Top Banner

of 9

Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

Jun 01, 2018

Download

Documents

Fauzan Rasip
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    1/20

     Islamic Research Institute, International Islamic University, Islamabad is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserveand extend access to Islamic Studies.

    http://www.jstor.org

    MUSLIMS IN SPAIN AFTER THE FALL OF GRANADA: SUPPRESSION, RESISTANCE, ECLIPSE, ANDRE-EMERGENCEAuthor(s): M. ALI KETTANISource: Islamic Studies, Vol. 36, No. 4 (Winter 1997), pp. 613-631Published by: Islamic Research Institute, International Islamic University, IslamabadStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/23076032Accessed: 10-03-2015 16:02 UTC

    Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/  info/about/policies/terms.jsp

    JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=iriiiuhttp://www.jstor.org/stable/23076032http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/23076032http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=iriiiuhttp://www.jstor.org/

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    2/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    MUSLIMS IN SPAIN AFTER THE FALL OF

    GRANADA:

    SUPPRESSION,

    RESISTANCE, ECLIPSE,

    AND RE

    EMERGENCE

    M. ALI

    KETTANI

    INTRODUCTION

    The

    genocide

    to which the Andalusian Muslims were

    subjected

    in the 16th and

    17th centuries

    is

    a sordid

    tragedy

    of colossal

    magnitude

    which has left its scars

    on the

    memory

    of the

    Muslims,

    especially

    those of the Western

    Mediterranean,

    both the descendants of the Andalusians and others. It is sad to note that the

    two

    main

    perpetrators

    of this

    genocide

    against

    the

    Andalusians,

    the so-called Catholic

    rulers,

    were

    glorified by

    the

    Vatican. It would have been more conducive

    to

    the

    moral

    prestige

    of the Vatican to have excommunicated them.

    We shall

    attempt

    in the

    following pages

    to

    briefly

    relate the

    tragic

    developments

    which not

    only

    put

    an end to the last

    vestiges

    of Muslim

    political

    power

    in the

    Iberian

    Peninsula,

    but also

    describe

    the

    extraordinary

    persecution

    which made it

    virtually

    impossible

    for the Andalusian Muslims

    to live

    openly

    as

    Muslims. The

    present paper

    argues

    that while the

    public

    observance of

    Islam

    came

    to an

    end,

    the Muslim

    populace

    of Andalusians tried its best to remain

    faithful to Islam. Generation after

    generation

    the Andalusians

    kept

    Islam alive

    in their hearts. The fact that

    their

    ancestors

    were Muslims was never erased

    from their

    memory. During

    the twentieth

    century

    a number of

    developments

    led

    to the

    rise of Andalusian

    nationalism,

    which has

    paved

    the

    way

    for the

    phenomenon

    of Islamic revival in Islam.

    THE FALL OF GRANADA

    After a series

    of

    agonising

    wars,

    Granada was taken over

    by

    the united Castellan

    and

    Aragonese

    forces on

    January

    2, 1492,

    twenty

    three

    days

    before the

    date

    agreed upon

    between them and its last Nasrid

    ruler,

    Abu 'Abd Allah.

    The

    capitulations

    comprised

    47 articles in which the victorious Catholic monarch

    guaranteed

    the

    protection

    of the Islamic

    faith,

    its

    institutions such as

    mosques

    and

    madrasahs,,

    imams and

    qâdïs,

    and Islamic laws.

    They

    also

    guaranteed

    freedom of

    religion

    and

    protection

    of the Arabic

    language.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    3/20

    614

    m. ali

    kettani/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the

    Fall of Granada

    Granada,

    however,

    was not the first Muslim

    city

    to fall to the Christian

    forces.

    Indeed,

    since the

    11th and 12th centuries and the fall of other Islamic

    cities

    such as Toledo

    (1085 ce)

    and

    Saragossa

    (1118

    ce),

    large

    numbers

    of

    Muslims

    had fallen under the Christian control.

    Although

    they

    were

    subjected

    to much persecution, they were allowed to keep their Islamic faith. The Muslims

    who were thus

    subjugated

    and called

    Mudejars,

    were

    organized

    into

    jamâ'ats

    with their

    mosques,

    their

    madrasahs and their

    fuqahä'.

    They

    even

    developed

    a

    literature

    in the

    Spanish language

    written in Arabic

    script,

    called

    Aljamiado.

    In

    the

    beginning

    of the 16th

    century,

    a

    quarter

    of the

    population

    of

    Arayon

    (its

    capital

    is

    Saragossa)

    and one third of the

    population

    of the Pais Valenciano

    (its

    capital

    is

    Valencia)

    were Muslims.

    After the

    collapse

    of their

    resistance,

    the Muslims of the

    Kingdom

    of

    Granada feared that

    they

    would

    be

    treated

    like the

    Mudejars.

    Later events

    showed that the

    Catholic rulers did not

    respect

    their

    commitments,

    and that the

    Catholic

    Church exceeded all limits of

    propriety

    in their effort to

    destroy

    all

    traces

    of Islam from

    Spain, sparing

    no

    atrocities

    whatsoever.

    OPPRESSION

    OF THE ANDALUSIAN MUSLIMS

    AND THEIR FORCED

    CHRISTIANIZATION

    (1492-1568)

    After

    the fall of

    Granada,

    the Catholic

    rulers

    appointed

    Count de Tendía as the

    Governor

    of the

    conquered Kingdom

    of

    Granada,

    and

    Herando de Talevera as

    its

    Bishop.

    As for the

    general population,

    several members of Muslim

    aristocracy

    decided to

    emigrate

    to Muslim countries because

    of their lack of

    faith

    in the

    promises

    of the Catholic rulers.

    Some of

    them,

    including

    a few

    princes,

    even succumbed to

    professing

    Catholicism,

    but the masses

    remained

    loyal to Islam and decided to resist all external pressures in order to protect their

    faith.2

    The first act of

    betrayal

    was

    witnessed even before the end of the 15th

    century

    when the Great

    Mosque

    of

    Granada was taken over

    by

    the Catholic

    Church

    and converted into a cathedral.

    Then,

    the

    priests

    organised parties

    of

    zealots

    to

    pressurize

    the

    Muslims

    to

    convert to

    Christianity.3

    In

    1499,

    the Catholic rulers

    invited

    Cardenal

    de Cisneros to Granada

    in order to increase

    the

    pressure upon

    Muslims so that

    they might accept

    Christianity.

    The Cardinal seized

    most of the

    mosques

    and

    changed

    them into

    churches. He concentrated

    his efforts on the Andalusian

    elite such as the

    'ulama',

    pressurizing

    them

    to

    convert

    to

    Christianity.

    This led to a revolt under

    the leadership of Ibrahim ibn Umayyah in the popular quarters of Albaicin in

    Granada which

    spread

    to the

    Alpujaras

    Mountains in 1500. The rebellion was

    put

    down

    by

    a

    relentless use of force. The

    mujâhidïn

    were

    virtually

    exterminated

    and their

    families sold into

    slavery.

    The

    same

    happened

    in 1501 in Almeria and

    Ronda.4

    In

    1500,

    the

    Spanish

    State and the Catholic Church launched forcible

    baptization

    of the Muslims

    on a mass

    scale.

    In

    1501,

    all the

    remaining mosques

    were converted

    into churches. On October

    12,

    1501 a

    royal

    decree was issued

    ordering

    all books written in Arabic to be

    put

    to

    the fire. Piles of books were

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    4/20

    Islamic Studies

    36:4(1997)

    615

    thus

    brought

    together

    at

    many places

    in the different cities

    and towns of al

    Andalus and

    reduced to ashes. This was one

    of the several crimes

    perpetrated

    against

    learning

    and

    culture

    that can

    hardly

    be

    forgotten.

    The next

    step

    was to

    prohibit

    the use of Arabic

    language,

    a

    prohibition

    whose

    violation invited the

    penalty of death. The Muslims of al-Andalus solicited help from abroad but

    these

    pleas

    had little effect on

    Sultan

    Abu

    'Abd

    Allah of

    Morocco,

    or the

    Ottoman Sultan

    Bayezid,

    or Sultan al-Ashraf of

    Egypt.

    In due time the Catholic

    Church

    established the

    Inquisitions

    in order to ensure

    that there remained no

    trace of Islam

    left in the Iberian Peninsula.

    The

    Inquisition

    tribunals

    spared

    no

    means,

    howsoever

    cruel,

    to force

    people

    to

    profess

    the Christian faith.

    They

    passed

    harshest

    sentences

    against

    people,

    basing

    them on

    the

    most

    flimsy

    grounds.

