22 GOVERNMENT OF INDIA DEPARTMENT OF ATOMIC ENERGY NUCLEAR FUEL COMPLEX HYDERABAD-500062 IN PLANT TRAINING ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PRODUCTION AT NEW ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PLANT AND ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PLANT AND DESIGNING OF DOUBLE PIPE HEAT EXCHANGERS SUBMITTED BY: RATAN MONDAL (B.TECH,CHEMICAL ENGG.) SUBMITTED ON: JUNE 16, 2015 INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, GURU GHASIDAS VISHWAVIDYALAYA BILASPUR
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
22
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
DEPARTMENT OF ATOMIC ENERGY
NUCLEAR FUEL COMPLEX
HYDERABAD-500062
IN PLANT TRAINING
ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PRODUCTION
AT
NEW ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PLANT AND ZIRCONIUM OXIDE PLANT
Until 1922, it was not known that zirconium and its compounds always contain small amounts of
chemical elements of atomic number 72. In 1922, Hevesy and Coster, while carrying out X-ray
spectroscopic investigation of zirconium, discovered new X-ray lines, which coincided with the
characteristic lines that had been calculated for the element of atomic number 72. It was named
hafnium. The simultaneous occurrence of zirconium and hafnium is because of the effect
“Lanthanide contraction” in hafnium.
Hafnium is a ductile metal with brilliant silvery lustre. Hafnium is dispersed in the earth’s crust
to 3ppm and is invariably found in zirconium minerals up to a few % compared with Zirconium,
altered Zircons, and some other zircon compounds.
Zirconium and hafnium are extremely similar in physiochemical properties. Hafnium’s large
thermal neutron capture cross section, high resistance to corrosion in hot water and good
chemical properties make hafnium an excellent material for the manufacture of control rods for
thermal nuclear reactors. Hafnium can also be alloyed or composite with other materials, which
can be used in the outlet nozzle of a rocket.
Hafnium is used for fabricating nuclear control rods because it easily absorbs thermal neutrons
and has excellent mechanical properties. Hafnium produces a protective film of oxides or nitride
upon contact with air and thus has high corrosion resistance. It forms alloys with Iron, Tantalum
and other transition metals. The alloy Tantalum Hafnium Carbide (Ta4 HfC5), with a melting
point of 41250C (76190F) is one of the most refractory substances known.
SEPARATION OF ZIRCONIUM AND HAFNIUM:
Separation of Hafnium & Zirconium is generally accomplished by liquid-liquid counter current
extraction process. In this procedure, crude Zirconium oxide is dissolved in a nitric acid solution
& tri butyl phosphate is passed counter current to the aqueous mixture, with the result that the
Zirconium nitrate is perfectly extracted.
For reactor grade zirconium (<50 ppm) the solvent extraction method using tri butyl phosphate is
appropriate with high purity hafnium (0.1 % Zr) can be obtained efficiently (42% recovery) by
ion exchange using Dowex-50 cation exchanger. A pure grade of Hf (0.02 % Zr) may be
obtained by less efficient process (20-30 % yield) using solvent extraction with
trifluroacetylacetone.
9
PHYSICAL CONSTANTS FOR ZIRCONIUM AND HAFNIUM
Properties Zr Hf
Atomic number 40 72
Atomic weight 91.22 178.49
Melting point, 0C 1830 2222
Density, g/cc 6.49 13.01-13.09
Boiling point, 0C 2900 3100
Transition temperature,0C 862 1670
CHEMICAL PROPERTIES:
Natural Zr is a mixture of five stable isotopes and natural Hf is a mixture of six isotopes. The
thermal neutron capture cross section of zirconium metal (0.18 barn) is very small when
compared with that of other metals, iron (2.53 barn), nickel (4.60 barn) or copper (3.69 barn). In
contrast to Zr, Hf has a large thermal neutron capture cross section of 115 barns.
Hf in Zr plays a decisive part, which is about 1-2% in impure Zr. The presence of this amount of
Hf in Zr causes a considerable rise in the value of thermal neutron capture cross section from
0.18 barn to 1 barn.
The valency of Zr&Hf may be 2, 3 or 4. The stability of their compounds increases at high
valencies. Compounds of bi- and trivalent Zr&Hf are known, but they are unstable & have strong
reducing properties. The characteristic oxidation state of the two elements is +4.
Zr&Hf are highly resistant to corrosion. Zr is practically unaffected by water, HCl, HNO3 or dil.
