SECTOR UPDATE 11 JUL 2014 Natural Gas At the cusp of change The Oil & Gas Index has rallied ~25% YTD in CY14. We feel further upsides are possible given a series of pending policy decisions which will revive sentiment. Companies across the value chain are set for good times. Currently the O&G sector is beset with numerous uncertainties (1) ambiguity on the new gas price (2) huge oil under-recovery (3) no transparency in UR sharing (4) uncertainty on future NELP guidelines (5) no incentives for transmission/CGD players to enter new areas. Industry’s morale has fallen further due to sporadic retrospective decisions by the govt. Rising energy needs and oil imports will lead to higher focus on energy security in India. Gas is cheaper, cleaner and offers higher upstream potential in India as compared to oil. We feel that gas will be the prime focus of the new govt. We are confident that a revised gas price will be applicable from 1 st Oct 2014 and will be below the much debated price of US$ 8.4/mmbtu. In our base case we have assumed gas price rising from $ 4.2/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu. Upstream : Adequate returns will lead to higher investments. Upstream gas players, ONGC and RIL will be the biggest beneficiaries of a gas price hike. Other drivers include higher net oil realisation for ONGC and returns from huge investments in core biz for RIL. Maintain BUY. RLNG : Concerns over Kochi volumes and muted growth at Dahej for next 2-years will keep Petronet LNG under pressure. Maintain NEUTRAL. Gas Transmission : GAIL and GSPL will benefit post the increase in gas supply (domestic + RLNG) by FY16 end. We don’t see significant earnings upgrade for them till FY16. Maintain NEUTRAL. City Gas Distribution : IGL and GGAS will remain in focus. However, increase in retail price and muted volume growth will be an overhang. Maintain NEUTRAL. SECTOR PERSPECTIVE COMPANY FY12-14 PAT CAGR (%) FY15-17 PAT CAGR (%) Rating FY15E FY16E RoE (%) P/E (x) P/BV (x) RoE (%) P/E (X) P/BV (X) ONGC 5.3 13.8 BUY 17.0 14.1 2.3 18.7 11.5 2.0 RIL 2.7 16.0 BUY 11.4 13.6 1.5 11.3 12.5 1.4 Petronet LNG 4.7 18.9 NEU 13.5 18.8 2.4 15.2 14.9 2.1 GAIL 4.8 8.8 NEU 14.6 14.3 2.0 15.0 12.7 1.8 GSPL * (6.1) NA NR 19.9 9.2 1.7 13.4 11.8 1.5 IGL 11.2 8.5 NEU 19.2 13.8 2.5 18.1 12.8 2.2 Source: Company, HDFC sec Inst Research, * Data for GSPL is for FY13 and FY14 Absolute Stock Returns (%) 1M 3M 1Y ONGC (8.5) 25.6 36.4 RIL (11.4) 2.9 16.5 Petronet LNG 12.7 24.5 39.8 GAIL 7.6 22.7 47.2 GSPL 6.5 26.5 50.8 IGL 3.7 24.8 28.8 Target Upside CMP (Rs/sh) TP (Rs/sh) Upside (%) ONGC 404 471 16.5 RIL 998 1,100 10.2 Petronet LNG 177 180 1.7 GAIL 466 470 1.0 GSPL* 88 NR NR IGL 360 380 5.5 * Not rated Satish Mishra [email protected]+91-22-6171-7334 HDFC securities Institutional Research is also available on Bloomberg HSLB <GO> & Thomson Reuters
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
SECTOR UPDATE 11 JUL 2014
Natural Gas
At the cusp of change The Oil & Gas Index has rallied ~25% YTD in CY14. We feel further upsides are possible given a series of pending policy decisions which will revive sentiment. Companies across the value chain are set for good times.
Currently the O&G sector is beset with numerous uncertainties (1) ambiguity on the new gas price (2) huge oil under-recovery (3) no transparency in UR sharing (4) uncertainty on future NELP guidelines (5) no incentives for transmission/CGD players to enter new areas. Industry’s morale has fallen further due to sporadic retrospective decisions by the govt.
Rising energy needs and oil imports will lead to higher focus on energy security in India. Gas is cheaper, cleaner and offers higher upstream potential in India as compared to oil. We feel that gas will be the prime focus of the new govt. We are confident that a revised gas price will be applicable from 1st Oct 2014 and will be below the much debated price of US$ 8.4/mmbtu. In our base case we
have assumed gas price rising from $ 4.2/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu.
Upstream : Adequate returns will lead to higher investments. Upstream gas players, ONGC and RIL will be the biggest beneficiaries of a gas price hike. Other drivers include higher net oil realisation for ONGC and returns from huge investments in core biz for RIL. Maintain BUY.
RLNG : Concerns over Kochi volumes and muted growth at Dahej for next 2-years will keep Petronet LNG under pressure. Maintain NEUTRAL.
Gas Transmission : GAIL and GSPL will benefit post the increase in gas supply (domestic + RLNG) by FY16 end. We don’t see significant earnings upgrade for them till FY16. Maintain NEUTRAL.
City Gas Distribution : IGL and GGAS will remain in focus. However, increase in retail price and muted volume growth will be an overhang. Maintain NEUTRAL.
