Nagpur Goon Akku Yadav Murder Case Judgement

8/10/2019 Nagpur Goon Akku Yadav Murder Case Judgement

1/41

1 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

Presented on : 07.1.004.!e"#stered on: 07.1.004.$e%#ded on : 10.11.014.$r't#on : 9 11 3$

IN THE COURT OF ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE,NAGPUR

(Pres#ded o*er + -.T. Sr''ns#)

Sessions Trial No. 453 o !""4. E#$. No. !%&.

Te St'te o ''r'str'Tro" P.S.. S'd'r,N'"2r. ..Co'(lainan)

*ers+s

1 n't $rod'n C''n, "ed '+ot 40 e'rs, %%. '+or, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

' Sd'm ood, "ed '+ot 35 e'rs, %%. '+or, !/o 'r' o;#,


2/41

S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

Sessions Trial No. 3/0!""5.

Te St'te o ''r'str'Tro" P.S.. S'd'r,N'"2r.

..Co'(lainan)

*ers+s

1 N#; = N#;es Sdeo >m'ne, "ed '+ot 30 e'rs, %%. P'#nt#n", !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

!#tes Sdeo >m'ne, "ed '+ot 3 e'rs, %%. P'#nt#n", !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

3 !'es = edr' s/o C'ndr'+'n $on"'de, "ed '+ot 38 e'rs, %%. P'#nt#n", !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

4 . ?s' 'd'r N'r''ne, "ed '+ot 33 e'rs, %%. Pr#*'te Ser*#%e, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

5 -#' = '+;' = 'r s/o S'n'rr'o '+'de = S#nde, "ed '+ot 3 e'rs, %%. P'n So2, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

6 !'es = !' s/o $'tt ?rde,

"ed '+ot 33 e'rs, %%. Pr#*'te or, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r. ... A--+se.


3/41

3 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

Sessions Trial No. 1510!""%.

Te St'te o ''r'str'Tro" P.S.. S'd'r, N'"2r. ..Co'(lainan)

*ers+s

1 P#n# = 'n#s' ' S'm+'r'r, "ed '+ot 8 e'rs, %%. >oseo;d, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

Smt. S'*#t' J#tendr' @'n'r#, "ed '+ot 35 e'rs, %%. >oseo;d, !/o '"#r't'+'# 'ot, J'r#2't', N'"2r.

3 Smt. '"r't' >'r#%'nd d#ne, "ed '+ot 70 e'rs, %%. >oseo;d, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

4 Smt. ee;'+'# !'"n't S'n"o;e,

"ed '+ot 58 e'rs, %%. '+orer, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

5 Smt. $e*'n"'n' Sdeo >m'ne, "ed '+ot 55 e'rs, %%. >oseo;d, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r. (Dea)

6 N#;es = !#tes S#t'r'm esr'm, "ed '+ot 8 e'rs, %%. P'#nt#n", !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

7 'no = 'n#s S'n'rr'o '+'de = S#nde, "ed '+ot 34 e'rs, %%. Ser*#%e, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

8 -#;'s Sr#r'm 'nde, "ed '+ot 4 e'rs, %%. d*o%'te, !/o 'str+'n'"'r, N'"2r.

9


4/41

4 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

A((earan-e:r. !'*#ndr' o'r, .P.P. or te St'te.r. !.. T#'r#, d*o%'te or ';; '%%sed.r. ..'n"de, d*o%'te or '%%sed No.3.

OFFENCES PUNISHA2LE UNDER SECTIONS 14&, 14,353 3"! R0 14/ OF THE INDIAN PENAL CODE.

Co''on J+'en)($e;#*ered t#s 10td' o No*em+er, 014)

. %%sed 2ersons st'nd %'r"ed or te oen%es

2n#s'+;e nder se%t#ons 147, 148, 353 'nd 30 r/ 149 o te


5/41

5 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

ent to P'n%2'o;# 2o;#%e st't#on 'nd +ro"t tose or

2ersons #n%;d#n" de%e'sed 'd'* to Cort #n ' 2o;#%e *'n

't 'rond .15 2.m. $e%e'sed 'd'* 'nd oter tree ere

nder 'nd%. ter "ett#n" don rom te 2o;#%e *'n, ';; te

tree 2o;#%e %onst'+;es ere t'#n" tose '%%sed to'rds

Cort no.7 #n +eteen .15 to .30 2.m. @en te re'%ed te

%'nne; "'te o Cort no.7, sdden; 10 to 1 omen 'nd 5 to

30 men rsed to te %'nne; "'te #;e '+s#n" de%e'sed

'd'*. Te ere 's#n" 2o;#%e %onst'+;es to re;e'se

'd'* 's te 'd to #;; #m. C $'mod'r Cod'r# 'nd P@9 !'*#ndr'

Sr''ns# tr#ed to 2re*ent te mo+, +t te mo+ 'd

o*er2oered tem 'nd st'rted "#*#n" +;os to de%e'sed #t

>'tt#m'r n#e, +;'de o s2e'r, B2t#, stones 'nd ";'ss, de to


6/41

6 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

#% 'd'* e;; don #n te Cort #n ront o te d'#s #n '

2oo; o +;ood. Te ';;, +en%es 'nd ';m#r' o te Cort ';;

ere st'#ned #t +;ood. Te mo+ 'd ';so 'ss';ted oter

tree 2ersons ('%%sed #n oter %'se) S%#ndr' !'mtee,

N#s'nt S'rm' 'nd !'m Bed'm. Te too 'd re%e#*ed

#nr#es. ter #n;#%t#n" te ser#os #nr#es to de%e'sed, te

'ss'#;'nts 'd ;ed ''. P@ >C $'mod'r Cod'r# 'd

%'sed 'nd %'"t o;d o one o te 'ss'#;'nts, +t te oter

'ss'#;'nts %'me to #s res%e 'nd + o*er2oer#n" #m, "ot te

s'#d 'ss'#;'nt res%ed 'nd ;ed ''.

n re%e#*#n" te mess'"e o te #n%#dent, P@1

Sen#or P.os2#t';.

