Page 1
MuslimsWhoRiskedTheirLivestoSaveJewsDuringtheHolocaust:
OverviewandSourcesofInformation
CraigT.PalmerDepartmentofAnthropology
UniversityofMissouri
AmberL.PalmerDepartmentofVisual&MediaAnthropology
FreieUniversitätBerlin
MountainseastofTirana,Albania
Page 2
HowwecametostudythissubjectThePuzzleofAltruism
MoralElevationBinahYitzritFoundation
YadVashemTheRighteousAmongtheNations
YearOne(2013-2014)
HolocaustMuseumsintheUnitedStates,Canada,Israel,Germany,Poland,andHungary
*YearTwo(2014-2015)RighteousMuslimsand/orArabs
Page 4
MajorStrasser:“ItispossibletheFrenchauthoritieswillfindareasontoputhimintheconcentrationcamphere.”
Casablanca(1942)
Page 5
RobertSatloff“AmongtheRighteous:
LostStoriesoftheHolocaust’sLongReachintoArabLands”
Page 6
ReadmoreaboutthetruestoriesinAmongtheRighteous.Plus,watchvideoclipsandextendedinterviewsaboutsomeofthepeopleprofiled.KhaledAbdulWahabAcharismatic,cosmopolitanTunisiannotonlyhidalocalJewishfamilyathisfarm,butalsoprotectedthewomenfromharm.SiAliSakkatAfteralongcareerinpublicservice,anArabnoblemanretiredtoafarm,where,oneday,hewelcomedandharboredsomeunexpectedguests--Jewishmenwhohadescapedfromalaborcampduringabattle.NissimZviliWhenthefatherofthisTunisianJewishfamilywasconscriptedforforcedlaborbytheNazis,theothersweretakentoafarmforprotectionbyanArabfriend.MoriceTondowskiAyoungPolishmanfledhiscountrytoescapethewar,butafterjoiningtheFrenchmilitary,woundupinadesertlaborcamp.SilvanShalomAfterthemalemembersofthisinfluentialJewishfamilyescapedtoavoidarrestbytheNazis,thewomenwereaidedbyacompassionateandquick-thinkingArabneighbor.HamzaAbdulJalilTheownerofaneighborhoodbathhouseinTunisiahidayoungJewishmanwhowastryingtoevadeaNazidragnetforforcedlaborers.JosephScemlaBetrayedbytheirArab'friend,'thisTunisianJewishmanandhistwosonssufferedtheultimatefate--deportationtoGermanyandexecutionataNaziprison.
Page 7
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,Jordan,SaudiArabia,Iraq,Iran,Syria? asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco KingMohammedV,TheJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt Mohammed“Mod”Helmy,EgyptiandoctorrecognizedasaRighteous AmongtheNations,butwhosefamilyrefusedtoaccepttheaward.
Paris
GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddour Benghabrit. *Children’sbookWestBank ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 8
Holocaustmemorial,JewishCemeteryBorgel,Tunis.
Page 9
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,Jordan,SaudiArabia,Iraq,Iran,Syria asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco? KingMohammedV,MoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt Mohammed“Mod”Helmy,EgyptiandoctorrecognizedasaRighteous AmongtheNations,butwhosefamilyrefusedtoaccepttheaward.
Paris
GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddour Benghabrit. *Children’sbookWestBank ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 10
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,Jordan,SaudiArabia,Iraq,Iran,Syria asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco KingMohammedV,MoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt? Mohammed“Mod”Helmy
Paris GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddour Benghabrit. *Children’sbookWestBank ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 11
Mohamed“Mod”Helmy
Page 12
Mohamed“Mod”Helmy“IfanyothercountryofferedtohonorHelmy,
wewouldhavebeenhappywithit,”MervatHassan,thewifeofHelmy’sgreat-nephew,toldtheAP.
Page 13
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,Jordan,SaudiArabia,Iraq,Iran,Syria asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco KingMohammedV,MoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt Mohammed“Mod”Helmy,EgyptiandoctorrecognizedasaRighteous AmongtheNations,butwhosefamilyrefusedtoaccepttheaward.