SECTOR PERSPECTIVE
COMPANY FY12-14 PAT CAGR (%)
FY15-17 PAT CAGR (%) Rating
FY15E FY16E
RoE (%) P/E (x) P/BV (x) RoE (%) P/E (X) P/BV (X) ONGC 5.3 13.8 BUY 17.0 14.1 2.3 18.7 11.5 2.0 RIL 2.7 16.0 BUY 11.4 13.6 1.5 11.3 12.5 1.4 Petronet LNG 4.7 18.9 NEU 13.5 18.8 2.4 15.2 14.9 2.1 GAIL 4.8 8.8 NEU 14.6 14.3 2.0 15.0 12.7 1.8 GSPL * (6.1) NA NR 19.9 9.2 1.7 13.4 11.8 1.5 IGL 11.2 8.5 NEU 19.2 13.8 2.5 18.1 12.8 2.2 Source: Company, HDFC sec Inst Research, * Data for GSPL is for FY13 and FY14
HDFC securities Institutional Research is also available on Bloomberg HSLB <GO> & Thomson Reuters
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Summary
Ups
trea
m
ONGC
• Biggest beneficiary of increase in gas price. Change in gas price from $ 4.2/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu changes FY16 standalone EPS from Rs 27/sh to Rs 35/sh
• Increase in net oil realization from $ 41/bbl in FY14 to $ 45/50/bbl in FY15/16 is another key driver • Trading at 11.5/2.0 x FY16E EPS/BV. FY16E RoE/RoCE is 18.7/14.7%. Maintain BUY, TP Rs 471/sh
RIL • ~70% increase in gas price will lead to higher investments in exploration. Gas volumes will increase • Capex in core business (petchem and refining) is key. EBITDA in FY17 will be ~70% more than EBITDA in FY14 • Trading at 12.5/1.4 x FY16E EPS/BV. FY16E RoE/RoCE is 11.3/8.3%. Maintain BUY, TP Rs 1,100/sh
RLN
G
PLNG
• No direct impact of increase in domestic gas price. No clarity on usage of gas by power segment may negatively impact Petronet LNG
• Robust demand and expanded capacity at Dahej will double volumes over five years, but near term growth will drag • Trading at 9.8/2.1 x FY16E CEPS/BV. FY16E RoE/RoCE is 15.2/10.4%. Maintain NEUTRAL, TP Rs 180/sh
Tran
spor
tatio
n GAIL
• Direct impact of gas price hike is negative. RM cost for petchem and LPG will increase • We expect no oil subsidy sharing by GAIL post gas price hike • Co will be the biggest beneficiary of rise in gas supply. We expect profits from transmission biz to double in 5 years • Trading at 12.7/1.8 x FY16E EPS/BV. FY16E RoE/RoCE is 15.0/11.4%. Maintain NEUTRAL, TP Rs 470/sh
GSPL • No direct impact of gas price hike. We see no significant trigger for next two years • Higher investments by upstream players will lead to increase in gas volumes from FY17 • Trading at 11.8/1.5 x FY14 EPS/BV. FY14 RoE/RoCE is 13.4/10.8%. NOT RATED
CGD IGL
• Increase in gas price will lead to increase in selling price of CNG/PNG to maintain margins. Price advantage with alternative fuels will reduce. However, govt’s decision for 100% domestic gas allocation for CNG and domestic PNG will keep retail prices below previous peak
• Tender for new buses by Delhi Transport is +ve. Volume growth should pickup from FY16 • Trading at 12.8/2.2 x FY16E EPS/BV. FY16E RoE/RoCE is 18.1/16.6%. NEUTRAL, TP Rs 380/sh
Source: HDFC sec Inst Research
Page | 2
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Current scenario : Indian Natural Gas Natural Gas Supply in India India’s domestic natural gas story suffered a setback due to continuous decline in volumes from KG-D6. Supply from RIL came down from the peak of ~60mmscmd during FY11 to ~13mmscmd currently. Part of the shortfall was compensated with RLNG. Still many sectors operated at low capacity utilisation due to shortage of gas.
Domestic sources contributed ~70% of total gas requirement in India in FY14. Increase in APM/KG-D6 gas price from US$ 4.2/mmbtu to US$ 7.2/mmbtu will change the dynamics for sensitive sectors like fertilisers, power and CGD (City Gas Distribution).
Refineries, petrochemical and other industries will also be negatively impacted. However, these industries are better placed as (1) Even at higher price, gas is competitive compared to alternatives (liquid fuels) (2) These are completely deregulated industries with no restraint on pricing.
For clearer impact of gas price hike, we have analysed the impact on different industries. We have used the gas usage proportions of FY13 for our analysis. Major difference in FY14 was owing to a further fall in KG-D6 volumes from ~26mmscmd to ~14mmscmd.
Gas net supply from different sources, excl internal usage (mmscmd)
Source: MOPNG, PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
52 51 51 51 55 56 55 54 54
- - - -
42 56
43 26
14 19 26 31 30
35
39 50
50
48 93 98
105 104
147 165 163
144
130
-
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14
ONGC OIL Pvt/JV KG-D6 RLNG Total
mmscmd
Page | 3
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Industry-wise consumption of Natural Gas in India (FY13)
Source: MOPNG, PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research Key findings from above table :
~75% of the total gas goes to sensitive sectors i.e. fertilisers 30%, power 32%, CGD (CNG/PNG) 7% and LPG 5%.
~85% of the total gas used in sensitive sectors is catered from domestic sources
CGD (12% of total consumption) has two parts
1. CNG/PNG : ~62%, sensitive, from Mar-14 govt directed 100% domestic gas supply to this segment
2. Industrial : ~38% non-sensitive, ~100% LNG can be used
Page | 4
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Impact of higher gas price Fertilisers
Currently ~40mmscmd of gas is supplied to the fertiliser sector of which ~80% is met through domestic sources.
Out of the total urea produced in India (~22mtpa), ~18mtpa uses natural gas as feed material.
From the current base (~80% domestic gas and ~18mtpa gas based production), every US$ 1/mmbtu increase in gas price will lead to additional cost burden of ~Rs 22bn.
Total increase in subsidy due to increase in domestic gas price from US$ 4.2/mmbtu to US$ 7.2/mmbtu is ~Rs 66bn. Total fertilisers subsidy for FY14 was ~Rs 670bn.
Every 5% increase in farmgate price of urea (from Rs 5.4/kg) will reduce govt’s subsidy bill by ~Rs 9bn but till date there is no clarity on urea price hike.
At our estimated gas price of US$ 7.2/mmbtu, all inclusive cost of urea produced from new plants (assuming previous policy) will be US$ 300 – 325/t. Current international urea price is ~US$ 300/t.
Our View
No major impact on players. Additional burden will be borne by the govt. We may see a small increase in urea farmgate price.
A new urea investment policy (with some modifications) is on the cards. We may see new 6-7 new plants in the next 5 years. Each plant requires ~2mmscmd gas for 1.2mtpa capacity.
Fertilisers : Gas demand (mmscmd)
Source: MOPNG, PNGRB, FAI, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Current capacity of gas based power plants is ~21,800 MW. Due to unavailability of natural gas they are operating at sub 30% PLF.
~10,000 MW gas based capacity additions are halted due to lack of gas supplies.
More than 75% of India’s power generation is from coal. Variable cost of generation from domestic coal is ~Rs 1.5/kwh and from imported coal (US$ 90/t) is ~Rs 2.3/kwh.
Variable cost of generation from natural gas at US$ 4.2/mmbtu is Rs 2.7/kwh.
Our View
Every 1 dollar increase in gas price increases cost of generation by ~Rs 0.5/kwh.
Gas price increase from US$ 4.2/mmbtu to US$ 7.2/mmbtu will increase the variable cost of generation to Rs 3.9/kwh (vs Rs 2.3/1.5 per kwh using imported/domestic coal).
Unless government policy neutralises higher generation cost vs coal, gas based power plants are not feasible.