P@ >C $'mod'r Cod'r# ent to 2o;#%e st't#on 'nd

;od"ed re2ort E.77. n te +'s#s o #s re2ort, %r#me 'sre"#stered '"'#nst '%%sed no.1 n't C''n 'nd oter 15

to 0 nnon 2ersons. P@1 P.


7/41

7 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

'nd P@. 9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# ere ';so reerred to 'o

>os2#t'; or eE'm#n't#on 'nd 's te rter #n*est#"'t#on 's

ordered to +e 'nded o*er to C.os2#t';. ed#%'; #%er 'd o2#ned t't te #nr#es re%e#*ed

+ te de%e'sed %o;d +e %'sed + tose e'2ons. P@16 $.

S.P. r. Por'te 'd sent te ;etter to S2e%#'; Jd#%#'; '"#str'te

or o;d#n" test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de o '%%sed n't


8/41

8 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

C''n, Smed 'r'de, $#;#2 Sende, 'nd oter '%%sed.

Te #tnesses 'd #dent##ed most o te '%%sed 2ersons. Te

*#s%er' 's e;; 's te se#Fed 2ro2ert#es ere sent to !.A.S.. or

%em#%'; eE'm#n't#on. Te +;ood s'm2;es o te '%%sed

2ersons ere ';so %o;;e%ted 'nd te ere ';so sent to !.A.S..

or 'n';s#s. s 2er te C.. re2ort te +;ood "ro2 o de%e'sed

's o "ro2 GG 'nd te +;ood st'#ns ond on te ';m#r',

%'#rs, ooden 2;'n, n#e, d'""er 'nd te +;ood st'#ned e'rt

%o;;e%ted rom te s2ot ere ond to +e st'#ned #t +;ood

"ro2 GG. No +;ood o "ro2 GG 's dete%ted on te %;otes 'nd

'n e'2ons se#Fed rom te 2ossess#on o '%%sed 2ersons

eE%e2t '%%sed no.1 n't C''n.

4


9/41

9 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

5 S#n%e ';; tose tree %'r"eseets ere 'r#s#n" ot

o te s'me %r#me, m ;e'rned 2rede%essor 's %;++ed ';; tose

%'ses #n Sess#ons Tr#'; No.453/004.

6 C'r"es or te oen%es 2n#s'+;e nder se%t#ons

147, 148, 353 'nd 30 r/ 149 ere r'med '"'#nst '%%sed

2ersons, to #% te 2;e'ded not "#;t 'nd %;'#med to +e

tr#ed.

7 $een%e o te '%%sed 2ersons 's re*e';ed rom te

mode o %rosseE'm#n't#on 'nd te#r st'tements re%orded nder

se%t#on 313 o te Code o Cr#m#n'; Pro%edre #s t't o tot';

den#'; 'nd ';se #m2;#%'t#on. %%ord#n" to '%%sed 2ersons,

de%e'sed 's ' notor#os %r#m#n';. Se*er'; oen%es o mrder,

'ttem2t to %omm#t mrder, tet, ro++er, eEtort#on, %r#m#n';

#nt#m#d't#on et%. ere re"#stered '"'#nst #m. >e 's 'r'ss#n"

te 2eo2;e or no ';t on te#r 2'rt. >e 'd %re'ted terror #n

'str+' N'"'r ;o%';#t. $e to #s n;'; '%t#*#t#es te

2eo2;e #n te ;o%';#t ere ed 2. Te 'd m'de %om2;'#nts

#t J'r#2't' 2o;#%e, +t no %o"n#F'n%e o te#r %om2;'#nts

ere t'en. n te oter 'nd, 2o;#%e ere "#*#n" 2rote%t#onto de%e'sed. Tereore, 2eo2;e o te ;o%';#t 'd t'en te

2rotest m'r% '"'#nst te 2o;#%e 's te ere 2rote%t#n" #;;e"';

'%t#*#t#es o de%e'sed 'd'*.


10/41

10 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

t#s %'se on; on te +'s#s o ss2#%#on. Te %;'#m to +e

#nno%ent.

8 C $'mod'r

Cod'r#, P@9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns#, P@10 S'ntos

'd'* 'nd P@11 *r' 'd'* 're te ee #tnesses to te

o%%rren%e. P@1 $#2' $eo"'re #s te 2'n% #tness to te

se#Fre o re"#ster rom 2o;#%e st't#on, se#Fre o n#orms rom

2o;#%e %onst'+;es 'nd %;otes 't te #nst'n%e o Smed

'r'de, $#;#2 Sende, !' $on"de, N#;es >m'ne 'nd

N#tes >m'ne. P@3 Pr'mod N'"re #s ';so te 2'n% #tness

to te se#Fre o re"#ster 'nd n#orms rom 2o;#%e %onst'+;es

'nd %;otes 't te #nst'n%e o '%%sed Sende, >m'ne, !'

edr', !' ?rde et%. P@4 'nd 'm+;e #s ';so 2'n%

#tness, #n ose 2resen%e St't#on d#'r E.55 'nd n#orm o

P@. 9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 's se#Fed on 17.08.004 #.e

'ter or d's. P@5 Sres T#'r# #s te 2'n% #tness to te

s2ot 2'n%'n'm', +t e 's not s22orted te 2rose%t#on.

P'n% #tness P@6 Bo;d's '#r'"# 's 2ro*ed te s2ot

2'n%'n'm' E.93. P@7 !'es ;e #s te 2'n% #tness tote se#Fre o %;otes o !'m Bed'm, 'n '%%sed #n 'noter

%'se. T#s #tness 's not s22orted te %'se. P@8 Sn#;

@'nede #s te 2'n% #tness to te memor'ndm 'nd

re%o*er 2'n%'n'm' o te +;ood st'#ned %;otes 'nd n#e 't

te #nst'n%e o '%%sed no.1 n't C''n. P@1 Sen#or P.


11/41

11 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de o '%%sed 2ersons #n S'nsrt# '*'n

'nd ';so #n Centr'; J'#;, N'"2r. P@14 S't' $'r'de 's

te oner o TT Smo #n #% '%%sed 2ersons %'me to te

Cort. T#s #tness 's not s22orted te 2rose%t#on. P@15

P.