    Anyone

    whom

    they

    could

    seize,

    rarely

    escaped

    death

    and his

    properties

    were confiscated

    by

    the

    corrupt priest-judges.

    Many

    victims

    of

    these

    tribunals

    were

    burnt alive

    along

    with their

    families in

    groups

    of

    "auto da

    fes"

    in

    great

    feasts which were

    gleefully

    witnessed

    by

    the

    King,

    the nobles and the common

    people.

    Many

    of the victims could avert

    being

    burnt

    alive,

    but

    many

    of them

    had the

    good

    fortune of

    dying

    natural deaths before the

    outrageous

    end of

    burning

    them

    alive could befall them.5

    As the Granadan Muslims could

    no

    longer

    put up open

    resistance and

    their

    cries for

    help

    to the

    Muslim lands went

    unheeded,

    they

    followed

    a

    different

    stratagem:

    they gave

    their tormentors the

    impression

    that

    they

    had

    accepted

    Christianity.

    In strict

    secrecy,

    however,

    they

    did their best to

    maintain their

    Islamic

    faith and

    practice. They

    were called Moriscos or

    New Christians and

    were

    subjected

    to merciless

    persecution.

    In

    1508,

    a

    royal

    decree forbade the Islamic

    dress. In

    1510,

    new taxes

    were imposed on the Moriscos. In 1511, another royal decree ordered the

    burning

    of Muslim

    books and forbade

    slaughtering

    animals

    according

    to Islamic

    rules,

    etc. Similar decrees

    continued to be issued

    until the death of the Catholic

    King

    Ferdinand

    in

    1516.

    Ferdinand's

    son,

    Carlos

    V,

    initially

    treated the

    Granadan Muslims

    with a

    degree

    of

    leniency.

    But in

    1523,

    he issued

    a

    royal

    decree

    ordering

    the

    baptism

    of all the

    remaining

    Muslims.

    All

    those

    who refused

    were to be enslaved.

    The Moriscos

    complained

    to the

    King

    about the

    unfairness

    of the

    decree,

    pointing

    out that

    they

    had never

    truly

    embraced

    Christianity,

    but

    they

    had

    been Muslims

    upon

    whom

    Christianity

    was

    imposed.

    Carlos

    V came

    to Granada to

    investigate

    the truth of the

    statement

    only

    to conclude

    that the

    Moriscos

    were true Christians and

    that

    they

    should

    obey

    the laws of the Catholic

    Church. The Moriscos collected

    80,000

    gold

    ducats and

    paid

    it to the

    King

    in

    exchange

    for

    exercising

    leniency

    in the

    implementation

    of his decrees. The

    King

    promised

    to

    grant

    the Moriscos a

    reprieve

    of 40

    years during

    which

    period they

    were to

    become assimilated to

    Christianity.

    A

    special

    annual

    cess was

    imposed

    on the Moriscos

    as a fee for

    keeping

    these

    harsh laws

    in

    abeyance.6

    Carlos

    V

    died

    in

    1555.

    He was succeeded

    by

    his

    son,

    Philip

    II,

    a

    fanatic

    who was a weak

    monarch and

    was, therefore,

    completely

    controlled

    by

    the Catholic

    priests.

    In

    1566,

    at the end of the

    40

    years period

    decreed

    by

    his

    father,

    Philip

    II decided to

    implement

    the

    de-Islamizing

    laws

    intending

    to force

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    5/20

    616

    m ali

    kettani/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the Fall of Granada

    people away

    from Islam with full force. As a result he

    punished

    the violators of

    those laws with

    imprisonment, expulsion,

    confiscation of

    property

    and

    burning

    people

    to death. This decree was read

    by

    the

    udges

    of the

    Inquisition

    tribunals

    in

    processions

    across towns

    and cities.

    As no effort

    of the

    Moriscos

    helped

    them

    escape the implementation of this decree, they started to think in terms of a full

    fledged uprising

    to free themselves from this

    nightmare.7

    THE GREAT REVOLT OF

    GRANADA

    (1568-1570)

    Some Muslim

    groups

    fled to the mountains of Granada and Valencia after

    valiantly breaching

    the lines of communication of

    the

    enemy.

    As the Governor

    of

    Granada

    formed a

    police

    force to

    implement

    the new

    laws,

    including

    the law

    that Morisco

    children would be seized and be raised under the care of the

    priests

    in the churches as Christians.

    In such

    circumstances,

    a

    group

    of Muslim

    leaders

    met in Albaicin towards the end of 1567.

    They

    made

    plans

    to rise in revolt.

    After

    making

    due

    preparation

    both within the

    country

    and

    outside,

    they

    did rise

    in revolt. These revolutionaries sent

    delegations

    to

    Algiers

    and

    Morocco,

    seeking

    from their rulers arms and

    money

    before

    starting

    the revolt. All

    they

    received in return were

    generous

    promises.

    Within

    al-Andalus,

    the

    organizers

    sent secret

    delegations

    to Muslims

    virtually

    all across the

    country.

    When

    they

    returned,

    they

    estimated the numbers of those

    ready

    to

    join

    the revolt at

    45,000.

    They

    found

    only

    the Muslims of the

    provinces

    of

    Granada,

    Malaga

    and Almeria

    who

    effectively supported

    the revolt.

    But

    the

    Muslims of

    Murcia,

    Valencia

    and

    Aragon

    did not

    support

    it for

    they strongly

    feared that the revolt would not

    succeed.

    Moreover,

    they

    entertained

    the

    hope

    that

    eventualy

    the Ottomans would

    come to their

    help

    and

    somehow rescue them from their

    present

    state.8

    Subsequently, the organizers of the Revolt met for the second time in

    Albaicin,

    studied the

    reports

    of

    the

    delegate

    that had visited different

    parts

    of al

    Andalus as well as Morocco and

    Algiers,

    and decided

    to start the revolt in

    April

    1568. This

    date had to be

    postponed

    as the Christian authorities

    got

    wind of the

    revolt and

    started

    arresting

    the Muslim leaders.

    In

    the third

    meeting

    that was

    held

    in

    September

    1568 in

    Albaicin,

    26 leaders of

    the revolt

    got together,

    elected Fernando

    de Valor Y Cordoba as the Sultan of al-Andalus. He

    immediately

    took

    up

    his

    Muslim

    name,

    Muhammad ibn

    Umayyah,

    and decided

    a new

    date,

    January

    1, 1569,

    for the start of the revolt. The revolt however

    actually

    started on December

    23,

    1568. The reason was that a

    group

    of

    Spanish

    soldiers started

    committing

    excesses

    against

    the

    people

    of Cadiar in

    Alpujaras.

    Enraged by these acts, a group of Muslim mujâhidïn reacted violently

    whereupon

    Muhammad

    ibn

    Umayyah

    left Granada and reached the

    Alpujaras

    Mountains

    where

    people

    renewed their oath of

    fealty

    to him on December

    29,

    1568.

    Ibn

    Umayyah appointed

    the commanders of the

    army

    and settled in

    Laujar,

    making

    it the

    temporary capital

    of al-Andalus.

    He

    also

    appointed

    governors

    to the

    provinces.

    Thereafter he launched the

    struggle

    with a two-fold

    aim:

    (1)

    to

    expel

    the Christian

    army

    and

    priests

    and to convert the churches

    back into

    mosques,

    to restore the Islamic

    identity

    of the Andalusians

    by

    reviving

    their Muslim

    names and

    dress

    and

    establishing

    Muslim

    public prayers;

    and

    (2)

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    6/20

    Islamic

    Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    617

    to seek

    support

    from the Ottoman

    Empire

    and the rulers of

    Morocco

    by sending

    delegations

    abroad.

    In

    the

    beginning

    the reaction of the

    Spanish

    State was slow and

    disorganized.

    Then,

    two armies were formed to attack the rebels from Murcia

    in the East, and from Granada in the West. Subsequently, Spain solicited

    support

    from the Christian states of

    Europe

    which it received. The

    Spanish army

    that left Granada started to attack the civilian

    population

    with

    great ferocity.

    The

    most atrocious attack was launched on

    January

    8,

    1569 when 2400 Muslim

    children,

    women and old men were massacred in one

    night

    in

    Jubiles. The

    Spanish army

    that left Murcia followed the 'scorch

    the earth

    policy'

    and

    destroyed

    the

    families of the

    mujähidin

    whom

    they

    found on their

    way,

    killed

    almost all

    of

    them,

    violated

    the

    honour of the

    women and sold the few survivors

    into

    slavery.

    In the course of time the

    mujähidin

    were left no other

    option

    but

    to follow

    the tactics of what is

    presently

    called the

    guerilla

    warfare

    against

    the

    Spanish

    army.

