www.nutritionmedicine.or g Nutrition Medicine: Genes, Nutrition & Health Dr Melvyn A Sydney-Smith. KGSJ. MBBS. PhD. Dip Clin Nutrit. FACNEM. Australian College of Holistic Medicine Doolandella. Qld.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Nutrition Medicine:Genes, Nutrition & Health
Dr Melvyn A Sydney-Smith. KGSJ.MBBS. PhD. Dip Clin Nutrit. FACNEM.
Australian College of Holistic MedicineDoolandella. Qld.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene~Environment InteractionThe interplay between genetic inheritance and
the environment is a major factor that determines propensity towards disease or health.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
This has long been known to physicians:
“Positive health requires a knowledge of man’s primary constitution and the powers of various foods, both those natural to them and those resulting from human skills …
If there is any deficiency in food or exercise, the body will fall sick.”
Hippocrates ~ circa 5th Century BC.
Gene~Environment Interaction
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene~Environment Interaction
Compare Hippocrates’ statement with OTM:
Nutritional state with genetic endowment, interacts with aetiological agents
in a way which causes,or fails to cause, disease
Good nutrition leads to healthand resistance to disease
Poor nutrition leads to ill-healthand susceptibility to many diseases.
Oxford Textbook of Medicine, Third Edition. 1999.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene~Environment InteractionNutrigenomics focuses on how:
genetic inheritance affects metabolic nutrient requirements ~AND~
diet and nutrient intake affects gene expression and tissue metabolism; ~AND~
common dietary chemicals affect the propensity towards health or disease.
Nutrigenomic studies will hopefully identify individual genotypic diet and nutrient requisites to enable: early prevention of disease ~and~ specific nutritional interventions to
remediate disease-related metabolic dysfunction
Kaput J & Rodriguez. 2004. Physiol Genomics. 16:166-77
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene~Environment Interaction
The basic tenets of nutrigenomic are:1) Dietary chemicals affect the genome,
altering gene expression or structure2) Diet can be a serious risk factor for a variety
of diseases3) Diet-regulated genes affect onset, incidence,
progression and severity of chronic diseases
4) The degree of dietary influence on the health~disease balance depends on individual genotype
5) Medical intervention based on knowledge of genotype, nutrient requirement and current nutritional status can be used to prevent, mitigate or remediate chronic disease
Kaput J & Rodriguez. 2004. Physiol Genomics. 16:166-77
www.nutritionmedicine.org
The human genome: is comprised of 46 chromosomes 22 autosomal pairs plus 2 sex chromosomes The 3 billion base pairs of DNA contain about 30,000 - 40,000 protein-coding genes.
•a much smaller number than predicted –•only twice as many as in the worm or fly
The coding regions are less than 5% of the genome
•function of the remaining DNA is not clear•some chromosomes have a higher gene density than others.
Understanding Genetics: available from: http://www.geneticalliance.org/ksc_assets/pdfs/manual Accessed 12th July 2006.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism
Each gene is composed of 2 alleles which may be: the same ~ homozygous ~ AA or
aaor
different ~ heterozygous ~ AaHowever, there may be more than 2
allele variants {polymorphisms} ~
e.g: APO E2, APO E3, APO E4Thus a person’s APO E genotype may be:
E2/E2, E2/E3, E2/E4E3/E3, E3/E4, E4/E4
NB: 6 different genotypes
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism
Polymorphism vs MutationVariant alleles occurring in over 1% of population are called
polymorphismsVariant alleles in less than 1% of population are mutationsAllele frequency varies between populations & families ~
Thus, nutritional requirements & disease susceptibility vary between populations
Allelic variation fostered by population isolation and cultural, preferential mating behaviour
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism
Single nucleotide polymorphisms ~ Single base-pair DNA differences
observed between people simplest and most common form of
DNA polymorphism ~ frequency about of 1/1,000 base pairs In any individual, gene polymorphism is
estimated to affect about 10% of the genome
SNPs may cause disease if they affect expression of an enzyme-coding gene About 1000 monogenic diseases due to
SNPs have been identified
Jimenez-Sanchez G et al. 2001. Nature. 409:853-55
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism and Disease
Fragile X syndrome
Maple syrup urine disease
Cystic fibrosis
Phenylketonuria
Tay Sachs disease
Homocystinuria
Methylmalonyl CoA deficiency
Sideroblastic anaemia
Carboxylase
deficiency
MTHFR deficiency
G-6-PD deficiency
Thalassemia
Monogenic DiseaseMonogenic Disease
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism and Disease
Multigenic disease: e.g. arteriosclerosisPolymorphisms that regulate expression and activity of
