Top Banner
Astronomical Instrumentation course lecture 7a Dec 15, 2010 Frans Snik BBL 710 [email protected] optical design a very rough overview…
42

optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

Aug 02, 2018

Download

Documents

donguyet
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

Astronomical Instrumentation course lecture 7a Dec 15, 2010

Frans Snik BBL 710 [email protected]

optical design a very rough overview…

Page 2: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

requirements definition

•  FOV •  (effective) focal length •  spatial resolution (+ sampling) •  spectral range & resolution (+ sampling) •  polarimetric performance •  transmission •  stability •  etc.

optical design

Page 3: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

boundary conditions

•  telescope •  telescope interfaces (see next lecture) •  focal station dimensions •  focal station gravity vector •  detector availability •  available € or $

optical design

Page 4: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

global set-up

•  lenses or mirrors (depends on wavelength range) •  choice of dispersing elements (prism, grating) •  location of aperture stop •  locations of image and pupil planes •  sampling (Nyquist: >2 pixels per resolution

element) •  (dichroic) beam-splitting •  etc.

optical design

Page 5: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

global set-up

•  (de-)magnification •  F-numbers

–  the amount of problems with aberrations increases with smaller F-number…

•  collimated beam? •  telecentric beam?

optical design

Page 6: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

global set-up optical design

•  m=f2/f1 •  minimum geometrical aberrations for

symmetric system (m=1)

f1 f2 f2

“Offner relay”

Page 7: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

global set-up

•  components in collimated beam? –  dispersion element –  cold stop –  Lyot stop –  filter? –  polarization modulator?

•  components in converging beam? –  slit –  coronagraphic mask –  detector –  filter?

optical design

Page 8: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

étendue

•  or “throughput” or “grasp”, connected with “Lagrange invariant” or “optical invariant”

•  derived from conservation of energy

•  considered in every pupil plane: – 3D: aperture*FOV = A*Ω = constant – 2D: d*θ = constant

•  unless focal ratio degradation in fibers…

optical design

Page 9: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

block diagram optical design

EPICS-EPOL

Page 10: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

block diagram optical design

SPICES

Page 11: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

ray tracing

•  used in optical design programs: – WinLens – ZEMAX – OSLO – CodeV – etc.

•  Such programs are only useful when major design decisions have already been made!

optical design

Page 12: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

ray tracing

•  direction cosines v=(γ,δ,ε) – γ = cos θ – δ = cos φ – ε = cos ψ

•  propagation along distance s measured in z direction: – x2 = γs/ε + x1

– y2 = δs/ε + y1

– z2 = s + z1

optical design

Page 13: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

ray tracing •  surface P with normal v’=(γ’,δ’,ε’) •  incidence angle i = arccos(γγ’ + δδ’ + εε’) •  reflection: γγ” + δδ” + εε” = cos 2r •  refraction: γγ” + δδ” + εε” = cos (i-r)

use Snell’s law •  relation with the surface normal:

γ’γ” + δ’δ” + ε’ε” = cos r •  plus v, v’ and v” should be in one plane:

(vxv’)v” = 0 (εδ’-ε’δ)γ” + (γε’-γ’ε)δ” + (δγ’-δ’γ)ε” = 0

optical design

Page 14: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

ray tracing

•  sequential –  from one surface to the next along the z axis – populate the pupil with rays – wavelength λ, field [x,y] as global parameters

•  non-sequential – specific 3D volume and fire off rays in all

directions

optical design

Page 15: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

ray tracing optical design

sequential

Page 16: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

spot diagrams

•  traced rays + Airy disk •  FFT PSF

optical design

Page 17: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

spot diagrams optical design

Jan Apr Jul

custom spherical doublets

S5T

Page 18: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

aberration plots

•  transverse / longitudinal aberration •  Seidel diagram

optical design

Page 19: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

optimization

•  variables: – positions – angles –  radii of curvature – conic constants – glass type – coating layers and material – etc.

optical design

Page 20: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

optimization

•  merit function •  weighted linear combination of:

–  system: •  effective focal length

–  spot: •  centroid position •  RMS radius •  MTF •  Strehl ratio (observed peak intensity / maximum peak intensity) •  encircled energy

–  coating polarization properties –  etc

optical design

Page 21: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

design examples optical design

SOLIS-VSM

Page 22: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

design examples optical design

X-shooter

Page 23: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

design examples optical design

X-shooter

simulated from optical design measured

Page 24: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

tolerancing

•  spot diagram diffraction limited with margin?

