Top Banner
Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA May 9-10, 2016 Peter Lyster Deputy Director, NITRD National Coordination Office My opinions only
47

Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Jun 03, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Ontologies, Big Data, Search and DiscoveryOntology Summit 2016 Symposium

Arlington, VA

May 9-10, 2016

Peter LysterDeputy Director, NITRD National Coordination Office

My opinions only

Page 2: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is an interagency program to enhance coordination and collaboration of the Information Technology Research and Development (IT R&D) that is performed and supported by Federal agencies

FY 2017 Request: $4.54B of IT R&D

The National Coordination Office (NCO) provides support for the NITRD Program, reports to OSTP, and interfaces for NITRD with OMB, GAO, Congress, etc

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 3: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD Member AgenciesCommerce: NIST, NOAA

Defense: DARPA, HPCMOD, NSA, OSD, Service research organizations

Energy: NNSA, SCI, OE

Homeland Security

Environmental Protection Agency

Heath and Human Services: AHRQ, NIH, ONC

National Archives

NASA

NIJ

NRO

NSF

Ontology Summit May 9, 2016

Page 4: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

2010 Big Data Arrives

Ontology Summit May 9, 2016

N * SNR log (N)Size of data Size of data~

Page 5: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Ontology Summit May 9, 2016

Page 6: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 7: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Evolution of NITRD Program Component Areas (PCAs)

Cyber Security and Information Assurance

Human Computer Interaction andInformation Management

High Confidence Software and Systems

High End Computing Research and Development

High End Computing Infrastructure and Applications

Large Scale Networking

Software Design and Productivity

Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications of IT

High-Capability Computing Systems Infrastructure and Applications

Large-Scale Data Management and Analysis

Robotics and Intelligent Systems

Enabling-R&D for High-Capability Computing Systems

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 8: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

FY2017 PCAs FY2018 PCAs FY2018 PCA Acronym

High Confidence Software and Systems Computing-Enabled Networked Physical Systems

CNPS

Human Computer Interaction Computing-Enabled Human Interaction, Communication, and Augmentation

CHuman

Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications of IT

Education and Workforce EdW

High-Capability Computing Systems Infrastructure and Applications

High-Capability Computing Infrastructure and Applications

HCIA

Robotics and Intelligent Systems Robotics and intelligent systems RIS

Software Design and Productivity Software Design and Productivity SDP

Cyber Security and Information Assurance Cyber Security and Information Assurance CSIA

Enabling-R&D for high-capability computing systems

Enabling-R&D for high-capability computing systems

EHCS

Large-scale data management and analysis Large-scale data management and analysis LSDMA

Large Scale Networking Large Scale Networking LSN

Page 9: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

A Different Inventory of NIH Biomedical Informatics and Computational

Biology

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 10: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Biositemaps Architecture

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Internet

Index.htmlSitemap.htmlBiositemaps.rdf

Index.htmlSitemap.htmlBiositemaps.rdf

Index.htmlSitemap.htmlBiositemaps.rdf

Browser

ResourceDiscoverySystem (RDS)

Biositemaps * Information Model* Biomedical Resource Ontology (BRO)* Biositemaps Editor(s)* Resource Discovery System(s) (RDS)

Page 11: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Biositemaps Information Model (BIM)

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 12: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Biomedical Resource Ontology (BRO)

May 9, 2016

BRO

Ontology Summit

Page 13: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Resource Discovery System (RDS)

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 14: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

BRO on BioPortal

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Page 15: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Data Integration

May 9, 2016Ontology Summit

Clinical Informatics

• Ontologies used to limit complexity and to organize information (wiki)• Facilitate communication of information from data acquisition through to

data storage, presentation, and analytics with minimal error (SNOMED-CT etc)

Basic Biomedical Research

• Genomics and Genotype-Phenotype studies (GO)• Cell Biology• Systems Biology• Whole organism modeling

Page 16: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Take Away

February 8, 2016Ontology Summit

• Ontology community (like software developers in general)needs to do a better job of explaining what they are doing and why is it useful, especially to management and bureaucrats

• What is the fundamental understanding of data integration in terms ofOntologies? Covariance estimation? Mechanistic and causal analytics?Especially for the multivariate, multiscale problems. Are the two sides(Ontologies and mechanism) talking to each other? What are theoverarching principles of validation?

• Should funders promote tools (or pre-competitive toolkits) thatUSE Ontologies

• Many a good idea founded on the rough seas of Adoption

• Use of Ontologies in basic science applications is still in early phase (see papers on GO etc), and needs some credit for tackling hard problems

(but beware of hype cycle)

Page 17: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Ontology Summit

Thank you!

