. Most definitions
include terms such as ‘judgment’, ‘metacognition’, ‘reason’, ‘logic’, ‘questioning’ and
‘mental processes’ (Halpern, 2003). Lipman (1991) proposes the definition of critical
thinking as healthy skepticism, people do not need to believe everything they see and they
need to be able to discriminate between what is believable and what is not. Elder and Paul
(1994) see critical thinking more as a form of self assessment. They claim that people need
to become responsible for their own thinking and be able to assess it in a correct way.
Halpern (2003) defines critical thinking as “the use of those cognitive skills or strategies
that increase the possibility of a desirable outcome” (Halpern, 2003, p.6). She also adds that
it should be “purposeful, reasoned and goal directed”. This definition is the one that
considers the previous two definitions since if people decide on a strategy looking for a
desirable outcome they need to develop their own conclusions by looking for themselves
pieces of evidence that make the outcome likely to happen. People need to be able to self-
assess their own thinking if they want to reach the most likely outcome, because they need
to be aware of the consequences each option they think of is going to have and which is
most likely to result in the expected outcome. For being good critical thinkers, people need
to reach some standards of clarity, relevance and reasonableness among others (Fisher,
2011).
Critical thinking skills encompasse five skills, which, at the same time, present a series of
sub-sills according to Facione (1990), which are shown in Table 1:
9
Table 1: Skill Sub- skills
Interpretation: to comprehend and express the meaning or significance of a wide variety of experiences, situations and data among others.
- Categorization - Decoding
significance - Clarifying meaning
Analysis: To identify the inferential relationships among statements, questions or other forms of representation intended to express beliefs, judgments and experiences among others.
- Examining ideas - Identifying
arguments - Analyzing
arguments Evaluation: To assess the credibility of statements or other representations which are accounts or descriptions of a person’s perception, judgment and opinion among others.
- Assessing claims - Assessing arguments
Inference: To identify and secure elements needed to draw reasonable conclusions, to form conjectures and hypotheses, to consider relevant information.
- Querying evidence - Conjecturing
alternatives - Drawing conclusions
Explanation: To state the results of one’s reasoning and to justify that reasoning in terms of evidence.
- Stating results - Justifying
procedures - Presenting
Arguments Self-Regulation: To self-consciously monitor one’s cognitive activities. - Self-examination
- Self-correction (Taken and adapted from Facione, 1990)
Critical thinking skills are considered through the graduation project trying to address all
the skills needed to be a good critical thinker.
These higher order thinking skills are needed nowadays because of the immense amount of
information people is exposed to. People need to discriminate between useful and true
information from the information that comes from unreliable sources or that is useless.
Language plays an important role in the way we see information. This is why it is essential
for people to learn how to use their critical thinking skills to assess the language they are
exposed to everyday through television, social networks and other sorts of media.
1.1 Critical Language Awareness
Within the parameters of critical thinking and what it conveys, critical language awareness
plays an important part in today’s society. Critical Language Awareness, according to
Fairclough (2013) “highlights how language conventions and language practices are
invested with power relationships and ideological processes which people are often
unaware of” (p.7). Considering that people constantly receive new messages, they need to
10
be aware if the message intends to convince, to persuade, to inform or to distort information
in order for them to make informed decisions.
Fairclough (2013) proposes that, considering the society we are living in, today it is
essential to raise critical thinking among students. “A language education focused upon
training in language skills, without a critical thinking component, would seem to be failing
in its responsibility to learners” (Fairclough, 2013, p.6). For this reason, in the workshop
proposed as part of this graduation project students will learn to identify the different ways
in which language can be used as a persuasive tool without them being aware of it. In this
way, they would develop their language awareness skills as a tool to develop their critical
thinking skills.
1.1.1 Framework for Developing Critical Language Awareness
Discourse is shaped by society and vice versa. Fairclough (2013), identifies the three
dimensions of discourse “it is a spoken or written language text; it is an interaction between
people, involving processes and interpreting the text; and it is part of a piece of social
action” (p.10). In the design of the pedagogical proposal, the dimensions are going to be
reflected in the work students will do with advertisement. At first, they are going to study
advertisement as a piece of text, learning about the important components of this text.
Secondly, they are going to make connections between the messages and the intention these
messages have with the receiver and finally, they are going to raise their own conclusions
on the role advertisement plays in the social aspect.
Figure 2 shows the relationship between the elements of the discourse mentioned above.
Figure 2
(Taken from Faiclough, 2013)
11
In Figure 2, it is shown how the three dimensions of discourse interact with the three
dimensions of critical discourse analysis: description, interpretation and explanation. In the
description stage, the text is described in terms of its formal features. In the interpretation
stage, the text is analyzed in terms of the conventions the text includes (e.g. genre or
discourse type), or if they do not follow the typical conventions. In the explanation phase,
the text is interpreted in terms of its interaction with the social action.
At the first stage, learners will be able to describe the text in terms of its language. In the
case of the pedagogical proposal the first stage is going to be present when the text is
studied in terms of parts and students will describe what they see. In the second stage,
which involves interpretation of the text, students will be working with advertisement and
its components, but now centered in the strategies advertising campaigns use to get the
consumer. In the last part, the explanation, students will be able to give clear arguments on
how they reached their conclusions on advertisement based on what they have learned in
the previous stages and their personal experience and the interpretation they give to the role
the different strategies played in the social interaction with consumers.
1.2 Process for the development of Higher Order Thinking Skills.
Limbach and Waugh (2010), propose a five-step model to help learners developing higher
order thinking skills. The model aims to make learning more active as well as giving them
responsibility for their own learning.
The five steps are shown in Figure 3:
Figure 3
(Taken and adapted from Limbach and Waugh, 2010)
I. Determine Learning
Objectives
II. Teach Through
Questioning
III. Practice Before
Assessment
IV. Review, Refine and Improve
V. Provide Feedback &
Assessment of Learning
12
I. Determine Learning Objectives
The first step, determine learning objectives, recognizes the importance of clear objectives
inside of the classroom. The aim of this step is that teachers set key objectives that
demonstrate what students should be able to do at the end of the class (Limbach and
Waugh, 2010). The ideal to be reached is that students go through all levels of thinking so
as to scaffold them to get to the higher levels (application, synthesis, evaluation)
II. Teach Through Questioning
The second step states that questions are an important element inside the classroom. Clasen
and Bonk (1990) propose that, even though there are many strategies that can have an
impact on a person’s thinking, questions by the teacher are the most significant. There are
two types of question: Convergent questions, which have one or more specific answers as
correct. Divergent questions are questions that present a variety of different answers and
they foster higher levels of thinking, which is why they should be present in the classroom.
III. Practice Before Assessment
The third step states that “practice is necessary to master any skill; students must have the
opportunity to practice the knowledge, skills, attitudes, and behaviors that will be
evaluated” (Limbach and Waugh, 2010). Practice also makes students more aware of their
learning experience and more involved in it.