    The

    hordes of the

    Reconquesta

    did not

    spare

    even

    those who had no

    hand in the revolt. In

    Granada,

    on

    March

    17, 1569,

    the authorities

    gathered

    150

    leaders of the Muslims.

    They

    were all killed without

    mercy

    in an

    orgy

    of death

    that

    went on all

    night along. Only

    the father and brother of Muhammad ibn

    Umayyah,

    Antonio and

    Francisco,

    were

    spared.

    All

    properties

    of the Muslims

    were confiscated

    regardless

    of whether

    they

    supported

    the revolt or not.

    This brazen

    cruelty

    further inflamed the revolt:

    more men

    joined

    the

    mujähidin, thereby reinforcing

    the insurrection.

    However,

    the

    much

    awaited

    support

    from the rulers of the

    Ottoman

    Empire

    and those of North Africa never

    arrived. The Ottomans first

    pleaded

    that

    they

    were too

    occupied

    with the

    problem of Cyprus, whereas the North Africans seemed to use the Andalusians

    simply

    as a

    pawn

    in

    their

    game

    of international

    politics.

    In due

    course

    the

    King

    of

    Spain

    formed a new and

    more

    powerful army

    which was led

    by

    his

    illegitimate

    brother,

    Juan de Austria.

    But

    the

    mujähidin

    were able

    to

    expel

    the Christian soldiers from most

    of the

    mountains,

    and

    extended their

    operations

    to Almeria

    in the East and Ronda

    in

    the

    West,

    leaving

    the

    Christians

    only

    with the

    large

    cities.

    As the Christians feared a revolt

    in

    the

    city

    of Granada in

    May

    1569,

    they expelled

    its Muslim

    population

    and

    dispersed

    them in Castilla.

    Then the

    army

    of

    Juan de Austria moved from

    the

    coast

    to

    reconquer

    the

    Alpujaras

    Mountains. But on this

    occasion the

    mujühidín put up

    a

    fierce resistance. This

    led the Christians to resort to a ruse.

    They spread

    the rumours that Sultan

    Muhammad ibn

    Umayyah,

    was

    ready

    to

    yield

    to the

    enemy

    to rescue his father

    and brother. Thus

    they

    succeeded

    in

    dividing

    the ranks of the

    mujähidin,

    which

    led to the

    assassination of Sultan Muhammad ibn

    Umayyah

    in October 1569

    in

    Laujar. Thereupon

    the

    mujähidin

    chose Muhammad

    ibn Abbou as the new

    Sultan. The latter

    reorganized

    the

    army

    of the

    mujähidin

    and

    appointed

    new

    commanders.

    He was able to

    liberate

    Orgiva,

    the

    capital

    of

    the

    Alpujaras

    Mountains,

    and extended the

    areas of the liberated territories.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    7/20

    618

    m. au

    kettanl/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the

    Fall of Granada

    The

    army

    of Juan the Austrian then doubled its

    efforts,

    the

    number of

    its soldiers

    increased,

    and it

    began

    to

    reconquer

    the

    territory

    held

    by

    the

    mujähidln.

    One of the

    most

    grievous

    events was the

    conquest

    of Galera

    which

    was

    strongly

    defended

    by

    Muslims,

    inlcuding

    Muslim women.

    After a resistance

    of three months, the Christian army entered that city in February 1570, and

    under the orders of Juan the Austrian its

    population

    was

    exterminated and salt

    was

    sprinkled

    over the whole land.

    Galera remains in ruins even

    today.

    The resistance

    put up

    by

    the

    Muslims

    against

    the invaders

    gradually

    weakened. Their cries for

    help

    to the Ottomans and the

    rulers of North Africa

    remained

    largely

    unheeded. The last letter of Sultan Ibn

    Abbou to the Mufti of

    Istanbul dated

    February

    11, 1570,

    in

    which he entreated for his intercession with

    the Ottoman Sultan for

    help,

    concluded with these words: "We are

    facing

    two

    strong

    armies of the

    enemy.

    If we are defeated in the

    coming

    battle,

    Allah will

    put

    difficult

    questions

    to the Ottoman Sultan on the

    Day

    of

    Judgement;

    on the

    Day

    when neither

    power

    nor

    pretext

    will be

    of

    any

    avail to him from His

    judgement".9

    Under these circumstances it was natural

    for

    the

    Andalusians to suffer

    defeat. But

    they

    continued to battle as small

    groups

    of

    mujähidln, preferring

    to

    die

    fighting

    rather than surrender. In March

    1571,

    Sultan Ibn Abbou was

    killed

    by

    an

    enemy agent.

    His

    body

    was

    brought

    to

    Granada,

    carried across the

    city

    in

    procession

    and

    decapitated

    in

    the main

    square.

    His dead

    body

    was

    put

    on

    display

    at the main

    gate

    of the

    city.

    The Muslim

    resistance, however,

    continued

    even after his death until

    1573

    when

    it was

    completely overpowered.10

    THE DISPERSION OF THE

    MUSLIMS AFTER THE

    REVOLT

    (1570-1608)

    After the

    expulsion

    of the

    people

    of the

    city

    of

    Granada as a result of

    enforcing

    the

    royal

    decree

    of March

    1570,

    a new

    tragedy

    befell

    the

    people

    of al-Andalus.

    The Christian authorities decided to

    punish

    the

    entire

    population

    of the former

    Kingdom

    of Granada

    by expelling

    them from their

    homes,

    confiscating

    all their

    properties

    and

    dispersing

    them all across

    Spain.

    The

    purpose

    was

    obviously

    to

    totally uproot

    them,

    reduce them to utter

    poverty,

    and

    scatter them

    among

    the

    Christians so that

    they

    lose their Islamic

    identify."

    After the

    expulsion

    of about

    7,000

    Moriscos from the

    city

    of

    Granada

    to other

    parts

    of

    Spain

    in

    compliance

    with the

    royal

    decree of March 1570

    ordering

    the

    expulsion

    of

    Moriscos from the

    remaining parts

    of

    Granada,

    these

    Moriscos too were dispersed all over Spain. Thus about 50,000 Moriscos were

    brought together

    and were

    forced

    by

    the

    army

    to walk in

    groups

    to

    Toledo,

    Cordoba,

    Sevilla and La

    Mancha,

    and

    from there to other

    places.

    More than

    17,000

    died of exhaustion on the

    way.

    The Christian

    army

    persisted

    in

    its effort

    to

    disperse

    the Moriscos to different towns and

    villages

    of the

    country

    till

    the

    end of

    1570.

    Subsequently

    a new decree

    was issued

    in

    November 1571

    ordering

    the

    dispersal

    of more Granadan

    Moriscos.

    Thus,

    by

    the end

    of

    1571,

    more than

    80,000

    Andalusian Muslims had been driven out of their

    homes,

    scattered all

    over

    Spain

    and reduced

    to a terrible state of

    poverty, misery,

    and sickness.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    8/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1 997)

    619

    The

    Spanish government

    then

    brought

    50,000

    Christians

    into the

    Kingdom

    of Granada and

    gave

    over to them the homes

    of the Muslims who

    had

    been banished.

    However,

    this colonization effort failed

    since

    in

    the course of

    time

    many

    Granadans

    returned home and

    many

    Christians left.

    Many

    Muslims

    also continued to put up resistance in the countryside and the mountains. The

    Government, however,

    kept issuing

    orders to

    expel

    Muslims from Granada until

    1585.

    The

    presence

    of the

    Granadan Muslims in Castilla

    revived Islamic

    feelings

    among

    the

    Mudejar

    Muslims. The result

    was that the Church and the

    State knew

    no more what to do.

    They

    were

    scared of the Muslims who

    kept

    coming together;

    scared

    of their contacts with the

    Ottomans;

    scared of their

    proselytism,

    etc. In a state of

    panic they

    issued one decree after

    another

    forbidding

    the Moriscos to live

    near the sea and to contact the Muslims of

    Aragon

    and

    Valencia,

    etc. The

    Inquisitions

    also increased the number of their

    victims and

    subjected

    them

    to even

    greater

    torment. But all

    this failed to

    undermine the

    religions

    faith

    of the

    Moriscos,

    or to make them

    abandon the

    hope

    that one

    day they

    would

    be freed.12

    The

    hopes

    of the

    Moriscos were focussed on the Ottomans who

    remained in close

    contact with them. Ottoman

    ships

    often landed on the shores

    of

    al-Andalus,

    carrying away

    hundreds

    of families to

    Muslim

    lands. The

    Moriscos of

    Aragon

    also maintained contact with

    the Protestants of

    France,

    hoping

    that

    they

    would

    join

    hands with them

    against

    their Catholic

    oppressors.

