Top Banner
News media content personalization: Converged, commodified, and contracted out ICA Annual Conference, Fukuoka, Japan, 9-13 June 2016 Neil Thurman [email protected] @neilthurman
26

News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Jul 06, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

News media content personalization: Converged, commodified, and contracted out

ICA Annual Conference, Fukuoka, Japan, 9-13 June 2016

Neil [email protected] @neilthurman

Page 2: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017

(January 2015)

Page 3: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 n=23,557 (average n=1,963)

Starting point for online news (January 2015)

Page 4: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)
Page 5: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

“the big difference is that is a more personalized experience”

Robin Pembrooke, general manager of news products at BBC Future Media (Kelion, 2015).

Page 7: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Growth in personalisation at 11 UK and US news publishers, 2007-2010

Source: Thurman & Schifferes, 2012

Page 8: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Changes in deployment of personalization features

at eleven national US and UK websites,

2007–16

• Mobile• Passive• Converged• Commodified

Page 9: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Av. number of

personalization features per

mobile ‘app’ 2010-2016

1.21

2.62

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

2010 2015

8.8

6.1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

2010 2015

Av. number of

personalization features per

web edition 2010-2016

Page 10: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Changes in deployment of passive and active

personalization features at eleven national US and

UK websites, 2010–16

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Active personalisation Passive personalisation

2010 2016

Page 11: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

2010

Page 12: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

“the time and effort to personalize something”

would put off all but a “relatively small number of

people”—Steve Herrmann, editor, BBC News website

(personal communication, 2008)

“anytime we’ve done anything that is not passive

we’ve got very, very little uptake””. —Jim Brady, WashingtonPost.com (personal

communication, 2008)

Page 13: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Changes in deployment of passive and active

personalization features at eleven national US and

UK websites, 2010–16

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Active personalisation Passive personalisation

2010 2016

Page 14: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

14

Page 15: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

15

Page 16: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

2010

Page 17: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

2016

Page 18: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

2016

Page 19: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

2010

Page 20: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

202016

Page 21: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

21

Page 22: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

• Prevalence of personalisation at news brands’ in decline

• Shift in focus from web to mobile• More likely to be passive• Industry consolidation – Outbrain’s virtual

monopoly for content recommendations• Content recommendations commoditised –

concern over editorial / advertising boundaries

Page 23: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 n=23,557 (average n=1,963)

Starting point for online news (January 2015)

Page 24: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)
Page 25: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 n=23,557 (average n=1,963)

Starting point for online news (January 2015)

Page 26: News media content personalization: Converged, commodified ... · Source: RISJ Digital News Report, 2015 UK - n=2149, Germany - n=1969, Japan n=2017 (January 2015)

Thank you.

Neil [email protected] @neilthurman