8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
1/22www.americanprogress.o
Navigating Political Currentsto Achieve Middle East PeaceAmerican Leadership Is Vital
David A. Halperin and Matthew Duss September 2010
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
2/22
Navigating Political Currentsto Achieve Middle East PeaceAmerican Leadership Is Vital
David A. Halperin and Matthew Duss September 2010
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
3/22
1 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Introduction and summary
Te ae o he direc alks beween Israelis and Palesinians will be signicanly
deermined by he exen o which he leaders on each side are able and willing o
navigae he consrains o heir respecive domesic poliics. I is also clear ha
he renewed Israeli-Palesinian negoiaions will require susained and deermined
U.S. involvemen rom he onse even hough he Unied Saes is in he hick o
is own mid-erm elecions.
Israelis and Palesinians launched direc negoiaions on Sepember 1 aer morehan a year o U.S. eors o bring hem o he negoiaing able, including our
monhs o indirec alks aciliaed hrough U.S. mediaion.
Te long awaied re-launch o negoiaions has eecively raised he sakes or
Israelis and Palesinians, demanding ha ocials in Jerusalem and Ramallah make
he poliically dicul decisions ha hey have successully avoided unil now.
I also raises he sakes or Presiden Barack Obama, who has made i clear since
aking oce ha he considers reaching a negoiaed end o he Israeli-Palesinian
conic o be a key U.S. ineres.
We raveled o he region his summer while he Unied Saes worked o
move he paries rom indirec o direc alks. We me wih dozens o Israeli
and Palesinian ocials and analyss rom across he poliical specrum during
he rip, as well as U.S. ocials in he region. Neiher Israelis nor Palesinians
repored a he ime o have a clear undersanding o he U.S. sraegy or uli-
maely achieving a susainable resoluion o he wo-sae conic. Each appeared
o use he salemae preceding he launch o direc alks o srenghen heir polii-
cal sandings wih heir respecive publics. One ormer Israeli ocial old us a
he ime, Israelis and Palesinians are working hard o posiion hemselves orhe ailure o direc alks. Tey wan o show ha he oher side is o blame or
he ailure o he peace process.1
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
4/22
2 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Now ha he Obama adminisraion has launched direc alks, i will need o work
wih Prime Miniser Benjamin Neanyahu and Palesinian Auhoriy Presiden
Mahmoud Abbas in order o help hem overcome heir respecive poliical
consrains o advance he newly launched alks and build wha will hopeully be
a new and robus sraegy or achieving a lasing resoluion o he conic. Boh
leaders mus avoid esablishing a posiion aimed a shedding blame or he alkspoenial ailure and mus demonsrae poliical courage by ariculaing a vision
ha promoes he esablishmen o wo saes as a realizaion o heir respecive
naional aspiraions and ideals, raher han as a compromise o hem. Neanyahu
and Abbas will a he same ime be challenged o rise above he inuence o
rejecioniss who will undoubedly inensiy heir eors o hwar progress, as he
recen atacks in he Wes Bank indicae. Tis could be heir las chance o do so
given growing quesions abou he viabiliy o he wo-sae soluion.
Teir success will require inensive U.S. suppor and leadership o ensure ha he
dispue over setlemens does no disrup he alks a he sar, o engage he Arabsaes in conribuing o he poliical process, o encourage he leaders o rame a
wo-sae soluion as inegral o heir naional ideals, and o consisenly commu-
nicae Americas sraegic and vesed ineres in he success o his eor.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
5/22
3 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Israel: Talks will test
Netanyahus coalition
Te re-launching o direc negoiaions provides he Unied Saes wih an oppor-
uniy o es wheher Israeli Prime Miniser Neanyahus acions will mach his
rheoric in suppor o a wo-sae soluion. Neanyahu had or monhs leading ino
he alks consisenly presened Israel as eager o begin negoiaions, while casing
he Palesinians as rejecioniss. Ye Neanyahu and his governmen have closely
wihheld any public exposure o key posiions Israel migh ake on he core issues
o be negoiaed.
Israelis balked when he Unied Saes called or a complee setlemen reeze las
summer, which would include Eas Jerusalem and he so-called naural growh
o exising setlemens. Israel ulimaely agreed in January o esablish a 10-monh
moraorium on consrucion in he Wes Bank setlemen, bu no in Eas
Jerusalem aer monhs o discussionand a imes ensionbeween he Unied
Saes and Israel. U.S. ocials a he ime hailed he moraorium as an unprec-
edened sep despie having requesed a ull reeze.
Israeli ocials ha we me wih during our rip poined o he moraorium as an
acion Israel has already aken in order o advance he peace process, providing
evidence o heir good inenions. One Israeli ocial deanly old us, we make
concessionslike he 10-monh setlemen reezeand ge nohing in reurn.2
o be sure, Israels moraorium on Wes Bank consrucion does no represen a
genuine concession, since Israel did commi o hal setlemens under he 2003
Quare Roadmap. Bu he issue o setlemens is one ha coninues o have re-
mendous resonance among he prime minisers coaliion and consiuency.