12/41

1 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

ere #t de%e'sed. Tereore, '%%ord#n" to ;e'rend .P.P. t't

#t #s +t n'tr'; t't tese #tnesses 'd #tnessed te #n%#dent.

P@10 S'ntos 'd'*, te ne2e 'nd P@11 *r' 'd'*, te

re'; +roter o de%e'sed 'd seen te #n%#dent rom te +roen

ooden door o te Cort. Tese or ee #tnesses '*e

reerred te n'mes o most o te '%%sed #n te#r res2e%t#*e

e*#den%e 'nd #dent##ed most o te '%%sed 2ersons. P@ >C

$'mod'r Cod'r# 'nd P@9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# '*e

st'ted t't te mo+ 'd o*er2oered tem 'nd 'ss';ted

de%e'sed #t de'd; e'2ons. Te %#;;# 2oder 'nd some

e'2ons ere ond on te s2ot #% s22orts te *ers#on o

tese #tnesses. Tese #tnesses '*e ';so #dent##ed te

e'2ons +eore te Cort. >m'n +;ood 's ond on te

n#orm o P@ >C $'mod'r Cod'r# 'nd t#s '%t sos

2resen%e o t#s #tness on te s2ot o #n%#dent. ost most o

te '%%sed 2ersons ere #dent##ed + te ee #tnesses #n test

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de to +e te 'ss'#;'nts o de%e'sed. ;ood

st'#ned %;otes 'nd one n#e 's re%o*ered 't te #nst'n%e o

'%%sed no.1 n't C''n #% %orro+or'tes te e*#den%e

o 'ores'#d #tnesses t't e 'd 'ss';ted de%e'sed #t n#e

';on" #t oter '%%sed. %%ord#n" to ;e'rned .P.P., tee*#den%e '*'#;'+;e on re%ord #s s#%#ent to o;d some o te

'%%sed "#;t or te oen%es, # not ';; te '%%sed. e'rned

.P.P 's s+m#tted t't ';; te '+o*e or #tnesses 're n'tr';

#tnesses 'nd tereore m#nor om#ss#ons, %ontr'd#%t#ons 'nd

d#s%re2'n%#es '22e'r#n" #n te#r e*#den%e do not render te#r

e*#den%e n+e;#e*'+;e. $e;' #n ;od"#n" te A.


13/41

13 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

#m2ort'n%e. 'r'n'

(001) 3 SCC 468, 'nd 10 St'te o ?.P *. $e*endr' S#n"

(004) 10 SCC 616.

11 s '"'#nst t#s, r. T#'r#, ;e'rned 'd*o%'te or te

'%%sed reted te 'ores'#d s+m#ss#ons o te ;e'rned .P.P.

'nd s+m#tted t't tere #s '+so;te; no %o"ent, re;#'+;e 'nd

%ons#stent e*#den%e to o;d 'n o te '%%sed "#;t or te

oen%es. e'rned 'd*o%'te s+m#tted t't P@ >C $'mod'r

Cod'r# 's noere st'ted t't 'n o te '%%sed 'd

'ss';ted de%e'sed #t 'n e'2on. >e 's st'ted t't e 's

no#n" some o te 2ersons o 'd "'tered on te s2ot o#n%#dent 'nd te ere '%%sed n't C''n, ?s'

N'r''ne, one ;'d + n'me or'r '# 'nd P'n' '"'t,

?rde >m'ne 'nd P#n#. >oe*er, e 's not n'med 'n o

tose 2ersons 's te 'ss'#;'nts o de%e'sed #n #s re2ort E.77

eE%e2t '%%sed no.1 n't C''n ose n'me 's to;d to

#m + one S< r. S#rs't. S'#d S< S#rs't 's not eE'm#ned #n

t#s %'se. oreo*er, to" e 's #dent##ed some o te


14/41

14 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

'%%sed #n test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de, e 's 'dm#tted t't te

2oto"r'2s o te '%%sed 2ersons ere 2+;#sed #n

nes2'2er 's e;; 's on nes %'nne;s 'nd tereore, te test

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de 's no s#"n##%'n%e. P@9 PC !'*#ndr'

Sr''ns# ';;e"ed; 2resent #n te Cort ';; 't te t#me o

#n%#dent #;e %'t%#n" o;d o te de%e'sed. t, no +;ood

st'#n 's ond on #s %;otes 2'rt#%;'r; en te +;ood st'#ns

ere s2re'd #" on te ';;s o te Cort ';;, ';m#r', %'#rs,

+en%es et%. Te +;ood st'#ns o te +;ood "ro2 o de%e'sed

ere not ond on te %;otes o +ot te %onst'+;es #%

sos t't +ot te %onst'+;es 'd ;ed '' rom te Cort

';; 's te mo+ 'd +e%ome *#o;ent 'nd te 'd not seen te

'ss'#;'nts o te de%e'sed. e'rned 'd*o%'te 's 2o#nted ot

te 'dm#ss#on "#*en + P@9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# t't

de2'rtment'; enD#r 's #n#t#'ted '"'#nst #m 'nd P@ >e'd

Const'+;e $'mod'r Cod'r# 'nd te ';;e"'t#ons ere

'"'#nst tem t't te 'd ;ed '' rom te s2ot ;e'*#n" te

de%e'sed #n te Cort ';;. Not on; t#s, P@11 *r' 'd'*

's %'nd#d; 'dm#tted t't no 2o;#%em'n 's 2resent #n te

Cort ';; en #s +roter 's +e#n" 'ss';ted. Tereore,

'%%ord#n" to ;e'rned 'd*o%'te, te e*#den%e o +ot te%onst'+;es %'nnot +e +e;#e*ed. s re"'rds te e*#den%e o oter

to ee #tnesses P@10 S'ntos 'd'* 'nd P@11 *r'