We think PLFs will further decline for gas based power plants. Some portion of the domestic gas currently used by power plants may be freed for other sectors.
o Short term negative for Petronet LNG
o Short term positive for GAIL
Power : Rising gas demand-supply gap
Source: CEA, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Variable cost of power generation with different feeds
Source: Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
-
50
100
150
200
-
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
FY13 FY15 FY18
Capacity (MW) Requirement (mmscmd)Supply (mmscmd)
mmscmd
Halted
MW
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
Coal (domestic)
Coal (Imported)
Fuel oil Naphtha
Rs/kwh
7.3 : LNG@$15/mmbtu
3.9 : NG@$7.2/mmbtu
2.7 : NG@$4.2/mmbtu
Page | 6
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
City Gas Distribution (CGD)
CNG
Increase in gas price from US$ 4.2/mmbtu to US$ 7.2/mmbtu will lead to ~30% increase in CNG prices to ~Rs 48/kg in Delhi.
Even at increased price, operating cost/km with CNG will be only ~55% of that of petrol.
If 100% domestic gas is allocated to CNG players, we see robust demand to continue for this segment.
PNG
Increase in gas price may slightly reduce the pace of switch from LPG to PNG.
However, with 100% domestic allocation and likely hike in LPG prices in coming years, difference will be marginal and urban customers will prefer PNG.
Industrial
Shortage of coal for power has resulted in liquid fuels being used as the only alternative for small industrial players.
Cost of power generation from fuel oil and naphtha is higher as compared to even RLNG.
Cost (Rs/km) Breakeven Petrol (Years)Breakeven Diesel (Years)
YearsRs/km
Page | 7
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Other Industries
LPG
~6mmscmd of gas is supplied to LPG sector. LPG is a subsidised product and burden of additional gas cost will be borne by the government.
Every 1 dollar increase in gas price increases subsidy burden by ~Rs 4.5bn.
Government might reduce burden by capping cylinder supply to 6 or 9/year from 12/year.
GAIL is the only player in our coverage universe which will be negatively impacted by a gas price hike. However, we believe that it will be compensated by reducing GAIL’s subsidy contribution for oil under recovery.
No major impact to LPG sector dynamics.
Petrochemicals
Increase in gas price will negatively impact the petrochemical sector as it consumes ~4% of total gas. GAIL is the only player in our coverage universe which will be impacted.
However, ~50% of the current demand is met through RLNG. So the impact will be only to the extent of ~50%.
We don’t see further gas based petrochemical capacity coming up in India.
Refining, steel and other sectors
Currently ~30mmscmd of gas is supplied to these sectors. All these industries are fully decontrolled with full pricing power.
Alternative fuels for these industries are naphtha and fuel oil.
Equivalent pricing :
o Naphtha @ $ 1k/t = RLNG @ US$ 22/mmbtu
o Fuel Oil @ $ 0.7k/t = RLNG @ US$ 17/mmbtu
We see no impact in demand from these sectors due to increase in gas price. We believe that demand will increase if regular gas supply is ensured.
Page | 8
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Future Energy ScenarioRising Energy Demand
Over the last decade India’s GDP has grown at 2-3x that of the global growth rate. India’s share in the global energy consumption has increased from 3.2% in CY01 to 4.5% in CY12. Average energy multiplier for India over the last decade has been ~0.74x of GDP growth. Hence to sustain an average GDP growth
rate of 6.7% over the next decade, India’s energy demand will grow at a CAGR of 5%. India ranks 4th in the world in terms of energy consumption (after China, USA and Russia). However, in terms of per capita and per area consumption in India is one of the lowest among the top-20 energy consumers.
India's share in usage (%) 3.2 3.2% 3.2% 3.3% 3.4% 3.5% 3.7% 3.9% 4.3% 4.3% 4.4% 4.5% Energy Growth - World (%) 3.2 3.2 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.7 3.9 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.5 Energy Growth - India (%) 0.9 1.9 3.5 4.8 2.9 2.8 2.6 1.3 (1.1) 5.6 2.4 2.1 GDP Growth - World (%) 0.5 4.5 3.2 7.6 6.3 6.3 7.7 6.3 8.4 5.7 4.5 5.4 GDP Growth - India (%) 1.7 2.1 2.8 4.2 3.6 4.1 4.0 1.4 (2.1) 4.1 2.9 2.4
Energy Multiplier - India 0.10 1.15 0.41 1.07 0.66 0.66 0.83 0.93 0.98 0.64 0.68 0.80 Sources : BP, World bank, Govt reports, HDFC sec Research
Energy Consumption : toe per capita (X axis) and per 1,000 sqkm (Y axis)
Sources : BP, World bank, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
China USA
India
Russia
Japan
Germany
Brazil
France
Canada Iran Indonesia
UK
Saudi Arabia Mexico
Italy
South Africa
Ukraine Spain
Australia
(0.2)
-
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
- 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0
• Size of bubble represents Energy usage • Emerging countries are green • OECD countries are orange
Page | 9
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Changing Global Energy Mix
Over the last two decades oil’s contribution in the global energy mix has reduced from 39% to 33%. This gap was filled by natural gas and renewable/hydro energy.
Fuel wise Energy Mix
Source: BP, HDFC sec Inst Research
BP predicts a fall in coal and oil proportions in future years. This gaps will be compensated by natural gas, renewable source and hydroelectric. Discovery of large gas reserves/shale gas and focus on cleaner energy are the driving force behind it.
Asia Pacific : skewed towards coal
Global energy mix is well distributed between oil, natural gas and coal. Coal caters to ~30% of the world’s energy needs. However, the mix is skewed towards coal (52% contribution) in the Asia Pacific region. China (ranked 1st globally in energy consumption) and India (ranked 4th) use coal to the extent of 68% and 53% respectively.
Fuel wise Energy Mix (CY13)
Source: BP, HDFC sec Inst Research
With limited availability of indigenous oil and natural gas in the Asia Pacific region, we expect coal to remain the major source of energy.
39 38 34 33 30 29
22 23 24 24 25 26
27 25 29 30 30 28
6 7 8 9 10 12
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
CY90 CY00 CY10 CY12 CY20E CY30E
Oil Natural Gas Coal Nuclear Others
33 37 37 27 29 18
24 26 30
11 8
5
30 19 20 52 55
67
9 9 5 8 7 9
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
World OECD US Asia Pacific
India China
Oil Gas Coal Nuclear Energy Others
Page | 10
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Future Energy Scenario : India Based on an energy multiplier of 0.74x, India’s energy need will rise at a CAGR of 5% to sustain the average GDP growth of 6.7% over the next decade. We have analysed the potential of existing energy sources to meet the future demand.