IV. Review, Refine and Improve
This stage aims at checking on the advances the class has had in the development of higher
order thinking skills. Teachers need to be able to act as monitors in their class activities. As
well as developing an environment of confidence. Also the teacher should have a register of
students’ participation in class (Limbach and Waugh, 2010).
V. Provide Feedback & Assessment of Learning
Limbach and Waugh (2010) claim that it is important for students to know under which
criteria they are going to be assessed and, as mentioned before, it is relevant for them the
opportunity to practice what they are going to be assessed for.
13
Throughout the pedagogical proposal, lessons will follow these five steps to encourage
students to develop their higher order thinking skills, boosting in the same way their critical
thinking skills.
1.3 Critical thinking in L2
The integration of critical thinking in the foreign language classroom could play an
important role (Liaw, 2007). However, there is no strong empirical information that
supports this claim. There are two studies that, even though the evidence is not sufficiently
strong, demonstrate that critical thinking instruction in L2 learning settings may translate
into an improvement in L2 learners’ proficiency (Davidson and Dunham, 1996; Liaw,
2007). Davidson and Dunham (1996) studied 36 Japanese students, dividing them into two
groups. One had content-based instruction and instruction in critical thinking while the
other just had content based instruction. The group that was instructed on critical thinking
scored better in tests than the one that was not.
Liaw (2007) did her study in China, with 32 students. All students went through critical
thinking instruction, so she compared the results obtained at the beginning and at the end of
the course, finding that students scored significantly better at the end of the course.
During the workshop, students will work on developing their critical thinking skills in order
to develop their proficiency in the L2. In this way, students will be able to assess different
types of information, in this case advertisement, and give their own opinions about it,
raising conclusions and establishing relationships with other types of sources and with their
personal experience.
1.4 Critical Thinking in Chile
There is little work regarding critical thinking in the L2 classroom in the Chilean context.
There are two previous graduation projects that somehow consider critical thinking in their
proposals. The first one addresses the development of higher order thinking skills inside the
classroom through reading, using as tool intertextuality (Mora, 2013). In this work, she uses
extensive reading as the tool for students to reach the higher levels of thinking. Mora’s
work guides students to work on a critical review of a book, which is the final outcome.
14
Even though it seems similar to this graduation project, the focus of the present one is the
development of speaking skills instead of writing skills, which might be more useful for
students in a real-life setting, and it is also a skill that is not frequently practiced in the L2
classroom, whereas writing skills are usually more present.
Secondly, Pacheco (2013) proposes to develop speaking skills through developing media
awareness. His work consisted on teaching students a framework for analyzing media and
teaching them how to create arguments using songs and readings among other materials.
Even though Pecheco’s project seems to be more similar to the one presented in this
graduation project, his project focuses on raising media literacy, which, despite sharing
some features with critical thinking, is not the same. Being able to think critically is useful
for students in all aspects of their lives, not only when assessing media-related material.
Also, the expected outcome of Pacheco’s proposal is the production of a video where
students relate media with social identity formation, which is a planned speech activity. The
present pedagogical proposal expects students to be able to critically assess a piece of
advertisement, and even though round table discussions have a planned speech component,
they also present an unplanned speech part where students need to answer questions, so it is
closer to a real-setting situation.
2. Speaking
Thornbury (2007) suggests that speaking in the L1 and the L2 is not extremely different; in
fact for both of them learners need to do the same mental processes: conceptualizing,
formulating and articulating. Accordingly, the pedagogical proposal will start from the
basic of advertisement because, even though students are supposed to have an intermediate
level of English, if they do not know enough about the topic of advertisement, they need to
start learning the main concepts in order to be able to formulate ideas and produce speech.
According to Thornbury (2007), usually speaking is not practiced as a skill in the L2
classroom. This skill is usually used as a means to practice grammar structures, so students
practice their speaking by using the focal grammar structure they are covering in a sentence
or a short paragraph, or sometimes they just repeat orally the answers they write for a
determined grammar exercise. These situations are not similar to what they would face
15
outside the classroom. Students need to practice their speaking skills as if they were going
to be used outside the classroom. This is why the classroom settings should resemble what
students would live in a real situation in the L2.
Here is when the appropriation stage or the collaborative construction between behavior
and mental processes (Thornbury, 2007) becomes important. Appropriation activities as
Thornbury (2007) states are important to start practicing speaking as a skill rather than a
controlled-practice of grammar.
Some useful activities for the stage of appropriation according to Thornbury (2007) are:
drilling, dialogues, writing tasks and reading aloud among others. Some writing tasks will
take place throughout the proposal.
After students have gone through the stage of appropriation, they should be encouraged to
be autonomous learners. There are also a series of activities that Thornbury (2007) proposes
for developing autonomy. The ones more useful for this proposal are:
2.1 Presentations and talks
Thornbury (2007) presents presentations and talks as a good practice for real-life settings,
even though students may not be asked to make a presentation in an L2. If at the end of the
presentation classmates have the opportunity to ask questions, this becomes a good
opportunity for practice unplanned speech. In the pedagogical proposal student will have to
prepare a presentation at the middle of the workshop in order to prepare students for the
round table discussion.
2.2 Discussions and debates
According to Thornbury (2007), discussions can either be spontaneous or the teacher may
prepare cards with topics for discussion. Debates should be ideally more prepared than
discussions, so as to students to have time for studying their arguments and points of view.
At the end of the workshop, students will have a round table discussion, which is why these
autonomy-related activities are relevant for the pedagogical proposal. The discussion is
going to be centered on the topic of advertisement, which is going to be the main tool to get
16
to develop critical thinking as well as speaking skills. As advertisement is the content
carrier of this pedagogical proposal, now it is going to be reviewed as the third strand.
3. Advertisement
Cook (2001) defines advertisement as “the promotion of goods or services for sale through
impersonal media” (p.9). Cook (2001) also adds that there are some campaigns that can be
considered advertisement, but they do not necessarily offer a product or a service, for
example, political campaigns. Throughout this pedagogical proposal the focus will be on
advertising campaigns that offer products.
Goddard (1998) defines advertising based on its Latin origin ‘advertere’ which means ‘turn
towards’. According to this definition, she explains the way in which images are used as
attention-seeker devices. According to Goddard (1998) “one attention-seeking strategy
developed in recent years to increasing level of sophistication is the startling image” (p.12).
Images are an essential part of advertisement; therefore, companies have found different
ways of using these to draw attention to them, even releasing controversial campaigns.
One key characteristic of advertisement is that they use a number of persuasive techniques
to get people’s attention. Apart from images, advertisement uses different phrases to get
persuade people to buy their products. A representation of these strategies are the ten
claims in advertisement proposed by Schrank (1994), who presents a list of ten claims that
demonstrate how these claims are constructed in terms of convincing people to use the
advertised product or service, even though they do not show any advantage over other
products.
