www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Aug 20, 2015
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Today’s workshop is designed to stretch thinking using specific insights as s9mulus to change views
Morning A=ernoon
S9mulate Priori9ze Challenge Focus and Next Steps
Clear Outputs Informed Inputs
External S9mulus
Reflect & Review
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
During the day we will cover four key areas and discuss a number of service innova9on models
1. Context for Service Innova2on: § History, leading examples and evolving framework of progress
2. Case Studies : § Examples of successful service innova9on to discuss and explore
3. Business Impact: § Discussion of which examples have greatest resonance and impact
4. Tools to Rethink Service Innova2on: § Four approaches for iden9fy game-‐changing service concepts
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
These four phases of learning are used during the day to build up knowledge, insight and applica9on
Morning A=ernoon
S9mulate Priori9ze Challenge Focus and Next Steps
Clear Outputs Informed Inputs
External S9mulus
Reflect & Review
1: Context
2: Case Studies
3: Business Impact
4: Tools
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
NEXT GENERATION SERVICE INNOVATION: THE CONTEXT FOR SERVICE INNOVATION
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
The first session sets the scene for service innova9on, its scope, its development and its future poten9al
Recogni9on of Service
Innova9on
• Inclusion of SI in R&D • Three Key Areas: • New service development
• Improved service processes
• Innova9on in service firms
Different Dimensions
• The Service Concept • The Client Interface • The Delivery System • Technology Op9ons • Service Dominant Logic
Next Genera9on Service
Innova9on
• Co-‐crea9on • Web 2.0 enabled • New Business Models • New Value Shi=s
Core Service Innova9on Focus is on “doing be*er things and doing things be*er”
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Service innova9on as a specific focus has now been on the scene in different views for over twenty years
Three types of service innova2on: Ian Miles -‐ Univ. of Manchester (1993)
§ New service development § New or improved service products – Axel Johne and Chris Storey etc
§ Improved service processes § New or improved ways of designing or delivering services
§ Innova2on in service firms § Organisa9onal innova9on -‐ processes and management of innova9on
Key components of service innova2on: TEKES § Replicable elements § Benefit to producer and customer § Changes to customer interface, distribu9on, forms of opera9on etc.
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
In recent years several others in have sought to classify the key dimensions of service innova9on
Four Dimensions of Service Innova2on: Den Hertog (2007) § The Service Concept
e.g. new value proposi9on, new retail format § The Client Interface
e.g. par9cipa9on of customers, changes in roles § The Delivery System
e.g. linkage between provider and customer, job roles § Technology Op2ons
e.g. more effec9ve informa9on processing, smart communica9ons Others views to note: Henry Chesbrough, Tony Ulwick.
Service Innova9on Focus is on “doing be*er things and doing things be*er”
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Service Dominant Logic is a good way of thinking about the change adopted by a some organisa9ons
Goods Dominant Logic Service Dominant Logic
Focus Goods Services
Experience Tangible Intangible
Resources Operand Operant
Informa9on Asymmetric Symmetric
Dialogue Propaganda Conversa9on
Value Crea9on Value Added Value Proposi9on
Contracts Transac9onal Rela9onal
Incen9ve Profit Maximisa9on Financial Feedback
Leading Examples: Nike, Apple, IBM, Xerox, GE, MasterCard, Cargill, Starbucks Source: Lusch R. F., Vargo S. L. and Malter A.J., Taking a Leadership Role in Global Marke9ng Management, Organiza9onal Dynamics, Vol. 35, No 3, pp. 264-‐278, 2006
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Over the past years, the discipline of service design and innova9on has evolved into the mainstream
Different specialist agencies propose their own views of the service design process Source: LiveWork
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Varied models also exist for the overall approach to service innova9on development and thinking
Many look at key components: § Process § Organisa9on § Features of Product § Nature of Product § Delivery of Product § Regula9on § Marke9ng § Role of Consumer
Big Focus on “Customers in context” Example Source: Engine
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
The importance of crea9ng, defining and delivering “great customer experiences” has become key
Great Customer Experiences:
§ Strongly reflect the customer’s iden9ty § Sa9sfy our higher objec9ves § Leave nothing to chance § Set and meet expecta9ons § Are effortless § Are stress free § Indulge the senses § Are socially engaging § Put the customer in control § Consider the emo9ons
Source: Watkinson, M., The Ten Principles Behind Great Customer Experiences, FT / Pearson, 2013
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
We can now clearly see the emergence of a new phase of ‘next genera9on’ service innova9on
• Developed in closer partnership with others especially including customers
Co-‐crea2on
• Take advantage of interac9vity, social networks and shi= towards seman9c web
Web 2.0
• Adopt and adapt new mechanisms for tangible and intangible value crea9on
New Business Models
• Underpinned by changes in how people and organiza9ons wish to share value
New Value ShiYs
The emerging successes are based on four key themes:
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Successful service innova9on only occurs when four key elements are all present, aligned and balanced
