NOMINATING COMMITTEE Thursday, November 9, 2017 10:00 am - 12:00 pm Room: Clipper Galveston Island Convention Center Galveston, Texas AGENDA 1. Call to order by Linda Siy, MD (Vice Chair: Justin Bartos, MD) 2. Roll call and introduction of guests. (Please have all those present sign the roll sheet.) 3. Approval of minutes: April 8, 2017 4. Current Business: A. Review process and tools for 2018 nominations and elections B. Review credentialing process for 2017 Member Assembly C. Discuss the possibility of a chair orientation call or meeting D. Identify members to nominate for TMA councils and committees E. Potential nominee for AAFP awards F. Review and update list of Potential Future Academy Leaders 5. Information Items A. Review nominations for TAFP Officer slots to be elected by the Member Assembly i. President-Elect Rebecca Hart, MD ii. Vice President Amer Shakil, MD iii. Treasurer Javier D. Margo, Jr., MD iv. Parliamentarian Adrian Billings, PhD, MD; Mary Nguyen, MD B. Review nominations for Delegate and one Alternate Delegate to the AAFP i. Delegate Linda Siy, MD (2019) ii. Alternate Delegate Ashok Kumar, MD (2019) C. Review nominations for other Board members i. At Large Terrance Hines, MD; Loren Lasater, MD ii. New Physician Lawrence Gibbs, MD; Mary Anne Snyder, DO; Irvin Sulapas, MD iii. Special Constituency Lesca Hadley, MD iv. Resident Samuel Mathis, MD v. Student Jason Johnston 6. Other Business 7. Adjourn If your commission has any items which require financing over $2,000, please meet with the Finance Committee from 3 - 5 p.m. on Thursday, Nov. 9, 2017, in the Clipper room of Galveston Island Convention Center to discuss the cost of the items before going to the Board for approval. Kathy McCarthy is the staff person responsible for this committee.
28
Embed
NOMINATING COMMITTEE · 1 1. The committee decided to select one nominee for the Delegate, Alternate Delegate, President-2 elect, Treasurer and Vice President positions and allow
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
NOMINATING COMMITTEE Thursday, November 9, 2017 10:00 am - 12:00 pm Room: Clipper Galveston Island Convention Center Galveston, Texas
AGENDA 1. Call to order by Linda Siy, MD (Vice Chair: Justin Bartos, MD) 2. Roll call and introduction of guests. (Please have all those present sign the roll sheet.) 3. Approval of minutes: April 8, 2017 4. Current Business:
A. Review process and tools for 2018 nominations and elections B. Review credentialing process for 2017 Member Assembly C. Discuss the possibility of a chair orientation call or meeting D. Identify members to nominate for TMA councils and committees E. Potential nominee for AAFP awards F. Review and update list of Potential Future Academy Leaders
5. Information Items A. Review nominations for TAFP Officer slots to be elected by the Member
Assembly i. President-Elect Rebecca Hart, MD ii. Vice President Amer Shakil, MD iii. Treasurer Javier D. Margo, Jr., MD iv. Parliamentarian Adrian Billings, PhD, MD; Mary Nguyen, MD
B. Review nominations for Delegate and one Alternate Delegate to the AAFP i. Delegate Linda Siy, MD (2019) ii. Alternate Delegate Ashok Kumar, MD (2019)
C. Review nominations for other Board members i. At Large Terrance Hines, MD; Loren Lasater, MD ii. New Physician Lawrence Gibbs, MD; Mary Anne Snyder, DO;
Irvin Sulapas, MD iii. Special Constituency Lesca Hadley, MD iv. Resident Samuel Mathis, MD v. Student Jason Johnston
6. Other Business 7. Adjourn If your commission has any items which require financing over $2,000, please meet with the Finance Committee from 3 - 5 p.m. on Thursday, Nov. 9, 2017, in the Clipper room of Galveston Island Convention Center to discuss the cost of the items before going to the Board for approval. Kathy McCarthy is the staff person responsible for this committee.
