1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES NSLS-II Project Overview Steve Dierker Associate Laboratory Director for Light Sources NSLS-II Project Director Experimental Facilities Advisory Committee May 10, 2007
Jan 12, 2016
1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Project Overview
Steve DierkerAssociate Laboratory Director for Light Sources
NSLS-II Project DirectorExperimental Facilities Advisory Committee
May 10, 2007
2 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
2006 was a busy year…NSLS-II Project Organization• Created – JanuaryFive Reviews• Lattice and Accelerator Configuration Review – May 11-12• DOE Review – May 16• Cost Review – June 13• DOE Review – July 18• DOE Review – December 12-14One Workshop• Acquisition Strategy Workshop (co-sponsored with SC) – June 20-21Four Advisory Committee Meetings• Held all four NSLS-II advisory committee meetings in OctoberHosted more than 75 Visitors• CDR A/E on board and A/E held several programming meetingsConceptual Design Completed• More than 150 contributors from 17 different institutions• Special site studies (Geotechnical, RFI, Vibration)• Constructability review & independent cost estimate for conventional facilities• Detailed project cost estimate & refined project WBS• Environmental Assessment completed; FONSI approved by BHSO• Required documents (AS, PPEP, ESH, QA, RM, PHA) all complete
3 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Conceptual Design Report
4 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Project ScopePresented at CD-1 Review
Accelerator Systems• Storage Ring• Linac and Booster Injection System
Experimental Facilities• Suite of ~ 5 initial beamlines and instruments
Conventional Facilities• Improvements to Land• Ring Building• Central and distributed Lab/Office Buildings• Utilities
• R&D• Advanced optics for achieving 1 nm and 0.1 meV• Advanced insertion devices
5 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Storage Ring Performance
• Very Broad Spectral coverage• IR through very hard x-rays
• Brightness exceeds any other synchrotron from 10 eV to 20 keV
• > 1021 p/s/0.1%/mm2/mrad2 from ~ 2 keV to ~ 10 keV• Flux exceeds any other synchrotron from 10 eV to 20 keV
• > 1016 ph/s/0.1%bw from ~ 500 eV to ~ 10 keV• Smallest beam size of any synchrotron:
• y = 3.1 m, x = 38.5 m• ’y = 1.8 rad, ’x = 18.2 rad
• Top-off Operation• Current stability better than 1%
• Accommodates 27 user insertion devices (8 m and 5 m) and 30 BM beamlines
X-ray Ring• 3 GeV, 500 mA, top-off injection• Circumference 780 m• 30 cell, Double Bend Achromat• Novel design featuring damping wigglers
and soft bend magnets• Ultra-low emittance (x, y) 0.5, 0.008
nm-rad(Diffraction limited in vertical at 10 keV)
• Pulse Length (rms) 15 psec
6 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS
LOB 3
RF-LINAC AREA
Service Bldg Typ 4
CFN
Ring Bldg
Future JPSI
Future Guest House
Conf. Center
Underpass
Loading
CLOB
NSLS-II Site Plan in CDR
Ring Road
LOB 2
LOB 1
LOB 4
Service Road
7 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
CD-1 Review
Principle Recommendations:• Consider moving booster outside of storage ring tunnel• Consider use of NC RF instead of SC RF• Increase the scope of the Experimental Facilities portion of the project to
provide a minimal suite of beamlines which both exploit the unique capabilities of the NSLS-II source and meet the scientific needs of the NSLS user community
• R&D program is appropriate but expand to include mirror metrology • Develop a policy whereby the design, construction, and operation of all
beamlines, both DOE funded as well as non-DOE funded, will be the responsibility of the Experimental Facilities staff
• Increase cost range to $750M - $900M
Overall, successful and very positive regarding design and team
8 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS
CFN
Linac
Booster
JPSI
LOBLOB
LOB
LOB
Storage Ring
LOB
0 100 200 400 FEET
Revised NSLS-II Site Plan
9 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Revised Building Program
• Alternatives to CLOB were evaluated• Space in NSLS will be maximized for NSLS-II administrative and
technical support functions• Only functions in direct support of NSLS-II facility and accelerator
operations will be housed at NSLS-II• Operations Center (OC)• Lab/office Buildings (LOBs)
• OC will include:• Control room, computer room, Ctrl rm Conference & break room, operations
supervisory offices• Entry foyer, viewing gallery and access bridge to electrical mezzanine and
control room area• All of these spaces (and more) were previously included in the CLOB
10 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Project Beamlines
• A minimum suite of insertion device beamlines to meet physical science needs has been identified. These take advantage of the unique source properties of NSLS-II and also provide work horse instruments for large user capacity
• Recommended beamlines:• Nanoprobe (1nm)• Inelastic x-ray scattering (0.1 meV)• Soft x-ray coherent scattering and imaging• Hard x-ray coherent scattering and SAXS• Powder diffraction (damping wiggler source)• EXAFS (damping wiggler source)
11 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Transitioning to Operations
• A phased transition to NSLS-II operations is planned:• CD-4a – Initial Operations
• Beneficial Occupancy of Experimental Floor• Initial limited storage ring operations and limited user operations during
installation and commissioning of beamlines• CD-4b – Start of Operations
• All commissioning goals have been achieved• Transitioning from NSLS to NSLS-II
• Important to begin this transition as early as possible• Continue operations of NSLS until NSLS-II operational (CD-4b)• Move NSLS programs to NSLS-II between CD-4a and CD-4b• NSLS and NSLS-II staff merge to operate NSLS-II
12 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS Beamline Transfer Plan• Evaluated NSLS beamlines in terms of technical suitability for moving to a soft bend,
a 3PW, or an insertion device at NSLS-II• Estimated moving costs and costs for upgrading to be suitable for NSLS-II• The productivity (number of publications and premier publications) and user demand
(hours requested) of the existing NSLS beamlines were evaluated• From this list, and the technical and cost considerations, about 20 bending magnet
beamlines were identified that would support the largest number of users with the greatest scientific impact, covering the following techniques:
• EXAFS, SAXS, powder diffraction, scattering, PX, imaging, microdiffraction, topography, far-IR spectroscopy.