Table 4:
Advertising claim Definition The weasel claim A weasel word is a modifier that practically negates the
claim that follows. The unfinished claim A claim in which the ad claims the product is better, or
more of something, but does not finish the comparison. The “We’re different and unique” claim A claim that states that there is nothing like the product
being advertised. The “water is wet” claim A claim that says something about the product that is true
for any brand in that product category. The “so what” claim A claim that is true, but does not give an advantage to the
product.
17
The vague claim A claim that is not clear. Use of colorful but meaningless words.
The endorsement or testimonial A celebrity or authority appears in the advertisement. The scientific or statistical claim Uses scientific proof, specific numbers, and impressive
mystery ingredient. The “compliment the consumer” claim A claim that butters-up the costumer with some sort of
flattery. The rhetorical question The ad demands a response from the audience
Even though Schrank centers these claims in written advertisement, we can encounter these
claims present in video-based advertisements since video advertisement also uses catchy
phrases in order to get the consumer’s attention. For this reason, video watchers are
exposed, unknowingly to these techniques and become passive consumers of different types
of products that they might not even need.
Advertisement will be the material students are going to use in order to improve their
critical thinking skills in an oral way, and these ten claims will be an important part of the
study of advertisement during the proposal.
4. Task-based approach
Ellis (2009) presents four key elements that should be present in a task: first, the main focus
of a task has to be on meaning. Secondly, students should fill a gap (e.g. express an
opinion). In the third place, students need to trust on their previous knowledge to complete
the activity. Finally, there is an expected outcome apart from the use of the L2.
Ellis (2009) proposes that for task-based language teaching “the primary unit for designing
a language program and for planning individual lessons should be a task” (p. 223). Because
of this, and considering the four elements presented by the author, this graduation project is
going to be organized in a task-based syllabus, centering the students’ attention on the
meaning, filling the gap present on language, giving them the resources for them to be able
to complete the tasks relying on their sources and having as an outcome a different activity
than just the use of the language.
18
Pedagogical Proposal
Course syllabus Name of the course: Talking about commercials
This is a 30-hour elective workshop for high school students who are in an intermediate level of English. The students are expected to develop their higher order thinking skills in order to be able to think critically in the L2. Also, they are expected to improve their speaking skills through the use of video-based advertisement and the final preparation of a round table discussion. This pedagogical proposal is informed by Needs Analysis conducted with 22 students from Rubén Castro School (Appendix B) in four aspects: purpose, skill, materials and topic. The students demonstrated their interest in using videos to develop some higher order thinking skills which are essential in order to think critically. In terms of skills to be developed, students showed their preference for developing speaking skills over the writing skills. When inquired about the type of video-based material they would like to use for the class, most of them chose advertisements. The topic was also important, and their three main preferences were: sports, food and technology. Therefore, this workshop is going to use video-based advertisement in order to improve students’ critical thinking skills through speaking.
Course organization
The lessons in this workshop are designed based on the task-based teaching principles. Throughout the workshop students will learn about the elements that are present in a piece of advertisement, the different persuasive strategies that advertisement uses, and in this way raise critical thinking skills. As the workshop is designed for students to reach higher order thinking skills, all the levels will be present in the workshop so as to scaffold students learning from the lower order thinking skills (knowledge, comprehension, analysis) to the higher order thinking skills (application, synthesis and evaluation), following the five-step
19
model presented in the Literature review. Speaking activities are going to be included throughout the workshop to prepare students for the round-table discussion.
The units for the course are presented as follows:
In unit I: students will learn what is an advertisement, the main elements of an advertisement and the different strategies advertisements use to persuade people. This unit will be based on the ten types of claims used in advertising, discussed in the literature review. The objective is for students to be able to identify these strategies in different types of advertising campaigns. In terms of speaking skills, in this unit this type of activities will be focused on conversation and chat. The students will use descriptive language to talk about advertisement.
In unit II: students will learn how to analyze advertisements based on the persuasive strategies leaned in unit I. For this, they will be taken through the three phases that Fairclough proposes for the interpretation of discourses (description, interpretation and explanation). Students will learn how to summarize and synthesize in order to help them doing this with the information they collect for their round table discussion. In terms of speaking, students will be presenting in groups at the end of the unit.
In unit III: students will work on the development of their arguments for the round table discussion. They will work with expressions for opinions and argumentative language.
In unit IV: students will work on the consolidation of their knowledge, presenting the round table. Students will need to use descriptive language as well as argumentative language.
20
Course objective:
By the end if this workshop, students will be able to critically assess video-based advertisement through a round table activity.
Unit Objectives I: Let’s meet advertisement! -Recognize the different parts of an advertisement.
-Identify persuasive strategies in different advertising campaigns. - Use descriptive language to talk about advertisement - Search for key information to prepare for a round table. -Search for representative video-based advertisement.
II: Getting into advertisement!
- Describe an advertising campaign in terms of persuasive strategies. -Analyze different advertising campaigns in terms of persuasive techniques. - Synthesize information
III: Creating your own arguments!
- Develop arguments on how persuasion is portrayed in video-based advertisement. -Assess critically an advertising campaign.
IV: Let’s present! - Use of persuasive/argumentative language to present their opinions on advertising in a round table discussion. - Describe advertisement in order to argument on them.
Assessment
In-class participation: The teacher will keep a record of each student’s participation in class. (15%)
Homework: The teacher will keep a record of the responsibility with materials and homework of each of the students. (15%)
Presentation: Students will prepare a 8-minute presentation on an advertisement that has called their attention, identifying different persuasive techniques present in it. (20%)
Round table discussion: Students will form groups of 4 and they will prepare a round table discussion in which they will discuss different advertisements depending on different techniques used. For this, students must use language of argumentative/ persuasive language to express their opinions. (40%)
Self-assessment of presentation and round table: Students will assess their own work and performance in the activities of presentation and round table. (10%)
21
Criteria Poor Acceptable Excellent Use of language from the units
The student does not use argumentative or persuasive language. The student is not able to describe a video based advertisement. The student does not use the names of the claims or forgets the parts of the advertisement. (1 point)
The student uses argumentative language, but tends to forget some of the names of the claims, or he/she is not clear enough when describing an advertisement. (3 points)
The student uses argumentative language. The student remembers all the claims he/she is referring to. The students is able to describe an advertising campaign. (5 points)
Task achievement The student does not complete the assigned task assigned to her. He/she is not able to answer a question or participate in the round table discussion. (1 point)
The student is able to participate in the round table discussion, but he/she does not manage to answer questions right. (3 points)
The students is able to participate actively in the round table. He/she also is able to answer questions from classmates or the teacher (5 points)
Discourse organization The student is not able to express his/her ideas clearly. He/she gets lost while speaking. (1 point)
The student is able to express his/her ideas. Sometimes the student gets lost at the moment of speaking (3 points)
The student is able to express his/her ideas in a clear way. The student does not lose track of thought. (5 points)
Grammar There are more than 7 grammar mistakes during the round table. (1 point)
There are between 4 and 7 grammar mistakes during the round table. (3 points)
There are less than 4 grammar mistakes during the discussion. (5 points)
Pronunciation There are more than 7 noticeable pronunciation mistakes. (1 point)
There are between 4 and 7 pronunciation mistakes. (3 points)
There are less than 4 pronunciation mistakes. (5 points)
Answer to question The student is not able to answer the question made by classmates or the teacher. (1 point)
The student is able to give a short answer to the question made by classmates or the teacher, but the answer is not complete or well explained (3 points)
The student is able to give a complete and clear answer to the questions made by the classmates or the teacher. (5 points)
22
Sample Lessons This section presents a series of sample lessons from each one of the units
presented in the syllabus.