COAL
Coal will remain the major energy source with more than 50% contribution. Currently domestic/import forms 80/20% of the total requirement
Coal India contributes ~80% of the domestic supply. Supply from Coal India has grown at a CAGR of 3% over the last 5 years. Even with removal of railway bottlenecks and environmental clearance we anticipate production growth of no more than 5-7% in the near future.
Imports will continue to rise. However, port limitations will keep growth in the range of ~10%. Coal contribution will remain at 53-55%. No major change expected.
OIL
Oil consumption (~3.8 bbl/d) has increased at a CAGR of ~4.2% over the last decade. Domestic oil production growth was muted at ~1.2%. Domestic sources contribute ~24% of total
need. We expect govt to incentivise domestic producers to increase domestic production. However, with domestic product growth remaining at 1-3%, proportion of imports is set to rise. Oil contribution can remain at 28-29% with rising imports. Govt will incentivise gas usage. Even
imported LNG is cheaper (and cleaner) than crude.
OTHERS incl RENEWABLE
Nuclear (1%), renewable (2%) and hydroelectric (5%) contribute 8% of total requirement. Nuclear, wind and solar are small and even if they grow at a faster pace India’s energy dynamics will
not change. India has huge opportunity with regard to hydroelectric power (just ~25% is tapped so far). However,
long gestation period (~10 years for large projects) restricts any major near term additions. Contribution will remain at 8-10%. No major change expected.
NATURAL GAS
Gas is cleaner (vs coal/oil), cheaper (vs oil) and easy to use. As against global share of 24%, gas accounts for just 9% of India’s energy needs.
Even high cost RLNG is cheaper than Naphtha/Fuel Oil (lowest cost crude product). ~75% of oil is imported i.e. ~22% of energy demand can be replaced with low cost gas. We expect both domestic (driven by favourable govt policies) and imported gas supply to increase. Contribution will cross 10% and will keep on rising (govt predicts it to double by 2030).
Our View : Natural Gas proportion will increase and oil’s share will reduce.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
Coal 55%
Oil 29%
Others 8%
Natural Gas 8%
India’s Energy Mix CY13
(Source: BP, HDFC sec Inst Research)
Page | 11
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Future Natural Gas Scenario : India Ample demand at higher gas price
As seen earlier, even RLNG (costs US$ 15-18/mmbtu) is cheaper than the cheapest petroleum product (naphtha and fuel oil). Theoretically, ~22% of India’s energy requirement which is met through imported oil can be replaced with natural gas. Hence there is a potential to take gas proportion from 9% to 30% subject to associated infrastructure.
Possible switching at different gas price
Source: Gail, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Additional customers at different gas price (Source - Gail)
Upto US$ 10/mmbtu : Power (CCGT), Fertiliser (Gas), Steel
Upto US$ 14/mmbtu : Fertilisers (Naphtha/FO), Industrial, CGD, Power (CCHP), Power (Peaking), Petrochemicals, Refining
Upto US$ 18/mmbtu : Power (Naphtha), Captive Power, Refining (Naphtha)
Future gas demand projection Strong GDP growth suggests rising energy demand for
India. Energy consumption will increase at ~5% CAGR to sustain the GDP growth rate of 6.7%. Even with coal contributing 53-55% of the total requirement there is need for oil and gas supply to increase at ~5% CAGR.
Demand of natural gas in India
Source: PNGRB, MOPNG, HDFC sec Inst Research
Natural gas being cheaper and cleaner as compared to oil will get priority in the future. Due to shortage of the gas at right price, just 50-55% of gas demand is met. Total demand is likely to increase by more than double in the next 10 years. Hence there is a potential for gas consumption to quadruple from current levels subject to attractive pricing and associated infrastructure.
Out of the total incremental demand projected by govt, around 50% is comes from fertilisers, CGD, refiners and others. We are confident of this demand. The remaining ~50% comes from power sector, which is subject to change in govt policies to absorb high cost power.
-
50
100
150
200
250
300
Upto US$ 10/mmbtu
Upto US$ 14/mmbtu
Upto US$ 18/mmbtu
mmscmd
150 - 160
60 - 70
60
134
243
378
522
655
746
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
FY13A FY13D FY17D FY22D FY27D FY30D
Power Fertilisers CGDRefineries Others Total
Page | 12
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Indian gas supply outlook
Govt reports (Planning Commission, PNGRB, Rangarajan report) are talking about optimistic gas supply scenario.
Gas supply projection from government reports
Source: PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research We see a significant miss from govt projections.
Adequate returns to producers and clarity on gas usage for power sector will actually decide the extent of supply and usage.
Realistic gas supply projection
Source: Companies, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Supporting distribution infrastructure
Transmission netowrk : Gail (~70%), GSPL (~12%) and RGTIL (~10%) are key players present in the regulated transmission pipeline business. Total pipeline capacity in India is ~3x that of current supply. Planned capex by Gail and GSPL suggests that pipelines are unlikely to be a bottleneck in India.
Gas supply projection from government reports
Source: PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Distribution network : City gas distribution will be one of the key growth drivers in the future. CGD model is a win-win situation for all stake holders. Consumers get cheaper alternate fuel, govt saves on forex and pollution reduces. Currently there are ~16 CGD players operating in more than 20 cities. Many new entrants have shown their interest in different rounds of bidding. PNGRB expects cities under CGD coverage to increase to ~80 over the next decade.
103 111 120 157 161
64 85 124
143 188
167 196
244
300
349
-
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
FY14P FY15P FY16P FY17P FY18P
Domestic RLNG Total
mmscmd
61 60 62 64 67 69
26 14 15 17 21 35 50
48 55 61 67 91 144 130 139 150
164
208
-
50
100
150
200
250
FY13 FY14 FY15E FY16E FY17E FY18E
ONGC/OIL Pvt/JV RIL RLNG Total
mmscmd
-
500
1,000
FY13 FY14 FY15 FY20 FY25 FY30
Gas demand Gas supplyPipelines Design Capacity Pipelines Capacity at sources
mmscmd
Page | 13
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
RLNG – no more a filler
Rising energy demand and decline in domestic supply led to increase in LNG contribution from 20% in FY06 to 37% in FY14. LNG consumption declined marginally in FY14 due to higher spot LNG price.
Gas supply in India
Source: PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Currently we have two RLNG pricing regimes in India :
(1) Long term pricing : Linked to crude price (at US$ 105/bbl this translates to a gas price of ~$ 14.3/mmbtu). This is applicable for 7.5 MMTPA (~28 mmsmcd) supply from Ras Gas, Qatar.
(2) Spot pricing : It is based on demand supply. However, this price is usually higher than LT prices.