Peter [email protected]

May 9, 2016

Page 18: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Ontology Summit May 9, 2016

Page 19: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is authorized by the HPC Act of 1991, as amended by:

The Next Generation Internet Act of 1998, and

The America COMPETES Act of 2007

Central ProvisionsRequires the President to establish NITRD

Requires the Director of OSTP to implement NITRD

Assigns specific functions to NITRD (e.g., coordination, prepare supplement to President’s budget, etc.)

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 20: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Update of Program Component Areas (PCAs)

Cyber Security and Information Assurance

Human Computer Interaction andInformation Management

High Confidence Software and Systems

High End Computing Research and Development

High End Computing Infrastructure and Applications

Large Scale Networking

Software Design and Productivity

Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications of IT

High-Capability Computing Systems Infrastructure and Applications

Computer-enabled Networked Physical Systems (CNPS)

Large-Scale Data Management and Analysis

Robotics and Intelligent Systems

Enabling-R&D for High-Capability Computing Systems

Computing-enabled human interaction, communication, and augmentation (cHuman)

IT foundational research and innovation (IT-FRI)

Next Year

gg

Page 21: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

S&T Priorities FT 2016-17

Multi-Agency R&D PrioritiesGlobal climate change

Clean energy

Earth observations

Advanced manufacturing and industries of the future

Innovations in life sciences, biology, and neuroscience

National and homeland security

Information technology and high-performance computing

Ocean and Arctic issues

R&D for informed policy-making and management

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 22: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

S&T Priorities FT 2016-17Other R&D Program Guidance

Support transition to practiceDescribe targeted outcomes of R&D programs using meaningful, measureable, and quantitative metrics; describe how plan to evaluate successUtilize Grand Challenges, incentive prizes, citizen science, collaboration with Maker MovementPreserving and improving access to dataSupport SBIR/ STTRImprove reproducibility

STEM educationReduce fragmentation of programsProgram design guided by evidence-based approachPriority to increase inclusion and diversity

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 23: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD Program Component Areas

Cyber Security and Information Assurance

High-End ComputingR&DI&A

High Confidence Software and Systems

Human Computer Interaction and Info Mgmt

Large Scale Networking

Social, Economic, and Workforce Implications

Software Design and Productivity

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 24: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Groups

Big Data

Computer Security and Information Assurance R&D

Cyber Physical Systems

Health IT R&D

Wireless Spectrum R&D

Faster Administration of Science and Technology

Visual Information Analytics

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 25: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD Supplement

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 26: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCA Budgets

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 27: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Agency Budgets

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 28: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCAST

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 29: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCAST 2015

IT R&D essential to many National Priorities

Cybersecurity - research on cybersecurity by design, defense against attack, systems resilience, implementation support, better and faster attack attribution methods

Health - research on treatment and outcomes, disease and wellness, mobile and biometric technologies for monitoring and care, actionable decision support, regulatory compliance

… Multi-agency coordination is essential to promote collaboration, public-private partnerships, and to create paths for translation into practice.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 30: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCAST 2015

R&D that Integrates people and NITPrivacy - a science of privacy based on NIT is needed to inform policy decisions and to enable appropriate use of personal data while protecting its source.

Cyber-human systems – computational systems that support communication and coordination of individuals, groups, and organizations, computational systems and methods supported by people and socially-intelligent devices and systems.

… Results from cyber-human systems are increasingly used to address important societal problems. Advances in both domains require broad, multidisciplinary research.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 31: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCAST 2015

Developing the Workforce The demand for skilled IT workers necessitates new approaches to identify and train students and to retain them in the educational pipeline as they progress from the K‐12 level to college and beyond.

Diversity in computing‐related fields continues to be a significant issue. This reduces our ability to fulfill the demand of the IT industry and limits the economic opportunities for those populations.

… Programs are needed to grow the pipeline by attracting and retaining students at all levels, and by enhancing diversity.

… Principled approaches for training and retraining of workers are needed to address immediate needs and opportunities to grow the IT workforce.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 32: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

PCAST 2015

Changing Program Component Areas

Enabling-R&D for high-capability IT systems

Large Scale Data Management and Analysis

Robotics and Intelligent Systems

Computing-enabled Networked Physical Systems

Computing-enabled Human Interaction, Communication, and Augmentation

IT foundational research and innovation

Large-scale research infrastructure

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 33: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Current Coordination Efforts: Strategic Plans

Big Data

Privacy

Cybersecurity

National Strategic Computing Initiative

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 34: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Current Coordination Efforts: Frameworks

Smart Cities and Connected Communities

Visual Information Analytics

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 35: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Current Coordination Efforts: Discussions

Human Computer Interaction and Info MgmtScientific foundations of visualization

Social, Economic, and Workforce ImplicationsScience of Team Science

Software Design and ProductivitySoftware design for the IoT

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 36: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is a subcommittee of the NSTC Committee on Technology.