Te prospec ha Israel will resume setlemen consrucion ollowing he
moraoriums conclusion on Sepember 26 already hreaens o derail he alks.Bu Neanyahu has saed publicly ha he does no inend o renew he reeze.3
A recen poll showed ha only 20 percen o Israelis believe ha building in
he erriories should reeze compleely, wih 39 percen supporing building
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
6/22
4 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
hroughou he Wes Bank and 36 percen supporing consrucion only wihin
he setlemen blocs.4 A poll his summer indicaed, meanwhile, ha he Israeli
public gives Prime Miniser Neanyahu high marks or his job perormance.5
Neanyahu and his governmen have also improved relaions wih he Obama
adminisraion. Te July 6 meeing beween Prime Miniser Neanyahu andPresiden Barack Obama, aer a year o ension over setlemen consrucion se
a new, posiive one in he relaionship beween he wo adminisraions. Te
Israelis we me wih lamened he ricion ha characerized he rs year o he
Obama adminisraion, bu hey lauded he recen warming in relaions as well as
securiy and inelligence cooperaionwhich one ocial described as Even be-
er han under [Presiden] Bush.
Prime Miniser Neanyahu will likely soon ace a momen o ruh, however,
where he has o reveal his posiions on a nal saus agreemen. Can he do so
while minimizing allou rom his ruling coaliion? Or will a new coaliion obe necessary? How Neanyahu addresses hese quesions while advancing he
renewed peace alks could deermine he ae o he negoiaions, as well as
Neanyahus relaionship wih he Obama adminisraion.
As one ocial old us, oday, here is a growing undersanding among Israelis
ha he saus quo wih he Palesinians does no mean a saus quo wih he
Unied Saes and he res o he world.6 Anoher old us ha, while he unda-
menals o he U.S.-Israel relaionship are srong, here is a divergence o ineress
on he Palesinian quesion Presiden Obama wans a [Palesinian] sae; Prime
Miniser Neanyahu wans a coaliion. In a choice beween a coaliion and a con-
ronaion wih he Unied Saes, [Neanyahu] will ake he coaliion.7
Progress is no impossible wih Neanyahu, bu ew Israeli analyss we spoke
o believe ha he Israeli governmen, as currenly consiued, can poliically
conclude and implemen a wo-sae soluion ha addresses he core, nal saus
issues o he conic, especially Jerusalem.
Neanyahus coaliion, which currenly has 74 seas in he 120-sea Knesse, is
dominaed by righ-wing paries: Neanyahus Likud (27 seas), Foreign MiniserAvigdor Liebermans Yisrael Beieinu (15 seas), and he Sephardic-religious Shas
pary (11 seas). Bu he coaliion also includes Deense Miniser Ehud Baraks
cener-le Labor pary, which has 13 seas ha Barak claims will be an inuenial
voice in suppor o peacemaking rom wihin he governmen.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
7/22
5 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
I is no clear, however, how long he Labor pary can remain in he coaliion.
One Labor miniser old us, I here is no progress by Sepember, here is no
reason or a liberal Zionis pary o be in his curren governmen.8 Ehud Barak
is reporedly relucan o leave he governmen, however, believing ha Labors
paricipaion is criical o he peace process and ha his role as deense miniser
is paricularly signican as concerns regarding Irans nuclear ambiions inensiy.His coninued presence in he governmen could also serve as a hindrance o new
Wes Bank setlemen consrucion, which he deense miniser in heory mus
approvehough setlers have already pledged o overcome such an obsacle. Bu
Barak may have no choice bu o leave he coaliion as he is aced wih growing
opposiion rom groups wihin his pary ha view him as a g lea or he righ-
wing governmen, especially i he alks break down.
Former Foreign Miniser zipi Livni and he Kadima pary (28 seas) meanwhile
remain ouside o he governmen as he opposiion, arguing ha he curren
Neanyahu governmen is no serious abou achieving and implemening a wo-sae soluion.
As one analys pu i, he prospec o Livni coming ino he coaliion has
become [Baraks] lieline. Ta is, i Kadima were o replace Yisrael Beieinu, or
example, he governmen would be ransormed rom a righ-leaning coaliion
skepical o he peace alks o a solidly cenris one espousing srong suppor or
he wo-sae soluion.
