Top Banner
ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 7 Keywords: computer attitudes, computer skills in nursing, information technology syllabus, nursing education, Abstract Background The need for addressing the issue of training nursing students in Health Informatics [the discipline dealing with the application of information and communications technology (ICT) to health care] and incorporating training in the basic information technology skills is becoming a matter for much dis- cussion. Literature reports that the previous com- puter experience of nurses can generate a positive or negative attitude to a specific computer system and influence the motivation to acquire new com- puter knowledge. Attempts to address this matter in Ireland came with the recommendation by the Syllabus of Nurse Training 2000 that ICT be in- cluded as a taught component within the curr icu- lum. The lack of emphasis on ICT being taught as a formal component with no guidelines as to what level this ICT component should reflect, do little to assist either nurse educators or programme developers. Literature on information and communications technology in health care generally, and in nursing and midwifery education specifically, is now expand- ing. Current literatur e on the subject addresses vari- ous issues including the applications of computers to nursing practice, approaches to teaching compu- ter skills to nurses and midwives, and various stud- ies dealing with computer literacy and attitudes. The purpose of this study was threefold: 1. To describe the self-reported experiences of nurses concerning their personal and professional use of computers. 2. T o describe the at titudes that nurses have con- cerning their personal and professional use of com- puters. 3. T o identify the comput er training needs of stu- dents undertaking the Bachelor in Nursing Studies degree programme. Method The study was designed as a descriptive survey using a modified three-part Questionnaire that collected self-reported information on the nurses’ experience and attitudes to using computers. The survey was carried out with a single cohort of regis- tered nurses undertaking a Bachelor in Nursing Stud- ies Degree during the year 2001. Introduction It is generally accepted that we live in a t echnologi- cal age. Information and Communications T ech- nology (ICT) is all pervasive to the extent that our economy and qua lity of life depend on it. (1) The increase in availability and use of computer networks and the Internet are producing a changing climate i n education as well as in health care. This increased use of computers in healthcare prompts a need to increase nurses’ computer knowledge. Since the 1970s computers have revolutionised the way in which healthcare is delivered, practised and managed. Evaluating nurses’ attitudes towards computer use is an area that has received much attention in the literature (2,3 4,5,6,7). Sinclair’s study of nurse teacher’s perceptions of information technology indicated that although some nurse teachers have had no formal traini ng and lack basic computer skills themselves, they do recognise the need for computer competenc e among teachers and students. (8) The purpose of this study was to describe the self-reported experience and attitudes that nurses have concerning their personal and professional use of computers. Peer reviewed research paper Nursing students experience and attitudes to computers: A survey of a cohort of students on a Bachelor in Nursing Studies course Elizabeth Curtis MEd.; RGN; ONC; DMS; Dip. Research Method  s.; Dip CHHP;  Lectur er and BN S Pro gramme L eader , School of Nursing & Midwifery Studies, Trinity College Dublin Paula Hicks, M. Sc., TDipIT Project Co-ordinator, Centre for Health  Informatics, T rinity Colle ge Dubl in Richard Redmond MEd.; RPN, RMHN, RNT , Dip Nur sing, FFNRSCI  Lectur er and BN S Pro gramme L eader , School of Nursing & Midwifery Studies, Trinity College Dublin
12

Nursing with computers

Jun 01, 2018

Download

Documents

BibiVmv
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 1/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 7

Keywords: computer attitudes, computer

skills in nursing, information technology

syllabus, nursing education,

Abstract

Background The need for addressing the issue of 

training nursing students in Health Informatics [the

discipline dealing with the application of information

and communications technology (ICT) to health care]

and incorporating training in the basic information

technology skills is becoming a matter for much dis-

cussion. Literature reports that the previous com-

puter experience of nurses can generate a positive

or negative attitude to a specific computer system

and influence the motivation to acquire new com-

puter knowledge. Attempts to address this matter

in Ireland came with the recommendation by the

Syllabus of Nurse Training 2000 that ICT be in-

cluded as a taught component within the curricu-

lum. The lack of emphasis on ICT being taught as a

formal component with no guidelines as to what level

this ICT component should reflect, do little to assist

either nurse educators or programme developers.

Literature on information and communicationstechnology in health care generally, and in nursing

and midwifery education specifically, is now expand-

ing. Current literature on the subject addresses vari-

ous issues including the applications of computers

to nursing practice, approaches to teaching compu-

ter skills to nurses and midwives, and various stud-

ies dealing with computer literacy and attitudes.

