SEMINAR REPORT ON MAGNETORHEOLOGICAL FLUIDS AND ITS APPLICATION IN INDUSTRIAL SHOCK ABSORBERS Submitted by Mr. NABEEL AHAMED In partial fulfilment for the award of the degree Of BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY IN MECHANICAL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING LBS COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING KASARAGOD 1
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
SEMINAR REPORT
ON
MAGNETORHEOLOGICAL FLUIDS AND ITS
APPLICATION IN INDUSTRIAL SHOCK
ABSORBERS
Submitted by
Mr. NABEEL AHAMED
In partial fulfilment for the award of the degree
Of
BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY
IN
MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
LBS COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING KASARAGOD
KERALA, INDIA - 671542
MARCH 2013
1
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the Seminar Report entitled “MAGNETORHEOLOGICAL
FLUIDS AND ITS APPLICATION IN INDUSTRIAL SHOCK ABSORBERS”
submitted by ‘NABEEL AHAMED’ to the University of Kannur in partial fulfilment of
the requirements for the award of the Degree of Bachelor of Technology in Mechanical
Engineering is a bonafide record of work carried out by him under my guidance and
supervision. The contents of this report, in full or in parts, have not been submitted to
any other Institute or University for the award of any Degree.
Place: Signed by
Date: Mr. Anil Kumar B.C.
Assistant Professor, MED
Signature of Head of the Department
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Sometimes words cannot express the feelings in its fullness. I express sincere gratitude to my
HOD Prof. MOHAMMED SHEKOOR and my tutor Mr. SREEJITH.M for their valuable
suggestions and instructions. I express my deep gratitude to my guide, Mr. ANIL
KUMAR.B.C for his valuable guidance. Also I remember my friends who helped me a lot. I
am thankful to my parents for giving help and support throughout the seminar. Above all I
am thankful to the almighty lord for making this seminar a success.
3
ABSTRACT
Magnetorheological fluids are suspensions of solids in liquid whose properties changes
drastically when exposed to magnetic field. They are micron sized, magnetisable particles
suspended in an appropriate carrier liquid such as mineral oil, synthetic oil, water or ethylene
glycol. When magnetic field is applied the stress required to make the fluid flow called the
“yield stress” of the fluid increases in a matter of milliseconds. Due to these special
characteristics it has got wide application in the field of mechanical engineering.
Magnetorheological fluids are now used in automobile clutches, machineries and some
researchers are going on. The activation of Magnetorheological fluid clutch’s built in
magnetic field causes a fast and dramatic change in the apparent viscosity of the
Magnetorheological fluid contained in the clutch. The fluid changes state from liquid to semi-
solid in about 6 milliseconds. The result is a clutch with an infinitely variable torque output.
In this presentation a brief introduction of the topic, physical and chemical properties of
Magnetorheological fluid, equations and working and various applications are listed out. Also
the application of Magnetorheological fluid in clutches are explained and highlighted in
detail. Advantages, limitations and future scopes are also discussed.
4
List of contents:
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 8
CHAPTER 2: FIELD RESPONSIVE FLUID 10
CHAPTER 3: A GOOD MR FLUID 13
3.1. Chemical composition 13
3.2. Physical properties 16
3.3. Magnetic properties 17
3.4. Rheological properties 18
CHAPTER 4: ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES 21
CHAPTER 5: WORKING 22
CHAPTER 6: APPLICATIONS OF MR FLUIDS
6.1. Industrial Shock Absorbers 24
6.2. Clutches 27
6.3. Automotive Industries 28
6.4.Optics 29
6.5. Human Prosthesis 29
6.6. Military and Defence 29
CONCLUSION 30
REFERENCE 31
5
LIST OF TABLES
Table 2.1.Comparison the Properties of MR Fluids, ER Fluids and Ferrofluids 11
Table.3.2.1.Properties of MR Fluid 17
6
LIST OF FIGURES
Fig.1.1. MR fluid particle distribution: a) no magnetic field b) with magnetic field. 11
Fig.3.1.1.Composition of MR fluids 15
Fig.3.3.1.Schematic representation of the affine deformation of a chain of spheres 17
Fig.3.4.1.Classification types of the behaviour of the fluid 19
Fig.5.1. MR Fluids in the absence of magnetic field 22
Fig.5.2. Alignment of MR particles under the action of magnetic field 22
Fig.6.1.1.Examples of typical hydraulic shockabsorbers(a) with a by passvalve and (b)
With an orifice between the piston and cylinder 24
Fig.6.1.2.Design of MR ShockAbsorber 25
Fig.6.1.3.Different braking characteristics 26
Fig.6.1.4.Diagram of shock absorber with MR fluid 27
Fig.6.1.5.Static characteristics of a built shock absorber with the gap height equal to
(a) 0.5mm and (b) 0.25mm. 27
Fig.6.3.1.schematic and photo of fluid damper 28
7
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
Science and technology have made amazing developments in the design of and machinery
using standard materials, which do not have particularly special properties (i.e. steel,
aluminium, gold). Imagine the range of possibilities, which exist for special materials that
have properties scientists can manipulate. Some such materials have the ability to change
shape or size simply by adding a little bit of heat, or to change from a liquid to a solid almost
instantly when near a magnet. Magnetorheological fluid falls under this category.