REPORT OF THE NOMINATING COMMITTEE 1 Author: Linda Siy, MD, Chair 2 Date: April 8, 2017 3 4 The following members of the committee were present for the meeting: 5 Justin Bartos, MD; Lindsay Botsford, MD, MBA; Douglas W Curran, MD; Bruce Echols, MD; Lesca 6 Hadley, MD: Terrance Hines, MD; Javier Margo, MD; Gurjeet Shokar, MD; Linda Siy, MD. 7 8 The following staff and guests were present for the meeting: Kathy McCarthy, Staff Liaison. 9 10 A regular meeting of the Nominating Committee was held on Saturday, April 8, 2017 at the Renaissance 11 Austin Hotel. The Chair announced that upon notice having been given and a quorum being present, the 12 meeting was called to order at 7:35 a.m. 13 14 The Committee took action at its meeting that resulted in the following recommendations for 15 consideration by the Board of Directors: 16 17
Item 1. That TAFP nominate Dr. Lindsay Botsford for Chair of the AAFP Commission on 18 Quality and Practice and Dr. Ajay Gupta for the AAFP Commission on Finance and 19 Insurance. 20 21 BACKGROUND 22 Both are in their fourth year on their respective commissions and are eligible for chair. Dr. Gupta 23 has not decided whether he wishes to be nominated by the committee wanted to voice their support 24 should he seek the position of chair. 25 26 Item 2. That the following members be nominated for AAFP Commissions in 2017. 27 28
Adrian Billings, MD Commission on Education Emily Briggs, MD Commission on Membership & Member Services Ron Cook, MD Commission on Education Mary Nguyen, MD Commission on Membership & Member Services Karen Smith, MD Commission on Health of the Public and Science Daniel Webster, MD Commission on Finance and Insurance Richard Young, MD Commission on Quality & Practice
29 BACKGROUND 30 The committee reviewed TAFP members serving on AAFP Commissions and discussed 31 nominations for 2017. There were seven members nominated in 2016 and one – Dr. Ike Okwuwa – 32 was appointed. Five of those nominated in 2016 are interested in being nominated again and two 33 additional members are interested in being nominated. The Nominating Committee recommends 34 that the following members be nominated in 2017. They noted that there are more than one 35 nominee for some commissions but felt that it would give AAFP more options for appointment. 36 37
The Committee took action at its meeting that resulted in the following recommendations for staff 38 implementation or referral to other commissions and committees. These items do not require Board 39 approval. Should staff find that the time needed for implementation exceeds five hours, the item 40 should be referred to the Board for approval before proceeding. 41 42
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 2
1. The committee decided to select one nominee for the Delegate, Alternate Delegate, President-1 elect, Treasurer and Vice President positions and allow multiple nominees for the 2 Parliamentarian, At Large and New Physician position if there were sufficient qualified 3 candidates. They arranged to meet with all candidates in attendance at Interim Session. 4
2. The committee reviewed candidates for the TAFP Board of Directors. Delegates to the 5 Member Assembly will elect one member to serve in the At Large and New Physician 6 positions at the Annual Session in November 2017. After meeting with candidates and 7 discussing their qualifications, the Nominating Committee puts forth the following slate of 8 candidates for the two positions: 9
New Physician Director: Mary Anne Snyder, DO; Irvin Sulapas, MD; and 10 Lawrence Gibbs, MD 11
At Large Directors: Terrance Hines, MD and Loren Lasater, MD 12 3. The committee reviewed candidates for Parliamentarian and met with members who 13
expressed interest. Both are well qualified and the Nominating Committee puts for the 14 following slate of candidates for the position for election at the 2017 Member Assembly: 15
Parliamentarian: Adrian Billings, MD and Mary Nguyen, MD 16 4. The committee reviewed candidates for TAFP’s officers and puts forth the following slate for 17
election at the 2017 Member Assembly during Annual Session in November: 18 President Elect – Rebecca Hart, MD 19 Vice President – Amer Shakil, MD, MBA 20 Treasurer – Jake Margo, Jr., MD 21
5. The committee reviewed candidates for Delegate and Alternate to AAFP’s Congress of 22 Delegates and puts forth the following slate for election at the 2017 Member Assembly 23 during Annual Session in November. Both will begin upon election in November. 24
6. The committee reviewed the future leaders list and recommended inclusion of Dr. Shiv 27 Agarwal and Dr. Leo Lopez. Staff will survey the entire Future Leaders list to determine if 28 they are still interested in leadership, what leadership rolls they are in with other 29 organizations, what they see as their next step with TAFP and whether they want to be paired 30 with a mentor or contacted by a current leader to discuss opportunities. 31
7. The committee discussed the presentation of candidates for election at the Member Assembly 32 and suggested that in addition to the current profile included in the magazine that the 33 candidates be asked to fill out a Q&A that is shared with Delegates and Alternates before the 34 Member Assembly. Staff will also be looking into the logistics of using video for some 35 positions rather than live speeches. 36
8. The committee discussed evaluating the committees and commissions to improve our 37 governance process. Staff will look into including evaluation questions in the TAFP 38 conference app at Annual Session. The questions will include an opportunity to suggest 39 topics for the next agenda. 40
The following routine business items are reported as official business of the Committee. 41 42 1. Dr. Linda Siy was elected chair and Dr. Justin Bartos was appointed Vice Chair. 43 2. The minutes from the November 3, 2016, meeting were approved. 44
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 3
3. The Nominating Committee decided to stay in executive session for the entire meeting given the 1 important decisions on their agenda. 2
4. The meeting was adjourned at 10:00 am. 3
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 4
Nominating Committee 4.A. 2018 Nominations
October 2017
Following is the application used for 2017 and the standing rules for nominations that we adopted last year. We changed the process a bit last year. We sent emails to all active members with reminders to those most likely to apply (current committee members, FMLE alumni, those on our Future Leader List and those who have applied in the past). The members were instructed to contact me if they were interested and I sent them an email in reply with instructions to nominate themselves and the link to the Google Form. I think this worked really well. Instead of being uncertain whether anyone would apply, I had a list that I could follow up with and they had already established contact with me. I recommend we continue.
In my response email, I asked that in addition to the application, a letter of interest from the member, a letter of recommendation from their local chapter or another TAFP member, and a CV be submitted. The application asks the candidate to state why they would like to serve, so I suggest that we not require a letter of interest in the future. I also suggest that we state a page limit on the CV.
