PBS - The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 1/18

The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts

For many middle-class families, the American Dream can feel as though it's slipping away.

For others, it can seem lost for good.

Consider Terry and Tony Neumann and Claude and Jackie Stanley -- the two Milwaukee

couples featured in tonight's episode of FRONTLINE, Two American Families (check local

listings here).

FRONTLINE > Business / Economy / Financial > Two American Families >

Follow @jbrezlowJuly 9, 2013, 3:11 pm ET by Jason M. Breslow and EvanWexler

E - M A I L T H I S Tweet

S U P P O R T P R O V I D E D B Y

In 1992, both Tony and Claude had recently lost their manufacturing jobs. For the next 20 years, our cameras followed them and their

families as they struggled to avoid poverty. When they could find work, it was often for longer hours, less pay and no benefits. Bills piled

up, tensions rose and relationships became strained.

Of course, their story is far from unique. Over the last several decades, the middle class has struggled to keep pace with smaller paychecks,

mounting debt and shrinking opportunities for steady work. The following eight charts offer a brief snapshot:

#1: Wages are down

Middle class incomes have shrunk 8.5 percent since 2000, after enjoying mostly steady growth during the previous decade. In 2011, the

average income for the middle 60 percent of households stood at $53,042, down from $58,009 at the start of the millennium.

Search Search This Site Search PBS

PBS.ORG VIDEO TV SCHEDULE PROGRAMS DONATE SHOP KIDS PARENTS TEACHERS

WATCH SCHEDUL E CONNECT TOPICS ABOUT SHOP TEACHER CENTER

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 2/18

#2: Less income for the middle class

Partly as a result of lower pay, the middle class’s share of the nation’s total income has been falling. In 1980, the middle 60 percent of

households accounted for 51.7 of the country’s income. By 2011, they were less than half. Meanwhile, the top fifth of households saw their

slice of the national income grow 16 percent, to 51.1 percent from 44.1 percent.

#3: Union positions are shrinking

One factor behind the decline in income has been a drop-off in the number of workers earning union salaries. In 2012, the median salaryfor a unionized worker stood at roughly $49,000. The median pay for their non-union counterparts was just shy of $39,000. Since 1983,

however, the share of the population belonging to a labor union has gone from one-in-five workers to just over one-in-ten.

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 3/18

#4: More workers stuck in part-time jobs

A second factor weighing down pay is the rise in the number of Americans stuck in part-time jobs. In 2012, more than 2.5 million Americansworked part-time jobs because they could not find a full-time position, the most since 1993.

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 4/18

#5: Fewer jobs from U.S.-based multinationals

Part of the challenge for job seekers is that U.S. multinational corporations having been hiring less at home. These large, brand-name firmsemploy roughly a fifth of American workers, but from 1999 to 2008 they shed 2.1 million jobs in the U.S. while adding more than 2.2

million positions abroad.

#6: Rising debt

Predictably, the economic pressures facing the middle class have left families deeper in debt. . In 1992, the median level of debt for the

middle third of families stood at $32,200. By 2010, that figure had swelled to $84,000, an increase of 161 percent.

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 5/18

#7: Families are saving less

The rise in debt has meant fewer families have the ability to put away money for things like retirement or a child’s tuition bills. In 2001,more than two-thirds of middle class families said they were able to save money in the preceding year. By 2010, that figure was below 55

percent.

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 6/18

#8: Net worth has plunged

The impact on family net worth — the amount by which assets exceed liabilities — has been painful. In 2007, median net worth peaked at

$120, 600. Then came the financial crisis, which pushed millions of Americans into joblessness and home foreclosure. By 2010, net worthhad plummeted 36 percent, to $77,300.

E - M A I L T H I S Tweet

R E L A T E D

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 7/18

July 12, 2013 / 5:09 pm

What Does the American

Dream Mean to You?

July 10, 2013 / 5:03 pm

Photos: Milwaukee’s Industrial

Past

July 9, 2013 / 10:24 pm

Is There Hope for the Middle

Class? – Live Chat Transcript

July 9, 2013 / 9:25 pm

What’s Happened to the Two

American Families?

73 comments

Comments for this thread are now closed. ×

Best Community Login Share

•

Debbie Til l is Tay lor • 6 months ago

The reason we do not have decent paying manufacturing jobs is they have been sent to other countries in order to give higher profits to

the already wealthy. Not everyone can go to college. That is a fact, and it is ignorant to say that all you need to do is take advantage of

funding options. Not everyone has the mental ability to start a business and/or come up with the money to start a business. It isn't

possible for all citizens to be wealthy for a variety of reasons. You must have the working class. If you don't, who will do the work? Who

will build the houses, pick-up the trash, run the cash register, answer the phone for you to make your doctor's appointment, teach our

children, run our transportation, sell the cars many people can't afford, etc. It is also a must that people doing this work make a wage

that enables them to provide a decent living for their family and afford to buy the products they make.

My husband retired from a railroad job two and half years ago. He made a wage that allowed me to stay home and raise our children and

made another job available since I didn't need to take it. When we graduated from high school, in the early seventies, there were many

job options that paid a wage that a man could support his family on. These jobs have disappeared or been so downsized that they hire a

fraction of the workers. We will become a country of workers that can not afford a good life for our families, with both husband and wife

working. We will be a country of slave labor. Many people are there. We spend billions and billions of dollars in the name of fighting for

"Freedom" and standing up for citizens in other countries all the while stripping our own citizens of the very basic right to take care of our

families. The very people fighting our wars can not afford to care for their families properly.

