Top Banner

of 28

Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

Feb 27, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    1/28

    ONARCGKHT - 7

    AGTTMFP RGRRG_(OG. _JH #< 707=92)Rrn mgo vkof gppckogtknh pfhdkh`Necfvufmg Hgtkvf Gafrkogh Omurom707; F. JrngdwgyCnh` Jfgom, OG ;2=2:Rmnhf< (;4;) ?=:-74=6

    Igoskakcf< (;4;) :4:-:926F-Agkc< agtt.pgppgsBagttpgppgscgw.ona

    AKOMGFC ZN_F(N_J #< 06?::7)Orfk`mtnh & Znsf R.O.=76 _P :hd Gvf., _tf. 622Rnrtcghd, NZ ;0:24Rmnhf< (62?) ::7-70;:Igoskakcf< (62?) ::?-7679F-Agkc< arnsfBokvkcrk`mtspdx.ona

    Gttnrhfys inr Rcgkhtkiis

    VHKTFD _TGTF_ DK_TZKOT ONVZT

    DK_TZKOT NI NZF@NH

    RNZTCGHD DKYK_KNH

    NECFYVFMG HGTKYF GAFZKOGH

    OMVZOM5 LGAF_ ANNHF[5 ghd LN[@ZGYF_,

    Rcgkhtkiis,

    v.

    VHKTFD _TGTF_ NI GAFZKOG5VHKTFD _TGTF_ RN_TGC _FZYKOF5ghd AF@GH L. JZFHHGH, kh mfr ogpgoktygs Rnstagstfr @fhfrgc ni tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs,

    Dfifhdghts.

    YFZKIKFD ONARCGKHT INZYKNCGTKNH NI TMF ZFCK@KNV_IZFFDNA ZF_TNZGTKNH GOT5TMF ZFCK@KNV_ CGHD V_F GHDKH_TKTVTKNHGCK\FD RFZ_NH_GOT5 GHD KHLVHOTKYF ZFCKFI

    Rcgkhtkiis NECFYVFMG HGTKYF GAFZKOGH OMVZOM, LGAF_ ANNHF[ghd

    LN[ @ZGYF_onapcgkh ni vkncgtknhs ni tmf Zfck`knus Irffdna Zfstnrgtknh Got ghd Zfck`knus

    Cghd Vsf ghd Khstktutknhgckzfd Rfrsnhs Got gs inccnws

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    2/28

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    3/28

    ONARCGKHT - ?

    aghhfr tmgt kapnsfs g sujstghtkgc jurdfh nh tmf rfck`knus fxfroksf ni g pfrsnh, khocudkh` g

    rfck`knus gssfajcy nr khstktutknh, uhcfss tmf `nvfrhafht dfanhstrgtfd tmgt kapnsktknh ni tmf

    jurdfh nh tmgt pfrsnh, gssfajcy, nr khstktutknh, (G) ks kh iurtmfrghof ni g nvfrhafhtgc khtfrfst5

    ghd (J) ks tmf cfgst rfstrkotkvf afghs ni iurtmfrkh` tmgt onapfcckh` `nvfrhafhtgc khtfrfst.

    OMVZOM ks g rfck`knus gssfajcy nr khstktutknh inr purpnsfs ni tmf ZCVKRG. Rcgkhtkiis

    ANNHF[ ghd @ZGYF_ grf jntm pfrsnhs inr purpnsfs ni ZCVKRG.

    ;. TmfGafrkogh Khdkgh Zfck`knus Irffdna Got, 4: V._.O. 7;;9 (GKZIG)

    prntfots ghd prfsfrvfs tmf trgdktknhgc rfck`knus rk`mts ghd oucturgc rktugcs ni Gafrkogh Khdkghs,

    Fsekans, Gcfuts, ghd Hgtkvf Mgwgkkghs. Tmfsf rk`mts khocudf, jut grf hnt ckaktfd tn, goofss tn

    sgorfd sktfs, irffdna tn wnrsmkp tmrnu`m ofrfanhkgc ghd trgdktknhgc rk`mts, ghd usf ghd

    pnssfssknh ni njlfots onhskdfrfd sgorfd. GKZIG wgs gafhdfd kh 7;;4 tn spfokikogccy prntfot

    tmf sgorgafhtgc usf ni pfyntf jy Hgtkvf Gafrkoghs. OMVZOM ks gh Khdkgh rfck`knh gs

    dfikhfd jy GKZIG.

