Top Banner
Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola, Michal Siwak,
49

Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Jan 15, 2016

Download

Documents

Ann Ward
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars.

Mike ReedMissouri State University

With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola, Michal Siwak, Waldek Ogloza.

Page 2: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Views of 3 pulsating sdB stars

Each with different properties.

We wish to understand them and determine how they resemble

other pulsating sdB stars.

Page 3: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Connecting to a larger picture:What can we learn using Asteroseismology?

*Stellar evolutionary timescales *Cosmochronology *Stratifying of stellar

interiors *Stellar crystallization *Nuclear fusion cross sections *Masses, radii, and luminosities of stars (distance scales and population synthesis) *Diffusive processes

*Convection *Neutrinos *Elementary particle physics *Helium flash *radiative levitation *binary evolution *Type I supernovae *Mass exchange and loss *Stellar magnetism *Interstellar enrichment *Electroweak theory *Core/Envelope ratios *semiconvection *Stellar equations of state *Stellar

winds *Lollypop to Popsicle ratio.

Page 4: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 5: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

A Radial Pulsator: l=0The entire surface changes.

Page 6: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

A Nonradial Pulsator: l=11 line across the surface.

Page 7: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

A Nonradial Pulsator: l=22 lines across the surface.

Page 8: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

But when many are combined....It is hard to distinguish the mode.

Page 9: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

First Goal:

Determine the spherical harmonics of pulsation frequencies to constrain

models.

Page 10: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Mode Identification Methods

Traditional: Frequencies and spacings: Feige 48

Binary interactions: PG1336-018

Page 11: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 12: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Feige 48Observed over several years and

from multiple campaigns.

Page 13: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Triplet

Page 14: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 15: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Our Model Solution:Total Mass: 0.4725 Msolar

Shell Mass: 0.0025 Msolar

Teff=29635 K (29,500+/-500)log g = 5.518 (5.50+/-0.05)

Near core He exhaustion (0.74% by mass)Predicted a rotation period near 0.4 days, which

was detected the following year.

Page 16: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Binary sdB pulsator

PG1336-018: Observed by WET in 1999 and 2001

Page 17: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Binary Period is ~2.4 Hours

The companion (~M5V) contributes little light to the

integrated flux. i=81o

Page 18: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

PG1336-018Over 20 Pulsation Frequencies

Detected within 2500 Hz

➢ 2.4 hour orbital period.

➢ Tidal forces are comparable to Coriolis force

Page 19: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Effects to look for.

➢ Eclipse Mapping

➢ Tidal Influence on Pulsations

Page 20: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Eclipse Mapping

Page 21: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

l=1, m=1

Page 22: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 23: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

PG1336-018

An ideal case!~15 minute

eclipses covering ~60% of the

pulsator.

Page 24: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Eclipse data for PG1336

➢ All the in-eclipse modes are new! (Except for 2.)

➢ But not where we expect them to be from splittings

seen in the OoE data.

➢ Most modes are splittings away from OoE modes.Results:

PG1336 eclipses do not map pulsations as we expect.

Page 25: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Tipped Pulsation Axis

(Tidal Influence on

Pulsations)

Page 26: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

A tipped pulsation axis?

➢ Tidal forces exceed Coriolis force.➢ Pulsation axis will point at companion-

similar to roAp stars.➢ Orbital motion will precess the pulsation

axis, completing one revolution every couple hours.

Page 27: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

l=2, m=1

Page 28: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 29: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 30: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Each tipped pulsation mode has

3 signatures.

➢ Number and separation of peaks in the

combined FT

➢ Predictable regions of like phase.

➢ If divided into regions of like phase, a central

peak should show up.

Page 31: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 32: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

And what did we really see?

Page 33: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 34: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 35: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Nothing new and/or exciting.

Page 36: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 37: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Here is one!

Page 38: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 39: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

What have we learned?

1 good and 1 mediocre l=1, m=1 identifications.

1 reasonable l=2, m=0 identification.1 reasonable l=2, m=1 identification.

On to the models for PG1336!

Page 40: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

PG0048: An unexpected surprise!

Page 41: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Every night, something new!

Page 42: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 43: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Detected a total of 29 frequencies.

But only 1 of them is detected in every good-quality run.

Page 44: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 45: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Page 46: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Signatures of stochastic oscillations:

*Highly variable amplitudes.*Sometimes (or often) damped below

detectability*Combinations of data have reduced

amplitudes (because of phase differences)

Page 47: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Simulations of stochastic oscillations

Page 48: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Best fit results for PG0048:

A damping timescale if 4 – 6 hoursand a

re-excitation timescale of 13 – 19 hours.

Page 49: Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,

Results:Feige 48 solved using traditional

methods.

PG1336 shows indications of inclined pulsation axis which can constrain

models.

PG0048 shows indications of stochastic oscillations.