Kadima has wo cenral demands o ener he coaliion: a prominen role in he
negoiaing process, and an undersanding o Neanyahus endgame or he con-
ic. Neanyahu has poinedly reused o provide eiher. One Kadima ocial old
us, Wihou a reshufe o he coaliion i is no possible o go orward in a serious
way. o be a leader, you have o be willing o ake risks. [Neanyahu] has o pu
ou a vision, oherwise we will oppose himhas poliics.9
Te direc alks may orce Neanyahu o ake such risks i he wans o mainain his
curren governmen wihou being orced o rely solely on an exreme righwing
coaliion and risk losing his appeal o he cener. Neanyahu will have no one le
ha suppors he wo-sae soluionbeyond elemens o his Likud pary, whichis isel racuredi Labor leaves and Kadima reuses o join. Some analyss posi
ha Foreign Miniser Avigdor Lieberman views he prospec o a Neanyahu
ailure in alks as a chance o poach seas rom he Likud and srenghen his own
posiion or uure elecions.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
8/22
6 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
A righ-wing dominaed coaliion ha is opposed o pursuing peace would also
likely ace renewed ension wih he Unied Saes a a ime when boh governmens
hope o srenghen heir relaionship oward curbing Irans nuclear ambiions.
Foreign Miniser Lieberman said in an inerview wih Israels Yedioth Ahronoth
newspaper on Sepember 6 ha he believes his job is o serve as a voice o opposi-ion rom wihin he governmen.10 He old he paper we will no resign or bring
down he governmen, regardless o wheher or no Israel renews he curren
setlemen reeze. Lieberman and ohers on he righ are willing o give Prime
Miniser Neanyahu ime in he alks, believing ha genuine movemen oward
a wo-sae soluion is unlikely beyond rheoric. Bu as Israeli columnis Shalom
Yerushalmi wroe inMaariv: Everyone [on he righ] can swallow heir saliva and
keep silen, because we have no ye sared o ake any real acion. Tere is no one
in he governmen who ruly hinks ha Neanyahu will dismanle hundreds o
setlemens in Judea and Samaria and pariion Jerusalem.11
Te conclusion o he setlemen moraorium provides he rs es or he
Neanyahu governmen. Renewing he reeze will already elici a harsh response
rom hose on he righ. As Danny Danon, he chairman o he setler umbrella
organizaion, he Yesha Council, oldMaariv newspaper on Sepember 12, I he
reeze coninues in any way, we promise o make every eor o gh agains he
Neanyahu governmen. I will be he beginning o he end or his governmen.12
Including Labor and Kadima in he Israeli coaliion may ulimaely be necessary o
generae real acion oward an agreemenand o conclude one. Bu Neanyahu
will no marginalize his curren coaliion parners easily. Tose who closely
observe Neanyahu believe ha we can gain more rom him wih an embrace han
a cold shoulder. One ormer ocial old us, I he Unied Saes ries o bend and
no break Neanyahus coaliion, i may nd he is more exible, as he easing o he
Gaza blockade suggess.13
Agains his backdrop, a majoriy o Israelis coninue o suppor a wo-sae solu-
ion (55 percen), bu remain deeply skepical abou he prospec o he negoia-
ions and abou Presiden Obama.14
Tis is he conex wihin which he Obama adminisraion mus work wih
Neanyahu: i mus sucienly advance negoiaions wih a largely righ-wing Israeli
governmen, creaing momenum oward an agreemen, which in urn may require
Neanyahu o bring Kadima ino he governmen in order o conclude he deal.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
9/22
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
10/22
8 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
The Palestinians: Abbas needs to
prove his strength in negotiations
Palesinian Auhoriy Presiden Mahmoud Abbas was a relucan paricipan in
he ceremony a he Sae Deparmen on Sepember 2 where Secreary o Sae
Hillary Clinon hosed a press conerence wih Israeli and Palesinian ocials o
ocially launch direc negoiaions.
Abbas does no hink Israel is serious abou a wo-sae soluion, parly because o
Israels coninuing reusal o honor is commimens on setlemens. Bu Abbas,
like Neanyahu, is loah o be depiced as a rejecionis o peace. Ta is why whileAbbas agreed o come o direc alks wihou a ull Israeli setlemen reeze; he has
no given up on he demand, hreaening o leave he alks i Israel does no exend
is moraorium on consrucion beyond he Sepember 26 deadline.
While sanding up o Israel and he Unied Saes is rarely an unpopular posiion
in he region, Abbas has aced even greaer inernal pressure o prove ha he is a
srong leader ha is able o deliver a sae o he Palesinians.
Te Palesinian leader old reporers ha, in opposing direc alks wih Israel
wihou receiving assurances on setlemen consrucion and a ramework or he
negoiaions, I am under a kind o pressure I haven been hrough all my lie. 15
A leaked inernal Palesinian memo conrmed his senimen, saing, Going
o direc alks while he Israeli governmen reuses o sop setlemen aciviies
and reuses o coninue alks where hey le o in December 2008 would be like
poliical suicide.16
Abbass iniial resisance o direc alks wihou a ull setlemen reeze was a
shrewd poliical move as much as i was a acical one in advance o negoiaions.