Amongst these smart fluids, MR fluids gain more attention since they can produce the
highest stress, which can be applied into many applications. An MR fluid is a suspension of
micron-sized magnetically soft particles in a carrier liquid, which can exhibit dramatic
changes in rheological properties. The change from a free-flowing liquid state to a solid-like
state is reversible and is dependent on the presence of a magnetic field. Iron powder is the
most popular material used as particle inclusion due to its high saturation magnetization.
Under the influence of a magnetic field, these iron particles are arranged to form very strong
chains of “fluxes” with the pole of one particle being attracted to the opposite pole of another
particle. Once aligned in this manner, the particles are restrained from moving away from
their respective flux lines and act as a barrier preventing the flow of the carrier fluid.
Magnetorheological fluids are magnetically polarisable particles suspended in viscous
fluids. They have the ability to change their rheological properties as shear modulus and
viscosity reversibly in milliseconds when subjected to magnetic fields. While the magnetic
particles are randomly distributed in the liquid when no magnetic field is applied, they form
chains in the presence of a magnetic field, and as a result rheological properties of the fluid
increase. Typically, the magnetisable particles are metal or metal oxide particles with size of
on the order of a few microns. The viscous fluid can be a non-magnetic liquid, usually oils.
Additionally, surfactants are used to allow for high particle volume fractions of the
Magnetorheological fluids that can yield higher variations in the rheological properties, and
increase the fluid’s stability against sedimentation. Depending on the type of magnetic
particles, viscous fluids and their volume rate, the rheological properties of
Magnetorheological fluids vary. The typical shear strength could vary from 2-3 kPa with no
magnetic field to 50-100 kPa with an applied magnetic field of 3000 Oersted. They can
operate in a temperature range of -40 0C to +150 0C. The viscosity of Magnetorheological
fluids can vary between 0.20 to 0.30 Pa-s at 25 0C.
MR fluids can be operated in three working modes depending on the type of deformation
8
employed such as shear mode, valve mode and squeeze mode. In the case of the shear mode,
the MR fluid is located between surfaces moving in relation to each other with the magnetic
field flowing perpendicularly to the direction of motion of these shear surfaces. In the valve
mode, the MR fluid is forced to flow directly between static plates, while in the squeeze
mode, the MR fluid is squeezed by a normal pressure in the direction of the magnetic field
under dynamic or static (compression or tension) loadings.
Fig.1.1: MR fluid particle distribution: a) no magnetic field, b) with magnetic field.
Advances in the application of MR materials are parallel to the development of new, more
sophisticated MR materials with better properties and stability. Many smart systems and
structures would benefit from the change in viscosity or other material properties of MR.
Nowadays, these applications include brakes, dampers, clutches and shock absorbers systems.
Applications of Magnetorheological fluids in torque transmission clutches are discussed in
this seminar. Quick time response and variable rheological properties of Magnetorheological
fluids in response to an applied magnetic field are utilized in generating the variable torque
transmission. Magnitude of the transmitted torque is adjusted by the level of the magnetic
field applied over the Magnetorheological fluids in the clutch mechanism.
9
CHAPTER 2: FIELD RESPONSIVE FLUIDS
Field responsive fluids are typical smart fluids, whose rheological properties depends on the
external applied field. Field responsive fluids are materials that undergo significant responses
leading to consequent rheological changes upon the influence of an external field. There are
three main classes of field responsive fluids. They are Magnetorheological fluids,
Electrorheological fluids and Ferrofluids. Magnetorheological fluids and Electrorheological
fluids works under the influence of applied magnetic and electric fields, respectively. The
fluids comprise a carrier liquid, such as a dielectric medium, including mineral oil or
hydrocarbon oil, and solid particles. Magnetorheological fluids require the use of solid
particles that are magnetisable, and ER fluids make use of solid particles responsive to an
electric field. In addition, Ferrofluids (magnetic liquid) also can be categorized as smart
materials. In the presence of a magnetic field, colloidal magnetic fluids retain their liquid
properties. They do not generally exhibit the ability to form particle chains or develop a yield
stress. However, Ferrofluids experience a body force on the entire fluid, and this force causes
the fluids to be attracted to regions of high magnetic field strength. Table 2 shows the
comparison of some of the properties between them. In a general manner,
Magnetorheological and Electrorheological fluids demonstrate specific advantages or
disadvantages which can be considered as complementary rather than competitive. They have
their own markets and applications in different fields. For instance, one of the advantages of
Magnetorheological fluids is higher stresses that they can withstand, while the major
advantage of Electrorheological fluids is a smaller size of the systems that they can be
developed with them.
