8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
1/26
!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. "-*$% ,/*-0!"/
"12 334/56
.789: 56 /;
"-*$% ,/*-0!"/ /''-,!/$!-" -. &?(,/$-*'@ !",2@ *!,%/*? A2
"!B-"@ *%-"?/ %-0+&'@ C*!/" 0!"D@ /""&$$& C&/$$E@ '$&)%/"!&F/00/,&@ GH: A-%" ?&I!00&
J2
$%& '$/$& -. "-*$% ,/*-0!"/
/;;9G8 ;K '2&23: 5 S3=56T@ GUU79 *"%6- .$N4&/ B'% H#"#$ >LA='-$$&
@&&'?4"#4'( 'B 7'%#; 3"%'=4("/ O(?9/ "L4?2& ?2%4"$9
&?+("?'@ AKLM7X92
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
2/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q3Q
$he North Carolina Constitution provides that “[t]he people have a right to the
;
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
3/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
QRQ
/L G GH: ̀ 2P G
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
4/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q[Q
*9J79_ ,1VV7MM99 ;
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
5/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q6Q
MW9 LXW118 \1G
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
6/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q>Q
expanded the definition of “demote” to include L1V9 X7
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
7/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
QPQ
M9GXW9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
8/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q4Q
M9LM7V1H]
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
9/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q`Q
M9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
10/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5=Q
MWGM L9XM71HL `2> GH: `2P 1U MW9 /XM G
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
11/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q55Q
V1M71H M1 LMG] MW9 M
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
12/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q53Q
VGb1
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
13/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5RQ
KHX1HJ7HX9: that repealing the Career Status Law “was a reasonable and necessary
V9GHL M1 G:JGHX9 MWGM ;K '2&23: GM 562 $W9 VGb1
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
14/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5[Q
3`2 $W9 'MGM9 G;;9G89: M1 MW7L ,1K
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
15/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q56Q
/XX1 S5`46T2 ,1HLM
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
16/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5>Q
(“[M]any MW7HZL :1H9 \] MW9 'MGM9 VG] L99V M1 W18: 1KM ;P>2 $W9 'K;PP2 %1_9J9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
17/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5PQ
!M L;9G^L 1U MW9 VG^7HZ GH: XGHX9887HZ 1U 7H:9U7H7M9 X1HM
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
18/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q54Q
$W1KZW MW9 \9H9U7ML _1K8: \9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
19/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q5`Q
!H G::7M71H@ MW9 1UMQGV9H:9: X1K
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
20/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q3=Q
X1HL9XKM7J9 ]9G
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
21/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q35Q
X1HM
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
22/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q33Q
or federal law.” O69 O 556,QR362RS9T S3=56T2 !U MW9 LK;9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
23/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q3RQ
7HM9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
24/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q3[Q
F9 UK88] GZ
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
25/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
Q36Q
M9GXW9
8/18/2019 NCAE v. NC
26/26
",/& I2 '$/$&
PA4(4'( 'B #;$ 3'2%#
3>
LK\LMGHM7G88] 7V;G7