Top Banner

of 962

Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

Apr 07, 2018

Download

Documents

edgardo gil
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    1/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    2/960

    PEARL HARBORTHE SEEDS AND FRUITS OF INFAMY

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    3/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    4/960

    PEARL HARBORTHE SEEDS AND FRUITS OF INFAMY

    Percy L. Greaves, Jr.

    Bettina B. Greaves, ed.

    Foreword by John Chamberlain

    L MIMISES INS I U E

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    5/960

    ISBN: 978-1-933550-33-6

    Copyright 2010 by the Ludwig von Mises Institute and published underthe Creative Commons Attribution License 3.0. http://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by/3.0.

    For information write the Ludwig von Mises Institute, 518 West MagnoliaAvenue, Auburn, Alabama 36832. Mises.org.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    6/960

    Contents

    E P , B B G . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .A P , P L. G , J . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F , J C . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    PART I: THE SEEDS OF INFAMY 1 U.S. I P (19331940). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 F R E Y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .293 U.S. B S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 534 U.S. M P P . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 755 U D . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1116 Modus Vivendi Y N !. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1297 J A A I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1618 T C B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1799 M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 203

    10 S I K W . . . . . . . 22111 F I I J A . . . . . 2312 D 6, P 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .249

    13 D 6, P 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .26914 T M F D . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .28115 A R , P H ! T N D !. . . . . . . . . . . . . 311

    v

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    7/960

    vi Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    PART 2: THE FRUITS OF INFAMY

    16 T F R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34317 T P H Q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34718 T C - B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35919 T A I I . . . . . . . . .320 19421944 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40521 1944: A Y I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .417

    22 A P H B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .43723 T N C I ( J 24O 9, 1944) . . 48924 1944: A P Y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54525 A D S I

    C , C , H . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56326 S M I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60727 J C C I

    P H A (N 15, 1945M 31, 1946) P 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .613

    28 J C C I P H A (N 15, 1945

    M 31, 1946) P 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .66729 J C C I

    P H A (N 15, 1945M 31, 1946) P 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .727

    30 J C C I P H A (N 15, 1945

    M 31, 1946) R . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .82331 E . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 839

    A :Dramatis Personae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 863B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 877I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 887

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    8/960

    Editors Preface

    N . E , , , . H

    , , , A

    , . A P H

    U S W W II. I ,

    A -

    . T

    . A

    - J P H

    W ffi . M , P G ,

    D 7, 1941 ,

    vii

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    9/960

    viii Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    R N C

    1944 R -D U S J A 1940

    J SECRE SUPER-SECRE . T , ,

    J .

    A A 1945, C J C C

    C M S ff J C - ,

    . H RC

    W J P

    , , , ,

    . T . T M R H

    , A H E. K G W CS . A M R

    - W ffi .

    U C C , P H H ,

    . M . W

    . B , .

    A 13, 1984, .

    B , ff . W I

    , , ,

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    10/960

    Editors Preface ix

    , ffi

    . A P ,

    . I , I

    FDR ff

    J D 7, 1941, ,

    .H I . A I

    ; ; . H you . O ,

    . B .A I ,

    . T

    W . M ,

    . T , , I

    P H .

    A I P I , I

    . I . A

    , , .

    MRS . P ERCY L. (B ETTINA B.) G REAVES , JR. May 2007

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    11/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    12/960

    Authors Preface

    W P H . I - - . I . F

    I P H .A D 7, 1941, J U S U.S. F P H

    H I . H US , . N , S E H

    P S 1939. T , E A

    A P . T

    J H . H ,

    P H N A

    H E. K A G W C. S .

    , ; , , .

    xi

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    13/960

    xii Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    T I P H

    1944. T R P T E. D , P FR . S RN C I R D U.S.

    J W ffi , , J

    .D , A C S ff G

    C. M , . O J, ,

    P U . D . W R

    S H F M , D , , . T

    P H . A R R

    A , I P .

    1945 . O J 20, R . H , A 12. T . V P H

    ffi . T E G M 7. A P

    J A 14.

    . . . . . . . .

    R , ff , ff P

    ffi

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    14/960

    Authors Preface

    W . S

    . A ,

    . P P

    . F , C A J C C I P H A ( JCC)

    T D C , R . T D C Cff. T R

    ff. A I R N C

    1944 ,

    J C C . T JCC

    1946 .M P H

    C . F (19451946) I P H

    P H . F , I P I

    . T , H E B I

    ,

    H . O - I

    .H - -

    A . T

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    15/960

    xiv Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . A P H . T J 1941 ,

    . F , I

    J P H 1941, 11895 S -J W .

    E ; ,

    . L . H

    . A W II ,

    .

    P H , , , ff

    , . T

    . A , . T

    H , ff ,

    . H P H .

    Percy L. Greaves, Jr.Summer 1984

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    16/960

    Foreword

    O O 28, 1944, W , D.C., I , R , I D L ,1 , R .O 28 . S

    .A , ,

    ff , U S J P H . F , U

    ffi

    J U S . T

    , W P H J .

    R T E. D . B ,

    . I J

    1L Plain alk, - Te Freeman National Review.

    xv

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    17/960

    xvi Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    , D

    J U.S. .

    I Life , . B I I

    H L , Life , . H D . H

    ;

    R J A 14, 1945, L N Y D . A

    , I E R . H

    G , . W L S . B I

    F L ; I D .I S 1944, , , , C

    C , D A C G M . T D J . W

    A J T ,

    J . A D P H J . D I

    , I . M S 24, 1945, Life .L

    J C C I P H A ,

    T C N 15, 1945, M 31, 1946, . T

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    18/960

    Foreword xvii

    ,

    . I

    .I

    A D. K . A J N

    P H . H W

    , , J . H , . K 1944 N C I . B

    C C , , ,

    H . T C C

    NCI. . O E W

    , J

    W U.S. S D 1:00

    W S , D 7.A K NCI, E W

    R , , J U S . C 1:00 p.m.

    NCI , S, D 7,

    1:00 p.m. W H . H , C

    C . W

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    19/960

    xviii Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    C S H F M ,

    - . H . M ,

    .

    . . . . . . . .

    P G

    R , ff. H C . I

    Life , I . H - . O

    R C ,

    .

    P P H . H . H ,

    . T . I P P

    H .P

    A 1984. H , B B G , , . H

    , J

    , .

    John Chamberlain January 1991

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    20/960

    Acknowledgments

    A P , P H - (19451946) C J C

    I A P H . A C ff,

    C . A , H E B

    . W ,

    1960 , P H . H ,

    : A W S. A , G W. C , C D , G B F , A TL. H , A R E. I , C T K. KC R A. L , A A W. M CC C C. M , A B M , A J R. R , A F.W. R , C LF. S ff , V A J F. S , G A W , G C A. W . C S ff

    . P W S ff

    xix

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    21/960

    xx Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    N -

    J MAGIC . W B , P

    P H . H ,

    . O -

    .

    A I , P 1984. H . A , , I . I

    - -

    . I : R . B , N

    E W R A K , Lanakai , R

    S C - J , A

    K , C T K , .

    A , . SR , Te Freeman, . DB

    . J M KN J

    ffi W , E (E W R )

    J W ; J U.S. I

    ffi C

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    22/960

    Acknowledgments

    S ff

    A L B , , I

    P ,

    P H

    I I

    - .Bettina Bien Greaves, Editor

    (Mrs. Percy L. Greaves. Jr.)

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    23/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    24/960

    Part 1

    The Seeds of Infamy

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    25/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    26/960

    1.U.S. International Policy:

    19331940

    Franklin Delano Roosevelt Elected President

    M 4, 1933, ,

    W , . T

    P - R , P H

    , P A

    H . R ffi , , C

    U S . H C ffi R

    . T D P R

    1932

    . T , 1929

    3

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    27/960

    4 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    , R

    . C

    : T . R

    . H .