The utilization of Magnetorheological or Electrorheological fluids can work to rapidly
respond in active interface between sensors or controls and mechanical outputs. The fluids
can be employed in vibration isolation systems as an example of precision surface
shaping/polishing machines, mechanical clutches, brakes damping devices, building seismic
isolators, torque/tension controllers, gripping/latching devices and fluid flow controllers.
MAGNETORHEOLOGICAL FLUID
The discovery of Magnetorheological fluids is credited to Jacob Rabinow at the US National
Bureau of Standard in 1948. MR fluids can be described as magnetic field responsive fluids
which are part of a group of relatives known as smart or actively controllable fluids.
10
Magnetorheological (MR) fluids are materials that respond to an applied field with a dramatic
change in their rheological behaviour. The essential characteristic of these fluids is their
ability to reversibly change from a free-flowing, linear, viscous liquid to a semi-solid with
controllable yield strength in milliseconds when exposed to a magnetic field.
Magnetorheological fluids consist of magnetically permeable micron-sized particles
dispersed throughout the carrier medium either a polar or non-polar fluid, which then
influence the viscosity of the Magnetorheological fluids.
Items MR fluids ER fluids ferrofluids
Particulate
Material
Ferromagnetic
Ferrimagnetic
Polymers,
Zeolite,etc
Magnetite,
Heamatite,etc
Particle Size 0.1-10µm 0.1-10 µm <10nm
Carrier Fluid Non-Polar And Polar
Liquids,Etc
Gel And Other
Polymers
Paramagnetic Salt
Solution
Density(G/Cc) 3-5 1-2 1-2
Off Viscosity
(Pa/S @25C
0.1-0.3 0.1-0.3 0.002-0.5
Required Field ~3koe ~3kv/Mm ~1koe
Device Excitation Electromagnets/
Permanent Magnets
High Voltage Permanent Magnet
Yield
Strength(Field)
100kpa 10kpa (B)/ (0)2
Table 2.1: Comparison the properties of MR fluids, ER fluids and Ferrofluids
Magnetorheological fluids are controllable fluids that exhibit dramatic reversible change in
rheological properties like elasticity, plasticity or viscosity either in solid-like state or free-
flowing liquid state depending on the presence or absence of a magnetic field. In the presence
of an applied magnetic field, the suspended particles appear to align or cluster and the fluid
drastically thickens or gels. The flow resistance i.e. apparent viscosity of the fluid is
intensified by the particle chain. When the magnetic field is removed, the particles are
returned to their original condition, which lowers the viscosity of the fluid. The fluid structure
is dependent on many factors such as volume fraction, magnetic field strength and carrier
fluid. The fluid structure is also responsible for a rapid formation and is reversible either in
solid-like state or free-flowing liquid state. The changes of solid-liquid state or the
consistency or yield strength of the Magnetorheological fluids can be precisely and
11
proportionally controlled by altering the strength of the applied magnetic field. These
characteristics provide simple, quiet and rapid response interfaces between electronic control
and mechanical systems.
Most of the researchers used carbonyl iron as particles scatter in oil medium, for instance
silicone oil, hydrocarbon oil, mineral oil and hydraulic oil. The material also can be produced
at a relatively lower cost as compared to Magnetorheological fluids that include hydrophobic-
oil type fluids as a carrier fluid. Iron powder is the most popular material used as particle due
to its high saturation magnetization about 2.1 T. Those particles are arranged in a proper
order from one pole to another pole of a magnet to form very strong chains or fluxes.
Initially, in the absence of the magnetic field, the iron particles in the space between two
walls move unrestrained. In the presence of the magnetic field, the iron particles are
organized along the direction of the applied magnetic field. These particles are constructed
into a uniform polarity and connected to the walls. Once aligned in this manner, the iron
particles are refrained from moving out of their respective flux lines and act as a barrier to an
external force. The yield stress, in this case, symbolizes the maximum of the stress-strain
relationship, and the chains will break when the stress has reached its maximum which allows
the fluid to flow even if the magnetic field is still applied.
