Top Banner
Notes NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN JAKARTA THE WAY FORWARD Workout.id Co-working Space, Jakarta, September 12, 2017 Organized by:
30

NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

Jul 19, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

Notes

NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT

URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN JAKARTA

– THE WAY FORWARD

Workout.id Co-working Space, Jakarta, September 12, 2017

Organized by:

Page 2: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

1

Table of Contents Table of Contents .......................................................................................................................... 1

AGENDA ..................................................................................................................................... 2

SEMINAR NOTES ...................................................................................................................... 3

Results .................................................................................................................................... 3

Opening .................................................................................................................................. 3

Presentation ........................................................................................................................... 5

I. Tri Leksono Hadiat (Jakarta Berkebun) ............................................................................. 5

II. Ade Nurhayati (Genus Organik) ........................................................................................ 7

III. Ridho Bilhaq (East West Seed Indonesia) ....................................................................... 8

IV. Dyah Perwitosari (MURIA/Marunda Urban Resillience In Action) ............................... 12

V. Repedibo (Anies-Sandi Ex-Campaign Team Member) .................................................. 16

Discussion............................................................................................................................ 16

Urban Farming from Four Aspects ..................................................................................... 23

Networking Session ............................................................................................................. 27

Pitching Session .................................................................................................................. 27

Promoting Online Platform ................................................................................................. 28

Closing ................................................................................................................................. 29

Page 3: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

2

AGENDA

08.30 – 09.00 Registration & coffee

09.00 – 09.15

Opening

- Workout.id (M. Maulana)

- AgriProFocus (Dedi Triadi)

09.15 – 10.45

10.45 – 11.00

Presentation

- Muria

- Jakarta berkebun

- East West Seed

- Genus Organik

11.00 – 13.00

Networking Session

Pitching/matchmaking (based on registration form)

Networking (Profile in advance)

Promoting Online Platform

13.00 – 13.10 Closing

13.10 – 14:00 Lunch

Page 4: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

3

SEMINAR NOTES

Date : Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Time : 08.30-14.00

Venue : Workout.id Coworking Space, Panglima Polim – Jakarta

Results

1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta.

2) To come up with solution(s) for more sustainable and viable model of urban farming

3) To build and expand network, as well as learning from participants' experience in urban

farming.

Opening

Maula Paramitha Wulandaru (AgriProFocus)

Today's agenda are:

1. Presentation and discussion with Jakarta urban farming initiators: Ade Nurhayati (Genus

Organik), Tri Leksono (Jakarta Berkebun), Ridho Bilhaq (East West Seed Indonesia), Dyah

Perwiosari (MURIA/Marunda Urban Resilience in Action – Karina Caritas Indonesia)

2. Networking and pitching session; in pitching session, registered participants could promote

their initiatives, organizations, products or make an open-call for experts for your projects.

Meanwhile, in networking session, participants could exchange contacts or get into early

discussion of future collaboration project.

Dedi Triadi (Country Coordinator AgriProFocus)

Today, we will listen to presentations of four urban farming initiators in Jakarta and Bekasi. Urban

farming is known as a positive solution to overcome food scarcity in the future (food security),

especially in urban area in Indonesia.

Based on FAO research data, in the year of 2050 there will be rapid growth of world's population

approximately up to 10 billion and most likely Indonesia would be one of the countries with largest

population of the world. Almost 70% of the population would be preferably live in the urban areas.

We could imagine such things would happen in Jakarta in 2050 as well, there would be more and

more people live here. According to the research, there will be needed farmland as large as a country

like Brazil so that we can feed the entire population in 2050. Unfortunately, we no longer have

sufficient farming lands, in terms of size and land's fertility to produce such amount. So that, we will

need the creativity to overcome this challenge, especially for urban people.

Page 5: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

4

AgriProFocus intentionally bring up the theme “Urban Farming” as a possible solution to limited

farming space to ensure food security. Aside from fulfilling nutritional needs, we are hoping that

urban farming could be a part of climate change mitigation and adaptation. As the population

increases, pollution in our environment is also on the rise, thus the degradation of world's population

health. We are hoping that today's meeting could be a good start for making a better future through

knowledge/experience exchange and networking with others. By doing it together, we are one step

closer to bring greater impact in our life.

Maulana (Workout.id)

In average people in Indonesia consume 35 Kg vegetable per year, meanwhile the United Nations

has set the vegetable intake at least 75 Kg/person per year. That means we are more than 50% less

than the ideal needs according to that standard. I, on behalf of Workout.id, really appreciate

AgriProFocus initiatives to gather us today to discuss about urban farming. I believe, we could do it

better if we are collaborating with others.

Workout.id is probably the first and only working space focused on agriculture issue. For past 15

years we intensively provide working space for start-ups, initiatives and events focusing on fisheries

and agriculture, but we also open daily for public.

Page 6: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

5

Presentation

I. Tri Leksono Hadiat (Jakarta Berkebun)

Jakarta Berkebun is a part of Indonesia Berkebun network, which already spreads around 45 cities

in Indonesia. It consists of cities network and 9 universities. We realized that this is community based

initiative, so the active member only around 70% of total member.

“Jakarta Berkebun” used to be an urban farming movement initiated by Ridwan Kamil (recent Mayor

of Bandung) in 2010, as a possible solution for food security problem. Sometimes we are questioning

ourselves, why people who lives in the city, could not produce or grow their own food. We found

other urban farmers and urban farming enthusiasts via Twitter and we had our first plots at (soon to

be) Spring Hill apartment in 2011. On March 2011, many urban farmers community has risen in other

cities such as in Bogor and Bandung, and by May 6, 2011, networks in 6 cities had been established.

Since the first site was temporary (a loan from a member), so as the apartment block was built, we

had to move to another apartment, namely Apartment Casa Goya. We start all over again, until now

we could harvest it.

Vision and Mission of Jakarta Berkebun

Vision: Ecology, Economy and Education

Mission: Re-purpose the fallow lands in the city, so they will be more productive and ready

to use for growing crops. The plot does not have to be necessarily big, but they could be the

idle front yard/backyard, idle space at balcony or rooftop. If we could grow our spinach at our

backyard, we could at least save our money to buy food, even though we could not harvest

it in daily basis.

Ecology: We are taking care of our gardens at Apartment Casa Goya every weekend or holiday. We

are trying our best to take a good care of it, not only plant and then abandon it. Our biggest challenge

was manpower to take care of it on weekdays, because most of Jakarta Berkebun members are

working 9 to 5 and students, so they only had time on weekend.

Education: We are teaming up with school or office, which need helps to build their plots for free.

We had done it several times.