Many people want to place the blame on those who are getting government help while never admitting that those who control the money

in this country are not at all to blame. It is a good thing, for the slave labor, that the right to bear arms still stands.

89

•

Dan • 6 months ago Debbie Tillis Taylor

As to your last sentence (Debbie), looking towards America from here in Canada, I think that you are headed for a revolution.

Certainly you are becoming like Mexico with gated communities of the rich and the poor living outside the walls in slums. But,

alas, history - including your own - will tell you that armed resistance seldom accomplishes more than bloodshed, You will be

better off electing representatives, at all government levels, who will truly fight for you - with words and a pen rather than a sword.

I haven't visited the United States since 2001 because it now feels like a police state. Very sad.

29

•

Michele Hogan • 6 months ago Dan

In theory, and as a life-long Quaker, I agree with you about armed revolution. But things have reached such a state in the

US that representatives who truly represent people and not corporations have absolutely no chance of getting elected.

Corporations donate as much money as they like to campaigns - they are 'people' after all, with free speech rights! - and

of course that is much more than even a huge group of poor people can muster. Corporate-owned media ridicule anyone

with the interests of the middle-class at heart - remember Howard Dean? - or persecute them until they give up their

ambitions. And media also perpetuate the idea of racial discrimination, blowing up any instance of it to national

proportions - remember the Harvard professor drinking beer with Obama? - to prevent the less wealthy from realizing that

whatever the color of our skin or national origin, we are all in this together, with a common, corporate enemy. We have

lost our voice, and, frankly, right now, I don't see the way out. It's terrifying.

15

Dan • 6 months ago Michele Hogan

I fully understand the desperation and anger - and must add that Canada is not really better off, as we have the

same problem of middle class erosion - but I say emphatically: another Revolution or Civil War will not acheive the

results you want. It would be better to look at examples like Gandhi or Lech Walesa, and explore a "passive

resistance". Stop shopping at stores that sell foreign-made goods, stop consuming the corporation's products

(like oil), have a small garden, refuse to accumulate debt and just do without, and cultivate a sense of family and

community, working together to inspire others - like the Stanleys are doing. Democracy is the most powerful force

humankind has ever created. If the representatives you elect don't do their job, find another that can. It will take

time, but it will work.

6

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 8/18

• 12

•

Debbie Til l is Tay lor • 6 months ago Dan

Dan, My guns comment was sarcasm, sorry I should have noted that. My point is that those who tend to be for the

wealthy are also the ones who want us to have the right to own any type of weapon and will not support background

checks. They seem to think that those who are opposed to voter ID are crazy. I mean who in their right mind would not

support voter ID, yet I say who in their right mind would not support background checks for gun owners. Also, I believe it

would be great if we could elect representatives who will "truly" fight for us, however, I have no delusions that if there is

such a person that they stand a chance of getting anything done. I don't know what you are referring to in "it feels like a

police state". I have lived long enough to see the middle class dwindle down to nothing. My definition of the middle class is

one working adult making enough money to support a family. I am the eldest of six. My father worked and supported our

family with his check. He was not a college graduate.

Sorry I gave the impression that I am up for a revolution. Far from it. I am saying that the majority of our population has

lived free since our arrival some 200 years ago. When people feel they have nothing left, when you strip them of their

pride and integrity, things will get ugly and they will use their 2nd Amendment right to take as many as they can with them,

and we know they have the right to stand their ground. -more sarcasm.

As I said in my original post, my husband retired from the railroad. We have lived a decent middle class existence. Not

everyone wants a huge home or many huge homes. The majority only want to live and enjoy the simple things of life.

Products and services have gone up and wages and jobs have gone down. Yes, wages are up from the 70s but not in

comparison with prices. Money runs this country. That is the way it is and in time it will lead to the destruction of this

country. Many years ago I told my father that the meek will inherit the earth, from scripture. His response was, with a

laugh, "yep, after the rest of us tear it up". I was greatly offended, mainly because it was scripture I was quoting to him.

Today, I can say his comment was point on.

5

•

Dan • 6 months ago Debbie Tillis Taylor

I hear you, Debbie. I also hope that those in the Occupy Movement see that their objective is flawed: they should

not be seeking to tear down the 1%, but rather to elevate the 99%. You cannot fight for a negative. An example

would be the Civil Rights movement where the objective was not to have white people become subject to

discrimination but rather to have equality for all. When individuals have lashed out at "the system" or "the

government" through violence, we rightly see them as crazy, and their victims are innocents. There have been

plenty of recent examples in Oklahoma City, in Colorado, New York, and so on. I know that you were not

advocating that, however I hope that no one else feels the need to take those measures ever again. I do still

believe that if people unite and assert their beliefs for better working conditions, results will happen. That led to the

creation of unions in the first place, and can lead to their resurgence in the future after decades of decline. Also, a

more important movement would be the re-establishment of community and family, and I think that is why we all

admired the Stanleys and their faith. The power of the masses is insurmountable.

3

•

ldfrmc • 6 months ago Debbie Tillis Taylor

Well stated. But, like Dan also says, you fail to recognize the power of ballots over bullets, a pen over a sword.

I am as frustrated. We do not need a college education to VOTE, to WRITE, to SPEAK - to produce the kind of American

Revolution that is our hallmark: Not threats, or violence, or arms - but VOTES, WORDS and DEEDS.

No bullet will ever make the lines on a chart reverse direction. Waiting to use the first amendment is a very poor excuse, even for

anyone who did not go to college. Using the fifteenth amendment (right to vote) requires work. We know how to do that, no

college required.

3

•

Debbie Til l is Tay lor • 6 months ago ldfrmc

My guns comment was sarcasm, sorry I should have noted that. Read my comment to Dan.

