national lawful intercept strategy - Electronic Frontier Foundation

À!I IIFOR}TÀTION CONTÀTIi'ED

IIEREIN I5 lJNCLÀssIFIEDDÀTE tr-24-2008 BE 6032Z|VCLRP.iP,I,/EHL

NATIONAL LAWFUL INTERCEPT STRATEGYCurrent and Future Challenges

Operational Technology Division

LAWFUL INTERCEPT CAPABILITIES ARE ERODINGAND AT RISK OF GOING DARK

Existing trends indicate the FBI will (spread electronic surveiffance d¡fficü

ave substantial and widetlss i,n 2 to 3 years

b:Þ rL

stabfe communication env_ironment from time terephoneinvented in 1876 until t gec --Áiä;ä;äer craham Betl

MULTIPLE ACCESS METHODS TO A VARIETY OF SERVICES

ALWAYS ON, ALWAYS CONNECTED, ALWAYS MOVINGWIRELESS SERVICES / CAPABILITIES

Cingular 8525 Blackberry Curve

- !!F

-E.' :

Samsung Blackjack

H¡Phone

g

Ëatat

2.sG (GPRS)

3G (UMrS)

Wi.F¡Bluetooth

GPS

3rd Party Appl¡catjonsCameraKeyboard

Touch ScreenPrice (w¡th contract)

''T- .Ihrbile.

WI-FI OVERVIEW

san Francisco coverage (from wigre.net)t;- ---\-

lE¡;i.i;+l,ii¡.ri:ir{,fi

'::it:'ií-;,i :

#ffi

A BLETCHLEY PARK APPROACH TO THE PROBLEM

ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE IS A FOUNDATION OFTHE FBI'S STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK

T6 - Align technology and science to ourstrategic objectives Lover¡ge Tochnology ¡nd Sc,lence .

T7 - Deploy fechnology and science to

--

,# maKeour wo¡kforcemoreeffectiveandeficient

BACKUP MATERIAL

NATIONAL LAWFUL INTERCEPT STRATEGY

Enhanced cooperation between faw enforcement andindustry

Enhanced cooperation and coordination across the lawenforcement

lomTu.nity (Nationat Lawful InterceptCoordination Center)

updated authorities (protection of sensitive/proprietaryinformation from industry etc.)

Update legal mandates (CALEA etc.)

Adequate resources and infrastructure for the lawenforcement community

NATIONAL LAWFUL INTERCEPT STRATEGYcurrent and Future challenges

Operational Technology Division

Ð;fÞÞT¡IF..{ F t¡.FT

HHFttl- E,I HO

r.J Lñ 'dtqÞ

I'J t Fl|ff-)H|fFOÕ0Þ4uÈlLc(l'r¡ Fl tf11crìHH,r!1FL.JÞHr.J 4rù rq\tJf'1ts{F¡É

c{

H

tr{

13

t7

2t

26

ATT II'IFORHÀTIOI'I üDI.ITATIIED

TIEREIIü IS IJ}ICLq.55IFIEDDATE 1t-24-200Ê Er 6æZZllJtLÈp/p,1/EHt

b6b?C

I

ÉdrrË :

=aÐ-go{i[s-ggã,Ë'ËFgëËdrff-ö ä'geöúi=

-rdÐ5€Goo

f-g{rà'

{

c{@A.ENDA

o Technlcaf Challenges Presented by EmergtngTechnologþs

o tttlgraüon ln Wreless Handset Gapablllües

ÞlNa-

INTERCEPTION CHALLENGES RESULTING FROMEMERGING PACKET-BASED COMMUNICATION SERVICES

i M Eentfces are erloþlrìg to ofror newfeaturQs anrd capablllües to subserlbers whhh rere notavallable on üadlüonal teleconrmunlcatlon netrcrks

' Thb evoluüon preEents Ee\teral dìallengesto lawen@lrildudlng

TARGET IVIOBILITY

t¡lC.J F-J] JI

NZ¡Io / subscriber may roam from location to location wíthout impacting theirservrces

c "l/-/Eorth1|n&

m@Løw Enforcement

l^,' .r:..¡.-.\r,. - J Ji..ii__.r:.!

@ØINETZERO

-

ünvo@TARGET IDENTIFICATION

TargetAddress A

AMw,bødgu¡@wffi.com

= Good Account

= Address A

ünttEnftw*^t7Ðs.^3

w

,ffiæw,,llrw*ß=.ffihæA

WWtu* MWM*

ENCRYPTION

ÞlôJ t-.

Law Enforcemenl

"@ 'EER-T'-'EER

c.¡ t*--a!