His insisence since agreeing o ener direc alks ha Israel coninue is setle-men reeze in he Wes Bank in order or he alks o coninue beyond he reezes
Sepember 26 deadline also represens an eecive poliical posure.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
11/22
9 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
A poll aken aer he launch o direc alks in Washingon indicaes ha 57
percen o Palesinians believe he proximiy alks did no achieve any progress
in he peace process.17 Bu he same poll shows ha 64 percen o Palesinians
would suppor direc negoiaions wih he condiions o a setlemen reeze and
inernaional guaranees.
Ye Abbass own Faah acion remains splinered, ueling public skepicism abou
he alks. Abbas posponed municipal elecions his pas July due o pary rag-
menaion in a number o disrics despie eors a a conerence las summer in
Behlehem o uniy Faah around a pary plaorm. A similar lack o pary discipline
caused various Faah-aliaed candidaes o run agains one anoher in January
2006, spliting voes and enabling Hamas o win a majoriy o he seas in he
Palesinian Legislaive Council, despie only winning 44 percen o he voe com-
pared o a combined 56 percen or Faah and oher naional-secularis paries.
An American ocial old us during one o our meeings ha, Tere is somerevival o people [in Faah] recognizing he need or messaging and o esablish a
rue poliical pary, bu i Faah doesn ge is ac ogeher, ohers will. Ta o-
cial said ha unlike Faah, people know wha Hamas sands or and is vision.18
Te Palesinian leadership is wary o losing heir already enuous poliical man-
dae since presidenial elecions scheduled or January 2010 were also posponed,
providing uel or hose quesioning Abbass legiimacy. Te leadership claims ha
he greaes way o srenghen Abbas and Faah is o show evidence ha he peace
process can indeed succeed.
One Palesinian ocial in Ramallah, describing he challenge presened by
Hamas, old us ha, our opponens [Hamass] sraegy is o show ha negoia-
ions lead nowhere and hey claim ha heir sraegy will bring resuls. We don
wan o ake any seps ha will jusi y skepicism o he negoiaions process
We need o win he public here and in he region.19
Te Unied Saes encouraged he Arab Leagues ocial suppor o he alks in
an eor o provide Abbas wih addiional poliical cover. Some Israelis argue,
however, ha Abbass need o consul he Arab League urher demonsraes ha
he is oo weak o conclude a deal. Palesinian ocials mainain ha suppor o heArab League bolsers heir posiion and links he negoiaions o he Arab Peace
Iniiaive, which calls or he 22 members o he Arab league o normalize rela-
ions wih Israel upon a negoiaed agreemen o he Israeli-Palesinian conic.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
12/22
10 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
One Palesinian ocial old us in Ramallah, We wan hem engaged, no jus
o announce he [Arab Peace] Iniiaive and walk away. Tey need o share he
responsibiliy wih us sep by sep. Some say where is your poliical indepen-
dence? We say his is our choice o expand he eor.20
Arab suppor or Abbas will be paricularly imporan as Hamas and oher rejec-ioniss seek o disrup he poliical process, as he recen shooing atacks in he
Wes Bank indicae.
Agains his backdrop, Prime Miniser Salaam Fayyads eor o build he inra-
srucure o a Palesinian sae by nex year comes wih he impliciand some-
imes explicihrea ha he Palesinians plan o seek inernaional suppor or
a Unied Naions resoluion recognizing he esablishmen o a Palesinian sae
even in absence o a nal agreemen.21 Recen polls show ha he Palesinian
public suppors his eor, wih 65 percen o Palesinians reporing suppor or
seeking a UN Securiy Council resoluion o recognize a Palesinian sae, 60 per-cen supporing a unilaerally declared Palesinian sae, and 51 percen suppor-
ing a nonviolen resisance campaign.22 A majoriy o Palesinians a he same ime
believe ha Fayyads governmen has led o a decrease in corrupion (52 percen)
and an increase in poliical reorms (57 percen).23
Te Unied Saes suppors he Palesinian sae-building eors, bu no a uni-
laeral declaraion o saehood. Te hrea o unilaeral acion oen undermines
diplomacy and could ulimaely hreaen a genuine wo-sae arrangemen.
Te Unied Saes sraegy or advancing he peace process has unil now been
based on a botom-up, op-down approach combining economic and securiy
improvemens wih high-level negoiaions. Te botom-up approach has led o
improvemens in Palesinian economic and securiy condiions in he Wes Bank.