•  sensitivity analysis for individual elements •  in the end: Monte Carlo

optical design

Page 25: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

tolerancing optical design

Page 26: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

tolerancing optical design

•  example: EPICS-EPOL

Page 27: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

stray light analysis

•  look at where “second order” light ends up in non-sequential ray tracing

•  or light outside FOV (in sequential ray tracing)

•  solutions: – baffling –  “ghosts”: defocus or tilt surfaces to move

outside FOV

optical design

Page 28: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

Astronomical Instrumentation course lecture 7b Dec 15, 2010

Frans Snik BBL 710 [email protected]

systems engineering

Page 29: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

why?

•  Consider instrument as being more than just sum of its parts (subsystems).

•  Crucial for complex instruments. •  Implement from beginning of the project. •  Interaction with optical, mechanical,

electronic, software design. •  Interaction between different international

teams (interfaces).

systems engineering

Page 30: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

budgets

•  wavefront error •  transmission •  thermal background •  radial velocity •  polarimetric accuracy •  etc.

•  financial!

systems engineering

Page 31: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

budgets

•  top-down or bottom-up? •  first: distribution of best guess •  add quadratically or linearly? •  continuously update during design process

and evaluate •  identify (critical) issues that contribute

substantially to overall degradation of performance, and take action to mitigate

systems engineering

Page 32: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

budgets

•  system – subsystem A

•  component 1 •  component 2

– subsystem B •  component 3 •  component 4 •  component 5

•  total

systems engineering

Page 33: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

budgets •  observing system imaging performance

–  seeing –  telescope

•  M1 –  manufacturing & testing –  alignment –  active optics performance –  wind buffeting

•  pointing & guiding –  AO

•  optics wavefront error •  wavefront sensor noise influence •  DM correction •  non-common path errors

–  spectrograph •  flexure •  detector focusing

systems engineering

static dynamic

Page 34: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

WFE budget

•  magnitude of error in [nm] •  decomposition in spatial frequencies or

Zernike polynomials •  location: close to pupil plane or image

plane? •  sensitivity analysis in optical design to

assess whether or not a certain error is critical

systems engineering

Page 35: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

WFE budget systems engineering

sensitivities from ZEMAX:

overall:

Page 36: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

interaction w/ mechanical design

•  mounting precision [x,y,x], [φ,χ,ψ] from optical design

•  optics deformation from mechanical design and finite element modeling

•  several iterations of loop between optical and mechanical design

systems engineering

Page 37: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

cryogenic instruments

•  alignment at room temperature •  contraction and deformation due to cool-down •  cryogenic alignment mechanisms

•  ZEMAX allows for lengths to be determined by metal at certain temperature

•  mirrors, mounts and bench out of aluminum: focus invariant

•  invar material

systems engineering

Page 38: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

transmission budget

•  reduce number of surfaces (>1% loss per surface)

•  optimize coatings

•  main ingredient for photon budget, plus photon noise and readout noise

•  exposure time calculator: S/N for science goal feasible within a night?

systems engineering

Page 39: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

transmission budget systems engineering

Page 40: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

transmission budget systems engineering

X-shooter

Page 41: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

controlling complexity

•  number of moving parts •  thermal control •  vacuum systems •  number of observing modes

•  deal with single-point failures –  redundancy

systems engineering

Page 42: optical design a very rough overview… - Leiden …home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~snik/downloads/AstroInstr2010-optical... · • detector availability ... • alignment at room temperature

requirements verification

•  verification matrix for lab tests •  traceability to science requirements

– What is the science impact if a certain spec cannot be achieved?

systems engineering