MSc Dissertation - Integrated Resource Management - Robbert Bosscher - s1300339

!!!!!!!!!

School of GeoSciences

Dissertation

For the degree of

MSc in Integrated Resource Management.

Robbert Derk Bosscher

August 2014

! "!

! #!

Title of Dissertation: !"#$%&'()%*)+,#-.)/0%'*12)

34#5"*"*&)6(07(89"%*:)%;)+'77(::)<0"9(0"#);%0)6#09"7"8#9"%*)!'0"*&)9,()="0:9)>%*9,:)%;)9,(!"#$%&%'(#!)*&+,$$'-+.(,/0!

! $!

! %!

?@3)ABCD3E+C?F)G=)3!CBHAE/@)))

)!"#$%!&'!(#)*+*#,%-!!!!!!E%II(09)!(0-)H%::7,(0).**/%00! ! !!JKD(0I'0&,L"M-)NOP)NNQR6<)?(05'*9(0S"M$))1%2/%%-!) ) ))C*9(&0#9(1)E(:%'07()>#*#&(5(*9) ) >+7)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1#,%-!! ! ! !!J'&':9)OT9,P)UVOQ)))3+,4%!&'!35%0+0-!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'()%*)+,#-.)/0%'*12)

34#5"*"*&)6(07(89"%*:)%;)+'77(::)<0"9(0"#);%0)6#09"7"8#9"%*)!'0"*&)9,()="0:9)>%*9,:)%;)9,()/0%*"*&(0)W!"#$%%&9#;($XK))

!"&6!&'!7&/*0!+)!,5%!$#+)!,%8,!&'!35%0+0-!!!!!!!ONKYZV!!"#$%!%&'()!*+,-$.*%!%&,/*#01(*2!3*24*3&$0.%!05!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!$.!&#*!502-!05!,!

8$,106'*! ",91*! $.! :20.$.6*.;! &#*! <*&#*21,.(%;! 9,%*(! 0.! &#*! 42$&*2$,=! $.&*.&$0.;!

$.$&$,&$0.;! $.41'%$>*.*%%;! $.502-,&$0.;! ,.(! $.51'*.4*?! "#*! -,$.! 2*%'1&! 05! &#*!

2*%*,24#!$%!&#*!,(($&$0.!05!$.&*.&$0.!,%!&#*!5$5&#!@$A!42$&*2$0.;!.*+&!&0!&#*!50'2!42$&*2$,!

32*%*.&*(! 9)! B$(,C,)! DEFFGH?! I,%*(! 0.! &#*%*! 42$&*2$,! &#*! 5$2%&! -0.&#%! 05! &#*!

:20.$.6*2!8$,1006&,5*1! DCCC?8$,1006&,5*1:20.$.6*.?.1H!#,>*!9**.!*+,-$.*(;! $.!

02(*2! &0! *1$4$&! -,$.! .,22,&$>*%;! %#0C! &#*! 31'2,1$&)! 05! >$*C%;! ,.(! 5$.(! 9,%*%! 502!

$-320>*(! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 9*&C**.! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! ,.(! %&,/*#01(*2%?!

J1&#0'6#!*>*2)!3204*%%!$%!'.$K'*;!$&!$%!,%%'-*(!&#,&!&#*!$.41'%$0.!05!@$.&*.&$0.A!,%!

,!9,%$%!502!40.%$(*2,&$0.%!,90'&!-,&4#$.6!70.*%!4,.!9*!-02*!C$(*1)!,331$*(;!,.(!

&#,&! &#*! .,22,&$>*%! 32*%*.&*(! #*2*! 4,.! #*13! ,332*4$,&*! &#*! 31'2,1$&)! 05! >$*C%! $.!

0&#*2! 3204*%%*%! ,%! C*11?! L*6,2($.6! &#*! 4,%*! %&'()! &#*! 40.41'%$0.! $%! &#,&! &#*!

30%%$91*!C,)%! 502! %,&$%5)$.6! B$(,C,)A%! DEFFGH! 42$&*2$,! #,>*! 9**.! *+,-$.*(!C*11;!

9'&! &#,&! 40.&$.'*(! 02! $.42*,%*(! 40--$&-*.&! D$.&*.&$0.H! C$11! 9*! &#*! 3$>0&,1!

(*&*2-$.,.&!05!10.6M&*2-!%'44*%%?!!

JH+?EJ<?)G=)?@3+C+)!

! &!

! '!

!

Authorʼs Note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

! ! ! ! ! ! ! "*2-'.&*27$Q1;!J'6'%&!UV&#;!EFUT!

!

!!

L099*2&!I0%%4#*2!

!

!

!!!!!!!

! (!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! )!

Acknowledgements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

! *+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! **!

Table of Contents: Abstract: ……………………………………………………………………………………………………..5

Authorʼs Note………………………………………………………………………………………………..7

Acknowledgements………………………………………………………………………………………...9

Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………………………….11

List of Tables……………………………………………………………………………………………….15

List of Abbreviations and Translations……………………………………………………………….17

Maps…………………………………………………………………………………………………………19

Chapter 1: Introduction………………………………..……………………………...21

Chapter 2: Executive Summary …………………….………………………………25

Chapter 3: Research Question ……………………………………………………..27

Chapter 4: Methodology ……………………………………………………………..29

4.1. Type of research: Positivism vs. Post-positivism……………………………………30

4.2. Qualitative Heuristics……………………………………………………………………...31

4.3. Criteria of Evaluation………………………………………………………………………34

4.4. Foreign, and Regional/Dutch Readers………………………………………………….36

4.5. Stakeholder Analysis………………………………………………………………………37

4.6. Interviews…………………………………………………………………………………….39

4.7. Ethics…………………………………………………………………………………………40

Chapter 5: Context of the Case Study…………………………………………….41

5.1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………….41

5.2. History………………………………………………………………………………………..42

5.3. Gas Production Induced Earthquakes………………………………………………….44

5.4. Main Documents and Agreements………………………………………...46 5.4.1. Meijer et al.j (2013)……………………………………………………………...46

5.4.2. Verklaring van Huizinge (2013)……………………………………………….48

5.4.3. VoH&HvV (2014a)……………………………………………………………….49

5.4.4. Van Geel & Wallage (2014)……………………………………………………52

Chapter 6: Literature Review………………………………………………………..54

! *"!

6.1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………….54

6.2. Treaties, Law & Sustainability Principles……………………………………………...55

6.3. Pragmatic Reasons………………………………………………………………………...57

6.4. Ethical Reasons…………………………………………………………………………….59

6.5. Participation in the Netherlands…………………………………………………………61

6.6. Matching Zones……………………………………………………………………………..64

6.7. Shared Solutions……………………………………………………………………………66

Chapter 7: Analysis……………………………………………………………………69

7.1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………….69

7.2. Analysis………………………………………………………………………………………71

7.2.1. Intention…………………………………………………………………………..71

7.2.1.1. Pre-negotiation Considerations………………………………….71

7.2.1.1.1. For NAM…………………………………………………..73

7.2.1.1.2. For Societal Actors……………………………………..75

7.2.1.2. Operational Considerations………………………………………76

7.2.1.2.1. Government and NAM………………………………….76

7.2.1.2.2. The Dialogue Table……………………………………..77

7.2.1.2.3. Protest Parties…………………………………………...80

7.2.2. Initiation…………………………………………………………………………..81

7.2.2.1. General………………………………………………………………..81

7.2.2.2. Tactical level principles……………………………………………84

7.2.3. Inclusiveness……………………………………………………………………88

7.2.3.1. Representation………………………………………………………88

7.2.3.2. Involvement in decision-making…………………………………90

7.2.3.3. Openness of Information & Presentation of Success………..91

7.2.3.4. Accountability……………………………………………………….95

7.2.4. Information……………………………………………………………………….96

7.2.5. Influence………………………………………………………………………….99

Chapter 8: Conclusion………………………………………………………………103 8.1. Satisfaction of Success Criteria & Shared Solutions………………………………103

! *#!

8.2. Transferability of Results………………………………………………………………..105

8.2.1. ʻIntentionʼ……………………………………………………………………….105

8.2.2. Satisfaction of Criteria and Shared Solutions…………………………...106

8.3. Lessons Learned & Reflections for Future Research……………………………...107

Reference:…………………………………………………………………………..…109

Appendix I: List of Respondents………………………………………………….116

Appendix II: Positivist vs. Post-positivist Research…………………………..117

Appendix III: Advice of the Meijer Commission………………………………..118

Appendix IV: Members of the Dialogue Table………………………………….119

Appendix V: Signatories to the Verklaring van Huizinge……………………..120

Appendix VI: Interview script (English Translation……..……………………..123

Appendix VII: Citation and Data Use Agreement (English & Dutch)………..125

Appendix VIII: Ethics Self Assessment Form…………………………………..131

Appendix IV: Travel Overseas Approval…………………………………………132

! *$!

! *%!

Table of Figures: Figure 1: Criteria of analysis……………………………………………………………………35 Figure 2: Stakeholder communication map with respondents indicated in red…………...38 Figure 3 Soil Subsidence………………………………………………………………………42 Figure 4: Gas Production Induced Earthquakes in Groningen……………………….…….44 Figure 5: Government Participation Ladder…………………………………………………..63 Figure 6: Shared Solutions……………………………………………………………………..67 Figure 7: Influence-Interest Matrix……………………………………………………………100

! *&!

! *'!

List of Abbreviations & Translations: 1+%!2+.(,![!! ! ! ! L*302&!9)!>,.!:**1!^!P,11,6*!DEFUTH!!3HB)[!! ! ! ! ! =)%/2+%>%*/+?'! "%*%/4#)*! _! O.*26)! [0-3,.)! &#*!!

<*&#*21,.(%!/HH)[)) ) ) ) ) @/&)+)2%/!A&*%$!A%7%2+)2!_!:20.$.6*2!:20'.(!!! ! ! ! ! ! W0>*-*.&!\B>C)[) ) ) ) !! ]0.$./1$Q/!<*(*21,.(%!W*&*2*0106$%4#!S.%&$&''&!_!!! ! ! ! ! ! L0),1!8'&4#!W*&*20106$4,1!S.%&$&'&*?!!3++-456+7!"#$%&%'(%)[)) ) \,2&.*2%#$3!:20.$.6*.!>("M(0)<%55"::"%*)[!! ! [0--$%%$*!8''27,-*!"0*/0-%&!<002(M`0%&!!! ! ! ! ! ! :20.$.6*.!_!!! ! ! ! !! ! [0--$&&**!B'%&,$.,91*!5'&'2*!<02&#MO,%&!! !! ! ! ! ! ! :20.$.6*.?! !>("M(0)E(8%09)[!! ! ! R*2&20'C*.!$.!**.!8''27,-*!"0*/0-%&=!O*.!!! ! ! ! ! ! B&*>$6!\*2%3*4&$*5!>002!<002(M`0%&!:20.$.6*.!_!!! ! ! ! ! ! a,>$.6!Z,$&#!$.!,!B'%&,$.,91*!Z'&'2*=!J!B01$(!!! ! ! ! ! ! \*2%3*4&$>*!502!!<02&#MO,%&!:20.$.6*.!!BJ>[!! ! ! ! ! <*(*21,.(%*!J,2(01$*!W,,&%4#,33$Q!_!! !! ! ! ! ! ! 8'&4#!`$1![0-3,.)!+<6)[!! ! ! ! ! B&:+##4!(C4,C/%%4!94#)>C/%#C!_!! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! B04$,1!['1&'2,1!\1,..$.6!J6*.4)!+3E![)) ) ) ) ) B&:+##4!=:&)&$+0:5%!D##*!_!!! ! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! B04$,1!O40.0-$4![0'.4$1!+>+)[) ) ) ) ! B#$%)7%/E+)2!F+?)>&C70:5#*%!_!! ! !! ! ! ! ! ! [003*2,&$0.!W$.$.6!8,-,6*!!?7II)[!! ! ! ! ! "*4#.$%4#*![0--$%%$*!I0(*-9*C*6$.6!_!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!! ! ! ! !!!!!!! !!!! "*4#.$4,1![0--$&&**!:20'.(!W0>*-*.&?!!D("$"&,("1:0(&"%)[) ) ) B,5*&)!L*6$0.!!D(0-$#0"*&)]#*)@'"S"*&(!![!! 8*41,2,&$0.!05!a'$7$.6*!D%@^D]D![!! ! ! ! G%/,/&C7%)!&;!H%/0,%4!#)*!H%/0,%4!I#)!G%/,/&C7%)!_!!! ! ! ! ! !!! "2'%&!$.!L*%&02,&$0.!,.(!L*%&02,&$0.!05!"2'%&?!!!

! *(!

! *)!

Maps: Groningen, The Netherlands !

!Map 1: Groningen, The Netherlands.!Db$4#*.;!EFUTH!!!Earthquake Map

!Map 2: Earthquake Map, Groningen, The Netherlands.!D:II;!EFUT4H!!!

! "+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! "*!

1. Introduction

JF<!5&C0%!+0!)&!4&)2%/!$<!5&C0%6!K,!C0%*!,&!>%!#!'/+%)*L!>C,!)&7!+,!5#0!>%:&$%!#)!C);/%*+:,#>4%!'#:,&/M!Dc*-91,;!EFUTH!!

JK,!+0!4+E%!,5%!07&/*!&'!1#$&:4%0N!#47#<0!/%#*<!,&!0,/+E%M!DB&0/>$%;!EFUVH!!

JK'!<&C!7&C4*!:&$;#/%!+,!,&!#!7#/O&)%L!<&C!#/%!+)!,5%!4+)%!&'!'+/%6!P&C!E)&7!<&C/!5&C0%!:#)!>%!5+,L!>C,!<&C!*&!)&,!E)&7!+'!+,!7+44!>%L!75%)!+,!$+25,L!#)*!5&7!$C:5!*#$#2%!7+44!>%!:#C0%*M!DB&0/>$%;!EFUVH!!

"#*%*! ,2*! %&,&*-*.&%!-,(*! 9)! $.#,9$&,.&%! 05! &#*!8'&4#! 320>$.4*! 05! :20.$.6*.?!

"#0'6#! .0&! ,.! ,2*,! 05! 2*4*.&! %*$%-$4! ,4&$>$&);! &#*! 2*6$0.! #,%! *+3*2$*.4*(!

,3320+$-,&*1)!UFFF!6,%!320('4&$0.M$.('4*(!*,2&#K',/*%!%$.4*!Udef!D]<WS;!EFUVH?!

\*031*!,2*!,.62);!#0'%*%!#,>*!9**.!(,-,6*(;!,.(!&#*2*!$%!'.4*2&,$.&)!2*6,2($.6!

&#*!30&*.&$,1!%&2*.6&#!05! 5'&'2*!*,2&#K',/*%! DR0a^a>R;!EFUT9H?!"#*!*,2&#K',/*!

05!a'$7$.6*!DJ'6'%&!Uf&#!EFUEH!C,%!&#*!%&20.6*%&!%0!5,2;!C$&#!,!-,6.$&'(*!05!V?f!0.!

&#*!L$4#&*2! %4,1*! D]<WS;! EFUVH?! L*4*.&! (,&,! %'66*%&%! &#,&! ('2$.6! &#*! .*+&! &#2**!

)*,2%!&#$%!-,6.$&'(*!-$6#&!2*,4#!T?U;!C$&#!,!%0$1!,44*1*2,&$0.!05!F?UE6!D$.!C#$4#!6!

$%! &#*! ,44*1*2,&$0.! 9)! 62,>$&)H! DR*$1$6#*$(%2*6$0;! EFUTH?! a0C*>*2;! ('*! &0! ,! UFg!

4#,.4*!&#,&!&#*%*!C0'1(!&'2.!0'&!%&20.6*2!02!#$6#*2;!2*%3*4&$>*1);!&#*!%,5*&)!31,.!

9)! G%+4+25%+*0/%2+&! QB,5*&)! L*6$0.H! ,331$*%! ,! -,+$-'-! 30%%$91*! %&2*.6&#! 05! G?F!

DR*$1$6#*$(%2*6$0;!EFUTH?! !! ! ! ! ! !

! J4402($.6!&0!8'&4#!-$.$.6!1,C;!,!3,2&)!*+310$&$.6!,!%'9&*22,.*,.!2*%0'24*!

4,.!9*!#*1(!2*%30.%$91*!502!2*%'1&$.6!(,-,6*!,90>*!620'.(!D"499;!EFFEH?!a0C*>*2;!

&#*2*! $%! -02*! &0! &#*! %$&',&$0.! &#,.! -0.*&,2)! 40-3*.%,&$0.?! a0'%*%! ,.(! 0&#*2!

%&2'4&'2*%!$.!&#*!2*6$0.!#,>*!.0&!9**.!(*%$6.*(!&0!(*,1!C$&#!*,2&#K',/*%;!,.(!&#*!

2*1,&$>*1)!%#,110C!#)304*.&2*%!05!6,%!320('4&$0.!$.('4*(!*,2&#K',/*%!4,.!104,11)!

-,/*! &#*-! -02*! (*%&2'4&$>*! &#,.! .,&'2,1! *,2&#K',/*%! 05! &#*! %,-*! -,6.$&'(*!

D<JW\bJ"Z`LW;!EFUTH?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!3*031*!4'22*.&1)!#,>*!,!>*2)!10C!1*>*1!05!

&2'%&! $.! :0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! &#*! "%*%/4#)*0%! .#/*&4+%! F##,0:5#;;+?! ! D8'&4#! `$1!

[0-3,.)!M!<JWH!DR,.!:**1!^!P,11,6*;!EFUTH?!!! ! ! ! !

! ""!

J5&*2! &#*! *,2&#K',/*! 05! a'$7$.6*;! &#*! \20>$.4$,1! :0>*2.-*.&! 05! :20.$.6*.!

40--$%%$0.*(! &#*! 2*302&! RG%/,/&C7%)! +)! %%)! 1CC/O#$%! 3&%E&$0,-! =%)! B,%I+2!

9%/0;%:,+%'!I&&/!"&&/*ST&0,!@/&)+)2%)U!Da,>$.6!5,$&#!$.!,!%'%&,$.,91*!5'&'2*=!,!%01$(!

3*2%3*4&$>*! 502! <02&#MO,%&! :20.$.6*.H! DW*$Q*2! *&! ,1?;! EFUVH?! Z20-! .0C! 0.! &#$%!

2*302&!C$11! 9*! 2*5*22*(! &0! ,%! h2*302&! 05i! &#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.?! \,2&! 05!W*$Q*2A%!

,(>$4*!C,%!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!D(*.!I'&&*2!^!&*.!P01(*;!EFUUH!

$.! &#*! 502-! 05! ,! 8$,106'*! ",91*! DW*$Q*2! *&! ,1?;! EFUVH?! "#*! ,(>$4*! 05! &#*! W*$Q*2!

[0--$%%$0.!C,%!920,(1)!*.(02%*(;!,%!%#0C.!9)!&#*!1,26*!.'-9*2!05!%$6.,&02$*%!

&0! &#*! @G%/E4#/+)2! I#)! HC+O+)2%U! D8*41,2,&$0.! 05! a'$7$.6*H! DR*2/1,2$.6! >,.!

a'$7$.6*;!EFUVH?!S.!X,.',2)!EFUT!&#*!%$6.,&02$*%!&0!RG%/,/&C7%)!+)!H%/0,%4!%)!H%/0,%4!

I#)!G%/,/&C7%)U!D"2'%&!05!L*%&02,&$0.;!,.(!L*%&02,&$0.!05!"2'%&H!,1%0!*.(02%*(!&#*!

*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!&#$%!8$,106'*!",91*;!C#$4#!,&!&#,&!-0-*.&!C,%!9*$.6!*%&,91$%#*(!

9)!R,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT,H?!S.!@.#)!,#'%4U!D"0!&#*!&,91*H!>,.!:**1!

,.(!P,11,6*!DEFUTH!32*%*.&!&#*!%&2'4&'2*!,.(!40-30%$&$0.!05!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*j!,!

-,&4#$.6!70.*!*%&,91$%#*(!&0=!!

J/%:&))%:,! 5&/+O&),#44<! &/2#)+0%*! 0&:+%,<! 7+,5! I%/,+:#44<! &/2#)+0%*! 2&I%/)#):%M!DR,.!:**1!^!P,11,6*;!EFUT=VGH!! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

"#*!8$,106'*!",91*!:20.$.6*.!$%!&#*!&#$2(!05!$&%!/$.(!$.!&#*!<*&#*21,.(%;!9'&!#,%!