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 5
Standing Rules for Nominations for TAFP leadership positions
Nominating Committee Standing Rules Adopted April 2016, revised November 2016
The Nominating Committee is composed of nine members and is charged with screening nominations for TAFP’s elected leadership positions, identifying potential future leaders, and recommending members to nominate for AAFP Commissions, TMA councils and to represent TAFP to the TMA Interspecialty Society. Each year they propose a slate of candidates for election at TAFP’s Member Assembly during Annual Session. The information below is intended to provide a clearer picture of the process. If you have any questions or concerns, please contact the chair of the Nominating Committee or Kathy McCarthy at [email protected].
Call for nominations
Once a year, active members will receive an email with a call for nominations providing the opportunity for all to nominate themselves for TAFP officer, delegate and Board of Director positions. The request directs interested members to submit a new officer/board member application, letter of interest, letter of recommendation, and CV to the TAFP headquarters. The deadline provided will be early enough that if we fail to have a sufficient number of interested members apply, staff and the committee have time to further promote the opportunity and extend the deadline. Whether to consider applicants without all of the requested documents or after the deadline has passed is at the committee’s discretion.
Nominating Committee meeting
The applicants may be asked to appear and discuss their interest with the Nominating Committee. This is not required for nomination. The Nominating Committee generally meets early on the Saturday of Interim Session. Applicants may want to make themselves available and check with staff on scheduling.
Slate of nominees
The bylaws state the committee will prepare a slate of nominees for election by the Member Assembly at Annual Session but they do not stipulate whether the committee should nominate one member per position or multiple members to allow a contested election. Historically, the committee has presented one nominee for each of the officer and delegate positions and since the governance change, the committee has presented multiple nominees for the At-Large and New Physician positions on the Board of Directors. The Nominating Committee intends to continue presenting a single member for each delegate position and the officer positions of President-elect, Treasurer and Vice President, but will strive to present 2-4 nominees for Parliamentarian and the At-Large and New Physician positions on the Board.
The evaluation of candidates will include an assessment of experience and service to TAFP, leadership training, and demonstration of skillsets and areas of expertise essential to the Board of Directors. While not required, members are encouraged to serve on one or more TAFP committees or commissions prior to applying for a position on the Board. Further, serving as chair of a TAFP committee or commission will strengthen a nomination.
Current members of the Nominating Committee are not prohibited from applying for elected positions but the committee will strive to be fair to all candidates. Such a committee member applicant will be excused from the meeting for the duration of the selection process for that position including interviewing of other candidates, discussion, and voting on the slate.
Other paths to election
Should a nominee not be selected for the slate, the committee may provide feedback on experience or training suggested to improve their chances of selection in the future. There are two other pathways to election provided in the TAFP Bylaws:
1. A component chapter may nominate any active member for the elected positions of the Academy. This nomination must be submitted in writing to the President at least 90 days prior to the beginning of the Annual Session. If a component chapter is inactive, five members in good standing of that component chapter may submit a nomination. The President will notify the Board of Directors of all nominations for all elected positions at least 60 days prior to the beginning of the Annual Session.
2. Nominations may be made from the floor at the Annual Session Member Assembly.
Member Assembly election
Candidates are normally profiled in Texas Family Physician and/or online prior to Annual Session to allow members to get to know them before the election. The nominees for Parliamentarian and the At-Large and New Physician positions on the Board of Directors may be asked to speak at the Member Assembly or on pre-recorded video. All positions are elected by a majority vote of credentialed delegates in accordance with the standing rules of the Member Assembly.
These Standing Rules of the TAFP Member Assembly can be amended by a majority vote at the start of each meeting of the Member Assembly.
1. The TAFP Member Assembly shall be convened once a year during the TAFP Annual Session and Primary Care Summit at a time and place to be determined by the TAFP CEO. Admission to the sessions shall be limited to members and other CME attendees who display a badge issued by TAFP.
2. TAFP’s President shall serve as Chair of the Member Assembly. 3. The order of business shall be outlined in an agenda for the meeting, which shall be distributed
electronically prior to the session. The chair may change the order of business. 4. The American Institute of Parliamentarians Standard Code of Parliamentary Procedure (most recent
edition) shall govern the Member Assembly except when this code is in conflict with the TAFP Bylaws or the Standing Rules of the Member Assembly.
5. The Member Assembly shall elect officers, Delegates to the AAFP, and members of the TAFP Board of Directors, and it shall act on business specifically referred by the Board of Directors.
6. The delegates to the Assembly may, by majority vote, approve a referendum for submission to the members of TAFP on questions affecting the policy or recommendations of the Academy. The option to bring a referendum to the Member Assembly for consideration should be used as the last resort for a member wishing to raise concerns. TAFP members wishing to have a concern addressed are encouraged to first contact the chair of the relevant committee or commission. TAFP’s committees and commissions are open to guests unless they are in executive session. If a member is not satisfied with the response of a committee, that member should then address his or her concerns with the Board of Directors. If the Member Assembly approves a referendum, the item must be submitted to the entire membership for a vote.
7. Each local chapter shall have delegates and alternates in proportion to the number of members in their chapter as of June 1 each year. Chapters with 1-49 members shall have one delegate and one alternate, chapters with 50-99 members shall have two delegates and two alternates, chapters with 100 to 199 members shall have three delegates and three alternates, chapters with 200 to 299 members shall have four delegates and four alternates and so on.
