The New Rules in College Choice: Findings from Lipman Hearne’s National Study on High-Achieving Seniors
May 11, 2015
The New Rules in College Choice: Findings from Lipman Hearne’s National Study on High-Achieving Seniorsy g g
Tom Abrahamson Managing Director & Principal
Donna Van De Water, Ph.D. Managing Director & Principal
About Lipman Hearne
• Established in 1966, now the nation’s largest marketing firm servingserving colleges, universities, and nonprofits
• Expertise from academia, global agencies, and nonprofit organizations
• 77 staff members in Chicago and Washington, D.C.
• Best practices and thought leadership
3
4An Integrated Approach• Research
• Brand Strategy
• Enrollment Marketing
• Integrated Marketing
C ti D l t• Creative Development
• Interactive
• Advertising• Advertising
• Media Planning and Buying
• Public AffairsPublic Affairs
55
The new rules• Rule #1: What matters to college-Rule #1: What matters to college-
bound students is not “one size fits all”
66
The new rules• Rule #1: What matters to college-Rule #1: What matters to college-
bound students is not “one size fits all”• Rule #2: The way students now learn• Rule #2: The way students now learn
about colleges has changed from push to pull.p
77
The new rules• Rule #1: What matters to college-Rule #1: What matters to college-
bound students is not “one size fits all”• Rule #2: The way students now learn• Rule #2: The way students now learn
about colleges has changed from push to pull.p
• Rule #3: The recession’s impact on college choice will stay with us a long g y gwhile.
88
The new rules• Rule #1: What matters to college-Rule #1: What matters to college-
bound students is not “one size fits all”• Rule #2: The way students now learn• Rule #2: The way students now learn
about colleges has changed from push to pull.p
• Rule #3: The recession’s impact on college choice will stay with us a long g y gwhile.
• Rule #4: Mom and dad are “all-in” at all t f th ll t d i istages of the enrollment decision
First a little background on gthe study…
1010
The 2009 study sought answers to these questions:
• Why are these high-achievers going to college?
• Where are they going (public vs private)?Where are they going (public vs private)?
• What college features and factors closed the deal and which ones didn’t?and which ones didn t?
• What features are they willing to trade-off?
1111
The 2009 study sought answers to these questions:
• How important is “fit?”
• What information sources broke through atWhat information sources broke through at decision time and were most valued?
1212
The 2009 study sought answers to these questions:
• In what cases will students travel for their education?
• How do students factor in financial aid and scholarships into their decision process?
• What role do parents play in the process?
1313
Survey respondents• 1,264 college-bound high
school seniors
• Solid-performers and Academic Superstars
• NRCCUA database and• NRCCUA database and screening
• Applied to and acceptedApplied to and accepted by at least three colleges
1414
Ability Level*Ability Level
Academic Superstars
66%66%
1515
Solid performers SAT M+V 1150 1290Solid performers: SAT M+V = 1150-1290Superstars: SAT M+V 1300 - 1600
Ability Level*
Academic S tSuperstars
66%
*SOURCES: Please indicate the college entrance exam that you took and earned the highest
**SOURCE: NRCCUA database
Please indicate the college entrance exam that you took and earned the highest combined/composite score? What was your combined SAT I verbal and math score (out of 1600)? What was your combined SAT II verbal and math score (out of 2400)? What was your ACT composite score?
1616
The survey participants:
24% Northeast 32% South 21% Midwest22% West
SOURCE: NRCCUA database
1717
Ethnicity• 64% White • 15% Asian• 15% Asian • 6% Hispanic• 3% African American• 6% Other • 9% Unknown
Gender• 65% Female • 35% Male
SOURCE: NRCCUA databaseNOTE: Multiple responses were allowed
1818
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence
1919
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence• 29 college attributes: importance in picking g p p g
schools to apply to/ at time of decision
2020
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence• 29 college attributes: importance in picking g p p g
schools to apply to/ at time of decision• Values
2121
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence• 29 college attributes: importance in picking g p p g
schools to apply to/ at time of decision• Values • Tradeoffs
2222
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence• 29 college attributes: importance in picking g p p g
schools to apply to/ at time of decision• Values • Tradeoffs• Perceptions of college cost
2323
What we measured
• 30 information sources: usage and influence• 29 college attributes: importance in picking g p p g
schools to apply to/ at time of decision• Values • Tradeoffs• Perceptions of college cost• Parental impact
2424
Rule #1 What matters to collegeRule #1 What matters to collegeWhat matters to college-bound students is not What matters to college-bound students is not “one size fits all.”“one size fits all.”
