I P fILEDI I JAN3Ui 1 ‘1 IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS RECEIVED FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT CLERK BLUE RIDGE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE) LEAGUE, ) ) Petitioner, ) Case No. 18—1 0132 ) v. ) ) FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY ) COMMISSION, and UNITED STATES ) OF AMERICA, ) ) Respondents. ) ) PETITION TO REVIEW A FINAL ORDER OF THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION Pursuant to Section 19(b) of the Natural Gas Act, 15 U.S.C. § 717r(b), Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure 15, and Circuit Rule 15, notice is hereby given that the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense Fund (“BREDL”) hereby petitions the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit for review of the order of Respondent Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“the Commission”) Issuing Certificates and Granting Abandonment Authority (“Order”) in Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC, 161 FERC ¶ 61,043 (2017), entered on October 13, 2017 (FERC Accession No. (20171013-4002). BREDL was an intervenor in the Commission proceedings below. BREDL brings this action on behalf of itself, its chapters Preserve Roanoke and Preserve 1 USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 1 of 57
57
Embed
P I 1 RECEIVED FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT …blogs2.law.columbia.edu/climate-change-litigation/wp-content/... · drdolittle0808“1gmail .com Jason Boyle 3930 Horsefarm
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
IPfILEDI I
JAN3Ui 1 ‘1
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
RECEIVED FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT CLERK
PETITION TO REVIEW A FINAL ORDEROF THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Pursuant to Section 19(b) of the Natural Gas Act, 15 U.S.C. § 717r(b),
Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure 15, and Circuit Rule 15, notice is hereby
given that the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense Fund (“BREDL”) hereby
petitions the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
for review of the order of Respondent Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
(“the Commission”) Issuing Certificates and Granting Abandonment Authority
(“Order”) in Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC, 161 FERC ¶ 61,043 (2017), entered
on October 13, 2017 (FERC Accession No. (20171013-4002).
BREDL was an intervenor in the Commission proceedings below. BREDL
brings this action on behalf of itself, its chapters Preserve Roanoke and Preserve
1
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 1 of 57
c y
Franklin, and its members and supporters, whose use and enjoyment of their
properties and of the scenic, historic and environmental resources in Roanoke and
Franklin Counties, Virginia will be adversely affected as a result of the decision
of the Commission challenged herein,
BREDL filed a timely request for rehearing of the Order, arguing, among
other things, that the Commission’s order was issued in violation of law,
including but not limited to the National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”), 42
U.S.C. § 4321 et secj., and Section 106 of the Historic Preservation Act, 54 U.S.C.
§ 306108. BREDL included in this motion a request for a stay of the Order
pending the Commission’s certificate.
BREDL’s request for rehearing was denied by operation of law pursuant to
15 U.S.C. § 717r(a) because the Commission did not lawfully act on the request
within thirty days. Instead, on December 13, 2017, Commission staff issued a
“tolling order” (FERC Accession No. 201712 13-3061), which purports to grant
BREDL’s request for rehearing solely “for the limited purpose of further
consideration.” The Commission staffs “tolling order” was not lawful and thus
did not prevent denial of BREDL’s request for hearing by operation of law
because authority to act on a request for rehearing paired with a motion to stay
has not been delegated by the Commission to staff. See Delegation of Authority
to the Secretary, the Director of the Office Electric Power Regulation and the
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 2 of 57
General Counsel, 60 fed. Reg. 62,326, 62,327 (Dec. 6, 1995). The staff also
lacked authority to issue a “tolling order” because the Natural Gas Act does not
permit the Commission to delegate such authority. See 15 U.S.C. § 717r(a).
finally, a “tolling order” does not constitute an “act” on a request for rehearing
under the Natural Gas Act. Id. Thus, Petitioner’s request for rehearing was denied
by operation of law and this Court has jurisdiction to review the Order Issuing
Certificates and Granting Abandonment pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 717r(b).
BREDL respectfully requests that this Court enter an order vacating this
Order pending the Commission’s compliance with applicable laws, including but
not limited to NEPA and Section 106.
