Top Banner
6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis? Claudia F. Lucchinetti, MD Professor of Neurology Mayo Clinic, Rochester MN Prototypic MS RR SPBenign MS RIS Restricted Distribution NMO/NMOSD Relapsing Myelitis Relapsing ON Fulminant Marburg MS ADEM/AHLE BCS Isolated ON Transverse myelitis Chronicity Severity Progressive Chronic myelopathy Cerebellar syndrome Courtesy: Brian Weinshenker
52

Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

Apr 26, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

1

Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a

Specific Diagnosis?

Claudia F. Lucchinetti, MD

Professor of Neurology

Mayo Clinic, Rochester MN

Prototypic MS“RR SP”

Benign MSRIS

Restricted DistributionNMO/NMOSD

Relapsing MyelitisRelapsing ON

FulminantMarburg MS ADEM/AHLE

BCS

IsolatedON

Transverse myelitis

Chronicity

Severity

ProgressiveChronic

myelopathyCerebellar syndrome

Courtesy: Brian Weinshenker

Page 2: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

2

Spectrum of CNS Inflammatory Demyelinating Diseases (IDDs)Spectrum of CNS Inflammatory Demyelinating Diseases (IDDs)

• May mimic or be mimicked by brain tumors, infectious encephalitides, granulomatous disorders, and other inflammatory disorders

• May present with focal, multifocal, or non-localizing neurological deficits

• Differentiation between specific inflammatory demyelinating diseases can be challenging

• Clinical and Therapeutic Implications

• Pathology Can Aid in Diagnosis

Prototypic MSPrototypic MS

Page 3: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

3

Pathological Hallmarks of MSPathological Hallmarks of MS

MS Plaque TypesMS Plaque Types

ACTIVE SMOLDERING INACTIVE SHADOW

D

HFE G

Page 4: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

4

T cell/macrophage associated

Pattern I Pattern II

Antibody/complementassociated

C

Pattern III

Distal oligodendro-

gliopathy

Pattern IV

Primary oligodendrocyte

degeneration

Patient Dependent Hetergogeneity

Lucchinetti/Brück et al., Ann. Neurol., 2000

Focal White Matter Lesion in Early MSHeterogenous Mechanisms of Demyelination

T cells/Macrophages(Cytokines, radicals)

Antibody/Complement

Increased CNSvulnerability

Page 5: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

5

Distinguishing Pathological Features

Distinguishing Pathological Features

PATTERN I PATTERN II PATTERN III PATTERN IV

Perivenous +++ +++ +/- NA

Sharp borders +++ +++ - NA

Ill-definedborder

- - +++ NA

Complement - ++ - -

MAG loss - - +++ -

OG apoptosis +/- +/- +++ ++

RM +++ +++ +/- NA

T cells/MOs +++ +++ +++ +/-

Cortical Demyelination Extensive in Progressive MS

(Bo et al. J Neuropath Exp Neurol 2003; Kutzelnigg et al. Brain 2005; Brain Pathol 2007)

Cortical Demyelination Extensive in Progressive MS

(Bo et al. J Neuropath Exp Neurol 2003; Kutzelnigg et al. Brain 2005; Brain Pathol 2007)

Page 6: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

6

Subpial Demyelination Only Observed in MSBruck et al.

Subpial Demyelination Only Observed in MSBruck et al.

• 251 tissue blocks/122 cases/20 different diseases

-Viral encephalitis (herpes, measles, CMV, PML),

-Bacterial meningitis (pneumococcus,

staphylococcus, haemophilus influenzae, syphilis,

tuberculosis),

-Neoplastic disorders (lymphoma, carcinoma)

-Metabolic disorders (central pontine myelinolysis)

180 tissue blocks from 33 MS cases

SUBPIAL DM ONLY SEEN IN MS

Radiologically Isolated Syndromes

Radiologically Isolated Syndromes

Page 7: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

7

Case HistoryCase History• Healthy asymtomatic subject volunteered to

undergo research MRI

• MRI: numerous periventricular WM lesions, large tumefactive ring enhancing lesion left frontal lobe

• Normal Neurological Examination

• Normal CBC, Lyme, Toxo antibodies, anti-cardiolipin antibodies, ACE, ESR, RPR, ANA, ENA, HIV and CSF

• Brain biopsy at two sites; “Gliosis in site #1 and ganglioma in site #2.

