Novel Powering Schemes for the CMS Tracker Upgrade - R&D at RWTH Aachen University Meeting of the Joint Atlas/CMS Powering WG 7th of April, 2008 Lutz Feld, Rüdiger Jussen, Waclaw Karpinski, Katja Klein , Jennifer Merz, Jan Sammet 1. Physikalisches Institut B, RWTH Aachen University
25
Embed
Novel Powering Schemes for the CMS Tracker Upgrade - R&D at RWTH Aachen University
Novel Powering Schemes for the CMS Tracker Upgrade - R&D at RWTH Aachen University. Meeting of the Joint Atlas/CMS Powering WG 7th of April, 2008. Lutz Feld, Rüdiger Jussen, Waclaw Karpinski, Katja Klein , Jennifer Merz, Jan Sammet 1. Physikalisches Institut B, RWTH Aachen University. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Novel Powering Schemes for the CMS Tracker Upgrade -
R&D at RWTH Aachen University
Meeting of the Joint Atlas/CMS Powering WG7th of April, 2008
Lutz Feld, Rüdiger Jussen, Waclaw Karpinski, Katja Klein, Jennifer Merz, Jan Sammet
1. Physikalisches Institut B, RWTH Aachen University
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 2
• The current CMS tracker and its powering scheme• Plans for R&D at RWTH Aachen University• System test with commercial DC-DC converters
– The converter– Setup and methodology – First preliminary results
• Summary & Outlook
Katja Klein
Outline
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 3Katja Klein
The Current CMS Tracker
2.5 m
5.8 m
Pure silicon tracker: 1m2 pixel area + 200m2 strip area 15 148 silicon strip modules, 29 different types 10 Million Strips, 84 Million pixels Operating temperature < -10 C
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 4Katja Klein
The Current CMS Tracker
Frontend-Hybrid with - 4 or 6 APV25 readout chips - PLL chip for timing - Multiplexer chip (MUX) - DCU chip for control
APV25 readout chip: - 0.25 m CMOS - 128 strips per APV - analogue readout - per channel: pre-amplifier, CR-RC shaper, 4 s pipeline - = 50ns
Typical strip module
• Supply voltages: 1.25V & 2.5V for analogue readout and 2.5V for digital control ring• Currents per APV: 0.118A at 2.5V and 0.061A at 1.25V• Power consumption of 4 (6) APV module including optical conversion: 1.8W (2.7W)
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 5Katja Klein
Powering the Current CMS Tracker
• Total strip tracker FE power consumption: 33kW• Total power supplied to strip tracker: 68kW 34kW = 50% is lost in the cables• Inside cold volume, 36% is lost in the cables
• Several modules (typically 8) are powered in parallel• Custom CAEN power supply system (EASY 4000) - A3486 AC/DC converter provides 48VDC - A4601/4602 provide 2.5V, 1.25V & bias voltage• Copper low impedance cables from racks to patch panel just outside of tracker volume ( 50m) • Aluminium or copper multiservice cables from patch panel to tracker structures (few metres)
Patch panel
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 6
• Significant R&D effort started slowly due to ongoing work for current tracker• Strawman tracker designs are being worked out• Main focus of current R&D on simulation of strawmen• A new big challenge: integration of tracker into Level1 trigger• Re-design of readout chip has not yet started
future chip parameters not known all system tests on powering schemes still have to be done with APV25
• Boundary conditions for powering to be understood - must current cables be re-used?
• Serious thinking on powering schemes has started about half a year ago; no prejudice for serial powering or DC-DC conversion
• Tracker power working group is being set up
Katja Klein
CMS Tracker R&D for SLHC
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 7
– Jan Sammet: System test measurements with DC-DC converters– Rüdiger Jussen: Development and test of radiation hard magnetic field
tolerant DC-DC converter (in collaboration with CERN PH-ESE group, see later)
– Jennifer Merz: Simulation of material budget of various powering schemes
Katja Klein
Working Group at RWTH Aachen University
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 8
• No prejudice wrt serial powering and DC-DC conversion investigate and learn about both schemes before decision can be taken
• DC-DC conversion started– Contributions to the development of a rad. hard, magnetic field tolerant buck
converter (development of PCB), in coll. with CERN PH-ESE (F. Faccio et al.)– Characterization of this custom converter: magnetic field test, irradiation tests– Integration into and system test with current & future tracker structures– Preparation of setups & first system tests with of-the-shelf converter ongoing– In the longer term: study of general system issues
• 1-step or 2-step conversion?• Converter on chip/hybrid/PCB?• Interplay with new readout chip etc.