Respectfully submitted,
Andrea C. Ferster (D.C. Bar # 384648)2121 Ward Court, N.W., 5th Fl.Washington, D.C. 20037(202) 974-5142(202) 223-9257(fax)[email protected]
Attorney for Petitioner
January 3, 2018
3
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 3 of 57
A
Certificate of Service
I hereby certify under penalty of peijury that on January 3, 2018, a copy ofthe foregoing Petition for Review was served by email on the following parties,including all members of the service list in FERC Docket Numbers CP16-10-000;CP16-13-000:
James DanlyGeneral CounselFederal Energy Regulatory Commission888 First Street. N.E.Washington. DC 20426james.danl yferc .gov
Robert SolomonSolicitorFederal Energy Regulatory Commission888 first Street, N.E.Washington, DC 20426robert. solomonferc .gov
Eleanor Amidon931 Tanbark Dr.
Eleanor Arnidon Afton. VIRGINIA 22920UNITED STATESelamidontj uno.com
sandra schlaudecker4254 fortress drive
sandrablacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060
schlaudeckrU1’JITED STATESspspas”d’aol.com
Carolyn Reilly404 Old Mill Creek Lane
Carolyn Reilly Rocky Mount, VIRGINIA 24151UNITED STATEScarolynreilly3gmail .com
Carl Zipper3910 Horse Farm Road
Carl ZipperBlacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATES
4
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 4 of 57
skybluenrv2 6grnai1. corn
Donna Riley341$ Deer Run Rd
Donna Riley Blacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESdonnamrileyyahoo.com
Louisa Gay3925 Horse farm Rd.
Louisa Gay Blacksburg. VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESlgay(vt.edu
Bill Dooley4793 Preston Forest Drive
Bill Doolev Blacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESbdooleyvt.edu
Stephen LeggeP0 Box 291
Stephen Legge Newport, VIRGINIA 2412$UNITED STATEShilldweller73 (yahoo.com
Ernest ReedWild Virginia President971 Rainbow Ridge Road
Ernest ReedFaber, VIRGINIA 2293$UNITED STATESlec(wildvirginia.org
David Werner51 3 Parkview Dr
David Werner Rocky Mount. VIRGINIA 24151UNITED STATESdavefourcornersfarm.com
Virginia Cross11317 Haibrooke Court
Virginia Cross Richmond, VIRGINIA 23233UNITED STATESCross .vagmail.corn
Dennis BryantDennis M Bryant
Dennis Bryant -
97 Cedar Meadow DrNellysford. VIRGINIA 2295$
5
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 5 of 57
ConservancyWaiteville. WEST VIRGINIA 24984UNITED STATESborderconservancyi gmail.com
Cahas Moutain John BernardRural Historic Founder. Cahas Mountain PreserDistrict 221 Glascock Street
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 35 of 57
Raleigh, NC. NORTH CAROLINA27604UNITED STATESjpbernard)earthlink.net
Joseph FaganPresident, Cave Conservancy of
Cave 13131 Overhill Lake LaneConservancy of Glen Allen, VA 23059, VIRGINIAthe Virginias 23059
UNITED STATEScave.conservancy.ofvat’)gmail.com
Paul SavageConsolidated Consolidated Edison Development, Inc.Edison 4 Irving Place, room I 875-sCompany of New York. NEW YORK 10003New York. Inc. UNITED STATES
savagepconed.com
Joel deJesusDinsmore & Shohl LLP11520 Highview Avenue
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 39 of 57
MontgomeryCountyGovernment
MountainValley PipelineLLC
MotintainValley PipelineLLC
Nancy TurnerProgram AssistantMontgomery County Government755 Roanoke St Ste 2FChristiansburg. VIRGINIA 24073UNITED STATEStumememontgomerycountyva.gov