The purpose of this study was threefold:

1. To describe the self-reported experiences of nurses concerning their personal and professional

use of computers.

2. To describe the attitudes that nurses have con-

cerning their personal and professional use of com-

puters.

3. To identify the computer training needs of stu-

dents undertaking the Bachelor in Nursing Studies

degree programme.

Method The study was designed as a descriptivesurvey using a modified three-part Questionnaire that

collected self-reported information on the nurses’

experience and attitudes to using computers. The

survey was carried out with a single cohort of regis-

tered nurses undertaking a Bachelor in Nursing Stud-

ies Degree during the year 2001.

Introduction

It is generally accepted that we live in a technologi-

cal age. Information and Communications Tech-

nology (ICT) is all pervasive to the extent that oureconomy and quality of life depend on it. (1) The

increase in availability and use of computer networks

and the Internet are producing a changing climate in

education as well as in health care. This increased

use of computers in healthcare prompts a need to

increase nurses’ computer knowledge.

Since the 1970s computers have revolutionised the

way in which healthcare is delivered, practised and

managed. Evaluating nurses’ attitudes towardscomputer use is an area that has received much

attention in the literature (2,3 4,5,6,7).

Sinclair’s study of nurse teacher’s perceptions of 

information technology indicated that although some

nurse teachers have had no formal training and lack 

basic computer skills themselves, they do recognise

the need for computer competence among teachers

and students. (8) The purpose of this study was to

describe the self-reported experience and attitudesthat nurses have concerning their personal and

professional use of computers.

Peer reviewed

research paperNursing students experience andattitudes to computers: A survey of a

cohort of students on a Bachelor inNursing Studies course

Elizabeth Curtis MEd.; RGN; ONC; DMS;

Dip. Research Method s.; Dip CHHP;

 Lecturer and BNS Programme Leader, School

of Nursing & Midwifery Studies, Trinity

College Dublin

Paula Hicks, M. Sc., TDipIT

Project Co-ordinator, Centre for Health

 Informatics, Trinity College Dublin

Richard Redmond MEd.; RPN, RMHN,

RNT, Dip Nursing, FFNRSCI

 Lecturer and BNS Programme Leader, School

of Nursing & Midwifery Studies, Trinity

College Dublin

Page 2: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 2/11

8 Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 ITIN

Literature Review

Although Knapp and Whiting-O’Keefe conclude that

computer implementation enhances medical care

there has been a history of non-use and resistance

to computers by health care workers. Some of the

causes of this negativity stem from technical,organisational, and lack of consultation in the change

process leading to poorly designed systems and

individual psychological factors such as

attitudes.(9,10) Research has shown that nurses’

attitudes toward computerisation have been found

to vary according to age, gender, level of education,

level of job satisfaction, past experience with

computers, clinical area of employment, geographic

location and the number of years of employment in

the health care field. (11,12,13,6)

Evaluating nurses attitudes towards computer use is

an area which has received much attention in the

literature (2,3,4,5,6,7). Birx et al. comment on

nurses in practice settings being exposed to a variety

of changes with responses to these changes varying

from total lack of acceptance to full support. (14)

The introduction of computers has the potential to

evoke a variety of feelings in the users, remarks

McBride in 1996. She further comments that

student nurses are the ‘future caregivers in our new

automated health care service’ and hence the need

to explore the factors that may be contributing to

their attitudes towards computers. (3)

Most authors use self developed instruments to

measure nurses’ computer knowledge. The

Staggers’ Nursing Computer Experience

Questionnaire (SNCEQ) consists of sections on

computer knowledge, computer application,

participation in and knowledge about informatics roleactivities. (15) Birx et al. developed a 10 item multiple

choice test based on computer orientation content

to measure student’s understanding of basic

computer terminology. (14) Burkes developed a

13 item list of true, false or uncertain type of 

questions on computer knowledge for her Nurses’

Attitudes Toward Computer Use instrument. (16)

Instruments used to measure attitudes include

Brondt and Stronge’s Nurses’ Attitudes TowardComputers Questionnaire, a 20 item Likert-type

instrument consisting of 6 positively worded and 14

negatively worded items rated on a five point scale.