23
Lesson 1
Objectives: Recognize the parts of a video based advertisement. Recognize the ten claims in advertisement.
Warm up:
Speaking Time! Get together in pairs. Discuss the following questions: Do you usually watch the advertisements part on TV? Is there any advertisement that has called your attention? Which one? Why?
Getting Ready! Activity 1: Recognizing parts of a video-based advertisement.
Lecture Time! You will learn about the elements of advertisement. Listen to the teacher and take some notes.
Unit I: Let’s meet advertisement!
24
a) Match the following elements of a video-based advertisement with its corresponding definition.
b) Compare your answers with your partner.
Lecture Time! You will learn about some persuasive strategies used in advertisement: the ten claims of advertisement. Listen to the teacher and take some notes.
Video
Audio
Computer Graphics
Target Audience
The letters or numbers that appear on the screen. Also special effects generated by computer.
Pictures and images that catch people’s attention.
People who are the intended receiver of the advertisement.
The music, the story told, voices, etc.
25
Activity 2: Recognizing the ten claims of advertisement.
a) Match the definition of the claim with its corresponding name from the box.
Claim Definition 1. It uses a modifier that practically negates the claim
that follows. 2. The claim states the product is better, or more of
something, but does not finish the comparison. 3. A claim that states that there is nothing like the
product being advertised. 4. A claim that states something about the product
that is true for any brand in that product category. 5. A claim that is true, but does not give an advantage
to the product. 6. A claim that is not clear. Use of colorful meaningless
words. 7. A celebrity or authority appears in the
advertisement. 8. Uses scientific proof, specific numbers, and
impressive mystery ingredients. 9. A claim that butters-up the costumer with some sort
of flattery. 10. The ad demands a response from the audience.
b) Compare your answers with a classmate. Then share them with the rest of the class.
Hands on! Activity 3: Recognizing the “ten claims of advertisement”
a) Read the list of advertising statements from next page. Recognize the claim they belong to:
The unfinished claim – The compliment the consumer claim – The weasel claim – The rhetorical question – The endorsement or
testimonial – The “water is wet” claim – The scientific or statistical claim – The “we´re
different and unique” claim - The vague claim – The “so what” claim
Glossary: Weasel words: words used in order to avoid being clear or direct. Claim: an affirmation of something as a fact.Brand: the company name in a product. Butter-up: To flatter someone. To treat someone especially nice in hopes of receiving special favors.
Glossary: Luscious: attractive. Sizzle: durable. Iron: Chemical element (Fe) Dandruff: dead skin under the hair which falls in small pieces.
26
a) _________________________________
b) _________________________________
c) _________________________________
d) _________________________________
e) _________________________________
f) _________________________________
g) _________________________________
h) _________________________________
i) _________________________________
j) _________________________________
b) Compare your answers with a classmate.
Activity 4: Describing advertisement.
Listening Time!
Pre-Listening: a) Discuss with a classmate the following questions.
Do you buy food based on its commercial? Which food commercial has called your attention? Why? Have you seen any M&M’s advertisement? Do they have any feature that calls your attention? Write down your conclusions:
“Supergloss does it with more color, more shine, more sizzle, more!”
“Only Doral has this unique filter system”
“Easy-Off has 33% more cleaning power than another popular brand”
“Shouldn’t your family be drinking Hawaiian Punch?”
“Helps control dandruff symptoms with regular use”
“Lips never looked so luscious”
“Geritol has more than twice the iron of ordinary supplements”
“Great Lash greatly increases the diameter of every lash”
“We think cigar smoker is someone special”
“I’m no pushover, I’m Proactive” – Avril Lavigne
27
Useful words for describing audios: Adjectives Nouns Dynamic Rhythm Fast Voice Gentle Music Hard Tone Sweet
Useful words for describing images: Adjectives Nouns Colorful Energetic Setting Dark Aggressive Background Modern Classical Landscape Realistic Beautiful Fantastic Calming
Useful words for describing CG: Adjectives Animated Simple Basic Sophisticated Colorful Digital Interactive Simple Modern
Useful words for describing people: Nouns Adjectives Men Young Women Elder Children Teenagers
While-listening: b) Watch the following M&M’s advertisement: D:\mm commercial 2013[1].mp4 c) Write down a description in terms of the four elements on an advertisement presented in the Lecture
d) Discuss your answers with a classmate in terms of similarities and differences. Then, write down your conclusions in the following chart: Similarities Differences
28
Wrap up:
Writing Time! Activity 5: Creating a new claim
a) Get together in pairs. Think of three new phrases for the M&M’s advertisement you just watched. b) Discuss to which of the ten claims they would belong to. c) Write down the new phrase, the claim it belong to and the reasons why you think it belong to that
This phrase belong to _____________________________________________________________ claim because ___________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________.
2. _______________________________________________________________________________. This phrase belong to _____________________________________________________________ claim because ___________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________.
3. _______________________________________________________________________________. This phrase belong to _____________________________________________________________ claim because ___________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________.
d) Present two of the new claims to the class.
Reflection:
a) When you watch a TV advertisement, what does call your attention? Why do you think this happens? Have you noticed any of the elements you learned in this lesson in an advertisement? _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Homework:
Get together in groups of 4 students. Each group will receive a topic (sports, food or technology).
Go to youtube.com. Look for an advertisement on the given topic for next class. All member of the group should have watched the same advertisement. Consider that: the sound is clear, it is attractive and you are able to understand it. If you cannot understand the advertisement, go to the bottom of the video, click on
CG and select subtitles in English. Look up the words you don’t understand.
29
Lesson 2
Objective: Create a short script using some of the “ten claims in advertisement”.
Warm up:
Speaking Time! Get together in pairs. Go to the teacher’s desk and take a magazine. Look for advertisements. Choose one and discuss:
a) Target audience (who is the advertisement directed to?) b) Image: What makes the image attractive to people? c) Claim (to which claim(s) does the main phrase belong to?
Go to the board. Put your advertisement there. Copy the main phrase on the board and write the target audience and the claim next to the advertisement. Some of you will explain the reasons for your answers.