H2SO4 and alkali solutions even on heating. However both metals are readily dissolved by H2F2
Property Zr Hf
Atomic radius,0A 1.452 1.442
Ionic radius, 0A 0.74 0.75
10
and by a mixture of HCl& HNO3, and at high temperature vigorously combine with O2, N2, H2,
halogens S, C, Si, and B; with the last mentioned compounds, Zr&Hf form refractor compounds.
The basic properties increase in the sequence Ti<Zr<Hf<Th, Hf being slightly more basic than
Zr.
FEATURES OF IMPORTANCE IN NUCLEAR INDUSTRY:
Ready availability
Low cross-sectional absorption of thermal neutron
Resistance to radiation damage
Excellent corrosion resistance in pressurizes hot water up to 3500C
OTHER SALIENT FEATURES:
Good guttering Highly pyrophoric Super conductive at low temperature with niobium High refractive index in oxide form Good refractive properties in oxide form
ZIRCALLOY USED IN INDIAN NUCLEAR REACTORS:
ZIRCALLOY -2(FUEL TUBES BWR’S)
Zircalloy -4(fuel tubes and calandria tubes of PHWR’s, coolant channels of BWR’s)
Zr- Nb (pressure tubes of PHWR’s)
Zr-Nb-Cu (garter springs PHWR’s)
Uses:
a) Fuel clad and structural material in alloy form for core components of Detonators and
Pyrotechnics.
b) Corrosion resistance applications as components in chemical industry.
c) Getter in vacuum tubes.
d) Refractory material in the form of oxide in lass and ceramic industries.
e) Lining of metallurgical furnaces in the form of oxide.
f) Artificial gems.
Deposits of zircon are high along the coastline of Needakara and Kayamkulum in Kerala.
Chavara mineral division near Kollam in Kerala, Manavalakurichi mineral division near
11
Kanyakumari in Tamil Nadu and OSCOM at Chatrapur in Orissa are the Indian Rate Earth
Division (IREL) units exploiting the huge zircon deposits in India.
4. FLOW SHEET OF ZIRCONIUM OXIDE
PRODUCTION
12
5. PROCESS OF PRODUCTION
LIST OF UNIT OPERATIONS AND UNIT PROCESSES CARRIED OUT IN ZOP:
5.1 DISSOLUTION OF DRY POWDER
5.2 SOLVENT EXTRACTION
I. SLURRY EXTRACTION
II. SCRUBBING
III. STRIPPING
IV. SODA SOLUTION TREATMENT
5.3 PRECIPITATION
5.4 REPULPING
5.5 VACUUM FILTRATION
5.6 DRYING
5.7 CALCINATION
5.8 GRINDING
5. 9 BLENDING
13
5.1 DISSOLUTION
Raw materials:
Dry powder
Nitric Acid (60% concentrated)
Storage of nitric acid:
Nitric acid is received in a horizontal SS tank. The receiving tank is placed below the ground level, so as
to receive the nitric acid from the tankers by the force of gravity. There are two vertical storage tanks each
of 150KL capacity. The vertical tanks are filled from the horizontal tank by the use of vertical pumps. The
specialty of the vertical pumps is that they are inside the horizontal tank, so the chance of nitric acid to
leak or spill is eliminated. To measure the level of nitric acid in the vertical tank, the float and weight
method is used. The tanks are made of stainless steel. The nitric acid from storage tanks is pumped to the
dozing tanks from where the required amount of nitric acid is fed into the reactor.
Storage of dry powder:
The dry powder is procured in 50 kg bags. The dry powder is mainly tested for the above required
compositions of the compound mainly zirconium before being charged into the reactor. It is tested in the
control lab, which plays a pivotal role in each and every part of production of zirconium. The dry powder
is taken to level above that of the height of the reactor and is charged into the reactor from conical
opening, because of which the chances of the powder being wasted is reduced and the handlings becomes
easier. The dry powder is taken to the required height by using a 2-ton hoist.
Material of construction:
Dissolution is done in SS tanks. It consists of an agitator and the feed is heated by steam.