GAIL has signed a 20-year gas supply agreement with Cheniere and Dominion, USA to supply 5.8 MMTPA of LNG. Pricing will be linked to Henry Hub prices and supply is expected to start from FY18.
• Equivalent pricing (crude at ~US$ 105-110/bbl) : o Naphtha @ $ 1k/t = RLNG @ US$ 22/mmbtu o Fuel Oil @ $ 0.7k/t = RLNG @ US$ 17/mmbtu
Upcoming RLNG facility in India
Price advantage with crude and shortfall in domestic gas output has led to spurt in RLNG projects in India. LNG re-gasification capacity is likely to triple from ~20 MMTPA to ~60 MMTPA in the next five years.
Gas supply projection from government reports
Source: PNGRB, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
All industries (except fertilisers and power) are ready markets for RLNG. To ensure supply, Indian companies are entering into long term supply agreement with global players.
Signed LT agreements
From Supplier Quantity (MMTPA) Starting
GAIL USA Cheniere & Dominion 5.8 FY18
GAIL Russia Gazprom 2.5 FY20 GAIL Australia Gorgon ~1 FY16 GSPC BG 2.5 FY15 Petronet Australia Exxon Mobile 1.4 FY16 Petronet Australia Gazprom 2.5 FY18 IOC Canada Process Energy 1.2 FY19
Source: Companies, Govt. reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
57 56 56 56 60 61 62 61 60
17 16 18 18 10 9 8 7 8
42 56 43 26 14 19 26 31 30
35 39 50
50 48 93 98 105 104
147 165 163 144
130
-
50
100
150
200
FY06
FY07
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14
ONGC/OIL Pvt/JV KG-D6 RLNG Total
mmscmd
-
75
150
225
300
-
25
50
75
100
FY13
FY14
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
PLNG-Dahej Shell-HaziraGail-Dabhol PLNG-KochiIOC-Ennore GSPC-MundraRIL-Kakinada PLNG-GangavaramEast Coast West Coast
mtpa mmscmd
Page | 14
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Global Natural Gas Scenario Top natural gas producers
Natural gas contributes ~24% of the total global energy requirement vs 8% in india. Total global supply in CY13 was ~9k mmscmd.
Gas consumption has increased at a CAGR of ~2.8% over the last decade as against the total energy CAGR of ~2.4%.
Region wise gas production
Source: Gail, Govt reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
The Middle East, Africa and Asia Pacific have seen the fastest growth over the last decade. Production from these three geographies has increased from 16% in 1990 to 37% in 2012.
India and China accounted for 1.0% and 3.5% of global gas production respectively in CY13.
Top natural gas consumers
Energy consumption growth is fastest in the emerging countries. Proportion of North America, Europe and Eurasia has declined from 83% in 1990 to 60% in 2012.
Region wise gas consumption
Source: PNGRB, MOPNG, HDFC sec Inst Research
New discoveries with low extraction challenges in the Middle East made it the largest LNG supplier in the world.
Rising energy demand and lower domestic availability made Asia Pacific the largest market for RLNG.
Africa is emerging as another gas surplus region with newer discoveries in Mozambique and Tanzania.
33 34 32 27 26 27
48 41 39 37 32 31
5 7 9 11 15 17
8 10 11 13 15 14
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2013
North America S. & Cent. America Europe & EurasiaMiddle East Africa Asia Pacific
33 35 33 28 27 28
50 43 41 40 35 32
5 7 8 10 12 13
8 10 12 14 18 19
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2013
North America S & C America Europe & Eurasia
Middle East Africa Asia Pacific
Page | 15
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
LNG trade movement (CY13)
E X P O R T E R S
(BCM) Trinidad & Tobago
Brazil/ Peru Europe Russia Qatar Other
Middle East Algeria Nigeria Other Africa Australia Indonesia Malaysia Total
Imports
I M P O R T E R S
North America 3 3 1 - 3 1 - 2 - - 0 - 12 S. & Cent. America 13 0 3 - 1 0 0 1 0 - - - 20 Europe and Eurasia 2 1 3 - 23 - 14 7 0 - - - 51 Middle East 0 - 0 - 3 - 0 0 0 0 - - 5 Asia Pacific 2 2 11 14 75 27 1 12 8 30 22 34 238
As seen in global demand-supply chart, the Middle East leads in LNG exports. Middle Eastern countries contribute ~41% of total Exports. Qatar leads the pack with ~1/3rd of global supply.
Asia Pacific countries accounts for ~73% of global imports. Japan leads with ~37% of global LNG imports. There are mainly three pricing regimes for LNG :
o America : Linked to Henry Hub o Europe and Eurasia : Linked to oil index and UK Heren NBP index o Asia Pacific : Linked to Japan crude cocktail
There is a large difference between the local price and exported price to other countries o America : Local Henry Hub price is $4- 4.5/mmbtu, however delivered price to India (including liquefaction,
transportation and re-gasification) will be $ 10-12/mmbtu. o Middle East : Petronet LNG receives gas from Qatar at ~$ 14/mmbtu. However gas price to urea plants in Oman is
less than $ 2/mmbtu.
Page | 16
NATURAL GAS : SECTOR UPDATE
Conversion factors Weight to Volume Conversion Volume Conversion
Product Weight (MT) Volume (KL) Barrel (bbl) From To
1 Standard Cubic Meter 35.3 Cubic Feet 1 mmbtu 25.2 scm @10,000 kcal/scm
1 BCM/year of Gas 2.74 mmscmd 1 US$/mmbtu (INR-US$ @ 60, NCV @ 9k) Rs 2.14/scm, Rs 2.8/kg
1 tcf of Gas Reserve (100% recoverable)
3.9 mmscmd for 20 years
GCV (Gross Calorific Value) 10,000 kcal/scm
NCV (Net Calorific Value) 90% of GCV
1 mmtpa of LNG 3.7 mmscmd Urea produced from 1 mmscmd of gas 0.6 mtpa
1 MT of LNG 1,314 scm Power generation from 1 mmscmd of gas 242 MW
Source: Gail, PPAC, Govt Reports, HDFC sec Inst Research
Page | 17
COMPANY UPDATE 11 JUL 2014
ONGC BUY
Proxy to India’s O&G growth We believe that ONGC will be the biggest beneficiary of oil & gas sector revamp in India. Government has clarified its intent to provide higher benefits to domestic upstream players to encourage investments. Rising imports of oil & gas and subsequently higher forex outgo further emphasise the need for higher domestic production.