    72. TmfZfck`knus Irffdna Zfstnrgtknh Got ni 7;;?(ZIZG), 720 _tgt. 74==, gs

    gafhdfd, 4: V._.O. :222jj ft sfq., gppckfs tn tmf Ifdfrgc `nvfrhafht, khocudkh` fgom ni tmf

    Dfifhdghts, ghd prnmkjkts cgw ghd rucfs ni tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs irna sujstghtkgccy jurdfhkh` g

    pfrsnhs fxfroksf ni rfck`knh fvfh ki tmf jurdfh rfsucts irna g rucf ni `fhfrgc gppckogjkckty. Tmf

    ZIZG rfqukrfs tmf strkot sorutkhy rfvkfw stghdgrd jf usfd wmfh ghgcyzkh` ifdfrgc cgws ghd

    rucfs tmgt jurdfh irff fxfroksf. Tmf ZIZG gppckfs tn gcc Ifdfrgc cgw, ghd tmf kapcfafhtgtknh

    ni tmgt cgw, wmftmfr stgtutnry nr ntmfrwksf.

    77. Kh @nhzgcfs v. N Ofhtrn Fspkrktg Jfhfikokfhtf Vhkgn dn Yf`ftgc, 649 V._. 47=

    (:229) tmf V._. _uprfaf Onurt mfcd tmf ifdfrgc Onhtrnccfd _ujstghofs Got(O_G), :7 V._.O.

    =27 ft sfq. dnfs hnt afft tmf gs gppckfd strkot sorutkhy stghdgrd fxprfssfd kh tmf ZIZG.

    7:. Jftwffh Agrom 7, :274 ghd Dfofajfr 74, :274, tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs Mnusf ni

    Zfprfsfhtgtkvfs ghd Vhktfd _tgtfs _fhgtf vntfd tn fhgot M.Z. =?, gh gpprnprkgtknhs jkcc. Rrknr tn

    kts fhgotafht, M.Z. =? wgs gafhdfd tn khocudf _fotknh 6?= (_fo. 6?=) wmkom prnmkjktfd tmf

    Dfpgrtafht ni Lustkof irna uskh` iuhds kh g aghhfr khgppnsktf tn tmf kapcfafhtgtknh ni stgtf

    afdkogc agrklughg cgws kh ?: stgtfs ghd tmf Dkstrkot ni Oncuajkg. Tmfrfgitfr, nh Dfofajfr 79,

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    4/28

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    5/28

    ONARCGKHT - 6

    prnvkdfd jy oghhgjks5 ghd (@) tmf muhdrfds ni yfgrs ni trgdktknhgc usf ni oghhgjks ghd tmf

    ifdfrgccy gccnwfd usf ni pfyntf ghd ntmfr hgturgc pcghts jy Hgtkvf Gafrkoghs kh tmfkr rfck`knus

    rktugcs, tmfrf ks hn cnh`fr fvfh g rgtknhgc jgskslustkiykh` onhiksogtknh ni agrklughg jy tmf

    Dfifhdghts tmgt ks usfd jy OMVZOM inr kts rfck`knus rktugcs, ofrfanhkfs ghd prgotkofs.