    F

    . A M 6, R I . H ,

    R. T L N

    K -B P . A H G ,

    V .O N 16, 1933, U S

    U S S R (U T

    .1 R

    W C. B U.S. U.B

    S .

    U.S.Far East Relations

    T A . J C , M . M J

    1F D. R ,Te Public Papers and Addresses of Franklin DelanoRoosevelt, . 1:Te Genesis of the New Deal, 19281932(N Y : RH , 1938), . 472.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    28/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 5

    M , J C

    C R C C J . A . H

    J

    1852 U.S. N C M C. P E ( ) B U S

    J . A

    , P J , L ,

    A C R . J C ( S -J W , 18941895) C - K J

    B R C (18991901) J B , F , RA , G P . J C J

    . H R ,

    P , T R -J W (1904) R

    M J . J M

    C , J , C K

    . J . J B U.S

    G W (19141918) WN C (N 12, 1921J 12, 1922)

    A . T N L N -F

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    29/960

    6 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    B -A -J 5:5:3 . I F E , O D ,

    C . A C

    . J

    . J - N L

    J U.S. E A (1924) A

    W O . M , J 1920 . H , , ff G D U. .

    T J M S 18, 1931, C . O J

    M T J M ,

    C M S1932, J , M .

    U.S. S S S J M

    , O D , N . S

    J MP H ;

    A F E . I

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    30/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 7

    A .2 T L N -

    M J . J B L

    H , 1933 J L .

    A 1925 S Y - , S C R , C

    . C . T , , , C . T

    C , C R . W C J , J

    S IS ( J 28M 4, 1932). M . U.

    C ; J . A , J

    , . A C K -

    M , J 5,000 . T R

    C C C . F , M -

    C R A CS C J , C . T K -C ( J 1937)

    J P N

    P . B .

    2 Henry L. Stimson and McGeorge Bundy, On Active Service in Peace and War (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1947/1948), p. 233.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    31/960

    8 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    Official U.S. Foreign Policy

    D 1930 , U.S. . C 1935

    . A FDR (S.J. R

    173) A 31, 1935, G

    U S . T , , . EU.S. R : T G

    .3

    I FDR , ,

    T Offi N I (ONI) N ,

    J . F , ONI J

    N Y

    .4 I A 10, 1936, - C N O A W D. L

    FDR . H J

    .5

    FDR , , F 1935, N A ,

    3R ,Te Public Papers and Addresses, 1935 , . 4, . 34546.4 Jeffrey M. Dorwart, Con ict of Duty: The U.S. Navys Intelligence Dilemma,19191945 (Annapolis, Md.: Naval Institute Press, 1983), p. 65.5R , A 10, 1936 C N OA W D. L . Q D ,Conict of Duty, . 65.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    32/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 9

    P H , A

    .6 H - C , N Y

    A 10 U.S. J :

    I . I . I . I -

    . I . . I

    -

    . I . I . . . .

    I I N ; . I U

    S . . . .

    I ff A , ,

    [ ] ffi P S S .7

    D , G J

    , S U . B G J [U.S.S.R.-

    C I , C , S

    T C - ,

    6Charles A. Beard, American Foreign Policy in the Making, 19321940 (NewHaven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1946), pp. 15675.7R ,Te Public Papers and Addresses, 1936, .5, pp. 28990.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    33/960

    10 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    .8 S G J

    C . O N 15, 1936, G -J A -C P .

    Prospects for Peace in the Far East?

    T J C J1937. P K . K

    U S . B F E .

    I 1937, U.S.S.R. N C ff

    SU .9 N , C

    J . O J 7, 1937, J

    M P B C . T C , J. J

    . T

    J . H , J . T U.S.

    F , C , J S S -J . R C

    R J R ,

    C . . . 150,000,000 C

    8U.S. H C F Aff . Events Leading up to World War II:Chronological History of Certain Major International Events Leading up to and During World War II with the Ostensible Reasons Advanced for their Occurrence,19311944, 78 C ., 2 ., 1944,p. 109.9 Charles Callan Tansill, Back Door to War: The Roosevelt Foreign Policy,19331941 (Chicago: Henry Regnery, 1952), p. 456.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    34/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 11

    C

    .10U.S. A J J C. G H

    ffi J G A

    [M P B ] . G

    C J 11

    S -J . C , E J . T

    J -C . B

    C P .

    T J C US C . T N A

    U.S. U.S. . O S 14, A , FDR

    U.S. - C J , J

    U.S. C . T , U.S. B ,

    C I C O 5, 1937, P R :

    T , , 90

    10D S ,Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers,Te Far East, 1938 (W , D.C.: G P Offi ), . 3,

    . 136, 165,et passim.11 Tansill, Back Door to War, p. 460.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    35/960

    12 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    10 ,

    . . . . I .

    W ,

    . . . . W ,

    . I

    . W , .12

    R J , S D

    J C ;

    S F E G U S C J G

    ff ff ,

    F E . . .I F E , G U S

    J C

    . [T N P F 6, 1922, K -B P A 27, 1928]13

    12D S ,Peace and War: United States Foreign Policy, 19311941(W , D.C.: U.S. G P Offi ), . 38387.13I ., . 38788.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    36/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 13

    O D 12, U S

    J U.S.S. Panay, U.S. , S O C Y R .

    A . H , U A

    F E . T , J ffi , , .

    S C , . I D1937, J N , . O 50,000 C ,

    , 200,000 300,000 J .

    Anticipating War in the Pacific

    I D FDR A R E. I U.S. W P D , L

    ffi B A . AI ,

    U S J P ,

    B , D , R , C T L U.S.-B

    , , , , . T

    J 1938. N .14

    1479 C ., 1 . J (C ) C I P H A .Pearl Harbor Attack,39 . (W , D.C.:

    U.S. G P Offi , 1946),part 9, pp. 427277. Ingersoll testi-mony. After the war started in Europe, the 1938 London document becamea dead cat, as Ingersoll expressed it (p. 4273), because Germany was in thewar. The London conclusions were superseded by the ABC-1 plan for militaryU.S. cooperation with the British, the plan which was developed in Wash-ington in 1941.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    37/960

    14 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    O N 3, 1938, J N O

    C , - J , M [ J J -

    M ] C .15 P M P K C K -

    C . K J

    , C

    F E . H , K : T J

    . W C F E . A , : J

    .16 K J

    C C C .

    J M E I , H K , .

    U S I . A J U S M

    D W H J A 17 A J F M Y M (1941) J : A

    15D S ,Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States: Japan, 19311941(W , D.C.: U.S. G POffi , 1943), . 1, . 478.16I ., . 480.17 J ,Te Rising Sun: Te Decline and Fall of the Japanese Empire,19361945 (N Y : R H , 1970), . 56.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    38/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 15

    C C .18 I U S , J N O A C . I J

    F M (N 7, 1938), A G J . H

    U.S. Y R ,

    (N 21) C A A

    .19 T J C . T H

    C . T C ffi

    . A , C C . B J , , 1939, . T ,

    W , A .20 I 19371938, C B R

    . T BR D 2, 1938. W R , B B , L

    B R K C YP , C .

    A A , 1938, FDR

    N A . H F E

    18I ., . 48.19D S , Japan, 19311941, . 807.20 ,Te Rising Sun, . 54.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    39/960

    16 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    J . A A

    S . O C

    . S J 4, 1939, C A : [O]

    .21 C

    , M 20 S R

    . FDR . H .B P M N C

    F E ff U.S. ffi . C J

    C . H C

    ff , J

    C

    . . . H M G

    - J .