24
2525
Why are these high-achieversWhy are these high achievers going to college?
2626
Top reasons for going to college (All respondents)(All respondents)
• Prepare for career• Learn to be an independent person• To contribute to social and professional success• Make “best” friends• Access to diverse people and backgrounds• Make family proud
2727
Why College:
89%95%You want to go to the college that will best prepare
you for a career
Why College:
70%62%It's best to go to a college where there are many
people who have different backgrounds and points of view from yours
50%57%
Wh d d t d i t
You want to go to college to make your family proud
49%
40%
38%
It' b t t t ll h t l
Where you earn your undergraduate degree is not nearly as important as where you earn your
graduate degree
30%
25%
40%
It's best to go to a college where you know you will
It's best to go to a college where most people share your views and interests
#REF!Solid Performers
Academic
Superstars
Solid Performers
17%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100%
t s best to go to a co ege e e you o yoube one of the very best students
Solid PerformersSuperstars
2828
Which is more important? Intellectual growth or career preparation?
2929
Did type of college selected change between 2006 and 2009?
Academic Superstars Solid Performers
2006N=300
2009N=828
2006N=300
2009N=433
Public 46% 47% 57% 63%
Private 52% 51% 37% 35%
Indeterminat 2% 2% 6% 0%e 2% 2% 6% 0%
3030
Most important in determining where to apply
SOURCE: What was most important to you in deciding where to apply? [Open-ended responses.]
3131
Most important in final college decision
SOURCE: Please rate how important each of the following were in your decision to enroll at [SCHOOL] instead of another college or university.
Not at all important Very important
3232
Least important factors in the final college decision
SOURCE: Please rate how important each of the following were in your decision to enroll at [SCHOOL] instead of another college or university.
Not at all important Very important
3333
Superstar’s Comment on “Fit”
“It was not just one thing. E thi h d t t thEverything had to come together; from the atmosphere to the academics to the price it all had to fit ”to the price, it all had to fit.
3434
2/3 of respondents said they are attending their top choice school. Yet, among these students…
3535
2/3 of respondents said they are attending their top choice school. Yet, among these students…
• 1/3 say they’re enrolling at a school that is not a very good fit
3636
2/3 of respondents said they are attending their top choice school. Yet, among these students…
• 1/3 say they’re enrolling at a school that is not a very good fit
• 1/3 say that they are at their “perfect fit” (rating 10/10 for their choice)
So, just how important is “fit”?
3737
Decision factors by level of “fit” achievedDecision factors by level of fit achieved
TOP 5TOP 5
TOP 10TOP 10
Not at all important Very important
3838
Top 5 Decision factors by level of “fit” achievedTop 5 Decision factors by level of fit achieved
Not at all important Very important
3939
Decision factors by level of “fit” achieved contDecision factors by level of fit achieved cont.
Not at all important Very important
4040
Bottom 10 Decision factorsBottom 10 Decision factors by level of “fit” achieved cont.
Not at all important Very important
4141
Trade off factors in the enrollmentTrade off factors in the enrollment decision
SOURCE: If you have to pick one characteristic, which of the two played a greater role in your decision to enroll at [SCHOOL]?
4242
Reputation Trumps Location
4343
Reputation Edges-out Cost
4444
Cost Beats Location
4545
Reputation (major) Trumps Location
4646
Overall Reputation and Program Reputation Both Matter
4747
Reputation of Major Trumps Cost
4848
Rule #2
The way students nowstudents now learn about colleges has changed fromchanged from push to pull.
4949
Most influential sources at decision timeMost influential sources at decision time
SOURCE: Please rate how influential each of the following were in your decision to enroll at [COLLEGE FROM Q. 6] instead of another college or university.