Paris?
GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddourBenghabrit. WestBank ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 15
"Tothememoryofthedirector,thestaffandthestudentsofthisschool,arrestedin1943and1944bytheVichypoliceandtheGestapo,deportedandexterminatedatAuschwitzbecausetheywereborn
Jewish"
Page 16
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,Jordan,SaudiArabia,Iraq,Iran,Syria asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco KingMohammedV,MoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt Mohammed“Mod”Helmy,EgyptiandoctorrecognizedasaRighteous AmongtheNations,butwhosefamilyrefusedtoaccepttheaward.
Paris
GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddour Benghabrit. Israel ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 18
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers
Algeria,Tunisia,Libya,MiddleEast asmallstonemonumentinaJewishcemeteryinTunisia Morocco KingMohammedV,MoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablanca Egypt Mohammed“Mod”Helmy,EgyptiandoctorrecognizedasaRighteous AmongtheNations,butwhosefamilyrefusedtoaccepttheaward.
Paris
GrandeMosquéedeParisanditsrectorSiKaddour Benghabrit. Israel ThePalestinianMuseumontheHolocaustcreatedby KhaledKasabMahameedinNazareth. NeveShalom
Page 20
NeveShalom
1949ArmisticeAgreement
Line
Page 21
IsraeliJewsandArabsPlant'GardenoftheRighteous'
toHonorForgottenHolocaustHeroes
Page 22
MonumentsorExhibitsonArabRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 23
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 31
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 32
AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Page 34
“InhonouroftheAlbanianmenandwomenwhoduringtheNaziGermanoccupation,1943-1944,guidedbytheprincipleofbesaandatgreatrisktothemselves,shelteredandsavedthelivesofallJewishpeoplelivinginAlbania.”
“Thegatesofyoursmallcountryremainedopen,Albania.Yourauthoritiesclosedbotheyes,whennecessary,togivepoorpersecutedpeopleanotherchancetosurvivethemosthorribleofallwars.Albania,wesurvivedthesiegebecauseofyourhumanity.”EscapeThroughtheBalkans
byIreneGrunbaum
Page 35
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers
Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 41
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers
Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 42
InoccupiedEurope,TurkeywastheonlycountrythatstoodupwhileJewsweretakentocampstobekilled.Ateveryturnitbravelyandforcefullytriedtoprotectitscitizens.
AllwhowereinvolvedinthesavingofJews,everywhere,andthereweremanyinEuropeaswell,promotedthemselvesassuch.WhereastheTurkishdiplomatswhodidthisdon’tseemtohavemadeanyefforttogetrecognition.ThismaybepartofTurkishcharacteraswell.
Page 43
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina
Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 44
TheQuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews
Istanbul
Page 47
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina Sarajevo Amongthe"righteous"aretheHardagafamilyfromBosniawho providedshelterfortheJewishKaviliofamilywhenGermanforces occupiedBosniain1943. Halfacenturylater,theHardagaswerethemselvessavedbythe KaviliosduringtheBosnianCivilWar. TheJewishMuseumorMuseumoftheJewsofBosniaand Herzegovina Gariwo
Page 50
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina Sarajevo MuseumoftheJewsofBosniaandHerzegovina Gariwo
Page 51
MuseumoftheJewsofBosniaandHerzegovina
Page 54
FiftyyearsaftertheHolocaust,whenin1994SarajevowasundertheattackofSerbforces,
Zejnebaandherfamilywereingreatdistress....
ItwasnowtheStateofIsraelthatpaidbackthedebtandhelpedtheHardagasintheirtimeofdistress.