    C B B C . . . 22

    T U S J . A

    ff 1911. U, ,

    . I , H J

    21D S ,Peace and War, . 49.22 U.S. Congress, Events, pp. 19899.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    40/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 17

    J 26, 1939 . T

    J . A 23

    War Breaks Out in Europe

    O S 1, 1939, G P . B F G

    , P . B F

    G . W W II .A , FDR

    . H S 3 : T N

    .24 S 5, P R ffi ,

    . I U S

    .25 O S 11, , FDR

    G B . T WC , P M C

    F L A , C W W I. (C

    M 1, 1940.) R , A S N W W I, E

    B C .

    23 Department of State, Japan, 19311941, p. 189.24 Department of State, Peace and War, p. 485.25U.S. C , Events, . 215.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    41/960

    18 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    FDR C : I

    I A .:

    W I P M I

    . Y [ ]

    .26

    T

    U S .

    U.S. Neutrality Patrol in the Atlantic

    O S 6, R N N P A 200 3

    ff , U.S. :

    T , . I

    , .27

    A S 8, .28

    D N , FDR O 9, 1939,

    U.S. N D : W

    26F L. L , H D. L , M J ,

    Roosevelt and Churchill: Teir Secret Wartime Correspondence (N Y : E.P.D , 1975), . 89.27P A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy: Te Private War of the Atlantic Fleet,1939-1942 (A , M .: N I P , 1975), . 65.28U.S. C , Events, . 216.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    42/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 19

    ,

    D . T E ,

    P E - . T , FDR ,

    . . . . PN C G

    E[L] S FDR.29

    M A , , E . 19141918 W W . S U S

    E F G .

    , . A New York Herald ribune F O

    26, :

    I C -

    A

    E . T , I . I

    . T W

    S , , , ,

    29A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy,. 68.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    43/960

    20 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    A E . T

    I 30

    F N , G C A H P G B F

    , R N . C

    ,

    N A 1939

    , , , U.S. .31

    O N P U.S. uscaloosa, A ,

    G Columbus.Columbus, C E , V C , M . H

    GH , B . H D13 , ,

    . AColumbus ,uscaloosa -

    . I FDR , E G B Hyperion -

    . S Columbus D 19, 425 ff C M , N J , . T G

    . .uscaloosa

    30F D R ,Public Papers, 1939.P F D. R ,Quotations from Franklin Delano Roosevelt (R -

    N C , 1940), . 37.31 U.S. Congress, Events , p. 223.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    44/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 21

    555 G

    .32 A ,

    . A H R. S , U.S. C H A. B uscaloosa

    G , ,

    C B B

    . S : W . . . 33 N , ,

    ; , P

    U.S. .

    FDR C J 3, 1940. T US . T

    U S .34 T , N A J.O. R

    - - U.S. F (CINCUS), A C C. B . R N

    - F . C J

    1940.35

    32Abbazia, Mr. Roosevelts Navy, p. 74.33 Ibid.34 Department of State, Peace and War, p. 511.35The New York Times , January 7, 1940.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    45/960

    22 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    U. S. Relations with Japan

    T J 1911 J

    1940. W , U.S.-J . T J

    U.S. ffi , , . B

    ff , , T C J .

    J G EC - N O N . O F 1 J

    ff . J , , ,

    J .

    British Military Procurement and Politics

    1940 . FDR .

    F FDR ffi ,

    H J. M , J . M J -H , E

    U S G .36 M

    36 As nancial editor from 19341935 of the United States News (predecessorto U.S. News & World Report ), I covered Morgenthau at the Treasury Depart-ment and came to know him well. Morgenthau was a good friend, con dant,and great admirer of FDRs. He could walk unobserved through an under-ground passageway that connected the Treasury to the White House, and heoften did so, to report to FDR or to assume con dential assignments. Morgen-thau had a residence in New York State, not far from FDRs Hyde Park home.He was undoubtedly closer to FDR personally than any other member of thecabinet and didnt hesitate at times to try to in uence him.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    46/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 23

    R S

    A 1940, A -F PM , B F

    . H A N A ,

    , E F . I [M ]

    . H

    ff A 37

    B F .38

    A U S ffi G G B , M

    FDR , U.S. ,

    , S W H H W , 1936, C G A A C

    H H (H ) A . M .39 A W H M

    12, 1940, [ A -F P M ] . . .

    40 WD . R M ,

    W D . . . . U ffi G . . . . W , [FDR ] A

    37 John Morton Blum, From the Morgenthau Diaries: Years of Urgency, 19381941 (Boston: Houghton Mif in, 1965), p. 109.

    38 Ibid., p. 113.39 Ibid., p. 117.40I ., . 118.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    47/960

    24 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    ,

    T : A H . M

    ff , O , G A 41

    A W H FDR B F . H

    U.S. . T N D . T

    1938 ffi T FDR U.S. E

    . T M ,

    D P . SM , A .42

    I M , FDR C 50,000 .43 H . O C .44 T

    FDR . T 50

    . FDR 50,000

    O A 17, 1940, S S C H

    J U.S. I

    41 Ibid., pp. 11718.42 This description of the March 12, 1940, White House meeting is based onBlum, From the Morgenthau Diaries , pp.10918. Morgenthau quote appearson p. 118.43R C , M 16, 1940.See U.S. C , Events,

    . 239 (M 16, 1940 ). S H. D H , North American Supply(L : H M S Offi ; L , G , 1955), . 127(the of cial British history of World War II).44 Ibid., p.127.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    48/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 25

    ff N I

    .45 B

    S . FDR A

    B F . S R

    U S ,

    . T

    S . T AF C - C

    A A A 46

    T M B .

    European War Impacts Asian Situation

    A , B B E G

    L , B G A

    . H S ff F E . S

    J B R , . T , C N A

    J 18, 194

    O 18, 1940.

    45 Department of State, Peace and War, pp. 51516.46 Hall, North American Supply, p. 92.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    49/960

    26 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    U F J 1940 N ,

    J V F F

    I C . T V ,

    S 23. T J F I

    J .

    J A P S 27, 1940, P G I

    . G J U.S. ff .

    T B J

    . T J I J ,

    , . B U S B

    J CB J 1941 C , , C B B

    H K .47 T U.S. $100 C D 1940 -

    . B 5 C C S

    F C 3 .48

    47S. W K , M -G ,Te War Against Japan: Te Loss of Singa- pore (L : H M S Offi , 1957), . 1, . 53.48I ., . 58.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    50/960

    U.S. International Policy: 19331940 27

    U.S. Fleet Stationed in Pearl Harbor

    O A 2, 1940, U.S. F H . S

    M , N U.S. . T M4, C - -C U.S. FA R , C

    O S :I LOOKS PROBABLE BU NO FINAL HA HE

    FLEE WILL REMAIN IN HAWAIIAN WA ERS FOR SHOR IME AF ER MAY 9 H. 49

    T M 7, S R W :

    I HAVE REQUES ED PERMISSION O REMAININ HAWAIIAN WA ERS O ACCOMPLISH SOME HINGS I WAN ED O DO WHILE HERE. HEDEPAR MEN HAS APPROVED HIS REQUES .

    R

    . A

    .R . A

    F F P , .50 F ,

    ffi H , , ,

    . 49 James O. Richardson, On theTreadmill to Pearl Harbor (Washington, D.C.:Naval History Division, Department of the Navy, 1973), p. 308.50I ., . 309.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    51/960

    28 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    R N D - - U S F ,

    , , ,

    .51 H W

    E :PRESEN INDICA IONS ARE HA FLEE WILL

    REMAIN HAWAIIAN WA ERS FOR SOME IME. 52

    R H . H W

    .