This questionnaire mainly measures nurses’ beliefs

and concerns regarding computers in general and

not specific computer applications. (12) Thomas in

1990 developed the ‘Attitudes Toward Computing

in Nursing’ a parallel measure instrument used to

assess change in attitudes among nurses and nursingstudents. (17) Burkes Nurses’ Computer-Use

Attitude Questionnaire measures nurses computer

attitudes on satisfaction, beliefs and motivation. (16)

Scarpa et al. survey of 136 nurses employed in a

non-computerised hospital showed the only

significant contributor to a positive attitude was

previous experience with computers. (18) Ball et

al. demonstrated that nurses’ attitudes toward

computers could be positively influenced by acomputer literacy course emphasising the

responsibilities of nursing and the way in which

computer technology is functionally relevant for

nurses and their work. (19) Schwirian et al.

compared attitudes of nurses (n=358) and nursing

students (n=353) toward computer use in nursing

practice and examined factors contributing to these

attitudes. Student nurses were found to have more

positive attitudes toward computers than registered

nurses. Owning a computer, intending to buy a

computer, having a computer in the home, working

in a computerised environment, and using computers

in school all contributed to a more positive attitude.

(20)

The degree to which computers impact on nurses’

day-to-day lives varies dramatically from hospital

to hospital. Van Bemmel et al. remarks that health

care professionals often lack knowledge of the

possibilities and limitations of systematically

processing data, information and knowledge and of the resulting impact on quality decision-making. (21)

Recommendations have been published over the

past ten years for teaching Health Informatics and

in parallel for nursing training in nursing informatics

(22,23,24). All agree that Health Informatics, but

more specifically Nursing Informatics should be

integrated into the nursing curriculum.

Bryson’s study of the perceptions of nurse educatorsfound that nurses should acquire skills in using the

computer as a tool in nursing, for example word

Page 3: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 3/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 9

processing for preparing nursing care plans, using

computer-aided instruction as a learning tool, using

a hospital computer information system, using a

computerised library database, and using software

for statistical computations. (2)

Research describes the various computer literacyobjectives for nursing. McGonigle and Eggars stress

nursing informatics courses must prepare student

nurses to manage information, enter into research

and communicate via computers. (24) Specific

requirements for nurses outlined in the United States

in 1988 by the National League of Nursing (NLN)

suggested four informatics competencies, 1)

documenting nursing practice; 2) accessing

information; 3) using the data and information from

a computer system; and 4) coordinating informationflow. (25) From these requirements Liu et al.

concluded that nurses’ computer knowledge should

include a basic understanding of the following;

Computer hardware and software; The concept of 

a computer program; Computer applications in

nursing; How a computer system operates; Word

processing; Computer aided instruction for

continuing education, and finally, nurses should also

be aware of system security and the limitations of 

the computer. (7)

Some experimental methods of improving computer

skills among nurses include Birx and Castleberry’s

evaluative study, which integrated the use of laptop

computers into student coursework. The outcomes

showed improved skills for those with the lap top

computers while both groups retained a positive

attitude towards computers. (14) Fullerton’s study

introduced self-paced tutorials developed

specifically for use by graduate students in an effort

to improve skills such as use of e-mail, world wideweb, file transfer protocol, eXcel and PowerPoint

presentation software – skills, that would help

students succeed in their course of studies. (5)

Developing the information and communications

syllabus in nursing education has become the subject

of a number of studies (26,8,13). In Ireland, An

Bord Altranais’ Requirements and Standards for

Nurse Registration Education Programmes (2000)

includes ‘Information/communication systems andtechnology’ as a topic in their syllabus/indicative

content of each nursing speciality. (27) The lack of 

emphasis on ICT being taught as a formal component

with no guidelines as to what level this ICT

component should reflect, do little to assist either

nurse educators or programme developers.

Purpose of Study

The lack of knowledge and insight that nurse edu-

cators have concerning the experience and attitudes

of nurses about computers provided the background

for this empirical study. The purpose of this study

was threefold:

1. To describe the self-reported experiences of 

nurses concerning their personal and professional

use of computers.

2. To describe the attitudes that nurses have

concerning their personal and professional use of 

computers.

3. To identify the computer training needs of stu-

dents undertaking the Bachelor in Nursing Studies

degree programme.

Method

This study was designed as a descriptive survey using

a modified three-part questionnaire. The unit of 

analysis was the individual nurses attending a Bach-

elor in Nursing Studies (BNS) degree programmein 2001.

Sampling Procedure & Sample Size

The sample used in this study was the single cohort

of students attending the BNS Programme 2001.

