Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 Petrology, geochemistry and zircon age for redwitzite at Abertamy, NW Bohemian Massif (Czech Republic): tracing the mantle component in Late Variscan intrusions Pavla Kova´ rˇ ı´ kova´ a, , Wolfgang Siebel b , Emil Jelı´nek c , Miroslav S ˇ temprok c , Va´ clav Kachlı´k c , Frantisˇek V. Holub c , Vratislav Blecha c a Department of Mineralogy, Geochemistry and Natural Resources, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Albertov 6, 128 43 Prague, Czech Republic b Institut fu¨r Geowissenschaften AK Mineralogie und Geodynamik, Eberhard-Karls-Universita¨t Tu¨bingen, Wilhelmstr. 56, 72074 Tu¨bingen, Germany c Faculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Albertov 6, 128 43 Prague, Czech Republic Abstract A small body of mafic texturally and compositionally varied igneous intrusive rocks corresponding to redwitzites occurs at Abertamy in the Western pluton of the Krusˇne´ hory/Erzgebirge granite batholith (Czech Republic). It is enclosed by porphyritic biotite granite of the older intrusive suite in the southern contact zone of the Nejdek- Eibenstock granite massif. We examined the petrology and geochemistry of the rocks and compared the data with those on redwitzites described from NE Bavaria and Western Bohemia. The redwitzites from Abertamy are coarse- to medium-grained rocks with massive textures and abundant up to 2 cm large randomly oriented biotite phenocrysts overgrowing the groundmass. They are high in MgO, Cr and Ni but have lower Rb and Li contents than the redwitzites in NE Bavaria. Compositional linear trends from redwitzites to granites at Abertamy indicate crystal fractionation and magma mixing in a magma chamber as possible mechanisms of magma differentiation. Plots of MgO versus SiO 2 , TiO 2 , Al 2 O 3 , FeO, CaO, Na 2 O, and K 2 O indicate mainly plagioclase and orthopyroxene fractionation as viable mechanisms for in situ differentiation of the redwitzites. The porphyritic biotite monzogranite enclosing the redwitzite is the typical member of the early granitic suite (Older Intrusive Complex, OIC ) with strongly developed transitional I/S-type features. The ages of zircons obtained by the single zircon Pb-evaporation method suggest that the redwitzites and granites at Abertamy originated during the same magmatic period of the Variscan plutonism at about 322 Ma. The granitic melts have been so far mainly interpreted to be formed by heat supply from a thickened crust or decompression melting accompanying exhumation and uplift of overthickened crust in the Krusˇne´ hory/Erzgebirge due to a previous collisional event at ca. 340Ma. The presence of mafic bodies in the Western pluton of the Krusˇne´ hory/Erzgebirge batholith confirms a more significant role of mantle-derived mafic magmas in heating of the sources of granitic melts than previously considered. r 2007 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved. Keywords: Fractional crystallization; Igneous petrography; I/S-type granite; Krusˇne´ hory/Erzgebirge; Mafic rocks; Magma mixing; Pb-evaporation age; Redwitzite; Variscan magmatism; Zircon ARTICLE IN PRESS www.elsevier.de/chemer 0009-2819/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.chemer.2007.04.002 Corresponding author. Tel.: +420 221 951 516; fax: +420 221 951 496. E-mail address: [email protected] (P. Kova´ rˇı´kova´ ).
24
Embed
Petrology, geochemistry and zircon age for redwitzite at ...
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
ARTICLE IN PRESS
0009-2819/$ - se
doi:10.1016/j.ch
�CorrespondE-mail addr
Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174www.elsevier.de/chemer
Petrology, geochemistry and zircon age for redwitzite at Abertamy,
NW Bohemian Massif (Czech Republic): tracing the mantle component
in Late Variscan intrusions
Pavla Kovarıkovaa,�, Wolfgang Siebelb, Emil Jelınekc, Miroslav Stemprokc,Vaclav Kachlıkc, Frantisek V. Holubc, Vratislav Blechac
aDepartment of Mineralogy, Geochemistry and Natural Resources, Faculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Albertov 6,
128 43 Prague, Czech RepublicbInstitut fur Geowissenschaften AK Mineralogie und Geodynamik, Eberhard-Karls-Universitat Tubingen, Wilhelmstr. 56,
72074 Tubingen, GermanycFaculty of Science, Charles University, Prague, Albertov 6, 128 43 Prague, Czech Republic
Abstract
A small body of mafic texturally and compositionally varied igneous intrusive rocks corresponding to redwitzitesoccurs at Abertamy in the Western pluton of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granite batholith (Czech Republic). It isenclosed by porphyritic biotite granite of the older intrusive suite in the southern contact zone of the Nejdek-Eibenstock granite massif. We examined the petrology and geochemistry of the rocks and compared the data withthose on redwitzites described from NE Bavaria and Western Bohemia.
The redwitzites from Abertamy are coarse- to medium-grained rocks with massive textures and abundant up to 2 cmlarge randomly oriented biotite phenocrysts overgrowing the groundmass. They are high in MgO, Cr and Ni but havelower Rb and Li contents than the redwitzites in NE Bavaria. Compositional linear trends from redwitzites to granitesat Abertamy indicate crystal fractionation and magma mixing in a magma chamber as possible mechanisms of magmadifferentiation. Plots of MgO versus SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, FeO, CaO, Na2O, and K2O indicate mainly plagioclase andorthopyroxene fractionation as viable mechanisms for in situ differentiation of the redwitzites.
The porphyritic biotite monzogranite enclosing the redwitzite is the typical member of the early granitic suite (OlderIntrusive Complex, OIC ) with strongly developed transitional I/S-type features. The ages of zircons obtained by thesingle zircon Pb-evaporation method suggest that the redwitzites and granites at Abertamy originated during the samemagmatic period of the Variscan plutonism at about 322Ma.
The granitic melts have been so far mainly interpreted to be formed by heat supply from a thickened crust ordecompression melting accompanying exhumation and uplift of overthickened crust in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirgedue to a previous collisional event at ca. 340Ma. The presence of mafic bodies in the Western pluton of the Krusnehory/Erzgebirge batholith confirms a more significant role of mantle-derived mafic magmas in heating of the sources ofgranitic melts than previously considered.r 2007 Elsevier GmbH. All rights reserved.
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174152
1. Introduction
The goal of the present study is to elucidate the role ofmafic magmas in the origin of the Variscan Krusnehory/Erzgebirge granite batholith in the Bohemianmassif. The presence of mafic magmas during theformation of the batholith is indicated by the rareoccurrences of redwitzites associated with the granites ofthe earlier suite in the Western pluton. The presentpaper contributes to the petrology and geochemistry ofthese rocks using modern laboratory methods and newgenetical interpretations.
Redwitzites were originally defined in NE Bavaria atthe NW margin of the Bohemian massif by Willmann(1920). They comprise coarse- to fine-grained, porphyri-tic to equigranular igneous rocks of mafic to inter-mediate chemical compositions ranging from quartzgabbro to quartz monzonites. Their structures are highlyvariable, ranging from massive undeformed randomlyoriented structures up to varieties with well developedplanar structures marked by preferred orientation ofbiotite flakes.
Their geochemistry and isotopic composition hasbeen studied by Troll (1968), Miessler and Propach(1987), Spiegel and Propach (1991), Holl et al.(1989), Siebel (1994), Siebel et al. (1995, 2003) and Rene(2000).
Typical dark minerals are amphibole (mostly second-ary uralite replacing pyroxene) and biotite (both rich inMg but markedly poor in Al). Plagioclase (An70–An30)is the predominant feldspar. Less common are quartz,K-feldspar, pyroxene, titanite and apatite as well aspostmagmatic Ca–Al minerals like uralite and chlorite(Freiberger et al., 2001). In comparison with theassociated granites they have lower SiO2 (53–63wt%),lower A/CNK (o1.05), high TiO2 (0.8–1.7wt%) andlow Rb/Ba (o0.18; Siebel et al., 2003). Their isotopicratios indicate heterogenous enriched mantle as possiblesource material (eNd325 Ma ¼+1 to �4 and 87Sr/86Sr325Ma ¼ 0.706–0.780; Siebel et al., 2003) modified by avarious degree of AFC processes and mixing withcrustal derived magmas.
