TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 1 Pivotal Problems: Knowing When to Use Them Pivotal Solutions: Knowing When to Reveal Them George W. Bright [email protected] Professor Emeritus University of North Carolina at Greensboro
Jan 12, 2016
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 1
Pivotal Problems: Knowing When to Use Them
Pivotal Solutions: Knowing When to Reveal Them
George W. [email protected]
Professor EmeritusUniversity of North Carolina at Greensboro
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 2
Introductions
• What grades do you teach?
• Where do you teach?
• What is your experience in delivering professional development for teachers?
• What is something others might not know about you?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 3
Rating Personal Understanding
On a scale of 1 (low) to 10 (high), rate yourself in terms of:
• how much you know about proportional reasoning
• how confident you are about helping students learn about proportional reasoning
• how confident you are about helping teachers learn about proportional reasoning
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 4
Goals for the Session
Solve proportional reasoning problems and explore their solutions
Identify why some problems and some solutions might be “pivotal” in helping learners understand proportional reasoning
Reflect on when pivotal problems and pivotal solutions might be most effectively presented
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 5
Pivotal Problems and Pivotal Solutions
What does pivotal mean?
When might a problem be pivotal in developing understanding?
When might a solution to a problem be pivotal in developing understanding?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 6
National Mathematics Advisory Panel
• The Final Report of the National Mathematics Advisory Panel recommends that understanding of fractions is one of the Critical Foundations of Algebra.
• Their definition of “fractions” includes ratios and proportions, so they really are recommending “proportional reasoning” as a critical foundation of algebra.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 7
The “3/5’s Problem”
What do you see?
Thompson, P. W. (2002). 3/5s problem. In B. Litwiller (Ed.). Making sense of fractions, ratios, and proportions: 2002 yearbook(pp. 103-104). Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 8
Reorganizing Thinking
What were the greatest challenges for you in the questions about the diagram?
How did the questions encourage you to reorganize your thinking about fractions and operations on fractions?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 9
Is this pivotal?
When might this problem be pivotal?
What might you want learners to understand before the problem is posed?
What would you want learners to understand after solving this problem?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 10
Equal or Equivalent?
Are 1/3 and 2/6 equal fractions or equivalent fractions or both or neither?
Does it matter what language we use?
How might the language we use influence what students learn?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 11
Fractions In Between, Part 1
Find three fractions between 4/7 and 5/7.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 12
Fractions In Between, Part 2
4.5 is halfway between 4 and 5.
Is 4.5/7 halfway between 4/7 and 5/7?
Why or why not?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 13
Fractions In Between, Part 3
Find three fractions equally spaced between a/b and (a+1)/b.
Would you ask students to solve the general case?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 14
Fractions In Between, Part 4
Find three fractions equally spaced between a/b and (a+N)/b.
Would you ask students to solve the even more general case?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 15
Is this pivotal?
When might this problem be pivotal?
What would this problem help learners learn that more traditional problems might not help them learn?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 16
Fractions In Between, Part 5
Does the same strategy work for this problem?
Find three fractions between 5/7 and 5/6.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 17
Fractions In Between, Part 6
6.5 is halfway between 7 and 6.
Is 5/6.5 between 5/7 and 5/6?
If so, is it halfway between 5/7 and 5/6?
Why or why not?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 18
Fractions In Between, Part 7
Find three fractions equally spaced between a/(b+1) and a/b.
Would you ask students to solve the general case?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 19
Fractions In Between, Part 8
Find three fractions equally spaced between a/(b+N) and a/b.
Would you ask students to solve the even more general case?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 20
Is this pivotal?
Could this problem be a pivotal problem?
What grade level would this problem be most appropriate for?
What mathematics does this highlight that other kinds of problems might not highlight?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 21
What is the Point?
What big mathematics ideas are embedded in these “in between” problems?
How might the solutions to these problems help move learners’ thinking forward?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 22
What is the label?
True or false: 6 ÷ 2 = 3.3 what?
True or false: 6 ÷ 3 = 2.2 what?