Chemical reaction:
ZrO2 + 4HNO3 Zr (NO3)4 + 2H2O
14
PROCESS DESCRIPTION
The requisite amount of nitric acid (12N) is charged into a reactor made of stainless steel. It is agitated
using an impeller and moderately heated using direct contact steam at a pressure of 3 kg/cm2. Then the
calculated amount of dry powder is added to the reactor and it is agitated for 2 hrs. This DP is dissolved in
12N (60%) Nitric acid, which is already present in the dissolution tank to produce Zirconium Nitrate
solution, which is the feed material for purification by solvent extraction. It is an exothermic reaction so
the temperature rises .The solution is diluted with scrub raffinate and allowed to settle for 2 hrs. After 2
hrs. The insoluble solids settle down and a clear layer of zirconium nitrate is formed above the solids. The
solids are drained off once a week in order to prevent choking of lines. The nitrate solution is checked for
the required qualities such as free acidity, total acidity and the composition of zirconium and hafnium
values. The nitrate solution is then sent to feed tanks, which is made of SS by means of centrifugal pump
whose impeller is also made of stainless steel. The feed tanks have a conical bottom to ensure free
draining of the silt that settles in due course time. The silt is cleaned once in 20 days. Large care is taken
while handling nitric acid since it corrodes materials like Mild Steel, so, only Stainless Steel components
are used while handling nitric acid. Here the material of construction of the reactor is SS-304L.
Some safety precautions that must be taken while dissolution, is that the temperature must not rise
abruptly to high value. If the temperature rises above this range then nitrate Fumes are released and the
batch gets wasted. Usually sodium carbonate is sprinkled on the floor to neutralize the nitric acid that
HN03
STEAM
m DRY POWDER
Baffles
Acidic slit
Feed slurry
SCRUB RAFFINATE
15
leaks from pipelines. The other main factor is the concentration of nitric acid: if a higher concentration is
used then the required acidity cannot be maintained. If the free acidity of the nitrate solution is above the
required value then in slurry extraction even hafnium is extracted and if free acidity is less than the
required value then some amount of zirconium is lost, so it is very necessary to maintain the free acid. If
free acidity is less than the required value acid is added to increase the free acidity and if the free acidity
exceeds the required value then acid addition is stopped.
The foremost and the important chemical unit operation of zirconium oxide is “solvent
extraction”. This process takes place as slurry extraction, scrubbing and stripping.
5.2 SOLVENT EXTRACTION The process of separation of the components of a solution depends upon the unequal distribution of the
components between two immiscible liquids is known as “LIQUID – LIQUID EXTRACTION” or more
simply “Liquid Extraction”. Liquid extraction is sometimes called as “SOLVENT EXTRACTION”.
Solvent extraction is a chemical engineering separation that has many variations and many applications in
that process industries and uses many types of equipment.
Solvent extraction is based on the principle that a solute can distribute itself in a ratio between two
immiscible solvents, one of which is usually water and the other an organic solvent such as benzene,
carbon tetrachloride, etc. in certain cases the solute can be more or less completely transferred into the
organic phase.
For a given metal, present in various species M1, M2, and so on up to Mi and distributed between an
organic and aqueous phase, the extraction can be defined in the following terms.
Distribution ratio or extraction coefficient, E
E = Morg/Maq
Where Morg = M1org + M2org + …….
Maq = M1aq + M2aq + ………
The above expression is valid for a simple system in which only one species is distributed and exists in
the same form in both phases. Under ideal conditions, where the solute exists in the same form in both
phases, interactions between solute and solvent are absent and association and dissociation reactions do
not occur.
When separation by distillation is ineffective or very difficult, liquid extraction is one of the main
alternatives to consider. Close boiling mixtures or substances that cannot withstand the temperature of
distillation, even under a vacuum, may often be separated from impurities by extraction, which utilizes
chemical potential difference instead of vapour pressure difference. Separations done by solvent
extractions are essentially physical in character and the various components are unchanged chemically.
Nevertheless, the chemical nature of the liquids influences the extent of solutions involved. The minimum
requirement for liquid extraction is the intimate contact of the two immiscible liquids for the purpose of
mass transfer of the constituents from one liquid to the other, followed by physical separation of the two
immiscible liquids.
16
The solvent extraction contains three units i.e., Extraction, scrubbing, stripping to produce the pure
solution. During the extraction process, the organic solvent (TBP+Kerosene) is contained with the
inorganic zirconium nitrate solution counter currently. Calculated amount of nitric acid is also added to
maintain free acidity. The ZrO2 is then loaded into the organic solvent by contact, which is again loaded
back into the pure solution (inorganic) as pre extract in the scrubbing unit.
The function of a stage is to contact the liquids, allow equilibrium to be approached and to make a
mechanical separation of the liquids. The contacting and separating correspond to mixing the liquids and
settling the resultant dispersion, so these devices are usually called “MIXER SETTLERS”.