Magnetorheological and Electrorheological fluids use feedback information such as rapid
response interfaces between electric controls and mechanical systems to vigorously change
the material behaviour. By changing the material behaviour, the performance of the devices is
intensified to a certain level that unattainable using conventional materials and devices.
Magnetorheological fluids can be considered as unique smart materials because they produce
milliseconds response time. The fluids may be used in both small and large displacement
devices in order to generate very large forces and torques without reliance on the velocity of
the working systems. The performance of the fluids depends on the fluids’ structure in
connection with many factors such as volume fraction, carrier fluid and particle size.
Research studies done by industries such as Lord Corporation and Liquids Research Limited
and all over the world have contributed to the Magnetorheological technologies in order to be
used in a wide variety of applications.
12
CHAPTER 3: A GOOD MR FLUID
The most common response to the question of what makes a good MR fluid is likely to be
"high yield strength" or "non-settling" for the purpose of effective working condition.
However, those particular features are perhaps not the most critical when it comes to ultimate
success of a magnetorheological fluids. As anyone who has made MR fluids knows, it is not
hard to make a strong MR fluid. Over fifty years ago both Rabinow and Winslow described
basic MR fluid formulations that were every bit as strong as fluids today. A typical MR fluid
used by rabinow consisted of 9 parts by weight of carbonyl iron to one part of silicone oil,
petroleum oil or kerosene.1 to this suspension he would optionally add grease or other
thixotropic additive to improve settling stability. The strength of rabinow’s MR fluid can be
estimated from the result of a simple demonstration that he performed. Rabinow was able to
suspend the weight of a young woman from a simple direct shear MR fluid device. He
described the device as having a total shear area of 8 square inches and the weight of the
woman as 117 pounds. For this demonstration to be successful it was thus necessary for the
MR fluid to have yield strength of at least 100 kpa.
MR fluids made by Winslow were likely to have been equally as strong. A typical fluid
described by Winslow consisted of 10 parts by weight of carbonyl iron suspended in mineral
oil.2 to this suspension Winslow would add ferrous naphthenate or ferrous oleateas a
dispersant and a metal soap such as lithium stearate or sodium stearate as thixotropic
additive. The formulations described by Rabinow and Winslow are relatively easy to make.
The yield strength of the resulting MR fluids is entirely adequate for most applications.
Additionally, the stability of these suspensions is remarkably good. It is certainly adequate
for most common types of MR fluid application. As early as 1950 rabinow pointed out that
complete suspension stability, i.e. no supernatant clear layer formation, was not necessary for
most mr fluid devices. Mr fluid dampers and rotary brakes are in general highly efficient
mixing devices.
3.1. CHEMICAL COMPOSITION
magnetorheological fluids consist of non-colloidal suspensions, magnetically soft
ferromagnetic, ferrimagnetic or paramagnetic elements and compounds in a non-magnetic
medium. However, magnetorheological fluids consist of suitable magnetizable particles like
iron, iron alloys, iron oxides, iron nitride, iron carbide, carbonyl iron, nickel and cobalt. A
13
preferred magnetic responsive particle that is commonly used to prepare magnetorheological
fluids is carbonyl iron. The possible maximum yield stress induced by magnetorheological
effect is mainly determined by the lowest coercivity and the highest magnitude of saturation
magnetization of the dispersed particles. Therefore, soft magnetic material with high purity
such as carbonyl iron powder appears to be the main magnetic phase for most of the practical
magnetorheological fluids composition. Other than carbonyl iron, fe-co alloys and fe-ni
alloys can also be used as magnetorheological materials, whereby, fe contributes to the high
saturation magnetization. However some of the ferrimagnetic materials such as mn-zn ferrite,
ni-zn ferrite and ceramic ferrites have low saturation magnetizations and are therefore
suitable to be applied in low yield stress applications.
Iron powder magnet can be prepared by hydrogen reduction of ferric oxide or by chemical
vapour deposition from iron pentacarbonyl,fe(co)5. Once the particles are magnetized, the
oriented domains can grow with the magnetization persisted and simultaneously increased
permeability. Saturation magnetization of the iron can be obtained when all of the domains
are properly oriented. The domain walls can easily move, ideally making the magnetization a
single-valued function of the magnetizing field, so that there is no hysteresis loss when the
field reverses repeatedly. The particle size should be meticulously selected, so that it can
exhibit multi-domain characteristics when subjected to an external magnetic field.
Magnetorheological particles are typically in the range of 0.1 to 10 μm, which are about 1000
times bigger than those particles in the ferrofluids. In the magnetorheological fluids, magnetic
particles within a certain size distribution can give a maximum volume fraction without
causing unacceptable increasing in zero-field viscosity. For instance, fluid composition that
consists of 50 % volume of carbonyl iron powder was used in the application of