'd'*, ;e'rned 'd*o%'te 2o#nted ot t't #nter#or 2'rt o te

Cort #s not *#s#+;e rom te +roen ooden door tro" #%

tese #tnesses s'#d to '*e seen te #n%#dent. Soon 'ter te

#n%#dent P@10 S'ntos 'd'* met te 2o;#%e, +t e d#d not te;;

tem t't e 'd seen te #n%#dent. Te st'tements o +ot te


15/41

15 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

#tnesses ere re%orded 'ter ' "'2 o %ons#der'+;e t#me 'nd

moreo*er te#r e*#den%e does not #ns2#re %on#den%e. Te

e*#den%e o ';; tese or so %';;ed #tnesses #s ne#ter

%ons#stent nor '%%e2t'+;e. Te test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de 's

e;d 'ter te "'2 o %ons#der'+;e t#me '2'rt rom te '%t t't

te 2oto"r'2s o te '%%sed 2ersons ere 2+;#sed #n te

nes2'2ers 'nd te;e%'st on nes %'nne;s. Te S2e%#'; Jd#%#';

'"#str'te 's not e*en enD#red #t te #tnesses eter

te 'd 'n o22ortn#t to see te '%%sed 2ersons #n te me'n

t#me. Te test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de 's not %ond%ted #n '

m'nner 's ;'#d don #n Cr#m#n'; 'n'; 'nd tereore, te

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de mst +e d#s%'rded. e'rned 'd*o%'te

rter s+m#tted t't te #tnesses '*e not #dent##ed most o

te '%%sed 2ersons. *en P@9 PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 's

not #dent##ed m'#n '%%sed n't C''n #n test

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de. Te e*#den%e #n res2e%t o te re%o*er

o +;ood st'#ned %;otes 'nd te n#e 't te #nst'n%e o '%%sed

no.1 n't C'*'n #s not %ons#stent. ot 2'n% #tnesses

'nd te


16/41

16 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

A#nd#n" o ';%oo; #n te *#s%er' o de%e'sed #s te e*#den%e o

2o;#%e so#n" '*or to de%e'sed 'd'* #% '%t 's

"#*en r#se to te #n%#dent. e'rned 'd*o%'te rter s+m#tted

t't tere #s '+so;te; no %o"ent, %on*#n%#n" 'nd re;#'+;e

e*#den%e '"'#nst 'n o te '%%sed to o;d t't te ere te

mem+ers o te mo+ o 'd %omm#tted mrder o de%e'sed.

#nd#n"s tereon 're re%orded 's nder or te re'sons to o;;o.

Poin)s Finins

1 @eter 2rose%t#on 2ro*es t't on13.08.004 't '+ot .35 2.m. #n te';; o Cort No.7, N'"2r '%%sed2ersons ere te mem+ers on;'; 'ssem+; 'nd #n 2rose%t#ono te %ommon o+e%t o s%'ssem+;, *#F. #n %omm#tt#n" mrdero 'd'* %omm#tted te oen%eo r#ot#n" 'nd tere+ %omm#tted 'noen%e 2n#s'+;e nder Se%t#on 147

o te


17/41

17 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

@eter 2rose%t#on 2ro*es t't onte 'ores'#d d'te, t#me 'nd 2;'%e'%%sed 2ersons ere te mem+ers o'n n;'; 'ssem+; 'nd #n2rose%t#on o te %ommon o+e%t os% 'ssem+;, *#F. #n %omm#tt#n" temrder o 'd'* %omm#t teoen%e o r#ot#n" 'nd 't t't t#me

ere 'rmed #t de'd; e'2ons #.e.n#*es, d'""er, +;'de o s2e'r, ";'sset%. 'nd tere+ %omm#tted 'noen%e 2n#s'+;e nder Se%t#on 148o te


18/41

18 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

o de%e'sed 'd'*, d#d %omm#tmrder + #ntent#on';; or no#n";%'s#n" de't o s'#d 'd'* 'ndtere+ %omm#tted 'n oen%e2n#s'+;e nder se%t#on 30 r/ 149o te


19/41

19 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

'd'* #t de'd; e'2ons.

15 s noted '+o*e, 2rose%t#on 's m'#n; re;#ed on

te e*#den%e o or ee #tnesses P@ >e'd Const'+;e

$'mod'r Cod'r#, P@9 Po;#%e Const'+;e !'*#ndr'

Sr''ns#, P@10 S'ntos 'd'*, 'nd P@11 *r' 'd'*.

16 eore 2ro%eed#n" to eE'm#ne te e*#den%e o tese

#tnesses, #t #s se; to note ere t't none o tese #tnesses

'*e de2osed ' s#n";e ord '"'#nst '%%sed Smed 'r'de,

-#' '+de, Smt. '"#r't#+'# d#ne, ee;'+'# S'n"o;e 'nd

N#;es esr'm. Tere #s ';so no oter e*#den%e '"'#nst tese

'%%sed to %onne%t tem #t te %omm#ss#on o te oen%es.

17 C $'mod'r C'd'r#, [email protected] PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 'nd

PC J'#s'n'r T'r ere on '%%sed "'rd dt 'nd te 'd

+ro"t de%e'sed 'd'* 'nd oter tree 2ersons rom

P'n%2'o;# Po;#%e St't#on or te#r 2rod%t#on +eore te Cort

#n ' 2o;#%e -'n. C $'mod'r

C'd'r# t't 'ter "ett#n" don rom te -'n, e 'nd #s

%o;;e'"es ere t'#n" de%e'sed 'nd oter tree 2ersons

('%%sed #n oter %'se) to'rds Cort no.7 rom te s#de o

A'm#; Cort. @en te re'%ed ne'r te %'nne; "'te o Cort

no.7, 10 to 1 omen 'nd 5 to 30 men rsed to'rds tem

#;e '+s#n" 'd'*. Te ere s'#n", I655& ('d'* 8o

C//od $o, >'m5o ?se 8/'t'm 8'rn' >'#J. 22reend#n"

d'n"er to te ;#e o de%e'sed, P@. >C $'mod'r C'd'r#

'nd #s %o;;e'"es too de%e'sed 'nd oter tree 2ersons #ns#de


20/41

0 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

te Cort +#;d#n" 'nd %;osed te %'nne; "'te. Persons orm

te mo+ ere "#*#n" +;os to te %'nne; "'te. Te st'rted

2e;t#n" stones 't te "'te 'nd tro#n" %#;;# 2oder on

de%e'sed. s te mo+ +e%'me *#o;ent, P@. >C $'mod'r "'*e

%';; to P< S''re, o 's 2'ss#n" rom ne'r te %'nne; "'te.