    51I .52I ., . 311. T :

    FROM: OPNAV [Offi , C N O ]

    O: CINCUS [C - -C , U.S. F ]

    SOME BRI ISH AU HORI IES FEEL HA I ALY MAY JOINGERMANY IN AC IVE PAR ICIPA ION IN IMMEDIA EFU URE HIS FEELING IS NO SHARED BY O HER CLOSE OBSERVERS X OUR S A E DEPAR MEN INCLINED O DISAGREE REGARDING DU CH EAS INDIES JAPANHAS MADE WO S A EMEN S WHICH IF AKEN A HEIR FACE VALUE S A E HEY WISH S A US QUO PRESERVED GREA BRI AIN HAS S A ED SHE HAS NO IN EN IONOF IN ERFERING WI H S A US QUO AND HERE IS ANUNCONFIRMED REPOR HA HE FRENCH FOREIGNOFFICE HAS ISSUED A SIMILAR S A EMEN PRESENINDICA IONS ARE HA FLEE WILL REMAIN HAWAIIAN WA ERS FOR SOME IME HOPE O ADVISE YOU MOREDEFINI ELY NEX WEEK

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    52/960

    2.Foreign Relations

    in an Election Year

    U.S.-British Cooperation

    O M 10, 1940, W C

    E . H R M 15: A ffi , I

    , .1 T

    B F P S 1939. A , R

    W H ,2 , ffi ,

    C , . T , ,

    1 F L. L , H D. L , M J , Roosevelt and Churchill: Teir Secret Wartime Correspondence (N Y : E.P.D , 1975), . 94.2 R . L , T W H C MU.S. Naval Proceedings, D 1969, . 63.

    29

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    53/960

    30 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    C M 15 U S

    :I , M . P U S

    . . . . A I , -

    .

    C B :[F] , . . . S ,

    . . . . T , - . . F . . . U S .

    C : W

    , I , ff C U.S.

    , G .

    T C : S , I J P , S

    S A ] .3

    R C . . . . I ,

    . T C

    . W , FDR

    C . A , [ ]

    3L , ., .,Roosevelt and Churchill , . 9495.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    54/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 31

    G

    S . C - A ,

    . FDR U.S. I .

    U S J , A , A

    H , 4C M 15, B . G- ff L H , 15

    , 15 A R , H

    OPNAV (C N O ) H

    5 ( . 2728). I , OPNAV ,

    C .

    he European Situation Worsensas France Falls

    W C. B , FDR U.S.S.R. 1933 U S M 1936 U.S. F .

    B 1940, B N .

    D E C . E ,

    B 84I ., . 9596.5J O. R ,On the readmill to Pearl Harbor (W , D.C.:N H D , D N , 1973), . 311.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    55/960

    32 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    , ( , , ). T , 200,000 B , F , B G (M 26J 4).

    B J , G B PR F R J 10: F 6 6 . . . .

    P .6 B R (M 31, 1940) F

    F M P R F

    P W ,

    F B E F E . W

    .

    R U.S. A F M . B ,

    [A ] , , M U.S. F PI , FDR R ,

    M.7 R , J 13,

    R : [ ] G A G

    so urgently require, and our efforts to do still more are beingredoubled. 8

    6D S ,Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers,1940 (W , D.C.: U.S. G P Offi ), . 1, . 245.7 Te New York imes, A 26, 1970, . 3031.8D S ,Diplomatic Papers, 1940 , . 248.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    56/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 33

    W C ,

    R , J 14,

    9 TR

    .A K L :

    M R -. . . . I G

    A . . . . T C .10

    G P J 14, 1940. O J 17 F . F G

    . F .

    FDR Moves toward a hird erm as President

    S F 1940, FDR , G W

    U.S. . H , J .B , , FDR

    . H ffi -

    . R 9J P. L ,Roosevelt and Churchill, 19391941: Te Partnership Tat Saved the West (N Y : W. W. N , 1976), .185.10D S ,Diplomatic Papers, 1940 , . 250.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    57/960

    34 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    S W W N S

    C E ,11 FDR E 50 12 ff

    R A M. L F K 1936 R

    L ff , M . K , N .R R

    . H HS . A H S S 1920 , S U S

    A . H , Y U

    , U S - J G

    T , J 18, Te New York imes.FDR ff - .13 W S

    imes,FDR , S , . T

    S . H S W J 10, 1940.

    T ffi U ; N ffi

    J 1, 1940, R E

    11P -W W II , D D

    N , 12J F , Jim Farleys Story(I C .: R S C ., 1948),

    . 24143.13H L. S M G B ,On Active Service in Peace and War (N Y : H & B , 1947/8), . 324.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    58/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 35

    W

    R .S , ,

    . H ff . T S S A 1940

    , S14

    British Secret Agent in the U.S.

    B 1940 E G E ;

    B ; U- B A

    .I J B N Y S W S

    ffi N Y R C . O - , S B

    I , C S C . I U S . FDR S

    , , I .15

    S R W . S U.S.-B

    F BI (FBI). I , -

    W U S

    E G J .

    14I ., . 34548.15 W S , A Man Called Intrepid: Te Secret War (N Y :H B J , 1976), . 127.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    59/960

    36 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    U.S. Encourages British Military Purchases

    B F 1939 N A U.S.

    . T

    D FDR N D . B F , B

    , . R ,

    . H B .

    O J 3 L L , B US , S D

    . B T U K ,

    . . . M G ]

    . . . . T . T US A L .

    R , B -

    . T B W ffi L

    .16

    A U.S. S M ,

    [ B ]

    16H. D H , North American Supply(L : H M S Offi ; L , G , 1955), . 243.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    60/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 37

    .17 M B

    . I -J B , S F P , W

    . T B M [ ] B . . . E

    .18 O J 24, M A P ,

    A -F P M , . Y B 3,000

    ; [W S.] K [ C N D ], . . . . D

    . . . . [Y] . . . . Y ff; 3,000 K

    ff

    . . . K 3,000 I .As he recalled later, The tactic worked. 19

    O J 25, M B

    : . B

    U S ; , , . . . . T [B ]

    . . . . I U S G ;

    U S .20

    17J M B ,From the Morgenthau Diaries: Years of Urgency, 1938 1941 (B : H M ffl , 1965), . 171.

    18I ., .170.19I ., .175.20H , North American Supply, . 25152.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    61/960

    38 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    Y M ,

    [ ] , , B .

    P , B ffi W E , M

    B . T ff , M

    A E . A , B ,

    A .21

    1940 U S . T B N

    .22 M , B

    N , P J . T

    .23 B B

    L U S , B ffi

    U.S. . I B U S U

    A B ,

    . T [ A A

    B

    21B ,From the Morgenthau Diaries, . 17071.22H , North American Supply, . 252.23I ., .250.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    62/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 39

    .24 S U S ff

    B, ,

    U S , ff B - A

    Secret U.S.-British Staff Conversations

    A B , L L A 6 FDR L ff

    U.S. ffi , N , AA F A C N O , R AR L. G ; C A W P DM G G V. S ; C G

    GHQ A F , M G D C. E . T

    .O

    U S

    B G .25 B - B ,

    . T B . L L

    .26

    24R.S. S ,Financial Policy, 19391945 (L : H M S Offi , 1956), . 369.25M S W ,Te War Department: Chief of Staff: Prewar Plans and Preparations(W , D.C.: D A , H D

    , 1950), . 115.26I ., . 118.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    63/960

    40 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    rade reaty with Japan Ended

    A U S J J 26, 1940, R , J 5, 1941

    , , J . T J 31,

    . F , U.S.-J

    T , E E , 1940. O J , J C. G , FDR

    J U S ,

    , , J . J .

    , .

    Japanese Diplomatic Code Broken

    I A U.S. A N J . J

    ,

    . W ,

    . E

    J

    J . A

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    64/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 41

    . I N

    C L.F. S ff A S C , , .27

    A J , J

    . W J P

    MAGIC.