Getting Ready: Activity 1: Identifying claims
a) Match the claim with its corresponding definition. Claim Definition 1. The unfinished claim It says something about that is true for any brand in
that product category. 2. The scientific or statistical claim A celebrity or authority appears in the advertising. 3. The “water is wet” claim It butters up the costumer with some sort of flattery 4. The endorsement or testimonial claim
It claims the product is better, but does not finish the comparison.
5. The compliment the consumer claim
Uses scientific proof, specific numbers, impressive ingredients, etc.
b) Compare your answers with a classmate. Hands on:
Listening Time! Pre-Listening:
a) Discuss the following questions with a classmate: Have you seen any mobile phone advertisement recently? What has called your attention? Who do you think mobile phone advertisements are usually directed to? What does a mobile phone advertisement need to be attractive?
Write down your conclusions: _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
30
Glossary Chaos: a state of confusion or disorder. Blizzard: a storm of wind and snow.
b) Get together in groups of 4 students. Go to the following link: D:\mophie 2015 Game Day
Commercial “All Powerless”[1].mp4. Watch the advertisement about a mobile phone. c) Answer the following questions:
1. What is being advertised?
_____________________________________________________________________________ 2. What is happening in Nebraska?
_____________________________________________________________________________ 3. What is happening in Africa?
_____________________________________________________________________________ 4. What is happening in Paris?
______________________________________________________________________________ 5. Who appears at the end of the advertisement?
______________________________________________________________________________ 6. What is the cause of all those disasters?
______________________________________________________________________________ 7. How much more battery power does the cellphone have?
_______________________________________________________________________________ 8. Who is the intended audience?
d) Choose one of your classmates to share the answer with the class. e) In the same groups of 4 students, watch the video again. Read the statements below and identify the
claims you think were present in the advertisement and discuss in what moment the claim is evident. Write down your ideas in the following table:
Claim When? The unfinished claim
The “water is wet” claim
The endorsement or testimonial claim
The scientific or statistical claim
The compliment the consumer claim
f) Share your answers with the rest of the class. Add any extra information you find useful from your
classmate’s work.
Activity 2: Identifying key elements of an advertisement
a) Individually, answer the following questions using the advertisement you chose as homework: 1. What is being advertised?
2. Is there any famous person promoting the product? Who? Why do you think they chose that person? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
3. Does the advertisement show any comparison? What is the product being compared to? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
4. Does the advertisement show any statistics? What do they say? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
5. What characteristics of the product are being promoted? Do other brands of the same product have the same characteristics? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
6. Does the advertisement say something good about the potential consumer? What does it say? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
7. Who do you think the advertisement is directed to? Why do you think so? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
8. What claims are used in this advertisement? Write down the claims and the reasons you think the claim is present in the advertisement.
Claim Why? Because
Because
Because
Because
b) Discuss the answers with your group from the previous activity. As you watched the same video, compare answers and complete the ones you have incomplete.
c) Each member of the group is going to for group with one of the members from the other groups. d) Show the advertisement to your classmates. e) Discuss about the questions you answered above. Ask them their opinions on the advertisement. Add
any extra information your classmates have noticed and your previous group has not.
Wrap up:
Activity 3: Create your own advertisement.
Writing Time! a) Get together in groups of 4 students. Create an outline for an advertisement on sports. Consider the
elements of advertisement (video, audio, computer graphics and target audience) . b) Explain each of the elements on your advertisement in the following page. Draw a picture that
represents your idea on each part. Consider at least two claims for this activity (audio, video or CG).
c) Each member of the group is going to present one of the elements in front of the class.
33
Reflection:
a) What did you learn in this lesson? Were you aware of these claims? When you watch TV advertisement, do they have any influence on you? Why? Write your answers individually: ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
34
Unit 2, lesson 1
Lesson 1
Objective: Summarizing a text.
Warm-up:
Speaking Time! Get together in pairs. Discuss the following questions: a) Do you usually summarize for studying? What steps do you follow for doing it? Discuss with a
classmate.
Getting ready:
Lecture time! You will learn about summary. Listen to the teacher and take some notes.
Unit 2, lesson 1Unit II: Getting into advertisement!
35
Activity 1: Summarizing a) What is summarizing? Define it in your own words
e) Write down the main ideas. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
g) Write your summary. Remember to use your own words. Do not include personal opinions. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
h) Share your summary with your classmate. Read each other’s summary. Talk about the things you would change in your classmate’s summary.
Hands on:
Activity 2: Summarizing an article.
Reading Time! Pre-reading:
a) Do you think advertisement has changed over the years? How do you picture advertising eighty years ago? Discuss with a classmate and write your main conclusions. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Shopping malls have produced a revolution in United States shopping and living habits in just 45 years. Before 1950, there were no malls, but now almost every city or region has at least one. In fact, shopping malls have become a part of daily life. Many people even think of them as social centers. In a way, malls have taken the place of Main Street. Shops and services, which were once spread over several city blocks, are now in one place at the mall. Busy householders can save time by doing their shopping at the mall. And people young and old, with time on their hands, often say, “Let’s go to the mall!”
Glossary: Householders: a person who owns or rents a house.
36
While-Reading: a) Read the following text about advertisement. Notice the underlined words.
Advertising
Advertising was initially meant to make people aware of the goods available in the market. It was as simple as announcing what you have in your store or the services you offer in your premises. Over the years, advertising has evolved into a major industry that goes beyond informing to persuading and influencing. It is a form of brainwashing consumers.
Advertising has become a type of culture with ardent followers. In the process, it attracts enviable attention from manufacturers and service providers who fancy an edge over their competitors. Unfortunately, in keeping with the ever-increasing demands of the manufacturers, the advertisers have resulted to creating unnecessary wants and excess consumption in most of us. This is a craving for harmful products that we are better off without. It preys on our minds rendering us completely irrational. The billboards (hoardings), television and radio advertisements target us from a very early age, forming our view of the world as we grow into adults. The buzzwords in advertising are, 'you are cool, type, sophisticated, off the hook', if you use this or that product.
The notion that the media is primarily in place to give us news is not very true. If the truth may be told, the media is there to gather enough audience, package them into a pricey commodity and sell it to the advertisers. The advertisers, on the other hand, are always on the lookout for a target audience to persuade them that this product or service is better than that of the competitor.
Advertising does influence people. Most of the advertisements are filled with images that equate emotional well-being with material acquisition and associate independence and leisure with consumption of alcohol. Advertising also makes people lavish their affect on products rather than real people, thereby destroying human relationships. We have become trapped in the web of advertising where products like brands of beer and cigarette take over our minds, doing away with our core family values.