.0&,91*!($55*2*.4*%!C$&#!$&%!32*(*4*%%02%j!&#*!F##0I4#E,%!,.(!",91*!05!J1(*2%!DR,.!

:**1!^!P,11,6*;! EFUTH?! B,(1);! &#*! 1,4/!05! 1$&*2,&'2*! 2*6,2($.6! &#*%*!32*(*4*%%02%!

-,/*%! ,! (*&,$1*(! 40-3,2$%0.! ($55$4'1&!C$&#$.! &#*! &$-*! 40.%&2,$.&%! 05! &#$%! %&'()?!

"#*2*502*;! &#$%! %&'()!2*%&2$4&%! $&%*15! &0! &#*!8$,106'*!",91*! h:20.$.6*.i!,.(!2*1$*%!

-0%&1)!0.!32$-,2)!(,&,;!6,&#*2*(!('2$.6!EV!$.&*2>$*C%?!"#*%*!$.&*2>$*C%!,.(!&#*!

,.,1)%$%!C*2*!(*%$6.*(!&0!*1$4$&!3*24*3&$0.%!2*6,2($.6!&#*!3204*%%A!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!

B$(,C,)A%! 50'2! 42$&*2$,! 502! %'44*%%5'1! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.k-*($,&$0.j! $.$&$,&$0.;!

$.41'%$>*.*%%;! $.502-,&$0.;! ,.(! $.51'*.4*! DEFFGH?! I,%*(! 0.! &#*! 0'&40-*! 05! &#*%*!

$.&*2>$*C%;! &#*%*! 50'2! $M%! #,>*! 9**.! 40-31*-*.&*(! 9)! ,! 5$5&#! $=! $.&*.&$0.?!

! "#!

O+,-$.$.6! &#*%*! 3*24*3&$0.%! ('2$.6! &#*! $.$&$,1!-0.&#%! 05! &#$%! 3204*%%! %*2>*%! &0!

*%&,91$%#!9,%*%!502!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6?!"#*!%&'()A%!60,1!$%!&0!@$-320>*!$.%$6#&!

$.&0!%&,/*#01(*2!,.(!32,4&$&$0.*2!3*24*3&$0.%!05!/*)!42$&*2$,!05!($,106'*!&,91*!%&)1*!

-,&4#$.6!70.*%;!$.!02(*2!&0!*%&,91$%#!9,%*%!502!$-320>*(!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6A?!!

! \,2&!05! &#*%*!9,%*%!C$11!9*!*%&,91$%#*(! &#0'6#!&#*!32030%$&$0.!05!30&*.&$,1!

@%#,2*(!%01'&$0.%A!DL*(3,&#;!EFUEH;!)*&!$&!$%!,4/.0C1*(6*(!&#,&!%0-*!($55*2*.4*%!05!

03$.$0.!,2*!9,%*(!0.!(**31)!#*1(!9*1$*5%!&#,&!,2*!.0.M.*60&$,91*!DB$(,C,);!EFFGH?!

S.! &#,&! %$&',&$0.! 40.&2,%&$.6! 3*24*3&$0.%! ,2*!-,33*(! ,.(! *+,-$.*(;! .0&! &0! 5$.(!

%#,2*(! %01'&$0.%;! 9'&! &0! $-320>*! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 9)! *+,-$.$.6! &#*!

'.(*21)$.6! 2*,%0.%! 502! &#$%! ($%,62**-*.&?! I)! (0$.6! %0;! 9,%*%! 502! $-320>*(!

'.(*2%&,.($.6!$.!($%,62**-*.&!,2*!*%&,91$%#*(?!"#*!%&'()!'%*%!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!

:20.$.6*.!DCCC?8$,1006&,5*1:20.$.6*.?.1H?!a0C*>*2;!$&!$%!.0&!,90'&!9*$.6!2$6#&!

02!C20.6;!9'&!,90'&!*%&,91$%#$.6!9,%*%! 502! $-320>$.6!'.(*2%&,.($.6?!I*4,'%*!05!

&#$%! ,3320,4#;! &#*! .,22,&$>*%! 32*%*.&*(! $.! &#$%! %&'()! 4,.! ,1%0! 9*! '%*5'1! C#*.!

,&&*-3&$.6! &0! '.(*2%&,.(! 0&#*2! %$-$1,2! 3204*%%*%?! O,4#! 4,%*! $%! '.$K'*;! ,.(!

3*24*3&$0.!$%!3*2%0.,1?!a0C*>*2;!('2$.6!&#*!%&'()!%*>*2,1!-,$.!1$.*%!05!2*,%0.$.6!

40.4*2.$.6!&#*!G!$!42$&*2$,!C*2*!*1$4$&*(;!,.(!&#0'6#!.0&!($2*4&1)!,331$4,91*;!&#*%*!

4,.!502-!,!'%*5'1!9,%$%!502!&#*!*+,-$.,&$0.!05!5'&'2*!-,&4#$.6!70.*%?!! !

! <*+&;! &#*! 2*%*,24#! K'*%&$0.! $%! 32*%*.&*(?! B'9%*K'*.&1);! $.! 4#,3&*2! T! &#*!

-*&#0(0106)! $%! 32*%*.&*(! ,.(! *1,902,&*(! $.?! "#$%! $%! 50110C*(! 9)! &#*! 1$&*2,&'2*!

2*>$*C!$.!4#,3&*2!G;!,.(!,.!*+31,.,&$0.!05!&#*!4,%*!%&'()A%!40.&*+&!$.!4#,3&*2!f?!S.!

4#,3&*2! l! &#*! $.&*2>$*C! (,&,! $%! 32*%*.&*(! ,.(! 40.&2,%&*(! C$&#! *,4#! 0&#*2! ,.(!

1$&*2,&'2*?! "#$%! 4#,3&*2! %#0'1(! 6$>*! &#*! 2*,(*2! ,.! $.%$6#&! $.&0! &#*! 31'2,1$&)! 05!

>$*C%!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!9*%&!C,)%!&0!2'.!&#$%!3204*%%?!"#*!($%4'%%$0.!05!&#*%*!>$*C%!

%#0'1(!320>$(*!&#*!2*,(*2!C$&#!,!40..*4&$0.!&0! &#*!4,%*!%&'()!C$&#!,!9,%$%! 520-!

C#$4#! &0! $-320>*!-'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6?! Z02! 2*,(*2%! .0&! 40..*4&*(! &0! &#*! 4,%*!

%&'()! &#$%! 4#,3&*2! 320>$(*%! ,! 1$>*1)! $.%$6#&! $.&0! 30%%$91*! C,)%! $.! C#$4#! &#*!

5'15$1-*.&! 05! %'44*%%! 42$&*2$,! 4,.! 9*!3*24*$>*(! $.! &#*! 5$2%&!-0.&#%! 05! ,!-,&4#$.6!

! "$!

70.*?! "#$%! 31'2,1$&)! ,.(! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! &0! $-320>*!-'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! $.! &#$%!

4,%*! %&'()! %#0'1(! $.%3$2*! 0&#*2%! &0! '%*! ,! %$-$1,2! ,.,1)%$%! C#*.! *%&,91$%#$.6! ,!

5'&'2*!-,&4#$.6!70.*?!Z$.,11);!$.!&#*!40.41'%$0.!$.&*2*%&$.6!30$.&%!,2*!#$6#1$6#&*(;!

&#*! 1*>*1! 05! %'44*%%! $.!-**&$.6! &#*! 60,1%! 05! &#*! 2*%*,24#;! ,.(! 40.%$(*2,&$0.%! ,2*!

320>$(*(!,.(!($%4'%%*(?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

!

!

!

! "%!

2. Executive Summary

"#$%!%&'()!#,%!*+,-$.*(!3,2&$4$3,.&;! %&,/*#01(*2;!,.(!*+3*2&!3*24*3&$0.%!0.! &#*!

8$,106'*!",91*!:20.$.6*.A%!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!B$(,C,)A%!DEFFGH!42$&*2$,!502!%'44*%%5'1!

3,2&$4$3,&$0.=! $.$&$,&$0.;! $.41'%$>*.*%%;! $.502-,&$0.;! ,.(! $.51'*.4*?!"#*! 5$*1(C02/!

$.($4,&*(!&#,&!$&!-$6#&!9*!$-302&,.&!&0!-02*!*+31$4$&1)!40.%$(*2!&#*!@$.&*.&$0.A!3,2&!

05!$.$&$,&$0.;!,.(!&#*2*502*!&#$%!#,%!9**.!,((*(!,%!&#*!5$5&#!$M42$&*2$0.?!! !

! "#*! %&'()! ,$-%! &0! 320>$(*! 9,%*%! 502! $-320>*(! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6!

40.4*2.$.6! ,! C$(*! >,2$*&)! 05! 3*2%3*4&$>*%! 0.! #0C! &0! 9*%&! %,&$%5)! &#*%*! 42$&*2$,?!

I,%*(!0.!&#*!$.3'&!05!,!C$(*!>,2$*&)!05!2*%30.(*.&%!$&!$%!40.41'(*(!&#,&!$.!02(*2!&0!

-,/*!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!$.!%'4#!,%!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!,!%'44*%%;!$&! $%!$-302&,.&!&0!

6,$.! ,! (**3*2! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! &#*! 620'.(%! 05! &#$%! 31'2,1$&)! 05! 3*2%3*4&$>*%?!

Z'2&#*2-02*;!&#*!(,&,!%#0C*(!&#,&!$&!$%!.0&!0.1)!$-302&,.&!&0!41*,21)!,2&$4'1,&*!&#*!

,(>,.&,6*%! 05! @1$&*2,&'2*! %'3302&*(A! 02! @9*%&! 32,4&$4*A! >$*C%;! 9'&! &0! 42*,&*! ,.!

0>*2>$*C!,.(!(*&,$1*(!'.(*2%&,.($.6!05!&#*!620'.(%!502!,11!3*2%3*4&$>*%?!! !

! I,%*(!0.!&#$%!'.(*2%&,.($.6!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!@%#,2*(!%01'&$0.%A;!02!&#*!

*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!920,(*2!9,%*%!05!%'3302&!502!@9*%&!32,4&$4*%A!-$6#&!9*!30%%$91*?!S&!

-$6#&! 502! $.%&,.4*! *-*26*! &#,&! ,1&#0'6#! 3,2&$*%! 4'22*.&1)! ($%,62**! 0.! ,! 4*2&,$.!

32,4&$4*;!90&#!%&2$>*!502!&#*!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!&#*!%,-*!32$.4$31*?!S.!&#,&!4,%*;!#,>$.6!

6,$.*(!,.!,332*4$,&$0.!05!&#$%!%#,2*(!32$.4$31*!-$6#&!#*13!$.!(*>*103$.6!,!%#,2*(!

%01'&$0.?! S5! ($%,62**-*.&! 3*2%$%&%! 9,%*(! 0.! 0330%$.6! .0.M.*60&$,91*! 32$.4$31*%;!

#,>$.6!'.*,2&#!&#*!'.(*21)$.6!2*,%0.%!#,%!%&$11!9**.!C02&#C#$1*?!I)!*%&,91$%#$.6!

&#*%*! '.(*21)$.6! 2*,%0.%;! $&! %#0'1(! 9*40-*! 41*,2! &#,&! &#*! 0330%$.6!3,2&)! $%! .0&!

$22,&$0.,1;!9'&!$.%&*,(!#,%!,!C021(>$*C!9,%*(!0.!($55*2*.&!32$.4$31*%?!"#*!$.42*,%*!

$.! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 320>$(*(! 9)! &#$%! $%! *%%*.&$,1! 502! &#*! $-320>*-*.&! 05!

&2'%&M9,%*(!3204*%%*%!%'4#!,%!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*?!!

! "&!

! "'!

3. Research Question

"#*!2*%*,24#!K'*%&$0.!05!&#$%!%&'()!$%=!!

W_,#9)I#:(:);%0)"580%](1)5'9'#$)'*1(0:9#*1"*&)"*)5#97,"*&)S%*(:)7#*)I()(:9#I$":,(1)7%*7(0*"*&)9,()70"9(0"#2))

C*9(*9"%*P)"*"9"#9"%*P)"*7$':"](*(::P)"*;%05#9"%*P)#*1)"*;$'(*7(KX)

"#$%!%&'()!4,.!9*%&!9*!(*%42$9*(!9)!a'2%&0.A%! DUdTEH!(*5$.$&$0.!05!2*%*,24#!4$&*(!

9)!`Ab*,2)!DEFUTH=!!

J;/<+)2!#)*!;&E+)2!7+,5!#!;C/;&0%M!DEH!!

8'*! &0! &#*! .,&'2*! 05! &#*! %&'()! $&! 4,..0&! 41,$-! &0! 1$>*! '3! &0! &#*!`+502(!O.61$%#!

8$4&$0.,2)!!DEFFlH!(*5$.$&$0.!05!2*%*,24#!,%=!!

J,5%!0<0,%$#,+:!0,C*<!&'!$#,%/+#40!#)*!0&C/:%0!+)!&/*%/!,&!%0,#>4+05!'#:,0!#)*!/%#:5!)%7!:&):4C0+&)0MQ`Ab*,2);!EFUT=EH!!! ! !

"#*! %&'()! $%! .0&!-*,.&! &0! *%&,91$%#! @5,4&%A! 05! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.?! S&%! 2*%'1&%! 40.%$%&! 05!

*+31,.,&$0.%! 05! 30&*.&$,1! (2$>*2%! 9*#$.(! %&,/*#01(*2! .,22,&$>*%;! ,.(! 30&*.&$,1!

%#,2*(!%01'&$0.%!DL*(3,&#;!EFUEH!$.!C#$4#!&#*!%&20.6!30$.&%!05!($55*2*.&!.,22,&$>*%!

-$6#&! 1*,(! &0! ,! 9*&&*2;! -'&',11)! ,62**,91*! %01'&$0.?! "#*! %&'()! 504'%*%! 0.! &#*!

8$,106'*! ",91*! :20.$.6*.;! C#$4#! $%! ,! &)3*! 05! C#,&! (*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.!P01(*!

DEFUUH! 4,11! ,! @-,&4#$.6!70.*A?!O,4#!-,&4#$.6!70.*! $%!'.$K'*;! ,.(!9,%*(!0.! &#,&;!

L**(! DEFFeH! ,26'*%! 502! ,! 2*31,4*-*.&! 05! C#,&! #*! 4,11%! ,! @&001M/$&A! ,3320,4#! h05!

%&,/*#01(*2!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!2*%*,24#i?!S.%&*,(!05!%**$.6!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!,%!,!-0%&1)!

&*4#.$4,1!4#,11*.6*;!$&!%#0'1(!9*!%**.!,%!,!3204*%%!&#,&=!!

J05&C4*! >%! C)*%/;+))%*! ><! #! ;5+4&0&;5<! &'! %$;&7%/$%),L! %VC+,<L! ,/C0,L! #)*!4%#/)+)2M!DL**(;!EFFe=ETUlH!! ! !

J!9,%$4!,%%'-3&$0.!05!&#$%!%&'()!$%!&#,&;!$.!02(*2!&0!-,/*!&#$%!3#$10%03#)!C02/;!$&!

$%! *%%*.&$,1! 502! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! &0! %&2$>*! 502! &#*! #$6#*%&! 30%%$91*! 1*>*1! 05! -'&',1!

'.(*2%&,.($.6?! "#$%! (0*%! .0&! -*,.! &#,&! &#$%! '.(*2%&,.($.6! .,&'2,11)! 1*,(%! &0!

! "(!

,62**-*.&?!a0C*>*2;!&#$%!%&'()!4*.&2*%!0.!&#*!$(*,!&#,&!/.0C$.6!&#*!9,4/620'.(!

05!,!($%,62**-*.&!$%!*%%*.&$,1!502!%'44*%%5'1!4003*2,&$0.?!"#*2*502*;!&#*!60,1!05!&#$%!

%&'()!$%!&0=!!

W"580%]()"*:"&,9)"*9%):9#-(,%$1(0)#*1)80#79"9"%*(0)8(07(89"%*:)%;)-(.)70"9(0"#)%;)1"#$%&'()9#I$():9.$()5#97,"*&)S%*(:P)"*)%01(0)9%)(:9#I$":,)I#:(:);%0)"580%](1)

5'9'#$)'*1(0:9#*1"*&KX!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ")!

4. Methodology

S.! &#*! 50110C$.6!%*4&$0.%! &#$%! %&'()A%!*>,1',&$>*! %&2'4&'2*! $%!32*%*.&*(?!Z$2%&;! &#*!

40.&2,%&! 05! $&%! \0%&M30%$&$>$%&! .,&'2*! C$&#! &#,&! 05! \0%$&$>$%&! 2*%*,24#! C$11! 9*!

*+31,$.*(?! "#$%! $%! 50110C*(! 9)! ,.! *+31,.,&$0.! 05! &#*! m',1$&,&$>*! a*'2$%&$4%!

D]1*$.$.6!^!P$&&;!EFFFH!*-310)*(!$.!&#$%!%&'()?!B'9%*K'*.&1);!&#*!%&'()A%!42$&*2$,!

05!,.,1)%$%!,2*!*+31,$.*(;!50110C*(!9)!,!%#02&!.0&*!40.4*2.$.6!1$/*1)!($55*2*.4*%!$.!

2*,($.6! *+3*2$*.4*! 9*&C**.! 502*$6.! 2*,(*2%! ,.(! &#0%*! 520-! &#*! 2*6$0.! 02! &#*!

<*&#*21,.(%?!Z$.,11);! &#*!320Q*4&!,.(!$&%!(,&,!6,&#*2$.6!,2*!32*%*.&*(;!($>$(*(!$.!

&#*!%&,/*#01(*2!,.,1)%$%;!&#*!$.&*2>$*C%;!,.(!,!%*4&$0.!0.!*&#$4%?!!

! #+!

4.1. Type of research: Positivism vs. Post-positivism

J%! %&,&*(;! &#$%! %&'()! $%! .0&! $.&*.(*(! &0! *%&,91$%#! @5,4&%A! &#,&! 4,.! 40.&2$9'&*! &0! ,!

&001M/$&! 502! *%&,91$%#$.6! %'44*%%5'1! -,&4#$.6! 70.*%?! S.%&*,(;! $&! *-310)%!

2*%30.(*.&%A! .,22,&$>*%! &0! $11'%&2,&*! 4'22*.&! ($%,62**-*.&%! 0.! &#*! %&'()A%! -,$.!

42$&*2$,;!,.(!9,%*(!0.!&#,&!9,%*%!502!30&*.&$,1!$-320>*(!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6!,2*!

*%&,91$%#*(?!J1&#0'6#!&#*!%&'()!$%!4*.&2*(!,20'.(!,!4,%*!%&'();!$&!40'1(!9*!,26'*(!

&#,&! $&%! 5$.($.6%! 4,.! 9*! '%*5'1! %&,2&$.6! 30$.&%! 502! $-320>$.6! '.(*2%&,.($.6!

9*&C**.!3,2&$*%!C$&#!40.&2,%&$.6!>$*C%!$.!0&#*2!%$&',&$0.%!,%!C*11?!a0C*>*2;!%$.4*!

3*24*3&$0.%! ,2*! >*2)! 3*2%0.,1;! &#*)! C$11! *>*.! 30%%$91)! C$(*1)! ($55*2! C$&#$.!

026,.$%,&$0.%;! ,.(! %$.4*! $&! C,%! 0.1)! 30%%$91*! &0! $.&*2>$*C! ,! 1$-$&*(! .'-9*2! 05!

2*%30.(*.&%;! &#$%! 2*%*,24#! 4,..0&! 9*! 2*320('4*(! $.! &#*!C,)! $.!C#$4#! \0%$&$>$%&!

2*%*,24#!%#0'1(!9*!2*320('4$91*?!!! ! ! ! !

! B$-$1,21);!&#*!0&#*2!30%$&$>$%&!42$&*2$,!,2*!,1%0!($55$4'1&!&0!%,&$%5)!$.!C$&#!&#$%!

&)3*!05!2*%*,24#?!a0C*>*2;!,%!32*%*.&*(!9)!`Ab*,2)!DEFUTH;!2*%*,24#!$%!.0&!1$-$&*(!

&0! &#*! 42$&*2$,! 05! \0%$&$>$%-;! ,.(! ,! %&'()! .0&! %,&$%5)$.6! $&%! 42$&*2$,! 4,.! %&$11! 055*2!