    Destroyers-for-Bases Deal

    T C M 15

    27C S ff , -P H ,

    J . , P 1940,

    , -P H .A D K (Te Codebreakers: Te Story of Secret Writing ,

    L : W & N , 1967, . 10, 388, 50304):

    C L F. S ff . . . N -- . . . . O

    M -P S D - N A ,

    B A U- . . . . H [S ff OP-20-G ,

    E H , N ,

    . . . . [H] N . . . . T C L F. S ff

    OP-20-G N -, U S ,

    A - - U- .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    65/960

    42 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    FDR

    C H , C N O S

    .S , - ffi . H

    , ff . H A 1903

    H R 1913, FDR

    N P W W . S FDR M

    C , C M . T

    .R S

    . I 1939, FDR C N OFDR S

    C.N.O. . . . [Y] I . M

    A I !28

    Stark took over as CNO on August 1, 1939.29

    W U.S. B , S . A N

    C N O

    S ;

    28F D R ,F.D.R.: His Personal Letters, 19281945 (N Y : D , S P , 1950), . 2, . 864.29J A. F , Administration of the Navy Department in World War II (W -

    , D.C.: U.S. G P Offi , 1949), . 46 .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    66/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 43

    A P .30 I , S

    FDR . A , . FDR

    C B

    S .S FDR . T , A

    B M , B Y D ,

    ffi , ffi . H S

    . S M . T U S - E . S

    , FDR , 31

    T 50 U.S. 99- G B (NB , B , C ( J , S . L , A ), B G .32 S

    . . . U S ,

    30P A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy: Te Private War of the Atlantic Fleet,1939-1942 (A , M .: N I P , 1975), . 9295.31 T - FDR

    . S P H ( , D 10, 1962). T

    D 1941. M , B Y D , . W

    , S . M

    , J . A ( Administration of the Navy Department in World War II , . 426)

    32W K ,Battle Report: Te Atlantic War (N Y : F & R ,1943), . 25.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    67/960

    44 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . W

    ; .33 T S 3 R . T , ,

    H MG U K

    U S U S ff

    A W H . . . U S

    C B G .34

    T U.S. , , B H S

    9. L . T N S

    A B

    T N A B . T

    N 26.35

    33I ., . 15.3454 S P . 2, 2405, U.S. H C F Aff Events Leading up to World War II: Chronological History of Certain Major International Events Leading up to and During World War II with the Ostensible Reasons Advanced for their Occurrence, 19311944,78 C ., 2 ., 1944,

    . 255; U.S. D N , N H D , Offi C N O ,United States Naval Chronology, World War II (W -

    , D.C.: G P Offi , 1955), . 5. S D S ,Peace and War: United States Foreign Policy, 19311941(W ,

    D.C.: U.S. G P Offi , 1943), . 56465.35A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 98102.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    68/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 45

    O N 1 A S

    U.S. N P P F A F .

    Retaining the Fleet at Pearl Harbor

    T U.S. F , A1940, , M H T - - , A R ,

    , . T H J R W

    F P H . H

    , , ff

    .R P H

    ffi . H , , , . H

    B

    P H . I ,

    , .36 R ,

    (H ) N (K ), C N O (SC B N (C W. N ),A C S ff (G C. M ),

    , C . H H

    36R ,On the readmill , . 30718, 38395.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    69/960

    46 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . H S - S D , S H ,

    F I .37

    R W O , S N , W ,

    P . T B B R C . R J

    I J , , ff J A ,

    H

    R K . T S , , K ,

    R ; ff ,

    .38

    R . W FDR , . R

    . R

    FDR 39

    3779 C ., 1 . J (C ) C I P H A .Pearl Harbor Attack,39 . (W , D.C.:

    U.S. G P Offi , 1946), 1, . 297.38R ,On the readmill , . 399400.39I ., . 434.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    70/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 47

    R

    H , P . T

    H J . A R

    ff , J U.S. F H

    . H , : D

    , I H, , J .40

    R

    . H J T , K P

    [ A S ], D E I

    , P ,

    .41

    T [ ] R ,

    [I] - , - ,

    . I 1940 P E ,

    N , ,

    40I ., . 425, 427.41I ., . 427; R J CC 1945, .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    71/960

    48 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    , -

    . . . .F ,

    [ F ], I [R ]

    : M . P , I I ffi N

    P . T , , J ,

    , , .42

    Financing of British Arms Purchases Assured

    T B . T B

    . T L .43 I ffi . E

    B L A ,

    A R . . . . H -O B A . H

    .44

    O O 14 L L , B , R M B

    P

    42I ., . 43435.43H , North American Supply, . 253.44I ., . 249.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    72/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 49

    . L

    .45 S E .

    T [ B ] , ,

    . T A L , [U.S.]

    A .46

    T B U S .

    B , ffi

    . O 20 O P [B

    W ] - SM

    9,000 . I P [S W ] L

    R F C

    . A ff WD . T - D .47

    FDR Winds Up His Election Campaign

    A , R

    S . F , C S

    45I ., . 250.46I ., . 253.47I ., . 254.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    73/960

    50 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    I , . I -

    I . I , , , [D P

    , C . I :

    W , A ,

    A , .48

    W R B ff U.S. G

    A . O O 23, P :49

    R D , , I : Y S

    S .

    W .

    W . I I

    P P . . . .

    I I : I .

    48F D R ,Te Public Papers and Addresses of Franklin DelanoRoosevelt, . 1:Te Genesis of the New Deal, 19281932(N Y : RH , 1940), . 313; C A. B , American Foreign Policy in the Making:19321940 (N H , C .: Y U P , 1946), . 31314.49R ,Public Papers, 1940, . 488ff. P F DR ,Quotations from Franklin Delano Roosevelt, July 1940August 1,1944 , R N C , S 1944, . 50. S B American Foreign Policy in the Making , . 31415.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    74/960

    Foreign Relations in an Election Year 51

    T O 30, FDR

    B :50

    A I , I .

    I , I :

    Y .

    T ,

    .

    T .

    R S, N 2, B ff , N Y , S ,

    N 3, C , O . I B ff , , Y .51 A

    , N 3, C:52

    T

    . . . . A [ ] ;

    A .

    50R ,Public Papers, 19281932, . 517; B , American Foreign Policyin the Making, . 316.51R ,Public Papers, 19281932, . 543ff.; B , American ForeignPolicy in the Making, . 317.52R ,Public Papers, 19281932, . 546ff.; B , American ForeignPolicy in the Making, . 318.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    75/960

    52 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . F , FDR

    B U.S. G . A

    A U S

    . T

    . S A B , - R ,

    . R W H B

    1940 . T A . . . . T -

    , B ,

    .53

    53 W C. B , H W W W L P , 2 Life (A 30, 1948), . 8397; (S 6, 1948), . 86103.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    76/960

    3.U.S. Ties to Britain

    Strengthened

    FDRs Re-election a Victory for Britain

    O N 5, 1940, P R

    , R W WH , 19 R A L . W

    FDR E . J - B P A P

    E . R B C -

    , FDR A ; .1

    1H. D H , North American Supply(L : H M S Offi ; L , G , 1955), . 25657.

    53

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    77/960

    54 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    O N 8 SSCity of Rayville U.S.

    W W II.2 I G A B S . F

    .M , U.S.

    O N 4 C N O S

    N . I ,

    N 12, S (A) A [ ] (B) J ,

    A ; (C) ; (D) ff A

    [ ] P .