Matthew EggerdingCounsel. MidstreamEQT Corporation625 Liberty AvenuePittsburgh, PENNSYLVANIA 15222UNITED STATESmeggerdingeqt. corn
Mark R ZakutanskyMid-Atlantic Policy ManagerAppalachian Mountain Club520 Long StreetAppalachian Mountain ClubBethlehem. PENNSYLVANIA18018mzakutansky(outdoors.org
MountainValley PipelineLLC
MountainValley PipelineLLC
NATURALRESOURCESDEFENSECOUNCIL
New RiverConservancy
Gregory BuppertSenior AttorneySOUTHERN ENVIRONMENTALLAW CENTER201 West Main Street. Suite 14Charlottesville, VIRGINIA 22901UNITED STATESgbuppertselcva.org
George SantucciNew River ConservancyI N. Jefferson Ave. Suite DWest Jefferson. NORTH CAROLINA28694UNITED STATESgeorgenewriverconservancy.org
Mara RobbinsVirginia Coordinator, Blue Rid110 Talley’s AlleyFloyd, VIRGINIA 24091mara.robbinsgmail.com
Louis A ZellerExecutive DirectorBlue Ridge EnvironmentalDefense League, Inc.P0 Box 88Glendale Springs. 28629-0088bredLskybest.com
40
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 40 of 57
NextEra EnergyPowerMarketing. LLC
NorfolkSouthernRailwayCompany
Ohio ValleyEnvironmentalCoalition
Peoples NaturalGas CompanyLLC
Peoples NaturalGas CompanyLLC
william lavarcoNextEra Energy Companies801 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Suite 220washington. DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20004UNITED STATESwilliam.lavarco(nexteraenergy.com
Helen HartGeneral SolicitorNorfolk Southern Railway Company3 Commercial PlaceNorfolk. VIRGINIA 23510UNITED STATEShelen.harti’nscorp.com
Vivian Stockmanproject coordinatorP0 Box A753
Huntington. WESTUNITED STATESvivianohvec.org
Christopher BarrAttorneyPost & Schell. P.C.607 14th St., N.W.Suite 600Washington. DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20005-2006UNITED STATEScbarrpostschell.com
Amy C SouthCo-chair The Border ConservancThe Border Conservancy5249 Waiteville RdWaiteville, WEST VIRGINIA24984pipelinefborderwv.org
Jane Lewis-RaymondVice President - General CounsPiedmont Natural Gas4720 Piedmont Row DrCharlotte. NORTH CARUNITED STATESpiedmontferc(ipiedmontng.com
mark JoynerPittsylvania County Historical
Scott ButlerConsolidated Edison Company ofNew York. Inc. and Orange andRockland Utilities. Inc.4 Irving PlaceNew York. NEW YORK 10003butlers(i)coned.com
Robert L ClineVP Engr
VIRGINIA 25773
PiedmontNatural GasCompany, Inc
PittsylvaniaCounty
OLINA 28210
41
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 41 of 57
Historical Pittsylvania County Historical Society 4425 Anjean RoadSociety P.O Box 976 Rupert, WEST VIRGINIA 25984
Chatham, VIRGINIA 24531 bcIine(coronadocoal.comUNITED STATEShistoricalarchaeologist2)yahoo.com
Roberta Bondurant11577 Bottom Creek Road (POB 96)
Preserve BentBent Mountain. VIRGINIA 24059
MountainUNITED STATESbondurantlawt),aol. corn
Rebecca Dameron10721 Bent Mountain Rd
Preserve BentBent Mountain, VIRGINIA 24059
MountainUNITED STATESbecdarneron(cox .net
Susan CrenshawcoordinatorPreserve Craig
Preserve Craig 49 Race StreetNew Castle, VIRGINIA 24127UNITED STATESPreservecraig1grnail.com
Richard ShinglesDr.
Preserve Giles 321 Dunford LaneCounty Newport. VIRGINIA 24128
UNITED STATESnorner(pemtel.net
Donna Pitt216 Zells Mill Rd
Preserve GilesNewport. VIRGINIA 24128
CountyUNITED STATEScvmdsp(ivt.edu
Richard ShinglesDr.