>,1',91*!$.%$6#&%?!"#*!.,22,&$>*%!32*%*.&*(!$.!&#$%!%&'()!C$11!.0&!32*%*.&!.*C!5,4&%;!

9'&! &#*)! ,2*!'%*5'1! &0! $-320>*!0'2!'.(*2%&,.($.6!05! %&,/*#01(*2!3*24*3&$0.%!05!

&#*! C02/$.6%! 05! -,&4#$.6! 70.*%?! "#*! \0%&M30%$&$>$%&! 42$&*2$,! ,(#*2*(! &0! 9)! &#$%!

%&'()!,2*!40.&2,%&*(!C$&#!$&%!\0%$&$>$%&!40'.&*23,2&%!$.!J33*.($+!SS?!!

! #*!

4.2. Qualitative Heuristics

"0!6'$(*!&#*!%*,24#!502!%#,2*(!,.(!0330%$.6!3*24*3&$0.%;!&#*!K',1$&,&$>*!#*'2$%&$4%!

32*%*.&*(! 9)! ]1*$.$.6! ,.(! P$&&! DEFFFH! #,>*! 9**.! *-310)*(?! "#$%! ,3320,4#!

%'66*%&%!&#,&!&#*!2*%*,24#*2!,(#*2*%!&0!&#*!50110C$.6!50'2!9,%$4!2'1*%=!!

W6 35%! /%0%#/:5! ;%/0&)! 05&C4*! >%! &;%)! ,&! )%7! :&):%;,0! #)*! :5#)2%! 5+0X5%/!;/%:&):%;,+&)0!+'!,5%!*#,#!#/%!)&,!+)!#2/%%$%),!7+,5!,5%$6!!

Y6 35%! ,&;+:! &'! /%0%#/:5! +0! ;/%4+$+)#/<! #)*! $#<! :5#)2%! *C/+)2! ,5%! /%0%#/:5!;/&:%006!!

Z6 1#,#!05&C4*!>%!:&44%:,%*!C)*%/!,5%!;#/#*+2$!&'!$#8+$C$!0,/C:,C/#4!I#/+#,+&)!&'!;%/0;%:,+I%06!!

[6 35%!#)#4<0+0!+0!*+/%:,%*!,&7#/*!*+0:&I%/<!&'!0+$+4#/+,+%0!D]1*$.!^!P$&&;!EFFF=EH!!

"#*!5$2%&!2'1*!$%!*%%*.&$,1!&0!,.)!%4$*.&$5$4!$.K'$2)?!"#*!%*40.(!#,%!320>*.!>*2)!

'%*5'1!502!&#$%!%3*4$5$4!%&'()?!"#*!4#,.6*!520-!&#*!@0'&%$(*2A!>$*C!520-!O($.9'26#!

&0! &#*! @$--*2%$0.A! $.!:20.$.6*.! #*13*(! &0! $-320>*! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! &#*! $%%'*;!

9'&! ,1%0! 5024*(! ,! 2*40.%$(*2,&$0.! 05! &#*! $.$&$,1! 2*%*,24#! K'*%&$0.?! "#*! K'*%&$0.=!

nP#,&!$.62*($*.&%!40'1(!#*13!%3**(!'3!&#*!$.$&$,1!%&,6*!05!,!3,2&$4$3,&02)!3204*%%o;!

C,%! &#*2*502*! ,1&*2*(! &0=! nL*6,2($.6! &#*! 50110C$.6! 42$&*2$,;! C#,&! 9,%*%! 502!

$-320>*(! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! $.! -,&4#$.6! 70.*%! 4,.! 9*! *%&,91$%#*(po! "#*!

2*%*,24#! 42$&*2$,! $.$&$,11)! *-310)*(! C*2*! &#*! 50'2! $M%! 32*%*.&*(! 9)! B$(,C,)j!

@$.$&$,&$0.;!$.41'%$>*.*%%;!$.502-,&$0.;!,.(!$.51'*.4*A!DEFFGH?!a0C*>*2;!('2$.6!&#*!

%&'();!9,%*(!0.!2*%30.(*.&%A!2*,4&$0.%;!$&!#,%!9**.!(*4$(*(!&#,&!&#*!$.&*.&$0.!3,2&!

05! $.$&$,&$0.! %#0'1(! 9*! %&,&*(!-02*! *+31$4$&1);! ,.(! %#0'1(! &#*2*502*! 9*40-*! &#*!

5$5&#!@$A?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! L'1*!&#2**!C,%!%,&$%5$*(!C$&#$.!&#*!40.%&2,$.&%!30%*(!9)!&$-*!,.(!2*%0'24*%?!

I,%$.6! &#*! %*-$M%&2'4&'2*(! $.&*2>$*C%! 0.! &#*! 42$&*2$,! 6$>*.! ,90>*;! $&! C,%!

,&&*-3&*(! &0! *+,-$.*! &#*!-,+$-'-!.'-9*2! 05! 30%%$91*!3*2%3*4&$>*%?!J1&#0'6#!

*,4#! 2*%30.(*.&!#,(!#$%!02!#*2!'.$K'*!3*2%3*4&$>*;! $.! &#*! ,.,1)%$%!3#,%*! $&!C,%!

! #"!

30%%$91*! &0! *1$4$&! -,$.! 1$.*%! 05! 2*,%0.$.6?! `Ab*,2)! %&,&*%! &#,&! &#*! %,&'2,&$0.!

&*4#.$K'*!502!&#020'6#!(,&,!4011*4&$0.!*.&,$1%=!!

J\+)+05+)2! :&44%:,+)2! *#,#! &)4<! 75%)! #**+,+&)#4! *#,#! )&! 4&)2%/! #**0! /+:5)%00! ,&!C)*%/0,#)*+)2!&/!#+*0!+)!>C+4*+)2!,5%&/+%0M!DEFUT=UVEH!!

[0.4*2.$.6! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! &#*! .,22,&$>*%! &#,&! #,>*! 9**.! 32*%*.&*(! $.! &#*!

$.&*2>$*C%! &#$%! 42$&*2$0.! 4,.! 9*! %,$(! &0! 9*! %,&$%5$*(?! a0C*>*2;! %$.4*! ('*! &0!

40.%&2,$.&%! 05! &$-*! $&! #,%! .0&! 9**.!30%%$91*! &0! $.&*2>$*C! %&,/*#01(*2%! 520-! *,4#!

3,2&! 05! &#*! %&,/*#01(*2! 40--'.$4,&$0.!-,3! DZ$6'2*! EH! $&! $%! $-30%%$91*! &0! ,26'*!

&#,&! .0&#$.6! #,%! 9**.! -$%%*(?! "#*2*502*;! $.! 5$6'2*! E;! 2*%30.(*.&%! #,>*! 9**.!

4010'2*(!2*(! D(,2/! $.!62*)M%4,1*!32$.&H;! %0! &#,&! &#*!2*,(*2!4,.! Q'(6*!0.!30&*.&$,1!

30%$&$0.,1! %'9Q*4&$>$&$*%?! "#*! .,-*%! 40..*4&*(! &0! &#*! %&,/*#01(*2! 40(*%! ,2*!

320>$(*(!$.!J33*.($+!S?!! !! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! "#*! 50'2&#! 2'1*! C,%! 50110C*(! 90&#! $.! &#*! $.&*2>$*C! ,.,1)%$%;! ,.(! $.! &#*!

40-3,2$%0.! C$&#! 1$&*2,&'2*?! W,$.! 1$.*%! 05! 3*24*3&$0.! C*2*! %0'6#&;! ,.(! $&! C,%!

4#*4/*(! C#*&#*2! &#*2*! C,%! ,62**-*.&! C$&#! 2*1*>,.&! 1$&*2,&'2*?! S.! 4,%*%! 05!

,62**-*.&! &#$%!C,%! ,44*3&*(;! ,.(! $.! 4,%*%! 05! ($%,62**-*.&! $&!C,%! ,&&*-3&*(! &0!

5$.(!0'&!$5!&#$%!($%,62**-*.&!40'1(!9*!*+31,$.*(?!<*+&!&0!&#$%;!%$-$1,2$&$*%!$.!.0.M

-,$.%&2*,-! >$*C%! C*2*! %0'6#&;! ,.(! 5$.,11)! &#*! >$*C%! 05! &#0%*! .0&! 5$&&$.6! ,.)!

4,&*602)!C*2*!.0&*(?!Z$.,11);!C#*.!&C0!0330%$.6!>$*C%!0.!&#*!3204*%%!#,(!9**.!

*1$4$&*(;!30%%$91*! %#,2*(! %01'&$0.%!C*2*! %0'6#&;! $.!C#$4#! $&!C,%!,&&*-3&*(! &0! 1*&!

*,4#!%$(*A%!@%&20.6!30$.&%A!40-31*-*.&!&#0%*!05!&#*!0&#*2?!]1*$.$.6!,.(!P$&&!DEFFFH!

%&,&*!&#,&!2*%*,24#!4,.!9*!2*6,2(*(!,%!>,1$(=!!

J+)! :#0%! )%7! I#/+#,+&)! &'! *#,#! #)*! ;%/0;%:,+I%0! 7+44! )&,! >/+)2! )%7! /%0C4,0! >C,!:&)'+/$! %8+0,+)2! &)%0ML! #)*! /%4+#>4%! +'! J#44! *#,#! :#)! >%! +$;C,%*! ,&! ,5%! 0#$%!:#,%2&/+%0M!DVH!

"#*)!,1%0!32030%*!,!@&*%&$.6!05!1$-$&%A!&0!%#0C!$.!C#$4#!2,.6*!&#*!2*%'1&%!,2*!>,1$(?!

"#$%!%&'()!($55*2%! 520-!&#*!>,1$($&)!,.(!2*1$,9$1$&)! &*%&%!,%!32030%*(!9)!]1*$.$.6!

,.(! P$&&! DEFFFH! $.! &#,&! $%! (0*%! .0&! %**/! &0! *%&,91$%#! 2*%'1&%! C$&#! &#$%! &)3*! 05!

! ##!

32*($4&$>*! >,1'*;! 9'&! $.%&*,(! &2$*%! &0! %#0C! &#*! 31'2,1$&)! 05! >$*C%! 32*%*.&! $.! &#*!

&)3*!05!3204*%%!%&'($*(?!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! #$!

4.3. Criteria of Evaluation

"#*! %&'()A%! %*-$M%&2'4&'2*(! $.&*2>$*C%! ,2*! 4*.&2*(! 0.! B$(,C,)A%! 42$&*2$,! 502!

%'44*%%5'1! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.k-*($,&$0.=! @$.$&$,&$0.;! $.41'%$>*.*%%;! $.502-,&$0.;! ,.(!

$.51'*.4*A!DEFFGH?!I,%*(!0.!&#*!$.&*2>$*C%;!@$.&*.&$0.A!C,%!,((*(!,%!,!5$5&#!42$&*2$0.?!

B&,&*-*.&%! 9)! 2*%30.(*.&%! %'3302&$.6! $&%! $.41'%$0.! 2*1,&*(! &0! &#*! $-302&,.4*! 05!

-,/$.6! &#*! *>,1',&$0.! 05! $.&*.&$0.! ,! -02*! *+31$4$&! 3,2&! 05! &#*! 32*M.*60&$,&$0.!

3#,%*?! Z'2&#*2-02*;! &#*! (,&,! $-31$*(! &#,&! $&!-$6#&! 9*! $-302&,.&! &0! $.42*,%*! &#*!

1*>*1!05!*>,1',&$0.!05!0C.!$.&*.&$0.;!,.(!05! &#*!3*24*3&$0.!05! &#$%!05!0&#*2%?!`.*!

2*,%0.!502!&#$%!$%!&#,&!,1&#0'6#!,!%&2'4&'2*!$%!C*11!%*&M'3!,.(!,!3,2&)!$%!32*3,2*(!

502! 10.6M&*2-! 40--$&-*.&;! 0&#*2! 3,2&$*%! -$6#&! .0&! 3*24*$>*! &#$%! ,%! 6*.'$.*?!

L*,%0.%! 502! &#$%! 40'1(! 9*! ,! #$%&02)! 05! 10C! 40--$&-*.&;! 02! D3,%&! ,.(H! 4'22*.&!

40--'.$4,&$>*! 5,$1'2*?! "#*! 5$>*! 2*%'1&$.6! 42$&*2$,! ,.(! &#*$2! %'9M42$&*2$,! ,2*!

%'--,2$%*(!$.!&#*!5$6'2*!U=!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! #%!

Criteria of analysis:

Figure 1. Criteria of analysis. DI,%*(!0.=!B$(,C,);!EFFG=lFH

o K),%),+&)!o ]5#,!&,5%/!Q,/#*+,+&)#4^!&;,+&)0!$+25,!>%!%$;4&<%*_!o H#I%! ,5%! Q+)+,+#,+)2X;#/,+:+;#,+)2^! ;#/,+%0! *%:+*%*! 75+:5! 0,%;0! &'! ,5%!

R2&I%/)$%),!;#/,+:+;#,+&)!4#**%/U!,5%<!#/%!7+44+)2!,&!C0%_!o H#I%!%8+,!0,/#,%2+%0!>%%)!:&)0+*%/%*_!!o H#I%!&,5%/0!2&,!,5%!/+25,!+$#2%!&'!<&C/!7+44+)2)%00!,&!;#/,+:+;#,%_!!

o K)+,+#,+&)!o 3%/$0!&'!/%'%/%):%!#)*!#2%)*#!

! H#0!,5%!;C/;&0%!#)*!'&/$!&'!,5%!%8%/:+0%!>%%)!#2/%%*!><!#44!;#/,+%0_!!! K0! ,5%! #2%)*#! >#4#):%*! ,&! :&I%/! ,5%! 'C44! /#)2%! &'! +00C%0L! &/! +0! +,!

:&)0,/#+)%*! ><! #! ;/%S%$;,+I%! ;&4+:<! &/! ;/&;&0+,+&)!$#*%! ><! ;&7%/'C4!+),%/%0,0_!

o K):4C0+I%)%00!o D%;/%0%),#,+&)!

! K0! ,5%! /%;/%0%),#,+&)! &'! +),%/%0,0! >#4#):%*! #,! %#:5! 4%I%4! &'! *%:+0+&)S$#E+)2_!!

o .::&C),#>+4+,<!! H&7!#::&C),#>4%!#/%!,5%!/%;/%0%),#,+I%0!,&!,5%+/!:&)0,+,C%):+%0_!

o T;%))%00!&'!#)*!+)I&4I%$%),!+)!*%:+0+&)S$#E+)26!!! ./%!#44!;5#0%0!&'!,5%!;/&:%00!&;%)!,&!#44!+),%/%0,!2/&C;0_!!! ]5#,!+0!,5%+/!*%2/%%!&'!+)I&4I%$%),!+)!%#:5!;5#0%_!

o K)'&/$#,+&)!! K0!+)'&/$#,+&)!'/%%4<!#I#+4#>4%!,&!#44!+),%/%0,0_!! H&7!&>?%:,+I%!+0!,5%! +)'&/$#,+&)L!5#0! +,!>%%)!2#,5%/%*!><! +)*%;%)*%),!

0&C/:%0_!! K0!,5%!+)'&/$#,+&)!:&I%/#2%!&'!+00C%0!%I%)4<!>#4#):%*_!!

o K)'4C%):%!o 1%4%2#,+&)!&'!#C,5&/+,<!+)!*%:+0+&)S$#E+)2!

! ]5&!5&4*0!,5%!;&7%/!,&!*%,%/$+)%!#)*X&/!%8%:C,%!*%:+0+&)0L!#)*!*&!#)<!+$>#4#):%0!&'!;&7%/!>%,7%%)!,5%!;#/,+%0!5+)*%/!,5%!;/&:%00_!!

! 3&!75#,!%8,%)*!5#0!#C,5&/+,<!>%%)!*%4%2#,%*! ,&!,5%!2/&C;!#)*!#/%!,5%!C4,+$#,%! *%:+0+&)S$#E%/0! :&$$+,,%*! ,&! +$;4%$%),! #)*! /%0&C/:%! ,5%!&C,:&$%0!#2/%%*!+)!,5+0!;/&:%00_!!

!

! #&!

4.4. Foreign, and Regional/Dutch Readers

"#*2*! $%! ,.! $-302&,.&! ($55*2*.4*! &0! 9*! .0&*(! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! 1$/*1)! 2*,($.6!

*+3*2$*.4*!05!2*,(*2%!520-!&#*!2*6$0.!05!&#*!4,%*!%&'();!8'&4#!2*,(*2%;!,.(!502*$6.!

2*,(*2%?! O+4*3&! 502! &#*! $.&*2>$*C*(! *,2&#K',/*! (,-,6*! 41,$-,.&%;! ,1-0%&! ,11!

2*%30.(*.&%! ,62**(! &0! #,>*! &#*$2! .,-*! ,&&,4#*(! &0! &#*$2! %&,&*-*.&%?! [0-9$.*(!

C$&#!,!(*%42$3&$0.!05!&#*$2!30%$&$0.!$.!&#*!3204*%%!$.!Z$6'2*!E!,.(!J33*.($+!S!&#$%!

%#0'1(! 6$>*! &#*! 2*,(*2! ,! 600(! 9,%$%! &0! *+,-$.*! &#*$2! %&,&*-*.&%! 502! 30%$&$0.,1!

%'9Q*4&$>$&)?! !a0C*>*2;!502!2*6$0.,1!02!8'&4#!2*,(*2%;!5'2&#*2!/.0C1*(6*!05!&#*$2!

026,.$%,&$0.;! 301$&$4,1! ,55$1$,&$0.;! ,.(! #$%&02)! ,((%! ,! 5'2&#*2! 1,)*2! &0! &#$%?!

Z'2&#*2-02*;! 502! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! $.! &#*! 4'22*.&! 3204*%%;! ($55*2*.4*%! $.! 03$.$0.!

32*%*.&*(! $.! &#$%! %&'()! 4,.! 502-! ,! 9,%$%! 502! $-320>*(! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6!

9*&C**.!&#0%*!$.>01>*(!$.!&#*!%'9Q*4&!4,%*!05!&#$%!%&'()?!! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;! C#*.! 40--*.&$.6! 0.! ,! 2*%30.(*.&A%! %&,&*-*.&%! 4$&*(! $.! &#$%!

($%%*2&,&$0.! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &0! .0&*! &#,&! ,11! %&,&*-*.&%! ,2*! 3,2&! 05! -'4#! 1,26*2!

.,22,&$>*%;!,.(!&#,&!&#*)!#,>*!9**.!%*1*4&*(!,.(!$.&*232*&*(!9)!-*?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!

('*! &0! &#*! 3204*%%A! #$6#! 2,&*! 05! 4#,.6*;! ,&! &#*! &$-*! 05! 3'91$4,&$0.! $&! $%! .0&!

'.&#$./,91*! &#,&! ,&! 1*,%&! %0-*! 2*%30.(*.&%! #,>*! ,1&*2*(! &#*$2! >$*C! 2*6,2($.6!

4*2&,$.!$%%'*%?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! #'!

4.5. Stakeholder Analysis

P#*.! ($%4'%%$.6! %&,/*#01(*2! ,.,1)%$%! B$(,C,)! DEFFGH! %&,&*%! &#,&! ,4402($.6! &0!

B'%%/$.(!,.(![2'$/%#,./!DUdelH!&#*2*!,2*!50'2!&)3*%!05!%&,/*#01(*2%;!1$/*1)!&0!9*!

$(*.&$5$*(!$.!,.!*.>$20.-*.&,1!40.51$4&?!"#*%*!,2*=!!

W6 J,5&0%!7+,5!:4#+$0!,&!4%2#4!;/&,%:,+&)N!Y6 ,5&0%!7+,5!;&4+,+:#4!:4&C,N!Z6 ,5&0%!7+,5!,5%!;&7%/!,&!>4&:E!)%2&,+#,%*!#2/%%$%),0N![6 ,5&0%!7+,5!$&/#4!:4#+$0!,&!;C>4+:!0<$;#,5<M!DllH!!

J.0&#*2! (*5$.$&$0.! 6$>*.! 9)! B$(,C,)! $%! &#,&! 05! P$140+! DUddTH?! P$140+! (*5$.*%!

%&,/*#01(*2%!,%!&#0%*!C#0!!