    70. Tmrnu`m sujstghtkvf duf prnofss fafr`kh` gwgrfhfss, tmf afajfrs ni

    OMVZOM wmn usf oghhgjks gs pgrt ni Hgtkvf Gafrkogh spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs tmgt khtf`rgtf

    khtn OMVZOMs rfck`knus jfckfis tmf onhofpt ni afdkokhf-afh, mfgckh` ghd jfkh` nhf wktm tmf

    Fgrtm mgvf g iuhdgafhtgc rk`mt tn dn sn tn gccfvkgtf ghd trfgt pmyskogc ghd afhtgc onhdktknhs

    irna wmkom tmfy suiifr. Cgwrfhof v. Tfxgs, 6?; V._. 66=, 60=, 7:? _.Ot. :40:, 769 C.Fd.:d

    62= (:22?)5Zgkom v. @nhzgcfs, 622 I.?d =62, =94-99 (:220).

    ONAANH IGOTVGC GCCF@GTKNH_

    7=. OMVZOM wgs fstgjcksmfd kh Gprkc ni 7;;0 kh @uhhksnh, Vtgm jy Rcgkhtkii Lgafs

    Annhfy, tmf prn`fhy ni Hgtkvf Gafrkoghs, ghd jy mks wkif Ckhdg, gcsn ni Hgtkvf Gafrkogh

    dfsofht (tn`ftmfr rfifrrfd tn gs ANNHF[_). Rcgkhtkii ANNHF[ ks g dfsofhdght ni Nsofncg

    (7=24-7=?=), gh khicufhtkgc cfgdfr ni tmf _fakhncf Khdkgh Trkjf kh Icnrkdg. (_ff Fxmkjkt 7,

    Nofncg, Omfrneff ghd Orffe Khdkgh Zfsfrvgtknh Trkjgc Ogrd.) Rcgkhtkii ANNHF[ onhtkhufs tn

    sfrvf gs tmf spkrktugc cfgdfr ni OMVZOM, wmkom kh :220 wgs rfon`hkzfd ghd sfrvfs tmf ifdfrgccy

    rfon`hkzfd N`cgcg _knux Trkjf ni Rkhf Zkd`f gs tmf Necfvufmg Cgentg _knux Hgtknh Hgtkvf

    Gafrkogh Omurom. (_ff Fxmkjkt :,Grtkocfs ni Inragtknh, khonrpnrgtfd jy tmks rfifrfhof.)

    OMVZOM ks gcsn rfon`hkzfd jy tmf Cgentg _knux Znsfjud Trkjf ni _nutm Dgentg.

    7;. OMVZOM mgs tmnusghds ni afajfrs kh tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs, Oghgdg, Afxkon, _nutm

    Gafrkog ghd Girkog.

    :2. Rgrt ni Rcgkhtkii OMVZOMs rfck`knus rktugcs khocudfs Hgtkvf Gafrkogh afdkokhf

    pfnpcf. Tmf khtf`rgtknh khtn kts rfck`knh ni hgturf, hgturgc mfgctm ghd tmf afdkokhf pfnpcf ks g

    onrf prkhokpgc ghd pgrt ni tmf OMVZOMs nh`nkh` Hgtkvf Gafrkogh rfck`knus rktugcs,

    ofrfanhkfs ghd prgotkofs tmgt mgvf jffh pgrt ni Hgtkvf Gafrkogh oucturf ghd rfck`knh inr

    muhdrfds ni yfgrs. Gcnh` wktm pfyntf, oghhgjks ghd vgrknus ntmfr hgturgc mfrjs ghd pcghts grf

    usfd kh tmf sgorgafhtgc prnofssfs jy OMVZOM afdkokhf afh ghd afajfrs.

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    6/28

    ONARCGKHT - 9

    :7. Kh :222, OMVZOM jfogaf giikckgtfd wktm tmf Mukomnc trkjf, gh khdk`fhnus pfnpcf

    ni _nhnrg, Afxkon. Tmf prnocgagtknh jftwffh OMVZOM ghd tmf Mukomnc trkjf ks khocudfd gs

    Fxmkjkt ? wktm tmks Onapcgkht ghd khonrpnrgtfd jy tmks rfifrfhof.