When you look critically at most of the advertisements on the television, you will discover how persuasive the advertisers are in deciding for us what, when, how much and why to buy. But most people think that they are not influenced by advertisements. This is precisely what the advertisers want us to think, that in the end 'the people decide'. If you think deeply, nobody in his profit-minded sense will pay so much money to make a thirty second advertisement, which might not be seen by a hundred people, leave alone convince them to buy. How we strike a healthy balance between the two will definitely have a direct bearing on the future of our country. It is unfortunate that alcohol and tobacco advertising forms a sizable chunk of the industry.
b) Glossary: Read the text. Infer the most suitable for the underlined words meaning from the context.
Word Definition A large board used for displaying advertising posters. Using or giving in great amounts. Relevant relationship or interconnection. Free time when one is not working or attending to other duties. To want to have or do something. A word or phrase that is frequently used because of its importance or popularity. Something that causes damage. Expensive A desire or longing. Something so “new” and “fresh” that is literally right off the store shelf.
37
Objects or products. To develop or achieve gradually. An idea or theory on which a statement or action is based. The application of a concentrated means of persuasion. Cause to be or become.
c) Compare your answers with a classmate. How many words were you able to infer from the text?
d) In pairs, answer the following questions using information from the text: 1. What was the first objective of advertising?
2. Name at least two consequences of the evolution in the advertising industry. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
3. Where can you find advertisement according to the text? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
4. What is the role of media for the advertising industry? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
5. What does advertising do to human relationships? Why? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
6. Do people know that they are being influenced by advertisement? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
7. What does advertisement industry do with people’s idea of not being influenced by advertisement? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
e) Underline the main ideas in the text. f) Get together with a classmate. Discuss the main ideas you have underlined. Try to explain them in
your own words. g) In pairs write down the main ideas of the text in your own words.
h) Explain in your own words the main idea of the text to the class.
Useful expressions you can use when summarizing: The author says The main idea of the text is The most important point in the text is The text is about
38
Wrap up: Activity 3: Summarize a video.
Writing Time! a) Go to youtube.com. Look for a short video (2-3 minutes) related to the same topic given to you in
unit 1, lesson 1. (food, sports or technology). b) Take notes about the video.
c) Make an outline of the main ideas of the video. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________
e) Get together with people that have your same topic. Explain them the video you chose in terms of main ideas. Use your own words
Reflection: Mark with a tick your answers to the following questions Yes No Did you use to summarize for studying? Do you find it useful? Does it seem easier after this lesson? Will you summarize for studying other subjects? Did your classmates understand your main ideas in the last activity?
39
Lesson 2
Objective:
Synthesize information from different sources.
Warm up:
Speaking Time!: Go and talk to three different classmates. Ask them the following questions. a) Do you think food companies’ advertisement campaigns have to do with the high levels of child’s
obesity in the world? Why? Take notes of your classmate’s answer. Is there any connection between these opinions? Write your conclusions.
Lecture Time! You are going to learn about Synthesis. Listen to your teacher and take some notes.
a) Define synthesis in your own words. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
b) What are the similarities and differences between a summary and a synthesis?
Similarities Differences
40
Glossary:
Straightforward: without difficulties or complications. Grease: thick, oily substance. Pointedly: in a very obvious way.
c) Based on the similarities and differences you found. Talk to your partner in order to share your answers. Write down your conclusions. ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Hands on: Activity 2: Synthesis: Text and video
Listening Time! Pre-Listening:
a) Discuss the following questions with a classmate. What words would you use to describe the advertising industry? Who do you think advertising affects the most, children or adults? Why? Write down your conclusions: ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
While-listening:
a) Watch the video “Media-Smart youth: The Power of Advertising” in the following link: D:\Media Smart Youth The Power of Advertising[1].mp4 and answer the following questions.
2. Why is it said that some time ago advertising was more straightforward? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
3. Where can we find advertising these days? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
4. How does advertising work on Facebook? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
5. How are cartoons used in advertisement? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
6. What are the adjectives David uses to describe advertising nowadays? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
7. How does advertising target kids? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
8. What are some of the subtle ways products are advertised? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
9. Does advertising affect people’s health? How? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
b) Share your answers with a partner.
41
c) Watch the video again. Write an outline of its main ideas: _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________________
Post-Listening:
d) Go back to Lesson 1 in this unit. Read the main ideas you wrote about “Advertisement” text. e) Get together with a classmate. Discuss the following questions considering the information from the
text and the video. 1. Were the video and the text viewpoints different or similar? Why?
2. Are your personal opinions similar or different from the video and the text? How? ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
3. How does the content you have learned in the class relate to what you read and watched? __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Wrap up:
Writing time! Pre-writing: Get together with another pair. Explain to the other couple the connections you found between the video, the text and your personal experience. Discuss and take notes on your conclusions. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ While-writing
a) Individually, write between 100 and 150 words synthesizing the ideas from the video and the text. Consider your personal opinion and the content and materials covered during the semester. REMEMBER that this is not summarizing. You need to show your own conclusions on the topic.
Useful Expressions: Linking words (go back to lesson 1) Verbs: agree, differ, support, evidence, etc.
42
Reflection:
a) Discuss with a classmate the following questions: Have you been able to make connections between your personal experience and the content of the class? Do you think knowing how to synthesize is useful in other subjects? Why? Write down your conclusions. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Homework (Post-writing)
Exchange your synthesis with a classmate. Chick your classmate’s synthesis. Give suggestions in terms of synthesis, summarizing ideas or using different
expressions. Be prepared to exchange your suggestions orally next class.
43
Remember:
To express your opinion you can use expressions such as: *In my opinion *To my mind * If you ask me * To my way of thinking * For me *In my view
Expressing agreement :
I agree with you. I couldn’t agree with you more. That’s so true. You’re absolutely right! Absolutely. That’s exactly how I feel. You have a point there. No doubt about it.
Expressing disagreement:
I don’t think so. I totally disagree. Not necessarily. That’s not always true. I’m afraid I disagree.
Lesson 1 Objective:
Express opinions about advertisement. Evaluate others’ opinions.
Warm up:
a) Read the statement written on the board “Advertising campaigns have led people to materialism.” You have a green and a red paper. Put the papers on the board according to your opinion (green: agree; red: disagree).
b) Discuss with a partner why you agree or disagree.
Getting ready: Activity 1: Expressing opinions! Think of an advertisement you had seen recently. Using the expressions from “Remember” box at the top of the page, write at least 4 sentences giving your opinion on the advertisement. ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Hands on: Activity 2: Start developing arguments.
Listening Time! Pre-Listening:
a) Discuss as a class the following questions: Do you buy expensive sports clothes? Why? Does advertisement has something to do with your decision? Take some notes:
a) Get together in pairs. Watch Reebok’s advertisement in the following link: D:\Reebok Freak Show Be More Human[1].mp4 .
a) Answer the following questions: 1. How do other people describe people in the video?
_________________________________________________________________________________ 2. How do they want to spend every day?
_________________________________________________________________________________ 3. Why does the man flip tires?
_________________________________________________________________________________ 4. In what aspects are people becoming better?