We see multiple triggers ahead for ONGC (1) Govt’s focus on energy will lead to stable policy regime (2) Gas price hike. We have built-in new gas prices at $ 7.2/mmbtu from 1st Oct 2014 (3) Increase in production (4) Lower UR sharing due to regular diesel price hike (5) Volumes growth at OVL
We remain upbeat on ONGC even with conservative assumptions (1) In current tight fiscal condition, we believe that Govt would like to keep maximum benefits of declining UR. We have modelled ONGC’s share to increase from 40% in FY14 to 55% in FY16. (2) New gas price at $ 7.2/mmbtu, 14% below the debated price of $ 8.4/mmbtu.
Our SOTP TP for ONGC is Rs 471/sh (11x FY16E standalone EPS + Rs 64/sh for OVL at 10x FY16E EPS of Rs 6.4/sh and Rs 22/sh for other investments). We maintain our estimates and have increased our TP by assigning higher multiple (11x vs 10x) to standalone business. Maintain BUY.
Earnings sensitivity : Our base case is based on net crude realisation at $ 50/bbl and gas price at $ 7.2/mmbtu.
Under recovery overhang to subside : Regular price hikes in diesel will lead to decline in oil UR from Rs 1.4tn in FY14 to Rs 1.0tn/0.9tn in FY15/16.
Benefits to Government : Govt’s share will decrease from Rs 708bn in FY14 to Rs 371/312bn in FY15/16.
Benefits to ONGC : Despite rise in ONGC’s share from 40% to 55%. We expect that Rs/bbl realisation will rise from Rs 2.5k/bbl in FY14 to Rs 2.7k/3.0k in FY15/16.
ONGC standalone 35.0 11.0 385 x EPS OVL 6.4 10.0 64 x EPS Traded investment 80% 22 at 20% discount to CMP Target Price 471 Source: Company, HDFC sec Inst Research
Building increase in volumes Even with higher proportion of UR sharing, Rs/bbl realization will increase by ~10%/yr We have assumed $3/mmbtu increase in gas price for ONGC No change in estimates Increasing standalone biz multiple from 10 to 11x FY16E EPS.
Enough steam from core biz E&P business contributed 11% of PBIT for RIL in FY14 (peak of 27% in FY11). However, most of the news for RIL over the last three years was from this segment. Decline in KG-D6 volumes (from peak of 60mmscmd in FY11 to 15mmscmd), Govt’s denial for part capex in KG-D6 and demand for higher gas price led to various controversies/news. In our base case we have cut revised gas price from US$ 8.4/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu. However, we feel that it will have more of sentimental impact and RIL’s story remains intact.
Though our assumed gas price is 14% below the debated price of $ 8.4/mmbtu, it is still 71% higher than the current price. Further, there are multiple growth drivers for RIL. Strong GRM, output from MA fields and incremental capacity in polyesters will be the growth drivers for FY15/16. Quantum jump in EBITDA (~70% increase over FY14 to Rs 520bn) will take place in FY17 post full impact of the capex of US$ 13bn in core business (refining and chemicals). Other encouraging triggers are (1) Retail biz has achieved critical mass and turned PAT positive (2) Positive outlook for domestic upstream assets (R-series/Satellite fields) (3) Ramp up in shale gas volumes (4) Strong balance sheet
The key risk for the stock is increasing capex in telecom business ($ 6bn spent till FY14 and Co has guided for additional capex of ~$ 6bn). However, we remain positive on RIL on the back of huge capex in
the core business. We raise our SOTP target to Rs 1,100/sh. Maintain BUY.
Capex on track : Ongoing US$ 13bn capex (~$ 5bn spent till FY14) is broadly on track. All projects will be commissioned by FY16 end. We expect EBITDA to jump to Rs 520bn in FY17 (~70% over FY14 EBITDA).
Cut in estimates due to lower gas price : We have cut our EBITDA estimates for FY15/16 by 1.5/3.7% factoring lower gas price.
Encouraging outlook for Retail biz : FY14 was an encouraging year for the retail biz. Company turned PAT positive in this biz and has achieved critical mass to gain from operating leverage. Co is operating across 146 cities and retail area has increased to 11.7 mn sqft.
Rising debt in consolidated balance sheet : RIL was a zero net debt co till last year. However, rising capex in telecom and shale gas has resulted in net debt of Rs 614bn (FY14 net D/E 0.3x) in the consolidated books. Standalone co’s net D/E is 0.1x.
HDFC securities Institutional Research is also available on Bloomberg HSLB <GO> & Thomson Reuters
RELIANCE INDUSTRIES : COMPANY UPDATE
ASSUMPTIONS FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15E FY16E FY17E Crude price (US$/bbl) 109.9 107.1 107.0 105.0 105.0 105.0 INR-USD 47.9 54.4 60.5 60.0 60.0 60.0 Refining business GRM (US$/bbl) 8.6 9.2 8.1 8.5 8.5 11.1 Crude thruput (mmt) 67.7 68.5 68.0 68.5 68.5 68.5 Upstream business PMT Gas (BCF) 145 115 93 87 83 79 KG Gas (mmscmd) 43 26 14 15 17 21 Gas price (US$/mmbtu) 4.2 4.2 4.2 5.7 7.2 7.2 Petrochemicals Sales volume (mmt) 9.0 8.9 9.0 10.2 12.0 14.0 Source : Company, HDFC sec Inst Research CHANGE IN ESTIMATES (Rs bn) FY15 Old FY15 New % ch FY16 Old FY16 New % ch Revenue 4,062.6 4,093.5 0.8 4,265.0 4,307.5 1.0 EBITDA 359.1 353.7 (1.5) 409.4 394.1 (3.7) PAT 238.4 236.7 (0.7) 272.2 257.0 (5.6) EPS (Rs/sh) 73.8 73.2 (0.7) 84.2 79.5 (5.6) SOTP VALUATION BASED ON FY16
Business EBITDA (Rs bn) Multiple Value
(Rs bn) Value* (Rs/sh) Valuation Basis
Petrochemicals 162 6.5 1,054 361 EV/EBITDA on FY16E Refining 189 6.5 1,227 420 EV/EBITDA on FY16E E & P PMT 17 4.0 69 24 EV/EBITDA on FY16E KG D6 gas 245 84 NPV NEC 46 16 NPV CBM 87 30 NPV Shale gas 1.0 420 144 x Investments Investments in Retail 1.0 100 34 x Investments Investments in Telecom 0.7 252 86 x Investments CWIP 1.0 327 112 As on Mar-14 Consolidated Net Debt 614 (210) As on Mar-14 Value per share 1,100 Source : Company, HDFC sec Inst Research, * Valuation is based on 2.923 bn shares (net of treasury shares)
Strong GRM due to higher global additional demand (1.4mbpd in 2014 vs 1.2 YoY) and delay in new capacities KG-D6 gas volumes decline is arrested and major boost will come from FY17 Change in estimates factoring gas price at $ 7.2/mmbtu vs 8.2 earlier Rising capex in telecom biz is a major overhang; hence we are valuing it at 30% discount
Volumes at the bottom Petronet LNG (PLNG) had a tough time in FY14. EBITDA declined by 23% YoY led by (1) Weaker demand owing to muted GDP growth. Volumes declined by 10% from its peak in FY12 (2) 11% YoY fall in INR vs USD increased gas prices (3) Tight global LNG market led to higher spot LNG prices.