Economy: Even though we had financial motives with growing crops, not everybody who able to

grow plants, also able to sell in large quantity. Focus in fulfilling your needs first. Do not worry that if

we grow our food, then the vegetable seller will eventually run out of business. Each of us has our

own portions in the business.

Why Gardening? Why It Matters?

Gardening is a positive and fun activity, you could meet people with similar passion/hobby,

you do the actual work such as plowing the land, sowing the seed, giving fertilizers, etc. We

will reap what we sow. Sometimes if the crops are way too many for ourselves to consume,

Page 7: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

6

we sell it through social media. The minus point is, we could not produce it continuously,

because of land size (too small).

To ensure food security.

To maintain soil fertility and productivity. At the beginning, the soil in our first plot are rocky,

we should buy a fertile soil to cover up the rocky soil beneath approximately 30 cm. If we

were digging to hard, then we hit the rocky parts. As we take care our plot, the soil was getting

better.

To free ourselves from typical city life. We miss those times when we meet our friends and

interact with them, we clean up the garden and harvest our crops, and we cook our meals

together.

To turn fallow land into fertile ground.

To increase oxygen supply.

You Are What You Eat

The foods we produce on our plot are free of hazardous chemical residue.

We know how our food is produced

We know where our food came from and the farmers.

For fertilizer, we are strongly suggest to compost your food scraps and yard waste at home, so you

will not need to buy one. It is relatively easy to build the simple composter.

Verticulture: A Solution for Gardening in Small Spaces

For home that only has small space for gardening, could use verticulture or vertical gardening. In

Jakarta, urban farmers merely use hydroponic system, they still use soil most of the time. They use

pipes that cut in half, containers, etc. and arrange them vertically. It could be done on your apartment

windowsill, wall, rooftop or balcony. As long as there are sufficient sunlight and proper care, most of

these crops will grow.

Urban Farming for Business

Aside from taking care of small-scale urban farm, Tri Leksono owns a large farming field in

Cigombong, Bogor. He admitted for business, we could not do it in smaller field, because we need

at least 2 hectare of land. For marketing his crops, he goes to distributor, who stocks up vegetables

and fruit at supermarket. They usually discuss, what commodity he can provide for them. Distributors

need continuous supply, so they need partners. We could offer them specific items, such as super

tomato or edamame and also discuss the quantity. Then we know our market from the beginning. I

avoid selling it directly to market, because my to-do list will be longer. I'd rather assign this marketing

stuff to the experts and let me focus on my farm.

Page 8: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

7

II. Ade Nurhayati (Genus Organik)

Ade started to grow her interest of growing vegetable organically around 8 years ago. At that time,

organic product especially vegetables are exclusive, in terms of how and where we could get it,

higher price (compared to non-organic) and difficult to sell it to the market. She started with 2,5

hectares land in Cisarua, Bogor. The land is already fertile, but for organic farming she still need to

rotate the crops.

One of objective in growing organic farm is to educate people, especially people in the city, the

importance of healthy food. She grew the crops together with her employees and also sell the crops

directly to the end-user (chef and regular buyer). She also has delivery service for the customer. She

thought, it will be more effective by direct selling, since she cut the distribution chain shorter.

Within 3 years, she accepted an offer to make urban farm in Bekasi, West Java. The field located

inside a new housing complex, Vida, in Bantar Gebang, Bekasi-West Java. Bantar Gebang landfill

site is the largest open landfill site, which received most of the dumps from Jakarta and it located 6

km from Ade's field. This was one of challenges, at the beginning the soil condition was bad, rocky,

infertile, dry, clay soil and low-level porosity. Heavy rain pours for a day, it may cause 2 weeks of

flooding. Ade once had to start her garden all over again because of the never-ending flood.

To revitalize the soil, Ade make a compost directly on top of the soil beds within 2 weeks, using

organic dumps she got from nearest traditional market (e.g. from fruits, vegetables, farmyard

manure). She is repurposing foils from baby formula milk as polybag, because the seeds cannot

grow if she planted it directly to the soil. Her farm is actually 3 hectares, but due to limited human

resource, she only works on half of it (approximately 1,5 hectares).

Aside from plantings, her garden has marketing and educational facilities namely “Warung Kebun”

(Garden Kiosk). Other facilities on the site are seedling nursery and green house special for micro

greens and edible flowers. In addition, micro greens and edible flowers are the major income source

for her organic farm business.

Why Urban Farming?

1) To restore the ecology, which had been destroyed by city constructions.

2) To raise Indonesian youth awareness of ecology.

3) To raise awareness of healthy and nutritious food.

4) To promote healthy lifestyle, by eating healthy food and minimize illness caused by

processed food.

Furthermore, her organic farm business unit also provides course and facility for beginner farmer,

who interested in organic farming. Few organizations had learnt from Ade, such as Bekasi Berkebun

and communities in Lodan. She also introduced organic farming in kindergarten. She hopes that the

earlier kids know about farming, the more they will love their ecology. A couple of times, Ade would

go visit other sites or institutions to give a free lessons on 101 organic farming for beginner and

recycling (e.g. composting, repurposing polybag for growing seeds).

Page 9: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

8

III. Ridho Bilhaq (East West Seed Indonesia)

East West Seed Indonesia (EWINDO) is a joint venture between Dutch companies Enza Zaden and

East West Seed group, but today 100% of its employees are Indonesian. EWINDO based in

Purwakarta, West Java and it is one of the urban farming initiator in Indonesia.

One of urban farming vision is to re-introduce both younger and older generation who lives in urban

areas about farming and the importance of healthy food. Urban farming could make distribution chain

to be more efficient. They could cut down the duration of transporting vegetables and fruit, so it could

retain its freshness. It does not mean necessarily diminish the important part of farmer in rural area,

in the other hand we are helping them to keep up with our consumption needs.

Nowadays, we have reached one of urban farming objectives, to make ourselves happier and feel

fulfilled, even though it has not touched the business part yet. We often suggested to novice farmer,

to not to think about the financial advantages if you are only about to begin, think more on

psychological advantages. The disappointment will be doubled, if your crops were a failure and you

gain nothing out of it.

Urban Farming EWINDO Ways

SHARING

Knowledge sharing is a way to educate people about urban farming. EWINDO has experts for each

market segments, for instance children, women, elderly, government officers. Each representative

will give education in unique ways, based on their audience.

TRYOUT/REAL-LIFE EXPERIENCE

After having sharing session, real-life experience or tryout will give greater impact to audience. It will

help the audience to remember the lesson given and apply it in daily life. Sometimes to make people

believe, that urban farming bring positive vibes in our life, EWINDO needs helping hand from others.

They need a living-proof. They often change their minds afterwards.