J5#I%!#)!+),%/%0,!+)!75#,!5#;;%)0!>%:#C0%!,5%<!7+44!>%!#''%:,%*!><!,5%!&C,:&$%!&/!:#)!5#I%!0&$%!+)'4C%):%!&)!+,M!D$.!B$(,C,);!EFFG=VeH!! ! !

N%$.6!*$&#*2!(*5$.$&$0.;!,11!&#0%*!1$>$.6!$.!&#*!2*6$0.!,.(!&#0%*!C$&#!,!301$&$4,1!02!

5$.,.4$,1!%&,/*!,%%04$,&*(!C$&#!$&!4,.!1*6$&$-,&*1)!41,$-!&0!9*!%&,/*#01(*2%?!"#$%!$%!

,!>*2)! 1,26*!,.(!($>*2%*!620'3;!,.(!,.)!%*1*4&$0.!05!,!-,.,6*,91*! %,-31*! 502!,!

%&'()!$.*>$&,91)!1*,>*%!-,.)!'.#*,2(?!! ! ! ! ! !

! `.*! 30%%$9$1$&)! 05! 1$-$&$.6! %,-31*! %$7*! C0'1(! 9*! &0! .0&! 504'%! 0.! ,11!

%&,/*#01(*2%;!9'&!0.1)!0.!&#0%*!C#0!31,)*(!,!201*!$.!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!&#*!&#2**!

2*302&%!&#,&!#,>*!1*(!&0!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*A%!*%&,91$%#-*.&!DW*$Q*2!*&!,1?;!EFUVj!>,.!

:**1!^!P,11,6*;! EFUTj! ,.(!R0a^a>R;! EFUT,H?!a0C*>*2;! 1$-$&$.6! &#*! %,-31*! &0!

&#*%*! %&,/*#01(*2%! 42*,&*%! &#*! (,.6*2! 05! *+,4*29,&$.6! 30&*.&$,1! *+$%&$.6! 9$,%*%;!

-$%%$.6! >,1',91*! $.3'&! 520-! @0'&%$(*2%A;! ,.(! -0%&1)! #*,2$.6! &#*! 3*2%3*4&$>*! 05!

@'%',1!%'%3*4&%A!D`Ab*,2);!EFUTH?!"#*2*502*;!&#*!,$-!05!&#*!%&,/*#01(*2!,.,1)%$%!#,%!

9**.! &0! -,/*! &#*! %,-31*! ,%! C$(*! ,.(! >,2$*(! ,%! 30%%$91*?! S.! 02(*2! &0! (0! %0;! ,!

.*&C02/$.6!,.,1)%$%!C$&#!>,2$0'%! %&,2&$.6!30$.&%!C,%!*-310)*(! D`Ab*,2);! EFUTH?!

J4402($.6!&0!`Ab*,2);!.*&C02/$.6!-*&#0(0106);!$.!C#$4#!&#*!%,-31*!$%!*+3,.(*(!

9,%*(!0.!,(>$%*%!$.!*,21$*2!$.&*2>$*C%;!4,.!9*!>*2)!'%*5'1!$.!5$.($.6!%&,/*#01(*2%!

! #(!

&#,&!&#*!$.$&$,1!,.,1)%$%!#,%!-$%%*(;!%,>$.6!&$-*;!,.(!$.!2*,4#$.6!%&,/*#01(*2%!&#,&!

-$6#&! 0&#*2C$%*! #,>*! 9**.!($55$4'1&! &0! 40.&,4&! DEFUTH?!a0C*>*2;! %#*! ,1%0! ,26'*%!

&#,&!'%*!05!&#$%!-*&#0(0106)!#,%!&#*!(,.6*2!05!*%&,91$%#$.6!,!%,-31*!9$,%*(!0.!&#*!

3*2%3*4&$>*!05!&#*!$.$&$,1!2*%30.(*.&%?!"#*2*502*;!&#$%!-*&#0(0106)!#,%!9**.!'%*(!

$.! 40-9$.,&$0.!C$&#!-'1&$31*! %&,2&$.6! 30$.&%;! ,.(! .0! $.&*2>$*C!#,%! 1*(! &0!-02*!

&#,.!&C0!0&#*2!$.&*2>$*C%?!"#*%*!%&,2$.6!30$.&%!C*2*!9,%*(!0.!&#*!,.,1)%$%!05!&#*!

%&,/*#01(*2!40--'.$4,&$0.!-,3!D5$6'2*!EH!,.(!0.!,&&*.($.6!*>*.&%!2*1,&*(!&0!&#*!

4,%*! %&'()?!"0! $11'%&2,&*!#0C!C*11! &#$%! ,3320,4#!#,%! %'44**(*(! $.! 2*%'1&$.6! $.! ,!

9,1,.4*(! %,-31*;! $.! &#*! 50110C$.6! 5$6'2*! &#*! %&,/*#01(*2! %&2'4&'2*! #,%! 9**.!

-,33*(;!,.(!2*%30.(*.&%!#,>*!9**.! $.($4,&*(! $.!2*(!D(,2/! $.!62*)M%4,1*!32$.&%H?!

J33*.($+!S! 1$%&%! &#*!2*%30.(*.&%!,.(!&#*! 1*&&*2!02!.'-9*2! $.!520.&!05! &#*$2!.,-*!

4,.!40..*4&!&#*-!&0!&#*$2!31,4*!0.!&#*!%&,/*#01(*2!40--'.$4,&$0.!-,3?!

Stakeholder Communication Map

Figure 2. Stakeholder communication map with respondents indicated in red.

! #)!

4.6. Interviews

"#$%! %&'()! $%! 9,%*(! 0.! &C*.&)M&#2**! %*-$M%&2'4&'2*(! $.&*2>$*C%;! &C0! 05! C#$4#!

$.41'(*(! &C0! 2*%30.(*.&%?! "#*2*502*! &#*! $.3'&! 05! &C*.&)M5$>*! 2*%30.(*.&%! #,%!

9**.!$.41'(*(!$.!&#$%!%&'()?!W0%&!$.&*2>$*C%!C*2*!40.('4&*(!$.!3*2%0.;!9'&!('*!&0!

&$-*!40.%&2,$.&%!02!($%&,.4*!%0-*!C*2*!40.('4&*(!9)!3#0.*?!W0%&!$.&*2>$*C%!C*2*!

9,%*(!0.!,!8'&4#!>*2%$0.!05! &#*! %42$3&! $.41'(*(! $.!J33*.($+!RS;! 9'&! *+4*3&$0.%!

C*2*!-,(*!(*3*.($.6!0.!&#*!30%$&$0.!05! &#*!2*%30.(*.&!,.(!&#*!32062*%%!05! &#*!

%&'()?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! "#*! $.&*2>$*C%!C*2*!2*402(*(!,.(!%'9%*K'*.&1)!%'--,2$%*(?!J1&#0'6#! $&!

#,%! 9**.! ,&&*-3&*(! &0! %&,)! ,%! 410%*! &0! &#*! 02$6$.,1! %&,&*-*.&%! ,%! 30%%$91*;! %0-*!

200-! 502! 3,2,3#2,%$.6! C,%! ,110C*(?! "#*! Q'%&$5$4,&$0.%! 502! &#$%! ,2*! ($55*2*.4*%!

9*&C**.!%30/*.!,.(!C2$&&*.!1,.6',6*;!,.(!&#*!510C!05!&#*!%&,&*-*.&%?!"0!*.%'2*!

&#,&! &#*! 2*%'1&$.6! &2,.%42$3&%! %&,)*(! &2'*! &0! &#*$2! 02$6$.,1! $.&*.&;! *,4#! &2,.%42$3&!

C,%! %*.&! &0! *,4#! 2*%3*4&$>*! 2*%30.(*.&! 502! ,3320>,1?! I)! &#*! &$-*! 05! 32$.&$.6;!

*+4*3&!502!&#*!$.&*2>$*C!&2,.%42$3&!05!P,11,6*;!,11!&2,.%42$3&%!C*2*!,3320>*(!05!>$,!

*-,$1;!02!2*&'2.*(!$.!*($&*(!502-?!"2,.%42$3&%!C*2*!$.!8'&4#;!,.(!0.1)!%&,&*-*.&%!

&#,&! ,2*! 4$&*(! $.! &#$%! 2*302&! #,>*! 9**.! &2,.%1,&*(! $.&0! O.61$%#?! "#*! 2*%30.(*.&%!

#,>*!.0&!4#*4/*(!&#*%*!&2,.%1,&$0.%?! ! ! ! ! !

! <*+&! &0!320>$($.6!&#*!03302&'.$&)! &0!4#*4/!&#*! &2,.%42$3&;!,11! 2*%30.(*.&%!

#,>*! 2*4*$>*(! ,! 502-!(*&,$1$.6! &#*! &*2-%! 05! (,&,! '%*;! $.41'($.6!-)!32062,--*!

%*42*&,2)A%! 40.&,4&! (*&,$1%;! ,.(! &#0%*! 05! &#*! O&#$4%! [0--$&&**! 05! &#*! B4#001! 05!

:*0%4$*.4*%?!"#$%! 502-!,1%0! $.41'(*(!,!4$&,&$0.!,62**-*.&;!,.(!2*%30.(*.&%!#,(!

&#*! 4#0$4*! ,%! &0! C#*&#*2! &0! %$6.! &#*! 8'&4#! 02! &#*! O.61$%#! >*2%$0.;! 104,&*(! 0.!

0330%$&*!%$(*%!05!&#*!3,6*%?!J11!2*%30.(*.&%!#,>*!%$6.*(!&#$%!502-;!,.(!-0%&!#,>*!

,62**(! &0!#,>*! &#*$2!.,-*! $.41'(*(! $.! &#$%! 2*302&?!J!403)!05! &#$%! 502-!#,%!9**.!

$.41'(*(!$.!J33*.($+!RSS?!!!

! $+!

4.7. Ethics

J%! %&,&*(! $.! &#*! 32*>$0'%! %*4&$0.;! ,11! 2*%30.(*.&%! #,>*! #,(! &#*! 30%%$9$1$&)! 05!

2*>$*C$.6! ,.(! *($&$.6! &#*! &2,.%42$3&! 05! &#*$2! 2*%3*4&$>*! $.&*2>$*C;! ,.(! ,11! #,>*!

%$6.*(!,.!$.502-*(!40.%*.&!502-!DJ33*.($+!RSSH?! ! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;!,%!,26'*(!9)!`Ab*,2)!DEFUTH;!,!3*2%$%&$.6!32091*-!$%!*.%'2$.6!&#*!

40.5$(*.&$,1$&)!05!,.0.)-0'%!%0'24*%?!b'4/$1);!-0%&!2*%30.(*.&%!,62**(! &0!#,>*!

&#*$2!.,-*!$.41'(*(!$.!&#$%!2*302&;!,.(!40..*4&*(!&0!&#*$2!%&,&*-*.&%?![0.4*2.$.6!

&#*! 4$&,&$0.! 05! ,.0.)-0'%! %0'24*%! `Ab*,2)! ,26'*%! &#,&! %$&',&$0.,1! (*%42$3&$0.%!

6$>*.!9)!2*%30.(*.&%!4,.!05&*.!-,/*!$(*.&$5$4,&$0.!*,%)?!"#*2*502*;!.0!%&,&*-*.&%!

2*1,&$.6!&0!&#*!,.0.)-0'%!2*%30.(*.&%A!%$&',&$0.!#,>*!9**.!$.41'(*(;!,.(!$5!4$&*(;!

0.1)! %&,&*-*.&%!C*2*! '%*(! &#,&!C*2*! 05! ,!-02*! 6*.*2,1! .,&'2*?! [0.4*2.$.6! &#*!

2*%30.(*.&%! C#0! C*2*! $.&*2>$*C*(! 9*4,'%*! 05! &#*$2! *+3*2$*.4*%! ,%! >$4&$-%! 05!

*,2&#K',/*! (,-,6*! $&! #,%! 9**.! (*4$(*(! &0! /**3! ,11! (,&,! ,.0.)-0'%?! <0&! ,11!

$.($4,&*(! ,! 32*5*2*.4*! &0! 2*-,$.! ,.0.)-0'%;! 9'&! ('*! &0! &#*! 2*1,&$>*1)! %-,11!

.'-9*2! 05! 2*%30.(*.&%! 05! &#$%! &)3*! $&! #,%! 9**.! (**-*(! *%%*.&$,1! 502! &#*!

40.5$(*.&$,1$&)!05!,.0.)-0'%!%0'24*%!&0!,331)!6*.*2,1!,.0.)-$&)!502!&#$%!620'3?!!

! S.! 02(*2! &0! *.%'2*! ($6$&,1! %,5*&)! 05! 2*402($.6%! ,.(! '.5$.$%#*(! &2,.%42$3&%!

&#,&!C*2*!%&02*(!0.!,! 1,3&03!,.(!9,4/*(!'3!0.!,!'%9M%&$4/!,.(!,.!*+&*2.,1!#,2(!

(2$>*;! &2,.%42$3&%!,.(!2*402($.6%!C*2*!40(*(!C$&#!,!.'-9*2;!,.(!&#*!/*)!&0!&#$%!

C,%!%&02*(!%*3,2,&*1)!0.!3,3*2?!W0%&!40.&,4&!C,%!>$,!*-,$1;!9'&!(0!&0!&#*!.,&'2*!

05! &#*! %&'()! ,.(! $&%! (,&,! .0! ,(($&$0.,1!-*,%'2*%! 40.4*2.$.6!($6$&,1! %,5*&)! #,>*!

9**.!&,/*.?!a0C*>*2;!,%!2*K'*%&*(!9)!0.*!,.0.)-0'%!2*%30.(*.&;!&#*!30%%$9$1$&)!

05! -,$1$.6! ,! 3,3*2! 403)! 05! &#*! $.502-*(! 40.%*.&! 502-! C,%! 055*2*(?! Z$.,11);!

2*%30.(*.&%! #,>*! 9**.! 055*2*(! &#*! 03&$0.! 05! (*-,.($.6! ,'($0! 5$1*%! '%*(! &0!

,.,1)%*!&#*!$.&*2>$*C%!&0!9*!(*1*&*(!&C*1>*!-0.&#%!,5&*2!&#*!2*302&A%!%'9-$%%$0.?!

W0%&!#,>*!$.($4,&*(!&#,&!&#*)!C0'1(!1$/*!&#$%!&0!#,33*.;!,.(!&#*2*502*!,11!,'($0!

5$1*%!C$11!9*!(*1*&*(!9)!&#*.?! !

! $*!

5. Context of the Case Study

5.1. Introduction

S.!&#$%!4#,3&*2!&#*!40.51$4&!#$%&02$4,1!9,4/620'.(!,.(!&#*!.,&'2*!05!&#*!*,2&#K',/*%!

,2*!%'--,2$%*(?!I0&#!,2*!$-302&,.&!&0!'.(*2%&,.(!&#*!40.&*+&!05!&#*!($,106'*;!)*&!

%$.4*!&#$%!%&'()!504'%*%!0.!&#*!3*24*$>*(!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!42$&*2$,;!,.(!,!%'--,2)!05!

90&#! %'55$4*%! 502! &#$%!3'230%*?!J5&*2! &#*%*;! &#*!-,$.!(04'-*.&%! ,.(! ,62**-*.&%!

1*,($.6!&0!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!,2*!*+,-$.*(?!"#*%*!#,>*!#,(!,!-,Q02!$-3,4&!0.!&#*!

",91*A%! 5$2%&!-0.&#%!,.(! &#*2*502*! &#*)!C$11!9*!32*%*.&*(!%*3,2,&*1)?![0.4*2.$.6!

&#*!4,%*!%&'();!&#*!50110C$.6!#,%!9**.!C2$&&*.!$.!&#*!$.&*2.,&$0.,1!-*($,=!

• <q";!X'.*!T&#;!EFUT=!J.!2#0!:#:5%L!)&7!C)*%/!05#E<!2/&C)*6M!• <q";!W,24#!Ef&#;!EFUV=!J9#/,0!&'!,5%!4&7!:&C),/<!#/%!)&7!#!VC#E%!:&C),/<6M!• c*$&;!Z*92',2)!Ue&#;!EFUV=!J]%))!*+%!=/*%!3`24+:5!A%>,6M!• S.6*.$*'2;! X'1)! UE&#;! EFUT=! J@#0'a/*%/C)2! I%/C/0#:5,! =/*>%>%)0%/+%! +)! *%)!"+%*%/4#)*%)6M!

• II[;!W,)!Ud&#;!EFUV=!J@/&)+)2%)!2#0!'+%4*0!b!35%!1C,:5!%#/,5VC#E%!O&)%!• "*1*62,3#;! X'1)!G&#;!EFUV=!J=#/,5VC#E%0!'/&$!&)05&/%!2#0!*/+44+)2!,5/%#,%)!#!*+0#0,%/L!7#/)!/%0+*%),0!&'!1C,:5!:+,<6M!!

• PBX;!W,24#!El&#;!EFUV=!J1C,:5!5&C0%0!05+I%/!#$+*!2#0S'+%4*!VC#E%06M!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! $"!

5.2. History

"#*!<*&#*21,.(%!#,%!,! 10.6!#$%&02)!05! 2*%0'24*!*+&2,4&$0.;!,.(!%0-*!*>*.!,26'*!

&#,&! &#*!8'&4#!L*3'91$4! 05! &#*! Ul&#! 4*.&'2)!C,%! &#*!C021(A%! 5$2%&! &2'*! 50%%$1! 5'*1!

9,%*(!*40.0-)!DW,,%!^![04K')&;!EFUUH?!S&!C,%!90&#!,!%#02&,6*!05!5$2*C00(;!,.(!

&#*!%'$&,9$1$&)!05!&#*!1,.(%4,3*!&#,&!1*(!&0!&#*!1,26*M%4,1*!*+310$&,&$0.!05!3*,&?!Z$2%&;!

410%*!&0!4$&$*%;!9'&!1,&*2;!,5&*2!40.%&2'4&$.6!*%3*4$,11)!('6!4,.,1%!,1%0!$.!2'2,1!,2*,%!

%'4#!,%!&#*!:20.$.6*2!G%%)E&4&)+%)!D\*,&![010.$*%H?!"#0'6#!&#*!-,6.$&'(*!05!&#$%!

5'*1A%!$-302&,.4*!&0!&#*!L*3'91$4A%!320%3*20'%!:01(*.!J6*!$%!(*9,&,91);!$&%!1*6,4)!

05!4,.,1%!,.(!10.6!%&2$.6M1$/*!>$11,6*%!$%!%&$11!32*%*.&!$.!&#*!<*&#*21,.(%!05!&#*!EU%&!

4*.&'2)!DW,,%!^![04K')&;!EFUUH?!!! ! ! ! ! ! !

! S.!UdGd!.,&'2,1!6,%!C,%!50'.(!.*,2!&#*!:20.$.6*2!&0C.!05!B104#&*2*.;!,.(!

&#0'6#!#,>$.6!9**.!*+&2,4&*(!%$.4*!UdfV;! $.!EFUE! $&!

%&$11!320>$(*(!&#* %&,&*!C$&#!,!2*>*.'*!05!-02*!&#,.!

UT! 9$11$0.! *'20! D>,.! :**1! ^! P,11,6*;! EFUTH?! "#$%!

$.40-*!#,%!.0&!,1C,)%!9*.*5$&&*(!*>*2)0.*;!,.(! $.!

UdeE![02(*.!,.(!<*,2)!3'91$%#*(!,!3,3*2!$.!C#$4#!

&#*)! ($%4'%%*(! C#,&! &#*)! 40$.*(! @8'&4#! 8$%*,%*Aj!

&#*!30&*.&$,1!#,2-5'1!*55*4&%!05!,!900-!$.!50%%$1!5'*1!

*+302&%!0.!,!%-,11!03*.!*40.0-)A%!$.('%&2$,1!%*4&02?!

O>*.!9*502*!&#*!,(>*.&!05!*3$%0(*!05!@8'&4#!8$%*,%*A!

&#*2*! C*2*! &#0%*! C#0! C,2.*(! &#,&! 6,%! *+&2,4&$0.!

40'1(! 1*,(! &0! %0$1! %'9%$(*.4*;!,%!*+*-31$5$*(! $.! &#*!

Figure 3 Soil Subsidence!!! !!!!50110C$.6!40-$4!520-!&#*!b**'C,2(*2![0'2,.&!05!!

! ! ! ! !!!!X,.',2)!UU&#;!UdlE?!"#*!40-$4!2*,(%=!