Bu many people we spoke o during our recen rip said ha hey believe he
Unied Saes has ailed o eecively communicae how direc alks will provide
a pah o saehood ha will complemen hese botom-up measures. Israelis and
Palesinians alike old us ha wihou a viable poliical process wih clear goals and
merics, hese improvemens only serve o make he occupaion more beauiul.24
I is doubul ha a unilaeral declaraion unsuppored by Israel or he Unied
Saes would subsanially change his dynamic. Wha would help is genuine prog-
ress in he poliical process alongside he sae-building eor. And ha requires
he Palesinians o say a he negoiaing able wih U.S. help.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
13/22
11 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Te majoriy o Palesinians coninue o suppor a wo-sae soluion and will
suppor Presiden Abbas and Palesinian leaders i hey are able o achieve ibu
some will do all hey can o see ha hey ail, including acs o errorism. Genuine
progress in he poliical process will inensiy rejecioniss ervor, bu i will pro-
vide Abbas wih ools o urn agains such violence and show ha here is indeed a
peaceul pah o saehood.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
14/22
12 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
The United States: The Obama
administration must build confidence
Te Unied Saes mus conend wih is own domesic poliics as i works wih he
paries o navigae heirs. Few Israelis or Palesinians have high hopes or he alks.
Only 32 percen o Israelis believe alks wih he Palesinians will lead o peace. 25
wo-hirds o Palesinians do no believe ha he U.S. Presiden Barack Obama
is capable o esablishing a Palesinian sae.26 Americans are equally pessimisic.
Seveny-hree percen o Americans polled a he launch o direc alks indicaed
ha hey do no believe we can achieve Middle Eas peace in he period ahead. 27
Te Whie House engaged in wha some Israeli analyss humorously reerred o
as a love campaign ollowing he ri wih Israel on setlemen consrucion o
quell he ension wih Israelis and he American Jewish communiy. American
conservaives have meanwhile atemped o capialize on hose ensions as
poliical ools or he upcoming miderm congressional elecion, alhough his
eor is highly quesionable.
A recen Gallup poll indicaed ha American Jewish approval o Presiden
Obamas job perormance has dropped consisenly wih he naional average,
bu remains considerably high a 61 percen.28 Bu he Whie Houses olerance
or ension wih Israel and he Palesinians will be challenged as he congres-
sional elecion season inensies, paricularly wih he already wide expecaion
o conservaive gains. Candidaes are likely o ollow public opinion in showing
skepicism o he Obama adminisraions abiliy o succeed in he re-launched
peacemaking eors. Ye he Whie House does no have he luxury o puting he
peace process on hold unil aer he November elecion.
Wheher he Unied Saes can simulaneously maneuver hrough poliics in
he Middle Eas and a home could depend on how much i learned rom issetlemen dispue wih Israel one year ago. Te Obama adminisraion received
criicism las summer or appearing o ocus only on he setlemen dispue, and
has again aken re his year or allowing he same percepion o arise wih regard
o direc alks. Tere is concern ha, jus as he Obama adminisraion seemed
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
15/22
13 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
unprepared o respond o Israels reusal o reeze setlemen consrucion, i also
does no have an eecive Plan B should he direc alks ge bogged down in he
absence o a renewal o Israels setlemen moraorium.
Te Obama adminisraions abiliy o couner hese percepions by eecively
communicaing is sraegy o Israel, he Palesinians, Americans, and he U.S.Congresssaring wih is approach regarding he end o he setlemen reeze on
Sepember 26could make he dierence in he success or ailure o direc alks.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
16/22
14 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
The two-state solution is
at a turning point
Te wo-sae soluion may depend on he Unied Saes abiliy o help Israel and
he Palesinians navigae pas hese obsacles. Bu here are alarming signs ha he
viabiliy o he wo-sae concepwhile sill suppored by he majoriy o Israelis
and Palesiniansis increasingly being quesioned on boh sides.
Some on he Israeli righ are becoming more vocal in suppor o a binaional sae.
Former Foreign Miniser Moshe Arens wroe in Haarez ha i is ime or Israel
o look a anoher opion: or Israel o apply is law o Judea and Samaria andgran ciizenship o 1.5 million Palesinians.24 Oher prominen gures share his
view, including he curren Speaker o he Knesse Likuds Reuven Rivlin, who
old reporers Is preerable or he Palesinians o become ciizens o he sae
han or us o divide he counry.29
Te growing Palesinian anipahy o he wo-sae soluion is equally serious.
One recen Palesinian poll indicaes ha Palesinians choose wo-saes (55
percen) over one-sae (27 percen) when presened a choice.30 Bu anoher poll
in June shows ha 52 percen oppose abandon[ing] he wo sae soluion and
demand[ing] he esablishmen o one sae or Palesinians and Israelis. 6 And a
hird poll aken jus prior o he launch o direc alks shows ha as much as 53
percen are willing o suppor, accep or consider he idea o one-join sae in which
Israelis and Palesinians are equal ciizens beween he Jordanian River and he
sea.31 In oher words, Palesinians are hesian o embrace a one-sae soluion, bu
hey are willing o enerain he idea, and some ocials are increasingly doing so.
One ocial old us ha, here are some on he Palesinian side who are emoion-
allyi no inellecuallyready o hrow in he owel on he wo-sae soluion.