However, with rising optimism on economic recovery, we see good days ahead for LNG players. Despite RLNG costing 2-3x (RLNG price is US$ 15-18/mmbtu) that of domestic gas price there is ample demand. RLNG is cheaper than the cheapest petroleum products (naphtha and fuel oil). Theoretically, ~22% of India’s energy requirement which is met through imported oil can be replaced with RLNG. LNG re-gasification capacity is likely to triple from ~20 mtpa to ~60 mtpa in the next five years.
There are multiple triggers for PLNG (1) Additional tolling volumes of 1.25 mtpa for GSPC from FY15 onwards as 2nd jetty was commissioned (2) Complete off-take agreement for upcoming 5 mtpa capacity at Dahej in FY17 (3) Increase in global supply will keep spot prices under check (5) Stable Govt will lead to higher economic activities and stable currency.
Stock has moved by ~21% in the last 3-months and is trading at 14.4x FY16E EPS. There are some short term concerns (1) higher depreciation and interest cost at Kochi will keep PAT growth muted (2)
Increase in domestic gas price may lead to non usage of domestic gas by power sector (unless government policy neutralises higher generation cost vs coal). In such scenario there might be replacement of some LNG volumes by domestic gas. Maintain NEUTRAL, TP Rs 180/sh (10/15x FY16E CEPS/EPS).
Volumes from Kochi will be low until Mangalore/Bangalore pipelines are ready. Bangalore pipeline matter is in SC (hearing in July). Mangalore pipeline issue, if resolved (expected sooner) may add ~1 mtpa demand.
Softer INR and higher spot LNG prices are the key risks.
To benefit from rising gas supply There will be three pronged impact of rise in domestic gas price on GAIL (1) Profitability of LPG segment will decline (2) Viability of new petchem plant will be at risk (3) Higher domestic gas price will lead to higher production and hence better prospects for transmission business.
Impact on LPG segment will be compensated by lower/no oil under recovery sharing by GAIL, which shared Rs 19bn (-29% YoY) as UR in FY14. We have built-in UR of Rs 5/0bn for FY15/16. We expect no contribution post gas price hike.
Returns from new petchem plant will be sub-nominal. However, operating leverage within existing unit will keep it EBITDA accretive. Further, gas price at $ 7.2/mmbtu against earlier discussed price of $ 8.4/mmbtu will be sentimentally positive.
GAIL is the largest gas transmission company in India with a market share of more than 70%. EBITDA contribution from this segment is down from ~50% in FY11 to ~30% in FY15E. It was led by 20% decline in gas volumes. Surge in gas prices will lead to higher domestic output. Rising LNG (we expect LNG volumes to double in five years) and domestic gas volumes will result in higher contribution from this segment. We expect EBITDA share from this segment to rise to ~45% in the next five years. There is an upside risk to our assumption, as we are not building upward revision in pipeline tariff.
Increase in gas volumes, no subsidy sharing and no major capex will improve returns and FCF. We revise our SOTP TP for GAIL to Rs 470/sh (~6.2x FY16E EV/EBITDA and Rs 126/sh from investments). Maintain NEUTRAL.
Upward revision in estimates : We have changed our base case gas price assumption from $ 8.4/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu. However, we have increased contribution of LNG in feed mix to ~46% from ~33% in FY14. Subsequently our EPS estimates for FY15/16 are revised upward by 3.4/4.1%.
Return ratios to bottom-out in FY15 : Sub-nominal returns from new capex (pipelines and petchem) are reducing profitability. RoE/RoCE are expected to bottom out at ~14%/10% in FY15E vs ~20%/17% in FY11. Return ratios should improve post higher gas volumes/no subsidy sharing and should move higher to 15%/12% by FY17E.
SOTP VALUATION (BASED ON FY16E) EBITDA (Rs bn) Multiple EV (Rs bn) Value/sh Basis Gas Transmission 28.7 8.0 229 181 x FY16E EBITDA LPG Transmission 2.6 6.0 16 12 x FY16E EBITDA Gas Trading 17.8 4.5 80 63 x FY16E EBITDA Petchem 17.6 4.5 79 62 x FY16E EBITDA LPG & Other Hydrocarbons 22.4 4.5 101 80 x FY16E EBITDA Standalone wt avg 6.2 Less : Net Debt (Mar-14) 68.8 69 54 Standalone Value 344 Investments ONGC 1.0 97 76 At our TP Petronet LNG & IGL 1.0 29 23 At our TP Others 1.0 34 27 1x BV Value per share 470 Source : HDFC sec Inst Research
Key events for GAIL (1) Increase in gas
transmission volumes (2) Increase in gas cost (3) No subsidy sharing Reduction in domestic gas price assumption from $ 8.4/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu and other marginal changes led to change in estimates Lower multiple to petchem & LPG/Trading due to gas cost/regulatory risk
No near term trigger GSPL is the 2nd largest natural gas transmission company in India with ~2,300 kms pipeline network. It forms the backbone of Gujarat’s gas infrastructure and is a proxy to Gujarat’s industrial growth. State accounts for ~1/3rd of India’s natural gas consumption and ~60% of that flows through GSPL.
Company faced difficult times over the last couple of years due to fall in KG-D6 volumes. GSPL’s transmission volumes declined from 36 mmscmd in FY11 to 21 in FY14. It was in sync with fall in RIL’s production from 56 to 14 mmscmd. Subsequently, RIL’s proportion in GSPL’s volume declined from 21 to 2 mmscmd.
Transmission tariff was another overhang for the stock. However, recent notification by PNGRB on 19th Feb 2014 has removed this overhang. PNGRB has revised upwards its previous notified tariff for high pressure pipelines by 11% to Rs 26.58/mmbtu.
