NATIONAL OVERVIEW 2014 ENERGY MARKET PERSPECTIVE Neil Copeland Management Consulting Division
Dec 26, 2015
2
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
About the Black & Veatch Energy Market Perspective
.
The EMP is available as a National Service or as one or more regional services: Western, Texas (ERCOT), Northeast, Midwest and Southeast.
EMP North American Market Coverage
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
3
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
EDBlack & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
Top 7 Electric Industry Issues
20
12
ST
RA
TE
GIC
DIR
EC
TIO
NS
SU
RV
EY
3Reliability, environmental regulation, and economic regulation are the top issues industry-wide
4
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Black & Veatch Outlook on U.S. Power Demand
• Growth of 1.6% annually from 2014-2016, before reverting to a long-term growth trend of about 1.0% per year
Source: EIA, Black & Veatch Energy Market Perspective Analysis
20082009
20102011
20122013
20142015
20162017
20182019
20202021
20222023
20242025
-
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1,000
-6.0%
-4.0%
-2.0%
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
Peak Demand - United StatesCoincident Peak Demand (GW) Annual Growth Rate (%)
Coin
ciden
t Pea
k De
man
d (G
W)
Annu
al G
row
th ra
te (%
)
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
5
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
5
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
Natural Gas; 352,226
Nuclear; 97,393 Coal; 293,597
Hydro & Other Re-
newables; 112,175
Wind; 67,681 Solar; 12,815
Coal (IGCC); 1,709
Other Steam Turbine; 86,246
34%
10%29%
11%
7%1%0%
8%
Natural Gas; 717,028
Nuclear; 61,137
Coal; 162,885
Hydro & Other Re-
newables; 113,324
Wind; 133,321
Solar; 39,227
Coal (IGCC); 5,166 Other Steam Turbine; 50,126
56%
5%
13%
9%
10%
3%0%4%
CAPACITY MIX (MW) IN 2014 CAPACITY MIX (MW) IN 2038
Capacity represents the total amount of electricity that can be produced.
The Changing Capacity Mix: Where U.S. energy will come from
6
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
6
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
ENERGY MIX (GWh) IN 2014 ENERGY MIX (GWh) IN 2038
Energy mix refers to total electricity consumed and where that electricity came from.
Natural Gas;
1,048,284
Nuclear; 773,764
Coal; 1,596,070
Other Steam
Turbine; 63,899
Wind; 185,157
Solar; 23,982
Hydro & Other Re-newables; 356,139 Coal (IGCC); 10,519
26%
19%39%
2%5%
1%9% 0%
Natural Gas; 2,705,297
Nuclear; 486,210
Coal; 1,079,001
Other Steam
Turbine; 39,076
Wind; 416,767
Solar; 123,609
Hydro & Other Re-newables; 371,286 Coal (IGCC); 40,879
51%
9%
21%
1%
8%
2%7%1%
The Changing U.S. Energy Mix
7
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Black & Veatch forecasts additional 86.2 GW of coal-fueled generator retirements by 2038
• Continuing trend in retirement of smaller, older coal-fired assets through 2020
• Forecasted retirements driven primarily by low-cost natural gas prices and EPA hazardous air pollutant requirements
• Future Green House Gas emission regulations could materially alter projections
Coal Unit Retirements Forecasted at 60.1 GW by 2020
Source: Black & Veatch
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
7
8
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
West County Energy Center, Fla.
Coal retirements and decline in regional reserve margins will drive continued capacity growth
• Power sector demand for gas expected to grow 3.1% annually
• More than 364,000 MW of new gas capacity is expected before 2038
• Technology advances, clean air initiatives drive growth
Natural Gas-Fueled Generation Will Continue to Grow
Source: Black & Veatch
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
8
9
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 $-
$1.00
$2.00
$3.00
$4.00
$5.00
$6.00
Henry Hub Natural Gas Spot PriceHistorical (Nominal) B&V Projection (Mid-Year 2013) B&V Projection (Year End 2013) EIA AEO 2013
2013
$/M
MBt
uNatural Gas Price Forecast
2013-2017Growth in low-cost supplies
dampens price growth
2017-2022Price growth is driven by LNG exports, coal capacity retirements, and GHG legislation
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
10
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
New England price spikes in winter signal infrastructure constraints
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
11
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Major Pipeline Constraint Points During Peak Winter in New England
Iroquois Gas TransmissionMaritimes & Northeast
Portland Natural GasTennessee Gas Pipeline
Algonquin Gas Transmission
Tennessee 300 Line
Algonquin G System/J Loop
Tennessee 200 Line
M&NE and TGP Dracut
Pipeline Constraint Points
• Winter pipeline constraints exist due to a lack of market area storage and growing peak residential, commercial, and power generation demand
• During last week’s winter storm, regional natural gas prices reached above $40.00/MMBtu while Gulf Coast prices remained at $4.00/MMBtu
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
12
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Planned U.S. Pipeline Projects Highlight Constraints on the System
Source: EIA, March, 2013
Over 50% of 2012 projects are in theNortheast U.S.
13
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Lopburi 55 MW Solar Farm - Thailand
Renewable capacity additions are driven by state Renewable Portfolio Standards requirements
• In the short term, the status of tax incentives for wind looms in the political arena
• ~93,200 MW of new capacity additions anticipated by 2038
• Wind will make up majority of new capacity additions
• Solar capacity expected to grow as a result of technology advances
Renewable Energy Growth Will Continue
Source: Black & Veatch
Black & Veatch EMP: 2014 Outlook
13
14
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
ED
Trajectory of Renewables Growth
Source: Black & Veatch Energy Market Perspective Analysis
15
BLAC
K &
VEA
TCH
CO
NFI
DEN
TIAL
—FO
R CL
IEN
T’S
INTE
RNAL
USE
ON
LY—
SECO
NDA
RY D
ISTR
IBU
TIO
N P
ROH
IBIT
EDBlack & Veatch EMP: 2013 Outlook
• Overall electric generation capacity will increase by 30%•Natural gas generation ↑ 100+%•Renewable generation ↑ 150%•Nuclear capacity ↓ 35%•Conventional coal ↓ 40%
• Overall market share will also shift•Natural gas = more than half of all electricity consumed•Coal’s market share ↓ 20%•Nuclear’s market share ↓ 10%
Nuclear and coal retirements will vary by region.
NATIONAL PROJECTIONS: WHAT DOES IT ALL MEAN?
DURING THE NEXT 25 YEARS:
15