Many o hese people are commited o Palesinian naionalism and recognizeha his means he end o i. Some o i is inended o creae a kind o bogeyman
eec in he even ha he peacemaking eors ail, bu some have a genuine con-
vicion ha his is jus no going o work.17 Anoher Palesinian ocial who has
long been supporive o he peace process old us ha, even a he highes levels
[Palesinian] poliicians are giving up on he wo-sae soluion, and ha he oo
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
17/22
15 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
was losing aih. Te mos imporan hing is my digniy, he old us. Give me an
Israeli passpor, Ill ake my digniy. I you wan he land, ake me wih you.32
An Israeli analys we me was even sarker, saying, In wo o hree years he
wo-sae soluion may remain he batle cry o he Palesinian naional move-
men, bu no longer be seen as a real poliical plaorm and agenda.33
Te analysalso prediced ha, I we don make an eor in he Obama adminisraion or
somehing subsanial, i will be oo lae. I we don lock-in Palesinian saehood
now, is over.
Te Unied Saes has succeeded in convincing Israel and he Palesinians o alk
aer more han a year o acive eors o bring boh sides o he negoiaing able.
Ye here are signican obsacles acing his renewed eor, and rejecioniss on
boh sides wield considerable power.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
18/22
16 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Recommendations: Sustained
engagement is critical
Overcoming he challenges o his eor will require he Unied Saes o aricu-
lae a vision o how o achieve a wo-sae soluion o he leadership and publics
on each side. Measures aken by boh sides should be viewed no as conces-
sions, bu as sraegic measures aken o realize he ulllmen o heir respecive
naional aspiraions. Te Whie House will need o mainain consisen, clear, and
ransparen communicaion o engender condence among Israelis, Palesinians,
and Americans, as well as debunk myhs abou he renewed peacemaking eor
ha rejecioniss will undoubedly pedal.
Te adminisraion has already made some progress in his regard. Repors ha
he paries will work on a ramework o he wo-sae soluion, Secreary o Sae
Hillary Clinons oureach o Israeli and Palesinian media, and boh sides rejec-
ion o violence a he onse o he alks are all welcome indicaions ha he pieces
may be coming ino place or a genuine eor a advancing he peace process.
Bu as Secreary Clinon saed a he conclusion o he launch ceremony in
Washingon, Now is ime o ge o work.
Dont let settlements derail talks
Addressing he Sepember 26 deadline o Israels setlemen moraorium is
clearly he mos pressing challenge o he alks. I is imporan ha he Unied
Saes coninue o publicly reer o he erms o he 2003 Quare Road Map,
which called or Israel o reeze all setlemen aciviy, consisen wih he 2001
Michell Repor. A useul way o saisy he poliical requiremens o boh sides
and jumpsar serious negoiaions could be o make a aci acknowledgmen o
he plan se-orh by Israels Miniser Dan Meridor, which calls or Israel o buildonly in he Wes Bank setlemen blocs ha i inends o keep and compensae he
res hrough land swaps. Te Meridor plan could be viable i i were o serve as a
poin o deparure or dening he exen o he setlemen blocs ha will remain
in Israel, which would require subsanive negoiaions regarding borders and,
ulimaely, Jerusalem.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
19/22
17 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Progress in he alks prior o he Sepember 26 deadline could provide Prime
Miniser Neanyahu wih he impeus o coninue he reeze and or Abbas o
remain a he negoiaing able, bu ensions will rise as he deadline looms. Te
issue should be addressed as early as possible so ha he reeze does no remain an
elephan siting a he negoiaing able. Repors ha Prime Miniser Neanyahu
has begun o acknowledge ha ull-scale building hroughou he Wes Bank willno coninue are a welcome sign.
Engage the Arab states
Secreary Clinons inclusion o Egyp and Jordan in he launch o direc alks
was an imporan gesure o he criical role each mus play in implemening any
agreemen. Egyp hosing he nex round o alks in Sharm-el-Sheikh is anoher
posiive sign. Te Unied Saes could uilize heir involvemen as co-chairs o he
Arab Leagues ollow-up commitee on he Arab Peace Iniiaive o more publiclyrecognize he signicance o he iniiaive.
Te Unied Saes atemps o gain goodwill gesures rom he Arab saesmos
noably Saudi Arabiaailed early in he adminisraion. Bu heir conribuions
will be criical going orward.
Presiden Obamas remark a he launch o direc alks on Sepember 1 ha A lo
o imes I hear rom hose who insis ha his is a op prioriy and ye do very litle
o acually suppor eors ha could bring abou a Palesinian sae was a hinly
disguised reerence o his poin. And Secreary Clinon echoed he remark a he
Sae Deparmen press conerence he nex day.