The NITRD subcommittee is co-chaired by the NSF assistant director for CISE and the NCO director.

NITRD is reviewed by the President’s Council of Advisors for Science and Technology (PCAST).

The NCO is managed by a director and a deputy director.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 37: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is a subcommittee of the NTSC Committee on Technology.

The NITRD subcommittee is co-chaired by the NSF assistant director for CISE and the NCO director.

NITRD is reviewed by the President’s Council of Advisors for Science and Technology (PCAST).

The NCO is managed by a director and a deputy director.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 38: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is a subcommittee of the NSTC Committee on Technology.

The NITRD subcommittee is co-chaired by the NSF assistant director for CISE and the NCO director.

NITRD is reviewed by the President’s Council of Advisors for Science and Technology (PCAST).

The NCO is managed by a director and a deputy director.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 39: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and the NCO

NITRD is a subcommittee of the NSTC Committee on Technology.

The NITRD subcommittee is co-chaired by the NSF assistant director for CISE and the NCO director.

NITRD is reviewed by the President’s Council of Advisors for Science and Technology (PCAST).

The NCO is managed by a director and a deputy director.

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 40: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 41: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

OMB provides guidance to agencies

Fed agencies first budget drafts

OMB reviewsdrafts

Fed agencies revise drafts

OMB compiles final budget

POTUS submits budget request to

Congress

House Budget Committee reviews

request

Senate Budget Committee reviews

request

Budget Resolution

12 House Appropriations subcommittee

hearing and markups

12 Senate Appropriations subcommittee

hearing and markups

Senate Appropriations

Committee reviews and approves

House Appropriations

Committee reviews and approves

Conference Committee

House final review

Senate final review

POTUSsigns into

law

Annual Budget Process

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 42: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

S&T Priorities

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 43: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

OMB provides guidance to agencies

Fed agencies first budget drafts

OMB reviewsdrafts

Fed agencies revise drafts

OMB compiles final budget

POTUS submits budget request to

Congress

House Budget Committee reviews

request

Senate Budget Committee reviews

request

Budget Resolution

12 House Appropriations subcommittee

hearing and markups

12 Senate Appropriations subcommittee

hearing and markups

Senate Appropriations

Committee reviews and approves

House Appropriations

Committee reviews and approves

Conference Committee

House final review

Senate final review

POTUSsigns into

law

Annual Budget Process

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Page 44: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Budget Committees

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Committee on the BudgetChair Thomas Price, Georgia 6th

Ranking member Chris Van Hollen, Maryland 8th

Committee on the BudgetChair Mike Enzi, Wyoming (Sr)Ranking member Bernie Sanders, Vermont (Jr)

House Senate

Page 45: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Appropriations Committees

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Committee on AppropriationsChair Hal Rogers, Kentucky 5th

Ranking member Nita Lowey, New York 17th

Appropriations Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice,Science, and Related AgenciesChair John Culberson, Texas 7th

Ranking member Chakah Fattah, Pennsylvania 7th

Committee on AppropriationsChair Thad Cochran, Mississippi (Sr)Ranking member Barbara Mikulski, Maryland (Sr)

Appropriations Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice,Science, and Related AgenciesChair Richard Shelby, Alabama (Sr)Ranking member Barbara Mikulski, Maryland (Sr)

House Senate

Page 46: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

Oversight Committees

February 8, 2016NIBIB

Committee on Commerce, Science and TransportationChair Lamar Smith, Texas 21st

Ranking member Eddie Bernice Johnson, Texas 30th

Subcommittee on Research and TechnologyChair Barbara Comstock, Virginia 10th

Ranking member Dan Lipinski, Illinois 3rd

Committee on Science, Space and TechnologyChair John Thune, Florida (Sr)Ranking member Bill Nelson, Florida (Sr)

Subcommittee on Space, Science, and CompetitivenessChair Ted Cruz, Texas (Jr)Ranking member Gary Peters, Michigan (Jr)

House Senate

Page 47: Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery · 2/8/2016  · Ontologies, Big Data, Search and Discovery Ontology Summit 2016 Symposium Arlington, VA ... Innovations in life sciences,

NITRD and you

February 8, 2016NIBIB