Case HistoryCase History

• Despite no Sxs, treated with 3 days of IVMP and Copaxone for two years

• Followup MRIs revealed resolution of enhancement and reduced size of the tumefactive lesion

• 2007-2013: developed single new non-enhancing T2 lesion left hemisphere

• Clinically stable; on no Tx and asymptomatic

• Biopsy sent for re-review

Page 8: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

8

NFLFB/PAS

CD68 GFAP

RIS Take Home MessagesRIS Take Home Messages

• Pathology does not differentiate asymptomatic RIS from RRMS

• Active demyelination can be seen in asymptomatic RIS

• Axonal injury is evident in RIS despite asymptomatic onset

• RIS can involve both WM and Cortex

Page 9: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

9

Spectrum of CNS Inflammatory Demyelinating Diseases

Spectrum of CNS Inflammatory Demyelinating Diseases

• Marburg variant of acute MS

• Balo’s Concentric Sclerosis

• Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis

• Acute Hemorrhagic Leukoencephalitis

• Tumefactive Demyelinating Lesions

• Neuromyelitis Optica/NMO Spectrum Disorders

Marburg MSMarburg MS

Page 10: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

10

Marburg MSMarburg MS

• 1906 Marburg described 3 cases of fulminant demyelinating disease

• Malignant course

• Rapid progression with death within 1 year

• Hemiplegia, hemianopsia, aphasia, seizures, confusion

• Pathology-Active Confluent Demyelination

-Admixture of astrocytes/myelin-laden macrophages

-Inflammation with variable T cells

-More destructive than classic MS

Marburg MS: 30 yo F; 3 wk hx of rapidly progressive left hemiparesis and neglect; raised ICP

12/24/1994

1/08/1995

Page 11: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

11

Pathology: Marburg MS

LFB/PAS Myelin

Bielschowsky Axon

Marburg MSMarburg MS• Classification in literature confusing as clinical

and radiographic phenotype can be seen in:

-ADEM, TDL, NMO

-Brain Tumor

-Abscess

• 18.5 kDa isoform of MBP is less cationic than the MBP of normal and classic MS due deamination of arginyl residues generating citrulline.

-May cause structural instability of central myelin sheath (Wood et al. 1996; Beniac et al. 1999)

Page 12: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

12

Balo’s Concentric SclerosisBalo’s Concentric Sclerosis

Balo’s Concentric Sclerosis Balo’s Concentric Sclerosis • Josef Balo (1929): Hungarian neuropathologist

• “leuko-encephalitis periaxialis concentrica”

• Course: Benign to Fulminant

• Young adults: 34 yrs (3-62)

• Predilection for SE Asian ancestry

• Lesions in cerebral hemispheres, optic chiasm, cerebellum, brainstem, spinal cord

• HA, cognitive/behavioral, hemiparesis, ataxia, dysarthria, aphasia, seizures

• Mimics ADEM or tumor

Page 13: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

13

Balo’s Concentric SclerosisBalo’s Concentric Sclerosis• Unique Concentric pathology

LFB/PAS

BielschowskyCD68Myelin LFB/PAS

Rovira et Al, Neuroradiology 2007

Antemortem dx possible via MRIAntemortem dx possible via MRI

Page 14: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

14

BCS Lesions Show MAG Loss-Pattern III

BCS Lesions Show MAG Loss-Pattern III

CD68 PLP

MOG MAG

Stadelmann et al, Brain 2005

Myelin Axon CD 68 D110

HYPOXIC-PRECONDITIONING

Page 15: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

15

CADASIL MUTATION AND BALO CONCENTRICSCLEROSIS: A LINK BETWEEN DEMYELINATION

AND ISCHEMIA?Chitnis et al. Neurology 2012

CADASIL MUTATION AND BALO CONCENTRICSCLEROSIS: A LINK BETWEEN DEMYELINATION

AND ISCHEMIA?Chitnis et al. Neurology 2012

Page 16: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

16

Balo’s Concentric SclerosisBalo’s Concentric Sclerosis

• Concentric lesions described in MS, Marburg MS, and NMO/NMOSD

ADEM/AHLEADEM/AHLE

Page 17: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

17

• Rare, typically monophasic; favorable prognosis

• Children > Adults ( age < 10 yrs); M>F

• First event: acute/subacute; polyfocal; “encephalopathy”