    By

    the end of the 16th

    century,

    both the

    Spanish

    State and the Catholic

    Church had lost the

    hope

    that

    they

    would be able to convert these

    Muslims into

    true

    Christians,

    or that

    they

    would be able to

    eradicate

    their

    allegiance

    to Islam.

    They began, therefore, to consider drastic solutions, solutions of a savage

    nature,

    to the Muslim

    problem. They

    decided

    upon

    the

    following:

    (1)

    to muster

    all Moriscos to

    special quarters

    where

    they

    would be exterminated

    gradually;

    (2)

    to

    exterminate them either

    instantly

    or in the due

    course of

    time

    by separating

    men from

    women,

    or

    by castrating

    all men

    so that

    they

    would not be able to

    procreate;

    or

    (3)

    to

    banish them from

    Spain.

    The third solution

    gained increasing support.

    But the Catholic Church

    was worried about the

    loss

    of

    'Christian'

    souls,

    as

    they

    continued to consider the

    Moriscos to

    be Christians

    despite

    all evidence to the

    contrary.

    The

    State,

    on the

    other

    hand,

    was worried

    by

    the

    prospect

    of

    banishing

    the

    Muslims for this

    might

    provide

    demographic strength

    to the Mediterranean Muslim states.13

    THE

    GREAT EXPULSION

    (1608-1613)

    In November

    1608,

    the

    Spanish government

    decided to banish

    all

    the

    Moriscos

    of

    Spain.

    The decision was

    kept

    secret as

    they

    did not want

    the

    Moriscos to

    leave the

    country

    with their

    possessions.

    At the same time

    due

    preparations

    were

    made to banish first of all the Muslims of

    the

    Pais Valenciano. In November

    1609,

    the

    Spanish King

    signed

    the order to banish all

    Mariscos, men,

    women

    and

    children,

    of Valencia

    to North Africa within three

    days

    after which

    all

    those

    who had failed to leave would be

    imprisoned

    and those who resisted

    expulsion

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    9/20

    620

    m. ali

    kettani/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the Fall of Granada

    would

    be killed. The Moriscos were

    required

    to

    stay

    in their

    homes,

    waiting

    for

    the officers of the State. Those who were thus banished were not

    permitted

    to

    take with them more than what

    they

    could

    personally carry.

    All those who

    destroyed

    or

    hid

    their

    belongings

    were

    to

    be

    punished by

    death. The

    properties

    left behind by these persons were handed over to the Christians. Children under

    the

    age

    of six were handed over to Christian families to be raised as

    Christians.14

    Many

    Muslims chose to

    put up

    armed resistance

    against

    the

    high

    handedness.

    They kept

    on

    fighting

    in the mountains until

    they

    were

    exterminated. Others found themselves

    overpowered

    and saw no

    other

    option

    but

    to

    willy nilly accept

    cruel orders.

    They

    were herded in different

    ports

    such as

    Alicante,

    Denia,

    Valencia. On their

    way, they

    were attacked

    by

    Christian mobs

    who took

    away

    from them the

    meagre belongings

    that

    they

    were

    carrying.

    Thus,

    between

    September

    1609

    and

    January

    1610,

    about

    130,000

    Valenciano Muslims

    were

    forcibly transported

    out of

    Spain

    in

    ships

    and

    dumped

    on the coasts of

    North Africa.

    Many

    ship

    owners

    preferred

    to steal

    the

    belongings

    of

    the

    passengers

    on

    board

    and

    dump

    those

    hapless

    creatures in the sea. In

    May

    1611,

    a decree announced a

    prize

    of 60

    gold

    pounds

    to whoever

    brought

    a

    Muslim

    alive with the

    right

    of

    keeping

    him

    as a

    slave,

    and 30

    gold pounds

    to whoever

    brought

    the dead

    body

    of a Muslim.

    After

    the Valencia

    Region,

    orders

    were issued in

    April

    1610 to banish

    the Moriscos of

    Aragon.

    More than

    61,000

    of them were

    then

    forcibly

    transported

    under

    harrowing

    condition.

    They

    were followed

    by

    about

    4,000

    Moriscos

    of

    Catalogna.

    In December

    1609,

    King

    Philip

    111 ordered the

    expulsion

    of the Muslims of

    Andalusia,

    Extramadura and Murcia.

    Thus,

    about

    52,000

    Moriscos were

    expelled

    from these

    provinces.

    In

    December 1609

    something

    similar

    happened

    in Castilla. The

    Spanish

    King

    ordered

    the

    expulsion

    of the

    Muslims of

    Castilla,

    whereafter about

    50,000

    Muslims were

    expelled

    from that

    region.

    Thus,

    it is

    estimated that

    between

    1609 and

    1614,

    about

    330,000

    Muslims were banished from

    Spain

    under the most

    tragic

    and inhuman

    circumstances,

    carrying

    with them no

    more

    than

    their

    bodies. In March

    1611,

    King Philip

    III

    walked

    at

    the

    head

    of a

    long procession

    of

    Leaders,

    giving

    thanks to God for

    purging

    the

    country

    of its Muslim

    populace.

    Of the

    expelled

    Andalusian

    Muslims,

    about

    60,000

    settled in

    Morocco,

    160,000

    in the Ottoman

    Empire including

    about

    65,000

    in

    Algeria

    and

    55,000

    in Tunisia, and many in Izmir, Istanbul and Bosnia. About 10,000 Andalusian

    Muslims settled

    in

    the Christian states of

    Europe

    and America. About

    70,000

    were

    killed,

    having

    been drowned in the sea and

    30,000

    managed

    to return to

    Spain.15

    Spanish history

    books

    claim

    that this

    great expulsion purged

    Spain

    of

    Muslims and that the

    places

    which the Muslims left were resettled

    by

    Christian

    immigrants.

    However,

    historical evidence shows that

    the

    percentage

    of

    those of

    Muslim

    origin

    in

    Spain

    amounted in the

    beginning

    of the 17th

    century

    to about

    35

    per

    cent of the

    population,

    or about

    2,000,000

    people.

    Of

    these,

    only

    few

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    10/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    621

    Muslims from

    Andalusia,

    and a

    great

    number of those from

    Aragon

    and

    Valencia

    were

    expelled,

    i.e. less than

    20%

    of the Muslim

    population

    of

    Spain.

    The rest were considered

    good

    Christians,

    and hence allowed to

    stay

    on.

    They

    were

    left

    leaderless,

    as

    slaves,

    children,

    women and

    men,

    with even less

    knowledge of Islam. For all practical purposes, Islam was considered dead in

    Spain

    after a

    presence

    of about 900

    years.

    But was it?16

    ISLAM

    IN SPAIN DURING THE 17TH

    CENTURY

    The

    persecution

    of

    Muslims

    in

    Spain

    did not

    stop

    with

    the

    Great

    Expulsion

    of

    1609. In

    1614,

    the

    Spanish King

    issued an order to the

    governors

    of all the

    provinces

    asking

    them to

    stop

    seeking

    hidden Moriscos since the Great

    Expulsion

    was over. The

    only

    exceptions

    to this were those

    who had

    returned.

    They

    were

    required

    to be banished and to be

    put

    to

    death if

    they

    were found

    to

    have returned

    against

    Royal

    decrees

    ordering

    the

    governors

    to

    pursue

    the

    Moriscos

    who were found

    guility

    of

    returning

    to their homes.

    King Philip

    III died in 1621. His son

    King Philip

    IV received a

    report

    in

    1621

    from the

    Inspector

    of

    Royal

    Properties

    in

    Catalogna, informing

    him

    that

    a

    large

    number of Moriscos

    in

    Aragon, Catalogna

    and Valencia had not left the

    country,

    and that

    many

    of those who had been banished

    had in fact returned

    home,

    that

    they

    lived in

    peace

    and

    were

    protected

    by powerful persons.

    The

    Inspector requested

    the

    King

    to take

    action

    against

    those

    Moriscos,

    but the

    King

    did not

    care to

    respond.

    In

    1623,

    the

    Spanish

    Cortes declared that much

    injustice

    had been

    committed

    against

    the Moriscos who had returned

    and

    requested

    the

    King

    to

    put

    an end to

    the

    chapter.

    In

    1624,

    the Cortes

    requested

    the

    King

    to issue a

    royal

    decree on the question. The King felt that there was no need for a decree, but

    advised the tribunals to

    stop accepting

    new

    denunciations

    of Moriscos.

    Complaints,

    however,

    continued

    to be made about the Moriscos in Castilla and

    Andalusia.