Løw Enforcement

CELLULAR COMMUNICATION SERVICES -THE "PERFECT STORM'' OF CHALLENGES

¡ ModeT:f!?I.t phones combl.e the mobilts ofhadlüonal cell phorrês wtÛr Hre capab¡mru of fixedcomputers

¡ Wll become more popularutllh 61e e\reregeGonsumeres costs ere rcduced and heti:lntrÐilacesbecome more eæsslbþ (*ó., eppl";ò rÞiiàñCi--i

ALWAYS ON, ALWAYS CONNECTED, ALWAYS MOVINGWIRELESS SERVICES / CAPABILITIES

Ëatat

z.tc (cPß$)3G (UMTS)

vrnBlaetooth

6TTT

3rd Pany Applicøtions

Keyboaú

Tooú ScrlenPrice (with contract)

.-T--tr'lobile.

DWbryúrc SetrrqDfiú

ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANC TRENDS .WHERE TITLE III WIRETAP AUTHORIZATIONS OCCUR

. Shlftln loceüon of wflctrps

' tfirchss I mobllo tochnologhr ilo g¡o prhncdmcdlum of communlcrtþns fior tergcts

I 991

ffi

2006

PROCESSING AND VIEWING COLLECTED DATA

i¡ QnpnhDoHed,,Laweffirccmmmrü* plgoÊÊs ttC hdtiktrd¡

¡ r e ìa

eBpxorüom'r X,ffiy'pfi@Jaffi ,Wnridntnær.ffir;ñrlLñÊ€ds

II

qìffir/äIþ,

Wffi{Wrqg¡ilttngq@&tæ.-{øffitñsîrþrr@IiløiÑ.@lg6tø¡rqfilÞmsffi

r hrpds.ofmvahrcofdaheøtcdcql'¡ W.@@-ryfrWtreqprrÊ3

vq¡nlltrarnftEÍe¡ø4p'r $gril.tr@JîÉ UC neø¿rc arengufiø) ¡ø ædVæ dil üilÊ @W&rdffil

TECHNICAL CHALLENGES WITH PROTOCOLPROCESSING AND APPLICATION COMPLEXITY

o lmplementatlons of packetùased segæs nolonger çlyon standärdÞed arcfrltþctrres andprotocolsrrNllæn\We#.d¡-&Æ¡F#4llærnvfæsanebuflft

upørttn¡@rnr€fiâmdbrdt@larWW¡tøwryøffis¡¡¡p*

- Ðßtnt ün¡e BMwdø wnil and¡t¡6*u ¡rW æ ryj¡Wnpgfi@dtm¡ aprøuidWr"sryfffrørrîwfiürwr - "'-'r' e-

,¡ çJræfæ attt e¡tnvfiiantrm¡ent øf erg¡nütrmnrt wx¡wflfM før uørtøt¡løns tntrrnpHrnøntøtlørtt

H¡øuldÐru wnfttni¡uø[f,iyt u@&¡tp-and mffiftytrlhetr ar{l/ræfføns tø Wfilrtøfie Wfn@frfue --'- --''t -¿r¡qr,v="-"¡rz¡,.¡ì¿

llnf¡øxrnøItøn aunÍtØMÞ ffnr øn¡e nú-vue'¡tn tîrry nøt W auniløUte fmlarmfilnør

CHALLENGES WITH TITIE III INTERCEPTION OFEII,IERG ING TECH NOLOGIES

The comblaüon of several tecfin¡cel hctorspresent unhue ]egal cfialbngÊs vútfii thelnterceptbn of packet commùnbaüons

TITLE ll¡ GOVERAGE: KEY DEFINITIONS

ilnteræpf * ecqulrlng æntents of a@mmunlcatlon uslng a devToe*contents'- substanoe pumort or meanlng of aGommunlcatonnwlre communlcaüon" -'ir frnnrollvfng tthr@ hrulnnørnr voføe

- €rt ljeast WW üh,nouglhr uæ øf awüne

- fndJuldlee tfh,nough a *suyijt-çJhfng str-arü@ni'

'¡ f nrciudles *d@ffiwnt fto st-onagp' øfr a @Mfriúfiî¡trurnrficøtfionr

TITLE lll COVERAGE: KEY DEF|NIT|ONS

i *elecüonlc @mmunlcaüon' - eny ftansþr ofslgns, sþnals, wrtüng, lmages, sounds, data orlntelllgence of any natunÐ, üansmltted ln wholeor in part byìillrê, radlo, ebchomegneüqphotoelectronlc, or photoopücel system exoept:- @! wtne w wr@tll çøntnn¡ulnl@rtdont

-

-t[@ßMng¡ dlevfræ

- ellæff@nrlCI fuindB trarnsfer

ìË

CHALLENGES IDENTIFYING WIRE AND ELECTRONICCOMMUNICATIONS IN PACKET NETWORKS

SUMMARY

Erne.rgi¡q tecfinologles present a unigue æt ofrecnroef g?lFgl$ g lgq.g@rcemeritb abifig roA ,Âr^.al-.^{consduct elecffion

¡ Gellularoommqniaüons are becomlns rnoresophft¡c.ated, ofreted all of t e Cpa-ËlÌtää-ùrtetouslyassociated vvth frted bfoadbend'g€n l'ces inä

!v-vr

moblle, llght weþht device

bsurvellalnæ

oCmoJo=o