ZejnebaHardaga
Page 56
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina Sarajevo MuseumoftheJewsofBosniaandHerzegovina Gariwo
Page 60
GardensoftheRighteousSarajevo
SvetlanaBroz
Page 61
GardensoftheRighteousSarajevo
SvetlanaBrozWhenarttransmitsmemorytheportraitsoftheRighteousbyFrancineMayran
Page 62
GardensoftheRighteousSarajevo
SvetlanaBrozWhenarttransmitsmemorytheportraitsoftheRighteousbyFrancineMayran
AFaceInscribedwithLifeAFaceInscribedwithLife
Page 63
GardensoftheRighteousSarajevo
SvetlanaBrozWhenarttransmitsmemorytheportraitsoftheRighteousbyFrancineMayran
CertificateSchoolforCivilCourage
AFaceInscribedwithLife
Page 64
GardensoftheRighteousSarajevo
SvetlanaBrozWhenarttransmitsmemorytheportraitsoftheRighteousbyFrancineMayran
TheatricalPerformanceaboutCivilCourage
AFaceInscribedwithLife
Page 65
DuskoKondorGARIWO
DirectoroftheSeminarsonCivilCourageFebruary22nd2007
Page 66
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Albania NormanGershman “Besa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringWorldWarII” AlbanianNationalHistoricalMuseuminTirana
Turkey SelahattinÜlkümen,Rhodes,Greece TheTurkishPassport QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJews BosniaandHerzegovina Sarajevo MuseumoftheJewsofBosniaandHerzegovina Gariwo Macedonia Skopje HolocaustMemorialCenterfortheJewsofMacedonia
Page 67
HolocaustMemorialCenterfortheJewsofMacedonia,Skopje
Page 68
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimandArabRescuers Berlin,Germany Berlin Stolperstein “StumbleStones” ModHelmy SilentHeroesMemorialSite
London,England FaithMatters“RighteousMuslims” Amsterdam
Page 72
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimandArabRescuers Berlin,Germany Stolperstein “StumbleStones” ModHelmy GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundation SilentHeroesMemorialSite
London,England FaithMatters“RighteousMuslims” Amsterdam
Page 74
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimandArabRescuers Berlin,Germany Stolperstein “StumbleStones” ModHelmy GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundation SilentHeroesMemorialSite
London,England FaithMatters“RighteousMuslims” Amsterdam
Page 75
GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundation
Page 82
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimandArabRescuers Germany Berlin Stolperstein “StumbleStones” ModHelmy GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundation SilentHeroesMemorialSite
London,England FaithMatters Amsterdam
Page 84
Faith-MattersTheRoleofRighteousMuslims
KhaledAbdulWahab
Page 85
MonumentsorExhibitsonMuslimRescuers Germany Berlin Stolperstein “StumbleStones” ModHelmy GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundation SilentHeroesMemorialSite
London,England FaithMatters“RighteousMuslims” Amsterdam
Page 86
JewsandMuslimsSavingEachOtherTentrueinstanceswhenJewsandMuslims
–attimesriskingeverything–savedeachother'slives.
http://virtualjerusalem.com/news.php?Itemid=18921
HopefullyNot
TheEnd
Page 87
IreneGrunbaumEscapeThroughtheBalkanshttps://www.amazon.com/Escape-through-Balkans-Autobiography-Grunbaum/dp/0803270828RobertSatloffAmongtheRighteous(book)https://www.amazon.com/Among-Righteous-Robert-Satloff/dp/1586485105RobertSatloffAmongtheRighteous(pbsvideo)http://www.pbs.org/newshour/spc/among-the-righteous/index.htmlhttps://www.ushmm.org/information/exhibitions/online-features/special-focus/among-the-righteousHolocaustmemorial,JewishCemeteryBorgel,Tunis.https://jewishphotolibrary.smugmug.com/AFRICA/AFRICANorth/TUNISIA/TUNIS/TNTunisJewishCemeteryBorgel/n-TBcC8F/i-WtJTFcKMoroccanJewishMuseuminCasablancahttp://casajewishmuseum.com/ModHelmyhttp://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/righteous/stories/helmy.asphttp://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2470135/Dr-Mohamed-Helmy-Family-Arab-honoured-saving-Jew-Nazis-rejects-award.htmlhttp://www.gedenktafeln-in-berlin.de/nc/gedenktafeln/gedenktafel-anzeige/tid/mod-helmy/