    In

    1625,

    the

    City

    of Seville

    published

    a

    report

    stating

    that a

    large

    number of

    Muslims,

    both slaves and

    freemen,

    had

    kidnapped

    Christian children

    and

    raised

    them as Muslims. But

    the

    King finally

    decided to issue

    a

    decree

    in

    1626

    in which he ordered that

    "no harm

    should

    be done to Moriscos who

    remained

    in the

    country

    as

    long

    as

    they

    lived

    away

    from the coast". But the

    Spanish

    State

    did not

    forget

    the

    Moriscos,

    as in 1634

    an official

    report

    from

    Murcia claimed

    that it was full of Moriscos.

    The

    King

    ordered that

    they

    should

    be watched and checked whether they were good Christians or not.

    As for the

    Inquisitions, they

    continued to

    persecute

    Muslims in the 17th

    century.

    In

    1616,

    this

    infamous tribunal in Denia and

    Valencia

    inquired

    as to

    what should

    be done with the enslaved Andalusians

    who were

    planning

    to flee

    to Muslim

    lands.

    In

    1620

    and

    1625,

    the same tribunals

    condemned Moriscos

    accused of

    witchcraft. In

    1625,

    the

    tribunal of Seville executed a Morisco

    in

    front

    of a crowd of

    Christians,

    and in 1625 the tribunal

    condemned an enslaved

    Morisco to

    100

    lashes,

    to

    hard labour on the boats

    for four

    years

    and then

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    11/20

    622

    m. ali

    kettani/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the Fall

    of Granada

    imprisonment

    for the rest of his life. All this was

    merely

    because of

    writing

    Muslim

    slogans

    on the

    gate

    of a church.

    In

    1633,

    the

    Inquisition

    tribunal of Cuenca

    persecuted

    for two

    years

    a

    Muslim and his

    family

    who had returned from exile on

    flimsy grounds.

    In

    1667,

    the

    Inquisition

    tribunal of Almadén condemned a Morisco to

    lashing

    for

    oking

    about Christian

    rituals. In

    1680,

    a man from Cadiz was

    burnt alive

    in

    Madrid

    in front of a

    huge

    crowd,

    as he was accused of

    having

    converted from

    Christianity

    to Islam.

    In

    1689,

    the

    Inquisition

    tribunal of Cordoba

    expelled

    from

    the

    city

    a

    group

    of slaves who were accused of

    being

    Muslims. In

    fact,

    the

    Inquisition

    tribunals of

    Spain persecuted

    at

    least

    177 Christians who

    converted

    to Islam

    and fled to Muslim

    lands

    after

    they

    were somehow

    caught

    in

    wars with

    Spain.17

    Another

    proof

    of Muslim

    presence

    in

    Spain

    in the 17th

    century

    is the

    continuous

    hope

    of

    many

    communities for freedom from the Christian

    yoke.

    In

    1624, the State Council presented a report on two families from Granada, the

    Cuellars

    and the.Madrids who

    controlled the silk

    industry. They

    were accused

    of

    being secretly

    Muslims and of

    having

    contacts with Muslims

    of

    North

    Africa.

    In

    1641,

    a

    conspiracy

    for a revolt in

    Andalusia,

    led

    by

    an

    Andalusian

    prince,

    Tähir

    al-Horr,

    was discovered. Tähir

    al-Horr

    died

    in

    battle near

    Estepona.

    But

    many

    descendants of the Muslims have

    organized

    themselves

    since 1644 in bands that attacked the Government

    caravans,

    seized

    spoils

    and

    distributed them to the

    poor.

    The

    plan

    of a

    popular

    revolt

    was discovered

    in

    1650,

    and five

    leaders

    were

    executed,

    four

    of

    them

    after

    being subjected

    to cruel

    torture. These

    popular

    revolts of the descendants of the Muslims

    persisted

    throughout

    the

    century,

    the most notable of

    which

    being

    the revolts of

    especially

    Cordoba and Seville.18

    Many

    visitors to Andalusia in the 17th

    century

    met Muslims who had

    kept

    their Islam a secret. The most known

    among

    them was Muhammad

    Ibn

    'Abd al-Wähid

    al-Ghassänl,

    an

    Ambassador

    of Sultan Isma'Tl

    of

    Morocco,

    who

    made an official

    visit

    to Andalusia in

    1690.

    Many

    Andalusians,

    including

    officials,

    informed him that

    they

    were

    secret Muslims.19

    ISLAM

    IN

    SPAIN

    IN

    THE I8TH CENTURY

    The fact that Muslims survived in

    Spain

    in

    the 18th

    century

    is evident from the

    decisions made

    by

    the State Council on

    September

    20,

    1712

    ordering

    the

    "expulsion

    of Muslims to North Africa". The

    order, however,

    remained

    unimplemented.

    It was the last decree

    against

    the

    Moriscos,

    more than

    one

    century

    after the

    Great

    Expulsion

    of 1609.

    The

    Inquisition

    tribunals,

    however,

    continued their task to

    eradicate

    every

    trace of Muslims. In

    1724,

    these tribunals

    expelled

    a

    large

    number of

    Andalusians accused of

    being

    Muslims. In

    1726

    they prosecuted

    in

    Granada

    alone no less than

    1,800

    persons

    (360 families)

    who were accused

    of

    professing

    Islam

    secretly.

    All

    this

    proves

    the existence of

    Islam

    on a

    large

    scale in

    Spain

    in that

    period.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    12/20

    Islamic

    Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    623

    Similar

    prosecutions

    were held

    against people

    accused of Islam in

    Granada

    in 1727. In

    May

    1728,

    46

    persons

    and

    in

    October

    1728,

    28 other

    persons

    professing

    Islam were condemned and their

    properties

    confiscated. The

    fanatic element of the

    city

    renewed their

    request

    to the

    King

    to

    purify

    Granada

    of its Muslim population. As late as 1769 a secret mosque was discovered in

    Cartagena

    in the

    province

    of

    Murcia,

    indicating

    that

    Muslims were

    secretly

    organized

    their.

    In fact several travellers to

    Spain

    in the 18th

    century

    reported

    about the

    presence

    of Islam

    in

    that

    land,

    albeit

    in

    secrecy.

    In 1766 and 1768 the Sultan

    of

    Morocco sent

    his ambassador to

    Spain,

    Ahmad Ibn al-MahdT

    al-Ghazäl,

    himself

    an

    Andalusian who

    originally

    hailed from

    Malaga,

    met

    many persons among

    the

    people

    and officials

    in

    the

    provinces

    that he visited were

    Muslims,

    albeit

    secretly.

    He also visited several cities such as

    Seville, Jaen, Granada,

    Murcia

    and Alicante. He

    observed about the

    people

    of

    Loja

    (a

    province

    of

    Granada):

    "They

    are

    similar to the

    people

    of Granada

    in their attraction of Muslim

    origin,

    men,

    women

    and

    children,

    some make some secret

    signs

    of

    belonging

    to

    Islam,

    others

    say

    it

    openly".20

    In the

    years

    1775-1776,

    the British traveller

    Henry

    Swinburne visited

    Andalusia

    and informed that he

    had met in Granada

    many

    secret Muslim

    families.

    In

    1779,

    the Sultan

    of Morocco sent another

    ambassador to

    Spain,

    Mohammed ibn

    'Uthmän al-MaknasI. He

    reported

    that he had met

    a

    great

    number

    of Muslims in

    Loja

    and Granada.21

    Finally,

    in

    1786-1787,

    another British

    traveller,

    Joseph

    Towsend,

    reported

    that a

    judge

    of

    the

    Inquisition

    tribunal of Granada

    told him:

    "Today,

    all

    people

    believe

    that Both Muslims

    and

    Jews

    are numerous

    in

    Spain.

    Most

    Muslims live in the mountains, and most Jews are in large cities.

    Both

    keep

    their faith

    completely

    secret". This was confirmed

    by

    another British

    traveller,

    George

    Barrow,

    in

    1787.22

    Furthermore,

    a

    large

    number of

    Muslims,

    joined

    the bands of

    gypsies

    in

    order

    to avoid

    anything

    similar to the Great

    Expulsion

    of

    1609. This

    explains

    the

    great

    Muslim influence on

    the culture of the

    Spanish

    gypsies

    of

    today.23

    THE

    BIRTH OF

    ANDALUSIAN NATIONALISM

    IN

    THE 19TH

    CENTURY

    In the 19th

    century,

    several travellers

    who visited

    Andalusia,

    such as a Britisher

    who

    visited the town

    of Alhamara

    in

    1809,

    the writer

    Miniano who visited

    Alpujaras in 1828, and the English traveller Ford who also visited Alpujaras in

    1848.