8. Local chapters will be given an opportunity to select delegates and alternates. If a chapter has not submitted the names of members of their delegates and alternates to TAFP staff at least 60 days prior to the start of the Annual Session, TAFP staff will contact members and assign delegates on a first-come, first-served basis.
9. In addition to chapter delegates, the Section on Special Constituencies, the Section on Resident Physicians, and the Section on Medical Students shall each elect two delegates and two alternates at their Interim Session meeting to serve at the subsequent Member Assembly. The current TAFP Board of Directors will also serve as voting members of the Member Assembly.
10. The term of office for all delegates and alternate delegates is one year but they may succeed themselves without limit.
11. To be seated, a delegate must be a member in good standing with TAFP and AAFP. 12. A quorum shall be 30 voting members of the Member Assembly. 13. Each delegate to the Member Assembly shall have one vote and the privilege of speaking. Should a
TAFP member in good standing not serving on the Assembly wish to have the privilege of the floor, they must petition the presiding officer and obtain permission to address the Assembly but they shall have no right to vote.
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 10
14. Delegates must be credentialed prior to the Member Assembly. They will be given ballots for elections and for run-off elections if necessary. If a delegate has not checked in 15 minutes prior to the start of the Member Assembly, the first alternate from their chapter or constituency shall be credentialed as a delegate.
15. Nomination process for elected positions: a. TAFP’s Nominating Committee will propose a slate of one or more names for the positions of
President-Elect, Vice President, Treasurer, Parliamentarian, Delegate to the AAFP, Alternate Delegate to the AAFP, At-Large Director on the TAFP Board of Directors and New Physician Director on the TAFP Board of Directors. Members interested in one of these positions should contact the Nominating Committee chair or staff prior to Interim Session.
b. In addition to the Nominating Committee slate, local or component chapters may nominate members for any elected position. This nomination must be submitted in writing to the president at least 90 days prior to the beginning of the Annual Session. If a component chapter is inactive, five members in good standing of that component chapter may submit a nomination. The president will notify the Board of Directors of all nominations for all elected positions at least 60 days prior to the beginning of the Annual Session.
c. Members can also be nominated from the floor during the Member Assembly. d. The Section on Special Constituencies, Section on Resident Physicians and Section on Medical
Students shall each elect a qualified member for the respective positions on the TAFP Board of Directors at their Interim Session meeting. Those names will be sent forth to the Member Assembly on the slate with the candidates for the other positions. There may be nominations from the floor for those positions.
e. The names of candidates nominated for positions in one of the methods outlined above shall be read and placed in nomination during the Member Assembly. The floor shall be open for additional nominations at that time.
f. Each candidate is required to give a speech, except in cases in which a candidate is running unopposed for election or re-election. Speeches shall not exceed five minutes and the limit shall be determined by the presiding officer prior to the Annual Session and Primary Care Summit.
16. Voting procedures: a. Delegates and members of the Board of Directors will be given ballots when they are
credentialed. There shall be one ballot for the initial election and another to use in case of a run-off. The ballots shall be different colors to avoid voting irregularities. The presiding officer of the Member Assembly will not vote unless there is a tie.
b. Candidates must receive a majority vote to be elected. c. If no candidate for a position receives a majority of the votes on the first ballot, a run-off will
occur between the two individuals with the highest number of votes on the first ballot. Voting members will already have a second ballot and will be instructed which individuals are in the run-off and will have 30 minutes to turn in their run-off ballot.
d. If the votes are not tabulated before the Member Assembly is adjourned, a run-off can still occur as long as the TAFP Annual Session and Primary Care Summit is still in session.
e. If the Member Assembly has adjourned before the votes are tabulated, the results will be announced in the general session and other meetings or CME events of TAFP’s Annual Session and Primary Care Summit.
17. Elected officers and delegates shall take office at the conclusion of the TAFP Annual Session and Primary Care Summit.
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 11
Ballot | 2017-18 TAFP Board of Directors, Officers, and Delegates All current members of the TAFP Board of Directors, all chapter and constituency delegates, and those who have been seated as delegates may vote. Printed below are the nominees from the Nominating Committee and the appropriate section meetings. Nominations may be made from the floor for all positions and space is available on the ballot to write in the name of an alternate candidate.
New Physician Director (select one) Please vote for one member for the New Physician position on the Board of Directors. The member with a majority vote will be elected. If no one receives a majority on the first ballot, there will be a runoff.
Officers, Delegates and Alternates to AAFP, Special Constituency, Resident and Student Directors
The TAFP Nominating Committee and appropriate Sections sent forth uncontested nominees for the positions printed below. Please vote for one member for each position. The individual with a majority vote will be elected.
Vice President Amer Shakil, MD, FAAFP _____ _________________________
Treasurer Javier Margo, MD, FAAFP _____ _________________________
Delegate to AAFP Linda Siy, MD, FAAFP _____ _________________________
Alt. Delegate to AAFP Ashok Kumar, MD, FAAFP _____ _________________________
Special Constituencies Lesca Hadley, MD, FAAFP _____ _________________________
Resident Physicians Samuel Mathis, MD _____ _________________________
Medical Students Jason Johnston _____ _________________________
DRAFT
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 12
Nominating Committee 4.C. Chair Orientation
October 2017
Dr. Lindsay Botsford suggested that TAFP might want to create an orientation conference call for committee, commission and section chairs. It would extend the leadership training that we have done and empower our members with the information they need to be good chairs. The AAFP does such a call and has an extensive orientation manual. I’ve included the agenda for their call and the table of contents from the orientation manual.