• Relapsing forms: MDEM

• Post-infection or vaccination (+/-)

• CSF: generally absent OCBs

• MRI

Multifocal (WM / cortical / deep GM)

Large lesions

Fuzzy-borders

Similar age (All enhancing)

• Diagnosis of Exclusion (overlap with NMO, MS, BCS)

ADEM: Clinical DefinitionsTenembaum et al 2000, Mikaeloff et al 2006, Dale et al 2000, Leake et al 2004, Anlar et al 2003, Schwarz et al 2001, Marchioni et al 2005, Lin et al 2007; Krupp et al. 2007; Krupp et al. 2013

ADEM

(Prineas 2002; Greenfield’s Neuropathology)

PeriVenous Demyelination in ADEM

MS

CONFLUENT DM

Page 18: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

18

ADEM: 30 F; HA, N,V, encephalopathy and gait impairment over 4 weeksADEM: 30 F; HA, N,V, encephalopathy and gait impairment over 4 weeks

CSF: WBC 8; PRO 248; OCB -

Page 19: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

19

Patterns of Perivenous DMPatterns of Perivenous DMPerivenous DM Coalescent DM

Confluent DM

PPWMn=3

n=7n=13

PV / CON: n=1PV / CL / CON: n=2

Pattern of Demyelination and Course

Pattern n Monophasic Relapsing

PV alone 4 4 0

PV + CL 6 5 1

PV + CON 3 1 (fatal) 2

Page 20: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

20

Clinical Correlates of Perivenous DM

Clinical Correlates of Perivenous DM

• Compared with the Confluent DM cohort (n=91; 90% MS), the Perivenous DM cohort was more likely to present with:

Encephalopathy (p < 0.004)

Depressed level of consciousness (DLC) (p < 0.001)

Headache (p < 0.001)

Meningismus (p < 0.005)

CSF pleocytosis (p < 0.02)

• Depressed LOC distinguishes ADEM from MS-Broadly defined “encephalopathy” does not

Broad Spectrum of MRI Findings Associated with Perivenous DMBroad Spectrum of MRI Findings Associated with Perivenous DM

Page 21: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

21

•Subpial and intracortical DM

•Unique pattern of cortical microglial activation and aggregation

• Only in PVD patients w/ decreased LOC (n=10) • None in Confluent DM cohort.

•? Substrate of ADEM encephalopathy

Cortical Pathology in ADEMCortical Pathology in ADEM

Histology ADEM & MSPathology ADEM MS

Macrophages ++ ++

Granulocytes ++ +/-

Perivenous (WM) DM ++ --

Coalescence +/- --

Confluence + +++

Perivenous (GM) DM ++ -

Microglial Cortical aggregate (GM) +++ -

Subpial DM ++ +++

Page 22: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

22

ADEM Take Home MessagesADEM Take Home Messages1. Pathology helpful in diagnosis of ADEM

2. The presence of PV +/- coalescence DM is associated with a monophasic course (survival or fatal)

3. ADEM demonstrates a unique cortical pathology associated with LOC

4. PV DM cases can be associated with confluent DM (? ADEM and MS share Pathogenic Spectrum)

5. Confluent DM in association with PV DM may be associated with a greater risk of recurrence: ? MDEM versus MS

Acute Hemorrhagic LeukoencephalitisAcute Hemorrhagic Leukoencephalitis

• Hurst 1941: Rare

• Viral prodrome

• Demyelination w/ hemorrhage (usually small, petechial)

• Severe, often fatal

(Prineas 2002; Greenfield’s Neuropathology)