Over the past many years, various designs of mixers settlers have been with general aim to decrease the
required while maintaining high throughput and efficiency. Mixers are relatively easy to operate, reliable,
flexible and fairly simple to design, are free of back mixing and the stage efficiencies are usually greater
than 90%. With sufficient residence time and power in the mixer, and sufficient residence time in the
settler, practically 100% stage efficiencies can be reached. Uncertainties in operation are considerably
decreased by high stage efficiencies.
A mixer settler transfers a solute from one liquid phase into another immiscible, or only partially miscible
liquid phase. It consists essentially of a chamber where two liquids are mixed by stirring or some other
means of agitation and a settler where two liquids are separated by gravity. Each stage consists of mixing
and settling chambers, which alternate along the box so that mixers and settlers of adjacent stages are in
juxtaposition. The liquids are brought into intimate contact in a mixing chamber and pass together, in the
form of an unstable emulsion, to the settler through a port or slot placed about midway up the dividing
wall. In the settler the phases disengage, the heavy phase on to the mixer of the next stage through a port
plated low in the wall, while the lighter passes over a weir to the next adjacent mixer in the opposite
direction. It will be seen that this flow pattern represents co current flow in each stage and counter current
flow overall. These mixer settlers thus show little change in performance with moderate variations in
through put and phase ratio, resulting in flexibility and ease of design.
The settler size is a critical factor in mixer settler designs. The size is governed by the throughput
limitations imposed by the rate of coalescence of the dispersed phase. The power input to the mixer has
apparently little effect on the specific settling rate, but the rate was found to vary in a
TBP/HNO3/Kerosene system with chemical composition, phase ratio and temperature.
Advantages of mixer settlers:
Good contacting of phases
Handles wide range of flow ratio (with recycle)
Low head room
High efficiency
Many stages can be accommodated
Reliable scale up
Low cost and maintenance
Disadvantages of mixer settlers:
Large holdup
High power costs
High solvent inventory
Large floor space
17
Inter stage pumping may be necessary
I. SLURRY EXTRACTION Raw materials:
Zirconium nitrate solution from the feed tanks
Lean solvent (TBP + Kerosene)
Nitric acid (to maintain free acidity)
Extraction:
In extraction, a solvent that preferentially dissolves one or more components in the
mixture treats a mixture of two or more components. Mixer-settler is the most common type of
extractor.
Objective:
For continuous operation a battery of mixer-settlers is used. Slurry extractor is multistage
equipment. Except the last stage, all the other stages contain small settling tanks where no interphase is
maintained between organic and aqueous. The last stage consists bigger settler tank (raffinate tank) where
well defined inter-phase is maintained between organic and aqueous. Each stage is provided with an airlift
for effective zirconium extraction and inter-stage pumping. Compressed air is used for operating airlift
pumps. A long vertical disengagement section is followed by an airlift for separating compressed air from
the mixed phases. A tangential entry is given from air disengagement section to settling tank for a better
phase separation in settling tank. Each disengagement section is provided with a mist-eliminator where
left out solvent in air is entrained and remaining air is vented out to a duct.
Material of construction:
A typical slurry extraction unit consists of mixers and settlers that are made up of SS-304. In this unit a
mixer and a settler comprises a stage.
Process description:
The nitrate solution (feed) is pumped through a digital rota meter (which is used for slurries) into the first
stage and the lean solvent (TBP+ Kerosene) is passed in a counter current fashion into the last stage. A
float rota meter cannot be used for slurries because the solids present in the slurry accumulate on the
surface of the float and tend to increase the weight of the float thereby faltering the flow rate reading of
the feed solution, so a digital rota meter is used.
Initially all the stages are filed up with the lean solvent before starting the extraction. The solvent TBP is
selected because of its tendency to extract only zirconium at a given acidity in the nitrate medium. The
principle behind this type of extraction is that the zirconium in the aqueous phase is extracted in the
organic phase. Nitric acid is added accordingly to maintain the free acidity. The extraction equipment
used by ZOP is the new mixer-settler (made of SS316/304L) that has been indigenously developed by
NFC. It mainly consists of a mixing section and a disengaging section. The main merit of this equipment
is that the mixing and propagation is done by means of compressed air. The airlift mechanism follows the
principle that when air mixes with the solution the density of the solution decreases and thereby it causes
18
the solution to rise and also it enhances the mixing operation. The disengaging section’s primary use is to
disengage the air from the solution after it has been propagated. The primary advantage of using such
airlift mechanism is that unlike the conventional mixer-settler it does not use any mechanical parts, which
can develop various types of mechanical problems, which is absent in airlift since there is no use of
mechanical components.
The problems relating to the slurry extraction are:
1) The build-up of aqueous and organic phases.