    Stark then argued for his fourth plan, Plan D or Plan Dog as itwas known in service lingo. 3

    U.S. Aid to the British

    [A ] U S [S ] U S

    A N ff

    B L , C W . . . B D S B ,

    ff U S .4

    2U.S. D N , N H D , Offi CN O ,United States Naval Chronology, World War II (W ,D.C.: G P Offi , 1955), . 6.3M S W ,Te War Department: Chief of Staff: Prewar Plans and Preparations(W , D.C.: D A , H D

    , 1950), . 119.4I .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    78/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 55

    B A L L

    O U S E

    O W N 23, . W , , , B ;

    .5 FDR, M , C .6 I , L

    L L

    A . . . . . .

    . . . . I

    , . I

    .7

    A , S W L , - B ,

    S M I O O . T B $2,062

    $699 C I N P C .8 M

    FDR . R ,

    , B.

    5F L. L , H D. L , M J , .Roosevelt and Churchill: Teir Secret Wartime Correspondence (N Y : E.P. D ,

    1975), . 125 .6 J P. L ,Roosevelt and Churchill, 19391941: Te Partnership Tat Saved the West (N Y : W. W. N , 1976), . 261.7H , North American Supply, . 258.8I ., . 259.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    79/960

    56 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    R uscaloosa - .9 W , 4,000- C A A

    2,000 , , . C

    G B . T

    .10 T FDR.

    S , B I , U.S.-B 1940 -

    .11 I , U S B

    , U.S. N A R

    U S

    .

    Lend-Lease for Peace

    I B - - . FDR

    E . F , - . O

    - -B I , :

    9L ,Roosevelt and Churchill, 19391941, . 26162.10L , .,Roosevelt and Churchill: Teir Secret Wartime Correspon-dence , . 125.11W S , A Man Called Intrepid: Te Secret War (N Y :H B J , 1976), . 155.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    80/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 57

    [I] . . . I

    , I , I . H C I

    B 12

    T - B U.S. .

    A FDR , G U.S. U K

    .13

    D D 29 , R H :

    T N G

    E , E

    T U S , :

    T A EF . T

    G . Y ,, E

    . O . I

    . . . . W . F

    12 W C. B , H W W W L P . 2 Life (A 30, 1948), . 8397; (S 6, 1948), . 86103. S L ,Roosevelt and Churchill, 19391941, . 263.13U.S. H C F Aff . Events Leading up to World War II: Chronological History of Certain Major International Events Leading up toand During World War II with the Ostensible Reasons Advanced for their Occur-rence, 19311944,78 C ., 2 ., 1944, . 1, 5.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    81/960

    58 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . W

    , , , .14

    FDR - C 1941. A New York imes A K

    ,

    C , E , U S , , ,

    W W II.

    F K , .

    [I]

    C P J ; L -L A U S

    EO .15

    M - , B A16 T

    H F 8, S M 8 M 11, 1941.

    14D S ,Peace and War: United States Foreign Policy, 19311941 (W , D.C.: U.S. G P Offi , 1943), . 599607.15A K ,Te Consent of the Governed, and Other Deceits(B : L ,B , 1971), . 40.16J M B ,From the Morgenthau Diaries: Years of Urgency, 1938 1941 (B : H M ffl , 1965), . 221ff.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    82/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 59

    Meanwhile in the Far East

    T U S $100 C - - .17 T ,

    J 1941, B C , , C

    B B H K .18 M , U.S.A A C C C C

    F B J , FDR . O A 15, 1941,

    R ffi A A C , N

    M A C AV G . S U.S. J

    C , ffi . TC A M C C

    A ,

    C .19

    A B D

    F E , J T , ,

    17S. W K ,Te War Againt Japan, . 1:Te Loss of Singapore (L : H M S Offi , 1957), . 38.18I ., . 5354.19J , Infamy: Pearl Harbor and Its Aftermath(G C , N.Y.:D , 1982). (1983 B P , N Y , P A 21, 1982, . 127 .)

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    83/960

    60 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    C .20 O A 13,

    1941, J R .21

    U.S. War Planning with Britain

    S U.S.-B ff , W J 29 M 27, 1941,

    . (A ffi B L J 1938, E

    , A 1940, E G .) T B ffi

    T ABC (AB -C ) ,

    A P M C . T ,

    M 22

    20 T J

    : M S U , ;

    N E I , U

    S ; I -C , , , S

    M , US B

    . (K ,Te War Against Japan, . 59)

    21I ., . 61.2279 C ., 1 . J (C ) C I

    P H A .Pearl Harbor Attack,39 . (W , D.C.:

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    84/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 61

    T W , ABC-1,

    L (1938) U S . I I J

    , M F E . T U S

    F E , US P F ff

    J , M 23 J M . A , U A M

    B C F E .24

    A R K , N

    , . A,

    U.S. G P Offi , 1946), 15, . 1488. S 15, 149192:

    I : I J ,

    M F E . T U S M F U S P F ff

    J , M J

    M . T U S A M

    B C F E .

    23 T M , I , ff A , NB , J , S , S M P . S C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 6, . 2864.24 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 15, . 1485550.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    85/960

    62 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    - , , , ,

    BC U S . O

    B , WPL-46 [U.S. N ] A

    J B , S W N P . T N

    M 1941, A

    A .25

    ,

    T ff P G , .

    N D , J G ,

    , US , , ff G

    U K E .26

    T ffi U.S.-B E G .

    I N A ffi U S

    G .

    25J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 26, . 264; H I ; 15, . 1485. P U S -BS ff C R : S N K 28, 1941, S W S J 2, 1941.26 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 26, . 26465;

    H I .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    86/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 63

    he Undeclared Battle of the Atlantic

    T G D A 91940. E U S

    G , D A A 9, 1941 US D , G

    -A

    A C .27

    FDR C A 11 U S

    B A . ,

    W

    . . . . W

    [ ] .28

    T , U.S. G W W II,

    . T U.S. Niblack H I ,

    I , G . SOS D

    G . Niblack . W

    Niblack , 29 T

    .

    27D S ,Peace and War, . 642; U.S. C , Events, . 277.28L , .,Roosevelt and Churchill: Teir Secret Wartime Correspon-dence , . 137.29P A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy: Te Private War of the Atlantic Fleet,19391942 (A , M .: N I P , 1975), . 19196.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    87/960

    64 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    O A , A H

    U S . O A

    . T - - , AE R , S . H R M 22,

    W . E A . . . . W

    only if US ships re the rst shot .30

    I A , R A 200 300 ,

    G 26 , ,31 20

    .32 T A B A . A

    A F P F , P H A .

    B M , U.S. N B

    - . O M 26 , L B. S , U.S.- PBY (CP B ) A , 690 B (F ), Bismarck, G .A , Bismarck

    B B Hood. W ,

    A PBY U.S. , B , . TBismarck

    , . S

    30I ., . 164, 176.31I ., . 154.32D N ,United States Naval Chronology, World War II , . 26.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    88/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 65

    M 27, ; 2,0

    ffi .33 T U.S. G

    , Robin Moor, S A M 21. N B J 11. R B , B ffi W , P , H H ,

    U.S. , FDR 34O J 6 R

    .35 G , I , D

    M 30 .

    T J 14 R A US . U S

    G I ff J 10,

    .36

    FDR N A . I , B

    G R J 21, 1941, FDR

    S U R S -

    , R B G . A

    33A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 18489.34L. L S. E G ,Te Undeclared War (L : R I -

    I Aff , 1953), . 51920.35D N ,United States Naval Chronology, World War II , . 9. S

    U.S. C , Events, . 283.36I . . 284.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    89/960

    66 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    U S S

    C . B

    U.S. J , S

    A , R U S

    O J 1 R

    I , I

    I N W

    W H .

    O J 7, U S I .37T I 38

    he U.S. Begins Escorting British Ships

    T U.S. B A

    1941. S J , E . H

    U.S. B H . T J 2

    A F I

    .