Page 23: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

23

AHLE: 21 M ; paresthesias; diplopia, gait ataxia, L facial weakness, dysarthria; respiratory compromise;

refractory to steroids/plasma exchange; died 1 mo

AHLE: 21 M ; paresthesias; diplopia, gait ataxia, L facial weakness, dysarthria; respiratory compromise;

refractory to steroids/plasma exchange; died 1 mo

CSF: WBC 25 pro 70 mg/dL, 0 OCB

2/2/2009

2/28/2009

Page 24: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

24

MOG-Associated Encephalomyelitis

(Spadaro et al. 2015)

MOG-Associated Encephalomyelitis

(Spadaro et al. 2015)

• 66 yo Caucasian woman

• 2011: Transverse Myelitis

• AQP4-IgG and NMDA Abs negative

• 2012: TM; brainstem syndrome

• MOG Abs positive

• Rituximab with complete B cell depletion

• Massive brain lesions

• Brain Biopsy: Type II pathology

Page 25: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

25

MOG-Ab Associated PathologyMOG-Ab Associated Pathology

MOG Ab Associated Demyelinating Disease

MOG Ab Associated Demyelinating Disease

• First pathological case of MOG-Abassociated demyelinating disease

• MOG Ab may be pathogenic-MOG Ab binds to extracellular domain

-Abs can access CNS via open BBB

-MOG Abs have a complement activating isotype

-Histopathology resembles MOG-EAE; Type II pathology

-

Page 26: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

26

Tumefactive Demyelinating Lesions

Tumefactive Demyelinating Lesions

Tumefactive Demyelinating LesionsTumefactive Demyelinating Lesions

• MS may present as a mass lesion(s) indistinguishable clinically and radiologically from a tumor

• Clear definition lacking• Present with cerebral

symptoms• Uni/multifocal; edema;

mass effect• Diagnostic difficulty;

brain biopsy may be necessary

• Biopsy specimen may resemble a tumor (Creutzfelt cells)

Open ring sign (Masdeu1996)

Page 27: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

27

• Presence of foamy macrophages, particularly in the absence of coagulative necrosis

• Intimate admixture of macrophages and astrocytes

• Even distribution of reactive astrocytes

• Creutzfeldt cells (“granular mitoses”)

• Sharply circumscribed white matter lesions

TDLs Histological Features of

Inflammatory Demyelination

TDLs Histological Features of

Inflammatory Demyelination

Clinical Courses Associated with Tumefactive Demyelination

1. Fulminant course to death--Marburg variant

2. Monophasic attack with recovery

3. Tumefactive presentation followed by typical RRMS

4. Typical MS course with subsequent tumefactive attack

5. RR course with strictly tumefactive attacks

Page 28: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

28

Pt. #1: Monophasic to Death “Marburg MS”

Pt. #2: Monophasic Course with Recovery

Page 29: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

29

#3 Tumefactive presentation followed by RRMS

1988

2001

1992Disease duration 17yrs

EDSS=3

Pt. #4: RRMS followed by tumefactive relapses

8/18/1993

2/15/1994

Page 30: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

30

#5 RR course with tumefactive attacks

Disease duration=13yrs EDSS=1

1990

1996

2001

2cm L parietal + satellite (x2) lesions

Bx: grade III glioma

Rx: whole brain XRT

subsequent radiosurgery

Re-review of slides: active demyelination

Progressive deterioration

Died 6.25 yrs after onset

38 yo F: subacute onset L arm and face paresthesias

Radiation Necrosis

Page 31: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

31

Diagnostic PitfallMisdiagnosis as Astrocytoma

Diagnostic PitfallMisdiagnosis as Astrocytoma

Creutzfelt Cells

Page 32: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

32

Radiographic Features of TDLsRadiographic Features of TDLs

Large lesion size (0.5-7.5 cm)

Mass effect (45%)

Edema (77%)

Gadolinium enhancement (95%)

Ring-enhancement pattern common

Butterfly configuration involving corpus callosum (7%)

Lucchinetti et al., 2008

Common Prebiopsy TDL Enhancement PatternsCommon Prebiopsy TDL Enhancement Patterns