Page 88
KarenGrayRuelle&DeborahDurlandDeSaixTheGrandMosqueofParis:AStoryofHowMuslimsRescuedJewsDuringtheHolocausthttps://www.amazon.com/Grand-Mosque-Paris-Muslims-Holocaust/dp/0823423042ArabInstituteforHolocaustResearch,Nazarethhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khaled_Kasab_MahameedMepeace.orghttp://mepeace.org/NeveShalom“GardenoftheRighteous”http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-1.730893NormanGershmanBesa:MuslimsWhoSavedJewsDuringtheHolocausthttps://www.amazon.com/Besa-Muslims-Who-Saved-Jews/dp/0815609345Besa:ThePromisehttp://besathepromise.com/thefilm.htmlPalmer,C.T.&A.L.Palmer2016“WhyTraditionalEthicalCodesPrescribingSelf-SacrificeAreaPuzzletoEvolutionaryTheory:TheExampleofBesa”JournaloftheAssociationfortheStudyofEthicalBehavior/EvolutionaryBiologyinLiterature,12(1):40-50.http://www.christopherxjjensen.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/BesaASEBL2016.pdf
Page 89
JewishMuseumofRhodeshttp://www.rhodesjewishmuseum.org/QuincentennialFoundationMuseumofTurkishJewshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_Museum_of_TurkeyTurkishPassporthttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkish_Passport_(film)MuseumoftheJewsofBosniaandHerzegovinahttp://muzejsarajeva.ba/en/depadance/the-jewish-museumhttp://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/righteous/stories/hardaga.aspGariwohttp://www.gariwo.org/en/HolocaustMemorialCenterfortheJewsofMacedonia,Skopjehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust_Memorial_Center_for_the_Jews_of_MacedoniaStolpersteinhttp://www.stolpersteine.eu/en/GermanResistanceMemorialCentreFoundationhttp://www.gdw-berlin.de/en/home/
Page 90
OttoWeidt(film)http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/the-blind-hero-new-film-tells-of-unsung-schindler-otto-weidt-who-saved-jews-from-nazi-death-camps-9042395.htmlSilentHeroesMemorialSitehttp://www.museumsportal-berlin.de/en/museums/gedenkstatte-stille-helden/Faith-Mattershttp://faith-matters.org/VirtualJerusalemhttp://virtualjerusalem.com/news.php?Itemid=18921YadVashem“MuslimRescuers”http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/righteous/stories/muslim_rescuers.aspYadVashem“BesaExhibit”http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/exhibitions/besa/index.aspProjectAladdinhttp://www.projetaladin.org/en/en-10-2.htmlSeedsofPeacehttp://www.seedsofpeace.org/
Page 91
YadVashem“MuslimRescuers”http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/righteous/stories/muslim_rescuers.aspYadVashem“BesaExhibit”http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/exhibitions/besa/index.asp
Page 92
NamesandNumbersofRighteousAmongtheNations-perCountry&EthnicOrigin,asofJanuary1,2016ThenumbersofRighteousarenotnecessarilyanindicationoftheactualnumberofrescuersineachcountry,butreflectthecasesthatweremadeavailabletoYadVashem.Formoreinformation>>>Albania 75 Italy 671Armenia 24 Japan 1Austria 107 Latvia 135Belarus 618 Lithuania 889Belgium 1,707 Luxembourg1Bosnia 42 Macedonia 10Brazil 2 Moldova 79Bulgaria 20 Montenegro1Chile 1 Netherlands 5,516China 2 Norway 62Croatia 115 Peru 1Cuba 1 Poland 6,620CzechRepublic115 Portugal 3Denmark* 22 Romania 60Ecuador 1 Russia 197Egypt 1 Serbia 135ElSalvador 1 Slovakia 558Estonia 3 Slovenia 7France 3,925 Spain 7Georgia 1 Sweden 10Germany 587 Switzerland 47GreatBritain(Incl.Scotland)21 Turkey 1Greece 328 Ukraine 2,544Hungary 837 USA 5Indonesia 2 Vietnam 1Ireland 1 Total:26,120 http://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/righteous/statistics.asp