We thought the Nominating Committee was a good place to discuss this idea. Who should lead the orientation? What topics should be covered?
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 13
COMMISSION CHAIR
ORIENTATION MANUAL American Academy of Family Physicians Page 1
Page 1
AAFP Commission Chair Orientation Manual
Table on Contents – October 2017
AAFP STRATEGIC PLAN AAFP Strategic Plan .......................................... 2 ROLES OF COMMISSIONS, MEMBER ADVISORY PANEL AND PROJECT TEAMS ... 4 AAFP LEADERSHIP 2017-2018 Officers and Board of Directors ........ 6 2017-2018 Board of Directors Subcommittees ... 7
AAFP GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE Commissions and Subcommittees Org Chart …11 2018 AAFP Commission Members, Board Liaisons and Staff ................................... 12 Commission Descriptions .................................. 16 2017 AAFP Commissions Scope of Work* ........ 30 Member Interest Group (MIG) ........................... 33 Relationship to the Congress of Delegates……..34 Relationship to the AAFP Board of Directors…...35 Role of the Board Liaison………………………...36 Role of the Staff Executive ................................ 37 Role of the Senior Vice President………………. 39
CHAIR RESPONSIBILITIES Commission Chair Job Description ................... 40 Characteristics of an Effective Chair ................. 42 Tips for Chairing a Commission Meeting ........... 43 Appointments of Subcommittee Chairs .............. 45 Appointments of Executive Committee…………46 Appointments of Commission Mentors for Resident and Students Members ...................... 47 Policy-Evaluation/Com. Member Performance...48 Commission Member Annual Review Form
for All Members ........................................... 49
COMMISSION MEETINGS Commission Agenda and Sample ..................... 52 Meeting Details ................................................. 54 Conference Calls and Online Discussions ......... 55
COMMISSION MEETINGS (continued) Cross-Commission Work .................................. 56
COMMISSION POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Policy-Participation on Commissions ................ 57 Policy on AAFP Face-to Face Commission
or Commission Subcommittee Meetings ........ 58 Procedure for AAFP Commission Appts ........... 59
ORGANIZATIONAL POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Parliamentary Procedures ................................. 61 Process for New Programs, Projects, Products, Services or Activities ..................................... 64 Developing New Policy Statements ................... 66 Weekly Board Chair 1:1 Recommendations ...... 67 Board Chair 1:1 Recommendations (sample) .... 68 Board/Executive Committee Recommendations
(Joint Recs included in this section) .............. 69 Board/Executive Committee Recommendations
sample .......................................................... 71 Guidelines to Determine Actions of Commissions
That Require Board Review/Action ............... 72 Bylaws Amendments ........................................ 73 Information on the RUC .................................... 74 Spokesperson Roles and Responsibilities ......... 75 Conflict of Interest & Disclosure Statement ....... 77
BUDGET AND FINANCIAL POLICIES Balanced Budget Policy .................................... 85 AAFP Commission Budgets .............................. 86 Reimbursable Expenses Active Members ......... 87 AAFP Commission Member Expense
Staff ........................................................... 95 Non Staff Expense Voucher ........................... 99
RESOURCES 2018-2019 AAFP Meetings Schedule ............. 100 Knowledge-based Decision Making ................ 101 AAFP Acronyms ............................................. 103 * Note: The Scope of Work for all commissions is reviewed and revised, if appropriate, at the 2017 Winter Cluster.
II. Note: The winter cluster has been shortened to a Friday through Sunday schedule (from a Thursday through Sunday schedule) beginning in January 2018.
III. Review of Strategic Objectives and Strategies of the AAFP in relation commissions’ scope of
work – Attachment A – Dale Culver
IV. Roles and Expectations of Commission Chairs, Commission Members, Board Liaisons, Senior Vice Presidents and Commission Staff
• Cooperation in creating agendas • Role of Board Liaisons - Attachment B
• Role of the Board Liaison at and in between meetings -- the Board Liaison is a member of the commission and the commission’s executive committee without vote.
• Role of the Senior Vice Presidents – Attachment C – Doug Henley, MD • Role of the Commission Staff Executive – Attachment D – Doug Henley, MD • Managing meetings well – Attachment E • Ensuring full participation by all commission members
• Evaluating commission members – Attachment F • Feedback to each commission member is important • Review Policy for Participation on Commissions outlining what is expected of chairs
as it relates to members of their commission – Attachment G • Meet immediately with a commission member who is struggling. Meeting one-on-one
is helpful in addressing issues. Ongoing conversations with the chair are important in ensuring the commission meeting and work is handled efficiently but the need for detailed conversations varies with each chair and their experience level.