Preserve Giles 321 Dunford LaneCounty Newport. VIRGINIA 24128
UNITED STATESnomeraipemtel.net
Preserve Giles Donna Pitt Ronald D WaitherCounty 216 Zells Mill Rd Dorninion Resources Services,
42
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 42 of 57
Donna Pitt216 Zeus Mill RdNewport. VIRGINIA 24128UNITED STATEScvmdsp@,vt.edu
Carl ZipperPreserve Montgomery County VA3910 Horse Farm RoadBlacksburg. VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESgreen.nrv.pmcva(agmail.com
Anita Puckett
Inc.120 Tredegar StreetRichmond, VIRGINIA 23219ronald.d.walther(dom.com
John TrimbleSr Gas OriginatorDuke Energy Corporation526 South Church StreetECO2FCharlotte. NORTH CAROLINA28202-1802
j ohn.trimb1e(iduke-energy.com
John TrimbleSr Gas OriginatorDuke Energy Corporation526 South Church StreetECO2FCharlotte. NORTH CAROLINA28202-1802ohn.trimble(iduke-energy.com
PreserveMontgomeryCounty VA
Preserve theNew RiverValley
Dr.306 Rucker Rd.Blacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESanitampuckett)gmail.corn
Wilbur Stanton2595 Spaulding RoadChristiansburg, VIRGINIA 24073UNITED STATESstanton.wil(gmail. corn
Franklin County Planning &Community1255 Franklin StSuite 103Rocky Mount, VIRGINIA 24151steve. sandyfranklincountyva.goV
Protect OurWater. Heritageand Rights(POWHR)
Red SulphurPublic ServiceDistrict
Angela Stanton2595 Spaulding RoadChristiansburg, VIRGINIA 24073UNITED STATESstanton.angielgmail.com
Justin St ClairMonroe County Prosecuting AttoP.O. Box 740Union. WEST VIRGINIA 24983
Newport. VIRGINIA 24128UNITED STATEScvmdspvt.edu
Preserve GilesCounty
PreserveMontgomeryCounty VA
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 43 of 57
UNITED STATESredsulphurpsdgmail.com
Jerry PitzerBoard Member
Red SulphurMarket Street
Public ServicePetestown. WEST VIRGINIA 24963
DistrictUNITED STATESJerrPitzer2 igmai1.com
William Deegans John D RossPresident Giles County Board of
Rex Coal Land Box 564 SupervisorsCo.. Inc. Lewisburg. WEST VIRGINIA 24901 315 N. Main Street
UNITED STATES Pearisburg, VIRGINIA 24134wedeegans mac.com jrossigilescounty.org
Diane ConnerRGC Resources, Inc.
RGC Resources. P.O. Box 13007Inc. Roanoke, VIRGINIA 24030
Valley Network 201 West Main Street. Suite 14Rt. 1 Box 46
Charlottesville. VIRGINIA 22901Union, WEST VIRGINIA 24983
UNITED STATESbIueroaminfarmgmail.com
gbuppertselcva.org
Charles SinexSmith Mountain 179 Windmere TrailLake Moneta, VIRGINIA 24121Association UNITED STATES
csinexcenturylink.net
George BarlowSenior Attorney
The NatureThe Nature Conservancy
Conservany490 Westfield RoadCharlottesville, VIRGINIA 22901UNITED STATESgbarIow’tnc .org
Hugh IrwinLandscape Conservation PlannerThe Wilderness Society
The Wilderness 30 Walker Town RoadSociety Black Mountain, NORTH CAROLINA
28711UNITED STATEShughirwinätws.org
VIRGINIA Jennifer HendersonPOLYTECHNI VIRGINIA POLYTECHNICC INSTITUTE INSTITUTE & STATE
45
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 45 of 57
& STATE 447$ Preston Forest DrBlacksburg. VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESgreennrv.j en(’,grnail.con1
Spenser SloughVirginia Polytechnic Institute and State
VirginiaUrnversitv
Polytechnic60 Overlook Drive
Institute andChristiansbur. VIRGINIA 24073
State UniversityUNITED STATESsdslough2ol 2()grnai1.coni
Robert TracyProfessor of Geosciences. VirgVirginia Tech
Virginia Tech 1110 5. Jefferson Forest LaneBlacksburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATESrtracyf’a)vt.edu