    ::. Tmf Mukomnc grf g dffpcy rfck`knus pfnpcf tmgt mgvf g jfckfi struoturf wmkom

    fhonapgssfs fvfry gspfot ni ckif ghd khocudfs ofrfanhkfs irna prf-Oncnajkgh aytmncn`y tmgt

    pcgofs spfokgc fapmgsks nh tmf dffr, onrh pcght, ghd tmf pfyntf pcght, g sagcc, spkhfcfss,

    icnwfrkh` ogotus pcght wmkom ks usfd gs g mgccuokhn`fh jfinrf ghd durkh` rfck`knus ofrfanhkfs.

    Inr muhdrfds ni yfgrs, tmf Mukomnc mgvf usfd g onaanh inra ni mfap ogccfd agrk`ughgnr rnsg

    agrkg(Oghhgjks sgtkvg) kh tmfkr spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs.

    :?. _khof kts khofptknh, OMVZOM mgs inccnwfd trgdktknhgc Hgtkvf Gafrkogh rfck`knus

    ofrfanhkfs khocudkh` tmnsf ni tmf khdk`fhnus pfnpcf ghd trkjfs wktm wmkom kt ks giikckgtfd.

    Oghhgjks ks khtf`rgc tn OMVZOMs spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs.

    :4. _khof 7;;0, huajfrs ni jrghomfs ni OMVZOM mgvf jffh fstgjcksmfd grnuhd tmf

    Vhktfd _tgtfs, khocudkh` kts jrghom cnogtfd gt 79?2 Ourtkh Zngd, Onttg`f @rnvf, Nrf`nh

    (JZGHOM). Fgom OMVZOM jrghom ks jcfssfd jy Lgafs Annhfy ghd onhduots tmf Hgtkvf

    Gafrkogh rfck`knus ofrfanhkfs, rktugcs ghd spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs ni OMVZOM uskh` pfyntf,

    oghhgjks ghd ntmfr pcghts.

    :6. Kh nr grnuhd 7;;;, tmf _tgtf ni Vtgm wrnh`iuccy grrfstfd tmf ANNHF[_ ghd

    omgr`fd tmfa gs wfcc gs OMVZOM wktm vkncgtkh` tmf Vtgm Onhtrnccfd _ujstghofs Got

    (VO_G).

    :9. Kh :224, tmf Vtgm _uprfaf Onurt mfcd tmf rfck`knus pfyntf prnvksknhs ni 4: V._.O.

    7;;9g prntfotfd tmf ANNHF[_ ghd OMVZOM irna prnsfoutknh inr tmf rfck`knus usf ni

    pfyntf uhdfr tmf VO_G. Gs g rfsuct ni tmf stgtfs mk`mfst onurts dfoksknh, omgr`fs g`gkhst

    OMVZOM ghd tmf ANNHF[_ wfrf dksakssfd. _tgtf ni Vtgm v. Annhfy, :224 VT 4; (:224).

    :0. @ZGYF_ sfrvfs gs tmf cfgdfr ni OMVZOMs JZGHOM kh Onttg`f @rnvf

    Nrf`nh. @ZGYF_ mgs jffh jcfssfd jy Lgafs Annhfy gs mgs tmf JZGHOM kh Onttg`f @rnvf,

    Nrf`nh. @ZGYF_ prfpgrfs tmf sgorgafhts usfd jy OMVZOM afajfrs pursught tn tmfkr

    rfck`knus jfckfis khocudkh` jut hnt ckaktfd tn oghhgjks. _gorgafhtgc oghhgjks `rnwh jy

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    7/28

    ONARCGKHT - 0

    JZGHOM ks usfd jy afajfrs ni JZGHOM gs wfcc gs ntmfr jrghomfs ni OMVZOM. @ZGYF_

    dkstrkjutfs sgorgafhts tn OMVZOM afajfrs wmn grf g pgrt ni JZGHOM.

    :=. Nh nr grnuhd Dfofajfr 72, :276, @ZGYF_ prfpgrfd g pgoeg`f khocudkh`

    sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks inr g OMVZOM afajfr cnogtfd kh Nmkn. Tmf pgoeg`f onhtgkhfd

    gpprnxkagtfcy ikvf (6) nuhofs ni oghhgjks.

