Putting Putting the the Power Power to to Work. Work. AN INTRODUCTION TO TURBODRILLS
Nov 28, 2015
Putting Putting
thethe
PowerPower
to to Work.Work.
AN INTRODUCTION TO TURBODRILLS
Brief Turbodrill History & Background
•First applied to Drilling in USSR in 1924
•First licensed in the West in 1956 (Neyrpic)
•Turbodrills built by Neyrfor, Preussag, Dresser, Christensen, and others………..but Neyrfor dominate market
•Neyrfor introduce first Oilfield Steerable Drilling System in 1982
•Weir (Scottish Engineering Company) buy Neyrfor in 1991
•Smith International buy Neyrfor in 2002
Downhole Motor Basic Principles
SOME SIMPLE PHYSICS & FACTS THAT APPLY TO ALL HYDRAULIC MOTORS (i.e. PDM’s & TURBODRILLS)
•Hydraulic Motors transform hydraulic energy into mechanical energy
•You DON’T get more power out than you put in!
•Power out is generally around 55 – 65 % of power in
•Efficiency, and maintaining efficiency is main factor in delivering performance
•Improving Efficiency by design and material science is the key to improving Performance & Reliability
Downhole Motor Basic Principles
•Mechanical Horsepower = (Speed x Torque) / 5252
•Hydraulic Horsepower = (Pressure Drop x Flow) / 1714
•Motor Horsepower = Hydraulic Horsepower x Efficiency
HORSEPOWER CALCULATION FOR ANY DOWNHOLE MOTOR
(IMPERIAL UNITS)
Turbodrill / PDM Comparison
What’s the difference?
6-3/4” M2PXL (2:3 Lobe)
BHI Quoted Figures
@ 530 gpm with 1160 psi differential pressure
With a 60% efficiency gives a max of 215 HP output
In reality differential pressure more likely to be around 400 – 600 psi (usually less when sliding)
So with a 60% efficiency and 600 psi differential pressure the max HP output = 111
NB. Efficiency with PDM’s deteriorates rapidly with operating hours
Turbodrill / PDM Comparison
Sii Neyrfor 6-5/8” FBS T1 MKII Turbodrill
@ 530 gpm will give 1676 psi (with 10ppg mud)
With a 55% efficiency gives a max of 285 HP output
So 30% + more power than PDM assuming a PDM differential pressure of 1160 psi
If actual PDM differential is only 600 psi (i.e.more like reality)……..then the Turbodrill offers 150% + more Horsepower!!
NB. Efficiency with Turbodrills deteriorates very slowly, typically having only very slight reduction even after several hundred hours
Turbodrill / PDM Comparison
Moving Air
Very Basic Aero Foil Theory
Turbodrill Basic Characteristics
LIFT (i.e. “Power”) is created by Differential Pressure
Higher Pressure beneath the wing & Lower Pressure above
HYDRAULIC POWER IN
Axial Thrust
Rotation
TorqueRotation
FIXED
BLADES
(i.e.Flow x Pressure)
Turbodrill Basic Characteristics
FIXED
BLADES
MOVING
BLADES
0
0.25
0.5
0.75
1
0 0.5 1
Speed
To
rqu
e /
Po
wer
Power
Torque
Nominal Speed Runaway SpeedStall
Turbodrill Basic Characteristics
Torque / Speed / Power Relationship
Standard Turbodrill Components
Conventional T3 (3 Motor Section) Turbodrill
Overall length could be 70+ ft (dependent on tool size i.e. OD)
Downward
Thrust
Mud
Flow
Rotor Blading
Disk
Stator Blading
DiskStator
Blading Disk
Rotor Blading
Disk
Assembly makes up
One Motor Stage
Motor Section
Turbine Body
Turbine Shaft
Turbine Blading Disc Arrangement
Standard Turbodrill Components
Turbine Body
Moving Disc
Fixed Disc
Moving Disc
Spacer Front Bearing
Labyrinth
Thrust Bearing
Flexible Shaft
Bent Housing
Front Bearing Stabiliser
Bit Box Stabiliser
Turbine Elastomer Axial Bearing Arrangement
Standard Turbodrill Components
Turbodrill Design Remit (1990’s)
Reduce Overall Tool length Closer to MWD / LWD Tools
Improve Efficiency Higher Power Output & Reliability
Incorporate Bent Housing Apply benefits to DD Applications
Provide Pressure Profile Enable Positive Feedback to Driller
Address Hole Quality Issues Eliminate Hole Spiralling
REQUIREMENT REASON
Turbodrill Evolution
Turbine Blade Design
essure
Nominal Pressure
Drilling Range
Turb
ine
Pre
ssur
e D
rop
Torq
ue
Bit Speed
Turbodrill EvolutionPressure Profile Blades
Turbodrill Evolution
PDC Bearings Races
Dramatic Improvement in Efficiency & Reliability!!