Justin HaberMr. Justin HaberVirginia Tech
Virginia Tech 924 Kabrich StBlacLsburg, VIRGINIA 24060UNITED STATEShaber23 9(ivt.edu
Gregory Buppert Paul DiehiSenior Attorney Senior Attorney - Midstream
VIRGINIASOUTHERN ENVIRONMENTAL EQT Corporation
WILDERNESLAW CENTER EQT Corporation
COMMITTEE201 West Main Street. Suite 14 625 Liberty Avenue. Suite 1700Charlottesville, VIRGINIA 22901 Pittsburgh, PENNSYLVANIAUNITED STATES 15222gbuppert1selcva.org pdieh1(eqt.corn
Rose LennonBrian D ONeill, ESQ
Washington Gas Light CompanyVan Ness Feldman. LLP
101 Constitution Avenue, NW1050 Thomas Jefterson St. N.W
Washington Gas 3rd FloorSuite 700
Lwht Company Washington. DIS I RICT OFCOLUMBIA 00$0
Washington. DISTRICT OF- COLUMBIA 20005-42 13
UNITED STATESbdo(i)vnfcom
rlennon(2washgas.com
WGL Telemac Chrryssikos Michael Pincus
46
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 46 of 57
Midstream. Inc.
Wild Virginia
Wild Virginia
Wild Virginia
AttorneyWashington Gas Light Company101 Constitution Avenue. NWWashington. DC, DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20080UNITED STATESTe1emacChryssikoswashgas.com
Ernest ReedWild Virginia President971 Rainbow Ridge RoadFaber. VIRGINIA 22938UNITED STATESlecwildvirginia.org
Georgianna ReidGeorgianna ReidWild Virginia8347 Wickham RoadSpringfield, VIRGINIA 22152UNITED STATESger4cc(dvirginia.edu
Georgianna ReidGeorgianna ReidWild Virginia8347 Wickham RoadSpringfield, VIRGINIA 22152UNITED STATESger4cc(ãvirginia.edu
Van Ness Feldman LLP1050 Thomas Jefferson StreetWashington, DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20007rnrp(vnf.com
Douglas F AlmquistLDC Gas TraderDominion Resources Services,Inc.120 Tredegar StreetRichmond, VIRGINIA 23219dougI79(dom. corn
Lorri J KleineNORFOLK SOUTHERNCORPORATIONThree Commerical PlaceNorfolk, VIRGINIA 23510Lorri . Kleinetnscorp.com
Jessica RogersPost & Schell, P.C.17 N. Second StreetHarrisburg, PENNSYLVANIA17101jrogerstdpostschell.com
47
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 47 of 57
William H RobertsSenior CounselPeoples Natural Gas CompanyLLCPeoples Service Company LLC375 North Shore DrivePittsburgh. [email protected]
Michelle R MendozaManager, Pipeline ServicesPiedmont Natural Gas Company,Inc.4720 Piedmont Row DriveCharlotte, NORTH CAROLINA28210FERCPipeIinepiedmontng.corn
Donna S Pitt216 Zells Mill RdNewport, VIRGINIA 24128cvmdsp(àvt.edu
Richard CaywoodAssistant County Administrator5204 Bernard DriveRoanoke, VIRGINIA 24018rcaywood(roanokecountyva.gov
48
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 48 of 57
Thomas HeadleyThomas W Headley2886 Pangbum Hollow Rd
Thomas Headley Monongahela. PENNSYLVANIA15063UNITED STATEStomheadley 1 ()comcast.net
Allegheny Ryan Talbott
49
Judy Dunscomb490 Westfield Rd.Charlottesville, VIRGINIA 22901j dunscornbtnc.org
Jim L BlasiakSenior Specialist, Reg. Affairjblasiak(iwashgas.com
Stephen R SouleVice PresidentCapitol Energy VenturesCorporation101 Constitution Ave. NWWashington, DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20080ssoule(washgas.com
Georgianna E ReidGeorgianna ReidWild Virginia8347 Wickharn RoadSpringfield, VIRGINIA 22152ger4cctvirginia.edu
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 49 of 57
Defense Project
AppalachianMountainAdvocates
Betty Jane Cline
Blue RidgeEnvironmentalDefense League,Inc.