We should coninue o challenge he Arab saes o make helpul conribuions o
he process, and work o incorporae he Arab Peace Iniiaive ino he ramework
o he negoiaions, as well as encourage Prime Miniser Neanyahu o recognize
he signicance i represens.
King Abdullah o Jordans recen visi o Syria o brie Presiden Basher Assad on
he launch o direc alks is a welcome signal ha we migh be able o uilize Jordanas a condui o promoe he Israel-Syria rack.34 Teir join saemen ha he mee-
ing emphasized ha resolving he Palesinian- Israeli conic on he basis o he
wo-sae vision requires he regaining o all Arab righs in accordance wih ... he
Arab Peace Iniiaive, is a reminder o he poenial ha he iniiaive represens.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
20/22
18 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
Frame two-state solution as a victory
Te alks began wih no precondiions, bu he conours o an agreemen are well
known. Previous experience shows ha hese alks can indeed advance quickly i boh
sides recognize he imporance o compromising on core issues or he sake o ullling
heir naional aspiraions. Recognizing ha each side mus ulimaely ake such mea-sures will be criical as he alks address issues such as Jerusalem, reugees, and borders.
Presiden Obama should encourage Prime Miniser Neanyahu and Presiden Abbas
o publicly ariculae a vision o a susainable wo-sae soluion as represening he
ulllmen o Jewish and Palesinian naional ideals, raher han as heir berayal. I is
unlikely ha he Israeli and Palesinian publics will be prepared in he absence o such
a vision o accep he compromises necessary o end he conic, or o have con-
dence ha a nal agreemen would represen he end o heir respecive claims.
Communicate Americas interests
Presiden Obama repeaed he o-heard phrase in launching direc alks ha, he
Unied Saes canno impose a soluion, and we canno wan i more han he paries
hemselves. Tis is rue. Bu achieving a wo-sae soluion is no only in he ineres o
Israelis and Palesiniansi is a key objecive o Americas oreign policy and naional
securiy agenda in he Middle Eas. Presiden Obama undersands his, which is why
he is spending considerable poliical capial in promoing an Israeli-Palesinian peace
agreemen amid a holy conesed congressional elecion season, concerns abou he
economy, and he end o comba operaions in Iraq.
Communicaing he imporance o succeeding on Arab-Israeli peace or U.S. ineress
will be criical boh o shore up suppor a home and send a message o he paries
ha he Whie House is commited o ackling he challenges ha lie ahead and suc-
ceeding where ohers have ailed.
8/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
21/22
19 C Amica Pgss | navigaig Piica Cus Aciv Mi eas Pac
About the authors
David A. Halperin is Assisan Direcor o Israel Policy Forum.
Matthew Duss is a Naional Securiy Edior a he Cener or American Progress.
Endnotes
1 Piva big wi Isai aays i Jusam, Ju 2010.
2 Piva big wi Isai cia i Jusam, Ju 2010.
3 Baak ravi a Avi Issacaf, nayau: exig S-m Fz Wi Caus Gvm Caps haaz, Juy 27,2010, avaiab a p://www.aaz.cm/pi-ii/ws/ayau-xig-sm-z-wi-caus-gvm--caps-1.304671.
4 P cuc by tnS /tsk pubis i Maaiv wspap,Spmb 8, 2010, p. B4.
5 Ju 7, 2010 Isai P o Ama Sip Baig: tp lirsus Pc Mi eas Ps, Ju 8, 2010, avaiab a p://sis.gg.cm/a/pcps.g/pcps/i--ws/ju-72010isaipamasipbaig.
6 Piva big wi Isai cia i Jusam, Ju 2010.
7 Piva big wi Isai aays i t Aviv, Ju 2010.
8 Piva big wi Isai cia i Jusam, Ju 2010.
9 Ibi.
10 Yuva Kai, libma: W W tpp Gvm, YiA, Spmb 6, 2010.
11 Sam Yusami, Impass, Maaiv, Spmb 6, 2010.
12 Amiai Aai, Ss nayau: Ciuai Fz WiMa a e Yu tm, Maaiv, Spmb 13, 2010.
13 Piva big wi m Isai cia i Jusam, Ju 2010.
14 Abbas rsiss Pus dic taks Wi Isa huiy daiy nws,Juy 29, 2010, avaiab a p://www.uiyaiyws.cm/.pp?=abbas-siss-pus--ic-aks-wi-isa-2010-07-29.
15 Kai laub, US Psss Abbas rsum dic Pac taks,Ya! nws, Juy 26, 2010, avaiab a p://ws.ya.cm/s/ap/20100726/ap___mi_a/m_isa_pasiias.
16 Pasiia C Picy a Suvy rsac, Ji Isai-Pas-iia P, Ju 2010 , Pss as, Ju 29, 2010, avaiab a p://www.pcps.g/suvy/ps/2010/p36ji.m.