>e to;d P< S''re t't te mo+ 's tr#n" to 'ss';t de%e'sed

'nd 'd reDested #m or e;2. P@. >C $'mod'r too

mo+#;e rom P< S''re 'nd m'de 2one %';; to Po;#%e Contro;

!oom. >e 'd '22r#sed te Contro; room '+ot te s#t't#on on

te s2ot 'nd reDested or send#n" 'dd#t#on'; 2o;#%e or%e. [email protected]

PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 'd t'en de%e'sed 'nd tree oter

to Cort >';; o Cort no.7. S#n%e te %'nne; "'te 's %;osed,

te mo+ ent to s#de ooden door 'nd st'rted to +r'e #t o2en.

S#n%e te mo+ 's tr#n" to +re' o2en te door, P@.

$'mod'r sent PC J'#s'n'r to te Contro; room or +r#n"#n"

'dd#t#on'; 2o;#%e or%e. C

$'mod'r C'd'r# 'nd [email protected] !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# tr#ed to

2re*ent te mo+, +t te mem+ers o te mo+ 'd 'ss';ted

tem 'nd st'rted "#*#n" +;os to 'd'* #t n#e, B2t#,

+;'de o s2e'r, ";'ss et%. $e to te se*er +e't#n" 'd'*re%e#*ed ser#os #nr#es. >e e;; don +es#de te d'#s #n te

2oo; o +;ood 'nd d#ed. Ten ';; tose 2ersons ;ed ''. P@.

>C $'mod'r 'd %'sed 'nd %'"t o;d o one o te

'ss'#;'nts, +t some oter 'ss'#;'nts srronded #m 'nd "ot

te s'#d 'ss'#;'nt res%ed. *#den%e o [email protected] PC !'*#ndr'

Sr''ns# #s s+st'nt#';; on te s'me ;#nes.


21/41

1 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

18 P@. $'mod'r C'd'r# rter de2osed t't e

ne some o te 2ersons o 'd "'tered tere 'nd tose

2ersons ere '%%sed n't C'*'n, P'n' '"'t, ?rde,

>m'ne, ?s' N'r''ne, or'r+'#, 'nd P#n.

19 P@. $'mod'r 's st'ted t't 'ter '+ot 0

m#ntes, 2o;#%e or%e rom S'd'r Po;#%e St't#on 'nd Contro;

room %'me to te s2ot 'nd tere'ter e ent to 2o;#%e st't#on

S'd'r 'nd ;od"ed re2ort E. 77. $r#n" te #n%#dent #s %;otes

ere torn. Po;#%e se#Fed #s %;otes on te neEt d' nder

se#Fre 2'n%'n'm' E. 79. P@. $'mod'r 's rter

st'ted t't e 's %';;ed to Centr'; J'#; or #dent##%'t#on o

'%%sed 2ersons rom t#me to t#me on 5.10.004, 15.01.005,

5.0.005 'nd 3.11.005 'nd e 'd #dent##ed '%%sed 'n't

C'*'n, $#;#2 Sende, P'n' '"'t, ?rde, >m'ne, ?s'

N'r''ne, or'r+'# 'nd P#n #n test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de.

0 [email protected] !'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 's st'ted t't en e

'nd P@. $'mod'r C'd'r# ere res#st#n" te mo+, some

2ersons ere #n;#%t#n" #nr#es to de%e'sed 'd'*.

%%ord#n" to #m, e ne tose 2ersons + te#r '%es. >e 'd#dent##ed '%%sed N#;es >m'ne, !'es $on"'de, !#tes

>m'ne, n't C'*'n, P'n' '"'t, !'es ?rde 'nd

P#n S'm+'r'r + 2o#nt#n" #n"er 't tem +eore te

Cort. >e s's t't on te d' o #n%#dent P< tr'm 'd

re%orded #s st'tement. ter 5 to 7 d's e, P@. $'mod'r

C'd'r# 'nd J's'n'r T'r ere %';;ed to C.


22/41

S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

!'*#ndr' Sr''ns# s's t't #s n#orm 's st'#ned #t

+;ood 't 2;'%es, #% 's se#Fed rom #s 2ossess#on nder

se#Fre memo E. 56.

1 ores'#d e*#den%e o +ot tese #tnesses #;; '*e

+e tested #t reeren%e to te#r %rosseE'm#n't#on 'nd oter

e*#den%e '*'#;'+;e on re%ord. C

$'mod'r #n #s e*#den%e ere 2resent 't te t#me o #n%#dent,

#t %'nnot +e s'#d t't te ere te 'ss'#;'nts o de%e'sed 's no

s2e%##% o*ert '%t 's +een 'ttr#+ted '"'#nst 'n o tem. Te

m' +e te ;#t#"'nts, re;'t#*es o some '%%sed or e*en tes2e%t'tors.

s noted '+o*e, P@ >C $'mod'r Cod'r#

's st'ted t't e ne some o te '%%sed 2ersons. >e 's

st'ted te#r n'mes +eore te Cort. >e 's 'dm#tted #n #s

e*#den%e t't e 'd n'rr'ted te #n%#dent #n #s re2ort #n

det'#;. S#n%e P@. >C $'mod'r ne some o te '%%sed, e


23/41

3 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

's eE2e%ted to '*e n'med tem #n A.C $'mod'r Cod'r# 's st'ted t't te

2ersons #n te mo+ 'd tron %#;;# 2oder on de%e'sed 't te

%'nne; "'te. >oe*er, te s2ot 2'n%'n'm' E.93 does not

so %#;;# 2oder ne'r te %'nne; "'te o Cort no.7. P@

$'mod'r Cod'r# rter s's t't 'ter 'rr#*'; o te 2o;#%e

or%e to te s2ot o #n%#dent, e ent to 2o;#%e St't#on, S'd'r.

>e 's rter st'ted t't e 's not e*en 2resent 't te t#me

o s2ot 2'n%'n'm'. Te e*#den%e o P@1 Sen#or P.