Blue RidgeEnvironmentalDefense League,Inc
Bold Alliance
ConsolidatedEdison Companyof New York.Inc.
5020 NE 8th AvenuePortland. OREGON 97211UNITED STATESrtalbottalleghenydefense.org
Benjamin LuckettAppalachian Mountain AdvocatesP0 Box 507Lewisburg. WEST VIRGINIA 24991UNITED [email protected]
Mara RobbinsVirginia Coordinator, Blue Rid110 Talley’s AlleyFloyd, VIRGINIA 24091mara.robbins(i)gmail.com
Louis A ZellerExecutive DirectorBlue Ridge EnvironmentalDefense League, Inc.P0 Box 88Glendale Springs, 28629-0088bredl@!skybest.com
Scott ButlerConsolidated Edison Company ofNew York, Inc. and Orange andRockland Utilities, Inc.4 Irving PlaceNew York, NEW YORK 10003butlersconed.com
50
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 50 of 57
) Patti A. Savage, ESQConsolidated Consolidated EdisonEdison Company Development, Inc.of New York, 4 Irving Place, room 1875-sInc. New York, NEW YORK 10003
Washington, DISTRICT OFCOLUMBIA 20005malfanojsslaw.com
Joel deJesusDinsmore & Shohi LLP Robert L Cline11520 Hihview Avenue VP Engr
Coronado CoaL1NC000000026385 4425 Anjean RoadSilver Spring. MARYLAND 20902 Rupert, WEST VIRGINIA 25924UNITED STATES bc1inecoronadocoaI.comoedjj d(comcast.net
Daniel ArchuletaAssociate Ronald D WaitherTroutman Sanders LLP Dominion Resources Services,401 9th Street. NW Suite 1000 Inc.
Dominion HopeWashington. DISTRICT OF 120 Tredegar StreetCOLUMBIA 20004 Richmond, VIRGINIA 23219UNITED STATES [email protected]
Company Norfolk. VIRGINIA 23510- Nortolk VIRGINIA 10
UNITED STATES . -
Lorn . Kleine(anscorp.comhelen.hartnscorp.com
Vivian Stockman• proj ect coordinator
Ohio Valley• POBox”7D
EnvironmentalHuntington. WEST VIRGINIA 25773
CoalitionUNITED STATESviviand)ohvec.org
William Roberts Jason DaltonSenior Counsel Peoples Natural Gas CompanyPeoples Natural Gas Company LLC LLC
Peoples Gas WV Peoples Service Company LLC 375 North Shore DriveLLC 375 North Shore Drive 6th Floor
Pittsburgh, PENNSYLVANIA 15212 Pittsburgh, PENNSYLVANIAUNITED STATES 15212wi1liam.h.roberts(peoples-gas.com Jason.DaltonPeoples-Gas.com
William Roberts Jason DaltonSenior Counsel Peoples Natural Gas CompanyPeoples Natural Gas Company LLC LLC
Peoples NaturalPeoples Service Company LLC 375 North Shore Drive
Gas Company -
LLC37 North Shore Drive 6th FloorPittsburgh. PENN S YLVANIA 15212 Pittsburgh, PENN SYLVANIAUNITED STATES 15212wi1liarn.h.robertspeoples-gas.com Jason.DaltonPeoples-Gas.com
Christopher Barr Jessica RogersAttorney Post & Schell, P.C.
Peoples NaturalPost & Schelh P.C. 17 N. Second Street
Gas Company607 14th St., N.W. Harrisburg, PENNSYLVANIASuite 600 17101Washington, DISTRICT Of jrogerspostsche1l.com
USCA Case #18-1002 Document #1711691 Filed: 01/03/2018 Page 53 of 57