Redwidzites occur as small, sometimes zonal intru-sions, hundreds of square meters to several squarekilometers of outcrop size, several square meters up toseveral tens of meter thick dikes and tabular bodiesintruding into Moldanubian gneisses, Saxothuringianmetasediments, metabasites of the Marianske LazneComplex and Kladska unit or larger irregular bodiesenclosed in host biotite porphyritic granites (Leuchten-berg, Western Krusne hory/Erzgebirge and Borplutons).
The formation of redwidzites of NW Bohemia,Oberphalz and Fichtelgebirte represents specific pulse(340–320Ma, Dorr et al., 1998; Siebel et al., 2003;Kovarıkova et al., 2005) of mantle derived magmas in
the Variscan Bohemian massif, after the intrusion ofearly syntectonic Variscan gabbros and associatedquartz diorites of the Central Bohemian Plutoniccomplex (370–350Ma, Kosler et al., 1993; Janouseket al., 2000) and with exhumation related ultra-potassic and high K-rocks of durbachitic series of theMoldanubicum (340–330Ma, Holub, 1997; Gerdeset al., 2000).
Various geochronological methods have been used todetermine their age. Troll (1968) interpreted them asbasic precursors of the Fichtelgebirge granites G1–G4on the basis of geological criteria. Taubald (2000)considered redwitzites as Upper Carboniferous in ageand regarded them to be younger than the earlyVariscan subduction-related processes at 380Ma. ThePb single grain evaporation method on zircons broughtnew data (Siebel et al., 2003) which showed an ageinterval between 324 and 322Ma for the redwitziteformation. This interval is comparable with the agesderived by U–Pb titanite geochronology (325–322Ma;Siebel et al., 2003). The zircons proved to be primaryminerals crystallizing from the magma not containinglead from older cores as was also shown by cathodo-luminescence investigation (Siebel et al., 2003).
The granitoids of the so-called ‘‘basic zone’’ of theBor massif between Tachov and Plana by Mar. Lazne(Vejnar et al., 1969) in the Western Bohemia werestudied by Siebel et al. (1997) and Rene (2000). Theserocks bear typical features identical with the redwitzitesfrom NE Bavaria in terms of composition and textures(Siebel et al., 1997).
Mafic igneous rocks in the Late Variscan Krusnehory/Erzgebirge granite batholith are rare. Their occur-rences have been reported from the southern part(Fig. 1) on the eroded slope of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge mountain range (Zoubek, 1948, 1951), andnamely in the Czech part of the Nejdek-Eibenstockmassif at Abertamy (Sattran, 1961; Stemprok, 1986).They also occur in the Slavkovsky les area near Lobzy(Fiala, 1961, 1968) south of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirgefault zone. The mafic rocks were grouped together withthe earlier group of granitoids (OIC group) as LateVariscan granitoids. Fiala (1968) used the name red-witzite only for a group of plutonic rocks with planartexture and identified other mafic rocks as biotite-amphibole pyroxene gabbrodiorite, biotite-amphibolediorite and quartz diorite to granodiorite and proposedthree possible explanations of their genesis: (a) hybrid,strongly metasomatic altered rocks of the Precambrianspilitic magmatism, (b) earlier mafic intrusions of theAssynthian cycle reworked by later granites, (c) earliermagmatic intrusions of the Variscan orogenic cycle. Atthe present time the third explanation is accepted(Jelınek et al., 2003, 2004) also for the Slavkovskyles redwitzite rock group on the basis of detailedgeochemical work.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 1. Simplified geological map of NE Bavaria, southern Saxonia and NW Bohemia showing Variscan granitoid distribution.
Redrawn using the geological map 1:500,000 (Czech Geol. Survey) and the data from Siebel (1993) and Rene (2000).
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 153
2. Geological setting
The studied redwitzites occur in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granite batholith area located in the Sax-othuringian zone of the Bohemian massif (O’Brien andCarswell, 1993). It is considered as one of the peri-Gondwana derived terranes, which formed the Armor-ican Terrane Assemblage (ATA; Matte, 2001;Linnemann et al., 2004). The Saxothuringian zone isinterpreted as a Cadomian crustal fragment whichunderwent Cambro-Ordovician rifting and was affectedby essentially south-eastward subduction and dextraltranspression (Franke, 1989, 1993) during the (?)Silurian, Devonian and Early Carboniferous time. Thesouth-eastern part of the Saxothuringian belt forms anantiform which exposes in its core (?) Proterozoic andCambro-Ordovician rocks of higher metamorphicgrades and in the flanks in the Northern and WesternErzgebirge/Krusne hory Lower Palaezoic sedimentaryand magmatic rocks.
The geographic location of the batholith coincideswith parts of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge, Vogtland andSlavkovsky les. The batholith intruded as a late- to post-tectonic body into various units differing in protolithages and metamorphic evolution which were stackedtogether during the Variscan collision of the Tepla-Barrandian and Saxothurigian microplates (Franke,1989; Franke et al., 2001; Kachlık, 1993, 1997; Rotzleret al., 1998; Mingram et al., 2004) and modified during
the following processes of crustal relaxations. This iswhy the host rocks include a large variety of lithologies.The batholith emplacement is associated with the lateVariscan collisional magmatism (330–280Ma, Forsteret al., 1999; Schust and Wasternack, 2002). The granitesare calc-alkaline and peraluminous, evolving from earlyI/S- to late S-types (Stemprok, 1986; Forster et al., 1999;Breiter et al., 1999) and form two subsequent intrusivecomplexes (older – OIC and younger – YIC, respecti-vely, Stemprok, 1986; Tischendorf et al., 1987; Tischen-dorf and Forster, 1990).
The batholith is spatially divided into three plutons(Western, Central and Eastern) of which the Westernpluton forms the largest outcropping body. Within thispluton the biggest intrusion is the Nejdek-Eibenstockmassif (Dalmer, 1900) which is divided into Eibenstock,NW of the state boundary between Czech Republic andGermany, and Nejdek which extends south from thestate boundary to the Sokolov basin. The granite bodiesin the Slavkovsky les are located southeast of theSokolov basin (Hejtman, 1984). The Czech authors sofar have preferred to use the name Karlovy Vary plutonfor all parts of this body (Zoubek, 1951; Sattran, 1961;Absolonova and Matoulek, 1972, 1975; Jiranek, 1982).In this paper we term the northern part of the pluton asthe Nejdek-Eibenstock massif and the southern part asthe Karlovy Vary massif (pluton, Fig. 1).
Geological and geophysical evidence suggests thatshallowly emplaced granites can be traced from the
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174154
eastern contact to a distance of approximately 15 kmeastwards from the surface exposures (Tischendorf etal., 1965). Intrusions of mafic rocks are known onlyfrom the southern part of the batholith in the area NWof Karlovy Vary and in the Slavkovsky les (KarlovyVary massif). However, numerous mafic rocks are acomponent of the bimodal dyke assemblage (Skvor,1975) that includes gabbros, diorites, granodiorites andlamprophyres.
Recent dating of the Eibenstock part of the Nejdek-Eibenstock massif gave a 207Pb/206Pb age of 32078Mafor the megacrystic Eibenstock granite and of29075Ma for a rhyolitic dyke suggesting a significanttime gap between the main granite intrusion andanorogenic rhyolite dykes, which intruded brecciabodies of tin-hosting greisens (Kempe et al., 2004).For the Kirchberg granite an age of 29075Ma wasdefined by U–Pb uraninite geochronology (Kempe,2003).