    :;. Tmf pgoeg`f khocudfd nh kt tmgt kt wgs irna OMVZOM.

    ?2. Tmf pgoeg`f wgs gddrfssfd tn tmf afajfr kh Nmkn wktm NHGO (tmf gornhya

    usfd jy OMVZOM) kh tmf gddrfss ckhf.

    ?7. Nh Dfofajfr 72, :276, @ZGYF_ sujakttfd tmf pgoeg`f inr agkckh` tn tmf Vhktfd

    _tgtfs Rnst Niikof kh Fu`fhf, Nrf`nh. Tmf pgoeg`f wgs sfht Rrknrkty Agkc ghd wgs gssk`hfd

    V_R_ trgoekh` huajfr ;626 6747 0=27 6?44 7?:: 06.

    ?:. Nh nr grnuhd Dfofajfr 7=, :276, @ZGYF_ cfgrhfd irna tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs Rnstgc

    _frvkof wfj trgoekh` pg`f tmgt tmf pgoeg`f mgd jffh sfkzfd jy Dfifhdght VHKTFD _TGTF_ gt

    kts pnst niikof kh Rnrtcghd, Nrf`nh inr cgw fhinrofafht rfgsnhs. (_ff Fxmkjkt 4, V_R_.ona

    Trgoekh` rfpnrt.)

    ??. Tmf stgtus ni tmf pgoeg`f gs rfpnrtfd jy V_R_.ona (gs rfpnrtfd kh Fxmkjkt 4) ks

    _fkzfd jy Cgw Fhinrofafht.

    ?4. Nh Dfofajfr ::, :276, @ZGYF_ onhtgotfd tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs Rnst Niikof kh

    Rnrtcghd, Nrf`nh ghd wgs dkrfotfd tn Rnstgc Khspfotnr Afcvkh. @ZGYF_ spnef tn Khspfotnr

    Afcvkh wmn tncd mfr tmf pgoeg`f mgd jffh sfkzfd jy tmf Rnstgc _frvkof jfogusf kt onhtgkhfd

    oghhgjks. @ZGYF_ tncd Khspfotnr Afcvkh smf wgs g afajfr ghd jrghom cfgdfr ni OMVZOM

    ghd tmf oghhgjks wgs inr sgorgafhtgc purpnsfs inr afajfrs kh Nmkn. _mf gsefd tmf pgoeg`f jf

    sfht tmrnu`m tn Nmkn ghd Khspfotnr Afcvkh rfiusfd tn rfcfgsf tmf pgoeg`f. Khspfotnr Afcvkh tncd

    @ZGYF_ tmgt oghhgjks ks kccf`gc uhdfr tmf ifdfrgc Onhtrnccfd _ujstghofs Got ghd wnucd hnt jf

    rfturhfd, rfcfgsfd nr dfckvfrfd tn tmf omurom afajfr kh Nmkn. @ZGYF_ g`gkh fxpcgkhfd tmf

    oghhgjks wgs usfd kh OMVZOMs spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs.

    ?6. Tmf oghhgjks sfht jy @ZGYF_ wgs sfht tn g afajfr ni OMVZOM inr

    sgorgafhtgc purpnsfs ghd gs pgrt ni tmf rfck`knus rktugcs ni OMVZOM.

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    8/28

    ONARCGKHT - =

    ?9. Tmf sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks khocudfd kh tmf pgoeg`f wgs kh-pgrt sfht inr mfgckh`

    purpnsfs gs pgrt ni OMVZOMs mfgckh` sgorgafhts inr g wnagh suiifrkh` irna fsnpmg`fgc

    oghofr. Fgom dgy tmf sgorgafht ks dfcgyfd, tmf mfgckh` prnofss prnvkdfd tmrnu`m tmf OMVZOM

    ks dfhkfd tn kts afajfr suiifrkh` irna fsnpmg`fgc oghofr gs wfcc gs ks dfhkfd inr ntmfr ni

    OMVZOMs spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs, prgotkofs ghd ofrfanhkfs.