2

•

Scot t Thor • 6 months ago Debbie Tillis Taylor

I agree that not everyone is "college material", but anyone with average intelligence (the majority of the population) can finish

college. There are a multitude of ways to pay for college outside of racking up CC debt. It won't be easy, but working FT and

going to school is one option, finding employers who have tuition reimbursement is another (I got both a BS and MBA mostly paid

for by my employers at the time).

3 4

Debbie Til l is Tay lor • 6 months ago Scott Thor

The college graduate pool is flooded. Many unable to find jobs. My daughter has a Master's Degree and jobs available to

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 9/18

•

her, which are few, pay no more than she was making before her degree. Now she has over $50,000 in student loans to

pay and there was nothing available to her to help pay her way. She was always just above or just below whatever, to

qualify and as I said we were middle class living a decent life but no where near paying for college educations for two

children. College tuition is as insane as is medical cost.

7

•

Scot t Thor • 6 months ago Debbie Tillis Taylor

I agree that college tuition is out of control. I recently finished a doctoral degree at a private university, and have

been blessed with a thriving consulting practice that has made the ROI for the degree well worth it, but I would

venture to guess I'm an anomaly.

My advice to those who are considering college is that you have to do the math on whether it's worth it. In the long

run there is no question a college degree is going to lead to higher earnings than just a HS diploma, but paying for

it may take a decade or two of loan payments.

The alternative is to look for options you can afford to pay cash for. Often people choose a college based not on

what they can afford, but instead on reputation and/or name recognition, when in many cases this has no impact

on earnings after you get the degree.

3

•

Jim Thykeson • 6 months ago

Right-wing philosophy has waged war, and won, against the thing they hate most; fair wages. They took away the lowest rung of working

folk by 'importing' illegal aliens from Mexico and central America. When I was a young man (73 now) agricultural field work, building

construction work, all jobs of this ilk was the domain of blacks and poor whites. When business thought this segment was making too

much wage they simply recruited workers from the forementioned countries. In doing this, they wiped out a whole class of the American

work force, and created the 'illegal alien' problem. Then they (the right) have the unmitigated gaul to bitch about the problem they are

responsible for. When unionized manufacturing ( ununionized as well) became too expensive they closed operations and went offshore.

They called this run away 'multi-nationalism', which again, was running from the fair-wage and union busting. Recently, with

manufacturing unions almost totally decimated, these same folks started dismantling public sector unions like teachers, fire fighters,

police, nurses, etc. Now we are being forced to take enormous wage cuts, plus forego pensions and healthcare. And oh by the way; they

HATE PBS and FRONTLINE!! They are ruining our nation. Wake up before it's too late...it might be already.

32

jskdn • 6 months ago Jim Thykeson

There is certainly a powerful minority of the Republican Party establishment, often termed as its “donor class,” that promotes

illegal immigration or some functional equivalent of suppressing wages through the importation of workers from other countries.

But you are deluding yourself to ignore the pivotal role of Democrats, the media, including PBS, and Democrat interest groups

like ethnic identity advocates and unions in opposing the kind of effective enforcement that is necessary to control illegal

immigration. PBS is an advocate of the illegal immigrants and their “right” to be here.

The reality is that many people in the working class have had their economic opportunities severely diminished by the elites in

this country, both left and right, including Bill Moyers and company. In market economies employers pay what they have to pay

and worker's labor market bargaining power is a function of the available supply of willing employees. This Frontline program

even had a brief reference to the one time in the last few decades when such tight labor conditions existed, in the late 1990's,

and you can see it in chart #1. The dot-come bubble had made the economy flush and the Federal Reserve seemed to have

changed its thinking on the “Phillips Curve” or NAIRU (Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate Of Unemployment) and potential

employees had choices.

Globalization certainly hurt the manufacturing areas of the country. While those pressures won't completely go away, persistent,

large trade deficits tremendously aggravate the problem. Policies that didn't allow such deficits would have a large effect on

reducing employment in this country. It's one thing to have free trade, as in the exchange of good and services from this country

with those produced elsewhere. It's another to allow continuing, massive debt-financed purchases by this country of what people

in other countries produce.

There are jobs that simply can't be off-shored but those jobs are subject to domestic labor market forces. If you look at who has

been getting the jobs, you'll find that they have been going disproportionately to immigrants. Reuters hired researchers at the

Center for Labor Market Studies at Northeastern University to review of U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and Census Bureau data

find out who was getting jobs for 2008-10.

“Over the past two years, as U.S. unemployment remained near double-digit levels and the economy shed jobs in the wake of

the financial crisis, over a million foreign-born arrivals to America found work, many illegally.”

“From 2008 to 2010, 1.1 million new migrants who have entered America since 2008 landed jobs, even as U.S. household

employment declined by 6.26 million over that same period.”

http://www.reuters.com/article...

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 10/18

•

Steven Camarota did a study covering 2000 to 2013 that gives a longer term picture of the trends.

http://cis.org/immigrant-gains...

We have massive numbers of working age people who are not in the workforce. The latest BLS employment numbers shows the

additional number of working-age persons not in the workforce over the last year exceeded the number of additional jobs added

over the same period. Yet this situation is cast aside as the elites push amnesty and greatly increased immigration, and that

includes the liberal media elites.