• Prevention of individuals from dominating discussions • Important “quartet” of the Chair, their staff executive, Board liaison and the appropriate VP
– Doug Henley, MD • Recommendations to the Board – Attachment H – Doug Henley, MD • Recommendations for Board Chair Consideration – Doug Henley, MD • Tips for engaging members:
• Identification of one commission member mentor for each newly appointed resident/student of the commissions – Attachment I
• Identification of one commission member mentor for newly appointed first year commission members
• Pre-meeting call with a new member(s) for better preparation • At cluster, intersperse the new members, residents and students with the residing
commission members. In doing so, this give all members a chance to get acquainted equally.
• Important to tap into the knowledge of the 3rd year members as well as staff. • Give specific assignments. The completion of these actions usually yielded a good
return on investment and gave a sense of ownership.
• Discussion regarding the Member Interest Groups (MIGs) and the process of reporting through commissions with their ideas for AAFP policy, member needs, etc.
• Note: A commission member will be “assigned” as the liaison to a given MIG. • Spokesperson Policy – Attachment J (For Information) • Parliamentary Procedures, Helpful Tips – Attachment K (For Information)
V. Discussion - The winter and summer clusters now both have a shortened schedule. Even with this change, consideration should be given at the time of either cluster for the opportunity for brainstorming within the Academy’s four strategic priorities.
VI. Getting work done between commission meetings
• Provide expectations of the Board with respect to work done between commission
meetings – continue this good work • Use a Commission Executive Committee - the Board Liaison is a member of the
commission and the commission’s executive committee without vote. • Use available tools, i.e., email technology, conference calls, webinars • Stress importance of meeting deadlines • Be responsive in between cluster meetings in order that business can be conducted
expeditiously – especially related to handling resolutions from the NCCL and National Conference.
• Members are to acquaint themselves with using the AAFP Community platform to conduct work between meetings. In general, the chairs need to buy in and promote to members the increased use of electronic communication technology to conduct the commission's work both at the meeting and throughout the rest of the year. If new or current commission members need initial or further training on the AAFP Community platform, this can be arranged via your commission staff executive.
• Keep commissions aware of our continuing need to focus on our Strategic Plan and the twelve strategy statements and be aware of our fiscal and staff resources.
VII. Inter-Commission Coordination/Cooperation – Dates and times tentative
1. Tentative times commissions can meet jointly during the Winter Cluster – January 26-28, 2018 (Sheraton Crown Center in Kansas City, MO) (times tentative): TBD
2. Tentative times commissions can meet jointly during the Summer Cluster – June 1 – 3,
2018 (Westin Crown Center in Kansas City, MO) (time tentative): Saturday, June 2 - 1 p.m. - 1:30 p.m.
(Note: All commission agendas are shared with chairs four weeks prior to each cluster)
VIII. Appointment of a member from each commission (except the Commission on Finance and
Insurance) on the following workgroup: 1. Working Group on Rural Health as approved by the 2007 Congress of Delegates
Tentatively scheduled - Friday, January 26, 2018 – 6 – 9 p.m. - Winter cluster in Kansas City, MO - Hotel: Sheraton Crown Center - Room TBD
2. Commission on Health of the Public and Science Subcommittee on Health Equity
Tentatively scheduled – Friday, January 26, 2018 – 6 – 9 p.m. – Winter cluster in Kansas City, MO - Hotel: Sheraton Crown Center - Room TBD
IX. Listing of chairs and staff for each commission - Attachment L (For Information)
XI. Adjourn
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 16
Nominating Committee Item 4.D. TMA Councils and Committees
October 2017
Each year we get a letter from the incoming TMA President asking for nominations for councils and committees. The request is sent to all members of the Interspecialty Society. We usually send an e-mail to Active members and submit anyone who replies using a form they provide just asking for a few lines of information. Below and on the following pages are lists of family physicians serving on TMA councils and committees to help you identify some gaps. I know that Dr. Fiesinger wants to be appointed to the Council on Legislation. It looks like we don’t have any TAFP members serving.
