Page 1
Pharmacodynamic markers of response to novel anticancer
agents using a protein profiling sandwich immunoassay format
Anthea Hardcastle,Matthew Cordwell, Peter Fong, Lindsay Stimson,
Paul Workman and Wynne Aherne
Cancer Research UK Centre for Cancer TherapeuticsInstitute of Cancer Research
Sutton, Surrey, UK
Page 2
Molecular mechanism-based drug discovery
Target Identification
Compound collections
Medicinal chemistry, combinatorial chemistrystructure-based design
In vivoevaluation
Mechanistic & cell-based
assays
Biochemical, phenotypic,
virtual screens
Target validation
Mechanistic endpoint or pharmacodynamic(PD) marker assays
Pharmacokinetics and metabolism
Clinical evaluation
Assays required for all matrices
Sample often limited so high sensitivity required
Page 3
Techniques for PD marker measurement Western blotting (Gold Standard’)
Immunohistochemistry
Flow cytometry
Microplate immunoassays (ELISA)
MSD Protein Profiling sandwich immunoassays
Multiplex ‘catalogue’ assaysSingle assay development ‘in-house’Option to multiplex ‘in-house’ and ‘catalogue’
assaysThe ease of validation for GCLP is an important consideration for PD assaysas compliance with regulatory requirements is essential
Page 4
Meso Scale Discovery (MSD) technologyMeasured signal is light
z
LIGHT
Page 5
Can these assays be applied to different matrices?In vitro cell lysatesHuman tumour xenograftsClinical samples eg. PBMCs, tumours and plasma
Aim : to carry out a feasibility study with inhibitors of HSP90 and HDAC
Page 6
PD markers for inhibitors of HSP90
The molecular chaperone HSP90 maintains the conformation, stability and function of oncogenicclient proteins (eg. ERBB2, AKT and CDK4)
HSP90 inhibitors cause degradation of client proteins, disruption of signalling pathways and antitumour activity
Several agents currently in Phase I and II trials e.g. 17-AAG and 17-DMAG
The molecular signature of HSP90 inhibition includes a fall in ERBB2, AKT and pERK and induction of HSP70
Page 7
‘Off the shelf’ MSD duplexed assays for PD markers of HSP90 inhibition
1 2A
B
Total Protein
1 2
3 4
BSAPhosphoprotein
BSA
SULFO-TAGTM labelled,detection antibody
Working Electrode
Capture Antibody
Protein
HCT116 cells,1µM geldanamycin,24h. 1.25-10µg protein/well
DMSO Geld0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Total ERBB2
Ru/ µ
g pr
otein
DMSO Geld0
250
500
750
1000
pERKTotal ERK
Ru/ µ
g pr
otein
Page 8
‘Off the shelf’ duplexed assays for PD markers of HSP90 inhibition
DMSO Geld LY0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700 pAKTTotal AKT
0
25
50
75
100To
tal A
KT
Phospho AK
T
HCT116 cells,1µM Geldanamycin,20µM LY294002 (LY) 24h. 1.25-10µg protein/well
Page 9
‘In-house’ MSD assay for HSP70
Capture HSP70 Monoclonal Antibody
SULFO-TAGTM labelled,Goat anti rabbit IgG
HSP70
Rabbit anti HSP70
Working Electrode
1 2A
B
DELFIA HSP70 assay validated to GCLP
In use for clinical trials of HSP90 inhibitors
Assay transferred to MSDPotential for multiplexing HSP70
with client protein expression
Calibration curve
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 70000
50000
100000
fmoles HSP70/well
Ru c
ount
s
HCT116 ± 1 µM Geld 24h
DMSO Geld0
250
500
750
1000
1250
1500
1750
fmole
HSP7
0/µg
lysa
te
Page 10
PD markers for HDAC inhibitorsHDACs catalyse the deacetylation of histones and are important for the regulation of gene expression
HDACs are involved in the development and progression of malignancy
HDACIs display antitumour activity and several compounds are being evaluated clinically
Their precise mechanism of action is not clear but the most obvious result of HDAC inhibition is hyperacetylation of histones
Hyperacetylation of histone H3 is used as a PD marker for HDAC inhibition
Page 11
‘In-house’ assay for acetyl histone H3 (AcH3)SULFO-TAGTM labelled,Goat anti rabbit IgG
Rabbit anti AcH3
Ac histone H3
Working Electrode
HistonesCapture Pan Histonemonoclonal antibody
Calibration curve
0 50 100 150 200 250 3000
2500
5000
7500
10000
12500
Butyrate-treated HeLa cell extract
ng/well AcH3 standard
Ru c
ount
s
Assay being successfully used to measure the effect of novel HDACIs on AcH3 in
human tumour xenograftsDMSO SAHA
1
10
100
1000HCT116 5X GI50 SAHA 24h
ng e
quivalen
ts /
µg
lysa
te DMSO SAHA
AcH3
GAPDH
Page 12
Ex vivo treatment of PBMCs with HDACIsPBMCs and plasma separated from whole blood
HDACIs SAHA and MS-275 or DMSO (control) added
Incubated at 37°C for 4h
PBMCs separated,washed and lysed
AcH3 in lysates measured by MSD assay and western blot
Ex vivo PBMNCs 4h 5XGI50
DMSO SAHA MS2750
1
2
3
ng e
quivalen
ts A
cH3
AcH3
GAPDH
DM
SO
SAH
A
MS-
275
This assay is being validated to GCLP for use in clinical trials of HDACIs
Page 13
SummaryExperience with the MSD format is encouraging
robust sensitiveminimal matrix interferencequantitative, higher-throughput alternative to western blotsboth catalogue and in-house assays used
Provided proof of principle for mechanism of action in 2 therapeutic areas, HSP90 and HDAC, in different sample matrices
Now used in a number of drug discovery projects in the Centre
Assays are amenable to GCLP validation to comply with regulatory requirements for clinical trials
Multiplexing potential for ‘in-house’ assays to be investigated
Page 14
Acknowledgements
Matthew Cordwell, Peter Fong, Lindsay Stimson,Paul Workman and Wynne Aherne
Colleagues in the Cancer Research UK Centre for Cancer Therapeutics
Members of the Analytical Technology and Screening Team
Tuc Ahmad from MSD