genes involved in blood lipid control are common: Occur in 7 – 16% of population Apolipoproteins: Apo A-IV, Apo A, Apo B, Apo E Lipoprotein lipase Cholesterol ester transfer protein
Affect cholesterol binding and clearance Promote hyperlipidaemia, arteriosclerotic disease
and dementia Alter responses to cholesterol reducing interventions
Both dietary & pharmacologicalConfound epidemiological & interventional
research
Knoblauch H, Bauerfeind A et al. Hum Molec Genet, 2002; 11(12):1477–85.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene Polymorphism and Disease
Incidence of specific allele variants between populations often varies:
Example: APO E4 ~
Caucasian population mean frequency15% ~ North-South variance ~ 23%
in Finland and 20% in Sweden down to 8% in Italy
Non-Caucasian populations About 30% in Africans
(Nigeria) 35% in Papua New Guinea 5% in China
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene PolymorphismPopulations ApoE2 ApoE3 ApoE4
Caucasians (Tyroleans) Hallman et al., 1991 9.0% 78.9% 11.7%
Blacks (Khoi San) Sandholzer et al., 1995 7.7% 55.3% 37.0%
Asians (Chinese) Kao et al., 1995 7.6% 87.5% 4.9%
Alaskans (Inuit) Scheer et al., 1995 2.0% 78.7% 19.3%
Amazonian (Amerindians) Marin et al., 1997 0.0% 83.1% 16.9%
GB Marin et al. 1997. Braz. J. Genet. 20(4)
Tribes Yanomami Wayana Wayampi Arara Kayapo
ApoE3 95.6 82.0 57.7 92.8 90.4
ApoE4 4.3 18.0 42.3 7.2 9.6
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Multi-Genetic Disease
In multigenic disease, single polymorphisms may exert a pronounced
influence: Hypertension ~ Glycine 460 Trp gene
variant that codes for Adducin Alters renal salt excretion hypertension
in presence of high-salt diet These patients respond well to low salt
diet and diuretic therapy Osteoporosis ~ influenced by VDR gene
variants BB + tt genotypes have increased
osteoporosis risk Homocystinaemia ~ polymorphism of the
gene coding for MTHFR 677CT variant increases folate
requirementsContributes to a wide range of disease
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Multi-Genetic Disease
More usually, multiple polymorphisms interact to:
modify nutrient demand and metabolism affect enzyme production and efficiency
alter epigenetic regulatory mechanisms cytokines, hormones, sensor molecules
and transcription factors Ppars, MAP kinases, NF-Kappa-B
modulate expression of other genes further alters metabolism and regulatory
elements change responses to environmental factors
nutrition, exercise, xenobiotics
Leads to development of disease phenotypeHypertension, coronary heart disease, Type 2 diabetes
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Genomic and metabolic complexity currently obscures clear definition ~several promising links have been identified ~ for example: Peroxisome proliferator activated receptor
Regulates genes coding for inflammatory mediators, lipogenesis and glucose metabolism
Gene variants contribute to cholesterol metabolism, insulin resistance & obesity
Sterol regulatory element-binding protein 1c (SREBP-1c)activates insulin-dependent increase in lipogenic gene
expression Carbohydrate Response element Binding Protein (ChREBP)
Glucose sensor that regulates glyco-lipid metabolism
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Multi-Genetic Disease
Carbohydrate Response-element Binding Protein (ChREBP) ~ major gene-metabolic molecule
Transcription factor coded for by a polymorphic geneUpregulates genes that code for lipogenesisDownregulates genes that code for glucose and lipid oxidationActivated by dietary carbohydrate (glucose & sucrose) and insulinChREBP activity inhibited/normalised by omega-3-EFA
Uyeda et al, 2002
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene-Nutrients-Lifestyle
Genotype is NOT an immutable prescription for disease
Multiple external and internal factors, (dietary, nutritional & lifestyle) strongly influence:
Nuclear & mitochondrial gene expression Promoter & suppressor codon activity Transcription factor production & activity Modulatory epigenetic molecules
Nutritional & lifestyle modification can counter a disease promoting genome
Kaput & Rodriguez, 2004
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Gene-nutritionMany polymorphic gene-regulated enzymes exhibit
an altered Michaelis constant (Km) with reduced cofactor or coenzyme binding About 30% of the 1000 disease phenotypes related to
SNP polymorphisms reportedly exhibit reduced specific enzyme binding
At least 50 diseases have been shown to respond to high-dose nutrient supplements
Vitamin B1, Vitamin B2, Vitamin B3, Vitamin B5, Vitamin B6
Vitamin B12, Folic acid : BiotinVitamin E : Vitamin K : Vitamin DLipoic acid, Carnitine, SAMe, TetrahydrobiopterinAmino acids: alanine, serine, glycine, isoleucine, inosineMinerals: zinc, copper, potassiumAscorbic acid – species genetic deficiency
Ames et al, 2002.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Nutrient insufficiencyNutrient deficiency/insufficiency in
10% population increases nuclear & mitochondrial DNA damage from:Progressive oxidative damage ~AND~ Molecular glycation (AGEs) Increased DNA mutation and
cancer risk Decreased metabolism, loss of