Heterogenous 32%Heterogenous 32%

Homogenous 8%Homogenous 8%

Ring, arc, open ring 42.5%Ring, arc, open ring 42.5%

Open ring cortex Open ring cortex

Lucchinetti et al., 2008

Page 33: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

33

Uncommon Prebiopsy TDL Enhancement PatternsUncommon Prebiopsy TDL Enhancement Patterns

Punctate 3%

Concentric 1%

No enhancement 15%

Nodular >2mm 0.5%Nodular >2mm 0.5%

Diffuse/ patchy 4%Diffuse/ patchy 4%

Fluffy 1%Fluffy 1%

OTHEROTHER

Lucchinetti et al., 2008

The Spectrum of Biopsied Tumefactive MS Lucchinetti et al. Brain 2008

The Spectrum of Biopsied Tumefactive MS Lucchinetti et al. Brain 2008

1. Detailed clinical F/U of 168 cases: > 90% patients develop clinically definite MS

2. Despite atypical MRI at presentation, most are multifocal on MRI prior to biopsy

3. 20% develop recurrent TDLs

4. Often good prognosisDisability at last f/u better than MS prevalence cohort

matched for disease duration >10 yrs

Longer interval to second attack (median 4.8 years)

Page 34: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

34

Diffusion Weighted Imaging Characteristics of Biopsy-Proven Demyelinating Brain Lesions

(AbouZeid et al. 2012)

Diffusion Weighted Imaging Characteristics of Biopsy-Proven Demyelinating Brain Lesions

(AbouZeid et al. 2012)

• 40 ADC maps reviewed from 30 patients

• 93% of lesions were enhancing

52% ring-enhancement pattern

• Compared to cohort of ring-enhancing tumors/abscess

• Variable ADC map in IDD

7% normal diffusion

33% restricted

60% increased

• Features to suggest IDD

57% had change in pattern on serial imaging

Peripheral restriction

Variable ADC Patterns in TDLsVariable ADC Patterns in TDLs

Page 35: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

35

Pattern of Diffusion RestrictionAbscess vs TDL

Pattern of Diffusion RestrictionAbscess vs TDL

• AbscessA) ADC map showing

central restriction

C) post-gad ring enhancement

• Demyelinating LesionB) ADC map showing

peripheral restriction

D) post-gad enhancement

Abou Zeid et al., 2012

Rapid DW/ADC Changes in TDLsRapid DW/ADC Changes in TDLs

Page 36: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

36

TDLs Take Home MessagesTDLs Take Home Messages• Classification of TDLs in literature

confusing

• TDLs can be found in:• Prototypic MS

• Marburg MS

• Balo’s Concentric Sclerosis

• NMO/NMOSD

• ADEM/AHLE

• Both pattern II and pattern III immunopathologies can be assocwith TDLs

NMO/NMOSDNMO/NMOSD

Page 37: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

37

What is NMO?What is NMO?

• Relapsing > Monophasic

• Any interval between attacks

• ON — unilateral or bilateral

• Longitudinally extensive myelitis in active disease

• Brain Involvement described

• AQP4-IgG: Specific and sensitive pathogenic auto-antibody

• Relapsing > Monophasic

• Any interval between attacks

• ON — unilateral or bilateral

• Longitudinally extensive myelitis in active disease

• Brain Involvement described

• AQP4-IgG: Specific and sensitive pathogenic auto-antibody

•Destructive lesions

•Eosinophils

•Perivascular immune complex deposition

•Humoralimmunity targeting perivascular space

Pathological Hallmarks

Lucchinetti; Brain, 2002

Rim Rosettes

IgG IgM

C9neo C9neo

Page 38: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

38

Destructive, DemyelinatedDestructive, Demyelinated

Lesion Types in NMO

Myelin AQP4C9neo

Myelin AQP4C9neo

Non‐Destructive, Non‐Demyelinated

Active MS shows Increase AQP4

NMO lesions show AQP4 loss

Active demyelination

Myelin preservation

No perivascular rosettes;Myelin debris in macrophages

Perivascular rosettes;Macrophages negative

Perivascular AQP4 enhanced

AQP4 loss

Myelin AQP4C9neo

Myelin C9neo AQP4

Page 39: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

39

CP1221732-3

“NMO-typical”Brain Lesions are in AQP4-rich Sites

Arch Neurol. 2006;63(7):964-8

NMO and the BRAINNMO and the BRAIN

NMO BRAIN LESIONS

Myelin C9neo AQP4

Page 40: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

40

• Supraspinal Neuromyelitis Optica (NMO) lesions may show complement deposits in combination with MAG loss and oligodendrocyte apoptosis

