11/26/14 1 Experimental structure determination in the undergraduate curriculum Creating data-rich integrated laboratory exercises Dean H. Johnston PDS/OVCS 2011 Why now? (what has changed?) • Access to crystallographic databases • Computing power – rapid structure solution / refinement – high quality graphical displays • Instrumentation – low maintenance – high level of automation Status and Future Potential of Crystallography (USNC/Cr 1976) • “It seems apparent that the major use of crystallography in most undergraduate chemistry curricula is simply the dissemination of certain crystallographic results.” • “In almost no case was there evidence that any information was given to students about how to evaluate the reliability of these results.” Searching “education and ______” Structural Data Continuum idealized experimental VSEPR Computed Textbook Database Laboratory • Most instruction in structural chemistry at the undergraduate level uses either idealized geometries (i.e. VSEPR) or selected bond distances and bond angles (average values) • Students are disconnected from the experimental sources of structural data, and therefore unaware of the associated uncertainty in such measurements Crystallography in the Curriculum • General Chemistry (1 st or 2 nd year) • Inorganic Chemistry (2 nd or 3 rd year) • Biochemistry (3 rd or 4 th year) • Stand-alone crystallography course
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
• Instrumentation – low maintenance – high level of automation
Status and Future Potential of Crystallography (USNC/Cr 1976)
• “It seems apparent that the major use of crystallography in most undergraduate chemistry curricula is simply the dissemination of certain crystallographic results.”
• “In almost no case was there evidence that any information was given to students about how to evaluate the reliability of these results.”
Searching “education and ______”
Structural Data Continuum
idealized experimental
VSEPR Computed Textbook Database Laboratory
• Most instruction in structural chemistry at the undergraduate level uses either idealized geometries (i.e. VSEPR) or selected bond distances and bond angles (average values)
• Students are disconnected from the experimental sources of structural data, and therefore unaware of the associated uncertainty in such measurements
Crystallography in the Curriculum • General Chemistry (1st or 2nd year) • Inorganic Chemistry (2nd or 3rd year) • Biochemistry (3rd or 4th year) • Stand-alone crystallography course
11/26/14
2
• General Chemistry (1st or 2nd year) • Inorganic Chemistry (2nd or 3rd year) • Biochemistry (3rd or 4th year) • Stand-alone crystallography course “many contexts exist in which crystallography can be incorporated in undergraduate education with minimal disruption to current courses, and should be included in curricula of all undergraduate programs in the physical and life sciences”
Crystallography Education Policies for the Physical and Life Sciences, ACA & USNC/Cr
Crystallography in the Curriculum Questions / Potential Issues • Curriculum
– If we add (crystallography), what do we take out?
– What do we want to teach our students? – What do we want our students to learn?
• Faculty time: – data collection, data analysis, and data
distribution is too time consuming – can’t “babysit” the instrument
insert favorite subject here
Our Context • Otterbein University
– 3000 total students – primarily undergraduate institution (PUI)
• Chemistry Department – six full-time faculty in Chemistry / Biochemistry – around ten majors per year
• General Chemistry – enrollment of 75-80 students – diverse majors including chemistry, biology
allied health, equine science, etc.
General Chemistry
General Chemistry Lab
Goal – to develop an integrated multi-week
laboratory activity that reinforces concepts of molecular geometry, intermolecular forces, unit cells and crystal packing using experimental data (both databases and student-generated)
General Chemistry Lab
1 Battle, G. M.; Allen, F. H.; Ferrence, G. M. J. Chem. Educ. 2010, 87, 813-818. 2 Crystals @ Otterbein: http://crystals.otterbein.edu
• Student groups assigned an amino acid • Cambridge Database VSEPR activity1 • Crystal packing / unit cell activity2 • Crystallization of amino acid (multi-week) • (X-ray analysis of amino acid samples) • Analysis of experimental X-ray data
Conclusions • Crystallography provides a rich source of
data that we can use to teach fundamental concepts of chemical structure, bonding, intermolecular forces, crystal packing, and critical analysis at the undergraduate level
• Advances in single crystal XRD instrumentation have made experimental crystallography accessible and feasible for teaching (and research) at primarily undergraduate institutions
Acknowledgements • Allen Hunter (YSU) • Otterbein Students • Chem Department,
Otterbein University • Greg Ferrence (ISU) • Matt Zeller (YSU) • ACA 2010 Summer
School faculty
• National Science Foundation (DUE #0942850)
Web Resources
• All materials available online at: – http://crystals.otterbein.edu – http://symmetry.otterbein.edu