FFD (Farmer Field Days)

Farmer Field Days (FFD) is a public showcase of urban farmers, mostly EWINDO's clients, partners

or community, that had been succeed in growing their garden. It is held not by EWINDO, but by the

community itself. The main objective of FFD is to amplify the effect of urban farming to wider society.

Example: together with Ace Hardware, EWINDO held knowledge-sharing session and they sell the

gardening packs at Ace Hardware stores.

In the sharing session, they allow the farmer to choose their own gardening preferences, organic,

hydroponic, chemical, aeroponic or soil, but they always give out important informations regarding

each planting methods (e.g. safe chemical/pesticide usage, hydroponic 101 & how to's, etc.)

DEMOPLOT

Demoplot is a land managed by EWINDO for educational and promotional purposes and it also

plays role as company's showcase. People could get information and support from EWINDO for

their farming needs here. Examples:

Page 10: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

9

Ladies group “Delima Cantik” at housing complex in Duren Sawit, East Jakarta, is

collaborating with government of East Jakarta to grow a garden at long-abandon house.

Now it becomes a model plot for neighboring areas.

Urban farming garden at Gading Nias Apartment rooftop (25th floor). We felt slightly

pessimistic at the beginning, since the temperature is too high and lack of water up there,

but miraculously it survived. Even they could produce approximately 30 kg/week of fresh

vegetables to supply the market tenants on the building.

Benefits of Urban Farming

a) Healthy life (physically and mentally).

b) Provides learning opportunity (esp. in more fun & enjoyable way for kids)

c) Brings back social value in daily life through interaction with others.

d) Produces healthy food you can respect. You get fresher food (vegetables/fruits) and promote

healthier eating habit.

e) Makes efficient use of land, as climate buffer, as well as its aesthetic values. (example: urban

farming rooftop at PT. Basuki Pulo Gadung, East Jakarta and at PT. Bukaka). Some of it still

survived until now, it depends on the maintenance. EWINDO is not fully responsible for the

final result and maintenance.

Page 11: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

10

Growth Rate of Urban Farming

Hereby is urban farming growth data according to EWINDO sales team data:

Figure 1. Urban Farming Growth (source: EWINDO presentation slide “Urban

Farming Sustainable Future”, AgriProFocus, Jakarta: September 12, 2017)

In the year of 2014, there were only 200 urban farmers, and by the first semester of 2017 there are

13,000 urban farmers, in Jakarta, Bogor, Depok, Tangerang and Bekasi area only. EWINDO seeds

in supermarket were sold out and their production line was barely stopped to keep up with customers'

demands. They also pretty stoked with the report, that many urban farmers likes to grow vegetables,

since they predicted people in the city prefer to plant flowers rather than vegetables or fruits. This

trend indicated, there is a mind-shift among urbans.

They are expecting for total 20,000 urban farmers in 2017, hence the greater impact. EWINDO starts

to spread their demoplots in wider area, such as in Sumatra and Java, alongside with Borneo and

Celebes. They tried to stock up regularly in supermarket chain such as Superindo and Alfamidi and

other retails such as Ace Hardware and Trubus, so customer does not have to wait too long to start

their own garden. EWINDO's demoplots in Sumatra are in these cities: Pekanbaru (Riau Islands),

Bengkulu, Lampung and Payakumbuh (West Sumatra).

Challenges in Urban Farming

The hype of urban farming sometimes is temporary, while urban farming project is meant to

be a sustainable, longer term project.

Page 12: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

11

Lack of commitment. In 2015, not many people were exposed to urban farming, so very few

(or almost none) clients willingly committed to long-term urban farming projects.

Many programs are focusing on selling modules or pure marketing, instead of campaigning

the urban farming movement itself. It would be better if we begin with the education, then

comes the selling. Let consumer's curiosity and interests on urban farming issue drive the

modules sales, instead of the other way around.

There are no official regulations (city codes/regulations from the government).

Opportunities for Urban Farming

Healthy food packs service, such as selling green diet pack, Mayo diet packs. One of the

vegan restaurants in Jakarta, Burgreens, uses the crops from their own garden in Jakarta.

Pick-and-pay for fresh vegetables, located in high-population area.

Office space greening, by having a team that specialized in setting up greenery at office

building.

For personal consumption, in order to improve our nutrition intake and also money-saving. It

may not significantly give us extra income, but we could save money, that we usually spent

for buying foods.

Selling full-grown plants in containers or seedlings trays. In Nusa Tenggara Barat, they sell

full grown plants in a nice container/pot for IDR 100,000.

Educational package for public, e.g. selling workshop package on how to start seeds or urban

farming 101 (could be held in cafe or co-working space and people has to pay for it).

EWINDO's Personal Pouch

EWINDO always provide the high-quality seeds and try our best to become farmer's best friend. If

you are buying our seeds, please check on the barcode, batch and expiry date. If it passed the expiry

date, you could still plant the seeds until next year.

SIPINDO Mobile Apps

“SIPINDO” is a free app, we are teaming up with a non-profit organization PRISMA (Promoting Rural

Income through Support for Markets in Agriculture) and dedicated to all farmers in Indonesia. You

could find detailed informations on plants, plant diseases, forums and more articles in agriculture

and gardening.

Page 13: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

12

IV. Dyah Perwitosari (MURIA/Marunda Urban Resilience In Action)

MURIA aims to improve city resilience in Marunda, North Jakarta. Reasons why Marunda had

been chosen as project area:

1) Population: Marunda is a highly populated area, with approximately population of 27,116

within 10 neighborhoods.

2) Poverty: Average daily income is less than USD $2 (equals to IDR 27.000), with most of the

population are working in informal sector and fisheries.

3) Access: Lack of access to clean water and sanitation in Marunda bay area.

4) Natural disaster: The area prone to flood and tidal flood.

5) Social problem: Higher rate of child abuse.

MURIA's Main Objective

All stakeholders in Marunda will be capable to build city's resilience and turns it into a valuable asset

for a better future. The project is also open for replication in other area/city.

Expected Outputs

a) To reduce disaster risk from floods, high-tides/tidal floods and heavy rain in Marunda.

b) To enhance sustainable livelihoods

c) To improve hygiene and sanitation habit in the community

d) To strengthen the multi-stakeholders platform in facilitating the community to actively

participate in city development.