3. Redwitzite body at Abertamy
The redwitzite body at Abertamy is located in theWestern Krusne hory/Erzgebirge about 7 km NW ofJachymov. The northern contact zone of the granitoidmassif is bordered by mica schists (Fig. 2) and two-micagneisses and intersected by abundant dykes of graniteporphyries. The south-eastern part of the area isoccupied by a Tertiary nephelinite which intersects thegranite.
Mafic intrusions are confined to the endocontact ofthe massif which is formed by coarse-grained andmedium-grained OIC granite. The earlier geologicalmap distinguished between these two granite varieties.However, owing to the lack of outcrops, their carto-graphic representation is difficult and not possible toidentify reliably as separate bodies without a newtrenching.
Fig. 2. Geological map of the Abertamy mafic intrusio
The earlier mapping (Zoubek, 1947; Skvor andSattran, 1974) revealed a very irregular shape of thisparticular outcrop. The new mapping in scale 1:10,000of the first author (using shallow cartographic drilling)showed that the two redwitzite outcrops can be mutuallyinterconnected below the Quaternary cover sedimentsand interpreted as a single outcropping lensoid body ofabout 0.6–1.4 km size of NE–SW strike (Fig. 2). Thegeophysical data (see below) point to a shallowextension of the redwitzite body.
The redwitzite body at Abertamy was studied byZoubek (1948) who interpreted the rock, which hereferred to as gabbrodiorite, to be younger than the OICgranites based on the surface shape resembling a lobatedyke. In general schemes, Zoubek (1951) and Stemprok(1986, 1992) considered, however, the redwitzites as theearliest members of Variscan granitoid magmatism.
In the south-western part of the redwitzite body weidentified a thin dyke of biotite granite with a sharpcontact against the redwitzite. This suggests that at leastsome contacts between the redwitzite and the granite areintrusive and the OIC granite intruded later than theredwitzite.
A complete silicate analysis for the Abertamygabbrodiorite is given by Sattran (1963) compared withsome other igneous and metamorphic rocks of theKrusne hory/Erzgebirge. A more detailed petrologicaland petrochemical description of gabbrodiorites fromthe western part of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge pluton ispublished in Stemprok (1986) and of the Abertamygabbrodiorite in Stemprok (1992). The results of a newstudy of redwitzites are reported in Jelınek et al.(2003, 2004).
4. Sampling
Samples (5–15 kg) for petrological and geochemicalstudies were taken from large boulders, from a section inthe valley of Brook Bystrice and from boulders in the
n with the profiles of geophysical measurements.
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 155
river base. The samples were collected in two campaigns:one in 1991–1992 (Stemprok, 1992, samples labelled asPLE) and the second in 2002 (Kovarıkova, 2004,samples labelled as AB). The list of samples is given inJelınek et al. (2003).
5. Analytical techniques
A Scintrex CG-3M gravimeter was used for gravitysurvey and a proton magnetometer PM-2 was used formeasurement of total component of magnetic field. Themean square error calculated from repeated measure-ments is 70.004mGal for gravity and 72 nT formagnetic values. Gravity measurements were processedto the form of relative Bouguer anomalies Dg withcomplete topographical corrections (radius 166.735 kmfrom measured stations). DT values were calculatedfrom total field magnetic measurements. The normalmagnetic field was set as a median of the measuredvalues at each locality.
Major and trace element analyses on selected whole-rock samples have been conducted in the Chemicallaboratory of the Czech Geological Survey in Prague byconventional wet methods (silicate analyses, majorelements), by optical emission spectrometry (OES)(B, Be, Bi, Co, Cr, Cu, Ga, Mo, Pb, Zn), by X-rayfluorescence analyses (XRF) (Nb, Y, Zr, U), inductivelycoupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) (REE andY, Sc, Th, Ta, W) and atomic absorbtion spectrometry(AAS) (Sr, Ba, Cs, Rb, Zn, V and Ni) methods.Additional analyses have been performed in thechemical laboratory of the Faculty of Science, CharlesUniversity, Prague (wet silicate analyses and AAS forLi, Rb, Cu, Co, Cr, Ni, Zn, Sr, Pb and ICP-MS for REEand Ba, Hf, Sc, Nb, Ta, Th, U).
The minerals were analyzed by electron microprobe inthe Chemical laboratory of the Czech Geological Surveyin Prague (CamScan S-4 Link ISIS 300), at the Facultyof Science, Charles University, Prague (CamScan S-4Link ISIS EDX) and at the Laboratory of the Instituteof Geology of the Academy of Science (CAMECA SX-100 electron microprobe in the wavelength dispersivemode). The CamScan microprobe was used for thebackscattered electron images of zircons.
Heavy mineral fractions were prepared in theLaboratories of the Czech Geological Survey inBarrandov, Prague. The crushed samples were separatedin heavy liquids and zircons were handpicked from theheavy mineral assemblage after magnetic separation.
For single-zircon Pb-evaporation (Kober, 1986, 1987)chemically untreated zircon grains were analyzed with aFinnigan MAT 262 mass spectrometer equipped with asecondary electron multiplier (SEV) at the University ofTubingen. Principles of the evaporation method used in
this study are described in Siebel et al. (2003). With theexception of four grains from sample AB4, only data withhigh radiogenic Pb component (204Pb/206Pbo1� 10�4)were used for evaluation. One grain from sample AB7yielded very high Pb intensities and masses 206, 207 and208 were also detected simultaneously in Faraday cups.All 207Pb/206Pb ratios were corrected for common Pbaccording to the formula given in Cocherie et al. (1992)following the two stage growth model for the evolution ofPb isotopic ratios of Stacey and Kramers (1975). Nocorrection was made for mass fractionation.
The common Pb corrected 207Pb/206Pb ratios nor-mally define a Gaussian distribution and the mean of the207Pb/206Pb ratios was derived from this distribution.The error for a single zircon age was calculatedaccording to the formula
where n is the number of 207Pb/206Pb isotope ratio scans,2s is the 2sigma standard error of the Gaussiandistribution function and Df an assumed error for themeasured 207Pb/206Pb ratios of 0.1% which includespotential bias caused by mass fractionation of Pbisotopes and uncertainty in linearity of the multipliersignal. The mean age for one zircon from sample AB7 isgiven as weighted average and the error refers to the95% confidence level (ISOPLOT, Ludwig, 1999).Repeated measurements on two internal standardzircons of similar age show that most of the investigatedsamples were performed for geologically realistic ageand error treatment.
6. Petrography
6.1. Granites
The biotite granite in the surrounding of Abertamy ismedium- to coarse-grained, and has a porphyritic tohypidiomorphic texture and is mostly classified withmonzogranite. Near the contact to the redwitzites theamount of biotite increases and forms conspiciousaccumulations with rare muscovite flakes. Phenocrystsof K-feldspar show no apparent preferred orientation.The matrix is composed of quartz, K-feldspar andbiotite, less abundant are plagioclase and muscovite.The main accessories are zircon, apatite, monazite andxenotime. K-feldspar is often perthitic. Myrmekiteoccurs near some margins of K-feldspars. Quartz formsisometric grains, usually with undulatory extinction.Biotite composes dark brown flakes with light brown todark brown pleochroism. Most biotites are altered bychloritization. Minute grains of radioactive accessoryminerals occur within the biotite flakes surrounded by
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174156
pleochroic haloes. They often intergrow with feldspars.Plagioclase (An26 to An11; Table 1) constitutes small,hypidiomorphic tabular crystals, which are markedlyzoned (Fig. 3a). Zircons show relicts of inherited cores(Fig. 3e) preserved from other cycles of zircon crystal-lization and this early component affected the age dating(Jelınek et al., 2004). Petrographically the granite iscomparable with the most primitive members of the OICgroup of granites (Stemprok, 1986; Hejtman, 1984).
Sporadically enclaves of fine-grained mafic rocks ofup to 5 cm in size occur in the OIC granites. Theboundary between granite and these mafic enclaves iscommonly sharp. Around such enclaves a 0.5–1 cm thickzone consists predominantly of plagioclase and quartz.The mineral assemblage of the mafic enclaves is identicalto that of the gabbrodiorite.