• Mimics an overlap of pattern II and pattern III

Bruck et al. Ann Neurol 2012

Apoptosis AQP-4

C9neo

MAG

NMO Brain Lesions Can Mimic Immunopattern Overlap

NMO Brain Lesions Can Mimic Immunopattern Overlap

Spectrum of early non-lytic astrocytic abnormalities: early stress response in NMO

Astrocyte Mitoses Multinucleated Astrocytes

Y. Guo

Rosenthal Fibers

Reactive Gliosis

Page 41: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

41

PLP

GFAP

Early Perivascular Astrocytic Loss in NMO but Preserved in MS

Early Perivascular Astrocytic Loss in NMO but Preserved in MS

PLP

GFAP

LFP/PAS

GFAP

NMO MS

Granulocytic InfiltrationProminent in NMO Rare in MS

Granulocytic InfiltrationProminent in NMO Rare in MS

NMO MS

Page 42: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

42

Early Eosinophil Recruitment in Vacuolated Perivascular Regions

H/E

C9neo

Early astrocyte responses drive early granulocytic recruitment:

complement deposition not required

Early astrocyte responses drive early granulocytic recruitment:

complement deposition not required

• 23.5% of regions examined had mild or marked granulocytic infiltration in the absence of complement deposition

23 patiets337 blocks

1048 regions examined

Page 43: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

43

Creutzfeldt-Peters Cell Present in MS but Absent in NMO

Creutzfeldt-Peters Cell Present in MS but Absent in NMO

PLP, 4x AQP4, 4x

GFAP, 40x

Astrocyte Death in Advanced NMO Lesion

Astrocyte Death in Advanced NMO Lesion

GFAP GFAP GFAP

Page 44: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

44

Cortical DM is Absent in NMOPopescu et al. Neurology 2010

Cortical DM is Absent in NMOPopescu et al. Neurology 2010

Meningeal Inflammation Differs in MS vs MNMOMeningeal Inflammation Differs in MS vs MNMO

CD20

PLP

CD3

PLP NF

Kim1p Neutrophils/LCN2

CD3 CD8 CD20

MS: Lymphocytic NMO: Plasma cell/Granulocytc

Page 45: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

45

Meningeal Lymphoid Follicles“PRESENT” in MS/ABSENT in NMO

Meningeal Lymphoid Follicles“PRESENT” in MS/ABSENT in NMO

Ki67CD35

CD20

CD20

CD20

CD20

Roberta Magliozzi et al. Brain 2007;130:1089-1104

MS NMO

Case 65 year old Female Presenting with Tumefactive Brain

Lesion

Case 65 year old Female Presenting with Tumefactive Brain

Lesion

• 2/2006: subacute onset right lower quadrantanopsia

• MRI brain: enhancing left occipital lesion

later involved both occipital lobes. MRI spine negative

• 8/2006: Brain biopsy “active demyelination”; dx MS

• CSF normal; VERs prolonged bilaterally

• 2007-2009: Glatiramer acetate started and courses of IVMP for exacerbations of visual dysfunction and cognitive impairment

Page 46: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

46

Follow-upFollow-up

• Pt seen back 4 years after onset, with new Gad-enhancing lesions on brain MRI

• Copaxone stopped and pt began IV steroids and pulse cyclo-phosphamide

• Re-review of original brain biopsy showed changes consistent with NMO (neuromyelitis optica)

Page 47: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

47

PLP; 10X AQP4; 10X

GFAP; 10X HE; 100X

FollowupFollowup• NMO-IgG testing recommended;

serum was positive

• Patient treated with Cytoxan

• Relapse LETM 3/2010 (first “typical”NMO relapse); 4 years AFTER onset

• Brain Lesions can be presenting symptoms in NMO

• Brain biopsy was “diagnostic”; prompted NMO-IgG testing

Page 48: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

48

Diagnostic Utility of AQP4 in Active Demyelinating Lesions (Popescu et al. 2015)