2) This build up is mainly caused due to presence of excessive amount of either feed or organic in
one stage.
3) This excessive amount of either feed or organic is mainly due to the presence of some amount of
unreacted silica in the feed.
4) This unreacted silica forms a coating inside the pipeline and tends decrease the diameter of flow.
5) The reduced diameter of flow reduces the flow rate and thereby creates a build-up.
6) Thus this coating is root cause for the above said problems, so it has to be cleared. It is cleared by
purging the equipment with steam, which melts the silica coating and thereby clears all the above
said problems.
II. SCRUBBING Raw materials:
Organic (extract) from the slurry extraction
Pure solution from stripping
Nitric acid
Material of construction:
The material of construction is SS316.
Process description:
The extract from slurry extraction that contains minimum amount of hafnium compounds is sent for
scrubbing into the conventional mixer-settler where it is scrubbed with pure solution, which is the
aqueous solution of pure zirconium nitrate obtained from the stripping process. The scrubbing operation
is a counter current operation. Both the phases are mixed in a mixer, which essentially consists of an
agitator, side baffles and two inlets for organic and aqueous phases.
The side baffles are provided in order to provide turbulence, which in turn provides good mass-transfer. If
there is no side baffle then the liquid moves in a circular motion without mixing with the bulk of the
solution. After the solution is mixed it is allowed to settle through an opening in the side. The settling
compartment is comparatively longer than that of the mixing chamber. The settled solution is again
transferred to the next stages by means of the density differences and again mixed and settled. This is
carried out repeatedly and finally we obtain the scrub raffinate and the extract pure (which is the feed for
stripping).
The salient problems encountered here are those of the mechanical parts or the moving parts, so regular
maintenance has to be made in order to keep the unit efficiently working.
19
The main importance of this unit is that the hafnium composition is totally eliminated (<50 ppm). The
other point to be noted is that the some amount of zirconium is associated in the scrub raffinate, which is
used for dilution in the reactor, and some part is again sent into another extraction chamber to get back the
zirconium.
Other than Lean solvent (TBP+Kerosene), the use of methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBP) in a cyanide medium
can be used as solvent for extraction. The main drawbacks of using MIBK are that it has a low flash point,
it is toxic and corrosive.
EXTRACTION:
The scrub raffinate is the feed and it counter currently extracted with lean solvent (TBP+ Kerosene). The
zirconium left out in the scrub raffinate is extracted in the acidic medium (nitric acid), which is again sent
to the scrubbingunit. The product obtained here is “Extract”.
20
III. STRIPPING Raw materials:
Extract pure from the scrubbing section
De Mineralized water
Process description:
The stripping unit is the same as the scrubbing and the extraction units, the only difference lies in that of
the minerals used. Here the extract pure from the scrubbing unit is counter currently mixed with
demineralized water. Here the zirconium in the organic phase is transferred to the aqueous phase. The
stripped organic solvent is sent for treatment with soda solution. The zirconium that is in the aqueous
phase is known as pure solution. Some part of the pure solution is transferred to the storage tanks and the
other part is recycled to the scrubbing section.
21
TREATMENT WITH SODA SOLUTION:
Raw materials:
Lean solvent from the stripping unit
Soda solution
DM water
Process Description:
The Lean solvent from the stripping section is sent to mixer-settler unit in which soda solution is passed
in a counter current flow. The lean solution i.e., tri butyl phosphate degrades into mono butyl phosphate
and di butyl phosphate. The main use of this treatment is to remove the mono butyl phosphate and di
butyl phosphate, which dissolve in soda solution thereby producing free tri butyl phosphate. MBP and
DBP have higher solubility in aqueous medium than that of TBP. So, it always betters to treat the
degraded TBP before sending it for extraction.
The most important point to be noted here is that the plant does not consume excess TBP as it can be
treated and recycled back to the extraction process. There is certainly some wastage but it is minor.
TBP has 0.39g/l solubility in water
DBP has 0.64g/l solubility in water
MBP has complete solubility in water
Safety precautions:
o Use personal protection accessories like gloves, masks etc.
o Avoid chemical spillage.
o TBP and kerosene are flammable. Hence all fire prevention measures must be taken.
o Wall and local exhaust must be on.
o Emulsion formation should be avoided.
o Ensure clear phase separation such that entrainment is avoided in organic aqueous streams.
o Maintain correct inter phase levels.
o Check airlift pump also for sufficient pressure.
o In this we should check the pulleys, belts and agitators before starting the operation.
o The silica coming from the slurry extraction may cause problems. So we have to check for
scaling.