10

•

Debbie Til l is Tay lor • 6 months ago Jim Thykeson

I completely agree Jim. As a railroad worker, my husband was a union worker. He was set up to be a supervisor and worked as a

supervisor for nine years at which time they sent in a hatchet man to set the majority of the supervisors back to their tools. The

supervisors that had protection as union workers. These are the people they wanted to shake loose. My husband continued to

pay his union dues while he was a supervisor so went back in his place of seniority. If he had not kept up his dues he would have

lost nine years and possibly laid off. That was in '92'. I told him hang on with everything you have. They were doing a major

shaking. For those of you who work for a corporation that has given you the impression you have a job for life. Don't believe it. It

was a lesson my husband learned. He was emotionally devastated. He would not have had a job if it had not been for the union

protection. My husband thought this railroad would always have his back. They told him they would. My father told my husband

don't believe. They will stab you in the back. Again, my father was right. Living brings wisdom. Not because our brain gets

somehow smarter, but because we live an hopefully learn.

Just a note on unions. Unions can be great thing, I do however believe they need some changes. Workers should not be

protected when they are lazy, sorry workers. I have seen employers powerless in getting rid of bad workers. Some things need to

be changed within the unions for sure. It is a shame that unions are needed to force business to do right by workers. This

comment meant for those to whom it applies.

5

•

Roger Arturo Delgado • 6 months ago Jim Thykeson

you've got that right. Outstanding brief analisis..Thks !

2

Claudia W • 6 months ago Jim Thykeson

Jim,I am a 65 year old Conservative Republican who just retired after 40 yrs in Health Care.

Nursing for 40 yrs has taken a toll on my body,my neck and sholder are shot, I didn't quit and get on

Disability,I stuck it out and now am ready to draw my S.S.

Everything you said you were against,me too !

Everything you blamed on my party,you are flat out wrong. I can tell you don't have any Republican friends,you would

know better. Most of the best people I've ever met are life long Republicans.

And as for not liking PBS and FRONTLINE....

I've spent a small fortune on purchasing shows from FRONTLINE and PBS...

i cry all through the animal shows on my local Oregon public Broadcasting,and love the politics and world news

on FRONTLINE. Their programs on the government and are simply brilliant.

I grew up in California and watched my beloved state start to crumble. All my school years years I never saw

any Blacks or Mexicans. But by the time I left in 1976 I really was depressed. Everybody you meet down there

has either just arrived and can't speak English,or doesn't work and are on Medical Marijuana.

We had the best of everything all thru the majority of those years.

I worked at Douglas Aircraft for 2 years starting at 17 yrs old,then onto college. I remember the older workers were

always laughing at Detroit paying 25 bucks an hr hanging doors. They used to say..'no way can they keep this up

paying that kind of wage for such a lightweight job.The machine did all the work"

Hummmm,that was back in 1967 ! That guy had a crystal ball.

Of course Douglas Aircraft then merged with McDonald and finally became a parking lot.

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 11/18

•

i loved that job ! 17 yrs old driving a brand new Barracuda.

Oh well..

Nursing became my heart and soul for almost 40 years.

I didn't vote for Obama,I can assure you!

I love George Bush and Laura,and owe no apology for that. History will judge them.

In closing,I want to tell you who did a dirty deed on the public that will haunt America for years.

I'm used to seeing people who cut their heart medicine in half,they can't afford it. Then I see them for

heart attacks and cva's .

Back to the dirty deed that just gets buried. Obama signed a back door deed with Canada that forbids cheaper drugs

in America. Meaning we pay the highest price for our meds with no place to go. One of my meds is 110.00,and I take 2 others.

All the time I worked it was 10 bucks per script. And I doubt we will ever fix this. He sucessfully buried it and it was done

without any conversation from opposition.

Well,I shared a bit of my life with you..I don't get mad when I talk to Dems/Libs, I just try and prove ir with facts.

No personal attacks,no blaming the entire Democratic Party like you blamed mine.

Good Luck from a

Conservative Republican

1

ETNIKS • 6 months ago

TO MAINTAIN A STRONG MIDDLE CLASS WE HAVE TO RESOLVE THE ISSUE OF MONEY CREATION

WHAT IS HE WARNING US ABOUT?

"I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous than standing armies...

If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of

currency, the banks and corporations that will grow around them, will deprive

the people of their property until their children wake up homeless on the

continent their fathers conquered"

Thomas Jefferson

MONEY CREATION

To understand Jefferson's warning we have to clarify a few points that most people don't know.

1- The US government does not create the money supply. The money supply in the current Fractional Reserve Banking System we use,

is done by private banks as they give credit

2- 95% of the money in circulation is not printed. It exists as a digital number in computers.

3- The money created as loans doesn't include the money needed to pay the interest, so the economy has a constant scarcity of funds.

4- The US central bank is NOT owned by the US government.

5- Once the loans are paid back to the banks it DISAPPEARS, that money ceases to exist and is out of circulation.

6- To replenish the vital money supply, NEW debts have to be created by bank lending

7- If governments, businesses and individuals pay back loans and don't do new borrowing (austerity) THEN THE MONEY SUPPLY

DECREASES and forces more bankruptcies, less tax revenue, less government services and ruin the economy

8- Banks only need 10% deposit to lend out money they don't have.

To solve this problem, we need to change the current system from a Debt-Based money system, to an Asset-Based currency system

controlled by the communities, not by for-profit banks, as it is today.

this video explains it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

And this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

WE'RE AT A CROSSROADS

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 12/18

•

WE'RE AT A CROSSROADS

The system is crashing like all ponzi schemes do eventually. Unless we change the way we create the currency, we won't solve the

Middle Class erosion.