5050
Important sources of college information that could potentially be more impactful
5151
Information source breakthrough opportunities
5252
In what cases will studentsIn what cases will students travel far for college?
5353
Proximity to home was among the least important factors among high achievers at decision time. They are more concerned with:They are more concerned with:
Fit• Fit• Academic opportunities• Career opportunities• Career opportunities• Reputation (both overall and within their major)
5454
Enrollment results by location type
Total Academic Solid performers
First time undergrads, recent HS gradsTotal
(N=1,261)superstars(N=828)
performers(N=433)
HS grads(N=2,272,255)
Location
Large/mid-sized city 68% 70% 67% 56%
Urban fringe 17% 18% 17% 24%
Town/rural 10% 9% 11% 20%
5555
Rule #3
The recession’srecession s impact on college choice will stay withwill stay with us a long
hilwhile.
5656
How the economy affected college choice this year
• 53% will enroll in a less expensive school• 53% will enroll in a less expensive school• 44% will rely more heavily on financial aid
counselingcounseling• 38% will obtain a larger loan• 38% will attend a college closer to homeg• 25% will visit fewer college campuses• 24% will change from a private to a publicg p p• 21% will live at home while attending college
Source: 2009 Report on the Impact of the Economy On College Enrollment by Longmire and Company
5757
H d t d tHow do students perceive costs?p
5858
A low-priced college = Median Cost of $15,000
A high-priced college = Median Cost of $35,000A high priced college Median Cost of $35,000
5959
Total costs by area of study
STEM Social H i i B i Ed i P f i l
Total costs by area of study
STEM Social Science Humanities Business Education Professional
A low-priced college costs less than
$15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000 $15,000than…
A high-priced college costs more than…
$35,000 $40,000 $36,500 $40,000 $30,000 $40,000
SOURCE: How would you define the following terms? (Median)
6060
How do students factor in fi i l id dfinancial aid and
scholarships into their pdecision process?
6161
Scholarship and tuition have different meanings for students attending privatemeanings for students attending private vs. public institutions
Not at all important Very important
6262
Money offered trumps prestige
Not at all important Very important
6363
Rule #4:Rule #4:
Know that Know that mom and dadmom and dadmom and dad mom and dad are “all in” at are “all in” at every stage of every stage of the collegethe collegethe college the college decision.decision.
6464
Do "helicopter” parents really exist?
6565
Students said parents were involved in:
•Identifying colleges to consider (75%) •Determining where to apply (75%)Determining where to apply (75%) •Managing applications (62%) •Deciding where to visit (75%) g ( )•Deciding where to enroll (69%)
SOURCE: Which family members, if any, were involved during each of the following stages of your college decision?
6666
Ranking of parents’ influence in final decision,influence in final decision, among all information sources used
• Conversation with your parents (#2 out of 30)p ( )
• Letters/mailings to your parents from colleges (#22 out of of 30)
SOURCE: Please rate how influential each of the following were in your decision to enroll at [NAME OF COLLEGE FROM Q. 6] instead of another college or university. NOTE: Ranks based upon top-two-box ratings
6767
Wh t th kWhat are the key observations of
the study?
6868
What are the key observations from the study?
• Expectations are sky high
6969
What are the key observations from the study?
• Expectations are sky high• Power of people and experiences must be
harnessed
7070
What are the key observations from the study?
• Expectations are sky high• Power of people and experiences must be
harnessed• Economic realities can take some schools out of
the game too soonthe game too soon
7171
What are the key observations from the study?
• Expectations are sky high• Power of people and experiences must be
harnessed• Economic realities can take some schools out of
the game too soonthe game too soon• Strive to “flip the communication pyramid”
Discussion
72
Additional analysis available:• Comparison of findings to
2006 t d h l t2006 study where relevant• Different approaches used
to achieve success in life• High-achieving seniors
choosing liberal arts colleges
• High-achieving seniors choosing metropolitan research universities
• High-achieving seniors choosing faith-based colleges
• Custom analysis possible upon request
73