6.2. Granite porphyry
In the OIC granite near the outcrop of the redwitzitebody, a steep granite porphyry dyke, about 0.5m thick,occurs with a sharp contact to the enclosing granite. It isa fine-grained rock with quartz and feldspar phenocrystsof up to 2 cm in size and with biotite flakes. The matrixconsists of quartz, plagioclase, K-feldspar and biotite.Phenocrysts of quartz also form clusters of severalquartz grains which show non-uniform undulousextinction. K-feldspar forms hypidiomorphic pheno-crysts. Biotite is strongly chloritised. In places smallenclaves (up to 15mm size) of the biotite granite ormafic rocks occur in the dyke. The rock shows aremarkable flow texture and texturally resembles therhyolites dated recently by the U–Pb method in thenorthern part of the Nejdek-Eibenstock massif at29075Ma (Kempe et al., 2004).
6.3. Redwitzites
The mafic body near Abertamy is petrographicallyinhomogeneous and consists of coarse- to medium-grained textural types. These differ also in mineralogyand geochemistry. However, both types have similartextural features, such as randomly-oriented idio-morphic to hypidiomorphic crystals of plagioclase andconspicuous large (from few mm to 2 cm) sheets ofbiotite, that enclose plagioclase crystals in poikilitictexture (Fig. 3b). The presence of large biotite flakesgives these rocks a very characteristic appearancecorresponding to redwitzites described from the classicallocality near Marktredwitz. Both rock-types displayhypidiomorphic-grained textures.
6.3.1. Quartz gabbrodiorite
The NE part of th mafic body is made up of biotite-amphibole quartz gabbrodiorite. It is a medium-grained
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 3. (a) Zoned plagioclase; OIC granite; (b) Poikilitic overgrowth of biotite with plagioclase; gabbrodiorite; (c) Hornblende in
gabbrodiorite; (d) Zoned plagioclase, gabbrodiorite (backscattered electron image, bar 500mm); (e) Zircon with xenotime, OIC
granite (backscattered electron image, bar 20mm); zr – zircon, xn – xenotime; (f) Apatite with zircon, OIC granite (backscattered
electron image, bar 10 mm); ap – apatite.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 157
rock composed of biotite, hornblende (Fig. 3c), andplagioclase, accompanied by smaller amounts of pyrox-ene, quartz and K-feldspar. Plagioclase crystals (An72 toAn26; Table 1) are hypidiomorphic to idiomorphic inshape and are markedly zoned (Fig. 3d, sample AB 1 inTable 1). They have noticeable core which is predomi-nantly of labradorite to bytownite in composition. Thentwo or three broad zones follow, that are oftenseparated by a narrow more acid zone. Marginal partsof plagioclase crystals range from calcic oligoclase tomedium andesine. Pyroxenes occur as turbid relicts ofdiopsidic composition (Table 2). Idiomorphic grains ofusually perthitic K-feldspar are present less commonly.Quartz composes oval xenomorphic grains which oftenshow undulatory extinction.
Amphiboles are light green with very weak pleochro-ism in idiomorphic crystals. They range in compositionfrom actinolite to magnesiohornblende with a lowamount of Al (Table 3). The abundant secondary
actinolitic amphibole probably originated from anearlier pyroxene generation.
Biotite (annite to phlogopite; Fig. 4) forms hypidio-morphic to xenomorphic, dark brown sheets oftenpoikilitically enclosing plagioclase crystals. Most bio-tites are altered to chlorite along the margins or cleavageplanes whose composition ranges from diabanite topyknochlorite.
The quartz gabbrodiorites have remarkable highcontents of accessories, especially of ilmenite andapatite. Titanite and zircon are common accessorieswhereas orthite is rare. Opaque minerals are repre-sented mainly by pyrrhotine and pyrite. Idiomorphicgrains of apatite, zircon or other accessories are oftenconfined to biotites; around them are noticeable darkpleochroic halos. Zircons studied in backscatteredelectron images do not show any cores and areweakly zoned suggesting that they crystallized directlyfrom the melt.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Table 3. Representative analyses of amphiboles (explanation of samples see Table 4)
Sample (wt%) AB 5 AB 5 AB 5 AB 7 AB 7 AB 7 PLE 1 PLE 1 PLE 1 PLE 3
Fig. 4. Biotite composition of redwitzites and granites as based on microprobe data.
Table 2. Representative analyses of pyroxenes (explanation of samples see Table 4)
Sample (wt%) AB 5 AB 5 AB 5 AB 5 PLE 3 PLE 3
opx opx opx opx cpx cpx
core rim
SiO2 55.33 53.41 54.51 54.02 53.90 53.56
TiO2 0.09 1.56 0.34 0.45 0.18 0.25
Al2O3 0.70 1.65 1.24 1.15 0.32 0.54
Cr2O3 0.03 0.24 0.11 0.10 – –
FeO 16.45 17.09 16.36 17.00 6.29 5.03
MnO 0.33 0.20 0.36 0.30 0.29 0.32
MgO 27.62 25.87 26.57 25.49 14.76 15.77
BaO 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 – –
CaO 0.60 1.51 1.29 1.23 24.64 24.50
Na2O 0.00 0.03 0.02 0.01 0.45 0.10
K2O 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 – –
Total 101.15 101.58 100.80 99.75 100.83 100.07
opx ¼ orthopyroxene, cpx ¼ clinopyroxene.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174158
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 159
6.3.2. Biotite-amphibole gabbronorite
Gabbronorite occurs in the western part of the maficbody. The plagioclase crystals of this rock type (An79 toAn33) are strongly zoned, in their inner parts thecompositions range from bytownite to anorthite(Table 1), the margins correspond to acid labradoriteand, very rarely, to andesine (near the contact withquartz). Plagioclase from sample AB7 (Table 1) has therim more basic than the core because of the strongalbitisation of the plagioclase’s core. The composition ofamphibole (Table 3) ranges from hornblende toactinolite. Quartz and K-feldspar are rare, similarly asin gabbrodiorite. The accessories are identical to thosein the gabbrodiorite. In one sample an apatite crystal ofblack color was observed in mineral separates increaseduranium content.
Some portions of the rock show a total uralitisation ofprimary mafic minerals, but in some samples preservedrelicts of pyroxene were observed. In a single samplerelicts of orthopyroxene (enstatite; Table 2) wereidentified. Clinopyroxene crystals form xenomorphicgrains which enclose small crystals of plagioclases alongtheir margins. Secondary amphibole (fibrous actinolite)after pyroxene and possibly also after primary horn-blende occurs in the samples which shows an advancedstage of uralitisation. However, from the bulk chemicalcomposition it can be deduced that in the primarymagmatic mineral association orthopyroxene was abun-dant among the rock-forming minerals. The presence oforthopyroxene in the primary mineral assemblage of thegabbronorites is the main difference from the quartzgabbrodiorite, where this mineral is absent.
7. Geophysical measurements
Gravity and magnetic methods were used to deter-mine the size and extent of the Abertamy redwitzitebody. It was expected that magnetic methods wouldindicate a near-surface situation of mafic rocks whilegravity would show the extent of the intrusion at depth.According to in situ kappametry, redwitzites haverelative magnetic susceptibilities two orders of magni-tude higher than densities of the surrounding granites.Densities of redwitzites are approximately 2850 kg/m3,markedly higher than densities of granites (2620 kg/m3).