functional reserve and tissue pathology
Folate, B6 & B12 deficiency may cause chromosomal breakage
Zinc & iron deficiency increase DNA damage and impair DNA repair Mitochondrial decay and
NeurodegenerationAmes, 2005 and Ho, 2002
www.nutritionmedicine.org
However, The major influence on genomic disease is probably
the gross discrepancy between our human ancestral genome
and the modern consumer-age diet
www.nutritionmedicine.org
The human genome evolved under harsh selection conditions over a period of 3.5 million years ~
The spontaneous mutation rate for nuclear DNA is estimated at about 0.5% per million years
Over the past 10,000 years, the human genome is calculated to have changed only 0.05% from our paleolithic ancestors ~
The human genome is now struggling to cope with the vastly different diet and lifestyle of the modern era
Eaton SB. 2006. Proc Nutrit Soc. 65(1):1-6
www.nutritionmedicine.org
The modern Homo sapiens genome evolved in northeast Africa about 200,000 years ago ~ then migrated throughout the rest of the world
The first migration occurred following hominid decimation about 70,000 years ago and gave rise to the hunter-gatherer societies of
the Middle East, Asia and Australia
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Following the last Ice-Age 12,000 years ago, the birth of agriculture 10,000 years ago Settled lifestyle and increased population density~ increased demand for intensive farming & animal
husbandry – which occurred about 8,000 years ago~ greater starch-yielding grain crops~ increased gluten content in grains~ altered fat content in animals from supplemental feeding
~ Industrial revolution altered food supply even further~ farming monoculture developed~ increased dependence on grains~ refined sugars became more accessible~ increased fat and trans-fat intake~ increased omega-6/omega-3 EFA ratio
Bradshaw Foundation. www.bradshawfoundation.com/stephenoppenheimer
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Paleolithic diet: Modern Diet
Protein ~ 30-40% 10-20%
Carbohydrates ~ 35% 60-70%
sugars ~ 2-3% 15%
Fats ~ 30-35% 30-35%
Saturated fats ~ 7.5% 15-30%
Trans-fat < 1% 5-10% of fats
Omega-6/omega-3 ~ 2:1 10-20:1
www.nutritionmedicine.org
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Before European contact, hunter-gatherer population diets approximated the Paleolithic Diet~ Australian Aborigines ~ migrated 50,000 yrs ago and
isolated until 1778Diet based on wild game, seafood, nuts, seeds, yams & greens
~ Pacific Islands ~ Fiji 1500 BC, Samoa & Cook Islands 200 BC, Hawaii 600 AD,
~ New Zealand about 1250 ADDiet was based on seafood, poultry, pig + taro, cassava, various greens, tropical fruits, nuts, seeds and coconut
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Plant and animal intake in hunter-gatherer diets. Analysis of dietary intake of 229 Hunter-Gatherer populations around the world showed median animal food intakes of 66 – 75% of total energy and plant food intakes 26 – 35% of total energy. Cordain L, Eaton SB et al. 2002. EJCN.56,Suppl 1:S42–S52.
PopulationAnimal food
(%)Plant food
(%)
Ache (Paraguay) 25S 78 22
!Kung (Africa) 20S 68 32
Aborigines (Arnhem Land) 12S 77 23
Anbarra (Australia) 12S 75 25
Hiwi (Venezuela) 6N 75 25
Onge (Andaman Is) 12N 79 21
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Traditional diet improves chronic disease:
In full-blood Aborigines with diabetes, hypertension and CHD, reversion for 7 weeks to a “traditional” diet resulted in:
~ mean wt loss of 8kg over 7 weeks~ reduced blood pressure~ reduced fasting insulin & glucose~ improved glucose and insulin responses on GTT~ reduced triglyceride and VLDL levels~ reduction or cessation of medication
The traditional diet consisted of: ~ 64% protein, ~ 13% fat and ~ 23% low-GI/GL CHOs~ 1200 Cal/person/day
K O'Dea. 1984. Diabetes, 33(6): 596-603.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Summary:The broad perspective of human metabolic and
archeological data suggests that human genes are adapted to a nutrient intake which approximates that of the Paleolithic Diet
Genomic research has identified several gene-regulated transcription binding proteins that are: a) responsive to dietary lipid and CHO intake and b) propel metabolism towards common disease phenotypes CHD, Hypertension, Insulin Resistance, Diabetes etc.
Individual gene variants have also been identified that affecta) disease development and b) response to nutritional and pharmacological therapy
www.nutritionmedicine.org
In the short-term, the assessment and management of genotypic disease will remain limited, and clinicians must perforce remain dependent on: Thorough family history Knowledge of ethnic disease links Careful patient nutritional assessment and Restricted range of validated genetic tests
whilst we await the clinical access to genomic analysis
However, the years ahead are exciting, as the genetic influences on disease ~AND~ the effect of dietary-nutrient modulation on gene expression & activity are clarified.
www.nutritionmedicine.org
Thank youfor your care and attention
andmay your genes always
work with you