27 2

•

Brenda Cowles • 6 months ago

I truly believe the U.S. is in a not-so-slow decline as the middle class foundation has been eroded over the past 30 years. Many factors

have played into this process including finance de-regulation, corporate malfeasance, the unending focus by this country on supporting

the military/industrial complex, loss of quality jobs, tax policies that favor corporations, incoherent political system, etc. This decline is

occurring in such a way that it has eaten into the very heart and soul of the average American. This loss of hope has made people feel

like they cannot affect any change. I, for one, have contacted my senators/house representatives, written to the White House, and

expressed my frustrations and offered suggestions for improvement, with only canned responses. No one is listening to the average

person. The conservative response is to blame people for their lack of a strong work ethic, lack of desire for advanced education, and

"big government"; all of these responses represent a complete lack of understanding with what is actually occurring and only result in

continued stalemate and inaction to make improvements. If people, both conservative and progressive, don't come together to address

these issues, then this decline can only continue. I, personally, don't see that happening for many years, if ever, and, by then, it may be

too late.

10

•

Mike • 6 months ago

I have been convinced since the ( "Greed is good..") days during the early 1990's that too much access to our government and national

assets had set off an international and domestic feeding frenzy. After the ultra wealthy and corporation heads engorged themselves by

taking every liquid asset, business, and holdings available they then realized that they could return labor back to the days of controlled

serfdom (european slavery). They have deliberately hollowed out our middle class, stolen our dreams, cancelled our liberty, and they

actively prohibit our golden symbol of abundence (the cornicopea filled with food and work's rewards) from filling and giving to all

Americans.

It is ever more apparent to me that we will have to go to war with the rich just like the French did with their foolish goverment, their banks,

and their greedy lawyers. You rich corporates and government had better change our economy for the better and for all OUR people

only! First comes awareness, then meetings, followed by armed insurrection. If you listen you can hear the growing thunderous storm

approaching.

10

•

Chupuk • 6 months ago

If I got this right, when Debbie lost her home, she had lived in it for 24 years and owed $96,000. I'm guessing that they did not pay much

more for the house when it was new, meaning that very little of their payments actually paid down the primary loan balance, meaning

that it all went into the pockets of the Bank or Mortgage company. This is all about simple exploitation of the under-privileged (most of us)

by the over-privileged new aristocracy in this country called the Banking and Financial Services Industry. The methods have changed,

but this is no-less than the same feudal system practiced in bygone eras. WAKE UP!! Make no mistake, we are working and dying for

this new aristocracy that are untouchable from any form of authority. It has become apparent that the Congress, Executive Branch and

major Government agencies are now firmly in their pockets and simply exist to do their bidding . It would seem that nothing less than

revolution is capable of fixing this mess that is destroying this country.

15 1

•

chwolverton • 6 months ago Chupuk

After 24 years she owed 96,000 and it later sold for 38,000. I suspect the original loan was for a lot less than +96k; most likely

they kept refinancing and adding more and more debt to the loan over those 24 years.

6

dvb • 6 months ago

Have you noticed the many empty seats lately at major league baseball games? Part of the reason for this drastic decline is that the

middle class have been squeezed out of enjoying the great “American Pastime.” Fathers with their sons and families can no longer

afford the exorbitant prices changed to watch players with their multi-million dollar contracts play ball.

Congress has not taken any action about the doubling of interest rates on student loans. This does not affect the elite; however, those in

the middle class seeking higher education will be saddled with enormous debt. Even now, most graduates cannot find a job in their field,

and end up in low paying or part-time jobs that keep them at arms-length from health benefits, and struggling financially.

The big banks were bailed out by the government, but have you tried to apply for a loan modification because you lost your job or

experienced a steep decline in your income? The bank will extend the term of your loan until you are in your 90’s, and ruin your credit

score in the process (that’s if you make it through month after month of paperwork). No problem for the elite; their mansions are paid off,

while the middle class struggles to put food on the table and gas in their cars.

Large corporations march into bankruptcy courts to wiggle out of paying union pensions and health care benefits to their employees and,

unfortunately, the courts oblige after allowing huge severance packages for the top executives. Those at the top who need it the least get

rewarded, while those at the bottom are simply forgotten. The salaries of most CEO’s in this country make the President’s

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 13/18

•

rewarded, while those at the bottom are simply forgotten. The salaries of most CEO’s in this country make the President’s

salary look pale. The figures cannot even be compared.

The United States has spent billions rebuilding Iraq. In contrast, FEMA couldn’t manage to get trailer homes sent to New Orleans.

Families who lost everything after recent hurricanes and tornadoes are still homeless, and struggling to get their insurance companies to

pay for damages – while they must continue to pay their mortgages, as well as property tax increases levied after the storms. We have

gone so global that Americans seem to come last.

Corporations continue to reap profits on the backs of women and children in Third World Countries. Prices have gone up while quality

has gone down. The “American Dream” of owning a home in the United States has all but disappeared thanks to the outsourcing of jobs.

If I’m not mistaken, these same corporations avoid taxes by doing their business in other countries. Corporate greed has been tearing

away the very fiber of the American worker.

The “mom and pop” businesses are gone. Wealthy foreigners now run most convenience stores, restaurants, and gas stations. The

profits go back to their countries, not ours.

We are quickly becoming a country of the haves and have-nots because those with power and money are heard, while the cries of the

middle class are mute.

9

•

Dave Holden • 6 months ago

Full circle: Ship jobs overseas so couple has no income, sell house to immigrants so couple has no place to live. Umm... someone

explain how our government is representing US citizens in all this?