    They

    all

    reported

    the

    presence

    of a

    diluted

    Islam

    in Andalusia.

    The

    feeling

    of

    being

    differentfrom the

    Christians,

    of

    being oppressed

    by

    an

    alien

    identity

    which

    imposed

    itself on them

    by

    force

    grew

    in the whole

    country, especially

    its southern

    part

    after the invasion of

    Spain by

    the armies of

    Napoleon

    in 1808.

    For the first

    time the

    enemy

    of

    the Andalusians had

    been

    defeated

    by foreign

    forces.

    The Andalusians

    rose

    against

    the

    French

    invaders,

    not

    as

    Spaniards,

    but as

    Andalusians,

    for

    the

    first

    time since

    the fall of Granada.

    The French

    marines surrendered

    on

    July

    14,

    1808 to

    the

    Andalusians,

    and the

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    13/20

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    14/20

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    15/20

    626

    μ·

    ali

    kettani/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the Fall of Granada

    Blas

    Infante and Jose Andres

    Pasques presented

    a

    request

    to the

    League

    of Nations to

    recognize

    the Andalusian Nation.

    By

    1921,

    Bias Infante had started

    linking up

    with Andalusians all over

    the

    world,

    especially

    in the

    Maghreb

    and in

    South

    America. On

    January

    13,

    1923,

    Spain

    entered a

    long period

    of

    dictatorship.

    The Government closed the

    Andalusian Centres and accused the Andalusian nationalists of

    working against

    the

    Spanish

    State.

    Bias Infante maintained a low

    profile

    and moved to the

    Province

    of Huelva.

    On

    September

    15, 1923,

    and

    during

    the

    war

    of liberation

    of

    al-Arriir

    Muhammed

    ibn 'Abd al-Karlm al-KhattabT in the Rif

    mountains,

    Bias Infante

    went to Morocco. He visited the tomb of

    Al-Mu'tamid ibn 'Abbäd of Seville in

    Aghmat

    where

    he

    declared his

    Islam. He then tried to contact the Islamic and

    Arab movements

    around

    the world.

    In

    1930,

    the

    dictatorship

    was

    removed,

    and Infante moved back to the

    province of Seville. He renewed his activism for Andalusian nationalism, but

    now

    with a

    strong

    Islamic

    emphasis,

    as Infante demanded the restoration of

    Andalusian

    land,

    history,

    culture and

    identity

    and

    the

    removal of the

    stranglehold

    of the Catholic Church from the lives of the Andalusians.

    By

    1936, however,

    the Civil War broke out

    in

    Spain,

    on

    August

    2,

    1936,

    the militia

    of

    General

    Franco

    kidnapped

    Bias Infante and on

    Monday

    August

    10, 1936,

    shot

    him to

    death

    in a street of Seville. He died

    shouting

    the

    slogan:

    "Long

    live free Andalusia".25

    THE FIRST MUSLIM ORGANIZATIONS

    Since the

    great expulsion

    of

    1609,

    it looked as

    if Islam had ceased to exist

    in

    Spain. The persecution of Muslims continued and the Catholic Inquisition

    continued

    its sinister task until the 19th

    century.

    After World War

    II,

    Muslim

    immigration, especially

    from

    Morocco,

    slowly

    increased,

    especially

    after 1960.

    By

    1990,

    the number of Muslims in

    Spain

    had reached the

    figure

    of about

    250,000

    which included about

    140,000

    Moroccans.

    These

    Muslim

    immigrants

    were able to

    organize

    themselves

    only

    after

    a

    new

    law was enacted in 1964 which allowed for the existence of non-Catholic

    religious organisations.

    In 1967 a new law was enacted which

    permitted

    a

    slightly greater degree

    of

    religious

    freedom. Arab

    students,

    mostly

    from the

    Greater

    Syria region,

    established the first Islamic Students Association in

    Granada

    in

    1966,

    which seems to have been a direct

    sequel

    of the

    visit

    of

    Shaykh

    Abü'l Hasan

    'All

    al-NadawT of India to

    Spain

    in 1963. This association

    was

    officially registered only

    in 1971 under the name of "The

    Islamic

    Association in

    Spain".

    After

    1974,

    this association

    opened

    branches in

    Madrid,

    Oviedo,

    Saragoza,

    Valencia, Santander,

    Santiago

    and

    Malaga

    in addition to its

    headquarters

    in

    Granada.

    Until

    1978,

    the "Islamic

    Association

    in

    Spain"

    remained

    basically

    a

    campus

    association. Later on it moved to the

    community

    but

    split

    into two

    groups

    after the establishment of "The Islamic Centre in

    Spain".

    The latter had

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    16/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    627

    its

    headquarters

    in Madrid with branches in

    Barcelona,

    Palmas,

    Granada,

    Seville

    and

    Malaga.

    Later on

    in

    1981,

    Prince

    Salman,

    the Governor of

    Riyadh,

    Saudi

    Arabia,

    built a

    mosque

    near his

    palace

    in Marbela in the

    province

    of

    Malaga.

    In the 1990s another

    mosque

    was built

    by

    the Saudis in

    nearby

    Fuengirola

    in the

    province

    of

    Malaga.

    In

    1990,

    the

    Kingdom

    of Saudi Arabia also

    completed

    the

    construction of the Islamic Centre of

    Madrid,

    which is

    administered

    by

    the

    Muslim

    World

    League.

    In

    1990,

    the number of

    mosques

    and

    places

    of

    prayer

    established

    by

    the

    immigrant

    Muslims

    increased

    dramatically throughout Spain, especially

    in

    Andalusia, Madrid,

    Valencia and

    Catalugna.

    Until

    1960,

    the Andalusian Muslims had

    kept

    their Islam

    secret,

    or had

    to

    emigrate

    to a Muslim

    country,

    usually

    Morocco.

    But after the death of

    Franco

    in

    1975,

    Spain changed completely

    as it

    became,

    for the first time since the fall

    of

    Granada,

    a multicultural

    decentralized democratic

    country. During

    that same

    year,

    three

    young people

    from Puertollano

    (Province

    of Ciudad

    Real)

    went to

    England

    and became Muslims

    at the hands of

    a Scottish

    Muslim,

    Sheikh Abd al

    Qädir

    al-Sufi

    (now al-Muräbit).

    They

    were followed

    by

    others,

    and

    in

    1977,

    their Sheikh ordered them to

    move

    to

    Cordoba

    and start an Islamic movement.

    This

    group

    did not remain for

    long

    time

    in

    Seville,

    and then in

    Huelva,

    they

    moved to Granada and formed an

    organization

    called

    the

    "Association for

    the Return

    of

    Islam to

    Spain".

    It

    was

    registered

    with the

    Ministry

    of Justice in

    1980 under the name of

    "Religious

    Association

    for the

    Propagation

    of Islam in

    Spain".

    This association soon became

    very strong

    and

    hundreds

    of Andalusians

    joined

    Islam

    through

    it.

    However,

    the

    strong personality

    of its

    Scottish

    leader,

    the continuous changes of his direction (from Sufi to DarqawT to Mälikl, to

    Muräbit)

    and of its name

    (from

    the above

    names to "Islamic Association in

    Spain"

    to

    "al-Muräbitün")

    led to the division of this association into a multitude

    of

    associations,

    most of them centred in the

    province

    of

    Granada,

    most

    specifically

    in the

    city

    of Granada and

    mostly

    in the

    old

    quarters

    of Albaicin.26

    Although

    this association

    has,

    over the

    course

    of

    years,

    ceased to have

    a

    leading

    role in Islamic

    activities,

    it

    played

    an

    important

    role in

    the

    beginning

    and

    provided

    a

    strong push.

    One of the

    major

    reasons

    why

    this

    group

    lost its

    drive seems

    to be its lack of

    appreciation

    of the historical dimension of

    Andalusia.

    THE Y AM A A ISLAMICA DE AL-ANDALUS (YIA)

    In

    1980,

    the

    Spanish

    Courts

    approved

    a law

    guaranteeing

    freedom of

    religion.

    In the same

    year,

    Andalusia with its

    eight provinces,

    and with Seville as its

    capital,

    was

    granted

    the status of an Autonomous

    Regipn.

    This

    region

    recognized

    Bias Infante as its founder and all the

    political

    elements

    unanimously

    adopted

    the

    political programme

    of Bias

    Infante,

    inlcuding

    the

    flag

    and the

    national anthem of the

    Region.

    The

    Region

    has an area of

    87,268

    square

    kilometres and a

    population

    of about seven

    million

    people.