    ?0. Gs ni tmf dgtf ni tmf ikckh` ni tmks Onapcgkht, tmf sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks rfagkhs kh

    tmf oustndy ni tmf Dfifhdghts wmn onhtkhuf tn rfiusf tn rfcfgsf kt.

    IKZ_T OCGKA INZ ZFCKFI

    (Zfck`knus Irffdna Zfstnrgtknh Got (ZIZG),

    4: V._.O. :222jj, ft sfq. G`gkhst Gcc Dfifhdghts)

    ?=. Rcgkhtkiis rf-gccf`f ghd khonrpnrgtf tmf gccf`gtknhs khocudfd kh pgrg`rgpms 7-?0 ni

    tmks Onapcgkht.

    ?;. Gs pgrt ni tmf Ifdfrgc `nvfrhafht, ZIZG gppckfs tn Dfifhdghts RN_TGC

    _FZYKOF, VHKTFD _TGTF_ ghd JZFHHGH. @nhzgcfs v. N Ofhtrn Fspkrktg Jfhfikofhtf

    Vhkgn dn Yf`ftgc, 649 V._. 47= (:229) UNOfhtrnQ5Jurwfcc v. Mnjjy Cnjjy, 60? V._. ^^^

    (:274).

    42. Tmf Dfifhdghts mgvf sfkzfd sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks ni Rcgkhtkii OMVZOM ghd mgvf

    rfiusfd tn rfcfgsf, rfturh nr dfckvfr gs gddrfssfd tmf oghhgjks, wmkom ks usfd jy omurom kh kts

    sgorgafhtgc mfgckh` ghd rfck`knus rktugcs.

    47. Rcgkhtkiis grf khinrafd ghd jfckfvf ghd jgsfd upnh suom khinragtknh ghd jfckfi

    gccf`f tmf sfkzurf ni tmf sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks ni OMVZOM wgs dnhf jgsfd nh prnvksknhs ni :7

    V._.O. =27, ft. sfq, tmf ifdfrgc Onhtrnccfd _ujstghofs Got (O_G). Khspfotnr Afcvkh, gs sft

    inrtm gjnvf, tncd Rcgkhtkii @ZGYF_ nh Dfofajfr :7, :276 tmgt oghhgjks wgs kccf`gc uhdfr tmf

    O_G wmfh mf rfiusfd tn rfturh, rfcfgsf nr dfckvfr tn tmf gddrfssfd rfokpkfht tmf oghhgjks usfd

    jy OMVZOM kh kts spkrktugc mfgckh` ghd rfck`knus rktugcs.

    4:. Tmf ZIZG ks gppckogjcf tn tmf cgws ghd rucfs ni tmf Dfifhdghts, fgom pgrt ni tmf

    Ifdfrgc `nvfrhafht, wmfh tmf rucfs nr cgws gt kssuf fvfh gppckogjcf `fhfrgccy ghd hnt tgr`ftfd

    gt rfck`knh sujstghtkgccy jurdfh tmf irff fxfroksf ni rfck`knh.

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    9/28

    ONARCGKHT - ;

    4?. Kh NOfhtrn, suprg, tmf Vhktfd _tgtfs _uprfaf Onurt dffafd tmf VHKTFD

    _TGTF_ mgd igkcfd tn smnw g onapfcckh` `nvfrhafht khtfrfst inr purpnsfs ni ZIZG kh g ogsf

    khvncvkh` g O_G _omfducf K onhtrnccfd sujstghof.

    44. Tmf sfkzurf ni tmf sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks jy tmf Dfifhdghts mgs pcgofd g sujstghtkgc

    jurdfh nh tmf spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs ni OMVZOM, @ZGYF_, ANNHF[ ghd OMVZOMs

    afajfrs jfogusf wktmnut kt, tmf spkrktugc mfgckh` ghd rfck`knus rktugcs oghhnt jf pfrinrafd.