This approach restricts researchers from making

generalisations about the findings beyond the sam-

ple group, and is commonly used in nursing studies.(28,29) Because the accessible population was

quite small the entire cohort of students on this de-

gree programme was invited to participate in the

study. The total number of students on the BNS

programme was 130, of which 10 were included in

the pilot study. The total size of the sample for the

main study was 120 students and the response rate

was 74 (61.7%).

Description of Sample

Page 4: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 4/11

10 Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 ITIN

All subjects were qualified nurses and were registered

with An Bord Altranais (Irish Nursing Board). Sub-

 jects had completed successfully either the (a) Diploma

in Nursing, (b) Higher Diploma in Nursing (UK) or (c)

Access to Degree Programme. All were undertaking a

one-year BNS programme.

Study Setting

The study was undertaken in The School of Nursing &

Midwifery Studies, The University of Dublin Trinity

College.

Data Collection

A survey using a questionnaire was the choice of method

of data collection. Data were collected on two days by

two of the researchers. A covering letter outlining the

purpose of the study and how anonymity and confiden-

tiality would be maintained was attached to each ques-

tionnaire. Students were informed of this research

project at the beginning of their BNS programme and

prior to the pilot study. The reasons for using a ques-

tionnaire include (a) suitable for a descriptive cross-

sectional study, (b) time constraints, (c) greater assur-

ance of anonymity and (d) less expensive than other

methods. (30). Questionnaires were distributed to all

students at the end of a lecture. Information regarding

the collection of data is given in Table 1 This cohort of 

BNS students attended lectures in two separate groups

on two different study days during each week. Group

one consisted of 67 students and group two of 63.

Questionnaire

The title of the questionnaire was “A Survey of 

Nursing Students’ Experience and Attitudes to

Computers” which collected self-reported infor-

mation on nurses’ experiences and attitudes to

computers. The questionnaire consisted of a

total of fifty items and took approximately twenty

minutes to complete. These fifty questions weredivided as follows: (a) five biographic questions

(b) twenty-two questions on experience of com-

puters and (c) an attitudinal scale of eighteen

questions. The questionnaire was developed by

Sinclair &Gardner, (1997) and permission was

obtained to use it for the present study. (8) The

questionnaire was amended for use in the present

study following review by two statisticians at

Trinity College, Dublin.

Validity Assessment

This refers to the ability of the instrument to

measure what it is supposed to measure. (31)

The questionnaire used in this study was

examined by two statisticians and an independent

IT consultant. All comments received were

examined by the researchers and changes were

made to the instrument before undertaking the

pilot study.

 Ethical Issues

Research that violates the rights of respondents

is unethical. To prevent this, codes of ethics for

human subject research have been developed

to ensure the protection of respondents’ safety

and dignity. (29,31). According to Burns &

 Table 1: Data Collection

Data CollectionInstrument No of  Subjects How When Where By Whom

N = 67

Group 1

Researchersdistributedquestionnairefollowing a lecture

Date: 10.04.01

 Time: 12.30-13.00

Lecture Theatre, Trinity College

ResearchersQuestionnaire

N = 63

Group 2

Researchersdistributed

questionnairefollowing a lecture

Date: 11.04.01

 Time: 12.30-13.00

Lecture Theatre, Trinity 

College

Researchers

Page 5: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 5/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 11

Grove the attitudes, beliefs, opinions and records

of anyone is regarded as private information and

therefore must be protected. (29) The right to

privacy also means that the respondents have the

right to anonymity and confidentiality. In this study

privacy was protected in several ways. First,

anonymity was assured because no names were usedand responses could not be linked to specific

individuals. Second, only the researchers involved

in this project had access to the data collected which

ensured greater confidentiality. Third, all data was

stored securely either in a locked cabinet or

computer file. In addition, all questionnaires were

destroyed when the data was analysed.

Informed consent is crucial to the right to self-

determination and is protected when consent isobtained. (28) The purpose of this study was

discussed with respondents several weeks prior to

its commencement and an opportunity for

respondents to ask questions was also provided.

Respondents were informed that consenting to

participate in the study did not in any way preclude

them from withdrawing at any time if they so wished.

Moreover, at no time was any respondent compelled

or coerced by any of the researchers to participate

in this study. These assurances were further

emphasised in a letter that accompanied all

questionnaires.