Why are the labels different for the quotients?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 23
What is the label?
True or false: 6 ÷ 2/3 = 99 what?
Is it important for students to understand what label is attached to a quotient?
Is this a pivotal idea?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 24
Reversibility
Asking learners to “reverse” their thinking helps them create connections among ideas.
Suppose a rectangular prism has a volume of 40 cm3 and height of 5 cm.
What else can you tell me about the rectangular prism?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 25
Thinking Differently about Familiar Ideas
Imagine what an inch looks like.
Imagine what a centimeter looks like.
What is the area of a rectangle that is
5 inches long and 3 centimeters wide?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 26
Changing Views
How might understanding of a familiar idea change by solving a problem that presents the idea in an unfamiliar way?
How might you decide when to pose such unfamiliar problems?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 27
Seeing the Big Picture
Solve this problem:
If 2(x - 3) = 8, then what is the value of
(x - 3)2 + 5(x - 3) - 2?
How flexible is your thinking?
Can you see the “big picture” in a problem or do you focus on the details?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 28
Interference
For any linear measurement,
let Y = number of yards for that measurement,
let F = number of feet for that measurement.
Write an equation showing the relationship of these two variables.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 29
Variables
How did these problems expand your understanding of variable?
Why is it important for learners to understand what a variable is?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 30
Numbers with a Simple Relationship
Melissa bought 0.43 of a pound of wheat flour for which she paid $0.86.
How many pounds of flour could she buy for one dollar?
Post, T. R., Harel, G., Behr, M., & Lesh, R. (1991). Intermediate teachers’ knowledge of rational number concepts. In E. Fennema, T. P. Carpenter, & S. J. Lamon (Eds.), Integration research on teaching and learning mathematics (pp. 177-198). Ithaca, NY: SUNY Press.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 31
Numbers with a Not-so-simple Relationship
Melissa bought 0.46 of a pound of wheat flour for which she paid $0.86.
How many pounds of flour could she buy for one dollar?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 32
Reflection on Problem 1 modified
Which problem was more difficult, the “simple” problem or the “not-so-simple” problem?
What made that problem difficult?
How does the choice of numbers in a problem affect the way you (or students) might think about the problem?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 33
Is this pivotal?
Could these problems be pivotal?
What would you want learners to take away from engagement with these problems?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 34
A Different Kind of “Adult” Problem
In an adult condominium complex, 2/3 of the men are married to 3/5 of the women.
What part of the residents are married?
Lester, F. (2002). Condo problem. In B. Litwiller (Ed.). Making sense of fractions, ratios, and proportions: 2002 yearbook (pp. 191-192). Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 35
Identifying Difficulties
Why do people struggle with this problem? What makes it difficult?
How do the different solutions reveal different aspects of the underlying mathematics ideas?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 36
Is this pivotal?
Could this problem be pivotal?
Could the solutions be pivotal?
What mathematics might this problem or the solutions to this problem help learners internalize?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 37
Graphs
How are the two graphs below alike?
How are they different?
distance
time time
speed
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 38
Graphing Speed
Joe walks down a straight path and then turns around a walks back to the starting point.
The graph below displays how far away he was from the starting point.
Sketch the graph of his walking speed(s).
distance
time
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 39
Graphing Speed
Joe walks down a straight path and then turns around a walks back to the starting point.
The graph below displays how far away he was from the starting point.
Sketch the graph of his walking velocities. (How is this graph different from the previous graph?)
distance
time
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 40
Connecting to the Real World
Speed and velocity are complex ideas. It takes considerable time and experience to understand them fully.
When might you use these problems? For what purpose?
How might discussion of the solutions help students understand mathematics more deeply?
Is this problem pivotal?
TDG Leadership Seminar 2009 41
Rating Personal Understanding (reprise)
On a scale of 1 (low) to 10 (high), rate yourself in terms of:
• how much you know about proportional reasoning
• how confident you are about helping students learn about proportional reasoning
• how confident you are about helping teachers learn about proportional reasoning