6

•

Jud • 6 months ago

As a retired corporate recruiter who in the late 1980's and early 1990's did business with Milwaukee manufactures including AO Smith,

Allen Bradley, Master Lock, Rockwell International and Johnson Controls, I am outraged because the pain suffered by dislocated workers

and their families can be avoided. What makes this situation so disgusting is that we know how to prevent these problems Just look at

the successful career and retirement coaching methods used by the auto industry. Where is the leadership? Where is the sense of

responsibility? Where is our collective commitment to treating our fellow human beings with dignity and respect?

4

•

c laudedaisy • 6 months ago

Two American Families was an excellent, if tragic story about two families struggling through the years to make it in America. I think they

represent thousands of families in this country who we never hear about, who have been dealing with job layoffs, foreclosures and low

wages for the last decade. It's unlikely the second generation of these families will do any better and perhaps even worse. The dream of

owning a home in this country is becoming a dream, rather than a reality based goal. While the stock market continues it's upward climb

from the big recession (depression), the average American isn't any better off. With low paying jobs and struggling to survive to put food

on the table and a roof over their heads, things still look pretty dark at the end of the tunnel. A college education is a good thing to enrich

one's mind, but there are very few jobs available for twenty year old college graduates that will help pay gigantic student loan costs or

support finding a place to live away from the family. Many manufacturing jobs once available to people who chose not to go to college

have now been shipped out of the country.These jobs only provide more profit for the corporations, horrific working conditions in

unregulated countries and often inferior products. The rich do not want anything done that will change their lifestyle, while the middle and

working classes have almost disappeared in this country due to huge wage inequalities. Both families, though working really hard at all

kinds of jobs, continue to struggle financially even as they grow older. Where they once might have hoped for retirement, now they know

they have to keep working until they physically can't anymore. Unfortunately, our politicians will say almost anything to be elected and

then once they win, it is easy to see they do what the corporations want, not the average American. Most all of our elected

representatives in government, are wealthy themselves and most have never faced life challenges like the families in this program.

Maybe a way for revolution without violence, is for everyone in the country not to send in their tax returns next April. Something

revolutionary needs to happen in the United States because at this point, it's only working for the wealthy as the rest of us face lifelong

struggle.

4

•

P. Nym • 6 months ago

End the Fed and end the income tax.

10 3

•

radsenior • 6 months ago

Everyone's $. 02 is still $. 02 excepting the top 1% have more $. 02 than everyone else. Net worth plunged 36% while multi-national

companies increased employees overseas and excess monies were moved off-shore. The average income has decreased while TEA-

Republicans languish in repeated anti-abortion bills that will go nowhere. Lest there be any doubt who's side the TEA-Republicans are

on! The 2014 Mid-term is a-coming! As is 2016, and 2018! V.O.T.E.(Vote Out The Encumberance)

3

Scot t Thor • 6 months ago

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 14/18

•

Scot t Thor • 6 months ago

These graphs paint an interesting picture! As the US economy

continues to shift away from high paying manufacturing jobs and more

toward lower paying service jobs the outlook is not good for those who

would have enjoyed the "good life" with only a HS education.

Part of the problem is that there is an ever-greater emphasis on education,

and those with no post HS degree, certification, etc. are going to

struggle in many cases. Their best hope, assuming they can't go to

college, which I would argue is not a valid argument with all the

funding options available, is to take on an entrepreneurial mindset and

dream big while living on a realistic budget while doing so.

Some of the problem is self-inflicted, I would argue, especially as it

relates to debt. Sure, the bankers may have taken advantage of some

ignorant people by giving them mortgages, CC's, etc. that they should

never have received, but one graph that is missing is the shift away

from personal responsibility to reliance on government help. I would

argue that graph would show a major downward trend in responsibility.

So what then is the solution? Tax the wealthy more? Shift a greater

percentage of the income to those in the middle? I'm not sure that who

has the money will make all that much a difference. I do know that

anyone who believes the federal government should get more tax dollars

because of their stellar track record for handling our money needs to be

slapped with the reality that they are the last role model we should

look up to regarding controlled and responsible spending.

9 5

•

Katray447 • 6 months ago Scott Thor

Ah, yes, the knee-jerk extreme right-wing voice, re: "shift away from personal responsibility to reliance on government help." This

argument doesn't even qualify as a valid argument - it has no basis in reality whatsoever. It is a shameful thing to even think, let

alone vomit into your keyboard. Did you actually watch the program?? You seem to have taken absolutely nothing away from it.

What is the solution? Good question. Stuff I would do? Whatever was necessary to repeal NAFTA. Whatever was necessary to

bust up the huge banks, and allowing the incestuous incursion of Wall Street into main street. Prosecute every "entrepreneur"

who very nearly destroyed the economy of the entire world - like, tomorrow. Tax the ever-loving crap on every dollar made by any

individual over $1 million. Personally, I think if you've made a million bucks this year alone, the rest of the country needs a big

chunk of it more than you do. Figure out how to slap HUGE fines on every multi-national holding trillions of $$ overseas to avoid

taxes. If they want to fold up shop and move overseas, fine - let them - THEY ALREADY HAVE DONE THIS - Let's just make it

official and revoke their citizenship on their way out the door. Make it illegal for the US military to HIRE corporations to do any job

they are perfectly capable of doing for themselves at a fraction of the cost - simply increase the pay for regular soldiers and

watch what happens to recruitment/retention rates. End multi-billion $ corporate welfare...NOW.

Gee, should I go on? There are so many it fairly boggles the mind. Our country has gotten so stupid, its breath-taking, and all you

can do is make baseless accusations against people who are hurting the most? Don't look now - you're a BIG part of the

problem, my friend.

28

•

Meg Elder • 6 months ago Katray447

AMEN!!! I second everything you said Katray447. NAFTA was the biggest blunder in US HIstory.