Successful Service
Innova2on
Unique Value
Proposi2on
Improved Delivery Approach
Growing Emerging Trend
Enhanced Customer Experience
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Each of these elements are sources of differen9a9on that collec9vely bring together the winning formula
Successful Service
Innova2on
Unique Value
Proposi2on
Improved Delivery Approach
Growing Emerging Trend
Enhanced Customer Experience
Unique Value Proposi2on: • Delivers customers clear value • Provides a compelling story • Can be delivered profitably
Improved Delivery Approach: • Does things beoer • More efficient than exis9ng • Highly effec9ve plaqorm
Enhanced Customer Experience: • Improves customer’s life • Simple & engaging touch-‐points • Transparent customer journey
Growing Emerging Trend: • Taps into evident shi= in market • Sustainable growing issue • Global / regional relevance
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Ul9mately, successful service innova9on changes expecta9ons of what can be repeatedly delivered
Service Innova9on Focus is on “doing be*er things and doing things be*er”
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
NEXT GENERATION SERVICE INNOVATION: CASE STUDIES
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
9 ini9al case studies provide a wide range of different s9mulus around successful service innova9on today
§ Efficiently delivering an ever changing porqolio
§ Reconfiguring a product into a service
§ Mass personalisa9on at scale
§ Using data to get close to customers
§ Redefining expecta9ons of travel
§ Scaling without constraints
§ Delivering a wide and dis9nc9ve porqolio of needs
§ Extending global adver9sing reach
§ Repackaging the concert value proposi9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
8 other case studies highlight some next genera9on service models that are now emerging and growing
§ Maximizing fixed asset u9liza9on
§ Reinven9ng the healthcare business model
§ Providing banking access at the booom of the pyramid
§ Pay as you drive insurance
§ Crowd funding public services
§ Peer-‐to-‐peer finance
§ Co-‐created investment funds
§ Real-‐9me dynamic pricing of 9ckets
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Inditex, the worlds best retailer, supports high levels of autonomy, fast decisions and con9nuous change
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
For Inditex, rapid, con9nuous change of merchandise results in high customer demand and very low waste
4 x Average store visits per year (Innova2on)
Fast Fashion
(Proposi2on)
Global 48hr
Logis2cs (Delivery)
Curated Choice (Trend)
Always Something
New (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Rolls-‐Royce has reconfigured a high tech product and support rela9onship into a long term service contract
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Rolls-‐Royce’s ‘power by the hour’ Total Care service has grown to represent over 70% of group revenues
Redefined Rela2onship (Innova2on)
Pay only for use
(Proposi2on)
24/7 Remote
Monitoring (Delivery)
Access not Ownership
(Trend)
Guaranteed Availability (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Nike has used Nike ID as a plaqorm for giving customers apparent personalisa9on at scale
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Nike ID has become the benchmark for mass customisa9on services around core products
Curated Op2ons (Innova2on)
Configure Your Own (Proposi2on)
Direct to Home (Delivery)
Mass Customis-‐a2on (Trend)
Unique Personal Products (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Amazon is a massively efficient business delivering customer sa9sfac9on via proprietary technology
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Amazon uses its data exper9se to give customers a huge range of credible personal recommenda9ons
Personal Matching (Innova2on)
Everything fast and cheap
(Proposi2on)
Integrated Logis2cs (Delivery)
Real-‐2me Analy2cs (Trend)
Simple and Ubiquitous (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Under Singapore Airline’s ownership, Virgin Atlan9c has consistently reinvented the flying experience
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Virgin Atlan9c’s crea9on of Upper Class and Premium Economy changed the mass accessible experience
Reinvent Status Quo (Innova2on)
Create New
Segments (Proposi2on)
Challenger Posi2oning (Delivery)
Flexible Spaces (Trend)
Radical Seamless Design
(Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Bhar9 Airtel’s extreme outsourcing business model enabled it to scale quickly and it is now the world #3
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
By partnering on everything but the core customer rela9onship, Airtel has been able to grow quicker
Scaling without Legacy
(Innova2on)
The Latest at Low Cost
(Proposi2on)
Global Partners (Delivery)
Pervasive Mobile (Trend)
Simple and Fast Access
(Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Starwood drives high loyalty by efficiently delivering consistent and memorable guest experiences
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Starwood Hotels has created mul9ple leading but separate branded experiences with global resonance
Dis2nc2ve Branded
Experiences (Innova2on)
Mul2-‐brand
Pordolio (Proposi2on)
Consistent Franchise (Delivery)
Global Connec2vity
(Trend)
Memorable Standards (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Google excels at par9cipa9ve product development that supports incessant adjacent sector disrup9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Google has been innova9ng across mul9ple sectors while building the world most connected ad agency
Growing Reach and Relevance (Innova2on)
Beeer Informa2on (Proposi2on)