MURIA Approaches

MURIA has their unique approach “Pengelolaan Resiko Terpadu” (PeRDu or Integrated Risks

Management). To achieve city resilience, there are points to be checked:

1) “Pengurangan Resiko Bencana” (PRB) or Disaster Risk Reduction

2) “Adaptasi Perubahan Iklim” (API) or Climate Change Adaptation

3) “Pengelolaan dan Perbaikan Ekosistem” (PPE) or Ecosystem Management and Restoration

Page 14: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

13

Figure 2. MURIA Approaches (source: MURIA presentation slide “MURIA-Marunda

Urban Resilience in Action for Network Learning Event Urban Farming Initiatives in

Jakarta - The Way”, AgriProFocus, Jakarta: September 12, 2017)

Principles of PeRDu

1) Working on different timescales

2) Recognizing geographical scales

3) Strengthening institutional resilience

4) Integrating disciplines

5) Promoting community self-management

6) Stimulating learning

7) Focusing on livelihoods

8) Forming partnerships

MURIA is a multi-stakeholder platform, consists of Cordaid, KARINA (Caritas Indonesia) dan Bina

Swadaya Consultant (sister company of Trubus). They are responsible for:

Platform coordination

Program supervision

Providing strategic directions by forming platform mechanism.

Also, there are other organizations/stakeholders joining in the platform: Ford Foundation (for

funding), Humanitarian Open Streetmap Team/HOT Indonesia (For flood risk reduction, they make

Openstreetmap using Ushahidi and Drupal system), CARE International-Indonesia (for gender

issue), East West Seed Indonesia, Bina Tani Sejahtera, Spire Research Consultant (for studies &

research access), Forum PRB-API DKI Jakarta (for facilitating communication with the government

Page 15: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

14

and flood contingency plans through early warning system), government and local communities.

The disaster management & hazard online map (made with Drupal system) consists of evacuation

route, evacuation camp, etc. Similar map had been replicated by Dinas Ketahanan Pangan, Kelautan

dan Pertanian (DKPKP/Food Security, Marine and Agriculture Agency). On the other hand, the urban

farming map is using Ushahidi system.

Urban farming is one of the expected results in MURIA (“by enhancing local communities livelihood”).

They already have community-based groups who runs urban farming in Marunda, managing Trash

Bank and “Usaha Bersama Simpan Pinjam” (UBSP or Credit Union). The connection between these

three: Urban farming will need fertilizer and pesticide from Trash Bank, who manages organic waste

from the community (and turn it into organic fertilizer). Meanwhile, UBSP is managing the money

they got from people's sales to Trash Bank, so they could use it to pay rent, electricity and phone

bills and many more.

Speaking of capacity building, especially for women, nowadays more women are capable to do

advocacy and public speaking about the issue on their neighborhoods, starting from 4 groups in RT

07.

Outputs from Urban Farming in Marunda

Management of small-scale plots. In comparison to other plots, Marunda has smaller and

limited land size, not by hectares.

More urban open space/green spaces.

Use of technology in agriculture (by using hydroponic system, collaborating with HidroJak).

As mentioned earlier, MURIA has encouraged good sanitation and hygiene habit, one of their

approaches is by rainwater harvesting. Pure water is hard to find in Jakarta, even the ground water

is contaminated, then we thought of reserving rainwater. Together with community, we share our

knowledge on rainwater harvesting and counting Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) on water in Marunda.

The result was quite surprising, pH of rainwater is 7,6 and TDS 31 ppm. Comparison between

different water sources is shown on table below:

Water Source (from Kepu, Marunda)

pH TDS

Rainwater 7,6 31

PAM (local water utility) 7,1 246

Bottled mineral water 6,9 64

Well 7,0 913

The ideal TDS for drinking water based on WHO standards is between 50-100 ppm, while TDS in

water from well in Marunda reached 913 ppm. Other benefits from rainwater harvesting is the

water is free, it was not taken from ground water and no need to drill deeper underground,

Page 16: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

15

Last but not least, about MURIA's objective to strengthen multi-stakeholder platform, they are

planning to form a bigger platform to overcome Marunda's greater problem. They need more

supporting stakeholders, because it is impossible to solve the problem by KARINA itself.

Is MURIA Really An Answer to Problem of Marunda?

Poverty – enhancing livelihood by urban farming and UBSP/credit union.

Access – access to clean water by rainwater harvesting and improved sanitation and

hygiene habit by waste management.

Natural disaster – setting up flood contingency plan in collaboration with BPBD DKI Jakarta

(DKI Jakarta Regional Disaster Management Agency)

Population and social problem – the impact from MURIA is indirect to this issue.

MURIA's scope is way too small, even though it is a successful platform so far. It only covers 2 RW

(neighborhood) and they are often running out of human resource to help them with the on-site

project.

MURIA's Challenges

a) Lack of engagement and sense of belonging, in order to create a better future of Jakarta.

They shall be ready to facilitate the different intentions or hopes within the project, so they

could minimize frictions between parties (communities-government-CSO-

scholars/academics)

b) Joint-agenda has not been set out yet, since each stakeholder is still focusing on their own

project and often coming up with their ego.

c) Innovative idea for city resilience is still needed, especially when it involves stakeholders from

private sectors (esp. in search for business investment model).

Scaling Up for Greater Impact

Multi-stakeholder needs to contribute in city development plan, starting from kelurahan to city

level.

Project replication and wider range of action (for urban farming, rainwater harvesting, waste

management, disaster contingency)

Developing Jakarta spatial plan. Urban farming is nonsense, if we are not concern on city

spatial planning. Spatial planning is not only about lands, but also about available space

around the city, such as rooftop, parking lots, etc. KARINA is currently setting out an urban

farming grand design for Jakarta, highlighting on land use.

Page 17: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

16

V. Repedibo (Anies-Sandi Ex-Campaign Team Member)

Food security is crucial matters and it is not only government's problem, because in the future we

are all facing the same problem. The issue would be no longer oil and gas. Political instability may

also affect food security.

Speaking of spatial plan, the newly elected governor of Jakarta had committed to focus on urban

farming and e-Food. It will need immediate support and collaboration from multi parties. Together

we have to develop specific spatial plan and regulations regarding the issue.

As we all know, urban farming is not about selling the modules, but the most important thing is the

education of sustainable living. We have already included it in our annual 2018 budgets, but we will

certainly need your help to attain self-sufficiency in food production in Jakarta. The government

cannot do it alone.

Jakarta is the center of consumption, not production, so most of commodity price highly depends on

supplies from other cities. Therefore, we saw this as a compulsion to be self-sufficient in providing

food for ourselves. It does not mean we are cutting the distribution chain short, but the more suitable

word for it is efficiency. Nobody is overlapping others.

Perhaps provincial government has to start cooperating with many producers here, including urban

farmers and digital e-farming enthusiasts.

Discussion

Question (Q). 1. First question goes to Mr. Tri Leksono, what is the definition of urban farming? Is it

a conventional farming but done in urban area or it requires special techniques? As seen on your

presentation, it is not different from the conventional (using soils, etc.) but it is done in urban area,

because at first I thought urban farming is using different technology, built in vertical landscape, and

about optimizing small size land.