    This

    development

    has

    created a

    favourable climate for the rivival of Islam in

    Andalusia.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    17/20

    628

    m. ali kettani/Muslims in

    Spain

    After the Fall

    of

    Granada

    The first Islamic

    organization

    established

    by

    Andalusians was the

    Islamic Association

    of Cordoba in 1980. The

    City

    of Cordoba then offered the

    Islamic

    Association the

    mosque

    of Cadi Abu Othman which then

    lay

    in

    ruins.

    This

    mosque

    had been converted into the Convent of Santa Clara

    after the

    conquest of Cordoba. The Catholic Church resisted the efforts of the Muslims

    to have the

    original

    position

    of the

    mosque

    restored. The

    Muslim efforts could

    not succeed

    owing

    to the

    stiff

    opposition

    put up by

    the Church.

    In

    fact

    by

    1983

    even the Islamic Association of the Cordoba ceased

    to

    exist.

    Nevertheless,

    during

    the three

    years

    of its

    existence

    many

    Andalusians embraced Islam.

    At the

    present

    the Islamic

    organization

    which

    mainly

    carries the

    Andalusian

    Islamic tradition is the "Yamaa Islamica de Al-Andalus"

    (YIA).

    It

    was

    established in Seville in 1982

    by

    a

    group

    of

    young

    Andalusians who had

    become Muslims

    around

    1981.

    This

    organization

    spread very quickly

    from

    Seville

    to all the

    provinces

    of Andalusia.

    It

    had to

    face,

    from the

    beginning,

    the

    attack

    of

    many

    Arab nationalists who

    were not

    happy

    to see the

    emergence

    of

    the Islamic

    trend

    indicating

    the

    beginning

    of the return

    of Islam

    to Andalusia.

    New centres of the Yamaa

    were,

    however,

    opened

    in

    Granada,

    Jerez

    and

    Malaga

    in

    1983,

    and in other cities. Later

    in

    1986,

    the Yamaa established

    itself

    in Cordoba

    by

    buying

    a house which it converted into

    an

    Islamic centre

    with

    the

    result that the entire

    community's

    centre of

    gravity

    moved from Seville

    to Cordova.

    In

    October

    1983,

    the Yamaa

    organized

    its first

    public

    activity

    in Seville

    in

    memory

    of

    al-Mu'tamid Ibn 'Abbäd. It was a

    great

    success

    which

    is

    evident

    from

    the

    presence

    of more than four thousand

    participants.

    The celebration

    started with the

    performance

    of the

    Maghrib

    prayers

    in

    congregation

    near

    the

    river Guadalquivir. The function came to an end in an old palace in the quarter

    of Triana

    where the

    teachings

    of Islam

    were

    explained

    to the audience and the

    poems

    of al-Mu'tamid

    were recited. In

    November-December

    1983,

    the Yamaa

    organized

    a "Cultural

    Week on Andalusian Culture"

    in

    Malaga

    in

    co-operation

    with the

    University

    of

    Malaga.

    In

    January

    1984,

    the Yamaa

    started its

    protest

    at the celebration of the

    conquest

    of Granada

    by

    the

    Christians,

    a

    celebration

    which was conducted in an

    unseemly

    manner

    by

    the Church and the

    officialdom of the

    Spanish

    State.

    The

    protest

    gained

    momentum

    and most

    of

    the citizens of Granada demanded the

    abolition

    of this celebration and its

    replacement

    by

    acts which

    signify

    fraternal

    feelings

    towards

    the Muslims. In

    July

    1984,

    the Yamaa

    organised

    a

    camp

    seminar in Collogos Vega near Granada where 200 Andalusian Muslims stayed

    together

    for several

    days

    in a

    truly

    Islamic

    atmosphere.

    In

    July

    1985 the Yamaa

    organized

    the First

    Congress

    of

    European

    Muslims

    in Seville in an effort to co-ordinate the work of those who were

    discovering

    the worth

    of Islam in different

    parts

    of

    Europe. Representatives

    arrived from

    Portugal, Spain,

    France,

    Italy, Germany,

    Britain,

    Cyprus

    and

    many

    other countries.

    In December

    1987,

    the Yamaa

    organized

    a conference

    in

    its

    newly

    established centre in Cordoba as the

    headquarters

    of the Andalusian Muslim

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    18/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1997)

    629

    community.

    In

    July

    1989 the Government of

    Spain recognized

    Islam as

    a

    religion

    which had

    deep Spanish

    roots.

    In

    September

    1989,

    the

    First International

    Congress

    of

    Andalusians was

    held

    in

    Castellar de la Frontera in the

    province

    of Cadiz. In this

    congress,

    representatives

    of the Andalusian

    diaspora

    around the world took

    part.

    Thus,

    in

    1980s,

    vigorous

    effort was made to establish Islam as a

    new

    reality

    in Andalusia. It was

    successful in this effort to a

    great

    extent.27

    THE AVERROES

    INTERNATIONAL ISLAMIC UNIVERSITY

    From the

    very beginning,

    the

    problem

    of

    educating Spanish

    Muslims was

    very

    acute. The Yamaa tried to

    bring

    teachers from Muslim countries to teach Islam

    in its

    different centres. To overcome the

    language

    barrier,

    the

    Moroccans who

    spoke Spanish

    were

    preferred

    as teachers.

    However,

    this solution did not

    always

    prove adequate

    for

    several reasons.

    Hence,

    the Yamaa started

    sending young

    people

    to

    study

    Islam and

    Arabic

    in

    Muslim countries. Dozens of

    young

    Andalusians were thus

    sent to Saudi

    Arabia,

    Algeria,

    Tunisia, Morocco,

    Jordan,

    Pakistan

    and

    Malaysia.

    This too created certain

    problems

    since

    many

    students

    who went abroad suffered from

    cultural

    shock,

    and others

    did

    not contribute to

    the work of

    the Muslim

    community

    after their return to their homeland.

    Thus,

    the

    idea of

    establishing

    an Islamic

    University

    in Cordoba

    was

    born. The first

    meeting

    to

    plan

    this was held in the

    University

    of Madrid in

    March 1989. It was followed

    by

    other

    meetings

    and

    in

    the course of time an old

    house was

    bought

    near the Great

    Mosque

    of Cordoba

    (presently

    a

    Catholic

    cathedral).

    It was

    renovated with the result that it became conformable to the

    Andalusian architectural tradition. The

    Mosque

    forms

    part

    of

    this renovated

    house and is the first regular mosque in Cordoba after the conquest of that city

    in 1236. The

    building

    was

    inaugurated

    in

    October 1994

    and

    classes were started

    in

    October 1995 with 25

    students,

    the

    majority

    of whom is from

    Spain.

    The official name of the

    University

    is "Universidad Islamica

    International Averroes de

    Al-Andalus".

    It

    is headed

    by

    a Board of 30

    members,

    including distinguished

    Muslims from

    Andalusia,

    Europe,

    and several Muslim

    countries. The Board elected Mr Amadou Muhtar

    M'Bow,

    the former Director

    General of

    UNESCO,

    as its chairman.

    Agreements

    were reached with

    International Islamic Universities to

    provide

    assistance in

    drawing

    up

    the courses

    of instruction and for

    exchange

    of teachers and students.

    This

    University

    is

    meant to serve as

    the centre

    of Islamic

    scholarship

    in Andalusia. Most of its teachers and students are Andalusians.

    Uptil

    now ithas

    been well received

    by

    the Andalusian

    community

    at

    large.

    THE ANDALUSIAN DIASPORA

    Since the

    fall

    of

    Granada,

    and even before that there has been a

    continuous flow

    of Andalusian

    emigrants

    who

    fled from their

    homeland

    owing

    to the brutal

    oppression

    to which

    they

    were

    subjected. They

    especially

    emigrated

    to the coasts

    of the Muslim countries on the Mediterranean.

    Thus,

    a

    great

    number of

    Andalusians

    during

    16th,

    17th and 18th centuries

    left

    Andalusia to settle down

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    19/20

    630

    Μ· AL|

    KETTANi/Muslims

    in

    Spain

    After the Fall of Granada

    in

    Morocco,

    Algeria

    and

    Tunisia,

    so much so

    that about 10

    per

    cent of the

    populations

    of these

    three countries could be considered

    of Andalusian

    origin.

    Most of the

    emigrants

    settled in

    existing

    cities

    (Fes, Marrakech, Tlemcen,

    Algiers,

    Tunis),

    but some of them even established

    new settlements

    (Rabat,

    Tetuan, Testour, Soliman, etc.).

    The Andalusians

    brought

    Andalusian culture to the North African

    countries.