Thrust >110,000 Lbs
(With Standard 9-1/2” T3(Mk1), pumping 750 Gpm)
W.O.B. ± 30,000 Lbs
80,000 Lbs
Turbodrill EvolutionAXIAL THRUST
Around 3% of Flow exits to Annulus or with TSH tools (Hollow Shaft) is diverted down centre of shaft and passes into Bearing SectionTurbine
Shaft
Pressure Equalising Leakage Flow
Micro Annulus
Balance Drum
Housing
Main Mud Flow into Turbodrill
Balance Drum Assembly
Motor Section
Main Flow to Motor Section
Turbodrill Evolution
Turbine Thrust Balance Drum
Turbodrill EvolutionTurbine Thrust Balance Drum (TS B)
Tur
bine
Bla
de
Hyd
raul
ic D
iam
eter
‘Db’
Bal
ance
Dru
m
Dia
met
er ‘D
d’
Thrust area for blades & Shaft
Thrust area for Balance Drum
Resultant Thrust area
FLOW
THRUSTTHRUST
6-5/8” : Thrust reduced by 50%
9-1/2” : Thrust reduced by 70%
THRUST EFFECTS?
NB. For 4-3/4” & smaller tools Balance Drum not required as thrust is much less & can be balanced by WOB.
Metallic Radial Bearings
Lower Radial Bearing
Have been successfully run
with BHST in excess of
260°C
LaserCarb™coating (Sleeve)
WallCarb™lining (Bush)
Turbodrill Evolution
Turbodrill Evolution
Flexible Titanium Shaft
Adjustable Bent Housing
Thrust Balance Drum
FBS Turbodrill Typical Layout
Turbine Stages
Interchangeable Stabiliser
Flexible Titanium Shaft
PDC Thrust Bearings
Lower Bearing Stabiliser
Lower Radial Bearing
Pin-Ended Shaft
Box Connection Bit With Integral Turbine Sleeve
Bent Housing
Single Motor Section
Turbodrill Evolution
Current FBS Turbodrill Tool Sizes
Turbodrill Evolution
2-7/8” 3.25 – 4.0”
3-3/8” 3.75 – 5.375”
4-3/4” 5.625 – 6.75”
6-5/8” 7.625 – 9.875”
9-1/2” 12.0 – 17.5”
TOOL SIZE HOLE SIZE
Steerable Turbodrills
Stabilisation
Varying Interchangeable “Mid-Point” Stabiliser size allows accurate control of inclination (Build / Hold / Drop) in Rotary Mode.
String Stabiliser directly on top of Turbine can also be sized to help “fine tune” the assembly
Lower Bearing Stabiliser (Generally 1/16 – 1/8” UG)
Adjustable Bent Housing
Long Gauge Box Connection Bit
Steerable Turbodrills
Reactive Torque
TurbodrillPDM
Hole QualityWhy is Hole Quality important?