Second, Ms. Ade, as far as I'm concerned, organic product needs to be certified first, before it is

marketed with organic label. Some might say, soil in Java is already contaminated, so it will be

impossible to have organic product here. Do you have any organic certification or any reasons

behind the organic labelling on your project? From four presentations I saw earlier, yours is the only

one who shows the business side of urban farming. I wonder, how did you recruit your employee

and how much is the salary? Is it competitive enough if compared to other professions?

Mr. Ridho, does the rooftop project profitable or just accessory/aesthetic purpose? Is it feasible?

And the last question goes to Mr. Repedibo, if government has shown their support for agriculture

industries, are there any special regulations or policy for land and building tax for agricultural

purpose? Or perhaps tax decrease for agricultural land?

Answer (A).1. How to grow crops in urban farming is actually the same with the conventional one

(the seeds, medium and methods), but the problem is the plot, since we live in the city and only have

limited space. We could use our preference to grow it, either with soils in containers, half-pipes,

hydroponic, or even aquaponic.

A.1.2. About organic labeling, some says organic farming is about not using hazardous chemical

Page 18: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

17

such as pesticide or insecticide on your crops. But for me, organic farming means you revitalize the

soils in natural way. Certification is important, but we could not afford the cost of organic certification,

because it is very expensive. Each vegetable has its own certificate and we could not afford it for

every vegetable we produced.

In terms of business, our farm is 3 hectares in size, we are making our own organic fertilizer,

providing growing medium (topsoil made of mixed compost and cocopeats) and producing micro

greens and edible flowers. Those are our income source, so we could pay 5 employees. For the

farmers, each will receive IDR 1,5 million/month, a supervisor will receive IDR 3 million/month and a

fertilizer technician that we pay daily. We also provide their accommodation and meals. This amounts

match provincial minimum wage for farmers, which different from factory workers.

One of our biggest challenges is farm security. Many people that used to live in the area, often came

to our farm. Some of them felt as if they still own the land, so they could do whatever they please. In

some occasions, someone took our machines or electrical devices, but they never took farming

supplies and our crops.

Comment (C).1.2. I once heard about prohibition of selling non-certified organic products but

claiming itself as organic products. That means without certification, we could not sell it to the

market/public. Do you have any solution for this?

A. 1.2.1. Well, that is actually our problem. People need healthy food, while organic certification

sometimes inhibits people’s access to proper food. Certification leads to higher price and organic

food will be a luxurious item once again, then people will choose the chemically produced

vegetables/fruits because of the lower price. Hence we decided to sell it directly door-to-door or at

the farm.

C.1.2.2. My suggestion is, from now on you may avoid the usage of word “organic”. You could just

easily say “healthy/nutritious/fresh vegetables”.

C.1.2.3. We do not use “organic vegetables” label on Jakarta Berkebun's product, but we use the

term “healthy vegetables”.

A.1.3. Ideally, 30% from the land we had in Jakarta is meant to be open/green space, but not all of

us had it. But if you change your mindset and imagine if you turn 1% of your land into urban farming

plot, then there will be 500 hectares plots in Jakarta. If we could get this into city regulation/policy, I

guess no one will objected with the size (considerably small). There will be extra income

approximately IDR 27 billion and if you convert it to income, there will be 9,000 workers who will

receive IDR 3 million.

About the rooftop project, some of them has already turns into business and the other is still for

aesthetic purposes. It depends on the company's policy. For instance, one of our projects at PT.

Bukaka was originally built for aesthetic purpose, but now they are planning to turn it into business.

Our plots are not always for aesthetic purposes, but we built them as pleasing as it can be, so people

would interest to interact with it. At least they have to be nice to look at.

Speaking of government program, they have a similar program launched by DKPKP. Now it is about

shifting your paradigm, that government official is hard to collaborate with. They actually have a lot

of programs in urban farming in near future, urban farming enthusiast could chip in or support them.

Page 19: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

18

Q.1.3.1. Does urban farming is proven feasible in terms of business?

A.1.3.1. Yes, it does. One of our successful plots is the one in Gading Nias Apartment. We needed

3 months to grow seeds, now the plots could provide fresh vegetable supplies for market tenants at

lower ground (of the apartment). Many housing developers are interested to create such plots on

their properties, because it is profitable. Or if there is a vacant land, instead of using it as “kos-kosan”

(or townhouse/mini-condo), it could be use as urban farming land or even better you could have a

townhouse with an urban farming plots on it. In Setu, Bekasi-West Java, few houses own rooftop

urban farming plots and they use hydroponic system. Urban farming is not always remained as

hobby, but turning it into business is another level. As Mr. Repedibo said earlier, education shall be

the first priority.

A.1.4. About land and building tax that goes higher nowadays, it is like a chain reaction. We

discussed this idea with our team, owners of idle lands or space are obliged to use it as urban farming

plots, if not, they shall pay for higher taxes. But this is only an early discussion, still subject to change.

We could not decrease the land and building tax, because now there are too many stakeholders

already involved. With the new elected government, we tried to set up new regulations and asking

the property developers to involve in it. As a starter, an urban farming plots for aesthetic purpose in

new real estate is enough. We would like to ask everybody to think about a sustainable future.

C.1.4. KARINA is now developing urban farming grand design for Jakarta. Before we started working

on the plan, we defined what urban farming is. If we unsure with the definition, then how can we

work on the grand scheme. Then we got the definition “urban farming is about growing and taking

care of plants/crops and livestock in urban area, with purposes as mention below:

(1) to maintain and improve food production and food security

(2) to improve social and economic aspects

(3) to manage the sustainability of natural resource

In terms of space (not lands), together with DKPKP, Cipta Karya Lingkungan Hidup, Biro Tapem

(National Civics Bureau), Biro Hukum (Bureau of Law), BAPPEDA (Regional Development Planning

Agency), we are suggesting five areas that should have urban farming plots: in low-income housing

projects (rumah susun), idle space/lands, office buildings (government and private sectors), schools

and child-friendly integrated open spaces (RPTRA). Urban farming will be integrated in school

curriculum too.

Q.2. I'm an urban farmer and I wonder about upcoming provincial government's program for urban

farming in Jakarta, is it still supporting our initiatives? Would the “30:30 commitment” still present?

(30:30 commitment is about green building, a commitment to reduce energy and water consumption

and carbon dioxide emission from building in Jakarta up to 30% by the year of 2030)?