24/41

4 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

St't#on S'd'r #mmed#'te; on 'rr#*'; o te 2o;#%e or%e to te

s2ot o #n%#dent. Pr#nted A.C $'mod'r 's not se#Fed on te d' o #n%#dent en

e %'me to ;od"e te re2ort. Arom t#s, #neren%e %o;d +e

dr'n t't #s n#orm 's ne#ter torn nor 's #t st'#ned #t

+;ood 'nd tereore, #t 's not se#Fed on te d' o #n%#dent.

5 P@ $'mod'r Cod'r# %;'#ms t't '%%sed

n't C''n, $#;#2 Sende, P'n' '"'t, ?rde,

>m'ne, ?s' N'r''ne, or'r+'# 'nd P#n# ere 2resent #n

te mo+ 'nd e 'd #dent##ed tem #n test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de.

>oe*er, e does not s' t't tose '%%sed 'd 'ss';ted

de%e'sed. P@. 9 PC !'*#ndr' 's #dent##ed '%%sed N#;es

>m'ne, !'es $on"'de, !#tes >m'ne, n't C''n,


25/41

5 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

P'n' '"'t, !#tes ?rde 'nd P#n# S'm+'r'r +eore

te Cort to +e te 'ss'#;'nts o de%e'sed.

6 >oe*er, #t mst +e noted ere t't [email protected] PC

!'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 'd #dent##ed on; to '%%sed n'me;

P'n' '"'t 'nd P#n# S'm+'r'r #n test #dent##%'t#on

2'r'de. >e 's not #dent##ed 'n oter '%%sed 's reerred to

+ #m #n #s e*#den%e to +e te 'ss'#;'nts o de%e'sed. >e 's

tr#ed to "#*e +oost to te 2rose%t#on %'se + n'm#n" more

'%%sed to om e 'd not #dent##ed #n test #dent##%'t#on

2'r'de.

7 So 'r 's #dent##%'t#on o some te '%%sed #n test

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'de #s %on%erned, P@ >C $'mod'r

Cod'r# 's %'nd#d; 'dm#tted #n #s e*#den%e t't 'ter te

#n%#dent te 2oto"r'2s o '%%sed 2ersons ere 2+;#sed #n

nes2'2ers 'nd te;e%'st on nes %'nne;s. Te test

#dent##%'t#on 2'r'des o '%%sed 2ersons ere e;d on

5.10.004, 15.01.005, 5.0.005 'nd 3.11.005. Te #n%#dent

's o%%rred on 13.08.004. Need;ess to s' t't tere 's

%ons#der'+;e de;' #n o;d#n" test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de.%%ord#n" to +ot te #tnesses, te #n%#dent o 'ss';t on

de%e'sed ;'sted on; or e m#ntes. +*#os; te %o;d not

"et s#%#ent t#me to o+ser*e e'% o '%%sed #n te mo+.

Pro+'+; t't #s te 'd not e*en "#*en des%r#2t#on o 'n

o te '%%sed +eore te 2o;#%e.


26/41

6 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

' %'se, P'r"'n S#n"/%#ted s2r', to %ontend t't #dent##%'t#on

o '%%sed 'ter 7 K e'rs o te #n%#dent +eore te Cort 's

re;#ed 2on. Te r;#n" %#ted + ;e'rned .P.P #s d#st#n"#s'+;e

on '%ts.


27/41

7 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

9 es#des t#s, te test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de 's not

e;d #n '%%ord'n%e #t ;'.


28/41

8 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

eE'm#n't#on o P@13 r. Som'r t't e 'd not se;e%ted

te dmm#es to s#m#;'r '"e "ro2 'nd te 2s#De o te

'%%sed 2ersons. onG+;e om+'

>#" Cort 's e;d t't ere #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de 's e;d

#n ' dee%t#*e m'nner #tot o;;o#n" te "#de;#nes o

Cr#m#n'; 'n';, 2oss#+#;#t o #tnesses '*#n" seen te

'%%sed +eore test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de %'nnot +e r;ed ot.


29/41

9 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

PC !'*#ndr' Sr''ns#. T#s '%t %ert'#n; %'st ss2#%#on

'+ot te 2resen%e o t#s #tness #n te Cort ';; 't te t#me

o o%%rren%e. e

'd ';so not "#*en des%r#2t#on o 'n o te 'ss'#;'nts #n #s

st'tements eE%e2t te '"e "ro2 o te 'ss'#;'nts. P@9 PC!'*#ndr' Sr''ns# 's e;; 's P@. $'mod'r Cod'r#

'*e not "#*en e*en des%r#2t#on o 'n 2erson o 'd

'ss';ted tem. Tere #s ';so not#n" on re%ord to #nd#%'te t't

te 'd re%e#*ed #nr dr#n" te #n%#dent.


30/41

30 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

3 NeEt ee #tness #s P@10 S'ntos 'd'*. >e #s

ne2e o de%e'sed 'd'*. %%ord#n" to #m, de%e'sed

's #n 2o;#%e ;o% 2 't P'n%2'o;# 2o;#%e st't#on. $e%e'sed

'd D'rre; #t '%%sed -#;'s 'nde 'nd tereore, on

'%%ont o t't D'rre; e 's #n 2o;#%e %stod. %%sed -#;'s

'nde 'd ;od"ed re2ort '"'#nst de%e'sed 'd'*. n

1.08.004 [email protected] S'ntos 'd +een to 2o;#%e st't#on P'n%2'o;#

to see te de%e'sed. >e 'd enD#red #t de%e'sed 's to 't

'd '22ened, ere2on de%e'sed to;d #m t't '%%sed -#;'s

'nde 'nd ?s' N'r''ne 'd +ro"t 30 to 40 2ersons 'nd

demo;#sed #s ose 'nd tereore e 'd D'rre; #t '%%sed

-#;'s 'nde. $e%e'sed 'd rter to;d #m t't on te neEt

d' e o;d +e 2rod%ed +eore te Cort, so e so;d +r#n"

#s ndere'r, +'n#'n 'nd toot +rs #n Cort.