• Estimate that these could accommodate at least 1300 users/yr• Plan to begin transferring these to NSLS-II at CD-4a• Assume that NSLS-II operations funding starts at CD-4a and covers transfer of
selected NSLS beamlines to the new NSLS-II facility as well as initial storage ring operations
13 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Operations Staffing Estimates
FTEs for Operations with No
Beamlines
FTEs for Operations with 66% of
Beamlines (~38)
FTEs for Operations with all
Beamlines (~57)
Scientists 46 172 232
Engineers 32 52 62
Designers 10 30 40
Technicians 89 129 149
Computer Analysts 23 27 29
Admin/Secretarial 35 39 41
Total 235 449 553
14 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Space Requirements at Full Operations
FTEs in Single Offices
FTEs in Shared Offices
FTEs in Bench or Design Area
Total FTEs
NSLS-II LOB 92 107 67 266
NSLS-II OC 6 1 63 70
JPSI 23 12 7 42
NSLS 93 34 48 175
Total 214 154 185 553
15 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
NSLS-II Project Organization
16 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Near Term Staffing Plan
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
FY07Oct
FY07Nov
FY07Dec
FY07Jan
FY07Feb
FY07Mar
FY07Apr
FY07May
FY07Jun
FY07July
FY07Aug
FY07Sept
FY08Oct
FY08Nov
FY08Dec
FY08Jan
FY08Feb
FY08Mar
FY08Apr
FY08May
FY08Jun
FY08July
FY08Aug
FY08Sept
Month
Hea
dco
un
t
Project Management and Support Accelerator Systems Division Experimental Facilities Division Conventional Facilities Division
Near Term Staffing plan
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
FY07Oct
FY07Nov
FY07Dec
FY07Jan
FY07Feb
FY07Mar
FY07Apr
FY07May
FY07Jun
FY07July
FY07Aug
FY07Sept
FY08Oct
FY08Nov
FY08Dec
FY08Jan
FY08Feb
FY08Mar
FY08Apr
FY08May
FY08Jun
FY08July
FY08Aug
FY08Sept
Months
hea
dco
un
t
Project Support Scientific (Below Division Level) Engineers Designers Technicians Management (Division Box & above)
Near Term Staffing Projections
17 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Preliminary Cost Estimate ($M)
Cost Range $750M to $900M
Project Management 40Acelerator Systems 181Conventional Facilties 210Experimental Facilties 74Contingency (38% of costs listed above) 190Total Estimated Costs (TEC) 695Research and Development 60Pre-Operations 95Other Project Costs (OPC) 155Total Project Cost (TPC) 850
18 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES18
Preliminary Funding Profile ($M)
• FY07 Start R&D and Title I Design• FY09 Start Construction • Nov 2007 baseline validation planned to support FY09 budget request
Fiscal Year 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 Total
PED (Project Engineering and Design)
3 45 12 60
Construction 138 180 142 95 50 25 5 635
OPC 1 5 22 20 12 15 30 40 10 155
Total 1 5 25 65 162 180 142 110 80 65 15 850
19 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
Preliminary Summary Schedule
18 Months Total Schedule Contingency
20 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES
•DOE Review Feb 7•Radiological Safety Design Workshop Mar 27-28•Stability Workshop Apr 18-20•Accelerator Systems Advisory Committee Apr 23-24•Conventional Facilities Advisory Committee May 8-9•Experimental Facilities Advisory Committee May 10-11•DOE Review May 22•Project Advisory Committee May 24-25•CD-1 ESAAB June 13•User Workshop July 17•EVMS Review and Certification Aug•Internal Review of NSLS-II CD-2 Performance Baseline Aug•NSLS-II Advisory Committee Meetings Sep/Oct•SC Independent Project Review/External Independent Review for CD-2 Nov 6-9
Project Reviews & Workshops in 2007