4

•

Guest • 6 months ago Scott Thor

so you want a graph showing the "shift away from personal responsibility..."? What does that mean and please EXPLAIN who

determines personal responsibility? Heritage Foundation maybe? Are you also posting as chowoleverton?

22

Scot t Thor • 6 months ago Guest

I wasn't proposing we literally start measuring personal responsibility, but I do believe that some of the problem is from

people who believe the government is going to fix the problem. The story last night showed a number of people taking

responsibility for their lives, which I really enjoyed seeing.

The problem that ran common to each person was their lack of education. It also didn't seem like any of them were

thinking past finding the next job, which would lead to a repeat of the same cycle all over again. If I was in their position I'd

be thinking about how to get out of that cycle instead of continuing to live in it.

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 15/18

• 3 2

•

Redact ive1 • 6 months ago Scott Thor

Scott, you seem to be a thoughtful---and even moderately compassionate---person, so you might not realize that

it's arguably borderline arrogant of you to opine that "[i]f I was in their position I'd be thinking about how to get out of

that cycle instead of continuing to live in it": it's unjustified to assume that none of the members of either of these

families thinks about breaking the cycle---and, especially with respect to those who might not have had the

educational or other opportunities for advancement that some of us have enjoyed---it's even more unjustified to

assume that thinking about bettering one's situation is a panacea.

10

•

Meg Elder • 6 months ago Redactive1

Not to mention the reality that there are many jobs that still need to be filled in our society for which a college

degree is superfluous. We need a strong working class, we need that working class to be paid a living wage in

which they can support a family. There will always be a portion of our citizens who are looking for handouts....but

there are soooooo many people who are out of work, or working 2 or even 3 jobs, many people forced into part-

time jobs to make ends meet. When you look at the enormous profits made by CEO's and billionaire corporate

leaders, when you see an exponentially increasing divide between the working class and the corporate elite, can't

you admit that there is a bigger problem than simply "personal responsibility?"

•

texrat • 6 months ago Scott Thor

It affects people with degrees, too.

13

•

Monaco • 6 months ago texrat

Your right, unemployment does effect people with degrees; however, it happens far less - particularly for someone with a

master's degree. In fact, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate for households with a

professional degree is only 2.1% versus 12.4% for families without high school diplomas.

Bottom line... education does play a huge factor in unemployment rates.

http://www.bls.gov/emp/ep_char...

2

•

Rick • 6 months ago Scott Thor

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/...

•

ldfrmc • 6 months ago Scott Thor

The federal government does "get more tax money" when the minimum wage provides enough for working people to live, to buy

what they need, to save a little for the future. People working and earning (your unstated "personal responsibility"), buying and

saving puts work-money into the economy - then government "gets more tax money".

Did you actually watch the Frontline Program? People must have a job and a job that pays a living wage to be "personally

responsible" for themselves, their families and their government. If you do not think you are part of government (society), what do

you think you are?

•

arobinson • 6 months ago

The Middle class is not suffering because manufacturing jobs went overseas; the middle class is suffering because the class beneath

them are suffering stagnation and low wage earnings. The Middle Class will continue as an indebted class as long as their base

continues to earn subsistence wages. The Middle Class represents roughly only 10% of the economy where as their base represents

80% of the economy. Increased wages for the bottom 80% will filter up to the Middle Class. Ronald Regan with his trickle down

economic approach robbed the Middle and destroyed the other 80% bargaining power at the table, following the Air Controller's Strike.

Americans have been told that we are poor because we lost manufacturing, If this was the case why are the corporations richer then in

anytime in history? Presently, the corporations are hording enough liquidity to pay the National Debt? If it was true why does 1% of the

American population control 80% of the Resources? No; the middle class is poor; because the class beneath them are poor.

2

•

Jake • 6 months ago

Graph #5 is the KEY to the current disaster our country is facing. All the other graphs flow from Graph #5.

2

Donnmaria Tucker Kil l inger • 6 months ago

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 16/18

•

Donnmaria Tucker Kil l inger • 6 months ago

I was impressed with both families and wish them well for themselves, their in a nice and safe area is becoming more difficult. Too

many landlords want to 'get rich' at their tenants' expense. Companies sending their manufacturing ovetseas and unions are responsible

for many of our problems along with a Congress full of wealthy people who promise their consiguents the world abd staft them when in

office. We need to lower or eliminate the income tax or tax the people who have the most money and can find ways to avoid paying

taxes. I wish both families, their children and grandchildren success in their efforts. To own your own home has always been the

American dream. I believe for the average person it has become the impossible dream. Even renting a house or an apartmet

3 1

•

Meg Elder • 6 months ago Donnmaria Tucker Killinger

Excuse me? How are unions the problem exactly? As unions have grown smaller and smaller our standard of living for the

majority of Americans has gotten worse. I don't understand your logic.

3

•

Dana • 6 months ago

Thank you to the two families who opened their lives and homes. After some reflection I have the opinion that we are now a part of a

global economy. The poverty level globally has come up. And our middle class is now competing not just with each other in this country

but globally. I think our expectations need to align. Other countries are better suited to accommodate with the family unit, several

generations living and growing older together. We have become too self centered and need to swing back to a more traditional model of

the family unit, work ethics, working together to grow together. Great piece of journalism. Thank you.

4 3

•

parterre • 6 months ago Dana

I've watched a very interesting series of DVDs about family life in countries around the world. It is astounding to see the children

around the world doing all their schoolwork in English, and learning other languages as well. The kids and parents are happy and

grateful to go to school. They're not whining about rules, homework, etc. I watched this with my kids and say "see, that's why you

want to study math and science". Because the 2nd graders in Egypt are learning it too, in English.