    37I ., . 288; D S ,Peace and War, . 68687.38A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 201.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    90/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 67

    J ,39 A 20,

    U.S. A B N A I .40

    T , B G

    H P A

    . . . P G

    B A . I , L -L

    .41

    Roosevelt Meets Churchill; hey Discuss Japans hreatening Encroachment

    on British in Far EastI A 1941 FDR

    W . H C G Calypso ff

    M . T A Augusta, N .

    C , E B Prince of Wales, N . T

    P B , ff A , N T , A 9 12, ,

    , O A 11 C L A

    FDR. H

    39I ., . 21316.40L G ,Te Undeclared War , . 665.41A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 216.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    91/960

    68 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    ff , A E , R

    [ J ] , , , S J

    . B J , I -C

    C . H J . T

    , P .

    C E :

    A N P J A

    : A J S P U S G

    - , U S J .42

    D , FDR C C

    , A ,

    J . C R U S G -I

    C A

    . H , C

    ffi : H C E , C . A

    42 W C ,Te Grand Alliance (B : H M ffl , 1950),. 43941.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    92/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 69

    C , H , I

    : I . I I C .43

    A C U.S. A FDR ff J

    C . N P ,

    U S U S J .44

    T A

    Augusta, S Prince of Wales. W FDR W ,

    A C ,45 . T C , R C

    . F ,

    N

    .

    43I ., . 593, C (N 9, 1941) G J C S , U S A ,

    A .44D S M C ( S W , ) W

    , A 11, 1941.45U.S. C , Events, . 293; D S ,Peace and War, .71819.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    93/960

    70 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    he Undeclared Battle ofthe Atlantic Continues

    T U.S. P F G

    M BD .46 T M1941, A U.S.

    , P F . A A , B U.S. A

    E , U.S. .

    O S 4, Greer I B

    G . T . TGreer . T . N

    Greer .47

    G - A

    SS Sessa P , I ; A 17, SSPanaman; S 6 G S , SSSteel Seafarer.48

    FDR, Greer, U.S. N A

    - - . H S 11:49

    46A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 12629.47I ., . 22329. S D N ,United States Naval Chro-

    nology, World War II , . 11.48U.S. C , Events, . 297.49D S ,Peace and War, . 73743.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    94/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 71

    I N

    . . . .

    W H . W . . . .

    B , .

    T N A . T

    . . . . T . . . .

    U A O

    A . T , ,

    A

    . T .

    I A . T

    . O .B . F , G I

    A .

    T I C - -C U S A N

    .

    A , N A

    T , ,

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    95/960

    72 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    G , . G

    B U.S.

    .O S 16, USSKearny,

    A I , .

    Kearny . T

    . A , . TKearny, , . T G U-

    , E 22 .

    , ff , S R H .50

    O S 22 S , W , A F C , A H , :

    S A , , [ ]. . . . I B ,

    . S . . . . I , U S

    I . . . . [C] . T

    .51

    S . A A U.S.

    . U , U.S. . I O Reuben James

    N A . S . O O 31 G

    50A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 26580.51 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 16, . 220911.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    96/960

    U.S. Ties to Britain Strengthened 73

    Reuben James ;

    F - ; .52 T U S ffi . Y

    A A . I E . I

    B G, . I

    A , B ,

    A . I . T U- - A N U.S

    C , C : ,

    .

    52A , Mr. Roosevelts Navy, . 297308. S D N ,United States Naval Chronology, World War II , . 11, S E M ,Te wo-Ocean War: A Short History of the United States Navy in the Second World War (B : L B , 1963), . 37.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    97/960

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    98/960

    4.U.S. Military Plansand Preparations

    U.S. Relations with Japan

    R J

    R J . Y , ,

    A - . J 1940 J U S . I1940

    . (W ,

    86 , J 1, 1940, 76 .1) T -

    J

    1I C A E. H , J 9, 1964 ( ). A H , J

    Offi N I , J 1941 86 J .

    75

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    99/960

    76 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    ,

    U S T J

    A , F I ( V , L , C ). A F

    1940, J V F F I

    , . T

    V . A U S ffi , J I

    .

    I J , , .

    U.S. A G J R

    C N O (NCO) S J . S

    S D J ff,

    . H , . . .

    , . . . I J .2

    M , E R , , J

    1940, J . FDR E N

    13, 1940:

    279 C ., 1 . J (C ) C I P H A .Pearl Harbor Attack, 39 . (W , D.C.:

    U.S. G P Offi , 1946), 32, . 43. N C I .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    100/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 77

    T

    J , J M , D E I . A

    F E . [S ] F.D.R.3

    T R J

    U S .

    I F 1941 S R C , B , F Offi L J

    B - S , B

    . A E , B ff , M S ,

    L , ffi ,

    B 4 W E H. D , U.S. , J ffO , O S R . O R J S DE I , ( J ) (

    A ). H , O F

    I . . .

    3F D R ,F.D.R.: His Personal Letters: 19281945 (N Y : D , S P , 1950), . 2, . 1077.4D S ,Foreign Relations of the United States: Diplomatic Papers,1941. . 2:Te Far East (W , D.C.: U.S. G POffi , 1956), . 3739; G F 14, 1941.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    101/960

    78 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    .5

    O J .

    Army Chief of StaffGeneral George C. Marshall

    C ff A G GC. M . M V MI 1901

    1902. T S -A W

    P . H W W I . I M

    , - - W W I G J J. P ,

    . A , 6 G D M A , M W P (1903), ff 1935. A , P

    M A M , . M

    ff .

    , . T

    FDR N D , A C C C (CCC). M

    CCC

    ff . T M5 I ., . 39.6K M ,ogether : Annals of an Army Wife (N Y /A : & L , 1946), A 1, . 28390.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    102/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 79

    . P

    M , . M I N

    (19331938).7 T M CCC

    R , J A

    S L , U.S. 1

    1946 J C C I H A ; M G F M C , S

    ; H H , FDR . P M . S

    .I J 1938 M W . F , H

    , M . H , ff O 1, 1938. O O 15,

    , O A 27, 1939, M

    ffi A ff. H ffi S1939, H P ,

    - !

    A ff, M S W M

    E . H S ,

    .8 T ff

    7F C. P ,George C. Marshall: Education of a General: 18301939,(N Y : V A , 1963), . 29099.8 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 3, . 1050. Q A

    .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    103/960

    80 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . D , M

    F D. R .

    T ff U S M

    , C G F F . I

    A ,

    , GHQ . I , P C

    G .9

    M N . M .

    T ff

    . T , , .

    Admiral Richardson, Commander-in-Chiefof U.S. Fleet, Relieved of Command

    I J 1941 R , - - U.F (CINCUS),

    . A H E. K , ff F 1.

    R , ,

    I I ,I F D. R .10

    9I .10 J O. R ,On the readmill to Pearl Harbor (W , D.C.:N H D , D N , 1973), . 420.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    104/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 81

    O W , R

    S N K . W M 24, CINCUS , 13

    24- . W , R , K W O , P . Y

    .11

    R - ffi , R . I ffi

    FDR, - - C .

    General Marshalls Responsibility

    for the FleetM L G W C. S

    H , ff F 7, 1941. T , M S

    K , PH , , CNO S

    P H . K . M S

    . . . H

    A .M

    H . N , M S A T F the a

    11I ., . 424.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    105/960

    82 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . [I ]. . . . [O]

    F . M S D [ ]

    . H , H

    .M H

    T A ,

    . F , I HI .

    H , M S :

    P N

    A K12

    M S M 5, H D

    . A , T

    .13 M ,

    ff, H H .