Connected Data
(Delivery)
Credible Sources (Trend)
Beta based Innova2on (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Live Na9on has aligned around change in its industry and fully repackaged the concert value proposi9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
While the cost to access music has declined, Live Na9on has premiumised the mass live experience
360 Wrap Star Deals (Innova2on)
Access to the Top Acts
(Proposi2on)
Exclusive Partners (Delivery)
Live Experiences
(Trend)
Seamless Integra2on (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Zipcar brings vehicle affordable access by the hour into the neighbourhood and changes rental models
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
By shi=ing both pricing and access models, Zipcar is making flexible access more popular than ownership
Replace Urban Car Ownership (Innova2on)
Flexible Access
(Proposi2on)
Availability Guarantee (Delivery)
Access not Ownership
(Trend)
Easy and Local
(Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Narayana Hrundayalaya leads in efficient surgery through integrated process and business innova9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
As a centre of exper9se Naranaya Hrundayalaya is the place to go for doctors and pa9ents globally
Systema2c Factory
(Innova2on)
Best for Less
(Proposi2on)
Op2mised Process (Delivery)
Medical Tourism (Trend)
Fast and Efficient (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Across Africa M-‐Pesa has proven that money transfer via mobile is viable at the booom of the pyramid
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
M-‐Pesa is scaling fast as a trusted plaqorm with momentum building to a wider porqolio and reach
Step change for the
Unbanked (Innova2on)
Low Cost Transfer
(Proposi2on)
Agent Networks (Delivery)
PervasiveMobile (Trend)
Simple and
Trusted (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
AA Drivesafe has made pay as you drive insurance accessible through rewarding behaviour change
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Improving on previous models AA Drivesafe provides transparent cheaper car insurance for safer drivers
Cheaper insurance for safe drivers
(Innova2on)
Visible Choice
(Proposi2on)
Partner with
Networks (Delivery)
Real Time Tracking (Trend)
Clear Payback (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Ci9zinvestor is bringing direct local benefit to those wishing to invest in social innova9on and ac9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
By matching tangible needs to investors Ci9zinvestor is efficiently by-‐passing local government ac9vi9es
Transparent Marketplace (Innova2on)
Invest in Local
(Proposi2on)
Collec2ve Ac2on (Delivery)
Crowd-‐funding (Trend)
Social Impact
(Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Zopa is a pioneer in peer-‐to-‐peer banking that shares efficiencies with both savers and those seeking loans
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
By crea9ng a more efficient and trusted system Zopa and co have the poten9al to disrupt the mainstream
Community Bond Market
(Innova2on)
Beeer Rates
(Proposi2on)
Using Dispersed Scale
(Delivery)
Power of Networks
(Trend)
Simple and
Trusted (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Mo9f is demys9fying the fund management arena by giving a plaqorm to those with the best ideas
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Investors can put their money behind the best concepts that Mo9f makes clear to everyone
Demys2fying Fund
Management (Innova2on)
Access High Performers (Proposi2on)
Credible Investment Engine (Delivery)
ShiY in Trust (Trend)
Informed Inves2ng (Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Qcue’s approach to real-‐9me dynamic pricing of 9ckets is helping improve the market efficiency
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
In providing transparency on value op9ons, Qcue helps all key event players maximise their revenues
Accurate Ticket Pricing
(Innova2on)
Op2mise Yield
(Proposi2on)
Enabling SoYware (Delivery)
Dynamic Pricing (Trend)
Real-‐2me Insight
(Experience)
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Across these ‘next genera9on’ service innova9ons, the four key themes are all evident and significant
• Developed in closer partnership with others especially including customers
Co-‐crea2on
• Take advantage of interac9vity, social networks and shi= towards seman9c web
Web 2.0
• Adopt and adapt new mechanisms for tangible and intangible value crea9on
New Business Models
• Underpinned by changes in how people and organiza9ons wish to share value
New Value ShiYs
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
NEXT GENERATION SERVICE INNOVATION: BUSINESS IMPACT
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
This third session uses the case studies so that you see which have greatest relevance for your business
The aim of this session is four-‐fold:
§ Allow you to consider the case studies more
§ Encourage you to think of what lessons they may have for you
§ Map those which highest poten9al impact and relevance
§ Select and discuss the few key case studies that have greatest insight
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
First use your case study cards and sort them by their poten9al impact to the market in which you operate
Increasing poten2al impact to your market
Low High
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Now thinking more specifically about your business, raise and lower the cards to sort them by relevance
Increasing poten
2al relevan
ce to
you
r business
Low
High
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Your matrix should now clearly highlight those case studies from which you think there is most to learn
High Relevance / Low Poten9al