 Pilot Study

In keeping with survey research methods, a pilot

study was conducted on a small sample of the cohort

of students. Ten students made up the sample for

the pilot study and they were precluded from

participating in the main study. All respondents

completed the questionnaire. Following review of the questionnaires no modifications were made prior

to the main study.

Results

Data were prepared and entered into a spreadsheet

using SPSS. The findings are presented in both

tabular and graphic format.

 Biographic:

The response rate was 74 (61.7%) of which 4%

were male. Fifty six (75.7%) of the respondents

belonged to the age range 20-25 while 14 (18.9%)

were between 26-30 years of age. These findings

were not surprising since most of this cohort of 

students had only just completed their Diploma in

Nursing. The majority of this sample reported that

they were currently working in general nursing.

Figure 1 summarises the percentage of the sampleworking in the various nursing disciplines. Seventy

(94.6%) of the respondents commenced their nurse

training as school leavers, only four (5.4%) entered

nurse training as mature students (i.e. over the age

of 23).

 Experience of Computers:

This section of the questionnaire was made up of three questions relating to prior computer training,

four questions on determining levels of skill and

computer usage and sixteen multiple choice

questions.

In response to the question on prior computer

training, forty seven (63.5%, n=74) reported to have

completed some form of training. Eighteen (37.5%)

of the 47 who had received training gained this

training at school. Twenty seven (57.5%) of the

forty seven who had some form of computer training

received training in word processing, nineteen

(40.4%) in spreadsheets and sixteen (34%) in

Internet use.

Students were then asked to estimate their level of 

skill with various computer packages based on a

four level scale (None/Low, Medium, High and

Expert). Results showed identical numbers for

general use of computers and Internet use, sixty three

students (85.1%) declaring a medium or high levelof skill and one respondent (1.4%) reporting an

expert level of skill in these two categories. Fifty

five (75.3%) reported a medium or high level of skill

in using hospital based systems with two (2.7%)

respondents declaring an expert level of skill in this

category. Fifty two (71.2%) reported a medium or

high level of skill in word processing. Slightly over

1/3 of the cohort responded to using a computer at

least once a week. Figure 2 shows the variety of 

activities included in this question and the range andlevel of skill reported by the respondents.

Page 6: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 6/11

12 Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 ITIN

Respondents were asked a variety of questions in

relation to computer knowledge and computer

One of these questions required a yes/no answer to

specific computer tasks such as saving a file and

deleting a file. Figure 3 shows the distribution of 

reported answers.

The final section on experience of computers

consisted of sixteen multiple choice questions.

Correct responses varied across the questions and

are summarised in Table 2.

As can be seen in Table 2, overall results showed

that responses varied, but a moderate to high per-centage of students reported a good knowledge of 

computers. Of the sixteen questions, thirteen were

answered particularly well. The range of knowl-

edge varied considerably between the questions

answered correctly by the largest and lowest number

of respondents, i.e. sixty seven (90.5%) knew what

a cursor does, in contrast only 19 (25.7%) knew

what was meant by the term debugging. Correct

answers ranged from 19 (25.7%) to 67 (90.5%)

and the mean of correct answers was 44.

Attitudes to Computers

A four part Likert type scale ranging from Strongly

Disagree to Strongly Agree was used to determine

attitudes to computers. This scale contained ten

positive and ten negative statements which werepresented in mixed order. Respondents were asked

to indicate the degree to which they agreed or

disagreed with the statements. Below are examples

of five positive and five negative statements from

the attitudinal scale.

Positive statements included  Learning about 

computers is essential for nurses working in

today’s health service and, I am generally quite

 proficient with computers. 98.6% of respondentsreported that they agree or strongly agree and 37.8%

of respondents reported that they agreed or strongly

agreed with these statements respectively.

Figuring out computer problems appeals to me,

only 22 (29.7%) agreed with this statement. In

response to  I would consider buying a home

computer , the majority of respondents, 63 (85.1%)

agreed or strongly agreed with this statement. The

majority of respondents, 60 (81%) said they agreed

or strongly agreed with the statement I expect to

use computers in many ways in nursing practice.