33 P@10 S'ntos 2ro%eeded to n'rr'te t't on

13.08.004 't '+ot 1.30 2.m. e %'me to Cort t'#n" #t #m

te ndere'r, +'n#'n 'nd toot +rs o de%e'sed. >e 's

st'nd#n" #n ront o Cort no.7. Po;#%e +ro"t de%e'sed to

Cort no.7 't '+ot .30 2.m. nder 'nd%. 0 to 5 2ersons

rom 'str+'n'"'r ere 'nder#n" #n te Cort 2rem#ses.Tose 2ersons rsed to +e't de%e'sed 'nd tereore, 2o;#%e

too de%e'sed #ns#de te Cort +#;d#n" 'nd %;osed te %'nne;

"'te. o+ 'd +roen don te s#de ooden door o te Cort

'nd entered te Cort ';;. >e d#d not no te n'mes o te

2ersons o 'd +roen don te ooden door. >e 's see#n"

te #n%#dent tro" te +roen door. %%sed ?s' N'r''ne

o 's #n te mo+ 'd tron %#;;# 2oder on te '%e o


31/41

31 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

de%e'sed. %%sed n't C''n 'd #n;#%ted #nr to

de%e'sed #t n#e. ter 2ersons #n te mo+ #t te de%e'sed

#t stone, +;'de o s2e'r 'nd n#*es. >e ne on; tree

2ersons rom te mo+ + te#r n'mes 'nd te ere '%%sed

-#;'s 'nde, ?s' N'r''ne 'nd P#n# S'm+'r'r. $e to

sdden 'tt'% on de%e'sed, e 's r#"tened 'nd ;et te Cort

'nd ent ome.

34 e 's

rter s2e%##%';; 'dm#tted t't e 'd not seen '%%sed no.1

n't #;e #n;#%t#n" #nr#es to de%e'sed #t n#e. So 'r 's

'%%sed ?s' N'r''ne 'nd P#n# S'm+'r'r #s %on%erned,

e 's 'dm#tted t't e 'd no o%%'s#on to *#s#t te ose o

?s' N'r''ne 'nd P#n# S'm+'r'r. >e 's rter

'dm#tted t't e 'd no '%D'#nt'n%e #t tem 2r#or to te

#n%#dent. Tereore, #t '22e'rs t't e %'me to no te n'mes

o tese to '%%sed 'ter te #n%#dent rom oter sor%es. >e

's not %';;ed or test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de. >e s's t't

'%%sed ?s' N'r''ne 'd tron %#;;# 2oder on de%e'sed.

>oe*er, [email protected] PC !'*#ndr' s's t't te ;'d o 'd tron%#;;# 2oder 's not 'mon"st te '%%sed 2ersons '%#n" tr#';.

Tereore, #t %'nnot +e +e;#e*ed t't '%%sed ?s' N'r''ne

'd tron te %#;;# 2oder on de%e'sed. s re"'rds '%%sed

-#;'s 'nde 'nd P#n S'm+'r'r, e 's not st'ted

'nere #n #s ent#re e*#den%e 's to 't 2'rt '%%sed -#;'s

'nde 'nd P#n S'm+'r' 2;'ed #n te %omm#ss#on o te

oen%es.


32/41

3 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

35


33/41


34/41

34 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

st'ted #n #s st'tement +eore te 2o;#%e t't e 's 't%#n"

te #n%#dent + st'nd#n" ne'r te "'te o Cort no.8. T#s

#tness 's %onronted to #s e'r;#er st'tement E.131, #%

e 'd den#ed, +t te e met

#t 'd*o%'te r. Pr''s J'#s'; 'nd to;d #m t't '%%sed

2ersons 'd 'ss';ted #s +roter.


35/41

35 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

39 So 'r 's te re%o*er o +;ood st'#ned %;otes 'nd

n#e 't te #nst'n%e o '%%sed no.1 n't #s %on%erned,

2'n% #tness, Sn#; @'nede (P@8) 's st'ted t't '%%sed

no. 1 n't m'de ' %oness#on'; st'tement +eore #m t't one

n#e st'#ned #t +;ood, s#rt 'nd e'n 2'nt ere e2t 't #s

ose 'nd e o;d so tose 'rt#%;es 'nd '%%ord#n";

memor'ndm 2'n%'n'm' E.98 's 2re2'red #n #s

2resen%e. >#s e*#den%e rter sos t't '%%sed no.1 ;ed #m

'nd te 2o;#%e to T's's#;' N'"'r 'nd 2rod%ed rom #s

ose one 2;'st#% +'" %ont'#n#n" s#rt, e'n 2'nt 'nd n#e

st'#ned #t +;ood 'nd tose 'rt#%;es ere se#Fed #n #s

2resen%e nder se#Fre 2'n%'n'm' E.99. e 's

rter st'ted t't e d#d not enter te t. Te m't 's

rest#n" '"'#nst te ';; o te t rom #% te '%%sed 'd

t'en ot te 2;'st#% +'". P'n% #tness s's t't te +'" 's

t'en ot rom #ns#de te t, ere's, te


36/41

36 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

se#Fre. @eter #t 's e2t #n ';'n' or e;seere. e

t't 's #t m', s#n%e te 'rt#%;es ere not se';ed nder te

nder te s#"n'tre o 2'n%'s, 2oss#+#;#t o t'm2er#n" #t

tose 'rt#%;es %'nnot +e r;ed ot. Tereore, e*en # te +;ood

o te "ro2 o te de%e'sed 's ond on tose 'rt#%;es, no

s#"n##%'n%e %'n +e 'tt'%ed to s% re%o*er to est'+;#s #ts

neEs #t te %omm#ss#on o te oen%e.

40 2'rt rom te 'ores'#d #tnesses, 2rose%t#on 's

eE'm#ned [email protected] P< rn Tem+'re to so t't on 8.08.004

#.e '+ot 5 d's +eore te #n%#dent te '%%sed 2ersons 'd

'ssem+;ed #n te 2rem#ses o te Cort to 'ss';t te de%e'sed.