Two perpendicular geophysical profiles were stakedout across the outcrops of the mafic rocks (Fig. 2). Thedistance between the gravity stations was 50m, thedistance between magnetic stations was 10m. Results ofthe geophysical measurements are shown in Fig. 5. Steepgradients of gravity values Dg on the SW side of profile 1and the SE side of profile 2 indicate the boundarybetween redwitzites and granites. The boundary betweenredwitzites and metasediments (mica schists) on the
opposite sides of the profiles is less obvious, because thedensity contrast between these rocks is smaller thanthe density contrast between redwitzites and granites.The averaged or quiet magnetic field above the granitesis by 20 nT lower than the magnetic field above themetasediments. The magnetic field above the redwitzitesis slightly higher than above the neighbouring geologicalunits and it is more variable. Sources of local anomaliesare boulder fields of mafic rocks on the surface. Themagnetic field is most variable at places of terraindepressions carved out by local streams (Fig. 2, profile 1,meters 400–500 and 1200–1700). Sources of fluctuatingmagnetic field are fluvial deposits bearing magneticminerals from nearby outcrops of highly magneticTertiary volcanic rocks (nephelinite).
Gravity measurements were interpreted quantita-tively. Geological models are shown in Fig. 5. Verticalgeological sections are not exaggerated and displayedare areas beyond the ends of the measured profiles, toinclude all modeled geological units and the real shapeof the mafic intrusion. The models are 2.75-D whichmeans that geological bodies have a finite length in thedirection perpendicular to the profiles and densities overthe ends of geological blocks could be different.Constrains of the model are gravity measurements,geological maps and densities of rocks taken fromBlızkovsky et al. (1981). We conclude that the maficintrusion is a plate-like body of about 1.5 km thickdipping generally to the north. Geophysical measure-ments support the fact that the two surface outcrops ofredwitzites form a continuous single mafic body whichextents shallowly at depth.
8. Geochemistry
Both redwitzite varieties from Abertamy differ in theirchemical composition (Fig. 6, Table 4). The gabbro-norites have MgO contents between 11 and 18wt%significantly higher than in the gabbrodiorites(4–5wt%). The CaO contents are roughly similar inboth rock types. Gabbrodiorites and gabbronorites,have low SiO2 (48–52wt%) classifying them as basic tomarginally intermediate rocks. In contrast to thegabbronorites, the gabbrodiorites have higher contentsof TiO2, Al2O3 and alkalies. Fluorine concentrations aregenerally lower in the gabbronorites than in thegabbrodiorites.
In the AFM diagram (Fig. 7) the gabbrodiorites andthe associated OIC granites from Abertamy plot into thecalc-alkaline series field (CA) whereas the gabbronoritesplot in the tholeiite series field close to the boundary ofthe CA field.
In comparison with literature data the Abertamyredwitzites are very similar in chemical composition to
ARTICLE IN PRESS
3
2
1
0
0 500 1000 1500
x (m)
2000 2500
300
200
100
0
-100
-200
920
880
840
800 H (
m)
a.s
.l.
NE
Profile 1
Profile 1
SW
=Observed =Calculated
=Observed =Calculated
NEAlluviumD=2000 kg/m2 D=2620 kg/m3
D=2620 kg/m3 D=2750 kg/m3
D=2850 kg/m3
Mica schistGranite
Redwitzite
SW
4
3
2
1
0
1500
1000
-1500
-2000 -1000 1000 2000 -3000 -4000 -50000
-1000
500
-500
0
Profile 2Profile 23
2
1
0
3
2
1
0
0 500 1000
920
880
840
800
powerline
H (
m)
a.s
.l.
SE NW
x (m)
Gravity Δg
Magnetics ΔT
Topography H
Distance (m)
SE NW
1000
1000
-1000
-1000
500
2000
Distance (m)
-500
0
0
Δg (
mG
al)
Δg (
mG
al)
ΔT (
nT
)
Nephelin
ite
Gra
nite
Redw
itzite
Mic
a s
chis
t
D=
3100 k
g/m
3
D=
2620 k
g/m
3
D=
28
50 k
g/m
3
D=
2750 k
g/m
3
Altitude (
m)
a.s
.l.
Altitude (
m)
a.s
.l.
Gra
vity (
mG
al)
Gra
vity (
mG
al)
Granite
_
Fig. 5. Geophysical measurements over the mafic body with the gravity, magnetics and topography profiles and geophysical model
of the redwitzite body at Abertamy.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174160
basic redwitzite varieties from the Marktredwitz typelocality (Troll, 1968) and to the gabbrodiorites from theSlavkovsky les (Fiala, 1968). The compositional differ-ence between more primitive gabbronorites and moreevolved gabbrodiorites is evident. The former are closerto the basic redwitzites from Marktredwitz (Troll, 1968),but the latter are more similar to redwitzites from the
northern Oberpfalz (Siebel, 1993), the Bor massif (Siebelet al., 1997; Rene, 2000) and the Fichtelgebirge(Taubald, 2000).
Abertamy redwitzites have lower contents of SiO2 andalkalies (K2O and Na2O) and higher contents of CaO andFeO compared with most other redwitzites described inthe literature. Gabbrodiorites at Abertamy have very high
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 6. Harker variation diagrams for redwitzites and associated granitoids from Abertamy.
Table 4. Chemical analyses of main and trace elements of redwitzites, granites OIC and granite porphyry
Sample AB 1 AB 2 AB 3 AB 4 AB 5 AB 6 AB 7 PLE-1 PLE-2 PLE-3 PLE-4 PLE-5
AB 1, PLE 3 – biotite-amphibole quartz gabbrodiorite, AB 2 – granite porphyry, AB 3, AB 4, PLE 2, PLE 4 – granite OIC.
AB 5–7, PLE 1, PLE 5 – biotitic gabbronorite.
nLa, nLu – La, Lu normalized to chondrite.
Fig. 7. AFM diagram for redwitzites and associated granitoids
from Abertamy.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174162
contents of TiO2, higher than all other redwitzites. On theother hand, gabbronorites have very low TiO2 and P2O5
content and have high MgO and thus are comparablewith Marktredwitz basic redwitzites.
The adjacent OIC granites and the granite porphyryhave higher SiO2 (470wt%) and lower TiO2, Fe2O3,FeO, MnO, MgO and CaO concentrations than theassociated redwitzites. Potassium prevails over sodiumand the average K2O/Na2O ratio is 1.47. The content ofaluminum is similar in all rock types (Table 4). Alldescribed granites are markedly peraluminous in con-trast to the redwitzites which are metaluminous. Thetypical OIC granites are close to I-type granites(Stemprok, 1986) but the Abertamy granites have morefeatures resembling S-type granites: they have low Na2Ocontent, A/CNK ratios higher than 1.1, and more than1% of normative corundum.
8.1. Trace elements
Generally, the gabbrodiorites have higher contentsof incompatible elements (Cs, Rb, Ba, Sr) and high
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 163
field strength (HFS) elements (U, Ta, Nb, Th, REE),whereas the gabbronorites are relatively enriched incompatible elements like Ni, Cr, Sc, V and Co (Fig. 8,Table 4).
The spidergrams of gabbronorites, gabbrodiorites andgranites from Abertamy are shown in Fig. 9. All rocktypes, normalized to primitive mantle, are characterizedby enrichment in large ion lithophile (LIL) elements andP and by negative peaks of Nb. This pattern is typicalfor rocks from the continental crust. Elevated phos-phorus contents are characteristic also for someVariscan granites in the Western part of the Bohemianmassif (Siebel et al., 1999).
The trace element composition of the OIC granites issimilar to that of the gabbrodiorites with respect to theenrichment in incompatible elements. The granites havehigh Rb (190–232 ppm), Th (up to 47 ppm) and Pb(47–58 ppm) concentrations and higher Rb/Sr (41.25)ratio compared to the gabbrodiorites (Rb/Sr ¼ 0.11)and the gabbronorites (Rb/Sr ¼ 0.17). The Abertamygranites are enriched in those trace elements whosecontent is controlled by the presence of accessoryminerals (Y, Zr, Sn, REE, Hf, Pb, Th, and U) asexpected from mineralogy. However, some trace elementconcentrations such as Li, Zr, Nb and Ba are at similarlevels as in the redwitzites whereas Co, Ni and V aretypically higher only in the redwitzites.