Impact
High Relevance /
High Poten9al Impact
Low Relevance / Low Impact
Low Relevance /
High Poten9al Impact
Example outcome:
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
NEXT GENERATION SERVICE INNOVATION: TOOLS TO RETHINK SERVICE INNOVATION
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
This final session pilots four different tools to help iden9fy game-‐changing service concepts
§ Parallel View – What if X, Y or Z were running our business § Developing scenarios of top case study examples taking control § Good at highligh9ng different cultural and strategic priori9es
§ Value Innova2on and Blue Ocean Strategy § Using this well regarded approach to reconfigure value proposi9ons § Provides a clear approach for refocusing on the customer
§ Lean Thinking § Taking out what does not add value and reusing freed resources § Very good at helping firms seeing how they can ‘do things beoer’
§ Destroy Your Own Business § Approach for rethinking how to create value if free of legacy § Excellent way of s9mula9ng people around ‘doing beoer things’
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Parallel Views help us think about how other brands would deliver a beoer / different service experience
§ Principle based on looking at issue through other’s eyes
§ Can be used for whole new service crea2on or experience innova2on
§ Works well if choosing organisa2ons both in your sector and outside
§ Best if you push the boundaries and go for extremes
§ Focus on revolu2onary changes that other brands could do
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Parallel Views – Approach Overview
Select
• Choose two different brands known for innova9on in service experience
Suspend
• Ignore your exis9ng and legacy ways of service delivery in your market
Change
• Discuss how the other brands could deliver a beoer experience
Detail
• Spell out the key components of the new service innova9on
Impact
• Discuss which of these could be achieved by your business and how
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Value innova9on, is the simultaneous pursuit of differen9a9on and low cost, crea9ng a leap in value
§ This is the cornerstone of ‘blue ocean strategy’ in crea2ng value for both buyers and the company:
§ Value to buyers comes from the offering’s u9lity minus its price
§ Value to the company is generated from the offering’s price minus its cost
§ So, value innova2on is achieved only when the whole system of u9lity, price, and cost is aligned.
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
One of the earliest successful uses of Value Innova9on thinking was for Formule 1 hotels
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Value Innova9on – Approach Overview
§ Iden2fy the key factors on the service delivery for customer and supplier § Plot and map a couple of current leading offers as curves
§ Break the value-‐cost tradeoff by answering the following ques2ons:
1. What factors can be eliminated that the industry has taken for granted? 2. What factors can be reduced well below the industry’s standard? 3. What factors can be raised well above the industry’s standard? 4. What factors can be created that the industry has never offered?
§ Redraw the value curve of a new service innova2on that changes the game
§ Discuss the new value proposi2on and how to delivery it effec2vely
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Lean Thinking first evolved as a technique used in manufacturing but is now applied to many areas
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
There are five overriding principles to Lean Thinking that have helped many reinvent their service delivery Iden2fy Customers and Specify Value § Only a frac9on of total effort in any organisa9on adds value for the end customer § Need to clearly define Value for a service from the end customer’s perspec9ve § All the non value ac9vi9es -‐ or waste -‐ can be targeted for removal Iden2fy and Map the Value Stream § The Value Stream is the end-‐to-‐end ac9vi9es across the firm delivering the service. § Understand what your customer wants and how you are delivering that to them. Create Flow by Elimina2ng Waste § When you map the Value Stream you will find less than half of ac9vi9es add value. § Elimina9ng this waste ensures that your service “flows” beoer to the customer. Respond to Customer Pull § See the customer demand and then create your process to respond to this. § Produce only what the customer wants when the customer wants it. Pursue Perfec2on § Radically reorganising individual process steps to eliminate waste. § Aim for perfec9on, where every ac9on adds value for the end customer.
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Lean Thinking – Approach Overview
Source: Peter Hines, Lean Enterprise Research Centre, Cardiff Business School
Iden9fy Value
Map the Value Stream
Create Flow
Establish Pull
Seek Perfec9on
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg
Destroy Your Own Business was an approach to radical rethinking that grew out of GE in 2000
Back in 2000 GE created the destroy-‐your-‐business exercise § It forced every company business unit to benchmark compe9tors, develop
a Web-‐based business plan to erode its own customer base and then change its own business opera9ons to respond to the threat.
Since then the approach has evolved into a co-‐crea2on experience § Working with customers to co-‐define new ways of mee9ng new needs
Core principle is well proven: § If you are freed from exis9ng prac9ce and assets, how would you use new
approaches available today to take #1 spot in your sector? § What can your exis9ng business do to take advantage of this by innova9ng
the service proposi9on to customers?
www.growthchampions.org www.trainingvision.com.sg