17 Piva big wi Amica cia i Jusam, Ju 2010.
18 Piva big wi Pasiia cia i ramaa, Ju 2010.
19 Cispia Bam, Iic taks Wi Isa n Pgssig-Fayaa,rus, Juy 2, 2010, avaiab a p://i.us.cm/aic/iInI-ia-49824720100702.
20 Pasiia C Pubic opii, P n. 172 (2010), avaiaba p://www.pcp.ps/ps.m.
21 t Isa dmcacy Isiu, Pac Ix, Juy 2010 (2010), avai-ab a p://www.ii.g.i/rsacAPgams/pac_ix/dcums/%d7%99%d7%95%d7%9C%d7%99%202010/Pac%20Ix-Juy-as.p.
22 Cnn/opii rsac Cpai P, Pigp.cm, Spm-b 1-2, 2010, avaiab ap://www.pigp.cm/isa.m.
23 Fak nwp, Musims Giv obama higs Jb Appva;Mms, lws, Gaup, Augus 27,2010, avaiab a p://www.gaup.cm/p/142700/musims-giv-bama-igs-jb-appva-mms-ws.aspx.
24 Ms As, Is a pi?,Haaretz, Ju 2, 2010.
25 nam Siza, egam,Haaretz, Juy 15, 2010.
26 d. na Sai, t Mi eas Pac Pcss: oppuiy i Fac dspai (ramaa: Aab W rsac a dvp-m, 2010), Augus 28, 2010, avaiab ap://www.awa.g/ps/egis%20pa1%20pac%20Augus%202010.p.
27 dPA, Ja a Syia ca Isai wiawa m a Aab as,Haaretz, Spmb 8, 2010, avaiab a p://www.aaz.cm/ws/ipmacy-s/ja-a-syia-ca--isai-wiawa-m-a-aab-as-1.312585.
28 Fak nwp, Musims Giv obama higs Jb Appva; M-ms, lws.
29 nam Siza, egam.
30 Pasiia C Pubic opii, P n. 172.
31 d. na Sai, t Mi eas Pac Pcss: oppuiy i Fac dspai.
32 Piva big wi Pasiia cia i ramaa, Ju 2010.
33 Piva big wi Isai aays i Jusam, Ju 2010.
34 dPA, Ja a Syia ca Isai wiawa m a Aab as.
http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.304671http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.304671http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.304671http://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=abbas-resists-push-for-direct-talks-with-israel-2010-07-29http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=abbas-resists-push-for-direct-talks-with-israel-2010-07-29http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100726/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinianshttp://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100726/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinianshttp://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2010/p36ejoint.htmlhttp://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2010/p36ejoint.htmlhttp://in.reuters.com/article/idINIndia-49824720100702http://in.reuters.com/article/idINIndia-49824720100702http://www.pcpo.ps/polls.htmhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.pollingreport.com/israel.htmhttp://www.pollingreport.com/israel.htmhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.awrad.org/pdfs/English%20part1%20peace%20August%202010.pdfhttp://www.awrad.org/pdfs/English%20part1%20peace%20August%202010.pdfhttp://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/jordan-and-syria-call-for-israeli-withdrawal-from-all-arab-lands-1.312585http://www.awrad.org/pdfs/English%20part1%20peace%20August%202010.pdfhttp://www.awrad.org/pdfs/English%20part1%20peace%20August%202010.pdfhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/142700/muslims-give-obama-highest-job-approval-mormons-lowest.aspxhttp://www.pollingreport.com/israel.htmhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.idi.org.il/ResearchAndPrograms/peace_index/Documents/%D7%99%D7%95%D7%9C%D7%99%202010/Peace%20Index-July-trans.pdfhttp://www.pcpo.ps/polls.htmhttp://in.reuters.com/article/idINIndia-49824720100702http://in.reuters.com/article/idINIndia-49824720100702http://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2010/p36ejoint.htmlhttp://www.pcpsr.org/survey/polls/2010/p36ejoint.htmlhttp://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100726/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinianshttp://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100726/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinianshttp://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=abbas-resists-push-for-direct-talks-with-israel-2010-07-29http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=abbas-resists-push-for-direct-talks-with-israel-2010-07-29http://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://sites.google.com/a/pechterpolls.org/pectherpolls/in-the-news/june72010israelipollonaftermathofshipboardinghttp://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.304671http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.304671http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/netanyahu-extending-settlement-freeze-will-cause-government-to-collapse-1.3046718/8/2019 Navigating Political Currents to Achieve Middle East Peace
22/22
The Center for American Progress is a nonpartisan research and educational institute
dedicated to promoting a strong, just and free America that ensures opportunity
for all. We believe that Americans are bound together by a common commitment to
these values and we aspire to ensure that our national policies reflect these values.
We work to find progressive and pragmatic solutions to significant domestic and
international problems and develop policy proposals that foster a government that
is of the people, by the people, and for the people.