Council or committee Full Name Expiration year
Committee on Cancer Lynn Stewart, MD 2020 Committee on Child and Adolescent Joane Goforth Baumer, MD, FAAFP 2019 Committee on Medical Home and Primary Care Jeffrey M Bullard, MD 2019 Committee on Medical Home and Primary Care Anne Marie Ponce de Leon, MD 2020 Committee on Medical Home and Primary Care Erica Williams Swegler, MD, FAAFP 2019 Committee on Medical Home and Primary Care, Chair
Lindsay Botsford, MD, MBA, CMQ, FAAFP 2018
Committee on Membership Tina J Philip, DO 2019 Committee on Physician Distribution and Health Care Access
Hector R Trevino, MD 2018
Committee on Physician Health and Wellness Dale Crawford Allison, MD, FAAFP 2018 Committee on Reproductive, Women's and Perinatal Health, Consultant
Emily D Briggs, MD, MPH, FAAFP 2019
Committee on Rural Health Alyssa Beth Molina, MD 2019 Committee on Rural Health Thomas David Greer, MD, FAAFP 2020 Council on Health Care Quality Luis Manuel Benavides, MD, FAAFP 2019 Council on Health Care Quality Jorge Duchicela, MD, FAAFP 2019 Council on Health Care Quality Javier D Margo, MD, FAAFP 2020 Council on Health Care Quality Robert Benton Morrow, MD 2020 Council on Health Care Quality Roger Mike Ragain, MD, MS, FACG, FAAFP 2018 Council on Health Promotion Linda Marie Siy, MD, FAAFP 2018 Council on Health Service Organizations Hattie E Henderson, MD 2020 Council on Health Service Organizations Li-Yu Huang Mitchell, MD 2020 Council on Health Service Organizations Robert A Friedman, MD, FAAFP 2019 Council on Medical Education Josephine Rebecca Fowler, MD, FAAFP 2019 Council on Medical Education Adela S Valdez, MD, FAAFP 2020 Council on Medical Education Jonathan E MacClements, MD, FAAFP 2018
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 17
Council or committee Full Name Expiration year
Council on Medical Education Dana Sprute, MD, MPH, FAAFP 2019 Council on Medical Education Irvin Sulapas, MD, FAAFP 2020 Council on Medical Education Troy Treanor Fiesinger, MD, FAAFP 2018 Council on Medical Education Ikemefuna Charles Okwuwa, MD, FAAFP 2020 Council on Medical Education Ronald Lynn Cook, DO, MBA, FAAFP 2020 Council on Practice Management Services Jack Edward DuBose, MD 2018 Council on Practice Management Services Christopher Shane Hall, MD 2019 Council on Practice Management Services Dean A Schultz, MD 2018 Council on Science and Public Health Carolyn Eaton, MD 2019 Council on Socioeconomics Rodney B Young, MD, FAAFP 2019 Council on Socioeconomics Gregory Michael Fuller, MD, FAAFP 2020
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 18
Nominating Committee Item 4.E. AAFP Awards
October 2017
AAFP has a slate of awards that they make available each year. TAFP automatically nominates our recipient of the Family Physician of the Year, Public Health Award and Teaching Awards for the equivalent AAFP award but there are others that we only nominate from time to time. Awards represent an opportunity to highlight excellence but they can also be a great deal of work. This year we nominated Dr. Lawler for the Thomas W. Johnson Award, Dr. Chenven for the Robert Graham Award and Dr. Kyle Sheets for the Humanitarian Award in addition to Dr. Kumar for Physician of the Year and Dr. Fowler for the Teaching Award. Dr. Chenven and Dr. Sheets were honored. Tom heard from someone from VillageMD wanting to nominate Dr. Clive Fields for the Robert Graham award next year. Below is a list of the awards and a brief description and following is a bio of Dr. Fields.
Humanitarian Award This award recognizes extraordinary and enduring humanitarian efforts. Dr. Kyle Sheets won this award in 2017.
Robert Graham Family Physician Executive Award
This award recognizes an outstanding family physician for his or her role as a physician executive. Dr. Chenven won the award in 2017. Dr. Roland Goertz is a past recipient.
Thomas W. Johnson Award for Career Contributions to Family Medicine Education
This award recognizes outstanding contributions to Family Medicine education in undergraduate, graduate and continuing education spheres. Dr. Ross Lawler was nominated in 2017 and can be resubmitted in 2018.
Arnold P. Gold Foundation Humanism in Medicine Award for Practicing Doctors
This award established by the Arnold P. Gold Foundation for specialty societies, identifies and honors practicing physician who best demonstrate the ideals of compassionate and respectful care for a patient's physical and emotional well-being. The recipient will receive a monetary award of $1,000, and financial support* to receive the award at the Congress of Delegates meeting.
John G. Walsh Award for Lifetime Contributions to Family Medicine
This award honors those individuals whose dedication and effective leadership has furthered the development of family medicine. It recognizes long-term dedication, rather than any single significant contribution, and effective leadership toward furthering the development of family medicine. Designed to be the highest honor presented by the AAFP, with the exception of honorary membership. The award will not necessarily be granted on a regular basis, but will be awarded at the discretion of the Board.
AAFP Award for Distinguished and Meritorious Service to Family Medicine
This award recognizes members, nonmembers, chapter executives with 25-year service, and entities for long-time dedication to furthering the objectives of the AAFP and furthering the specialty of family medicine.