5.3 PRECIPITATION Raw materials:
Pure solution from the stripping unit
Ammonium hydroxide
Sulphuric acid
22
Material of construction:
Precipitation tank is made up of SS-304. An agitator is provided for mixing.
Chemical reaction:
The required amount of pure solution, ammonium hydroxide and sulphuric acid are taken into the
precipitation tank and are agitated. The temperature is maintained around 600C. The following reaction
exchangers used in industries. On one hand, these heat exchangers are cheap for both design
and maintenance making them good choice for small scale industries. On other hand, their
low efficiency coupled with the high space occupied in large scale has led modern industries
to use more efficient heat exchangers like shell and tube or plate heat exchangers. However
double pipe heat exchangers are used to teach heat exchanger design basics to students as the
fundamental rule for all the heat exchangers are same. It is used where flow rate of fluid and
heat duty is small. It is suitable for high pressure service. It is used when heat transfer area
requirement is small.
Advantages • Inexpensive • True countercurrent or co-current flow • Easily designed for high pressure service
Disadvantages
• Difficult to clean on shell side. • Only suitable for small sizes. They are generally not economical if UA > 50,000 Btu/hr-oF. • Thermal expansion can be an issue.
Typical Applications
1. Single phase heating and cooling when the required heat transfer area is small.
2. Can be used for heating using condensing steam if fabricated with elbows to allow expansion
U-type or hairpin construction for a double pipe heat exchanger.
33
2. Shell and tube heat exchanger: It is usually a cylindrical casing through which
one of the fluid flows in one or Shell is commonly made of carbon steel. The minimum
thickness of shell made of carbon steel varies from 5mm to 11mm depending upon the
diameter. It may be cut to the required length from a standard pipe up to 60 cm diameter
or Fabricated by rolling a metal plate suitable dimension into a cylinder and welding
along the length. Tubes are providing the heat transfer surface. Variety of materials
including low carbon steel, stainless steel, copper, brass, aluminum, etc. are used as tube
material. Outside diameter of tubes vary from 6 mm to 40 mm. The tubes with outside
diameter 19 mm to 25 mm are very common. The tube lengths used are 0.5, 2.5, 3, 4, 5
and 6 m. It depends upon the material of construction and diameter. The tubes that are
placed in a tube bundle inside the shell are either rolled or welded to the tube sheet. Tube
side fluid first enters a channel through and then through the tubes in one or multi pass
fashion. The shortest center-to-center distance between the adjacent tubes is called the
tube pitch. Tubes are generally arranged in square or triangular pitch manner. The
shortest distance between the two tubes is called the clearance. The minimum pitch is
1.25 times the outside diameter of tube. Baffles are commonly employed within the shell
to increase the rate of heat transfer by increasing the turbulence of shell side fluid and
also provides supports for the tubes and act as dampers against vibration.
Fig.: Shell and tube heat exchanger.
34
Passes are generally used to obtain higher velocities and long paths for a fluid to travel without
increasing the length of the exchanger that leads to high heat transfer area. Single or two pass is
used in shell side. One, two, four, six up to twelve passes used in tube side. Passes in tube side
are formed by partitions placed in the shell cover and channel
3. Plate heat exchanger: It consists of a series of rectangular, parallel and corrugated
plates held firmly together between substantial head frames. The plates have corner ports
and are sealed and spaced by rubber gaskets around the ports and along the plate edges.
These plates serve as the HT surfaces and are of stainless steel. Corrugated plates provide
a high degree of turbulence even at low flow rates. Gap between plates is 1.3 to 1.5 mm.
It is provided with inlet and outlet nozzles for fluid at the ends. Hot fluid passes between
alternate pairs of plates, transferring heat to a cold fluid in the adjacent spaces. The plates
can be readily separated for cleaning and the HT area can be increased by simply adding
more plates. As it is very compact, requires very small floor space. High heat transfer
coefficient, easy to clean. Plate heat exchanger are competitive with Shell and tube heat
exchanger where the corrosive fluid is to be handled. Heat sensitive material, where the
temperature control is required, these units are used.
Fig.: Plate heat exchanger.
