Top Banner
New York | London Jason Prince Director of Research T: (646) 845-0095 [email protected]
11

New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

Apr 18, 2018

Download

Documents

dinhthuan
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

New York | London

Jason Prince Director of Research T: (646) 845-0095 [email protected]

Page 2: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

Karbone  •  Karbone  is  an  integrated  Energy  and  Environmental  Markets  firm  •  Founded  in  2008  with  offices  in  New  York  and  London    •  Karbone  provides:  

BROKERAGE  |  CAPITAL  ADVISORY  |  MARKET  RESEARCH  •  Since  its  founding,  the  firm  has  been  recognized  in  mulHple  

instances  in  the  Renewable  Energy  Sector  by  its  clients:    

2  

Page 3: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

Agenda  

1.  New  England  Energy  Overview  

2.  Prospects  for  Renewable  Energy  

3.  REC  Market  Fundamentals  

4.  PotenHal  Game  Changers  

3  

Page 4: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

4  

New  England  Energy  Overview  Figure  1:  Evolving  Energy  Mix  

Figure  3:  Old  Coal  &  Oil  

Figure  2:  Infrastructure  Constraints  

FCA  8:    Defic i t   i n   Power  System   Resources   to  M e e t   C o n s um e r  Demand  in  2017-­‐2018  

Sources:  ISO-­‐NE,  Bentek  

Page 5: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

Bullish  Prospects  for  Renewable  Energy  

Support  Factors   Challenges  

Limited  AlternaHves   SiHng  

Revenue  Drivers   Variability  

Tax  Credit  Regime   Regulatory  Uncertainty  

RGGI  

5  

Page 6: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

6  

REC  Market  Fundamentals  

$0.00$

$10.00$

$20.00$

$30.00$

$40.00$

$50.00$

$60.00$

$70.00$

January214$ February214$ March214$ April214$ May214$ June214$ July214$ August214$ September214$ October214$ November214$

$$/$REC$$

NEPOOL$2014$Class$I$REC$Prices$

MA$Class$I$REC$2014$ CT$Class$I$REC$2014$ RI$New$REC$2014$ ME$Class$I$REC$2014$ MA,$ME,$RI$ACP$ CT$ACP$

Page 7: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

7  

Bearish  Game  Changer:  Hydro    

!"!!!!

!500,000!!

!1,000,000!!

!1,500,000!!

!2,000,000!!

!2,500,000!!

!3,000,000!!

2014! 2015! 2016! 2017! 2018! 2019! 2020!

MW

h

•  PotenHal  for  up  to  10%  of  CT  Class  I  demand  to  be  met  by  large-­‐scale  hydro  by  2020  •  However,  concerns  regarding  transmission  viability  of  wheeling  all  this  power    •  Also,  declining  Biomass  &  LFG  REC  value  /  VT  SPEED  disqualificaHon  counter-­‐balances  new  supply  

2.8M  RECs  

Page 8: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

!"!!!!

!500,000!!

!1,000,000!!

!1,500,000!!

!2,000,000!!

!2,500,000!!

!3,000,000!!

2015! 2016! 2017! 2018! 2019! 2020! 2021!

MWh!

CT! MA! RI! ME! NH!

8  

Bearish  Game  Changer:  NY  Wind  

•  Over  1  GW  of  NY  sited  wind  already  qualified  in  Massachuseds  for  Class  I  RECs  •  Graph  displays  exisHng  New  York  wind  that  is  rolling  off  of  NYSERDA  Main  Tier  contracts  •  However,  power  markeHng  &  congesHon  concerns  limit  opHonality  

2.5M  RECs  

Page 9: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

9  

Bearish  Game  Changer:  Offshore  Wind  

!"!!!!

!200,000!!

!400,000!!

!600,000!!

!800,000!!

!1,000,000!!

!1,200,000!!

!1,400,000!!

!1,600,000!!

!1,800,000!!

2016! 2017! 2018! 2019! 2020!

MWh!

•  Projects  in  advanced  stages:  Block  Island  &  Cape  Wind  •  NEPOOL  cross-­‐eligibility  •  But  –  project  development  risks  

1.7M  RECs  

Page 10: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

10  

Bullish  Game  Changer:  Vermont  SPEED  

A  Different  Kind  of  Change  

~1,000,000  RECs  

Commercial  DisrupHon  

An  RPS  in  the  Cards?  

Canary  in  the  Coal  Mine  

Spillover  Claims  SensiHvity  

Page 11: New York | Londoninfo.argusmedia.com/uslib/Karbone NEPOOL REC Presentation.pdf · Agenda 1. New(England(Energy(Overview(2. Prospects(for(Renewable(Energy(3. REC(MarketFundamentals(4.

New York | London

Jason Prince Director of Research T: (646) 845-0095 [email protected]