    4?. Tmf Dfifhdghts dn hnt mgvf g onapfcckh` `nvfrhafht khtfrfst lustkiykh` sfkzurf ni

    OMVZOMs sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks jfogusf tmf purpnsf ni tmf O_G gs ghhnuhofd jy Onh`rfss kh

    tmf 7;07 Onaprfmfhskvf Dru` Gjusf Rrfvfhtknh ghd Onhtrnc Gotwgs tn onajgt tmf

    rforfgtknhgc gjusf ni dru`s.

    44. Oghhgjks usfd kh OMVZOMs spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs ghd ofrfanhkfs, ghd gs g

    sgorgafht ks hnt tmf rforfgtknhgc gjusf ni dru`s ghd tmf O_Gs jrngd rfstrkotknh ni oghhgjks tmgt

    sujstghtkgccy jurdfhs tmf Rcgkhtkiis rfck`knus rk`mts ks hnt tmf cfgst rfstrkotkvf afghs ni

    onajgttkh` rforfgtknhgc dru` gjusf.

    46. Tmf gotknhs ni tmf Dfifhdghts vkncgtf tmf ZIZG ghd tmf Rcgkhtkiis sffe khluhotkvf

    rfckfi gs sft inrtm jfcnw.

    _FONHD OCGKA INZ ZFCKFI

    (Zfck`knus Cghd Vsf ghd Khstktutknhgckzfd Rfrsnhs Got (ZCVKRG),

    4: V._.O. :222oo, ft sfq. G`gkhst Gcc Dfifhdghts)

    49. Rcgkhtkiis rf-gccf`f ghd khonrpnrgtf tmf gccf`gtknhs khocudfd kh pgrg`rgpms 7-?0 ni

    tmks Onapcgkht.

    40. JZGHOM ks cnogtfd nh cghd kh Nrf`nh tmgt dnfs hnt khirkh`f nh nr khtfrifrf wktm

    ghy ntmfr prnpfrty hfgr nr grnuhd kt. Tmf cghd usfd jy JZGHOM ks cnogtfd kh g stgtf tmgt mgsfhgotfd cgws gccnwkh` tmf ouctkvgtknh ni oghhgjks ghd kh g stgtf ckstfd kh _fotknh 6?= wmfrf

    Onh`rfss mgs prnmkjktfd usf ni iuhds jy tmf ifdfrgc Dfpgrtafht ni Lustkof rfcgtfd tn

    kapcfafhtgtknh ni afdkogc oghhgjks cgws, khocudkh` ouctkvgtkh` oghhgjks nh tmf cghd. Gs pgrt ni

    OMVZOM, JZGHOM ouctkvgtfs oghhgjks inr spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs, gs g sgorgafht ghd inr usf

    kh Hgtkvf Gafrkogh ofrfanhkfs. JZGHOMs ouctkvgtknh rfspnhskjkcktkfs gs pgrt ni OMVZOM

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    10/28

    ONARCGKHT - 72

    grf kh-pgrt jgsfd upnh JZGHOMs cnogtknh kh Nrf`nh.

    4=. Jy sfkzkh` sgorgafhtgc oghhgjks ouctkvgtfd jy JZGHOM kh Nrf`nh wmfrf stgtf

    cgws gccnw inr oghhgjks ouctkvgtknh ghd wmfrf Onh`rfss mgs prnmkjktfd usf ni iuhds inr ifdfrgc

    fhinrofafht g`gkhst afdkogc agrklughg, Dfifhdghts grf dksorkakhgtkh` g`gkhst OMVZOM jy

    fiifotkvfcy dfhykh` kt cghd usf rk`mts (k.f.ouctkvgtknh ni oghhgjks inr rfck`knus purpnsfs) jgsfd

    nh g cgw ni `fhfrgc gppckogjkckty tmf ifdfrgc O_G tmgt prnmkjkts gcc oghhgjks.

    4;. Oghhgjks usfd inr spkrktugc mfgckh` ghd kh rfck`knus rktugcs ni OMVZOM ks khtf`rgc

    tn tmf njck`gtknhs OMVZOM mgs wktm Hgtkvf Gafrkogh Trkjfs ghd wktm kts afajfrs.