4. Waste heat recovery unit: A waste heat recovery unit (WHRU) is a heat exchanger
that recovers heat from a hot stream while transferring it to a working medium, typically
water or oil. The hot gas stream can be the exhaust gas from a gas turbine or a diesel
engine or waste gas from industry or refinery. Big system with high volume and
temperature and gas stream, typical in industries can be benefit from steam Rankine
Cycle in WHRU, but these cycle are too expensive for small system. The recovery of
heat from low temperature system requires different working fluids than steam. An
organic Rankine Cycle WHRU can be more efficient at low temperature range using
Refrigerant that boil at lower temperature than water. Typical organic refrigerant are
Ammonia Pentafluoropropane and Toluene. The refrigerant is boiled by the heat source
in the evaporator to produce super-heated vapor. This fluid is expanded in the turbine to
35
convert thermal energy to kinetic energy, that is converted in to electricity in the
electrical generator. This energy transfer process decrease the temperature of the
refrigerant that, condenses. The cycle is close and complete using a pump to send the
fluid back to the evaporator.
9. DESIGNING OF DOUBLE PIPE HEAT EXCHANGER
The double-pipe heat exchanger is one of the simplest types of heat exchangers. It is called a
double-pipe exchanger because one fluid flows inside a pipe and the other fluid flows between
that pipe and another pipe that surrounds the first. This is a concentric tube construction. Flow
in a double-pipe heat exchanger can be co-current or counter-current. There are two flow
configurations: co-current is when the flow of the two streams is in the same direction, counter
current is when the flow of the streams is in opposite directions. As conditions in the pipes
change: inlet temperatures, flow rates, fluid properties, fluid composition, etc., the amount of
heat transferred also changes. This transient behavior leads to change in process temperatures,
which will lead to a point where the temperature distribution becomes steady. When heat is
beginning to be transferred, this changes the temperature of the fluids. Until these temperatures
reach a steady state their behavior is dependent on time.
In this double-pipe heat exchanger a hot process fluid flowing through the inner pipe transfers its
heat to cooling water flowing in the outer pipe. The system is in steady state until conditions
change, such as flow rate or inlet temperature. These changes in conditions cause the
temperature distribution to change with time until a new steady state is reached. The new steady
state will be observed once the inlet and outlet temperatures for the process and coolant fluid
become stable. In reality, the temperatures will never be completely stable, but with large
enough changes in inlet temperatures or flow rates a relative steady state can be experimentally
observed. . The outer tube is called the annulus. In one of the pipes a warmer fluid flows and in
the other a colder one.
Co-current Flow
To understand what factors influence the dimensions of this heat exchanger when a certain heat rate is
expected some simple equations will be examined.
Countercurrent Flow
36
First a simple heat balance:
q = m& h ⋅ch ⋅(ThI −ThII ) = m& c ⋅cc
⋅(TcII −TcI ) (1.1)
With:
qh = heat transferred from the hot to the cold fluid (kW)
m& h = mass flow of the hot fluid (kg/s )
ch = specific heat of the hot fluid (kJ/kg/°C)
ThI = hot fluid at position I (°C)
ThII = hot fluid at position II (°C)
The subscript c stands for cold.
But also the next equation is valid:
q =U ⋅ A⋅LMTD (1.2)
With:
q = the heat transferred between the hot and the cold fluid (kW)
U = the overall heat transfer coefficient (kW/m2/°C)
A = the heat transferring surface (m2)
LMTD = the log mean temperature difference
LMTD for counter flow the following can be written down:
LMTD =(𝑇1−𝑡2)−(𝑇2−𝑡1)
𝑙𝑛(𝑇1−𝑡2)
(𝑇2−𝑡1)
(1.3)
Where:
T1= Hot fluid inlet temperature.
T2= Hot fluid outlet temperature.
t1 = Cold fluid inlet temperature.
t2= Cold fluid outlet temperature.
37
Another big factor in heat exchanger design is of course costs. The three main relevant factors
that have the greatest effect on size and therefore on costs are:
- Pressure drops
- Log Mean Temperature Difference
- Fouling factors
They will be discussed one by one.
Pressure drops – If unrealistically low allowable pressure drops are imposed, the designer is
forced to use lower fluid velocities to maintain the pressure drops limitations. Lower velocities
can result in a large heat exchanger. Higher pressure drops result in a smaller heat exchanger, but
a pumping device is needed to maintain this high pressure drop. This pumping device needs
energy and so operating costs must be calculated in the overall cost for the heat exchanger. Only
by considering the relationship between operating costs and investments can the economical
pressure drop be determined.
Log Mean Temperature Difference – The size, or surface, of a heat exchanger is inversely
proportional to the overall heat-transfer coefficient and the corrected LMTD. When looking at a
shell-and-tube heat exchanger a so-called ‘corrected LMTD’ must be used instead of the LMTD
presented earlier when the double-pipe heat exchanger was discussed. Assuming that reasonable
temperatures have been specified, a designer should try to maximize the product of the heat-
transfer rate and the LMTD.