Q.2. Urban farming and agriculture issue will be one of our priorities in upcoming city planning. Our

strategies to support urban farming initiatives are organic fertilizer procurement, mentorship &

coaching, providing information on agricultural issues (in collaboration with digital farming portal). E-

farming platform could be an informative or commercial portal.

C.3. This is the first time I met urban farming enthusiasts and communities in Jakarta. Yesterday I

was wondering, if it possible to develop urban farming in Jakarta. Jakarta as central of consumptions,

heavily relied on West and Central Java as main food producers. The government has two big

Page 20: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

19

problems: inflation and food security. For instance, the last time the price of chili peppers was

rocketed high, it was all over the news. But I realized, the weakness is on food logistic, there is no

central of food distribution or regulation about it. In 2005 Jakarta had a sub terminal for agribusiness

products, but it was no longer functioning.

As for now, we have to figure out on how to bring urban farming as an initiative, as well as business

model. If we took it only as initiative without business as “fuel”, it would be stagnant and vice versa.

If we took it only for business/profits without any value, probably it will not sell well. The newly elected

government is highly concern on price fluctuation and inflation, especially for commodity such as

tomato, shallot and chili. Those are spices and vegetables that could easily grow in lowlands and

city. I guess, urban farmers here are experts on this field.

54% of organic waste from is now become a problem too in Jakarta. Many vegetable or fruit

producers are carrying the whole thing along with their harvested crops. “Sub Terminal Agribisnis”

(STA or sub terminal for agribusiness) regulated this kind of waste, by limiting them from entering

the market. As all STAs are no longer operating nowadays, there is no terminal to control and

supervise the waste. I am suggesting to re-open the STA and urban farmers community could ensure

there is an access to it.

Q.4. Please let me introduce myself, I'm here as a representative of Komunitas Kata Tanah, that had

just been formed last Saturday and it consists of government officials, private sectors, media,

hobbyists and scholars. We decided to join the forum today to widen our networks. I got questions

for Mr. Tri Leksono & Mr. Repedibo. With two years experience in Ridwan Kamil's program

“Kampung Berkebun”, an urban farming initiative in RW (neighborhood) levels in Bandung, I reached

a conclusion that urban farming is often taken as short-term or temporary project by local

communities. The government actually had allocated budget for the maintenance, but no one is

really using it.

An additional note to Mr. Harris, what if we developed a urban farming educational plan for

commercial use. From my experience, people would only harvest their crops 1-2 times, before they

gradually forgot. At least the education program would improve the sustainability of urban farms.

A.4. It happens all the time, urban agricultures are not always sustainable, because most of the time,

it was manage by community or person. In “Jakarta Berkebun”, we attempt to hold routine activities,

but in the same time we realized, we could not force them to participate in all of our activities. One

of the plus point of urban farming initiative in Bandung is a top-down government program, which

could be an enforcement point for the local community. The mayor has given the 'rod and baits', but

the community has a minimal willingness to continue the project. They only aim for the 'fish' (or

harvested product/commercial benefit, in urban farming context). It is personal choice, whether you

are going to continue or not.

A.4.1. Basically I agree, that education on urban farming had became the first priority, but we'd better

not forget the most important thing: commitment. We also need commitment from the government

and collaboration between private sectors and farmers. In the newly elected governor's programs,

he already included multi-stakeholders collaboration for food security in Jakarta, so each

stakeholders really understand what the program's objectives and expected outcomes.

We no longer have time for discussion, because it only matters of days. One of the objectives on

“First 100 days of Anies-Sandi” is food price stabilization, so we will need support from each

Page 21: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

20

stakeholder. We are going to be more proactive, with the help of HIPMI (Indonesian Young

Entrepreneurs Association

A.4.2. Speaking of education, I agree with Mr. Repedibo.

Q.5. I am a member of Himpunan Pengusaha Muda Indonesia (HIPMI or Indonesian Young

Entrepreneurs Association) as the Head of Department of Agribusiness. Nowadays, bottom-up

program is highly on demand, while top-down program is no longer wanted. We are planning a

community roadshow, to gather opinions about urban farming from communities or enthusiasts. Now

I'm asking the audience here, what are your suggestions for positioning of HIPMI within the issue?

I also would like to enlist other urban farming issues, aside from food security, for instance farmer

regeneration. Do you have any other crucial issues, which require clear action plan and further

collaboration?

A.5. Price stability, please do not set it too low or high. The higher the price is, the more people

interested in stealing it. Fair price is all we need. If the price is higher because of natural disturbance

(change of seasons, etc.), it is a common thing. As long as we reach turnover points or even had a

bit profit from our sales, we will be just fine.

C.5.1 If Jakarta always depends on supplies from other cities, then it will never sustain itself. For

price stability, how about cooperating with producer at the other regions to keep each other's eye on

production stability.

C.5.2. About food supplies from farmers, nowadays Superindo has continuous supply from farmers.

They are facing the same marketing challenge, it is hard to decide to whom and where they should

sell their products. Not all middlemen are evil, many of them are nice and practicing fair trade to

farmers. If we are scattered, i.e. each of us making our own urban farming and trade system, then it

will be harder for the modern market to collect our products. It would be better if it is centralized.

Andro’s question earlier made us think of a professional and well-structured depository system and

warehouse to circulate harvests from urban farmers. On that level, they are no longer thinking about

soil’s fertility, but things like terms of payment. We all know that modern market’s term of payment

is 3-weeks up to 1 month. Superindo has an agreement with BNI (Bank Negara Indonesia –

Indonesian State Bank) to pay the farmer within 5 days, while Superindo will pay to BNI (the amount

they paid to farmers) with normal term of payment (3 weeks). It is like BNI gives temporary loan for

Superindo to pay the farmers, so it will not disturb the Superindo’s financial cycle. The 3-weeks

payment is more profitable for Superindo, but not for the farmer.

There shall be a division of labour, there are urban farmers and also people who takes care of the

business and marketing.

C.5.3. In farming business, the process itself is pretty complicated, there should be someone whose

role is a risk-taker for farming utilities or for someone who starts up the business.

Q.6. Recently I heard about the positive point of organic certification, but somehow it becomes a

boomerang for small-scale farmers or farmer who has limited access to financial resource and the

certification process is severely long. Are there any other options to show the values of each farmer’s

product, e.g. how organic their crops are?

Why we thought so? We learnt form Rainwater Harvesting in Marunda. We got used to the fact, that

mineral water (or bottled mineral water) is good, but we actually have no idea at all what is inside.

Page 22: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

21

Through the tests ran by local community, we discovered that mineral water is not better than the

other source. The pH and TDS level is not that pure or good as stated in commercial. Local

community has prior knowledge how to test the water, so they could spread it to other community or

public. It is not only about selling purified water. It is also about to change people’s behavior, to be

more critical about things they consumed. In relation to urban farming, perhaps we could do similar

things, as substitute for organic certification. People will learn how to differentiate the quality of foods

especially the organic ones, so they will have no doubt in consuming it.