_________________________________________________________________________________ 5. What are the adjectives does the speaker use to describe the kind of human the brand is directed to?
6. What are the people supposed to do to their bodies and their minds? ___________________________________________________________________
b) Identify from the ten different claims which of them are used as a strategy in the advertisement. Answer yes if the claim is present in the advertisement and no if it not present. Give your reasons
Claim Yes/No Why? The weasel claim
The unfinished claim
The we’re different and unique claim
The water is wet claim
The so what claim
The vague claim
Glossary:
Weirdo: a person who behaves strangely. Beaten: fatigued by hard work. Muddy: covered in mud (wet soft earth) Sore: suffering pain. Tire: a band of rubber placed over the rim of a wheel to provide traction. Sharpen: to become sharp.
45
The endorsement or testimonial claim
The scientific or statistical claim
The compliment the consumer claim
The rhetorical question
c) Select two of the claims you found. Discuss on how could the selected claims influence on people’s
decisions. Explain your reasons. ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
d) Get together with another pair. Compare your answers and explain your opinion to the other couple.
Write down the differences you notice in your opinions. Similarities Differences
Wrap up:
Activity 3: Present arguments
Speaking Time!
Get together in groups of four students (the people with the same topic assigned in unit I, lesson 1). Each group will look for advertising on the given topic. Prepare a short presentation (8 minutes/ 2 minutes each).
Your presentation must include:
- Short description of the advertisement. - Explanation of the claims used in the advertisement. - Your opinion on the advertisement, referring to different sources (class material, news, internet,
etc) - Consider the following questions:
Which claims are present in the advertisement? Who do you think is the target audience? Why?
46
How does video/audio/computer graphics influence on the target audience? Would you buy the product? Why? Have you tried the product?
Reflection:
Speaking Time! Discuss in pairs the following questions:
a) Will a sports brand make you be a better human? b) What do you think the company is trying to do by using this phrase? c) Would you buy something to this company based on their advertisement? Write your conclusions:
Objectives: To develop your speech for the round table discussion.
Warm-up:
Speaking Time! Get together in your groups for the round table. Discuss the following statements. Explain why you agree or disagree with them.
a) “Food advertisements have contributed to people’s obesity” b) “Sports advertisement has contributed to giving more importance to what you wear than the sport
itself” c) “Technology advertisements have led to materialism because people are buying the most advanced
technologic devices even though they don’t need them” d) Take some notes on your opinions.
Getting ready:
Hands on: Instructions for the moderator:
a) Gather all the sources you have worked with during the semester related to your group’s topic. Also consider your personal experience and sources (news, movies, television, etc.)
b) Outline the main ideas from each type of source. Source Main ideas Videos
Readings
Other
Unit IV: Let’s present!
Remember: A round table is:
Discussion involving several participants It has one moderator Each participant has a time to speak Each participant should answer questions from the
audience.
48
c) Create 10-15 questions that can be asked to any of your group members during their presentations. Consider the sources you have found. Also consider:
Ten claims Target audience (age, gender, sex, etc) Parts of the advertisement (video, audio, CG)
Instructions for the rest of the group:
a) Choose an advertisement on your topic. b) Examine it in terms of: Claims, elements of an advertisement, target audience.
Claim Yes/No Why The weasel claim
The unfinished claim
The “We’re different and unique” claim
The “water is wet” claim
The “so what” claim
The vague claim
The endorsement or testimonial
The scientific or statistical claim
The “compliment the consumer” claim
The rhetorical question
Element Description Video
Audio
Computer Graphics
Target Audience
c) Look for all the sources from the semester (readings, videos) that have connections with your video
and your view on the advertisement. Also consider personal experience and other sources you
49
remember from outside the classroom (videos, news, magazines, newspapers, etc). Write the main ideas.
Source Main ideas Videos
Readings
Other
d) Make an outline of the connections you can make of the video with class videos, readings and your personal experience.
Source Main ideas Avertisement/ class ideos
Advertisement/ class readings
Advertisement/ personal experience
e) Make an outline of the main points you would like to include in your presentation.
Consider: Target audience, claims, elements of an advertisement, intention, attractiveness, objectives, other sources, your opinion.
Speaking Time!: Get together with your round table discussion group: f) Show your main points to your group classmates. Explain them in general terms. Let them ask you
some questions for improving your presentation. Write down the questions you think are useful for you. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Reflection:
a) Discuss with your group: Think of 5 elements your presentation must have in terms of information. Then, think if you have those elements.
Element Yes/No
b) What elements do you have to improve? How will you improve it? ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
At the end of the lesson:
Hand in your main ideas for the presentation to the teacher
51
Appendix A: Needs Analysis
Needs Analysis
Nombre: Catalina Pavez
Objetivo: Identificar necesidades e intereses de los alumnos en cuanto al uso de material audiovisual dentro de la clase de inglés. También busca que los alumnos evalúen sus propias habilidades de pensamiento crítico.
1. ¿Con qué frecuencia se utilizan videos en la clase de inglés? a) Nunca b) 1 vez al mes c) 1 vez por semana d) Todas las clases
2. Marca con una ‘X’ tu grado de acuerdo con cada uno de los siguientes enunciados.
Enunciado Muy de acuerdo
De acuerdo
En desacuerdo
Muy en desacuerdo
a) Se utiliza material audiovisual (videos) para comparar o contrastar información con la materia/otros videos.
b) Se utilizan videos para la síntesis de información.
c) Se utilizan videos para debatir acerca de ellos y defender nuestras posturas.
d) Me gustaría utilizar videos para comparar información en inglés.
e)Me gustaría utilizar videos para sintetizar información en inglés.
f) Me gustaría utilizar videos para debatir y defender mi postura en inglés.
3. Enumera del 1 al 4 las siguientes habilidades trabajadas en la clase de inglés según el grado de dificultad que tengan para ti (siendo 1 el más fácil y 4 el más difícil) _______ Comprensión lectora _______ Comprensión auditiva _______ Producción oral _______ Producción escrita
4. ¿Cuál de las siguientes habilidades te gustaría desarrollar mejor?
52
a) Producción oral b) Producción escrita
5. Califica del 1 al 4 (siendo 1 malo y 4 excelente), tu habilidad en inglés para: Habilidad 1 2 3 4
Inferir información Predecir de qué se trata un texto
Analizar textos/videos a partir de la información vista en clases
Comparar textos Sintetizar información a partir de un video
Debatir/Argumentar acerca de temas de tu interés
6. En relación al material audiovisual, ¿cuál de las siguientes opciones de material te llama más la atención? a) Noticieros b) Reportajes c) Comerciales d) Documentales
7. De la siguiente lista de temas, marca los 3 que llamen más tu atención.
a) Deportes b) Comida c) Belleza d) Moda e) Vida Saludable f) Automóviles g) Tecnología h) Otro ¿Cuál? _________________________________________
Gracias por su tiempo y por sus respuestas
53
Appendix B: Needs Analysis Results
The present needs analysis was constructed under the principles proposed by Dudley-Evans and
St. John (1998). The present needs analysis considers the target situation analysis in questions 4, 6
and 7 which informs of the learners interest in developing a skill as well as the topic and material
they are interested in covering. Question 2 statements d, e and f address the interest of students
in learning some skills that will guide them to get to thinking critically, so they address the learning
situation analysis. The present situation analysis is informed by questions 1, 2 (statements a, b and
c), 3 and 5.