Though the worst is behind GSPL, we don’t see any near term positive trigger. Increase in transmission volume is a key trigger for GSPL. Significant increase in GSPL’s volumes is not possible before the pickup in KG-D6 production. Another risk for GSPL is that ~30% of current volumes go to RIL refineries. This supply will stop post the commissioning of RIL’s petcoke gasification project in FY17. Gas freed from refinery will be RLNG (at ~$ 15/mmbtu) and hence can only be absorbed by industrial players.
Investment in Cross Country pipelines : GSPL is laying three cross country pipelines under two of its subsidiaries (59% and 62% stake). Total ~4,000 km pipelines will be laid with a capex of ~Rs 140bn. Three OMCs are the other partners in the subsidiaries. Returns from these pipelines will be muted in the initial phase due to lower volumes and lower tariff (GSPL own through aggressive bidding). Projects have received environmental clearances.
Investment in CGD business : GSPL owns 29.1% stake in GSPC Gas, 13.8% in Sabarmati Gas (as per FY13 AR) and 38.9% stake in GSPC Distribution Networks (GDNL). GSPC Gas and Gujarat Gas will be merged into GDNL. Total volumes of the combined entity will be ~8 mmscmd and it will be Asia’s largest CGD player.
Valuation : GSPL is trading at 11.3/1.4 x FY14 EPS/BV. RoE/RoCE of the company has decreased from 28/17% in FY11 to 13/11% in FY14.
Total Current Liabilities 8,334 6,169 5,664 5,653 6,231 Net Current Assets -1,889 -1,906 1,350 6,550 2,431 TOTAL APPLICATION OF FUNDS 29,639 34,972 39,024 46,882 47,797
Recovery on the cards IGL had its golden period from FY09 to FY12 when volumes increased at a CAGR of 22% led by (1) Impetus during Commonwealth Games 2010 (2) Significantly lower running cost/km with CNG vs petrol/diesel.
Co faced multiple challenges starting FY13 (1) PNGRB directed to cut network tariff and compression charges by ~60%, matter is sub-judice (2) Fall in domestic gas led to rise in RLNG proportion and consequently CNG prices increased by ~60% between Dec 11 (Rs 32/kg) to Dec 13 (Rs 50/kg). Reducing advantage vs competitive fuels and no new bus addition by Delhi transport resulted in muted volume growth of 3.5% YoY in FY14.
However, we believe that worst is behind and there are multiple triggers ahead. Govt’s decision for 100% allocation of domestic gas for CNG (~75% for IGL) and domestic PNG (~5% for IGL) in Feb 14 was the biggest positive. It led to fall in CNG prices by 30% to Rs 35.2/kg and PNG prices by 17% to Rs 24.5/scm in Delhi. Now even with the increase in domestic gas price from US$ 4.2/mmbtu to $ 7.2/mmbtu, CNG price will be below its previous peak at ~Rs 48/kg. On 30th Jun 2014, Delhi Transport Corporation issued a tender for ~1,400 CNG busses (currently ~19.5k CNG busses are running in Delhi).
Increase in gas price from 1st Oct 2014 will lead to increase in CNG/PNG prices by ~30%. Despite the
hike in CNG/PNG prices, they continue to be the competitive vs alternative fuels.
The dispute with PNGRB is sub-judice. With rising focus on CGD we see rare chances of any unfavourable decision. Our TP for IGL is Rs 380/sh at 13.5/2.3x FY16E EPS/BV, NEUTRAL.
Price comparison with competitive fuels
CNG : At new gas price of $ 7.2/mmbtu, running cost with CNG will be ~Rs 2.2/km vs ~Rs 4.3/3.8/km for petrol/diesel. Conversion breakeven time for a normal user (30km/day) will be 1.7/2.7 years.
Margins to remain stable : IGL has maintained margins even at the peak of gas cost. We expect Gross/EBITDA margin to remain in the range of Rs 9/5.5/kg. We have built-in 5.1% CAGR in volumes over FY14-16E.
Disclaimer: This report has been prepared by HDFC Securities Ltd and is meant for sole use by the recipient and not for circulation. The information and opinions contained herein have been compiled or arrived at, based upon information obtained in good faith from sources believed to be reliable. Such information has not been independently verified and no guaranty, representation of warranty, express or implied, is made as to its accuracy, completeness or correctness. All such information and opinions are subject to change without notice. This document is for information purposes only. Descriptions of any company or companies or their securities mentioned herein are not intended to be complete and this document is not, and should not be construed as an offer or solicitation of an offer, to buy or sell any securities or other financial instruments. This report is not directed to, or intended for display, downloading, printing, reproducing or for distribution to or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident or located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, reproduction, availability or use would be contrary to law or regulation or what would subject HDFC Securities Ltd or its affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. If this report is inadvertently send or has reached any individual in such country, especially, USA, the same may be ignored and brought to the attention of the sender. This document may not be reproduced, distributed or published for any purposes without prior written approval of HDFC Securities Ltd . Foreign currencies denominated securities, wherever mentioned, are subject to exchange rate fluctuations, which could have an adverse effect on their value or price, or the income derived from them. In addition, investors in securities such as ADRs, the values of which are influenced by foreign currencies effectively assume currency risk. It should not be considered to be taken as an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any security. HDFC Securities Ltd may from time to time solicit from, or perform broking, or other services for, any company mentioned in this mail and/or its attachments. HDFC Securities and its affiliated company(ies), their directors and employees may; (a) from time to time, have a long or short position in, and buy or sell the securities of the company(ies) mentioned herein or (b) be engaged in any other transaction involving such securities and earn brokerage or other compensation or act as a market maker in the financial instruments of the company(ies) discussed herein or act as an advisor or lender/borrower to such company(ies) or may have any other potential conflict of interests with respect to any recommendation and other related information and opinions. HDFC Securities Ltd, its directors, analysts or employees do not take any responsibility, financial or otherwise, of the losses or the damages sustained due to the investments made or any action taken on basis of this report, including but not restricted to, fluctuation in the prices of shares and bonds, changes in the currency rates, diminution in the NAVs, reduction in the dividend or income, etc. HDFC Securities Ltd and other group companies, its directors, associates, employees may have various positions in any of the stocks, securities and financial instruments dealt in the report, or may make sell or purchase or other deals in these securities from time to time or may deal in other securities of the companies / organisations described in this report.
Rating Definitions
BUY : Where the stock is expected to deliver more than 10% returns over the next 12 month period
NEUTRAL : Where the stock is expected to deliver (-)10% to 10% returns over the next 12 month period
SELL : Where the stock is expected to deliver less than (-)10% returns over the next 12 month period
HDFC securities Institutional Equities Unit No. 1602, 16th Floor, Tower A, Peninsula Business Park, Senapati Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400 013 Board : +91-22-6171 7330 www.hdfcsec.com