A.6. As far as I know, for organic farming there are many criteria to be fulfilled. Including the water

we used to water our field and the neighbouring farm. If the neighbouring farm is non-organic/using

chemical, wind could carry residue of hazardous chemical to our farm. This little thing would lead us

to failure to get organic certificate. Other things we could do, is simply by branding our product with

other names (that is not including “organic”). Organic certification is not an easy task and it has

ratings too (1-5 stars). Example: for 5-stars rate, distance between organic farm and conventional

farm should be at least 30 km.

C.6.1. We need more research papers or data about water and other farming needs regarding the

organic farming. We need it to check whether our farming practice is already in organic farming

corridors or not.

C.6.2. Speaking of organic rice, there are groups in Boyolali, Central Java under CSO namely PEKO

and also groups in East Nusa Tenggara. PEKO is providing their groups an international organic

certification for the products. They paid for it in more economical price and the farmer groups are

annually supervised. This initiative turns Boyolali into an area for organic food producer and the local

government finally decided to buy organic certification by SNI (Indonesian National Standard,

regulated by National Standardization Agency of Indonesia). The certification process consists of 5

years turning conventional farm into an organic one. Therefore, it is possible for local government to

buy organic certification.

About the organic label, perhaps we could learn from story of women network in Solo who regularly

sharing their knowledge and marketing organic products (organic rice, etc.), after the government

has confiscated self-proclaiming organic rice and vegetable producer, which later proven for

marketing false organic product.

C.6.3. The community will eventually learn about organic farming products and how their food is

made. Probably we need an educational center or information center, with experts who could provide

us knowledge about organic products, the process and nutritional value in it, as well as knowledge

to spot an organic product on the market.

Before it is exported, our latest harvest from Pengalengan, West Java, had been tested locally for

pesticide and declared as pesticide-free. But they could not get into Singaporean market, since they

found traces of pesticide there. What we learned from this experience, each country has different

ppm standards for pesticides. So we have to really pay attention to it if we are targeting export

market.

Q.6.4. To measure the pesticide level like that, is the tool similar to TDS meter?

A.6.4 Yes, it is similar to TDS meter.

C.7. If we are going to collaborate with certification agency, the (certification) price might be not as

high as the usual. This will work out well if there is a revenue system. At the beginning the profits

Page 23: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

22

might seems not significant, but if there were a system as safety net (to keep the financial stability),

I think the company will keep investing on the project.

There are two things to follow up: about the collaboration with private sector (and organic certification

agency) and knowledge sharing between us.

C.7.1. There is a company, who already has a certification system. They have organic rice varieties

such as Pandan Wangi, Rojo Lele or black rice. For export market, they mixed these varieties. This

could be an idea for business model, urban farmers produces crops, and they could send it to

company with certification system to get their products certificated. Therefore, they could export their

products.

Page 24: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

23

Urban Farming from Four Aspects

Participants will write their comments or hopes on urban farming on Post-It Notes (provided)

and put it on 4 columns on the wall, categorized by these aspects: Production Method and

Technology, Production Capacity and Market, Sustainability, Identifying Needs of Supports)

(Documentation of Participants’ Notes)

Production Method and

Technology

Using verticulture method for limited space/land

Good agricultural practice in urban farming, since the

farming product is risk sensitive

Hydroponic

Verticulture

Education of good agricultural practice

Building a pergola (or climbing plants or vines)

Harvest on demand, online/internet integrated farming

Depends on space and land size, could be hydroponic or

organic.

Seeking for other high-value commodity

Farmer will be directly connected with middleman

Hydroponic is one of the suitable methods for urban

farming, since it only requires smaller space and could be

done vertically.

Using high-yield variety seeds to achieve higher

productivity.

We need apps like Uber (or Go-Jek in Indonesia) that

could seek other’s help to take care of our plant when we

are away. We could name them as Go-Garden, for

instance.

Methods in urban farming are mostly depends on

availability of space/land, water, growing media and other

planting factors. They could be adjusted on owner’s

preference too, either it is organic, verticulture, hydroponics

or even aquaponics.

Hydroponics.

Rooftop urban farming

Modern farming such as using hydroponics or verticulture

system.

Rotating the plants, so we could harvest it in daily basis.

Production Capacity and Market

Each neighborhood (or RW) is producing food for

themselves

Collaborating with local IT-company to develop internet

solution for urban farming initiatives.

Page 25: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

24

Each house has at least an urban farming plot and each

time they harvest, they would gather it, to fulfill their needs

and sell the rest at the nearest market.

Each household produces food and they could collect in a

central depository in the neighborhood.

Urban farmer shall be connected with each other and

produce together. The harvests could be store in

warehouse/depository.

Use of technology to increase productivity (precision

farming)

A house with 2x2 m2 land could grow their own food and

sell the excess to their neighbor.

One village, one product.

Farmers-based distribution central.

Forming a community of producers.

Creating an innovative and creative business model for

urban farming initiative.

Product diversification by providing more varieties of

seeds, including weeds.

Production should be coordinated, communal, not

individual.

One commodity per neighborhood.

Building a strong partnership.

Sustainability System for supervision, evaluation and transparency.

Collaboration between stakeholders.

Workshop.

Educational garden/farm plot.

Socialization & farmer's market.

Market sustainability.

Socialization and internet-based campaign (so it gets viral).

Bounding between farmers

Farmer's market

Incentives for urban farmers

Page 26: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

25

Seeking for wider space or land.

Marketing via networking, start-ups or online business.

Sustainability will be achieved, if there was a system,

coordinated by professionals and supervised by the

government.

Socialization and urban farming demo event in schools.

Technical assistance form experts.

Multi-stakeholders discussion and collaborations for urban

farming issues.

An organization to ensure the quality of harvest (as quality

controller)

An organization to gather or distribute products to end-user

with minimum margin.

Sustainable market access.

Education

Research

Education, assistance and evaluation.

Continuous assistance and development in urban farming

development.

Farmers regeneration

Training and motivational push.

Support from areas that supplies food for Jakarta.

Establishing an information portal for research in how to

increase production.

Needs of Support Knowledge sharing with community and institutions.

Private sectors (through CSR)

Government shall have regulation about urban farming,

e.g. 1% of the land/space we own, should be turns into

urban farming plot.

Continuous supervision.

Affordable organic certification facility.

Community that connected with government, NGO,

financial and academics/educational institution.

Page 27: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

26

Support from provincial/local government in order to make

urban farming happens, such as Regional Plantation

Agency and Ministry of Trade.