# PROVEN TO BE MAJOR FACTOR IN ABILITY TO SLIDE #
ADDITIONALLY………………
•Ensures good transmission of WOB
•Reduces Torque & Drag
•Facilitates better Hole Cleaning
•Helps to reduce Stuck Pipe Incidents
•Allows easier running of Logging Tools
•Provides better quality Logging data (Pad based tools)
•Allows easier running of Casing / Liner / Core Barrels etc.
•Allows easier running of Completion Equipment
Basically Better Overall Drilling Efficiency
Hole Quality
Unstabilised Vs. Stabilised
Unstabilised (Slick) PDM can allow excessive lateral movement of the bit which can lead to very poor hole quality & spiralling
Stabilised Turbodrill with Long Gauge Box Connection Bit minimises lateral movement resulting in superior hole quality
and minimal risk of problematic spiralling
LONG GAUGE PIN CONNECTION.
NEAR BIT STABILISER. BOTTOM BEARING
STABILISERBOX END SHAFT
LONG GAUGE PIN CONNECTION.
SHORT GAUGE PIN CONNECTION
BOX END SHAFT
BIT BOXSTABILISER
BOTTOM BEARINGSTABILISER
BOTTOM BEARINGSTABILISER
BOX-UPLONG GAUGE BIT.
BOTTOM BEARINGSTABILISER
Hole Quality
Bit “Overhang” Configurations
Hole Quality
Spiralling
Ultrasonic Image & Calliper Log Mechanics of BHA in Spiral Hole
RESULT: Severe Torque & Drag and possible damage to BHA and String in Rotary Mode
Or Constant “Hanging Up” when Sliding!
Hole Quality
Hole Spiralling
Turbine with Bit Box Stabiliser (NEW)
Turbine with Box-Up Bit The Best Solution to combat Hole Spiralling
Turbine with what’s left of Bit Box Stabiliser Showing Effect of Spiralling in an Abrasive Formation
MAINTAINING VERTICALITY
•Drilling with Speed & Power – Low WOB Requirement
•Intermediate Stabiliser dictates Inclination Trend
Eg. In 8-1/2” Hole
8-7/16” LBS x 8-7/16” Intermediate Stab x 8-1/2” SS or RR
Will drop inclination or maintain verticality
AZIMUTH
0 100 200 300
INCLINATION
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600
1700
1800
1900
2000
2100
2200
2300
2400
2500
2600
2700
2800
2900
3000
0 1 2 3 4 5
DLS
0 1 2 3 4 5
MAINTAINING VERTICALITY
TURBINE
POWER V
OPERATOR: Suncor Energy
COUNTRY: Canada
WELL: Panther 14-25
HOLE SIZE: 12 ¼”
TURBINE TYPE: 9 ½” T1B
Turbine Assembly
Maintained Inclination between 0 & 0.5 Deg. Over 1050 meters
MINIMISING VIBRATION
Vibration level Vibration level w/Turbodrillw/Turbodrill
Vibration level Vibration level w/PDMw/PDM
Global Turbine Mean Time Between Failure(All Tools 1990 – August 2005)
•Total Number Runs 5,808
•Total Footage Drilled 3,697,457
•Total Drilling Hours 322,956
•Total Operating Hours 413,259
•Total Number Failures 148
•MTBF 2,792 Hours
•MTBF % 2.55%
BHA
Bit Wear
Company Request
Core PointHole Problems
LIHLogging
MWD
TD Section
Turbine
WashoutOthers
Penetration Rate
Rig RquipmentBOP Test
Build IntervalApprox 3°/100’ Build IntervalApprox 3°/100’
Geo-SteeredInterval
Geo-SteeredInterval
8 ½” Hole 8 ½” Hole
Cromer Knoll
Limestone
Cromer Knoll
Limestone
SkaggerakSandstone Reservoir
SkaggerakSandstone Reservoir
BP ETAP Project – North Sea – Marnock Field
8-1/2” Intervals to be drilled from + 65º, landed horizontal and geo-steered to TD
Wells were to be completed by running sand screens
• Well 22/24a-A03
• Short 1” Gauge PDC Bits on PDM for Build
• Drilled to TD in 2 runs
• Total of 3,642 ft at average of 36.4 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A03
• Short 1” Gauge PDC Bits on PDM for Build
• Drilled to TD in 2 runs
• Total of 3,642 ft at average of 36.4 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A03z
• Short 1” Gauge PDC Bits on PDM for Build
• Drilled to TD in 2 runs
• Total of 3,976 ft at average of 28.7 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A03z
• Short 1” Gauge PDC Bits on PDM for Build
• Drilled to TD in 2 runs
• Total of 3,976 ft at average of 28.7 ft/hr
• Unable to run sand screens to bottom due to hole condition• Unable to run sand screens to bottom due to hole condition
• Unable to run sand screens to bottom due to condition of hole• Unable to run sand screens to bottom due to condition of hole
Initial Two Wells Drilled With PDM’s
• Well 22/24a-A02 - Drilled Build & Horizontal in One Run to TD
• Total of 3,862 ft turbine drilled at average of 29.3 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A02 - Drilled Build & Horizontal in One Run to TD
• Total of 3,862 ft turbine drilled at average of 29.3 ft/hr
• Sand screens run on all wells with no problems!• Sand screens run on all wells with no problems!
