-
INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGIESFOR ADA
ACCESS COMPLIANCE
CivicCivicCenterCenterPlazaPlaza
LafayettePark
JeffersonSquare
80
80
101
At&TParkParkPark
AlamoSquare
BuenaVistaPark
AtlaPlazw
California St
Geary St
O’ferrell St
Pine StBush St
Montgom
ery StM
ontgomery St
Montgom
ery St
Kearny StKearny St
Golden Gate Ave
Turk St
6th St
5th St4th St
2nd St
2nd StFremont St
Fremont St
Fremont St
Town
send
St
Town
send
St
Town
send
St King
St
King S
t
16th St280101Swanarch.com
New Technology Solutions to Inventory & Scope ADA Barrier
Mitigation within Sidewalk Programs
101101
BroadwayBroadway
Fillmore St
Fillmore St
Sally Swanson Architects, Inc
-
ADA Access Requirements
Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requires
all public entities to identify physical barriers that preclude
access to a City’s programs, services and activities.
Most ADA Self Evaluation and Transition Plans typically included
programs housed in buildings and parks, but not many included a
detailed inventory of their sidewalks.
Chapter 28 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) part 35.150 (d)
requires the inclusion of a schedule for providing curb ramps,
where the entity has jurisdiction over the sidewalks in the
rights-of-way.
But it took several lawsuits to actually provide the impetus to
include the sidewalk program into most Entities’ Transition
Plans.*
* Kinney v. Yerusalim - 3rd Circuit Court decision: simultaneous
accessibility improvements required within project scope; Barden v.
Sacramento - 9th Circuit Court decision: continuously maintained
sidewalks are required
What is the goal?
e goal of taking an inventory of sidewalks, required by law, is
to create a prioritized list of improvement projects. A list takes
the guesswork out of scoping and budgeting for ADA improvements,
part of major Capital Improvement or Street Resurfacing
projects.
With such a plan in hand, it is easy for everyone to see the
steps needed to transition towards accessibility. is legally
defensible ‘Transition Plan’ includes a prioritized list of
barriers to accessibility, and an annual budget for getting rid of
the barriers.
Is it easy to take an inventory of sidewalks for the Transition
Plan?
Not that easy. Sidewalk measuring is a labor-intensive task. One
person walks down the sidewalk, placing a level at a prescribed
distance, usually every two to four feet. Rather than do all
sidewalks, a sampling is taken. But this leaves out many possible
sidewalk hazards...
-
Pro�lers and GIS Tools
Sidewalk pro�ling devices enable the capture of highly accurate
location-speci�c data about barriers and hazards that can make a
sidewalk di�cult to navigate. Innovative software mounted on the
pro�lers allow for the data to be exported to a city’s asset
management database or integrated into a geodatabase.
Unlike survey data collected at a curb ramp, which is located at
one point in an intersection, data along a mid-block section of a
sidewalk could be spread over anywhere between a ¼ mile to several
miles. Using GIS technology to pinpoint these multiple locations
along the length of a section of sidewalk is the most feasible way
for a contractor to go out and repair sections of sidewalk.
Prioritize Barriers
To prioritize barriers, layers of information are created and
laid on top of each other. A variety of location characteristics,
such as socio-economic data, transit routes and stops, arterial
classi�cations, housing and employment density and others, are
integrated into GIS. Heavily used pedestrian facilities are
assigned a higher activity score, which would determine their
priority for upgrades.
User-friendly interfaces also allow you to adjust weights based
on stakeholder input and try dierent scenarios to validate the
scoring strategy, based on the severity of each individual barrier.
Knowing the prioritization scores, you can now scope the work to �t
your annual budget.
GIS Viewers
Using Surface Pro�lers with Geographical Information System
(GIS) is a cost-eective solution to inventory and map ADA barriers
within your pedestrian infrastructure. For those who do not have
access to GIS software, a browser-based GIS viewer is also
accessible from a dedicated webpage. Just like Google maps, the GIS
viewer allows panning can pan across or zoom into a jurisdiction’s
map, turn on and o layers to identify barrier types for dierent
pedestrian features, and view collected data and analysis on a
dedicated web page from any computer.
e ability to have documents updated regularly with real-time
information on compliance facilitates barrier removal, and easy
access from a website improves data input as projects are
programmed and funding is secured, allowing regular measuring of
progress.
-
Generating Reports
�e sidewalk inventory data is used to generate reports at the
push of a button:
• �e reports can be generated by street, with scope and cost
summaries.• Alternatively work orders can be generated to identify
a particular type of barrier across the entire inventory.• Annual
update reports provide governing bodies with a dashboard on the
utilization of public funds.• Reports identify barriers within the
limits of work of a Capital Improvement Project ensuring inclusion
in the nal scope and budget.
Updating
As projects are completed, or new ones appear in the eld, they
can be added or annotated in the eld through handheld devices. ADA
codes and guidelines are automatically incorporated and analyzed,
and are updated as they change.
Advantages
A detailed inventory of your pedestrian infrastructure meets the
basic requirement of the law and also provides other
advantages:
• Identify severe hazards• Manage risk and legal exposure• Track
your progress• Document good-faith eort
�e large database of non-compliant conditions with proposed
mitigation solutions meets the basic requirement of the law and
allows you to:
• Scope barrier removal as part of larger Capital Improvement
Projects (CIP) projects • ‘Encourage’ property owners to improve
adjacent sidewalks as a condition of their permit approval• Develop
a recurring maintenance program
With the right planning tools, local public agencies can be
proactive in addressing trip and fall hazards or prioritizing
barrier-removal within their pedestrian infrastructure.
220 Sansome Street, Suite 1100San Francisco CA 94104T:
415-445-3045F: 415-445-3055E: [email protected]
Swanarch.com