Examples of the nature of the negative statements

Figure 1: Nursing Discipline (n=74)

Page 7: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 7/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 13

are, I feel intimidated if a conversation turns to

computers and, I do not understand how people

can enjoy working with computers. 44.5% of respondents agreed or strongly agreed with the first

statement and 8% of respondents agreed or strongly

agreed with the second statement. This means that

92% disagreed and strongly disagreed with the lat-

Figure 2: Reported level of skill at variouscomputer activities

 Table 2: Summary of correct responses to

questions 16-28

Question Correct Answers

Percentage(n=74)

What does a cursor do? 67 90.5%

What device converts computer signals to telephone tones? 63 85.1%

Why make a back-up copy on another disk? 57 77%

What is RAM? 56 75.7%A file can be stored permanently on…. 56 75.7%

Computer software refers to…. 51 68.9%

Physical parts of a computer are called? 50 67.7%

What is the purpose of directories? 50 67.6%

Spreadsheets are best used for? 45 60.8%

Best method for correcting multiple spelling errors…… 44 59.5%

Formatting a floppy disk is….. 37 50%

What is a computer program? 36 48.6%

Which of the following is an application…… 31 41.9%

Data accessed on networked PC’s is through…? 25 33.8%

In a database data is stored as…… 23 31.1%

What is meant by the term ‘debugging’…… 19 25.7%

Page 8: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 8/11

14 Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 ITIN

ter statement. Other negative statements include I 

avoid using computers whenever I can, only 22

(29.7%) agreed or strongly agreed with this state-

ment.  I feel threatened by the thought of having

to use a computer , only 14 (18.9%) agreed with

this statement and in response to the statement I 

 find computers boring, only 10 (13.5%) agreedor strongly agreed.

The last two questions on the questionnaire asked

respondents to suggest what computer training they

would consider useful to the BNS Programme and

to comment on the use of computers in Nursing

Practice.

With regard to training that would be useful to the

BNS Programme, the majority of students, fifty two

(72.8%) requested training in basic computer skills,

to include general use of computers, word

processing, spreadsheets and presentation software.

Other main requirements for students included

bibliographic retrieval systems and electronic library

catalogues and internet use 15 (21%).

When asked to comment on computers in nursing

practice an overall majority commented on the im-

portance of the use of computers in the future. Other

comments include, “not widely used in nursing” and“not encouraged”. In general, the overall feeling

among students was that computers are useful in

nursing practice, for example, for producing care

plans. However, participants felt that enough en-

couragement and training was not provided.

Discussion of the results

The positive attitudes reported by respondents

would suggest an interest in learning about comput-

ers and an understanding of the importance the roleICT will play in the future of Health care. Schwirian

et al. (1989) states that ‘nurses constitute the larg-

Figure 3: Summary of Responses for Question 12

Page 9: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 9/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 15

est single group of professionals who use hospital

information systems’. (20) The findings from this

study revealed that fifty five (75.3%) reported a

medium or high level of skill in using hospital based

systems and two (2.7%) respondents declared that

they were at an expert level of skill in using hospital

information systems. 98.6% of the respondentsagreed that Learning about computers is essen-

tial for nurses working in today’s health service

which is a positive start to developing any Health

Informatics programme.

The limited experience of the respondents in this

study reflects on the lack of use of ICT in healthcare

and emphasises the importance of integrating com-

puter teaching at nursing undergraduate level. These

students will be working in an ever advancing tech-nological world and their attitudes and acceptance

of computers is essential. Over the next few years

the numbers of students who receive computer train-

ing at school will certainly increase thereby filling

the gap in the lack of basic level of skills of incoming

students to the BNS.

Defining the idea of computer literacy itself is diffi-

cult. McGonigle (1991) and Liu et al. (2000) have

endeavoured to tackle this issue in relation to nurs-

ing students, but the diversity in the level of skills of 

incoming students continues to make this a difficult

task. (24, 7)

Saranto (1997), Sinclair (1997) and Sinclair (1999)

have stated that it is important in developing any

curriculum to have information on the cohort of 

students. (26, 8,13) This survey has given some

baseline information on the computer skills, and

attitudes of this group of students and can act as a

guide for developing any future curricula. A recentinitiative in the National Health Service (UK) offers

free IT training for all staff using the European

Computer Driving Licence (ECDL) model and level

of standard. The ECDL is a Europe wide

recognised standard of basic computer skills and

competence with computers.

Given that almost one hundred percent of 

respondents felt that learning about computers was

essential for nurses, and the fact that the majoritywere under the age of thirty years, the researchers

do not know if nurses from an older age group would

share such a positive attitude to computers.