    12 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 32, . 56566. M F 7, 1941, S .13I ., 15, . 1605.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    106/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 83

    Admiral Kimmel, New Commander-in-Chief, U.S. Fleet, Strives to Build up

    Fleets Strength in Pearl Harbor

    K , , F P H . H R

    . Y K

    . T . O , CNO S , , , ,

    , , .14

    CNO A S R

    FDR 300,000 N . T . FDR,

    , . , B ,

    S , ; .15

    , N P16

    H , . A B M , N

    , , . H

    S FDR, N ff , . W

    , S F W M , S

    14I ., 16, . 222557.15I ., 5, 2273. S .16J A F , Administration of the Navy Department in World War II (W , D.C.: U.S. G P Offi , 1959), . 404.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    107/960

    84 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . H

    , .17 S S ,

    , , .

    S K N .

    I , I , I W H , ,

    . . . . T P . I - ff

    . I I H I I

    W H .18

    I K P F , S

    B , . H

    - .

    S N L -L B

    , B

    N D19

    17R G A R H C ,Forrestal and the Navy (N Y : C U P , 1962), . 8788.18 J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 16, . 2148, S K ,F 10, 1941.19I ., 16, . 2153. S K , M 3, 1941.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    108/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 85

    Admiral Stark Opposes Antagonizing Japan

    R B , ,

    , U S G . S

    , R P .

    S FDR . O F 11, 19S FDR ,

    P .20 T P

    ffi . F ,

    5 6 [] . . . P . S

    .21 S 22

    S [ M ] J , S , J

    . F J . W ,

    G .A P F

    J N ,

    J . I 20I ., 16, . 215051; 33, . 120304.21I ., 16, . 2150; 33, . 1203.22I ., 16, . 215051; 33, . 120304.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    109/960

    86 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    P F .

    , A , M -P , W P .I , S ,

    ff AG . W , ,

    F E . T P F J . T , M

    A ,

    M [ P W W I J

    ] J J B D .

    A , A .S F E

    . W . . . M [ ]

    J . W G S F I

    J ] ,

    , . T J B -

    .

    J , U.S.

    :R

    A F E . A

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    110/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 87

    [,]

    .

    I , , S FDR K

    P , .

    A , . H FDR:

    I ff I A , A , S ,

    .

    S ,

    .O F 25 S K . H K

    , S . S K , FDR ,

    ff .23 H

    J (

    ff J M B

    S , S , . . . [ ]

    . B , , . I

    ( SECRE ) I . T , K .

    23I ., 16, . 214950. S (F 25, 1941) K .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    111/960

    88 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    T

    E . S K . H , S ,

    , W H . E ,

    ,

    T , S . I

    . H FDR , , F E .

    Admiral Kimmel in Pearl HarborRequests Intelligence

    I , ; , ,

    N D W ,

    , , . A K P

    H , , , , , ; S 24

    S N I (ONI). ONI

    .25 I 1941, J

    W P H . T K

    24I ., 16, . 2229. K S (F 18, 1941).25I ., 17, . 2160. S K (M 22, 1941).

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    112/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 89

    . G , S

    , K , W

    .

    Security Leak in Washington

    S A 1940

    J , P . T J . T

    MAGIC . E ,

    1941

    J . A . . . S D . T A .26 I C L.F.

    S ff , , . A . I J

    , ff . W

    .S ff

    . H , A M P G ,

    U S , U.S. J . B A

    W I, 80 OI E

    26I ., 8, . 3735.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    113/960

    90 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    . A B

    M 3:

    S AHMER ( ) . . . G

    ( U.S. ),

    ( ) U.S. A N .27

    A , J

    U S , J , ,

    I , P .

    he American-Dutch-British (ADB)Conversations, Singapore, April

    A S A , D , B

    ffi , - ADB C , . T ( . T

    A 27 ffi AP U S , U K , N I , A , N Z , I .28 T U S .

    27I ., 4, . 186061. /B ; 4, . 1815, J 23, 1941 M : T [ A ] [ J ] .28I ., 15, . 155184 (E N . 50). A -D -BC , S , A , 1941 (S , A.D.B.), R .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    114/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 91

    T 33- ADB S

    MOS SECRE . I J

    J .

    I J

    - J ,

    G :

    ( ) A J M AP . . . .

    ( ) T J

    T W 100

    E S 10

    N .

    ( ) T J , J

    P I , E I K

    S

    A ] E M , 6 N M P ,

    G D [ - P ] W I [ -

    N G ], E E W .

    ( ) T J P .

    ( ) T J N C L I [ N C ].29

    29I ., . 1564.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    115/960

    92 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    T ADB

    , , . T U S

    B P S .

    R Y

    B . A R S

    FDR , R .30 F

    , , A -B , ,

    . S

    , G J ; ,

    C , A .31

    U.S. Ships ransferred fromPacific to Atlantic Fleet

    I A 1941 K

    30R E. S ,Roosevelt and Hopkins: An Intimate History(N Y :H & B , 1948), . 274.31I ., . 27374. H S , C

    B :I

    A ff , C P , ffi , ffi , .

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    116/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 93

    A F . T U.S.-B ABC-1 .

    T - , K A 19. A

    , , P A

    B

    CV () . T , , P .32

    H , , WH A 25,

    A . S K

    A . S A3 BB [ ], 1 CV [ ], 4 CL [2 . A

    P F . A .33

    I M 1941 , . . . P F ,

    K P . T - A B .34

    32J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 16, . 2164. S K ,A 19, 1941.33I ., 16, . 2165. S K , A 26, 1941.34 W L. L S. E G ,Te Undeclared War, 19401941 (N Y : H & B ., 1953), . 451.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    117/960

    94 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    Coordination of U.S. War Plans andProduction

    B , U S . R

    B , A S ; C

    J ;

    Eff . O M 21, M , W D , Offi PM , W H ,

    A 1941 1942 . H W D ff

    , , ,

    T W P D M ( L . G .) A W

    , , , .35

    United StatesJapan DiplomaticConversations: in Washington

    J A U S , A KN , U S . J , J 1941,

    . T J C . I

    , J 35M S W ,Te War Department: Chief of Staff: Prewar Plans and Preparations(W , D.C.: D A , H D

    , 1950), . 33637.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    118/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 95

    C . S ,

    O M . . . . T

    C ff .

    J R C J

    :36 (1) N ; (2) J ; (3) E .

    A J : (

    ; (2) M

    F E ; (3) W J C

    J C ; (4) N , ; (I M .37

    P

    U S , J U S J

    , ( , , , ) 38

    36D S ,Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States: Japan, 19311941(W , D.C.: U.S. G POffi , 1943), . 2, . 44445, 44849.37I ., . 423.38I ., . 462.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    119/960

    96 Pearl Harbor: The Seeds and Fruits of Infamy

    R S S H ,

    , . T J C 39 O J 21, H , J A

    .40 T J .

    Hitlers Invasion of Russia Alters Situationand Expands Call for Worldwide Coordination

    D J 2122 H U.S. T S G , B S . O

    G R B S U G , U.S.

    R , S U , A S 41

    R ff . O J 9

    . . .

    . . . [ ]

    .42

    39I ., . 444, 447.40I ., . 483. S J C ,Pearl Harbor Attack, 14, .140001. (7/24/41, J ).41 U.S. H C F Aff . Events Leading up to World War II: Chronological History of Certain Major International Events Leading up toand During World War II with the Ostensible Reasons Advanced for their Occur-rence, 19311944,78 C ., 2 ., 1944, . 28687.42 W ,Te War Department, . 33839.

  • 8/3/2019 Pearl Harbor. the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy. Percy L. Greaves Jr.

    120/960

    U.S. Military Plans and Preparations 97

    T M W M ,

    A , N A C . F V P

    , (A 30, 1941),

    U.S. , G B , .43 T W P D

    , W J 1,

    , W .44

    I U S , - V

    O , W ; S

    FDR, . I

    U.S.-Japan Relations reading the Evil Road

    A , J V F

    F I .45 B US B . O JU S S W ff

    J A W . T