This Needs analysis was conducted with 22 participants from Colegio Rubén Castro located in Viña
del Mar. It was conducted in Spanish to avoid misunderstandings as it was conducted online. The
participants were 10th graders. The students answered seven items in order to find out how the
needs and interest of the students match with the pedagogical proposal.
Each question is represented with the graphic for the answers. At the top of each graphic is the
question and the answers are on one side.
Figure 1: Current use of videos in class
Figure 1 shows that students do not receive video-based input. Most of them answered that
they watch videos once a month and some of them even answered that they never use it in
the L2 classroom.
54
Figure 2: Use of video-based material in class for making comparisons and contrast.
Figure 3: Use of video-based material in class for synthesis of information.
Figure 4: Use of video-based material in the class for debates and opinions.
Figures 2, 3 and 4 show that, even though students use video-based material in class, they
are not used for encouraging higher order thinking skills in students. According to the
students’ answers, they have not had the opportunity to use it for synthesis of information
or for giving their opinions and having class discussions and debates. This is why, the
following set of questions intends to know if students are interested in using this type of
material for the development of higher order thinking.
55
Figure 5: Interest on using video-based material for comparison of information.
Figure 6: Interest on using video-based material for synthesis of information.
Figure 7: Interest on using video-based material for debates and discussions.
Figures 5, 6 and 7 show that in each statement, most of the students expressed their interest
on using video-based material in different kind of activities, which involve higher order
thinking skills. Therefore, these kinds of activities will be present along the workshop.
Figure 8: Skills difficulty: Reading
Figure 8 shows that students do not consider reading comprehension a difficult skill, or at
least is the least difficult for most of them.
Figure 9: Skills difficulty: Listening
56
In Figure 9, most of the students demonstrated that listening is not as easy as reading
comprehension for them. In terms of percentages, 45% of them answered that it was the
second in the scale, but an important number of them showed that it was not that easy for
them, showing that a 36% of people considered it one of the most difficult skills.
Figure 10: Skills difficulty: Speaking
Speaking was the skill that, according to the questionnaire is more difficult to the students,
showing that a 50% of the students think it is the most difficult of the four skills.
Figure 11: Skills difficulty: Writing
Writing was one of the most difficult skills for students too, showing a 36% of people
answering it is the most difficult for them.
Figure 12: Productive skill students want to improve
57
In Figure 12, students show their preference for improving their oral skills (81%) rather
than their writing skills. Therefore, speaking is the main focus of the pedagogical proposal,
even though students will also practice their writing skills.
Figure 13: Present situation in thinking skills: Inferring
Even though students do not tend to infer through videos, they consider themselves good at
inferring, showing a 77% that considers themselves between good and excellent at this
skill.
Figure 14: Present situation in thinking skills: Prediction
Most of the students consider themselves good at prediction, having a 46% thinking they
are good at it and a 27 % considering themselves excellent.
Figure 15: Present situation in thinking skills: Analysis
58
Students see themselves as good at analyzing things, having 55% of them considering they
are between good and excellent at this skill.
Figure 16: Present situation in thinking skills: Comparison
In terms of comparison, students do not consider themselves as good as in the previous
skills. The 45% of the students consider that they are not good at comparing texts.
Figure 17: Present situation in thinking skills: Synthesis
In terms of synthesizing, students were between good and bad at this, 45% of them
considered themselves good at synthesizing and 36% thought they were bad at it.
Figure 18: Present situation in thinking skills: Debate
The 54% of students that answered the questionnaire consider themselves good or excellent
at debating and giving arguments.
59
Figure 19: Audio-visual material of students’ interest
In figure 19 students manifest their interest in using advertisement as a video-based
material. 15 out of 20 students chose advertising option, which represent a 68% of the
participants. Therefore, the pedagogical proposal will use advertising as a tool to develop
critical thinking.
Figure 20: Topics of students’ interest.
Students manifested their interest in all of the topics presented, but this pedagogical
proposal will focus on the three most chosen topics that are sports (77%), Food (54%) and
technology (54%).
Conclusion
In conclusion, this workshop seeks to develop critical thinking skills through the use
speaking activities based on video advertisement on food, technology and sports.
60
References
Clasen, D. R. & Bonk, C. (1990). Teachers tackle thinking. Madison, WI: Madison Education Extension Program.
Cook, G. (2001). The Discourse of Advertising. New York: Routledge.
Davidson, B., & Dunham, R. (1996). Assessing EFL Student Progress in Critical Thinking with the Ennis-Weir Critical Thinking Essay Test. International Conference on Critical Thinking and Educational Reform, (págs. 1-22). California.
Dudley-Evans, T. & St. John, M.J. (1998) Developments in English for Specific Purposes: A multi-disciplinary approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Elder, L., & Paul, R. (1994). Critical Thinking: Why we must transform our teaching. Journal of Developmental Education , 34-35.
Facione, P. (1990). Critical Thinking: A Statement of Experts Consensus for Purposes of Educational Assessment and Instruction. Fullerton: California State University.
Fairclough, N. (2013). Critical Language Awareness. New York: Routledge.
Fisher, A. (2011). Critical Thinking: An Introduction. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Goddard, A. (1998). The Language of Advertising. New York: Routledge.
Halpern, D. F. (2003). Thought & Knowledge: An Introduction to Critical Thinking. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
INE (2013). Resumen CENSO 2012. Retrieved from: file:///C:/Users/USUARIO/Downloads/resumencenso_2012.pdf
Limbach, B., & Waugh, W. (2010). Developing Higher Level Thinking. Journal of Instructional Pedagogies , 1-9.
Lipman, M. (1991). Thinking in Education. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Meei-Ling, L. (2007). Content-Based Reading and Writing for Critical Thinking Skills in an EFL Context. English Teaching & Learning , 45-87.
Mora, M. (2013). Using intertextuality as a tool to develop higher thinking skills in L2 reading (graduation project). Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Valparaíso, Chile.
61
Ministerio de Educación (2004): Programa de Estudio segundo año medio. Santiago: Gobierno de Chile.
Pacheco, I. (2013). Raising media literacy through speaking and the language of argumentation (graduation project). Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Valparaíso, Chile.
Schrank, J. (1994). The Language of Advertising Claims. Language Awareness .
Thornbury, S. (2007). How to Teach Speaking. Harlow, England: Longman.