• Well 22/24a-A04z - Open Hole Sidetrack
• Total of 1,961 ft turbine drilled at average of 26.7 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A04z - Open Hole Sidetrack
• Total of 1,961 ft turbine drilled at average of 26.7 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A01zz - Sidetrack One Run to TD
• Total of 1,827 ft turbine drilled at average of 42 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A01zz - Sidetrack One Run to TD
• Total of 1,827 ft turbine drilled at average of 42 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A04 - Sidetrack One Run to TD
• Total of 1,010 ft turbine drilled at average of 20.2 ft/hr
• Well 22/24a-A04 - Sidetrack One Run to TD
• Total of 1,010 ft turbine drilled at average of 20.2 ft/hr
Then…..6-5/8” FBS Steerable Turbine + Box Up PDC Bits
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
JULY15-97A JUL15-15AST1 J15-95 J 15-98
0.0
5.0
10.0
15.0
20.0
25.0
30.0
35.0
FTG ROP av.
TD176
S88H
VP
AR445
TD19H
M73BP
M65BP
EHP51
M65
0.0 50.0 100.0 150.0 200.0 250.0
J ULY15-97A
J UL15-15AST1
J 15-95
J 15-98
TD19H M73BP M65BP
EHP51 M65
TD176 AR445
S88HVP $ 99.7
$ 202.8
$245.7
$ 180.1
Drilled shoe and 2742 ft vertically and then kicked off and built angle to 42º in single run!
New Field Record in 12-1/4” Hole For Gupco In Egypt
9-1/2” FBS Steerable Turbine with Smith Bits S88BHVPX PDC Bit
4545 ft at 33.6 ft/hr
Lowest 12-1/4” CPF in Field
S88BHVPX
TYPICAL UBD SIDETRACK APPLICATIONS
A 4-3/4” TS1(Mk3) Steerable Turbodrill with 1.25° bend completed an open-hole ST with an impregnated diamond bit in 6” hole. The Turbodrill made 3,902 ft in horizontal mode, first drilling 754 Ft then pulling back for the ST before drilling another 3,148 Ft to TD.
Steered footage = 2,647 Ft (68%) – on the ST run only, giving excellent steering & drilling performance along a very demanding well profile. Overall ROP for job = 37.3 Ft/hr
Total Turbodrill circulation time = 262 hours.
Sidetracking: Low-head application-1.25° Bend with typical UBD steerable tool
Location : UK S-North-Sea Depth In : 19,200 Ft Formation : Rotliegendes SST Diamond Bit : S280 G89YMud Type : WBM Mud Weight : 8.6 ppgFlow : 220 Gpm WOB : 2-12 KlbsBHP : 1600 Psi Surface press. : 3,400 Psi
COILED TUBING + UNDERBALANCED DRILLING APPLICATION
A 3-3/8” T2(Mk2) Steerable Turbodrill was used on 2” Coiled Tubing to complete a well extension in 3-7/8” hole: in a live, producing UBD well.