!J9/&I+):%! ;#<0! :4&0%! #,,%),+&)! ,&! 0&+4! 0C>0+*%):%! #0! #! /%0C4,! &'! 2#0! %8,/#:,+&)c!<&C!5#I%!,&!;#<!:4&0%!#,,%),+&)!,&!,5%!5&/+O&)M!!

! $#!

"#*!%0$1!($(!$.(**(!%'9%$(*;!$.!UdeT!&#*!@(&$$+00+%!A&*%$*#4+)2U!D[0--$%%$0.!502!

B0$1! B'9%$(*.4*H! C,%! 50'.(*(;! ,.(! %$.4*! &#*.! &#$%! 40--$%%$0.! #,%! C02/*(! 0.!

40-3*.%,&$.6! &#*! #,2-5'1! *55*4&%! 05! %0$1! %'9%$(*.4*;! 90&#! 9)! 40--$%%$0.$.6!

$.52,%&2'4&'2*! $-320>*-*.&%;! ,.(! 9)! 40-3*.%,&$.6! (,-,6*! &0! 3203*2&)!

D[0--$%%$*!I0(*-(,1$.6;!EFUTH?!!! ! ! ! ! !

! S.!Udef!&#*!5$2%&!6,%!320('4&$0.!$.('4*(!*,2&#K',/*!C,%!*+3*2$*.4*(!.*,2!

J%%*.! D>,.! (*2! B1'$%;! UddlH?! a0C*>*2;! $&! &00/! '.&$1! UddV! 9*502*! <JW!

,4/.0C1*(6*(!&#*!30%%$9$1$&)!05!,!4,'%,1!40..*4&$0.!9*&C**.!6,%!320('4&$0.!,.(!

*,2&#K',/*%! D>,.! (*2! B1'$%;! UddlH?! B$.4*! &#*.;! &#*! 2*6$0.! #,%! *+3*2$*.4*(!

,3320+$-,&*1)! UFFF! *,2&#K',/*%! D]<WS;! EFUVH?! a0C*>*2;! $&! C,%! 0.1)! ,5&*2! &#*!

*,2&#K',/*!05!a'$7$.6*!0.!J'6'%&!Uf&#!EFUE!&#,&!320&*%&!62*C!&0!,!%'9%&,.&$,1!%$7*!

D"20'C;!EFUTH?!\0%%$91);!,.! $-302&,.&! 4,&,1)%&! 502! &#$%!320&*%&!C,%! &#*!410%$.6!05!

J1(*1;! ,.! ,1'-$.$'-! %-*1&*2! $.! 8*157$Q1! ,.(! ,! -,Q02! *-310)*2?! J! -,$.! 2*,%0.!

320>$(*(! 502! &#*! %-*1&*2A%! 410%$.6! 40.4*2.*(! '.40-3*&$&$>*! *1*4&2$4$&)! 32$4*%!

40-3,2*(! &0! &#0%*! *.Q0)*(! 9)! 40-3*&$&02%! ,920,(;! ,%! 410%*! ,%! :*2-,.)!

DR01/%/2,.&;!EFUTH?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! S.! &#*! 2*6$0.! C#0%*! .,&'2,1! C*,1&#! 320('4*%! -0%&! 05! &#*! <*&#*21,.(%A!

*.*26);! &#$%! C,%! 2*4*$>*(! >*2)! 9,(1)! DZ2*(*2$/;! EFUTH?! S.! 2*,4&$0.! &0! $.42*,%$.6!

320&*%&! ,.(! &0! *%&,91$%#! &#*! 9,%$%! 502! ,! 10.6M&*2-! %01'&$0.! &#*! 320>$.4$,1!

60>*2.-*.&!05!:20.$.6*.!40--$%%$0.*(!&#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.!&0!$.>*%&$6,&*!&#*!

%$&',&$0.?!"#$%!C,%!&#*!%&,2&!05!&#*!3204*%%!&#,&!#,%!1*(!&0!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!&#*!

8$,106'*!",91*?!"#*!2*302&!05!&#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.;!,.(!%'9%*K'*.&!2*302&%!,.(!

,62**-*.&%;!C$11!9*!*+,-$.*(!$.!%*4&$0.!G?T?!!

!

!

!

! $$!

5.3. Gas Production Induced Earthquakes

"#*! L0),1! 8'&4#! W*&*020106$4,1! S.%&$&'&*! D]<WSH! #,%! 9**.! 2*6$%&*2$.6!

*,2&#K',/*%!%$.4*!Udef!D<JW;!EFUT,H?!"#*!.,&'2,1!6,%!320('4*(!$.!:20.$.6*.!$%!

104,&*(! $.! ,! 3020'%! %,.(%&0.*! 1,)*2! ,&! ,! (*3&#! 05! ,3320+$-,&*1)! V! /$10-*&2*%?!

P#*.!6,%! $%! *+&2,4&*(!32*%%'2*! $.! &#$%! 1,)*2! $%! 10C*2*(!,.(! $&! %&,2&%! &0! 40-3,4&;!

1*,($.6!&0!%0$1!%'9%$(*.4*?!S5!&#*!40-3,4&$0.!044'2%!,&!.,&'2,1!Z,'1&!b$.*%!&*.%$0.!

-$6#&! 9'$1(! ,.(! &#*.! 9*! 2*1*,%*(! %'((*.1)?! "#$%! %'((*.! %#$5&! 42*,&*%! ,.!

*,2&#K',/*?!"#*!6*0106$4,1!%$&',&$0.!&#$%!044'2%!$.!$%!>$%',1$%*(!$.!5$6'2*!T=!!

! Gas Production Induced Earthquakes

!

Figure 4. Gas Production Induced Earthquakes in Groningen.!D<JW;!EFUT,H!

Z$6'2*!T!%#0C%!&#,&!&#*%*!*,2&#K',/*%!,2*!&#*!2*%'1&!05!&2,($&$0.,1!6,%!320('4&$0.?!

"#0'6#! <JW! #,%! ,331$*(! #)(2,'1$4! 52,4&'2$.6! &0! $-320>*! &#*! 510C! 05! %-,11*2!

! $%!

5$*1(%! $.! &#*$2! 5$.,1! %&,6*!05!320('4&$0.;! &#$%! $%!.0&! &#*!02$6$.!05! &#*! *,2&#K',/*%!

4'22*.&1)!9*$.6!*+3*2$*.4*(!D<JW;!EFUT9H?!! ! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ! ! ! !

! $&!

5.4. Main documents and Agreements

5.4.1. Meijer et al., (2013)

J1%0!/.0C.!,%=!

G%/,/&C7%)!+)!%%)!1CC/O#$%!3&%E&$0,-!=%)!B,%I+2!9%/0;%:,+%'!I&&/!"&&/*ST&0,!

@/&)+)2%)!

S.!O.61$%#=!

a,>$.6!5,$&#!$.!,!%'%&,$.,91*!5'&'2*=!,!%01$(!3*2%3*4&$>*!502!<02&#MO,%&!:20.$.6*.!

J5&*2!&#*!*,2&#K',/*!05!a'$7$.6*!0.!J'6'%&!Uf&#!EFUE;!&#*!\20>$.4*!05!:20.$.6*.!

40--$%%$0.*(! &#*! 2*302&! G%/,/&C7%)! +)! %%)! 1CC/O#$%! 3&%E&$0,-! =%)! B,%I+2!

9%/0;%:,+%'!I&&/!"&&/*ST&0,!@/&)+)2%)! DW*$Q*2!*&!,1;! EFUVH?!"#$%! 2*302&!C,%!C2$&&*.!

9)! &#*! (&$$+00+%! 1CC/O#$%! 3&%E&$0,! "&&/*ST&0,! @/&)+)2%)! D[0--$%%$0.!

B'%&,$.,91*! Z'&'2*! <02&#MO,%&! :20.$.6*.Hj! ,1%0! /.0C.! ,%! &#*! (&$$+00+%! F%+?%/!

DW*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.H?!"#*!2*K'*%&!&#*!40--$%%$0.!60&!C,%!&#*!50110C$.6=!!

JD%#0&)! +'L! #)*! ,&! 75+:5! *%2/%%! &)%! :#)! 0;%#E! &'! *+0#*I#),#2%! +)! ,5%! /%2+&)! +)!75+:5! ,5%! %''%:,0! &'!2#0!;/&*C:,+&)!#/%!)&7!)&,+:%#>4%6!.)07%/! ,5%!VC%0,+&)!5&7!,5%! 4&00! &'! I#4C%! :#)! >%! /%0,&/%*! '&/! :+,+O%)0L! :&$;#)+%0! #)*! :&$$C)+,+%06! 35+0!VC%0,+&)!*&%0!)&,!:&):%/)!*+/%:,!%#/,5VC#E%!*#$#2%N! ,5+0!:#)!#)*!05&C4*!>%!*%#4,!7+,5! I+#! /%2C4#/! ;/&:%*C/%06! "&/! +0! ,5%! :&$$+00+&)! #0E%*! ,&! VC#),+'<! +)*+/%:,!*#$#2%L! 4&00! &'! d;/&;%/,<e! I#4C%L! &/! *+0#*I#),#2%! '&/! +)*+I+*C#4! :+,+O%)0! &/!:&$;#)+%06! 3&! ,5%! &/*%/! +0! 5&7! ,5%! 'C,C/%! ;%/0;%:,+I%L! ,5%! +$#2%L! :&)*+,+&)0! &'!0%,,4%$%),L! #)*! VC#4+,<! &'! %8;%/+%):%! :#)! >%! 0C0,#+)#>4<! +$;/&I%*! #)*! 75+:5!$%#0C/%0!05&C4*!>%!,#E%)6!35%0%!$%#0C/%0!05&C4*!:&),/+>C,%!,&!,5%!7+05%*!%)%/2<!,/#)0+,+&)M!DW*$Q*2!*&!,1;!EFUV=eH!!

I,%*(!0.!(07*.%!05!40.>*2%,&$0.%!C$&#!$.#,9$&,.&%;!*.&2*32*.*'2%;!026,.$%,&$0.%;!

,(-$.$%&2,&02%;! ,.(! %&,/*#01(*2%! #*1(! 9*&C**.! X'.*! ,.(! `4&09*2! EFUV! &#*!

40--$%%$0.!32030%*(! &#*! &C*1>*!-*,%'2*%!($>$(*(! $.! &#*! 50110C$.6!32062,--*!

1$.*%=!

! $'!

• 89#$'#+::(!,&%(!;<!B#'%,<!#)*!'C,C/%!0%:C/+,<!'&/!+)*+I+*C#4!+)5#>+,#),0!#)*!%),/%;/%)%C/0!

• 9#$'#+::(!,&%(!=<!!fC#4+,<!&'!4+I+)2S!#)*!7&/E!%)I+/&)$%),!!

• 9#$'#+::(!,&%(!><!BC0,#+)#>4%!%:&)&$+:!;%/0;%:,+I%!'&/!,5%!/%2+&)!

• ?(@!A%B(#4-+%B&%'!F%#0C/%!WY-!! 1+#4&2C%!3#>4%!#,!75+:5L!C)*%/!,5%!0C;%/I+0+&)!&'!#)!!! ! ! +)*%;%)*%),!:5#+/$#)L!".FL!=:&)&$+:!.''#+/0L!#)*!!! ! ! 0,#E%5&4*%/0!'/&$!,5%!/%2+&)!:&S:/%#,%!#*I+:%0!/%2#/*+)2!!! ! ! 2#0!;/&*C:,+&)!+)!/%4#,+&)!,&L!#$&)20,!&,5%/0L!0#'%,<!#)*!!! ! ! 'C,C/%!0%:C/+,<!'&/!,5%!/%2+&)U0!+)5#>+,#),0!#)*!! !! ! ! %),/%;/%)%C/0M!DW*$Q*2!*&!,1?!EFUV=lH!!

"#*!5'11!1$%&!05!32030%*(!-*,%'2*%!$%!$.41'(*(!$.!J33*.($+!SSS?!

!

!

!

! $(!

5.4.2. Verklaring van Huizinge (2013)

S.!O.61$%#=!!

8*41,2,&$0.!05!a'$7$.6*!

`.! <0>*-9*2! UG&#! EFUV! &#*!G%/E4#/+)2! I#)! HC+O+)2%! C,%! %$6.*(! 9)! ,! 1,26*! ,.(!($>*2%*!620'3!05!%&,/*#01(*2%?!\,2&!05!&#*!(*41,2,&$0.!2*,(%=!!

J35%!:&$$+00+&)!dF%+?%/e!5#0!&>0%/I%*!,5#,!,5%!,/C0,!&'!,5%!+)5#>+,#),0!5#0!>%%)!I+&4#,%*6!35%!#47#<0S;/%0%),!#::%;,#):%!&'!2#0!;/&*C:,+&)!5#0!>%%)!0%I%/%4<!*#$#2%*6!B#'%,<L!/%0,&/#,+&)!&'!,/C0,!#)*!#!)%7!'C,C/%!;%/0;%:,+I%!#/%!&'!%00%),+#4!+$;&/,#):%!,&!/%0,&/%!;C>4+:!0C;;&/,6!35%!:&$$+00+&)!#*I+0%0!,5%!%0,#>4+05$%),!&'!#)!&;%)!*+#4&2C%!+)!,5%!/%2+&)!,&!0#'%2C#/*!,5+06!]%!0C>0:/+>%!,&!,5+0!#*I+:%!#)*!;/&)&C):%!,5%!7+44+)2)%00!,&!;#/,+:+;#,%!+)!,5#,!*+#4&2C%M!DR*2/1,2$.6!>,.!a'$7$.6*;!EFUV=UH?!!! !

"#*!1$%&!05!%$6.,&02$*%!&0!&#$%!(*41,2,&$0.!,2*!$.41'(*(!$.!J33*.($+!R?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! $)!

5.4.3. VoH&HvV (2014a)

J1%0!/.0C.!,%=!

G%/,/&C7%)!&;!H%/0,%4!%)!H%/0,%4!I#)!G%/,/&C7%)!

S.!O.61$%#=!

"2'%&!$.!L*%&02,&$0.!,.(!L*%&02,&$0.!05!"2'%&!

J5&*2! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! C,%! 32030%*(! 9)! W*$Q*2! ,.(!

*.(02%*(! 9)! &#*! 8*41,2,&$0.! 05! a'$7$.6*;! &#*! B&,&*;! \20>$.4$,1! :0>*2.-*.&;!

-'.$4$3,1$&$*%! ,.(!<JW! %$6.*(! &#*! 2*302&! RG%/,/&C7%)! &;!H%/0,%4! %)!H%/0,%4! I#)!

G%/,/&C7%)U!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT,H?!"#$%!C,%!32*%*.&*(!0.!X,.',2)!Ul&#;!EFUT;!0.!&#*!

%,-*!(,)!&#,&!&#*!W$.$%&*2!05!O40.0-$4!J55,$2%!C,%!$.!&#*!2*6$0.!&0!32*%*.&!,!.*C!

6,%! ,62**-*.&j! ,! 52,-*C02/! >,1$(! 502! &#2**! )*,2%! &#,&! (*&,$1%! &#*! &*2-%! '.(*2!

C#$4#!<JW!4,.!*+310$&!&#*!:20.$.6*.!Z$*1(!,.(!0&#*2!6,%!5$*1(%!D],-3;!EFUTH?!!

! R0a^a>R! DEFUT,H! 9'$1(%! 0.! &#*! ,(>$4*! 05! &#*! W*$Q*2! [0--$%%$0.! ,.(!

%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

JK)!,5%!/%2+&)!,5%!(&$$+00+&)!BC0,#+)#>4%!\C,C/%!"&/,5S=#0,!@/&)+)2%)!QF%+?%/!(&$$+00+&)^!5#0!;/%0%),%*!#)!#*I+:%6!35+0!#*I+:%!5#0!>%%)!7+*%4<!%)*&/0%*6!K,! +0!0%%)! #0! #! /%:&2)+,+&)! &'! ,5%! ;/&>4%$0! #)*! #0! #! >#0+0! '&/! ,5%! /%0,&/#,+&)! &'! ,5%!*+0,C/>%*!>#4#):%!&'!I#4C%0MDUH!

"#*!2*302&!2*406.$%*%!&#*!2*6$0.A%=!!

J*+00#,+0'#:,+&)!:&):%/)+)2!,5%!'#:,!,5#,!'&/!#!4&)2!,+$%!,5%!/+0E0!&'!2#0!;/&*C:,+&)!5#I%!>%%)!*%)+%*M!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT,=eH!!

S.! 02(*2! &0! ,.%C*2! &#$%!($%%,&$%5,4&$0.! ,.(! 2*%&02*! &2'%&! &#*! 2*302&! %&,&*%! &#,&! $&%!

40.&2,4&!3,2&$*%!*.(02%*!&#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!0.!C#$4#!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!C0'1(!

%00.! 32*%*.&! &#*$2! 2*302&! R.#)! ,#'%4U! DR,.! :**1! ^! P,11,6*;! EFUTH?! a0C*>*2;!

,1&#0'6#! &#*! 2*302&! %&,&*%! $&! 2*406.$%*%! &#*!303'1,2! %'3302&!05! &#*! 2*302&!9)! &#*!

W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.;! ,.(! &#,&! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! ,! 2*302&! 0.! $&%!C02/$.6%! ,.(!

! %+!

40-30%$&$0.!4,.!9*!1*5&!&0!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*;!&#*!,62**-*.&!$%!.0&!%$-31)!,.!

*.(02%*-*.&!05!90&#?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! S.%&*,(!05!403)$.6!W*$Q*2A%!32062,--*!1$.*%;!&#*!2*302&!#,%!502-'1,&*(!$&%!

0C.=!!

W6 JK$;/&I+)2!0#'%,<!#)*!;/%I%),+I%!0,/%)2,5%)+)2!&'!5&$%0!#)*!>C+4*+)20!Y6 K$;/&I+)2!,5%!*#$#2%!/%;#+/0!;/&:%*C/%!#)*!I#4C%!+):/%#0%!$%#0C/%0!Z6 K$;/&I+)2!,5%!4+I+)2!%)I+/&)$%),![6 K$;/&I+)2!,5%!%:&)&$+:!;%/0;%:,+I%MDR0a^a>R;!EFUT,=UH!

P#*.!40-3,2*(!&0!W*$Q*2;!R0a^a>R!%**-%!-02*!6*.*2,1! $.!$&%!,(>$4*;!,.(!&#*!

%3*4$5$4!,(>$4*%!05!W*$Q*2!40.4*2.$.6!$%%'*%!%'4#!,%!*.*26)!&2,.%$&$0.!,2*!-$%%$.6?!

Z'2&#*2-02*;!100/$.6!,#*,(!,&!&#*!3'91$4,&$0.!05!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!DEFUTH!&#*!

2*302&!*%&,91$%#*%!%0-*!$-302&,.&!40.%&2,$.&%?!`.*!05!&#*%*!$%!,.!,62**-*.&!0.!&#*!

%'9Q*4&!05!&#*!(,-,6*!2*3,$2%!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.?!S&!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

J,5+0! h&#*! *+*4'&$>*! 026,.$%,&$0.i! 05&C4*! 5#I%! 0C''+:+%),! +)*%;%)*%),!0C;%/I+0+&)6! 35%! %8%:C,+I%! &/2#)+0#,+&)! 7+44! >%! '&/$%*! 7+,5! /%2#/*! ,&! ,5%! 4%2#4!/%0;&)0+>+4+,<!#)*!+)I&4I%$%),!&'!".FMQR0a^a>R;!EFUT,=VH?!!

Z'2&#*2-02*;!&#*!2*302&!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

J35%!1+#4&2C%!3#>4%!5#0! #0! #! 0,#/,+)2!;&+),! ,5#,! #44! ,5&0%! +)I&4I%*! :&)0+*%/! ,5+0!/%;&/,L!,5#,!*&%0!?C0,+:%!,&!,5%!#*I+:%0!&'!,5%!(&$$+,,%%!BC0,#+)#>4%!\C,C/%!"&/,5S=#0,!@/&)+)2%)!DW*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.HL!#0!*+/%:,+&)!2+I+)2!'&/!,5%!7&/E+)20!&'!,5%!1+#4&2C%!3#>4%M!! !

a0C*>*2;!.0&!,11!3,2&$*%! &#,&!#,>*!9*40-*!-*-9*2%!05! &#*!8$,106'*!",91*!#,>*!