Fig. 8. Trace elements versus silica for redwitzite
8.2. Rare earth elements
All studied rocks are enriched in LREE compared toHREE (Fig. 10). The total amount of REEs in thegabbrodiorite exceeds that of the gabbronorites. Fromthe most primitive to the most evolved redwitzitesamples, normalized La and Ce increases by a factorof three. The normalized La/Lu ratio in the OICgranites at Abertamy is about 100, in gabbrodiorites itis approximately 250 and in gabbronorites around 130.The OIC granites are characterized by a negative Euanomaly whereas the Eu anomaly is absent in theredwitzites. The REE pattern for the OIC granite andthe crosscutting granite porphyry (rhyolite) are almostidentical.
8.3. Harker diagrams
Fig. 11 shows the comparision of Abertamy red-witzites with those from the Slavkovsky les (Fiala,1968), northern Oberpfalz (Siebel, 1993), Bor massif(Rene, 2000) and Marktredwitz (Troll, 1968) in Harkervariation diagrams. All plots show a continuouscompositional trend from the most mafic members ofthe redwitzite suite to the OIC granites. Redwitzitesfrom Abertamy as well as redwitzites from the
s and associated granitoids from Abertamy.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 9. Spidergrams for redwitzites and associated granitoids from Abertamy (normalized to primitive mantle – Taylor and
McLennan, 1986).
Fig. 10. REE normalized diagram for redwitzites and associated granitoids from Abertamy (normalized to chondrite, Boynton,
1984).
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174164
Slavkovsky les and the basic varieties from Marktred-witz have SiO2 contents o55wt%. Others have silicacontents ranging from 55 to 60wt%.
The TiO2 vs. SiO2 diagram shows a large scatter forsamples with SiO2o55wt%. For samples with SiO2
over 55wt% TiO2 correlates negatively with SiO2. Asignificantly negative correlation also exists for the FeOcontents. This is apparently caused by decreasingamounts of mafic minerals from redwitzite towardsgranites. A similar relationship with a wider scatter isshown between the CaO and SiO2 contents which can beexplained mainly by the decreasing anorthite componentin the plagioclases. The MgO contents in rocks with lowSiO2 show a wide scatter and a steep negativecorrelation. In rocks with SiO2 contents over 50wt%the trend is less scattered and characterized by amoderate decrease of MgO with raising silica. A changeof the slope with increasing silica can also be observedfor Al2O3. K2O and Na2O. These show a positivecorrelation with raising SiO2 but are characterized by
very large variations which can be explained in additionto primary magmatic processes by secondary alterations(e.g. deuteric albitization in redwitzites and granites,muscovitization in the granites, etc.). The diagram forthe P2O5 vs. silica contents indicates two populationsindependent of SiO2: one with P2O5 content over0.8wt% and the other one with P2O5o0.6wt%.
9. Age determination
From the redwitzite sample AB7 two zircon grainsgave 207Pb/206Pb-evaporation ages of 322.971.8Ma(grain 1) and 322.471.8Ma (grain 2) (Fig. 12,Table 5). Grain 1 was also analyzed in static mode bythe Faraday detection (instead of ion counting in peakjumping mode) and gave an age of 326.972.1Ma. Thesmall difference in age (i.e. 322.9 vs. 326.9Ma) might bedue to systematic counting error but it is within the
ARTICLE IN PRESS
45 55 65 75
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
45 55 65 75
12
14
16
18
20
22
45 55 65 75
10
45 55 65 75
10
15
MgO
wt. %
CaO
wt. %
45 55 65 75 45 55 65 75
4
45 55 65 75
2
45 55 65 75
0.2
0.6
1.0
2
4
6
8
2
3
2
4
6
8
5
0
3
4
5 redwitzites: granitoids:
Marktredwitz
Bor massif
Oberpfalz
Slavkovský les
Abertamy
granite Bor massif
granite Abertamy
gr. porphyry Abertamy
SiO2 wt. %
K2O
wt. %
P2O
5 w
t. %
TiO
2 w
t. %
AL
2O
3 w
t. %
Na
2O
wt. %
FeO
t w
t. %
SiO2 wt. %
SiO2 wt. %
Fig. 11. Harker diagrams for the redwitzites and selected granites from the NW margin of the Bohemian massif.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 165
bounds of the errors. The two zircon grains from sampleAB7 can be thus regarded as equal in age.
Granite sample AB4 contains zircons with aninherited component. However, a single grain (grain 6)gave a well defined Pb-evaporation age of 323Ma. Therewas no evidence of older core material in this sampleand this age, although not reproduced by a secondanalyses, may constraint on the time of granite crystal-lization. Most of the analyzed grains from sample AB4are characterised by a very high common lead compo-nent (i.e. low 206Pb/204Pb ratios). This component waspresent even at the high temperature evaporation steps.This was particularly the case for grain 4 and grain 5,but also partly for grain 2 and grain 3. In general, onlydata with high 206Pb/204Pb ratios are considered forevaluation because the exact isotopic composition of thecommon lead component is not well known and thusincreases the uncertainity of the 207Pb/206Pb age.
The reason for the high common Pb componentremains unclear and most of the data from AB4 mainlyserve only as an indication for the presence of older corecomponent present in the zircons. However, the lack ofPrecambrian ages may be taken as indication that theinherited component (at least for this sample) wasPaleozoic in age.
10. Granites and redwitzites derived from
sediments and amphibolites
Patino Douce (1999) produced experimental melts bymelting rocks with various mineral associations andsuggested that the differences between the amphibolite-derived melts and melts derived from mica-rich sourcescan be deduced from the differences in the major
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Fig. 12. Histograms showing the distribution of radiogenic 207Pb/206Pb ratios obtained from evaporation analyses of one zircon
from granite sample AB4 and two zircons from redwitzite sample AB7.
Table 5. Isotope data for single grain 207Pb/206Pb evaporation analyses (explanation of samples see Table 1)
No. of 207Pb/206Pb ratios 204Pb/206Pb 206Pb/208Pb U/Th 207Pb/206Pb Age (Ma)
aMeasured with Faraday cups instead of ion counter.
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174166
element oxides. Melts derived from amphibolites aredepleted in total alkalies and are enriched in CaOrelative to mica-rich sources. Melts derived frommuscovite-rich sources are depleted in FeO+MgO+TiO2 relatively to biotite-rich sources. In Fig. 13 thefields of melt composition derived from different sources(greywackes, mafic pelites, felsic pelites and amphibo-lites, Patino Douce, 1999) are marked and the composi-tions of redwitzites and granites from Abertamy andfrom other redwitzite localities plotted in this diagram.The Abertamy redwitzites as well as the redwitzites fromother localities partially overlap with the fields of
amphibolite-derived melt. However, the plots of mostsamples are outside of this field. Redwitzites have lowercontent of alkalies, but they have higher amount offerromagnesian components (FeO+MgO+TiO2) andAl2O3 compared with amphibolite-derived melt. Theyfollow well the trend of the low pressure (LP) mixingcurve. The granites from Abertamy coincide with thefield of greywackes-derived melt. Forster et al. (1999)postulated for the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granitesmore variegated metasedimentary sources like metape-lites, metagreywackes and orthogneisses. We can con-clude that amphibolites are an improbable lithology for
Fig. 13. Composition of redwitzites and selected granites from the NW margin of the Bohemian massif as plotted in the diagram
according to Patino Douce (1999). The thick solid lines are reaction curves that model melt compositions that would be produced by
hybridization of high-Al olivine tholeiite with metapelite. LP – low pressure (Po ¼ 5 kbar, reaction produces an assemblage
dominated by plagioclase and Al pyroxene), HP – high pressure (P ¼ 12–15 kbar, product of reaction is garnet accompanied by
subordinate plagioclase).
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 167
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174168
the origin of the Abertamy redwitzites but the enclosinggranites originated probably from greywacke lithology.