Whereas eighty five percent of respondents reported

having a moderate to high level of general computer

skills, we can only speculate about whether this is

due to prior training where nearly two thirds reportedhaving prior training in computers.

Of interest is the observation that while almost all

respondents felt nurses should learn about computers

and the majority said they had moderate to high

levels of computer skills, just under half the

respondents (44.5%) said they felt intimidated if the

conversation turns to computers.

Limitations of this studyLimitations are restrictions within a study that may

restrict researchers from generalising the findings.

(29,31) According to Dempsey & Dempsey (1996)

all studies have limitations but suggest that in

quantitative studies limitations are usually due to the

use of small unrepresentative samples and

inadequate methodology. (31) The researchers have

identified the following methodological limitations.

• The sample used in this study was fairly small

and was not selected randomly. This means

that the sample was not representative of 

the total population of nurses undertaking

BNS programmes and will restrict the

generalisation of the findings.

• A second weakness relates to the single

cohort of students used in this study.

Inclusion of additional cohorts of students

would overcome this limitation.

• Another weakness identified by the

researchers relates to the use of a singlesetting. This could be avoided by including

subjects from other institutions.

• While the instrument was used by other

researchers for a similar study and pretested

for the current study, extensive reliability and

validity data are lacking.

•  Using a single cohort of students has to

some extent restricted the researchers in the

choice of statistical tests.

Page 10: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 10/11

16 Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 ITIN

Implications and recommendations

Despite the small sample the researchers believe that

the findings from this study have implications for

nurse education and further research.

· These findings demonstrated a positive atti-

tude to computers in general and a need for addi-tional training in the use of computers. In view of 

these results the researchers plan to make recom-

mendations to their own school to initiate computer

training programmes for incoming students. The

authors’ own institution provides facilities for stu-

dents to avail themselves of ECDL e-learning tool.

· Further research using a larger sample is rec-

ommended. The use of only one cohort of students

indicates the need for additional cohorts and if pos-sible including cohorts from other institutions.

· Additional research that will encompass prac-

tical computer activities to verify the nature and level

of computer skills.

Conclusion

The literature reveals that there is a need to improve

computer skills amongst nursing students, and high-

lights the dilemmas that face course developers in

attempting to address this situation.

This study attempted to establish the experience and

attitudes of one cohort of nurses. While respond-

ents reported a medium to high level of skill and

positive attitudes to computers generally, 72.8%

requested training in basic computer skills when

asked to comment on what skills they would find

useful on the BNS programme. Despite this, little

can be verified in terms of the actual practical skills

of this sample. The authors believe that it is impor-tant to encourage students to develop further their

basic computer skills and that students should avail

themselves of opportunities to advance these skills,

such as the ECDL e-learning tool available on cam-

pus.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the following for

their co-operation and assistance in preparing this

study Marlene Sinclair MEd, BSc, DASE, RNT,

RM, RN., John Gardner PhD, MSc, BSc, PGCE

C. Eng. , Mary Sharp, B.Sc. (comp.), M.A., C.

Eng., FICS, MIEI, Colin Kirkham, B.Sc.

References

1. Fisher, C., Swyer, D., Yocam, K., Education and

technology: reflections on computer in classrooms,

Education and Technology. Apple Press, London

19962. Bryson, D. (1991) The computer-literate nurse.

Computers in Nursing. 9(3): 100-107

3. McBride, SH. and Nagle, LM. (1996) Attitudes

Towards Computers: A Test of Construct Validity.

Computers in Nursing. 14(3): 164-170.

4. Ngin, P. and Simms, L (1996) Computer Use for

Work Accomplishment: A Comparison Between

Nurses Managers and Staff Nurses. Journal of 

Nursing Administration. 26(3): 47-55

5. Fullerton, J. and Graveley, E (1998) Enhancement

of Basic Computer Skills: Evaluation of an

Intervention. Computers in Nursing. 16(2): 91-94.

6. Baringer, J. (2000). Trying to Excel. Computers

in Nursing. 18(4): 207-208

7. Liu, J., Pothead, L., Lu, Z., & Khamphonsiri, T

(2000) Computer Knowledge, Attitudes, and Skills

of Nurses in People’s Hospital of Beijing Medical

University. Computers in Nursing. 18(4): 197-206.