%$6.*(!&#$%!,62**-*.&?!Z02!&#0%*!3,2&$*%!&#*!,(>$4*!05!&#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.;!,.(!

&#*! ,62**-*.&! &#*)! %'9%*K'*.&1)! 2*,4#*(!C$&#! >,.!:**1! ,.(!P,11,6*!-$6#&! 9*!

1*,($.6?! "#*! %$6.,&02$*%! &0! R0a^a>R! ,2*! 6*.*2,11)! 40.%$(*2*(! ,%! &#*! -02*!

30C*25'1! 3,2&$*%! ,&! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*?! "#*2*502*;! &#$%! 32*M($,106'*!

,62**-*.&! ;&#,&!(0*%!.0&! $.>01>*! &#*! 0&#*2!3,2&$*%;!-$6#&! 9*! %**.! ,%! ,! %$6.! &#,&!

,12*,()! $.! &#*! 32*M.*60&$,&$0.! 3#,%*! &#*%*! 3,2&$*%! &2$*(! &0! *+*2&! ,! #$6#! 1*>*1! 05!

40.&201?!J.0&#*2!30%%$91*!*+,-31*!05!&#$%!$%!&#*!2*302&A%!32*%*.&,&$0.!05!31,.%!502!

! %*!

,.! O40.0-$4! I0,2(?! "#$%! 90,2(! $%! %*3,2,&*! 05! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! ,.(! $%! .0&!

-*.&$0.*(!$.!*$&#*2!W*$Q*2!02!$.!&#*!2*302&!9)!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*?!"#*!8$,106'*!

",91*! ,.(! O40.0-$4! I0,2(! C$11! 1$/*1)! #,>*! ,! %1$6#&! 0>*21,3! 05! 2*%30.%$9$1$&$*%?!

"#*2*502*;! &0! &#*! .0.M%$6.,&02$*%! &0! R0a^a>R! DEFUT,H! &#$%! -$6#&! 9*! %**.! ,%!

,.0&#*2! C,)! $.! C#$4#! &#*! -02*! 30C*25'1! 3,2&$*%! #,>*! ,&&*-3&*(! &0! %&**2! &#*!

3204*%%!*>*.!9*502*!$&!#,(!9**.!$.$&$,&*(?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! %"!

5.4.4. Van Geel & Wallage (2014)

J1%0!/.0C.!,%=!

.#)!,#'%4!

S.!O.61$%#=!

"0!&#*!",91*!D02=!8$..*2A%!2*,()H!

J5&*2! &#*! C$(*! *.(02%*-*.&! 05! &#*! ,(>$4*! 9)! &#*! W*$Q*2! [0--$%%$0.! &#*!

\20>$.4$,1!O+*4'&$>*!05!:20.$.6*.!,%/*(!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!&0!502-!,.!,(>$4*!

40.4*2.$.6!#0C!&#*!,(>$4*!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!40'1(!9*%&!9*!*+*4'&*(?!

"#*! ,3320,4#! 4#0%*.! 9)! &#*! >,.! :**1! ,.(! P,11,6*! 40.%$%&*(! 05! &#*! 50110C$.6!

%&*3%=!!

W6 J1%'+)+)2!0,#/,+)2!;&+),0!Y6 (&)I%/0#,+&)0!7+,5!*+/%:,!0,#E%5&4*%/0!Z6 g%#/)+)2!'/&$!,5%!3#>4%!&'!.4*%/0!Q*+#4&2C%!,#>4%!+)+,+#,%*!+)!Yhhi^![6 .)#4<0+0!#)*!;/&;&0+,+&)!J!DEFUT=UUH!

J5&*2! #,>$.6! *%&,91$%#*(! &#,&! &#*2*! $%! ,! 9,%$%! 502! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*A%!

*%&,91$%#-*.&;!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!%&,&*!&#,&=!!

J35%!3#>4%!5#0!#0!#!0,#/,+)2!;&+),!,5#,!#44!,5&0%!+)I&4I%*!:&)0+*%/!,5%!;/&;&0+,+&)0!&'! ,5%! F%+?%/! (&$$+00+&)! #0! *+/%:,+&)! 2+I+)2! '&/! ,5%! 7&/E+)20! &'! ,5%!3#>4%MQEFUT=ETH!

a0C*>*2;!%*>*2,1!C**/%!9*502*!&#*!3'91$4,&$0.!05!&#$%!2*302&;!&#*!B&,&*;!\20>$.4$,1!

:0>*2.-*.&;!-'.$4$3,1$&$*%;! ,.(!<JW!#,(!,12*,()!,62**(! &#,&! &#*$2! ,62**-*.&!

C0'1(!9*!($2*4&$0.!6$>$.6!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT,H?!8'*!&0!.0&,91*!($55*2*.4*%!9*&C**.!

90&#!2*302&%!&#$%!320>$(*%!,!9,%$%!502!'.4*2&,$.&)!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!",91*A%!&*2-%!05!

2*5*2*.4*!,.(!,6*.(,?!"#*!40.&2,4&!3,2&$*%!&0!R0a^a>R!C$11!1$/*1)!,26'*!&#,&!$&!$%!

&#*$2! 2*302&! &#,&! %#0'1(!32*>,$1?!a0C*>*2;!0&#*2!-*-9*2%!05! &#*!",91*!#,>*!.0&!

! %#!

%$6.*(!&#,&!,62**-*.&;!,.(!#,>*!*.&*2*(!&#*!3204*%%!9)!&#*$2!*.(02%*-*.&!05!>,.!

:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!DEFUTH!0.!C#$4#!$.!,.!$.&*2>$*C!P,11,6*!%&,&*(=!!

J35%!%),/<!,+:E%,!,&!,5%!3#>4%!+0!,5%!/%;&/,!,5#,!7%!5#I%!;C>4+05%*M!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! %$!

6. Literature Review

6.1. Introduction

"#$%!1$&*2,&'2*!2*>$*C!%&,2&%!C$&#!,!(*%42$3&$0.!05!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!$.!&2*,&$*%;!1,C;!,.(!

%'%&,$.,9$1$&)! 32$.4$31*%?! "#$%! $%! 50110C*(! 9)! ,.! *+,-$.,&$0.! 05! 32,6-,&$4! ,.(!

*&#$4,1! 502!3,2&$4$3,&$0.;! $.41'($.6!30%%$91*!42$&$K'*%?!Z$.,11);! &#*!8'&4#!%$&',&$0.!

,.(!40.4*3&%!'%*(!$.!&#*!,.,1)%$%!05!&#$%!($%%*2&,&$0.!,2*!32*%*.&*(?!J1&#0'6#!&#*!

,.,1)%$%!$%!1,26*1)!9,%*(!0.!&#*!42$&*2$,!32*%*.&*(!9)!B$(,C,)!DEFFGH;!&#*%*!,2*!.0&!

$.41'(*(!#*2*!%$.4*!&#*)!#,>*!9**.!32*%*.&*(!$.!&#*!-*&#0(0106)!D4#,3&*2!TH?!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! %%!

6.2. Treaties, Law & Sustainability Principles

S.!Udel!&#*!P021(![0--$%%$0.!0.!O.>$20.-*.&!,.(!8*>*103-*.&!DJ1%0!/.0C.!,%!

&#*!I2'.(&1,.(![0--$%%$0.H!32*%*.&*(!&#*!2*302&!@`'2![0--0.!Z'&'2*A!DP[O8;!

UdelH?!"#*!2*302&!(*5$.*%!%'%&,$.,91*!(*>*103-*.&!,%!50110C%=!!

JBC0,#+)#>4%! *%I%4&;$%),! +0! *%I%4&;$%),! ,5#,! $%%,0! ,5%! )%%*0! &'! ,5%! ;/%0%),!7+,5&C,! :&$;/&$+0+)2! ,5%! #>+4+,<! &'! 'C,C/%!2%)%/#,+&)0! ,&!$%%,! ,5%+/! &7)!)%%*0M!DP[O8;!Udel=UH!! ! ! ! !

"0!,4#$*>*!&#*!%'%&,$.,91*!(*>*103-*.&!,.(!D$.&*2M6*.*2,&$0.,1H!*K'$&)!,$-*(!502!

9)!&#*!I2'.(&1,.(![0--$%%$0.;!&#*!%$6.,&02$*%!05!&#*!L$0!8*41,2,&$0.!DUddEH!,26'*!

&#,&=!!

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ddEH! !

"#*!Udde!J,2#'%![0.>*.&$0.;!2,&$5$*(!9)!&#*!<*&#*21,.(%!$.!EFFT!D`>*2#*$(;!EFUTH;!

%&,&*%!&#*!50110C$.6!$.!32$.4$31*!U!05!,2&$41*!V=!!

J=#:5! 9#/,<! 05#44! ,#E%! ,5%! )%:%00#/<! 4%2+04#,+I%L! /%2C4#,&/<! #)*! &,5%/! $%#0C/%0L!+):4C*+)2!$%#0C/%0!,&!#:5+%I%!:&$;#,+>+4+,<!>%,7%%)!,5%!;/&I+0+&)0! +$;4%$%),+)2!,5%! +)'&/$#,+&)L! ;C>4+:! ;#/,+:+;#,+&)! #)*! #::%00S,&S?C0,+:%! ;/&I+0+&)0! +)! ,5+0!(&)I%),+&)L!#0!7%44! #0!;/&;%/! %)'&/:%$%),!$%#0C/%0L! ,&! %0,#>4+05!#)*!$#+),#+)!#!:4%#/L! ,/#)0;#/%),! #)*! :&)0+0,%),! '/#$%7&/E! ,&! +$;4%$%),! ,5%! ;/&I+0+&)0! &'! ,5+0!(&)I%),+&)M!DN<O[O;!UddeH!! !

S.!Uddf!,!620'3!05!-*,%'2*-*.&!32,4&$&$0.*2%!,.(!2*%*,24#*2%!520-!5$>*!40.&$.*.&%!

4,-*! &06*&#*2! $.! I*11,6$0;! S&,1);! &0! 2*>$*C! 32062*%%! 2*6,2($.6! %'%&,$.,91*!

(*>*103-*.&! -*,%'2*-*.&! ,.(! &0! %).&#*%$%*! $.%$6#&%! 520-! 0.M60$.6! 32,4&$4,1!

*5502&!Da,2()!^!c(,.;!UddlH?!"#*!-**&$.6!40.41'(*(!C$&#!'.,.$-0'%!,62**-*.&!

! %&!

0.!UF!32$.4$31*%!502!%'%&,$.,91*!(*>*103-*.&!,%%*%%-*.&!&#,&!#,>*!9*40-*!/.0C.!

,%! &#*! I*11,6$0! 32$.4$31*%?! S.! 1$.*! C$&#! &#*! L$0! 8*41,2,&$0.! ,.(! &#*! J,2#'%!

[0.>*.&$0.!&#*!32$.4$31*%!$.41'(*=!03*..*%%!DfH;!*55*4&$>*!40--'.$4,&$0.!DlH;!,.(!

920,(!3,2&$4$3,&$0.! DeH! Da,2()!^!c(,.;!UddlH?!O1,902,&$.6!0.!32$.4$31*!e;!a,2()!

,.(!c(,.!%&,&*!&#,&=!!

J.00%00$%),!&'!;/&2/%00!,&7#/*0!0C0,#+)#>4%!*%I%4&;$%),!05&C4*-!

• T>,#+)!>/&#*!/%;/%0%),#,+&)!&'!E%<!2/#00S/&&,0L!;/&'%00+&)#4L! ,%:5)+:#4!#)*!0&:+#4!2/&C;0L!+):4C*+)2!<&C,5L!7&$%)L!#)*!+)*+2%)&C0!;%&;4%!b!,&!%)0C/%!/%:&2)+,+&)!&'!*+I%/0%!#)*!:5#)2+)2!I#4C%06!!

• =)0C/%!,5%!;#/,+:+;#,+&)!&'!*%:+0+&)S$#E%/0!,&!0%:C/%!#!'+/$!4+)E!,&!#*&;,%*!;&4+:+%0!#)*!/%0C4,+)2!#:,+&)M!DVH!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! %'!

6.3. Pragmatic Reasons

P#*.! ($%4'%%$.6! 32,6-,&$4! 2*,%0.%! 502! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.! B$(,C,)! DEFFGH! 4$&*%!

"#0-3%0.!DUdllH!,%!$(*.&$5)$.6!32,6-,&$4!2*,%0.%!502!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!,%!50110C%=!

• J75%)! #:,+&)! +)! ,5%! ;C>4+:! +),%/%0,! $#<! 5#I%! #! 0%I%/%! #*I%/0%! %''%:,! &)! #!$+)&/+,<L!#0!+)!,5%!:#0%!&'!#!$#?&/!/&#*!0:5%$%N!

• 75%)!,5%!*%$&:/#,+:!;/&:%00!'#+40L!>%:#C0%!,5&0%!+)!#C,5&/+,<!#/%!)&,!+)!,&C:5!&/!+)!0<$;#,5<!7+,5!,5%!$#?&/+,<!&'!;%&;4%!#''%:,%*!><!,5%+/!*%:+0+&)0N!#)*!

• 75%)!4&:#4!2&I%/)$%),!&''+:+#40!#/%!+):&$;%,%),L!#)*!,5%+/!;4#)0!#/%!#;;/&I%*!><!:&C):+40!&/!:&$$+,,%%0!75+:5!5#I%!)%+,5%/!,5%!,+$%!)&/!,5%!VC#4+'+:#,+&)0!,&!%8#$+)%!,5%$!;/&;%/4<M!DUUlH!!

J.0&#*2! 32,6-,&$4! 2*,%0.! 3'&! 502C,2(! 9)! B$(,C,)! $%! &#,&! &#*! $.41'%$0.! 05!

%&,/*#01(*2%! $.! ,! (*4$%$0.! 4,.! #*13! &#*! (*4$%$0.A%! 3*24*$>*(! 1*6$&$-,4)?! "0!

$11'%&2,&*!&#$%;!#*!K'0&*%!&#*!50110C$.6!%&,&*-*.&!9)![2*$6#&0.!DUdleH=!!

JK)! %''%:,L! ,5%!*%:+0+&)S$#E+)2!;/&:%*C/%c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dH!!! !

O%3*4$,11)! $-302&,.&! 502! &#*! 4,%*! %&'()! 05! &#$%! 3,3*2! -$6#&! 9*! &#*! 50110C$.6!

%&,&*-*.&!9)!82)7*/! DUddFH;! 4$&*(! $.!"%'90#,2,! DEFUFH?!J4402($.6! &0!"%'90#,2,;!

82)7*/!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

J&C/!I+%70!#/%! '&/$%*!0&:+#44<!#)*! '&/$%*!7+,5!*+0:/%,%! :C4,C/%0L! 0&!#! :&)0%)0C0!:#)!>%!/%#:5%*!><!0,/+I+)2!,&!C)*%/0,#)*!,5%!:C4,C/#4!,/#*+,+&)!#)*X&/!:&):%;,C#4!'/#$%7&/E!&'!,5%!&,5%/!;#/,+:+;#),0MQTEH!

B*>*2,1!2*%30.(*.&%!40--*.&*(!0.!&#*!($55*2*.4*!9*&C**.!&#*!<JWA%!402302,&*!

4'1&'2*;!&#,&!05!&#*!%&,/*#01(*2%;!,.(!92$(6$.6!&#$%!6,3!$.!'.(*2%&,.($.6!-$6#&!9*!

3,2&!05!&#*!%01'&$0.!&0!30&*.&$,1!4'22*.&!-$%'.(*2%&,.($.6%?!! ! ! !

! %(!

Z$.,11);! $&! $%!,26'*(! &#,&!%&,/*#01(*2!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!-$6#&! $-320>*!%04$,1! 1*,2.$.6!

DI1,4/%&04/! *&! ,1?;! EFFlH?! I,%*(! 0.! Z02*%&*2! DUdddH;! \,#1MP0%&1! ,.(! a,2*! DEFFTH;!

b**'C$%!,.(!\)9'2.!DEFFEH;!,.(!B&2$.6*2!*&!,1?!DEFFfH;!L**(!DEFFeH!%&,&*%!&#,&!%04$,1!

1*,2.$.6!#,33*.%=!!

J75%/%!0,#E%5&4*%/0!#)*!,5%!7+*%/!0&:+%,<!+)!75+:5!,5%<!4+I%L!4%#/)!'/&$!%#:5!&,5%/!,5/&C25! ,5%!*%I%4&;$%),!&'!)%7!/%4#,+&)05+;0L!>C+4*+)2!&)!%8+0,+)2!/%4#,+&)05+;0L!#)*!,/#)0'&/$+)2!#*I%/0#/+#4!/%4#,+&)05+;0!#0!+)*+I+*C#40!4%#/)!#>&C,!%#:5!&,5%/0U!,/C0,7&/,5+)%00!#)*!4%#/)!,&!#;;/%:+#,%!,5%!4%2+,+$#:<!&'!%#:5!&,5%/U0!I+%70MDETEFH!

Z$.,11);!$&!$%!,26'*(!&#,&!*.6,6$.6!C$&#!%&,/*#01(*2%!4,.!$-320>*!&#*!,(03&$0.!05!,!

&*4#.0106)! 02! $.&*2>*.&$0.! %$.4*! &#*! $.41'%$0.! 05! &#*! 104,1! 3*2%3*4&$>*! 4,.! #*13!

&,$102!&#*%*!&0!&#*!104,1!%$&',&$0.!DL**(;!EFFeH?!! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;! &#0'6#! %&,/*#01(*2! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.! #,%! -,.)! 41,$-*(! 9*.*5$&%;!

L**(!DEFFeH!,1%0!09%*2>*%!&#,&!&#*2*!$%!,1%0!($%$11'%$0.-*.&!,-0.6%&!32,4&$&$0.*2%;!

%&,/*#01(*2%;!,.(!&#*!C$(*2!3'91$4!C#*.!&#*%*!41,$-%!,2*!.0&!2*,1$%*(?!I*4,'%*!05!

&#$%;! $&! $%! $-302&,.&!&0!$-320>*!0'2!'.(*2%&,.($.6!05!C#,&!$-320>*%!&#*!4#,.4*%!

502! %'44*%%5'1! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.;! %$.4*! *,4#! 5,$1'2*! #,%! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! &0! (*-0&$>,&*!

3,2&$4$3,.&%!$.!5'&'2*!320Q*4&%!,.(!-,/*!&#*-!%4*3&$4,1;!*>*.!05!9*&&*2M%&2'4&'2*(!

320Q*4&%?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! %)!

6.4. Ethical Reasons

<*+&! &0! &#*!32,6-,&$4! 4,%*! 502!3,2&$4$3,&$0.! &#*2*! $%! ,.! *&#$4,1! 4,%*! &0! 9*!-,(*?!

J4402($.6!&0!J2.%&*$.!DUdfdH=!!

J9#/,+:+;#,+&)! +0!#>&C,!0&:+#4!#)*!;&4+,+:#4!%VC#4+,<!><!2+I+)2!;&7%/!,&!,5&0%!75&!*&!)&,!5#I%!;&7%/M!QUH!!

"#*! $(*,! &#,&! *.6,6$.6!C$&#! %&,/*#01(*2%! $%! &#*! *&#$4,11)! 2$6#&! &#$.6! &0! (0! ,1%0!

%**-%! &0! #,>*! 31,)*(! ,.! $-302&,.&! 201*! $.! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#*! L$0!

8*41,2,&$0.A%!\2$.4$31*!UF! DN<[O8;!UddEH;!,.(!&#*!J,2#'%![0.>*.&$0.! DN<O[O;!

UddeH;!($%4'%%*(!$.!*,21$*2?!a0C*>*2;!,1&#0'6#!2*,1!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!-$6#&!9*!&#*!,$-;!

&#*!50110C$.6!C02(%!'%*(!&0!42$&$K'*!&#*!I01$>$,.!b,C!05!\03'1,2!\,2&$4$3,&$0.!9)!

,!I01$>$,.!$.502-,.&!%#0C!&#,&!$&!$%!.0&!,1C,)%!*+3*2$*.4*(!&#,&!C,)=!!

JK!;#/,+:+;#,%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!P&C!;#/,+:+;#,%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!H%X05%!;#/,+:+;#,%0! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!]%!;#/,+:+;#,%!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!AC,c! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!35%<!*%:+*%M!D:0-*7;![022,($;!:0'1,2&!^!<,-*2,;!EFUF=UUH!!

8'2$.6! ,.! $.502-,&$0.!-**&$.6! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! ,! -*-9*2! 05! &#*!

