On the Sociology of Science (STS) 1. Key Orientation of STS (and Religion): Science & Religion as Social Products/Institutions Facts, Methods, Concepts, Theories and ways-of-studying 2. Tools of a Sociological analysis Social Epistemology Social Constructivism Bruno Latour on “critique”
15
Embed
On the Sociology of Science (STS) 1. Key Orientation of STS (and Religion): Science & Religion as Social Products/Institutions Facts, Methods, Concepts,
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
On the Sociology of Science (STS)
1. Key Orientation of STS (and Religion): Science & Religion as Social Products/Institutions Facts, Methods, Concepts, Theories and ways-of-
studying
2. Tools of a Sociological analysis Social Epistemology Social Constructivism Bruno Latour on “critique”
Key Orientations of STS
Science is a thoroughly social activity (therefore a sociological analysis is appropriate)
The process are subtle (complex) interweavings of practices, philosophies, and dialectical relations with the material world.
General rejection of the Common View of Science. (PUS)– E.g., material world is not mechanically translated into knowledge
(e.g., “discovery.”);
– The Material world is USED by scientists to develop models.
A Sociological Understanding…
On the Sociology of Science (Tools)
Sociologists often say something is “socially constructed”.
That IS NOT – “It’s simply a social construction.”
On the Sociology of Science
Basic Principle: 'what is taken to be real is real in its consequences'.
W.I. Thomas:– "If people define situations as real, they are
real in their consequences."
Social Epistemology
study of the intellectual process of society
the analysis of the – production– distribution– utilizationof intellectual products
(just like other products – what are the materials, knowledge, mechanical & other processes that go into their production? What are the economic conditions, or policy [political] arrangements that facilitate or inhibit?)
What is Knowledge?
Social Construction
An example - perception matters– Husband sees an event the way he sees it
– Wife sees an event the way she it
– Who’s right?– What does the marital counsellor do?
Sociologically: Perception is a SHARED process (construction)
Do we want an example?
On the Sociology of Science - from Bruno Latour (2004) The Point of Social Constructivist versions
of Science Studies– “I myself have spent some time in the past
trying to show "the lack of scientific certainty" inherent in the construction of facts.”
– The point is “to emancipate us from prematurely naturalized objectified facts”
On the Sociology of Science - from Bruno Latour (2004) The Point of Social Constructivist versions
of Science Studies (Cont.)– “The question was never to get away from facts
but to get closer to them.”– “Reality is not defined by matters of fact.” – “Matters of fact are only very partial and very
polemical, very political renderings of matters of concern.”
On the Sociology of Science
Latour concludes:– “Whereas the Enlightenment profited largely from the
disposition of a very powerful descriptive tool, that of matters of fact -- which were excellent for debunking quite a lot of beliefs, powers, and illusions -- it found itself totally disarmed once matters of fact, in turn, were eaten up by the same debunking impetus.”