%%ord#n" to t#s #tness, on 8.08.004 #t 's Snd'. n

%om#n" to no t't de%e'sed 'd'* 's +e#n" 2rod%ed

+eore te Cort 'nd some 2ersons rom 'str+'n'"'r ere

'ttend#n" te Cort to o22ose te +'#; '22;#%'t#on o

'd'*, e %'me to te Cort ';on" #t 2o;#%e st'. @en e

%'me to Cort, e s' 30 to 40 men 'nd 100 omen 2resent

ne'r $'"d# #;d#n". >e "'*e #norm't#on '+ot #t to Contro;

!oom 'nd reDested or send#n" 'dd#t#on'; 2o;#%e or%e to Cort

2rem#ses. T#;; ten 'd'* 's not +ro"t to Cort. >e'd 'sed tose 2ersons 's to te %'me to Cort,

ere2on te to;d #m t't te %'me to o22ose te +'#;

'22;#%'t#on o 'd'*. t '+ot 4.00 2.m. Cr#me r'n%

Po;#%e +ro"t 'd'* to Cort #n ' 2o;#%e ee2. Te mo+

rsed to'rds te 2o;#%e ee2, +t te 2o;#%e 'd 2re*ented

tem. .C.P. 'nd $.C.P. "'*e nderst'nd#n" to tose 2ersons 'nd

d#s2ersed tem rom te Cort 2rem#ses. %%ord#n" to t#s


37/41

37 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

#tness, '%%sed 2ersons ere te mem+ers o te s'#d mo+.

>oe*er, #n %rosseE'm#n't#on, e 's 'dm#tted t't e 's not

%';;ed or test #dent##%'t#on 2'r'de o 'n o te '%%sed. >e

's ';so not "#*en des%r#2t#on o tose 2ersons. >e 's 'ss#"ned

no re'son 's o e 'd #dent##ed '%%sed 2ersons 'ter '+ot

10 e'rs o te #n%#dent t't te ere te mem+ers o te mo+.


38/41

38 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

'ss'#;'nts ot o te mo+. Te e*#den%e '*'#;'+;e on re%ord

sos t't te mo+ %ons#st#n" more t'n 30 to 40 men 'nd

omen 'd 'tt'%ed de%e'sed. t on; 1 2ersons '*e

'rr'ed 's '%%sed. t o tem, tree ere de'd dr#n" te

2end'n% o te %'se. !est o te mem+ers o te mo+ ere not

'rrested. Tereore, 2oss#+#;#t o 'ss';t on de%e'sed + tose

2ersons 'nd ';se #m2;#%'t#on o '%%sed on; +e%'se te 're

res#dents o 'str+' N'"'r %'nnot +e r;ed ot. T#s #neren%e

#nds stren"t rom te '%t t't most o te '%%sed 2ersons

ere not #dent##ed + te 2rose%t#on #tnesses 'nd no o*ert

'%t 's +een 'ttr#+ted to tem.

43 S#%e #t to s' t't tere #s '+so;te; no %o"ent,

%on*#n%#n" 'nd re;#'+;e e*#den%e '*'#;'+;e on re%ord to o;d t't

te '%%sed 2ersons ere te mem+ers o 'n n;'; 'ssem+;

'nd #n 2rose%t#on o te %ommon o+e%t o s% 'ssem+;, te

%omm#tted r#ot#n", 'ss';ted 2o;#%e %onst'+;es #n te d#s%'r"e

o te#r dt 'nd %'sed de'd o de%e'sed 'd'*.

44 Te s+m#ss#ons m'de + te ;e'rned .P.P. %'nnot

+e '%%e2ted or te re'sons st'ted '+o*e. t te most tee*#den%e P@. >C $'mod'r sos t't some o te '%%sed

ere 2resent on te s2ot o #n%#dent, +t e 's 'ttr#+ted no

o*ert '%t to tem. Tere #s no '%%e2t'+;e e*#den%e to o;d t't

te 'd 'ss';ted de%e'sed or t'en 'n 2'rt #n te

%omm#ss#on o te oen%es.

45 Te e*#den%e +ro"t on re%ord n'#;#n"; sos


39/41

39 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

t't 'd'* 's ' notor#os %r#m#n';. Se*er'; %r#m#n';

%'ses #n%;d#n" mrder, 'ttem2t to %omm#t mrder, ro++er,

eEtort#on, %r#m#n'; #nt#m#d't#on et%. ere re"#stered '"'#nst

#m. >#s re'; +roter P@11 *r' 'd'* 's 'dm#tted t't

'+ot 5 oen%es ere re"#stered '"'#nst 'd'*. Te

ne2e o de%e'sed P@10 S'ntos 'd'* 's ';so 'dm#tted

t't ser#os oen%es ere re"#stered '"'#nst 'd'* #n

2o;#%e st't#on J'r#2't' 'nd P'n%2'o';# #n%;d#n" to mrder

%'ses. >e 's ';so 'dm#tted t't de%e'sed 'd'* 'd

%re'ted terror #n te ;o%';#t. >e 's rter 'dm#tted t't te

2eo2;e o te ;o%';#t ere ed 2 de to te n;'; '%t#*#t#es

o de%e'sed. Ne*erte;ess, no one 'd r#"t to t'e ;' #n

'nd 'nd #;; ' 2erson to" e #s notor#os %r#m#n';. rder

o de%e'sed #n te Cort %'nnot +e st##ed to" #t 's

%omm#tted ot o 2+;#% ot%r 'nd 'tred '"'#nst de%e'sed.

46 eore 2'rt#n" #t te d"ment %ert'#n oter '%ts

mst +e t'en note o. $e%e'sed 'd'* 's #n 2o;#%e

%stod. >e 's e2t #n 2o;#%e ;o% 2 #n P'%2'o;# 2o;#%e

st't#on. Te C.. re2ort sos t't 100 m;. ';%oo; 's ond #n

te *#s%er' o de%e'sed. T#s ndo+ted; sos t't 2o;#%eere so#n" '*or to de%e'sed.


40/41

40 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

%om2;'#n'nts '"'#nst #m.


41/41

41 S.T. Nos. 453/04, 389/05 & 151/06 Common (J)

P#n# = 'n#s' ' S'm+'r'r, Smt. S'*#t' J#tendr'@'n'r#, Smt. '"r't' >'r#%'nd d#ne, Smt. ee;'+'#!'"n't S'n"o;e, N#;es = !#tes S#t'r'm esr'm 'nd'no = 'n#s S'n'rr'o '+'de = S#nde, -#;'s Sr#r'm'nde 'nd

Nagpur Goon Akku Yadav Murder Case Judgement

Documents