,'($*.4*!,%/*(!C#*&#*2!&#*!",91*!$%!.0&!Q'%&!,!502-!05!C#,&!W,24'%*!DUdfdH!4,11%!

@2*32*%%$>*! &01*2,.4*A?! W,24'%*! ,26'*%! &#,&! &01*2,.4*! 4,.! 1*,(! &0;! 02! -,$.&,$.;!

0332*%%$0.!$5!$&!$%=!!

J%8,%)*%*! ,&! ;&4+:+%0L! :&)*+,+&)0L! #)*! $&*%0! &'! >%5#I+&C/! 75+:5! 05&C4*! )&,! >%!,&4%/#,%*MQeEH!!

I)!%*&&$.6!'3!,!($,106'*!3204*%%!C#*.!,!30C*25'1!3,2&)!$%!>$01,&$.6!&#*!2$6#&%!05!,!

1*%%!30C*25'1!3,2&)!&#*!091$6,&$0.!502!&01*2,.4*!-$6#&!1*,(!&0!&#*!-,$.&*.,.4*!05=!

J,5%!%0,#>4+05%*!$#:5+)%/<!&'!*+0:/+$+)#,+&)MQW,24'%*;!Udfd;!eGH!!

!

! &+!

W,24'%*!40.&$.'*%!9)!%&,&$.6!&#,&=!!

J35%! ,&4%/#):%! 75+:5! %)4#/2%*! ,5%! /#)2%! #)*! :&),%),! &'! '/%%*&$! 7#0! #47#<0!;#/,+0#)!b!+),&4%/#),!,&7#/*0!;/&,#2&)+0,0!&'!,5%!/%;/%00+I%!0,#,C0SVC&MQUdfd;eGH!!

"#$%!1*,(%!&0!32091*-%!2*6,2($.6!&#*!.*'&2,1!30%$&$0.!05!&#*!-*($,&02;!,.(!-$6#&!

,4&',11)! 320-3&! ,! -*($,&02! &0! ,%%'-*! ,! 201*! &#20'6#! C#$4#! &#*! $-9,1,.4*! 05!

30C*2!$%!,&!1*,%&!3,2&$,11)!40-3*.%,&*(!DW,24'%*;!UdfdH?!!!

! &*!

6.5. Participation in the Netherlands

J12*,()!$.!UdGV;!-*-9*2!05!3,21$,-*.&!,.(!502-*2!C,2&$-*!\2$-*!W$.$%&*2!\$*&*2!

BQ0*2(%!:*292,.();!$.!(*9,&*!C$&#!X'%&$4*!W$.$%&*2!80./*2;!%&,&*(=!!

JA%! #7#/%L! 7+,5! #44! <&C/! 7&/EL! 75+:5! +)! +,0%4'! K! I#4C%! 5+254<L! ,5#,! )%8,! ,&!2&I%/)$%),#4!?C0,+:%L!+)!,5%!;&;C4#:%!,5%/%!#/%!:&C),4%00!'&/:%0!,5#,!&):%!#:,+I#,%*!#/%!#!,5&C0#)*!,+$%0!$&/%!I#4C#>4%!,5#)!&)%!5C)*/%*!4#70M!DL09;!EFUE=EH!!

B$.4*!&#*.;!"0./*.%!,26'*%!&#,&!&#*!%&,.4*!05!&#*!8'&4#!:0>*2.-*.&!&0C,2(%!$&%!

4$&$7*.%!4,.!9*!($>$(*(!$.!&#*!50110C$.6!3#,%*%=!!

o JWj[kSlh-!(#/%,#E%/!2&I%/)$%),!o WjlhSmh-!g+$+,%*!Q*%$&:/#,+:^!:/+,+:+0$6!!o WjmhSYhhk-!A/&#*%/!:/+,+:+0$-!/%,/%#,+)2!2&I%/)$%),6!!o .',%/!Yhhk-!(&))%:,+)2L!+)I+,+)2!2&I%/)$%),6!.,!4%#0,L!,5#,!+0!,5%!/&4%!$#)<!#0;+/%L!>C,!+,!5#0!)&,!<%,!'C44<!:/<0,#44+0%*6MDEFFd=eH!

J4402($.6!&0!8*.!I'&&*2!,.(!"*.!P01(*!DEFUUH!&#*!<*&#*21,.(%!#,%!-,(*!'%*!05!

3,2&$4$3,&02)! %&2'4&'2*%! $.! &#*! 502-!05! @-,&4#$.6! 70.*%A! D%*4&$0.! f?TH! %$.4*! UdGF;!

,.(!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!W0%4#!DEFFVH!*>*.!,26'*!&#,&!&#*!8'&4#!@\01(*2!W0(*1A!C,%!,!

-,$.! (2$>$.6! 5024*! 9*#$.(! &#*! <*&#*21,.(%A! 2*-,2/,91*! *40.0-$4! 2*40>*2)!

9*&C**.! UdeE! ,.(! EFFF?! `.*! 05! &#*! 9*.*5$&%! ,%42$9*(! &0! &#$%! 40.%*.%'%M9,%*(!

(*4$%$0.M-,/$.6! $%! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! &0! 10C*2! &2,.%,4&$0.! 40%&%! D8*.! I'&&*2! ^! "*.!

P01(*;! EFUUH?! J.0&#*2! $%! $-320>*(! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6! ,.(! &2'%&;! 9,%*(! 0.!

10.6M&*2-!4003*2,&$0.!D8*.!9'&&*2!,.(!W0%4#;!EFFVH?!!! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;! 4'22*.&1);! ,4402($.6! &0! &#*! B&:+##4! (C4,C/%%4! 94#)>C/%#C! DB04$,1M

['1&'2,1! \1,..$.6! J6*.4)! M! B[\H! &#*! 504'%! 05! 60>*2.-*.&! $%! .0&! 0.! 301$4)M

$.51'*.4$.6!3,2&$4$3,&$0.;!9'&!0.!$.42*,%*(!4$>$4!2*%30.%$9$1$&)!DEFUTH?!B[\!,26'*%!

&#,&! ,1&#0'6#! $.42*,%*(! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)! $%! 6,$.$.6!303'1,2$&)! ,-0.6%&! 301$&$4$,.%;!

301$4)M$.51'*.4$.6!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!$%!-,$.1)!,331$*(!$.!%-,11M%4,1*!104,1!320Q*4&%?!!

! "#*!D##*!I&&/!5%,!&;%)>##/!>%0,CC/!DB4$*.&$5$4![0'.4$1!502!:0>*2.-*.&!\01$4)!

M!L09H!,26'*%!&#,&!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!%#0'1(!.0&!9*!1$-$&*(!&0!&#$%!DL09;!EFUFj!EFUEH?!Z02!

! &"!

,! %&'()! 05! &#*!8$,106'*! ",91*! &#*%*! 2*302&%! 05! L09! ,2*! 05! #$6#! $-302&,.4*;! .0&!

1*,%&! %$.4*! 0.*! 05! &#*!8$,106'*!",91*A%! &C0! 4#,$2-*.! DP,11,6*H! ,1%0! 4#,$2%!L09?!

Z'2&#*2-02*;!-'4#!05!&#*!$(*,%!32*%*.&*(!9)!L09!#,>*!9**.!,(03&*(!$.!&#*!2*302&!

D40M,'&#02*(! 9)!P,11,6*H! &#,&! 1*(! &0! &#*! ",91*A%! *%&,91$%#-*.&=! R.#)! ,#'%4U! D>,.!

:**1! ^!P,11,6*;! EFUTH?! `.*! 05! &#*! 30$.&%! 05! L09! &#,&! %'25,4*%! $.! >,.!:**1! ,.(!

P,11,6*!DEFUTH!$%!&#*!.0&$0.!&#,&=!!

J35%! 5&/+O&),#44<! &/2#)+0%*! 0&:+%,<! 05&C4*! >%! /%:&))%:,%*! ,&! ,5%! I%/,+:#44<!&/2#)+0%*!2&I%/)$%),M!DVGH!!

J%!-*&#0(%!&0!2*40..*4&!&#*%*!L09!%**%!&#2**!30%%$91*!40..*4&$.6!30$.&%=!!

W6 J9&4+,+:0!'/&$!I#4C%0!#)*!;/+):+;4%0!Y6 F&/%!+)'4C%):%!'&/!:+,+O%)0!&)!;&4+:<!#)*!;&4+:<!$#E+)2!V? F&/%!+)'4C%):%!&'!:+,+O%)0!&)!,5%!:5&+:%!&'!,5%+/!;&4+,+:#4!4%#*%/0M!DEFUF=TVH!!

J.0&#*2! 30$.&! &#,&! 320-$.*.&1)! 5*,&'2*%! $.! >,.! :**1! ,.(!P,11,6*! DEFUTH! $%! &#*!

L09A%!2*502-'1,&$0.!05!J2.%&*$.A%!DUdfdH!1,((*2!05!3,2&$4$3,&$0.?!!

L09! DEFUEH! ,26'*%! &#,&! &#*2*! $%! .0&! 0.*! $(*,1! 02!

9*%&!201*!502!60>*2.-*.&?!S&!,26'*%!&#,&!&#*!201*!05!

60>*2.-*.&! C$11! (*3*.(! 0.! &#*! %$&',&$0.! ,.(!

%'9Q*4&;! ,.(! &#,&!301$&$4%!,.(!60>*2.-*.&! %#0'1(!

-,/*!*+31$4$&!C#$4#!201*! &#*)!%**!502! &#*-%*1>*%?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Figure 5.Government Participation Ladder DL09;!EFUE=flH!

S.!@.#)!,#'%4U!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!DEFUTH!32030%*!,!%&2'4&'2*!$.!C#$4#!C$&#$.!&#*!

8$,106'*! ",91*! 3204*%%! &#*! %&*3! 05! &#*! 1,((*2! &0! 9*! '%*(!C$11! 9*! *>,1',&*(! 3*2!

%'9Q*4&?! b,&*2;! *%3*4$,11)! 502! &#$%! 3'230%*! &#*! ",91*! #,%! ,62**(! &0! *%&,91$%#! ,.!

@,6*.(,! 40--$&&**A! &#,&!C$11! (*&*2-$.*!C#$4#! %&*3!C$11! 9*! *-310)*(! 502!C#$4#!

($%4'%%$0.! 30$.&! D8$,1006&,5*1;! EFUTH?! L09! (*%42$9*%! &#*! %&*3%! 05! &#*! 1,((*2! ,%!

50110C%=!!

! &#!

• JF(-! '$-! ]5%)! ,5%! 2&I%/)$%),! :&$;4%,%4<! 4%,0! 2&L! 05%! *&%0! )&,! 5#I%! #)<!+)'4C%):%!&)!:&),%),!#)*!;/&:%006!!

• G+5&,&-+-(-! 35%! 2&I%/)$%),! :5&&0%0! #! '#:+4+,#,+)2! /&4%! +'! ,5%! +)+,+#,+I%!&/+2+)#,%0!'/&$!%40%75%/%!#)*!05%!0%%0!,5%!+$;&/,#):%!&'!$#E+)2!+,!;&00+>4%6!!

• H-&:A,+-&%'-!T)%! 0,%;! 5+25%/! ,5%! 2&I%/)$%),! *&%0! 5#I%! ,5%! ;/%'%/%):%! '&/! #!:%/,#+)!;&4+:<!&/! +),%/I%),+&)! ,&!7&/EL!>C,! 05%! 4%#I%0! +,0! /%#4+0#,+&)! ,&!&,5%/06!B5%!&)4<!0%#/:5%0!'&/!+):%),+I%0!,&!2%,!&,5%/0!$&I+)26!!

• *&#(5--!]5%)!,5%!2&I%/)$%),!:5&&0%0!*+/%:,+)2L!,5#,!$%#)0!,5#,!&,5%/!;#/,+%0!5#I%!#! /&4%L!>C,! ,5#,! ,5%!2&I%/)$%),!:&)0+*%/0! +,! +$;&/,#),! ,&!5#I%!#! 4%#*+)2!/&4%6!!

• I('A,+-(-! .,! ,5%! ,&;! &'! ,5%! 4#**%/! /%2C4#,+)2! +0! ,5%! 5%#I+%0,! +)0,/C$%),!#I#+4#>4%! ,&! 2&I%/)$%),L! +)! ,5%! '&/$! &'! /%2C4#,+)2! I+#! 4#70! #)*! /%2C4#,+&)0M!!DEFUE=flH!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! &$!

6.6. Matching Zones "#*!8$,106'*!",91*!5$&%!&#*!(*%42$3&$0.!05!C#,&!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!DEFUUH!

1,9*1!,!@-,&4#$.6!70.*A?!J4402($.6!&0!&#*-=!!

JK)!#!$#,:5+)2!O&)%L!2&I%/)$%),!&/2#)+0%0!#)!+)0,+,C,+&)#4+0%*!'&/C$!'&/!*%:+0+&)S$#E+)2! >%,7%%)! ,5%! 2&I%/)$%),! #)*! 0&:+%,<!b! ,5%! 4#,,%/! :&)0+0,+)2! &'! >C0+)%00%0!#)*X&/!:+,+O%)0M!DEFUU=EH!

!"#*)!,26'*!&#,&!&#*!-,$.!09Q*4&$>*!05!&#$%!&)3*!05!$.%&$&'&$0.,1!$..0>,&$0.!$%!&0=!!

J4&7%/!,5%!,/#)0#:,+&)!:&0,0!75+4%!&;,+$+0+)2!;&4+:<!&C,:&$%0M!DEFUU=EH! !

"2,.%,4&$0.! 40%&%! 4,.! 9*! (*%42$9*(! ,%! &#*! 40%&%! 2*%'1&$.6! 520-! 3204*('2,1!

$.*55$4$*.4$*%;!,.(!4,.!9*!($>$(*(!$.!3'91$4!,.(!32$>,&*!&2,.%,4&$0.!40%&%!DI'$&*1,,2;!

EFFlH?! "#*! 502-*2! ,2*! 40%&%! &0! %04$*&);! &#*! 1,&&*2! 40%&%! &0! 32$>,&*! *.&$&$*%! %'4#! ,%!

3*2%0.%!02!026,.$%,&$0.%?!J4402($.6!&0!I'$&*1,,2!$&!$%!$-30%%$91*!&0!5$.(!,!-,2/*&!

C$&#!.0!&2,.%,4&$0.!40%&%;!9'&!$.!>*2)!*55$4$*.&!%$&',&$0.%!&#*)!-$6#&!9*!.*61$6$91*!

DEFFlH?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! J4402($.6!&0!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!DEFUUH!&#*!<*&#*21,.(%!#,%!,!10.6!

#$%&02)! 05! '%$.6! -,&4#$.6! 70.*%?! "#*)! %&,&*! &#,&! &#*! RB&:+##4! =:&)&$+0:5%! D##*U!

DB04$,1!O40.0-$4![0'.4$1! M!BOLH!4,.!9*!%**.!,%!,.!*,21)!*+,-31*?!"#*)!(*%42$9*!

BOL!,%=!!

J#! :&/;&/#,+0,! #*I+0&/<! &/2#)! &/2#)+0%*! #/&C)*! ,5%! ?C8,#;&0+,+&)! >%,7%%)! ,/#*%!C)+&)0! #)*! %$;4&<%/0U! &/2#)+0#,+&)0L! 7+,5! +)*%;%)*%),! $%$>%/0! ;/&I+*+)2!$%*+#,+&)! #)*! #*I+:%! &)! $&0,! +00C%0! &'! :&):%/)0! ,&! %$;4&<%/0! #)*! %$;4&<%%0M!DEFUU=TH!!

J.0&#*2!*+,-31*!05!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!320>$(*(!9)!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!$%!&#*!

",91*! 05! J1(*2%j! ,.! *,21$*2! ($,106'*! &,91*! 0.! C#$4#! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! 05! &#$%!

%&'()!$%!9,%*(?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! 8*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!,26'*!&#,&!$.!02(*2!&0!9*!%'44*%%5'1!,!-,&4#$.6!

70.*! %#0'1(! ,(#*2*! &0! ,! %*&! 05! %&2,&*6$4;! &,4&$4,1;! ,.(! 03*2,&$0.,1! 32$.4$31*%?! S.!

! &%!

4#,3&*2! l! &#*%*! ,2*! '%*(! C#*.! *+,-$.$.6! 3*24*3&$0.%! 05! &#*! 4'22*.&! 8$,106'*!

",91*!$.!:20.$.6*.?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! &&!

6.7. Shared Solutions!"#*! %*,24#! 502! 30%%$91*! @%#,2*(! %01'&$0.%A! $%! 9,%*(! &#*! 2,&$0.,1*! 9*#$.(! &#*!50110C$.6!5$6'2*=!

Shared Solutions:

Figure 6. Shared Solutions.!DL*(3,&#!*&!,1;!EFUEH!

J4402($.6!&0!L*(3,&#!*&!,1! DEFUEH!&#*2*!,2*!%$&',&$0.%!$.!C#$4#!,!6*.'$.*!C$11! &0!

4003*2,&*!,.(!'.(*2%&,.(!*,4#!0&#*2A%!30%$&$0.!4,.!1*,(!&0!,!C$.MC$.!%$&',&$0.!DGH?!

['22*.&! 0330%$.6! >$*C%! 4,.! 9*! 2*6,2(*(! ,%! &#*! 1*5&! 62,3#! $.!C#$4#! 90&#! %$(*%!

40.%$(*2!&#*$2!>$*C!&#*!4022*4&!0.*?!8'2$.6!&#*!,.,1)%$%! $&! $%! 1$/*1)!&#,&!0.*!>$*C!

C$11! #,>*! %&20.6*2! %'3302&$.6! *>$(*.4*;! ,.(! &#*2*502*! S! C$11! 2*6,2(! &#$%! ,%! &#*!

-,$.!>$*C?!a0C*>*2;!$&!-$6#&!9*!30%%$91*!&0!5$.(!40--0.!620'.(!,.(!,!@%#,2*(!

%01'&$0.A! &#,&!90&#! %$(*%! 4,.!,62**!'30.?!\2*5*2,91);! &#$%! %#0'1(!9*!-02*! &#,.!,!

40-320-$%*!DTH;!,.(!9*!,.!$-320>*-*.&!90&#!C$&#!2*6,2(%!&0!&#*!3204*%%!,.(!&#*!

3*24*3&$0.!05!$&%!5,$2.*%%!,.(!*55*4&$>*.*%%!9)!90&#!%$(*%!DGH?!!! ! !

! <0&! 9*$.6! ,91*! &0! *%&,91$%#! %'4#! '.(*2%&,.($.6!-$6#&! 1*,(! &0! ,!C$.M10%*!

%$&',&$0.! DU! 02! EH;! 02! $&! 40'1(! 1*,(! &#*! @10%$.6A! 3,2&)! &0! 09%&2'4&! &#*! 3204*%%A!

32062*%%;!,.(!&#*2*9)!1*,(!&0!,! 10%*M10%*!%$&',&$0.!DVH! DL*(3,&#;!EFUEH?!"#*2*502*;!

&#*!5$2%&!%&*3!05! &#*!,.,1)%$%!C$11! &2)!&0!*+31,$.!&#*!2,&$0.,1*!502!&#*! @-,$.%&2*,-A!

>$*C;! &#*! %*40.(!C$11! ,&&*-3&! &0! *%&,91$%#! @%#,2*(! %01'&$0.%A;! ,.(! $5! &#,&! %**-%!

$-30%%$91*! &#*! *+,-$.,&$0.! 05! 30%%$91*! 2,&$0.,1*%! 9*#$.(! &#*! 0330%$.6! >$*C%!

!

! &'!

%#0'1(!320>$(*!9,%*%!502!$-320>*(!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6!C$&#!&#*!,44*3&,.4*!05!

40.&$.'*(!($%,62**-*.&?!!

! &(!

7. Analysis

7.1. Introduction)

S.!&#$%!4#,3&*2!&#*!-,$.!1$.*%!05!3*24*3&$0.!&#,&!#,>*!*-*26*(!520-!&#*!5$*1(C02/!

C$11!9*!32*%*.&*(!,.(!,.,1)%*(?!"#*!$.&*2>$*C!(,&,!520-!EV!$.&*2>$*C%!,-0'.&%!&0!

,3320+$-,&*1)!Vl?GFF!C02(%?!"#*! $.&*2>$*C!%42$3&%!C*2*!9,%*(!0.!K'*%&$0.%! &#,&!