11. Magma mixing
Magma mixing in the genesis of redwitzites (Wurm,1932; Siebel, 1993; Taubald, 2000) was accepted as oneof the possible mechanisms of their origin. Holl et al.(1989) explain on the basis isotopic evidence the originof redwitzites as isotopic heterogeneous mixing betweenbasic and intermediate magmas.
In general mixing may range from complete andhomogenous mixing (where the character of thedifferent magmas is not noticeable) to a magmamingling where original components maintain much oftheir individual features. Our geological evidence is infavour of homogenous mixing as inhomogeneoustransitional textural types were not found on theoutcrops studied at Abertamy and we observed inter-section of the solid redwitzite enclave by the granite inthe southern part of the body.
The linear trend in binary geochemical plots is theresult of ideal mixing of mafic and felsic magma and thiscan be observed in FeOt and CaO Harker diagrams(Fig. 11). The correlation depends on the stage ofmixing, homogeneity of both end members, otherpetrogenetic processes which can occur, and the preci-sion of analytical methods (D’Lemos, 1996).
From two end members – mafic and acid (granitic)magmas – it is possible to calculate the composition ofhybrid magmas according to the linear equation (afterLangmuir et al., 1978; Fourcade and Allegre, 1981)
CM ¼ XA � CA � ð1� XAÞ � CB,
where CM is the concentration of the element in hybridmelt, CA the concentration of the element in acidcomponent, CB the cocentration of the element in basiccomponent, XA the amount of acid component partici-pating in mixing (number from 0 to 1) and XB ¼ 1�XA
the amount of basic component participating in mixing.In the case that one of the end members is missing it is
possible to carry out inverse calculation for CM usingthe composition of a real hybrid (averaged Abertamyredwitzite). With one end member known (averagedOIC granite from Abertamy) we can calculate thetheoretical composition of the other end member under
Table 6. The calculation of mafic end member composition for m
wt% SiO2 TiO2 Al2O3 Fe2O3 FeO
% of acid member
15 48.03 1.71 14.60 1.84 7.31
20 46.50 1.80 14.64 1.91 7.72
25 44.78 1.90 14.68 1.99 8.18
the assumption that we state the amount of theadmixture of the acid component. Using the amountsof Ni and Cr as the typical mafic compatible elementswe postulated that the admixture of acid component tothe magma parental to redwitzite did not exceed25wt.% but was probably less (about 15wt.%).
The theoretical composition of the mafic end memberis given in Table 6. This composition corresponds bestto mafic gabbros, namely to olivine gabbros or noriteaccording to Soloviev (1970) or Kramer (1988). Thisstrengthens the early concept of Wurm (1932) postulat-ing the genesis of redwitzite in Marktredwitz area bymixing of the granitic magmas with norites at depth.
12. Fractional crystallization
The variation between the composition of gabbronor-ites and gabbrodiorites are expected to be caused by in
situ fractionation of predominant rock-forming mineralswhich is the typical process in mafic igneous rocks. Thisis also supported by the geological situation of the rocksat Abertamy. Guo et al. (2004) pictured the trends ofchemical changes in a magma during fractionation ofrock forming and accessory minerals in MgO vs. majorand trace element binary plots based on the study oflamprophyres. The fractionated minerals are similar tothose crystallizing from a mafic magma. The result ofsuch modelling is a residual magma composition arisingfrom a fractionated mineral assemblage, which canexplain the chemical variation of the rocks.
In Fig. 14 we compare the major element oxidecomposition of the gabbronorites and gabbrodiorites inMgO versus major oxides plots. Diorites from theSlavkovsky les (Fiala, 1968), which have a similarposition to the redwitzites from Abertamy, are shownfor comparison. The trends of fractionation have beencalculated according to the equation
ciPM ¼ ci
minf min þ ciRLð1� f minÞ,
where ci is the concentration of an element, PM is theoriginal magma, RL refers to the magma afterdifferentiation, min means the mineral that fractionatesand f is the amount of fractionated mineral (numberfrom 0 to 1).
The result of such calculation is the composition ofmagma, which originated by fractional crystallization of
agma mixing
FeOt MnO MgO CaO Na2O K2O
8.95 0.15 9.67 8.11 2.00 1.55
9.42 0.15 10.22 8.54 1.91 1.35
9.95 0.16 10.84 9.03 1.80 1.13
ARTICLE IN PRESS
58
54
50
46
5 10 15 20
2.5
1.5
0.5
5 10 15 20
22
14
18
10
5 10 15 20
4
3
2
1
5 10 15 205 10 15 205 10 15 20
5 10 15 20
MgO wt. %MgO wt. %
MgO wt. %
8
6
4
2
12
10
8
6
5
3
1
SiO
2 w
t. %
FeO
t w
t. %
CaO
wt. %
TiO
2 w
t. %
Na
2O
wt. %
Al 2
O3 w
t. %
K2O
wt. %
redwitzite:
Abertamy
Slavkovsky les
bt
plgcpx
amfopx
bt
plgcpxamf
opx
bt
plg
cpx
amf
opx
btplg
cpxamfopx
bt
plgamf
opx
bt
plg
cpxopx
bt
plgcpxamf
opx
`
Fig. 14. Fractionation trends in Bowen diagrams for redwitzites from the NW margin of the Bohemian massif, amf – amphibole, bt
P. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 169
a single mineral. Arrows in the MgO binary diagramsshow the changes of composition if 10% of plagioclase,biotite, orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene or amphibolefractionate from the magma.
In Fig. 14 there is positive correlation between MgOand FeO values of CaO are very scattered, howeverweak positive correlation can be deduced. These trendscould be explained by the fractionation of plagioclaseand orthopyroxene. Most of the plots show negativecorrelation such as those of SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, Na2Oand K2O. These trends could be correlated with thefractionation of plagioclase, or of orthopyroxene (in thecase of Al2O3 and Na2O). The variations of K2O andTiO2 can be explained by the fractionation of biotite.We conclude that some chemical variations of theredwitzite bodies can be explained by in situ fractiona-tion of the essential redwitzite minerals which may havegenerated orthopyroxene and clinopyroxene cumulatesin the crystallizing magma and have led to the difference
between the composition of the gabbronorite andgabbrodiorite.
13. Zircon thermometry
According to the calibration curves of Watson andHarrison (1983), the Abertamy redwitzites and OICgranites have low zircon saturation temperatures be-tween 750 and 860 1C. These zircon saturation tempera-tures are also typical for redwitzites and early biotitegranites from NE Bavaria (Siebel et al., 2003). Unlikethe granites from NE Bavaria, the Abertamy OICgranites have zircon grains with preserved older cores.Even if the temperature of the melt was probably higherthan the zircon saturation temperature, a chemicaldisequilibrium between zircon and the melt may haveexisted during partial melting causing the older cores ofzircon grains in the granitic magmas to be preserved.
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174170
14. Discussion
The role of the mafic magmas in the genesis ofgranitoids is broadly discussed in the literature using theconcept of magma mixing and/or mingling or consider-ing additional heat sources for melting or remelting ofcrustal rocks (Castro et al., 1991; Barbarin and Didier,1991; Collins, 1998). Collins (1998) supposes that largehomogenous granodioritic to granitic intrusions couldrepresent well-mixed hybrids. However, Gerdes et al.(2000) argue that such hybrids should be stronglyheterogenous on a large scale because of a high viscositycontrast, slow rates of chemical diffusion, fast coolingrates and limited convection in plutonic systems whichimply that homogenous felsic granitoids are unlikely tobe hybrids of mantle derived and crustal melts.