Affordable seeds.

Capital supports

Sharing of innovation within the community.

Incentive for active urban farmers/urban farming

enthusiasts.

Supports from private sectors and government to be off-

taker of farming products, such as Bulog (Badan Urusan

Logistik or Indonesian Bureau of Logistics), restaurant,

café and hotel.

Micro-finance access.

Involvement of ‘Himpunan Mahasiswa Pertanian Indonesia’

(or Association of Indonesian Agricultural Students.

Academics/researchers.

Involvement (active) from wider audience/public.

Involving ‘Karang Taruna’ (or local youth community) as

human resource

A solid and active multi-stakeholder platform.

Intensive assistance from related government agency or

office.

Page 28: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

27

Networking Session

This session divided in 3 parts:

1. Pitching/matchmaking (based on prior registration forms)

2. Networking session

3. Online Platform Presentation

Pitching Session

(Each registered participants has 2-3 minutes to promote themselves, their organizations, initiatives,

products or service. They could also announce if they require service, products or support from

others. There will be 2 slot and each slots will consist of 3 participants.)

YSEALI (Putra Aditya – Embassy of the United States of America)

I’m going to promote the youth program called Young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiatives (YSEALI).

YSEALI is a platform for Southeast Asia youth between 18-35 years old, who has developed

initiatives in their own community. Our 4 big themes are education, sustainable development, civic

engagement & economic empowerment. There are many offerings available within the platform, from

1-month academic and professional exchanges in the U.S, thematic regional workshop in Southeast

Asian countries, and project grants competition. We also offer wide-range network to friends in

Indonesia and other ASEAN countries, who has similar interests, to do something together.

Thomas Pandu (MIFA)

Together with my team, we are recently developing an affordable urban-farming business model.

Our visions-missions are: first, to make organic food more affordable; second, to develop urban

farming system to be more urban area friendly and requires less maintenance. Starting from planting

the seeds to harvest time, we don’t even need to touch them and could be grown organically. We

could test its organic factors, since we tried to limit the disturbing factor that usually appeared in

ordinary organic farming. Perhaps among us there are starter, who is not ready for maintaining

bigger plot size (e.g. measuring soil’s acidity, temperature, adjusting soil’s need, etc.), what we are

developing now might be the answer. We tried to be as simple as possible, all we have to do is

waiting for harvest time.

As we are still a start-up project, we still need more feedbacks from you (customer’s experiences).

Today, for the first seven persons who came up to me, there are modules with special price (original

price is IDR 350,000, special price for today IDR 100,000). To grow seeds in the module, you only

need to water it, no need to fertilize and other high-maintenance stuff or treatments.

Page 29: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

28

Arie (‘Institut Pertanian Bogor’ or Bogor Agricultural University Alumna)

Now I’m on Creative Agriculture Management business, focusing on education of urban farming with

hydroponic system. Together with team, we held knowledge-sharing session in school and

universities. We are not only sharing about urban farming, but also trash management/trash

recycling (especially on styrofoam and plastic containers). We sell hydroponic modules with

affordable price, also we provide the hydroponic growing medium (rockwool, etc.) as well as its

nutrition supplies (that we made ourselves).

Rosemary

I came from community of housewives in a Buddhist organization. I am actively contributing in

‘Koperasi Maju” in Puri Kembangan, West Jakarta. This weekend, Saturday and Sunday, September

16-17, 2017, we will hold an expo and workshops on farming. It is open for public and free of charge.

We invited people from Trubus (well-known agricultural magazine in Indonesia) and its sister

company and many more.

Yudha (Yayasan Rumah Energi)

‘Yayasan Rumah Energi’ (YRE) is an organization formed by Hivos to continue the BIRU program

(Biogas Rumah or Indonesian Domestic Biogas Programme). BIRU aims to promote the use of

biodigesters as a local and sustainable energy. Biodigesters are using biogas from cattle and it is a

good source of organic fertilizers. There are 10 provinces since we started in 2009 namely Lampung,

Banten, Yogyakarta, East Java, Bali, Lombok, West Sumbawa, Sumba and South Celebes. We

facilitate and distribute products from our biogas user in form of organic fertilizer to be used in urban

farming. Until now, in Jakarta there are not so many people use this biogas system, since it requires

areas near livestock farm (cattle, chickens, quails) and lemna plants (duckweed).

The nearest BIRU project site from Jakarta is in Bekasi. We are still establishing more spots, so they

could provide energy needs in Jakarta. If you have business or partners in soya bean processing

industry (e.g. tofu industry) and they need to install biogas system, you could contact YRE.

Promoting Online Platform

Maula Paramitha Wulandaru

AgriProFocus is a multi-stakeholder network in the agricultural sector consisting of farmer

entrepreneurs, private sector enterprises, CSOs, knowledge institutions, government officials.

AgriProFocus network members collaborate to strengthen the position of farmers and other agri-

entrepreneurs in agricultural value chains. We use an online platform to make knowledge-sharing

and interaction process easier for each AgriProFocus members in all around the globe. We shared

our discussion/meeting notes and materials from trusted resource within the platform too. Please do

sign up, if you are interested.

(Mitha demonstrated the sign-up process and AgriProFocus site walkthrough)

If you already signed up, you will be lead automatically to “Pool of Expert”. You could also build your

Page 30: NETWORK & LEARNING EVENT URBAN FARMING INITIATIVES IN ... · 1) Participants will get better understanding of urban farming initiatives in Jakarta. 2) To come up with solution(s)

29

own sub-web for your organizations. If you are going to promote your event, you could easily fill in

the “Event” section and it will be automatically sent as promotional e-mail blast to all AgriProFocus

users. We have “Market Place” section too, where you could promote your products or services, and

we are helping you to get wider audience by spreading the news through our newsletter mailing list.

Within the platforms, there are thousands of contacts of worldwide AgriProfocus networks and it is

accessible for all users.

On the site we also provide agricultural information, for instance, a marketplace for Gayo (Aceh)

coffee, published reports, job vacancies, fellowships and scholarships info and open call for grants.

Also, we published latest agricultural news, including events by AgriProFocus Network, such as our

latest campaign to promote farmers regeneration through Young Farmer Ambassador.

Actually we could do almost anything within AgriProFocus platform. For instance after this event, we

could establish a coalition to create an ideal urban farming environment in the city. In AgriProFocus,

we called it member coalition (formerly known as Innovation Community).

Closing

We are waiting for your your participation on AgriProFocus online platform, please sign up and join

us.

If you are interested in other participants program, we have their brochures up front. Thank you for

your participation in today's networking and learning event, hope it gives you better understanding

at urban farming issue.