Fouling factors – According to Garrett-Price (1985) “fouling is generally defined as the forming
of deposits on heat transfer surfaces, which interferes with heat transfer and/or fluid flow”. In
other words, by using a heat exchanger small layers of insulating material will be formed on the
heat transferring surfaces of that heat exchanger. The influence of this layer is two-sided:
1) The layer has a high thermal resistance, higher then any other part of the heat exchanger,
thereby increasing the total thermal resistance. This will decrease the amount of heat
transferred through the surfaces and reduces the efficiency of the heat exchanger.
2) The presence of a layer will decrease cross-sectional flow area of the medium. To
achieve the same throughput through this smaller area, there’s a bigger pressure drop
needed. Additional pumping is needed, increasing to total amount of energy added to the
system, decreasing the efficiency.
So fouling is a absolutely not-wanted phenomenon. The problem is that the heat exchanger that
doesn’t suffer from fouling still has to be invented. Furthermore fouling is extremely difficult to
describe. That’s why recent years there’s a lot of emphasis on the analysis of this problem.
38
A convenient order of calculations follow:
1. From T1, T2, t1 and t2 check the heat balance Q, using c at Tmean and tmean
Q = MC(T1 –T2 ) = mc(t2 - t1).
2. Calculate LMTD assuming counter flow.
3. Tc and tc : if liquid is neither a petroleum fraction nor a hydrocarbon then the calorific
temperature need not to be determine. If neither of liquid is very viscous at cold terminal
say not more than 1 centipoise, if the temperature difference is less than 50oF, then the
arithmetic mean temperature T1 and T2 and t1 and t2 can be used in place of Tc and tc for
evaluating the physical properties of liquids. For non-viscous liquid, 𝝋= (𝝁/𝝁w)0.14 may
be taken as 1.
Inner pipe.
4. Flow area, ap = 𝛑𝐃𝟐/4, ft2 .
5. Mass velocity, GP = (mass flow rate of liquid in inner pipe ./ ap) , lb/(hr.)(ft2).
6. Obtain 𝝁 at Tc or tc depending upon which flow through the inner pipe. 𝝁 , lb/(ft)(hr) =
centipoise x 2.42 . From D, ft (inner diameter of inner pipe.) and Gp , obtain Reynolds
number Rep =DGp / 𝝁 .
7. From fig. 24, in which JH = (hiD/k)(c𝝁/k)-1/3(𝝁/𝝁w)0.14 vs. DGp / 𝝁 , obtain JH.
8. From c Btu /(lb)(oF) , 𝝁 lb/(ft)(hr) , k Btu / (hr)(ft2)(oF/ft) , all obtained at Tc or tc ,
compute (c𝝁/k)1/3.
9. To obtain hi multiply JH by (k/D) (c𝝁/k)1/3 (𝝋 = 1) gives hi Btu/(hr)(ft2)(oF).
10. Convert hi to hio by using , hio = hi x ID/OD of inner pipe.
Annulus:
11. Flow area, aa = 𝛑(D22-D1
1) / 4, ft2.
39
Equivalent diameter De = 𝟒 𝒙 𝒇𝒍𝒐𝒘 𝒂𝒓𝒆𝒂
𝒘𝒆𝒕𝒕𝒆𝒅 𝒑𝒆𝒓𝒊𝒎𝒆𝒕𝒆𝒓 = (D2
2 – D12) / D1 , ft.
12. Mass velocity, Ga = (mass flow rate of liquid in annlus. / aa ) , lb/(hr.)(ft2).
13. Obtain 𝝁 at Tc or tc depending upon which flow through the inner pipe. 𝝁 , lb/(ft)(hr) =
centipoise x 2.42 . From De ft (inner diameter of inner pipe.) and Ga , obtain Reynolds
number Rep =DeGa / 𝝁 .
14. From fig. 24, in which JH = (hoD/k)(c𝝁/k)-1/3(𝝁/𝝁w)0.14 vs. DeGa / 𝝁, obtain JH.
15. From c Btu /(lb)(oF) , 𝝁 lb/(ft)(hr) , k Btu / (hr)(ft2)(oF/ft) , all obtained at Tc or tc ,
compute (c𝝁/k)1/3.
16. To obtain ho multiply JH by (k/De) (c𝝁/k)1/3 (𝝋 = 1) gives ho Btu/(hr)(ft2)(oF).