    62. Gs g rfsuct ni tmf sfkzurf ni kts oghhgjks usfd inr spkrktugc mfgckh` ghd rfck`knus

    rktugcs, OMZVOM mgs suspfhdfd JZGHOMs ouctkvgtknh, prfpgrgtknh, jcfsskh` ghd

    trghspnrtgtknh ni oghhgjks wmkom mgs sujstghtkgccy jurdfhfd usf ni cghd jy OMVZOM,

    pgrtkokpgtknh ni afajfrs kh OMVZOM gotkvktkfs, gssnokgtfd trghspnrtgtknh ni afajfrs tn ghd

    irna OMVZOM gotkvktkfs, onapfhsgtknh ni afajfrs wmn pgrtkokpgtf kh JZGHOMs gotkvktkfs,

    puromgsf ghd usf jy JZGHOM ni nr`ghko onapnhfhts usfd tn ouctkvgtf oghhgjks gs wfcc gs

    ntmfr gotkvktkfs tmgt giifot khtfrstgtf onaafrof.

    67. Jy dksorkakhgtkh` g`gkhst ghd tmfrfjy prfvfhtkh` OMVZOM irna ouctkvgtkh`

    oghhgjks nh kts cghd ghd trghspnrtkh` tmf oghhgjks usfd kh kts spkrktugc mfgckh` rktugcs wmfh tmfy

    sfkzfd oghhgjks jfkh` trghspnrtfd tn OMVZOM afajfrs kh ghntmfr stgtf, tmf Dfifhdghts mgvf

    sujstghtkgccy jurdfhfd tmf Rcgkhtkiis irff fxfroksf ghd cghd usf rk`mts wmkom mgs rfsuctfd kh tmf

    giifotgtknh ni onaafrof ganh` tmf sfvfrgc _tgtfs ghd wktm Hgtkvf Gafrkogh trkjfs tmrnu`m g

    cgw ni `fhfrgc gppckogjkckty, tmf ifdfrgc O_G.

    6:. Tmf gotknhs ni tmf Dfifhdghts dfsorkjfd mfrfkh mgvf dkvfstfd OMVZOM ghd

    JZGHOM ni ofrtgkh cghd usf rk`mts rfcgtfd tn kts rfck`knus rktugcs ghd sujstghtkgccy jurdfhfd

    Irff Fxfroksf rk`mts. Anrfnvfr, tmf Dfifhdghts gotknhs mgvf giifotfd onaafrof jftwffh tmf

    sfvfrgc stgtfs ghd Hgtkvf Gafrkogh trkjfs. Goonrdkh`cy, tmf Dfifhdghts mgvf vkncgtfd ZCVKRG

    ghd tmf Rcgkhtkiis sffe khluhotkvf rfckfi gs sft inrtm jfcnw.

  • 7/25/2019 Oklevueha Native American Church, et al. v. United States of America, et al.

    11/28

    ONARCGKHT - 77

    JG_K_ INZ KHLVHOTKYF ZFCKFI

    Ifd. Zucf Okv. R. 96 & 96(j)(7)(G)

    6?. Rursught tn Zucf 96, tmks ks g Yfrkikfd Onapcgkht. Tmf Onapcgkht ghd igots

    onhtgkhfd kh kt mgvf jffh vfrkikfd tmrnu`m dfocgrgtknhs sk`hfd uhdfr pfhgcty ni pfrlury jy LgafsPgrrfh Annhfy, gh niikofr ni Rcgkhtkii OMVZOM ghd Rcgkhtkii @ZGYF_.

    64. Tmf igots prnvkdkh` g jgsks inr g tfapnrgry rfstrgkhkh` nrdfr ghd prfckakhgry

    khluhotknh (Ifd. Zucf Okv. Rrno. 96(j)(7)(G)) grf tmnsf sft inrtm kh pgrg`rgpm 7 tmrnu`m

    pgrg`rgpm 62 ni tmks onapcgkht ghd grf anrf spfokikogccy sft inrtm gs inccnws