• Serial powering not started yet– Integration of serial powering scheme into current/future tracker system– System performance test
• R&D proposal submitted and approved (Dec.) within CMS
Katja Klein
Plans for R&D at Aachen
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 9Katja Klein
A Commercial DC-DC Converter
Market survey (W. Karpinski) with main criteria: - high switching frequency small size of passive components - high conversion factor - sufficient current (~ 1A) & suitable output voltages (1.25V and 2.5V) Enpirion EN5312QI (studied) and Micrel MIC3385 (delivered recently)
Characteristics of EN5312QI:• Small footprint: 5mm x 4mm x 1.1mm• fs 4 MHz• Vin = 2.4V – 5.5V (rec.) / 7.0V (max.)• Iout = 1A• Integrated planar inductor with iron-manganese-zinc core
Custom rad. hard converter under development, delivery expected for summer start with a commercial of-the-shelf converter to prepare setups, to learn about
system behaviour and to gain experience
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 10Katja Klein
Integration into CMS End Cap System
• 4-layer adapter PCB• Plugged between Tracker End Cap (TEC) motherboard and FE-hybrid• 2 converters provide 1.25V and 2.5V for FE-hybrid• Input and output filter capacitors on-board• Input power external or via TEC motherboard
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 11Katja Klein
Integration into CMS End Cap System
Front-end hybrid
L-type:Larger flat PCB,1 piece
TEC motherboard(„InterConnect Board“, ICB)
S-type:Smaller inclined PCB, 2 pieces
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 12Katja Klein
EN5312QI: Inductor & Magnetic Field Tolerance
• MEMS technology: spiral inductor betw. magnetic cores• Decrease of efficiency in magnetic field• Total breakdown for fields below 1T (no surprise)• Lower magnetic field tolerance for higher duty cycles D D = Ton / T = Vout / Vin • Tolerance depends on orientation of converter in field
magnet (B < 1.2T)
Vout = 1.25VAxial:Tangential:
B-probe
X-ray, U = 35kV, 5 minutes
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 13Katja Klein
EN5312QI: EMI Measurements
• Standardized EMI test setup at CERN (details in talk by G. Blanchot)• Standalone test of converter noise (common & differential mode)• Different converters and PCB designs can be compared• Low noise emission of EN5312QI (only S type measured)• Duplication of setup in Aachen has started
Common modeDifferential mode
Load
EMI receiver
Filters
Current probe
EMI Setup at CERN
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 14Katja Klein
System Test Setup• TEC “petal“ with InterConnect Board• Four ring-6 modules powered & read out• Petal housed in grounded metall box• Optical readout• Optical control communication• Thermally stabilized at +15°C• Final components (spares)• Official DAQ software
6.16.4 6.3 6.2
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 15Katja Klein
Effect of Converter (Position 6.4)
Pos. 6.4
Pos. 6.4
---- No converter---- L type---- S type
Powered via ICB
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Raw noise increases by 5-10% Design of PCB has significant impact Further optimization seems possible
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 16Katja Klein
Effect of Converter (Position 6.4)
Pos. 6.4
Pos. 6.4
---- No converter---- L type---- S type
Powered via ICB
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Broader common mode distribution Huge increase of noise at module edges, APV edges and “bad“ strips effect is not yet understood
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 17Katja Klein
Effect of Converter (Different Positions)
Pos. 6.2
Pos. 6.3 Pos. 6.4
---- No converter---- L type---- S type
(Comparison for position 6.1 not possible because L type does not fit)
Powered via ICB
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 18Katja Klein
Common Mode Subtraction---- Raw noise without converter---- Raw noise with converter---- CM calculated per APV (128 strips)---- CM calculated for 32 strips---- Linear CM subtraction
L Type Powered externally
Pos. 6.4L type
Prel
imin
ary
Additional noise completely subtractable with proper common mode algorithm Noise increase due to higher common mode
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 19Katja Klein
Cross Talk
L TypePowered externally
Pos. 6.4L type
Pos. 6.3
---- No converter---- Converter on all positions---- Converter on 6.4 only
---- No converter---- Converter on 6.4
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Performance with converter does not depend on # of modules operated with converter A converter on position 6.4 does not spoil the performance of modules without converter (e.g. 6.3)
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 20Katja Klein
Cross Talk
Pos. 6.3
Pos. 6.4
Strip number Strip number
Cor
rela
tion
coef
ficie
nt
Cor
rela
tion
coef
ficie
nt
PreliminaryPreliminary
Study correlations between pairs of strips i, j (R = raw data):Corrij = (<RiRj> - <Ri><Rj>) / (ij)
No cross-talk between neighbouring modules observed High correlations only within single modules (common mode)
With converters on 6.3 and 6.4Without converters
Strip
num
ber
Strip
num
ber
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 21Katja Klein
Noise versus Input Voltage
Pos. 6.4L type
Pos. 6.4L type
Prel
imin
ary
Mean noise increases with input voltage or conversion ratio g (g = Vin / Vout)
2 2
1 1 1 1(1 ) 116 16
outout in
out s out out s
VV D D V DLC f V LC f
Expectation for output voltage ripple Vout (with duty cycle D = Vout / Vin):
Mean noise per module
Prel
imin
ary
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 22
• We have started to a programm to understand the issues related to operation of CMS tracker modules with DC-DC converters
• First measurements with a commercial converter indicate an increase ofthe module noise due to a higher common mode by up to 10%
• Increase of edge strip noise to be studied • Further optimization of adapter PCB seems possible• No indication for cross talk when powering with DC-DC converters• Many more interesting measurements are in the pipeline
– Operation of a complete petal with Enpirion converters– Noise injection on silicon modules– Micrel converter with 8 MHz switching frequency– Integration of EN5312QI with external air coil– Combination of DC-DC converter with voltage regulator
• Hope to start similar studies with custom converter (CERN) this summer
Katja Klein
Summary & Outlook
Back-up
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 24Katja Klein
Different Methods of Powering
Pos. 6.4L type
Pos. 6.4S type
---- No converter---- L/S type powered externally---- L/S type powered via ICB; many filter capacitors
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Sensitivity to input voltage ripple to be strudied, but sensitivity seems to be small
CMS tracker R&D on novel powering schemes at RWTH Aachen University 25Katja Klein
Effect of Output Filter Capacitance
Powered externally
Pos. 6.4L type
Pos. 6.4S type
---- No converter---- Standard output filter capacitors---- Additional 22 F capacitor---- Additional 100 F capacitor
Prel
imin
ary
Prel
imin
ary
Noise can be reduced further by larger output filter capacitances