Diagnostic Utility of AQP4 in Active Demyelinating Lesions (Popescu et al. 2015)

• Retrospective analysis of 20 surgical biopsies (19 pts; 11 brain/9 spinal cord)

• Inclusion Criteria: 2 of 3 AQP4 associated neuropathologicalfindings

Vacuolated Myelin

Granulocytes

AstrocyticInjury

NMO Spinal Cord n=9

NMO Brain n=9

MS Brain n=2

AQP4 ImmunohistochemistryAQP4 Immunohistochemistry

Page 49: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

49

©2013 MFMER | 3306930-97

Dystrophic astrocytes

GFAP + macrophages

AQP4 in PPWM

Creutzfeldt cells

Myelin vacuolation

Vascular hyalinization

Granulocytes

NMO/NMOSD

LETM/rLETM

RRMS

NMO-IgG+

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

Patient

Pat

ho

log

ical

Fea

ture

s o

n B

iop

syC

lin

ical

Ou

tco

mes

AQP4 LossAQP4

Increase

©2013 MFMER | 3306930-98

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 3 6 8 10 0 15 26 11 4 7 952

Months Years

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

TMONBilateral ON

Brain syndromeN/V

BiopsyDeath

15 yrs

15 yrs

26 yrs

Pat

ien

t

Spinal cord biopsy

Brain biopsy

Page 50: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

50

SummarySummary

• AQP4 Immunohistochemistry useful in identifying cases of NMO/NMOSD

• NMOSD should be considered in DDxof tumefactive brain or spinal cord lesions

• AQP4-IgG testing may avert biopsy and avoid ineffective therapies if treated erroneously for MS

CNS-INFLAMMATORY DEMYELINATING SYNDROMES

CNS-INFLAMMATORY DEMYELINATING SYNDROMES

BALO’S CONCETRIC SCLEROSIS

NMO/NMOSD

MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS

MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS

ADEM/AHLE

MARBURG

Page 51: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

51

Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

PATHOLOGY DIAGNOSIS

Confluent Demyelination MS/Marburg/TDLs

Perivenular Demyelination ADEM/AHLE

Concentric Demyelination BCS/Marburg/NMOSD/TDLs

Immunopatterns I-IVIIIII

MS/TDLsMS/Marburg/MOG-AbMS/BCS/NMO/NMOSD

Subpial Cortical DM MS/ADEM

Perivenular Hemorrhages AHLE

Astrocytopathy BCS/AHLE/NMO/NMOSD

Vasculocentric Complement NMO/NMOSD

AQP4 loss in active DM NMO/NMOSD

Thank you for your attention!

Page 52: Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can … · 2018-04-02 · 6/18/2015 1 Pathologic Features of CNS Demyelinating Disease: Can Pathology Lead to a Specific Diagnosis?

6/18/2015

52

Univ Vienna:H. Lassmann; J FrisherUniv Vienna:H. Lassmann; J Frisher

CollaboratorsCollaborators

Univ of Gottingen:W. Bruck,; I MetzUniv of Gottingen:W. Bruck,; I Metz

Mayo Clinic: B. Popescu.; Y Guo, C Howe, M Caulfiled; Parisi JE; B Weinshenker; S Pittock; V Lennon; A McKEon; D Wingerchuk;  P Zeimer; L Linbo; S. Weigand

Mayo Clinic: B. Popescu.; Y Guo, C Howe, M Caulfiled; Parisi JE; B Weinshenker; S Pittock; V Lennon; A McKEon; D Wingerchuk;  P Zeimer; L Linbo; S. Weigand

CNS Inflammatory Demyelinating Syndromes

CNS-IDS

Anti-MOGBCSNMO/NMOSD TM/rTMCRION MarburgADEM/AHLE

MSCIS RIS

Relapses Chronicprogression

Active DM plaque heterogenous patterns

I II III IV SmolderingWM plaque

CDM “NAWM”

Primary 0Gdegeneration

Hypoxia/mitochondrial

Ab/CTcells/M