The evidences that mixing of mafic and felsic magmasat different scales exist is testified by mafic enclaves(Barbarin and Didier, 1991) in felsic granitoids, linearelemental co-variation between assumed mafic and felsicend members (Wall et al., 1987) and evidence fromisotopic investigations and modeling (DePaolo, 1981).An important problem of granite petrology is theidentification of heat sources, causing large scale meltingof crustal rocks producing granitoid magmas. Henk etal. (2000) envisaged four potential heat sources in theVariscan orogen of Europe: (1) radiogenic productionfrom the decay of U, Th, K in thickened crustal rocks;(2) advection of heat by exhumation of deeply buriedhot rocks; (3) advection of heat by intrusion of mantle-derived melts; (4) conduction of heat from a hotter thannormal mantle. It is extremely difficult to find outexactly the contribution from the mentioned sources inthe case of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granitic mag-mas. Evidence of magma mixing/mingling and geo-chemical and isotopic criteria showing interaction ofmantle derived melts with crustal rocks are describedfrom root domains of the Variscan chain from CentralIberian Zone (Menendez and Ortega, 1999; Bea et al.,1999), Massif Central (Turpin et al., 1998; Joly et al.,2006) and Bohemian Massif (Janousek et al., 2000;Gerdes et al., 2000; Holub and Janousek, 2003).
In the Bohemian Massif Variscan magmatism isconcentrated in the Moldanubian root zone, largecalc-akaline plutons straddle the Moldanubian/Tepla-Barrrandian and Saxothuringian/Tepla Barrandianboundaries. The mantle derived granitoid magmasintruded in several short-lived pulses divided by longerepisode of a weak magmatic activity.
Intrusions of redwidzites follow a relatively narrowbelt between the Franconian line and the WestBohemian shear Zone and its continuation to theSaxothuringian belt (Marianske Lazne fault). Theemplacement ages on zircon by U–Pb technique rangebetween 342 and 323Ma (342 – Mutenın body on theczech quartz lode, 332Ma – Drahotın body, Dorr et al.,
1998), Ar–Ar-cooling ages 326 and 323Ma (Kreuzeret al., 1992). The most recent data from the Oberphalz,the Fichtelgebirge and the Western pluton of the Krusnehory/Erzgebirge batholith cluster between 326 and323Ma and overlap with the age of biotite granites ofthe older intrusive suites (Siebel et al., 2003).
The occurrences of mafic rocks in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge batholith area have been so far considered asunimportant (Bankwitz and Bankwitz, 1994) for granitegenesis and their practical absence was taken as evidencethat other processes than mafic magma intrusion orunderplating were decisive in melting of the crustalrocks. Forster et al. (1999) point to the lack ofredwitzites in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge comparedwith the geological situation in NE Bavaria and favoredthe model of intracrustal origin of the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granites with heat provided by radioactivedecay in a thickened continental crust. However, theydid not rule out additional heat from mafic magmassupported by lithosperic thinnig of the thickenedorogenic root delaying thermal equilibration.
Our description thus shows that redwitzites arepresent in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge batholith areaand can be identified within the Western pluton of thisbatholith and thus offer an indication for the role ofmantle input in Variscan time to the granite sources.
The evidence is in favour of the idea that the LateVariscan mantle has triggered melting of the crust. Thescenario could be either the delamination of materialfrom the bottom of the crust and/or underplating/replacement of mantle lithosphere. However, the physi-cal involvement of mantle melts in the crust shouldassume to be rather small. At least there is no firmevidence for this in currently exposed crust documentedin different occurrences of Variscan granitoids in NWBohemian Massif.
The proof for mantle derivation of the basic mixingend member is, however, much more difficult to provide.There is no exact evidence whether the parental meltscame directly from the mantle. Instead they could havebeen added to the crust before and remelted to give riseto the basic precursor of the redwitzites. Sr and Ndisotope ratios measured in Bavarian redwitzites indicateheterogenous enriched mantle as a possible sourcematerial modified by a various degree of AFC processesand mixing with crustal derived magmas (Siebel et al.,2003). An argument that one of the mixing end-members was derived from the mantle can be Troll’sobservation that gabbroic rocks occur in the Mark-tredwitz area (Troll, 1968) and also our assumption ofthe gabbroic end member in our studies of the mixingseries at Abertamy.
Intrusion of mafic magma is often considered as thesource of heat in the origin of many granitic rocks(Bergantz, 1989) in general. This has been proposed alsofor the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge granite batholith
ARTICLE IN PRESSP. Kovarıkova et al. / Chemie der Erde 67 (2007) 151–174 171
(Kramer, 1976) also in connection with its ore-bearingpotential using the occurrence of coeval lamprophyresas the representatives of mafic rocks. However the smallvolumes of lamprophyres have led to the rejection ofthis concept (Forster et al., 1999) by the most recentresearcher in the area. Our evidence distinctly proves theexistence of the mantle input in the early stages of theVariscan granitoid magmatism in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge batholith area but the exact nature of thiscontribution remains still not fully clear.
The mafic magma in the early stages of Variscanmagmatism may have served not only as the heat carrierbut it interacted also with the crustal magmas. Thesechemical interactions are complex and involve assimila-tion and other processes such as magma mixing,fractional crystallization of mixed magmas and crystalaccumulation and can produce hybrid magmas oftypical redwitzites. This interaction is evidenced by theintrusions of redwitzite broadly synchronous with theearliest Variscan granites (Siebel et al., 2003) and this isshown also for the Abertamy redwitzite.
It is difficult to make solid estimates of the volumes ofmantle melts added to the crust during Late Variscantimes based on the exposed volume of redwitzite. Theredwitzites are so much modified by mixing/hybridiza-tion that the original amount of mantle material whichcould have been present in these rocks appears to bevery small. Gerdes et al. (2000) give the estimate for thecase of the large granitoid South Bohemian Batholiththat it is unlikely that the enriched mantle melts madeup more than 4% of the total melt budget.
15. Conclusions
The Abertamy mafic rocks enclosed in the earlybiotite granites of the Western pluton of the Krusnehory/Erzgebirge batholith are gabbronorites and gab-brodiorites and correspond to redwitzites defined fromthe NW margin of the Bohemian massif. They wereemplaced in the contact zone of the Nejdek-Eibenstockmassif as a tabular body not exceeding the thickness of1–2 km in which differentiation occurred predominantlyby fractional crystallization. The mafic body intrudedand crystallized before the intrusion of granites but inthe same magmatic period as the most primitivegranitoids as testified by numerous zircon age data inNE Bavaria (325Ma) and the dating on our samples.The mafic precursors are indication of the role of maficmagmas as heat suppliers to the Late Variscan granitemagmatism. This mafic magma mixed with graniticmagmas in the crust during the initial stage of Variscangranitic magmatism forming compositions from gab-brodiorites/gabbronorite to granodiorites in dependenceon the amount of acid component. The most probable
composition of the mafic end member as calculatedunder the assumption of the 15–25% admixture of acidend member (Abertamy granite) are olivine gabbrodior-ite or norite. This explanation is alternative to theopinion on the predominant role of thickened crustunaffected by the mantle in the origin of Late Variscangranites in the Krusne hory/Erzgebirge.
Acknowledgement
The study was funded by the grants 205/02/0458 and205/05/0156 of the Grant Agency of the Czech Republic.P. J. O’Brien is thanked for his constructive reviewwhich improved the quality of the paper. The help inmicroprobe studies by A. Langrova and J. Haloda isacknowledge with thanks.
References
Absolonova, E., Matoulek, M., 1972. Application of the
lithogeochemical research in the exploration for Sn-
deposits in the Karlovy Vary massif. Geol. Pruzk. 14,
259–262 (in Czech).
Absolonova, E., Matoulek, M., 1975. Geochemical distribu-
tion of the elements in the Karlovy Vary massif. Sbor.
Geol. Ved Loz. Geol. Miner. 17, 7–32 (in Czech).
Bankwitz, E., Bankwitz, P., 1994. Crustal structure of the
Erzgebirge. In: Seltmann, R., Kaempf, H., Moeller, P.
(Eds.), Metallogeny of Collisional Orogens. Czech Geolo-
gical Survey, Prague, pp. 20–34.
Barbarin, B., Didier, J., 1991. Macroscopic features of mafic
microgranular enclaves. In: Didier, J., Barbarin, B. (Eds.),
Enclaves and Granite Petrology. Elsevier, Amsterdam,