519 Feet of new hole was drilled at an average ROP of >25 Ft/hr With all objectives being met.
World First: steerable Turbodrill on Coiled Tubing- In live, producing UBD well
Location : Norway Depth In : 12,800 Ft Formation : MudST/ SST Diamond Bit : D 72 / 901-UMud Type : Brine Mud Weight : 8.6 ppgFlow : 90 Gpm WOB : 1-3 KlbsBHP: ± 700 psi Surface pressure: 3,900 psi
N.B.: ROP was >x 2.5 best PDM run (same Formations & TVD)
BHT was 167° C
6-5/8” Steerable Turbine Achievement
Statfjord Field Norway
Section Drilled in Single Run
Best Offset – 4 Runs with PDM
Dropped & Built from 22.5° - 90°
Turned from 158° - 30°
Cut 9.5 Days from AFE
WORLD RECORD
A 4-3/4” TS1XL(Mk3) Steerable Turbodrill powered a Smith MA32CTPX PDC bit to a new world footage record for a single run in 6” hole. The Turbodrill made 4,487 Ft in a horizontal well for Shell in the Southern Sector of the North sea. The well was drilled Low-head with Base Oil, steering 1,345 Ft (30%) from 55° to 88°.
Average ROP was 31.6 Ft/hr.
Total Turbodrill circulating time = 198 hours
10 days rig time saved.
4 ¾” TS1XL sets World PDC Record:
Depth In : 8,911 Ft Depth Out : 13,398 Ft
Footage : 4,487 Ft Average ROP : 31.6 Ft/hr
Rotated : 3,142 Ft (70%) Steered : 1,345 Ft (30%)
– longest 6” PDC run
MA 32 CTPX
4-3/4” FBS T1-MK2 COMPLETES THE LONGEST RUN EVER IN THE CAMBRIAN RA IN ALGERIA
On a recent Horizontal well for Sonahess a 4-3/4” FBS T1-Mk2 Turbodrill in association with a 6” impregnated bit drilled 960 m of Cambrian Ra in one run on El Agreb field with an average ROP of 4.2 m/hr.
Best PDM performance in the Cambrian Ra was 588 m drilled at 2.9 m/hr with a high speed motor
NEW RECORD IN ALGERIA FOR TURBODRILL - 960M DRILLED IN ONE RUN
Additionally: Drilled out 7” Liner Equipment and completed final build up to Horizontal in same single run!
WORLD RECORD
A 4-3/4” TS1XL Steerable Turbodrill powered a Smith KGR50CTPXX impregnated diamond bit to a new world record footage for a single run in 6” hole. The Turbodrill made 6,478 ft in a horizontal well for Shell Expro in the Southern Sector of the North sea and beat the previous Sii Neyrfor record by 1,333 ft.
Total Turbodrill circulating time = 308 hours
4 ¾” TS1XL sets World Record in S.North Sea:
Depth In : 10,676 Ft Depth Out : 17,154 Ft
Footage : 6,478 Ft Average ROP : 33.1 Ft/hr
Rotated : 5,224 Ft (81%) Steered : 1,254 Ft (19%)
TURBODRILLING SUMMARY
Features Benefits High Power Output Capability Maximise ROP
All Metallic Construction Reliability with no Heat Constraints
Different Blade Types Adaptability to suit the Application
Modular Units (Bearings/Motors/Stabs) Rig-Site Interchangeable
Interchangeable “mid-point” Stabiliser Predictable Rotary Trends
Pin-Ended Shafts - Box-Up Bits Proven Hole Quality / Steerability
Bit Choice to suit Formation Not the Motor Minimal trade off in sliding ROP
Exceptionally Low Vibration Levels Protects Bit, BHA, MWD etc.
RELIABLE DOWNHOLE POWER – WHERE & WHEN YOU WANT IT!