8. Sinclair, M. & Gardner, J. (1997). Nurse

teachers’ perceptions of information technology: a

study of nurse teachers in Northern Ireland. Journalof Advanced Nursing. 25: 372-376

9. Knapp, R., Miller, M. & Levine, J. (1987)

Experience and attitudes toward computers in

medicine of students and clinical faculty members at

one school. Journal of Medical Education 62: 344-

346

10. Whiting-O’Keefe, Simborg, D., Epstein W,

Warger, A. (1985) A computerized summary

medical record system can provide more information

than the standard medical record. JAMA. 254:1185-1192

11. Axford, R., Carter, B. (1996) Impact of Clinical

Information Systems on Nursing Practice: Nurses’

Perspectives. Computers in Nursing Vol. 14(3)

pp.156-163

12. Stronge, J., Brodt, A. (1985) Assessment of 

nurses’ attitudes toward computerization.

Computers in Nursing 3: 154-158

Page 11: Nursing with computers

8/9/2019 Nursing with computers

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nursing-with-computers 11/11

ITIN Volume 14 Issue 2 June 2002 17

13. Sinclair, M. & Gardner, J. (1999). Planning for

information technology key skills in nurse education.

Journal of Advanced Nursing. 30(6): 1441-1450

14. Birx, E., Castleberry, K., Perry, K. (1996).

Integration of Laptop Computer Technology into an

Undergraduate Nursing Course. Computers in

Nursing. 14(2): 108-112

15. Staggers, N. (1994) The Staggers nursing

computer experience questionnaire. Nursing

Research. 7: 97-106

16. Burkes, M. (1991) Identifying and relating

nurse’s attitudes toward computer use. Computers

in Nursing 9: 190-201

17. Thomas B. S. (1990) Attitudes toward computing

in nursing. In: Waltz C., Stickrland OL.

Measurement of Nursing Outcomes: Measuring

Clinical Skills and Professional Development inEduction and Practice. 3rd Ed. New York: Springer

18. Scarpa, R., Smeltzer, S.C. & Jasion, B. (1992)

Attitudes of nurses toward computerization: a

replication. Computers in Nursing. 10(2) 72-80

19. Ball MJ, Snelbecker GE, Schecter SL. Nurses’

perceptions concerning computer uses before and

after a computer literacy lecture Computers in

Nursing 1985;3:23-32

20. Schwirian P, Malong, J, Stone, V, Nunley, B.,

Francisco, T. (1989) Computers in nursing practice:A comparision of attitudes of nurses and nursing

students. Computers in Nursing. 7: 168-177

21. Van Bemmel, J. H., Musen, M.A. (eds.) (1997)

Handbook of Medical Informatics, Heidelberg:

Springer-Verlag

22. Hannah, K. (1988) Using computers to

education nurses. In Nursing Informatics; Where

Caring and Technology Meet  (Ball M., Hannah,

K., Jelger U. & Peterson H. eds.), National League

for Nursing, New York 

23. Saba V. K. (1988) Factors that enhance faculty

commitment to computer use. Shaping Directions

for Computer Use in Nursing Education Second

Regional Conference. Continuing Nursing Education

in Computer Technology Project, Southern Regional

Education Board, Atlanta, Georgia, 29-43

24. McGonigle D. & Eggers R. (1991) Establishing

a nursing informatics program. Computers in

Nursing. 9(5): 184-188

25. Grobe, S. (1988) Nursing informatics

competencies for nurse educators and researchers.

In Preparing Nurses for Using information Systems:

Recommended Informatics Competencies (Peterson

H. & Gerdin-Jelger, U. eds), National League for

Nursing, New York 25-40

26. Saranto, K. & Leino-Kilpi, H. (1997).

Computer literacy in nursing: developing the

information technology syllabus in nursing education.Journal of Advanced Nursing 25: 377-385

27. An Bord Altranais. (2000) Requirements and

Standards for Nurse Registration Education

Programmes. Dublin: An Bord Altranais

28. LoBiondo-Wood, Geri and Haber Judith. (1994)

Nursing Research: Methods, Critical Appraisal, and

Utilization St. Louis: Mosby.

29. Burns, N. & Grove, SK. (1999) Understanding

Nursing Research 2nd Edition. Philadelphia: W.B

Saunders Company30. Judd, C.M.; Smith, E.R. & Kidder, L.H. (1991)

Research Methods in Social Relations New York:

Harcourt Brace Jovanovich College Publishers.

31. Dempsey, P.A. and Dempsey, A.D. (1996)

Nursing Research: Text and Workbook Boston:

Little Brown and Company