Sheridan Scott Evans, MD Finance, Cms CPDActive Mckinney
Mitchell Frank Finnie, MD, FAAFP Old BoardActive San Antonio
Linda Whidden Flower, MD, FAAFP Cms on LegActive Tomball
Ami C Foster, MD Cms HCS, Cms CPD, Cms Public Health, Liaison Cmt
Active Katy
Grant Carlton Fowler, MD, FAAFP Cms CPD, Old board, Chaired Academic Affairs and TF on Procedural Skills; 2015 & 2016 Member Assembly
Active Houston
Melecia Fuentes, MD Valley Chapter leadership, 2016 Member Assembly
Active Weslaco
Kelly A Gabler, MD, FAAFP Old board, Chaired Residents, Chaired Sect on Communications, Bylaws, Cms Academic Aff, Cms Membership, Attended NCSC/ALF 2011‐13
Active Baytown
James Stanley Garrett, MD, FAAFP Membership, HCS & CPDActive Lubbock
Oscar Garza, MD Leadership Dev; Chaired Rural Physicians, Cms CPD, TF on Governance, Finance; 2015 Member Assembly
Active Pearsall
April Gatson, MD FMLE 2016; 2016 & 2017 Member Assembly, Cms HCS
Active Longview
Louis Jarrel Gilbert, DO Active Houston
Lisa Biry Glenn, MD Old board, Chaired Public Health, Cms Leg, HCS; 2014 Member Assembly
Active Austin
Sander J Gothard, MD Active Plano
Jay L Gruhlkey, MD, FAAFP Old board, Cms Leg, FinanceActive New Braunfels
Tanya R Grun, MD Old board, Cms AS&CME, Cms Public Health
Active New Braunfels
Lesca C Hadley, MD, FAAFP Chaired Maternity, Chaired Bylaws, Chaired Special Constituencies, was AAFP New Physician Delegate, Chair of Membership. On Academic Affairs; Old Old board; 2014 & 2015 Member Assembly, FMLE 2017
Active Cleburne
Suhaib W Haq, MD, FAAFP Cms HCS, Cms CPD; 2014 Member Assembly
Active Helotes
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 23
Full Name Experience with TAFPMember Type
City 2017 or 2018 Appointment
Katharina Hathaway, MD Old board, Cms Public Health, Chaired Section on Research, Attended NCSC in 2011
Active Austin
Sharon Hausman‐Cohen, MD CPD, 2014 & 2015 Member AssemblyActive Austin
Beverley L Henwood, MD Active San Antonio
Terrance S Hines, MD, FAAFP Chair of Bylaws; Spec. Const Director on Board 2013‐15, Cms Academic Affairs, Cms Leg, Chaired Special Constituencies, Attended NCSC, FMLE 2016
Active Austin
Jose R Hinojosa, MD Cms Academic AffairsActive San Antonio
Anthony Holbert, MD, MBA Cms HCS, Cms Leg; 2015 Member Assembly
Active DALLAS
Jill Diane Holland, MD old Board; 2014 & 2015 & 2016 Member Assembly, Public Health
Active Kilgore
Farron Cheryl Hunt, MD, FAAFP Special Const Director on Board, 2015‐16; Cms on Leg, Bylaws Cmt; 2014 & 2015 Member Assembly, Attended ALF 2014, FMLE 2016, Chair of Leadership Development
Active Port Arthur
Jamal Islam, MD, MS Cms Public Health, Cms CPD; NCSC 2011; 2015 Member Assembly
Active League City
Jennifer D Jackson, MD Cms Public HealthActive Georgetown
Carlos Roberto Jaen, MD, PhD, FAAFP Chaired Public Health, Cms Academic AffActive San Antonio
Li‐Yu Huang Mitchell, MD FMLE 2016, 2016 Member Assembly, Cms on Leg, Cms on Public Health
Active Tyler
Bhavana Mocherla, MD Attended NCCL 2015 as resident, Academic Affairs, CPD and Leg as Resident; 2015 & 2016 Member Assembly
Active Odessa
Sherri L Morgan, MD, MPH, FAAFP Cms Public HealthActive Dallas
Mariana Munante, MD FMLE 2016, Cms HCSActive San Antonio
Batool Amir Mundrawala, MD, FAAFP Cms Membership, Public HealthActive Houston
TAFP Nominating Committee, AS17 Page 25
Full Name Experience with TAFPMember Type
City 2017 or 2018 Appointment
Xavier J Munoz, DO Old board, Cms Membership, Cms Leg, PAC Board
Active El Paso
Maria De Jesus Munoz, MD Cms Public Health; Cms Academic Affairs, 2014 & 2016 Member Assembly
Active San Benito
Kenton Kumar Murthy, DO, MPH, MS FMLE 2016, Cms Public HealthActive Grapevine
Mark Nadeau, MD, MBA, FAAFP Chaired Academic Affairs; 2014 Member Assembly
Active San Antonio
Stuti Nagpal, MD FMLE 2016; 2016 Member Assembly, VC Maternity Care, Cms on Academic Affairs
Active San Antonio
Francisco Xavier Neira, MD Cms Public HealthActive Dallas
Mary Suzanne Nguyen, MD, FAAFP Old board, Chaired Rural Physicians, Exec, Nominating, Cms Leg, Cms Public Health, Cms Membership; 2014, 2015, 2016 Member Assembly, Attended NCSC 2011‐15, FMLE 2016, 2017 Board as Special Constituency Mbr, Co‐convener of NCCL, Member Constituency Delegat
Active Castroville
Donald R Nino, MD, FAAFP Old board, Chair, TF on LC operations, Exec, Cms Membership, TF Chapter Revitilization; 2014 & 2015 &2016 Member Assembly
Active Channelview
Ikemefuna Charles Okwuwa, MD Elected Member Constituency Alt Delegate at NCCL 2015; Academic Aff, Leadership, HCS, old Board as resident; 2015 & 2016 Member Assembly, FMLE 2016, New Physician on 2017 Board
Active Odessa
Sherri D Onyiego, MD, FAAFP FMLE 2016, Cms on MembershipActive Houston
kiran Kumar panuganti, MD Active Frisco
Mehjabin I Parkar, MD Cms Academic AffActive Sugar Land
Robert Warren Parker, MD, FAAFP Cms Academic AffActive San Antonio
Sandra K Parker, MD Active Willow Park
John A Partin, MD Cms Leg, FinanceActive Kerrville
Anush S Pillai, DO, FAAFP Bylaws, CommissionActive Pearland
Anne Marie Ponce de Leon, MD Cms HCS, CMS Leg, FMLE 2016Active Sugar Land