•

Dr. S • 6 months ago

More Americans need to vote. They can vote to end the fake free marketeers, which really believe in captured markets by captured

politicians with campaign money and lobbying. If politicians were more afraid of the voters than their money sources, America can be a

better place. They could bring back Glass Steagall, end false right to work states, raise the minimum wage, wasted money and blood on

wars we will loose, and kill a bunch of faceless foreign civilians and gain nothing from, not even cheaper oil, or total elemination of mortal

enemies. As long as we don't vote, we have no say in America.

3 2

•

fargo44 • 6 months ago Dr. S

Sounds like a recipe for disaster to me doc. That's the kind of approach used in Detroit, which has been under complete control

of the democratic party for the last 51 years (as in half century). It went bankrupt yesterday. QED

2 2

•

see more

ponichan • 6 months ago

My take on the 8 Graphs.

1. Nothing really surprising there. Peaks in the late 90s and the mid-2000s correspond with the dot.com bubble and the housing bubble.

Both of these bubbles probably pushed up incomes to a non-sustainable level. Yet looking at the trend overall you see steady growth in

wages since 1980 even after the current hit we are still considerably above where we were 30 years ago.

2. Probably the most troubling graph of the lot. Income distribution is a tough one and the trend should not be diverging like is shown.

3. Union membership shrinking is a direct result of the mix of jobs currently available in the US. Not sure how I feel about this. I would

think that the goal would be to create jobs that can support a middle class lifestyle regardless of whether or not they are union based or

not.

4. Absolutely nothing surprising about this graph. The trend lines for the current recession look identical to previous recessions. You can

see the inverted impact of the dot.com and housing bubbles in the graphs. Again the current recession does not look any more severe

than previous recessions.

5. Feels like a misleading graph. Only using US multinationals would only tell half the story What about Toyota, Honda, Siemens, and the

multitude of other non-US multinationals? If their graphs look the same then yes there is something to think about. With Globalization I

would expect the trend for US multinationals to be exactly as shown on the graph over the last 30 years. I would also expect the graph to

be inverted for non-US companies as they ramped up their presence in the US over the last 30 years. I would expect the actual overall

1

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 17/18

In order to foster a civil and literate discussion that respects all participants, FRONTLINE has the following guidelines for commentary. By submittingcomments here, you are consenting to these rules:

Readers' comments that include profanity, obscenity, personal attacks, harassment, or are defamatory, sexist, racist, violate a third party's right toprivacy, or are otherwise inappropriate, will be removed. Entries that are unsigned or are "signed" by someone other than the actual author will beremoved. We reserve the right to not post comments that are more than 400 words. We will take steps to block users who repeatedly violate ourcommenting rules, terms of use, or privacy policies. You are fully responsible for your comments.

Load more comments

•

Chery l Hanson • 6 months ago

This is an important story. A book well worth reading is "The Price of Civilization: Reawakening American Virtue and Prosperity" by

Jeffrey D. Sachs. He reminds us that we do need safety nets, and that judgment of those in hard times is not the American Way.

1

•

ETNIKS • 6 months ago

Wealth Inequality In America

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...

1

•

baron95 • 6 months ago

What a biased piece of journalism. It purposefully stop many of the graphs (like household wealth) in 2010. When the 2012 data has

been published by the FED showing that household wealth has fully recovered and topped 2007 levels.

Similarly, the income distribution hart shows only the 40%-60% range to make the changes look massive. On a proper 0-60% scale, the

changes come across as very modest.

The union vs non-union pay chart, again,misleadingly is not adjusted for part-time workers which is almost non-existant in union

employment, and it also is not adjusted by occupation. Union workers in the US are primarily government, manufacturing and

transportation, and overwhelmingly full time. What is the non-union average salary for FULL time workers in government, manufacturing

and transportation? Answer, there is no gap.

Average middle class income, again, misleading because it does not include benefits (like medical insurance and 401K paid by

employers). When those are folded in, the median income is nearly flat.

There are real challenges to working families in America. But tabloid/sensationalistic features like this, completely discredits the cause.

Put honest data in,and the nation can have an honest dialog.

6 14

Subs cribe Add Dis qus to your s i te

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

NE X T ON FR ONT L I NE

To Catch a TraderJanuary 7th

T OD A Y ' S ST OR I E S

January 7, 2014 / 3:30 pm

Chart of the Day: The SAC

Advantage

January 7, 2014 / 10:33 am

SAC In Spotlight As Insider

Trading Trial Opens

January 6, 2014 / 11:56 am

“Isn’t This Illegal?”

Join our newsletter

e-mail address

Subscribe »

Follow @frontlinepbs

FRONTLINE on

1/7/14 The State of America’s Middle Class in Eight Charts | Two American Families | FRONTLINE | PBS

www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/business-economy-financial-crisis/two-american-families/the-state-of-americas-middle-class-in-eight-charts/ 18/18

Funding for FRONTLINE is provided through the support of PBSviewers and by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Majorfunding for FRONTLINE is provided by the John D. andCatherine T. MacArthur Foundation. Additional funding isprovided by the Park Foundation, the Wyncote Foundation,and by the FRONTLINE Journalism Fund.

Supporting Investigative Reporting

FRONTLINE Watch FRONTLINE About FRONTLINE Contact FRONTLINEPrivacy Policy Journalistic Guidelines PBS Privacy Policy PBS Terms of Use Corporate Sponsorship

FRONTLINE is a registered trademark of WGBH Educational Foundation.Web Site Copyright ©1995-2014 WGBH Educational Foundation

PBS is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.