    They

    contributed

    to

    Arabicizing

    the coastal

    regions

    since these

    refugees

    had a

    higher

    level of culture than

    the locals. Andalusians also became

    leaders

    in

    many

    fields,

    especially

    in

    politics,

    culture and

    economy. Many

    of

    them led the defence of the

    Maghrebi

    countries

    against European

    invasion,

    and

    many

    continued to serve as the

    vanguard

    of the effort to ensure the

    security

    of

    Muslim lands

    against

    the efforts to

    subjugate

    them.

    Other Andalusians

    emigrated

    to

    the Ottoman

    State,

    including

    the

    Bosnia-Herzegovina.

    Turkey,

    Lebanon,

    Syria, Egypt

    and

    the

    Arabian Peninsula.

    Traces of this

    emigration

    are observable

    even

    today

    in the name of

    many

    families.

    However,

    not all the Andalusians

    who

    fled

    their

    country

    had the

    opportunity

    to move to Muslim

    countries. Some fled to France and Switzerland

    in the

    hope

    of

    reaching

    Muslim Ottoman

    lands,

    but

    for one

    reason

    or the other

    many

    of them were unable

    to do so. With time

    they

    were Christianized but

    Islam and

    al-Andalus were not

    completely

    erased from their

    memory.

    Many

    Andalusians also fled to America. The

    Spanish

    state

    forbade

    these so-called "New Christians"

    from

    moving

    to the

    newly

    conquered

    territories

    of

    America,

    but it was not

    always easy

    to

    implement

    this

    prohibition.

    As

    Muslims

    were discovered in the New

    World,

    Inquisitions

    were established to

    persecute them. Some of them fled to North America where the Melungeons in

    the

    Appalachian

    Mountains are believed to be their descendants.

    The Andalusians who embraced Islam

    in

    Andalusia

    in recent

    years

    were

    very eager

    from the

    beginning

    to establish links with this Andalusian

    diaspora.

    This was one

    of the reasons

    underlying

    the

    holding

    of the First International

    Andalusian Conference

    in Castellar de la Frontera

    (Province

    of

    Cadiz)

    in 1989.28

    CONCLUSION

    It is

    quite

    evident that the Andalusians did not leave Islam of their

    free

    will. On

    the

    contrary, they

    were

    subjected

    to the most atrocious

    persecution,

    continuously

    for several centuries.

    Eventually, they

    became

    deprived

    of their

    names,

    their

    culture,

    almost their roots and their

    identity.

    But a flicker of love for Islam

    always

    remained in their hearts. More

    specifically,

    the

    feeling

    of

    being

    different

    from

    the rest

    of

    Spain

    was never

    quite

    obliterated.

    Blas

    Intante,

    the man who

    developed

    the

    theory

    of Andalusian

    nationalism,

    based it on its Islamic roots. He

    paid

    for this effort

    with

    his life.

    His 'crime'

    lay

    in

    telling

    the Andalusians that

    they

    were

    different

    from

    other

    Spaniards.

    But Infante's efforts enabled the return of Islam to Andalusia after

    the death of Franco

    in

    1975,

    which

    soon

    led to the restoration of

    democracy

    in

    Spain.

    This content downloaded from 152.118.24.10 on Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:02:17 UTC

    All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

    http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

  • 8/9/2019 Muslims in Spain After the Fall of Granada

    20/20

    Islamic Studies 36:4

    (1 997)

    63 1

    In

    1980,

    there

    was

    not a

    single mosque

    in

    Spain

    and

    only

    a few Islamic

    associations.

    At the

    present,

    in

    1996,

    there are 180

    mosques

    and

    prayer

    halls

    in

    Spain

    of which 50 are in Andalusia

    alone. Of

    those in

    Andalusia,

    more than half

    have been established

    by

    the Andalusian returnees to Islam.

    At the

    pesent

    Islam is

    recognized

    as a

    religion

    in

    Spain.

    With effect

    from

    1996-97,

    Islamic education

    will

    be

    imparted

    in

    public

    schools to Muslim

    children.

    The

    Islamic Commission of

    Spain, representing

    all the Muslims of the

    country,

    has been established to

    negotiate

    with the State

    as

    regards guaranteeing

    Muslims their

    rights.

    Thus,

    as the Muslims in

    Spain

    stand at the threshold of the

    twenty-first

    century, they

    have

    good

    reasons to feel much more at home in their homeland

    than

    they

    felt until

    two decades

    ago.

    For

    good

    reason

    they

    have

    begun

    to

    look

    forward

    to a

    bright

    future when the

    tragic rupture

    between Islam and

    Spain

    will,

    in all

    likelihood,

    become a relic of the

    past.

    'Μ.A. Ladero

    Quesada,

    Los

    Mudejares

    de Castilla en

    Tiempo

    de

    Isabel

    I

    (Vallalolid:

    1969).

    ^Hernando de

    Baeza,

    Las Coses de

    Granada,

    ed. M. Muller

    (Gottingen:

    1863).

    'Luis del Marmoral

    Caravajal,

    Historia del Rebelion Y

    Castigo

    de los Moriscos

    (Madrid:

    Revista

    de

    Occidente,

    1978).

    "A.

    Domínguez

    Ortiz

    y

    Bernard

    Vincent,

    Historia de tos Moriscos

    (Madrid:

    Revista de

    Occidente,

    1978).

    5J.

    Caro

    Baroja,

    Los

    Moriscos

    del Reino de

    Granada

    (Madrid: 1976).

    '•ibid.

    1lbid.

    "Diego

    Hurtado de

    Mendoza,

    Guerra

    de

    Granada,

    ed.

    (Madrid: 13,

    Blanco

    Gonzalez, 1970).

    ''As'ad

    Hammäd,

    Mihnat

    al-

    'Arabft

    Ί-Andalus

    (al-Mu

    'assasat al-

    'Arabiyyah

    li Ί-Diräsät wa

    Ί

    Nasr).

    "'Diego

    Hurtado de

    Mendoza,

    op.

    cit.

    "Bernard

    Vincent,

    L.

    Expulsion

    des

    Morisques

    du

    Royaume

    de Granada et leur

    Repartition

    en Castille

    (1570-1571),

    Melanges

    del Casa

    Velazquez,

    vol.

    VI,

    1970.

    l2Pedro

    Longas,

    Vida

    Religiosa

    de tos Moriscos

    (Madrid: 1915).

    "B.

    Vincent,

    op.

    cit.

    HH.C.

    Lea,

    History of

    the Moriscos

    of Spain,

    Their Conversion and

    Expulsion

    (London:

    1901

    ).

    "M.A.

    Kettani,

    Inbi'âth al-Islâm

    fi'l-Andalus

    (Islamabad:

    Islamic Research

    Institute,

    1992).

    "'Boronát

    y

    Barrachina,

    Los Moriscos

    Españoles y

    su

    Expulsion

    (Valencia:

    1901).

    "A.

    Domínguez

    Ortiz,

    "Felipe

    IV

    y

    los

    Moriscos", MEAII,

    voi.

    VII,

    No.

    8.

    '"Fernando

    Repiso,

    Símbolos

    y

    Derechos Andaluses

    (Sevilla:

    1980).

    '''Muhammad

    ibn 'Abd

    al-Wahhâb

    al-GhassänT,

    "Rihlat al-WazTr fi Iftikâk

    al-Asïr",

    Manuscript

    No.

    11329,

    al-Khizänah

    al-Hasaniyyah,

    Rabat,

    Morocco.

    2"Ahmad ibn al-Mahdï ai-Ghazäl, Natljat al-Ijtihâd fi' al-Muhâdanah wa'l-Jihâd, ed. Ismä'TI

    Haqqî

    (Beirut:

    1980).

    2lHenry

    Swinburne,

    Travels

    Through Spain

    in

    the Years

    1975 and 1976.

    "Joseph

    Towsend,

    A

    Journey Through Spain

    in

    the

    Years 1786 and

    1887,

    3 volumes.

    23Manuel

    Barrois,

    Las Oscuras

    Raices del Flamenco

    (Sevilla: 1986).

    MJuan

    Anstonio Lacomba

    Abellan,

    Regionalismo

    y

    Autonomia en la Andalucía

    Contemporanea

    (1835-1936)

    (Granada: 1988).

    5Manuel Ruiz

    Lagos,

    Blas

    Infante

    (Fondation

    Blas

    Infante, 1984).

    "Jacinto

    Bosch

    Vila,

    "The Muslims of

    Portugal

    and

    Spain",

    Journal

    of

    the Institute

    of

    Minority Affairs,

    vol.

    7,

    No.

    1,

    January

    1986.

    "Kettani,

    op.

    cit.

    2KIbid.,

    chapter

    12.