%#0'1(! *1$4$&! 2*%30.(*.&%A! 3*24*3&$0.! 05! #0C! C*11! &#*! 4'22*.&! 3204*%%! %,&$%5$*%!

B$(,C,)A%! DEFFGH! 42$&*2$,! 502! 3,2&$4$3,&02)M3204*%%! ,.,1)%$%j! $.$&$,&$0.;!

$.41'%$>*.*%%;! $.502-,&$0.;! ,.(! $.51'*.4*?! 8'2$.6! &#*! %&'()! ,! 5$5&#! 42$&*2$0.!

*-*26*(! 520-! 2*%30.(*.&%A! 2*,4&$0.%?! "#0'6#! $-31$4$&1)! 3,2&! 05! $.$&$,&$0.;! $&!

*-*26*(! &#,&! &#*2*!-$6#&! 9*! ,! .**(! 502! $.&*.&$0.! &0! 9*!-02*! *+31$4$&1)! '%*(! $.!

3204*%%! 32*3,2,&$0.! ,.(! ,.,1)%$%?! "#*2*502*;! $.&*.&$0.! #,%! 9**.! $.41'(*(! ,%! &#*!

5$5&#!@$A?!8'*!&0!$&%!$-302&,.4*!$.!&#*!32*M.*60&$,&$0.!%&,6*!$&!#,%!9**.!31,4*(!9*502*!

$.$&$,&$0.;!,.(!C$11!&#*2*502*!9*!,.,1)%*(!5$2%&?!! ! ! ! ! !

! "#*! $.&*2>$*C%! $.41'(*(!K'*%&$0.%! ,! %'9%&,.&$,1! .'-9*2!05! K'*%&$0.%! &#,&!

(0!.0&!($2*4&1)! 2*1,&*! &0! &#*!42$&*2$,!05!,.,1)%$%?!J.%C*2%! &0! &#*%*!K'*%&$0.%;!,.(!

30&*.&$,11)!>*2)!'%*5'1!40--*.&%!2*1,&$.6!&0!$%%'*%!0&#*2!&#*.!&#*!5$>*!$!42$&*2$,!,2*!

.0&!$.41'(*(?!"#*!*+41'%$0.!05!&#*%*!$%%'*%!520-!&#$%!,.,1)%$%!(0*%!.0&!-*,.!&#,&!

&#*%*!K'*%&$0.%!C*2*!05!1$&&1*!'%*!&0!&#*!%&'()?!S.!02(*2!&0!32*3,2*!502!&#*!,.,1)%$%!

05! &#*%*! 5$>*! 42$&*2$,! $&! C,%! *%%*.&$,1! &0! *%&,91$%#! ,! 41*,2! $-,6*! 05! &#*$2! 40.&*+&?!

a0C*>*2;! 9,%*(!0.! %3,4*! ,.(! 41,2$&)!05!32*%*.&,&$0.! &#*%*! $%%'*%!#,>*!.0&!9**.!

$.41'(*(!$.!&#*!5$.,1!32*%*.&,&$0.!05!&#$%!%&'()?!!! ! ! ! !

! I)!41'%&*2$.6! 2*%30.(*.&! %&,&*-*.&%!,20'.(! &#*! 5$>*!42$&*2$,!-,$.! 1$.*%!05!

3*24*3&$0.;!,.(!3*24*3&$0.%!41*,21)!40.&2,%&$.6!C$&#!&#*%*!*-*26*(?!I,%*(!0.!&#*!

-*&#0(0106)! '%*(;! &#*! %,-31*! %$7*! ,.(! &#*! %,-31*A%! ($%&2$9'&$0.! 0.! &#*!

%&,/*#01(*2! -,3! D5$6'2*! EH! >$*C%! %#,2*(! 9)! %*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%! #,>*! .0&!

,'&0-,&$4,11)!9**.!,C,2(*(!-02*!C*$6#&?!S.%&*,(!05!32*%*.&$.6!@9*%&!32,4&$4*A!&#$%!

! &)!

%&'()! $%! 40.4*2.*(! C$&#! $-320>$.6! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! &#*! 31'2,1$&)! 05! >$*C%!

40.4*2.$.6! &#*! -,$.! 42$&*2$,! 05! ,.,1)%$%?! I,%*(! 0.! $-320>*(! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05!

*,4#! 0&#*2%A! 3*2%3*4&$>*! $&! -$6#&! 9*! 30%%$91*! &0! (*>*103! %#,2*(! %01'&$0.%?! S5!

40.&2,%&$.6!>$*C%! %**-! &0! 9*! 620'.(*(! $.!(**31)!#*1(!9*1$*5%! &#$%!-$6#&! .0&! 9*!

30%%$91*?!a0C*>*2;!$.!&#,&!%$&',&$0.!$-320>$.6!0'2!'.(*2%&,.($.6!05!&#*!9,%$%!502!

($%,62**-*.&!$%!%&$11!#*135'1?!B#,2*(!%01'&$0.%!%#0'1(!02$6$.,&*!520-!3,2&$4$3,.&%A!

$.$&$,&$>*%!,.(!C$11!9*!($55*2*.&!$.!*,4#!%$&',&$0.?!a0C*>*2;!C#*2*!&#*%*!%01'&$0.%!

%**-!30%%$91*;!*+,-31*%!,2*!$.41'(*(!$.!&#$%!,.,1)%$%?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! '+!

7.2. Analysis

7.2.1. Intention

S.&*.&$0.;!,%!32*%*.&*(!$.!&#$%!%&'();!2*1,&*%!&0!&C0!-,$.!&#*-*%?!Z$2%&;!S!40.%$(*2!$&!

*%%*.&$,1! &0! *+31$4$&1)! %&,&*! ,.(! *+,-$.*! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! 9,%*%! 502;! ,.(k02!

09%&2'4&$0.%!&0;!*%&,91$%#$.6!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!$.!&#*!32*M.*60&$,&$0.!3#,%*?!B*40.(;!

90&#! 9*502*! ,.(! ('2$.6! &#*! 03*2,&$0.! 05! ,! -,&4#$.6! 70.*;! -$%'.(*2%&,.($.6%!

2*1,&$.6!&0!&#*%*!.*60&$,91*%!,.(!.0.M.*60&$,91*%!#,>*!&#*!30&*.&$,1!&0!09%&2'4&!&#*!

3204*%%?! "#*2*502*;! S! 40.%$(*2! $&! *%%*.&$,1! 502! 3,2&$*%! &0! *+,-$.*! #0C! 0&#*2!

%&,/*#01(*2%!3*24*$>*!&#*$2!$.&*.&$0.%;!,.(!&0!41*,21)!40--'.$4,&*!$.!&#*!*>*.&!05!

,!3*24*$>*(!-$%'.(*2%&,.($.6?!S.!&#*!50110C$.6!%*4&$0.%;!5$2%&!&#*!32*M.*60&$,&$0.!

40.%$(*2,&$0.%! ,2*! *+,-$.*(;! 50110C*(! 9)! ,.! *+,-$.,&$0.! 05! 03*2,&$0.,1!

40.%$(*2,&$0.%?! P#*.! C,22,.&*(! 9)! &#*! (,&,;! &#*%*! %*4&$0.%! #,>*! 9**.! 5'2&#*2!

%'9($>$(*(!$.!($55*2*.&!&,26*&!620'3%?!!

7.2.1.1. Pre-negotiation considerations

J4402($.6! &0! (*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.!P01(*! DEFUUH! ,! -,&4#$.6! 70.*! (*%$6.! %#0'1(!

,(#*2*! &0! ,! %*&! 05! %&2,&*6$4;! &,4&$4,1;! ,.(! 03*2,&$0.,1! 32$.4$31*%?! "#*! %&2,&*6$4!

32$.4$31*%!,2*!*+,-$.*(!$.!&#$%!%*4&$0.?!"#*!&,4&$4,1!,.(!03*2,&$0.,1!32$.4$31*%!C$11!

9*!*+,-$.*(!$.!&#*!%*4&$0.%!0.!$.$&$,&$0.!,.(!$.51'*.4*?!! ! ! !

! [0.4*2.$.6!&#*!(*4$%$0.!,%! &0!C#*&#*2! &0! $.%&$&'&*!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!02!.0&!

(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!DEFUUH!,26'*!&#,&!&#$%!%#0'1(!0.1)!9*!(0.*!$5!,&!1*,%&!0.*!

05!&#*!50110C$.6!&#2**!%&2,&*6$4!42$&*2$,!$%!%,&$%5$*(=!

+6 J35%! 2&I%/)$%),! 5#0! ,/&C>4%! 'C4'+44+)2! +,0! 0%/I+:%0! ,&7#/*! 0&:+%,<!0#,+0'#:,&/+4<L!*C%!,&!#!4#:E!&'!+)'&/$#,+&)!#>&C,!0&:+%,#4!#:,&/0N!

++6 B&:+%,#4! #:,&/0! 5#I%! ,/&C>4%! 'C4'+44+)2! ,5%+/! &>4+2#,+&)! ,&7#/*! 0&:+%,<!0#,+0'#:,&/+4<L!*C%!,&!>#*!:&$$C)+:#,+&)!7+,5!,5%!2&I%/)$%),L!#)*X&/!*C%!,&!#!4#:E!&'!:&&/*+)#,+&)!>%,7%%)!2&I%/)$%),#4!*%;#/,$%),0N!#)*!

! '*!

$$$? D%;/%0%),#,+&)! &'! +$;&/,#),! #''%:,%*! ;#/,+%0! +0! +)%I+,#>4%L! *C%! ,&! ;&;C4#/!*%$#)*!#)*X&/!4+E%4<!&>0,/C:,+&)!&'!+$;4%$%),#,+&)!><!,5%0%!;#/,+%0M!DEfH?!

W02*0>*2;!&#*)!,26'*!&#,&=!!

J,5%! $#,:5+)2! O&)%! 05&C4*! >%! ,5%! $&0,! %''+:+%),! 7#<! &'! #44%I+#,+)2! &)%! &'! ,5%0%!;/&>4%$0M!DEfH!!

S.!EFUV!&#*!W$.$%&*2!05!O40.0-$4!J55,$2%!,..0'.4*(!&#*!(*>*103-*.&!05!,!%&2,&*6)!

&0! %01>*! &#*! 32091*-%! 5,4*(! 9)! &#*! 2*6$0.! DR0a^a>R;! EFUT9H! a0C*>*2;!

*>*.&',11)! ,! 301$4)! ,62**-*.&! C,%! %$6.*(! DR0a^a>R;! EFUT,H! C,%! %$6.*(! &#,&!

C,%! 1,26*1)!9,%*(!0.! &#*! ,(>$%*!05! &#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.?!"#$%! ,62**-*.&! ,1%0!

$.41'(*(! &#*! *.(02%*-*.&! 05! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#*!8$,106'*! ",91*;!C#$4#! ,&!

&#,&!-0-*.&!C,%!9*$.6!*+,-$.*(!,.(!*%&,91$%#*(!9)!>,.!:**1!,.(!P,11,6*!DEFUTH?!

! "#*! -,$.! %&2,&*6$4! 42$&*2$0.! C#0%*! %,&$%5,4&$0.! #,%! 1$/*1)! 1*(! &0! &#*!

*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!$.!&#$%!%$&',&$0.!$%!42$&*2$0.!$$$?!S.!EFUV!&*.%$0.!

C,%!#$6#;!,.(!320&*%&!620'3%!C*2*!6,$.$.6!-*-9*2%!,.(!303'1,2!%'3302&?!J%!3,2&!

05! $&%! 2*302&! &#*!W*$Q*2![0--$%%$0.!,26'*(! &#,&! $.!02(*2! &0! 2*6,$.!303'1,2! &2'%&!

&#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! ,!-,&4#$.6! 70.*! $.! &#*! 502-! 05! ,! ($,106'*! &,91*!C0'1(! 9*!

9*.*5$4$,1?! "#0'6#! &#*!-,$.! (2$>$.6! 5024*! 9*#$.(! &#*! $.$&$,&$0.! 05! &#$%! ($,106'*!

C,%! &#*! .**(! &0! $.41'(*! /*)! %&,/*#01(*2! 2*32*%*.&,&$>*%;! &#*! $%%'*%! &0! 9*! (*,1&!

C$&#! 9)! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! 2*1,&*! &0! 42$&*2$,! $! ,.(! $$! ,.(! %01>$.6! &#*%*! $.!

4003*2,&$0.!C$&#! %&,/*#01(*2! 2*32*%*.&,&$>*%!C$11! 9*! *%%*.&$,1! $.! 2*%&02$.6! &2'%&?!

a0C*>*2;!*>*.!$5!&#*!42$&*2$,!9)!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*!,2*!%,&$%5$*(;!$&!-$6#&!9*!

&#,&! &#*!*%&,91$%#-*.&!05!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!-$6#&!.0&!9*! &#*!9*%&!40'2%*!05!,4&$0.!

%$.4*! &#*! 30$.&%! 05! ($%4'%%$0.! ,2*! .0.M.*60&$,91*! 502! 0.*! 02! -'1&$31*! 3,2&$*%?!

"#*2*502*;! $&! $%! *%%*.&$,1! 502! ,11! 3,2&$*%! &0! *+,-$.*! &#*$2! .*60&$,91*%! ,.(! .0.M

.*60&$,91*%;! ,.(! &0! ,&&*-3&! &0! '.(*2%&,.(! &#0%*! 05! &#*! 0&#*2! 3,2&$*%! ,%!C*11?! S.!

02(*2!&0!(0!%0!$.!,!%&2'4&'2*(!C,);!&#*!50110C$.6!%&2'4&'2*!9)!B$(,C,)!DEFFGH!4,.!

9*!'%*(=!! !

! '"!

!

\`BS"S`<B!<*60&$,&$.6!%&,.4*!*+32*%%*(!,%!41,$-%;!(*-,.(%!02!%01'&$0.%!C#$4#!,2*!?$%J%('$-&+K,(!

,.(!#$.(*2!.*60&$,&$0.![`<[OL<B!

W,)!9*!*+32*%%*(!,%!.**(%!,.(!5*,2%!C#$4#!#*13!&0!$(*.&$5)!$.&*2*%&%?!?$%J%('$-&+K,(!KA-!:+L!K(!&%5#(+4(B!$#!B(5#(+4(B!

<OO8B!Y!9,%$4;!'.(*21)$.6;!4,.!9*!-*&!$.!,!.'-9*2!05!C,)%!ZOJLB!Y!3*24*$>*(!2$%/%!&0!&#*!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!.**(%!

S<"OLOB"B!`5&*.!09%4'2*(k#,2(!&0!(*&*4&!

M+%!K(!:(-!&%!+!E+#&(-L!$.!@+L4!+%B!+#(!?('$-&+K,(!RJbNOB!J<8!IObSOZB!

R$*C%!0.!C#,&!$%!2$6#&!02!C20.6!,.(!#0C!&#*!C021(!%#0'1(!9*;!C#$4#!2*51*4&!3*2%0.,1!02!620'3!$(*.&$&)?!"#*!32$02$&)!6$>*.!&0!($55*2*.&!>,1'*%!-,)!4#,.6*!$.!6$>*.!%$&',&$0.?!

?$%J%('$-&+K,(0!DB$(,C,);!EFFG;!VdH!

`5!40'2%*!$&!$%!>*2)!($55$4'1&!&0!5'11)!'.(*2%&,.(!&#*!30%$&$0.!05!0&#*2!3,2&$*%!

2*6,2($.6!&#*%*! $%%'*%;!*%3*4$,11)!%$.4*!.0&!41*,21)!40--'.$4,&$.6!&#*-!4,.!9*!,!

&,4&$4,1! -0>*! DB$(,C,);! EFFGH?! a0C*>*2;! 1$%&$.6! )0'2! 026,.$%,&$0.A%! .*60&$,91*%!

,.(! .0.M.*60&$,91*%! 9,%*(! 0.! &#$%! %&2'4&'2*;! ,.(! ,&&*-3&$.6! &#*! %,-*! 502! 0&#*2!

3,2&$*%!4,.!#*13!&0!9*&&*2!'.(*2%&,.(!&#*!9,%*%!502!30&*.&$,1!40.%*.%'%!02!*.('2$.6!

40.51$4&?! S(*,11);! &#$%! %&2'4&'2*! %#0'1(! 9*! '%*(! $.! &#*! 32*M.*60&$,&$0.! -**&$.6!

('2$.6!C#$4#! 2*32*%*.&,&$>*%! ,2*! $.&20('4*(! &0! *,4#! 0&#*2?! B*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%!

30$.&*(! &0! &#*! $-302&,.4*! 05! 2*,11)! -,/$.6! ,.! *5502&! &0! 6*&! &0! /.0C! &#*! 0&#*2!

3,2&$4$3,.&%! 9*502*! &#*! 3204*%%! %&,2&%;! ,.(! 03*.1)! %#,2$.6! >$*C%! 0.! &#*%*! 30$.&%!

40'1(!9*!,!>*2)!'%*5'1!-*,.%!05!5,4$1$&,&$.6!&#$%?!S.!&#*!.*+&!%*4&$0.%!%3*4$5$4!32*M

.*60&$,&$0.! 40.%$(*2,&$0.%! 502! 30C*25'1! D:0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! <JWH! ,.(! 1*%%!

30C*25'1!D%04$*&,1!,4&02%H!,2*!*+,-$.*(;!9,%*(!0.!&#*!%&'()A%!$.&*2>$*C%?!!

7.2.1.1.1. Pre-negotiation considerations for Government and NAM

['22*.&1);! $&! $%! ($55$4'1&! &0! %,)!C#*&#*2! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#$%!-,&4#$.6! 70.*!

C$11!320>*!&#*!-0%&!*55$4$*.&!03&$0.?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!&#*!3*24*3&$0.!05!$&%!%'44*%%!C$11!

! '#!

1,26*1)!(*3*.(!0.!&#*!3*2%3*4&$>*!05!&#*!2*%3*4&$>*!,4&02%?!J%!W011!%&,&*%;!$&!-$6#&!

9*!&#,&!<JW!,.(!:0>*2.-*.&!#,>*!'.(*2*%&$-,&*(!&#,&=!!

J#,!#!:%/,#+)!$&$%),!,5+0!d,<;%!&'!;/&:%00e!7+44!0,#/,!4+I+)2!#!4+'%!&'!+,0!&7)M!!

"#$%! $-31$*%! &#,&! &#*! 3204*%%! -$6#&! .0&! 60! C#*2*! <JW! ,.(! :0>*2.-*.&! #,(!

$.&*.(*(!$&!&0!60?!a0C*>*2;!,%!]'$3*2!%&,&*%=!!

JK'!<&C!,#E%!;4#:%!#,!,5+0!3#>4%!#)*!%),%/!+),&!*+#4&2C%!<&C!05&C4*!>%!;/%;#/%*!,&!>%!+)'4C%):%*M!!

Z'2&#*2-02*;!P,11,6*! %&,&*%! &#,&! ,1&#0'6#! 303'1,2! 3*24*3&$0.! %**-%! &0! 9*! &#,&!

<JW!C,.&!&0!40.&201!)*&!$%!.0&!32*3,2*(!&0!9*!$.51'*.4*(=!!

JK!#$!$&/%!&;,+$+0,+:!0+):%! K! ,5+)E! ,5#,! ,5%!7+)S7+)!0+,C#,+&)! +0! 4&:#,%*!$&/%! ,&!,5%!4%',!h05!&#*!%3*4&2'-io!!

"#*! %3*4&2'-! P,11,6*! 2*5*2%! &0! 4,.! 9*! 2*6,2(*(! ,%! ,! #02$70.&,1! >*2%$0.! 05!

J2.%&*$.A%! DUdfdH! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.! 1,((*2;! C$&#! .0.M3,2&$4$3,&$0.! &0! &#*! 2$6#&;! ,.(!

4$&$7*.!40.&201!0.!&#*!1*5&?!J!600(!*+,-31*!05!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!$.!C#$4#!&#$%!%**-%!

&0!#,>*!320>*.!&0!9*!&2'*!$%!&#*!",91*!05!J1(*2%j!,1%0!/.0C.!,%!&#*!B4#$3#01!",91*!

DJ1(*2%&,5*1;!EFUTH?!J4402($.6!&0!P,11,6*;!,%!,!2*%'1&!05!&#,&!3204*%%=!!

J,5%! #2/%%*! $#8+$C$! )C$>%/! &'! '4+25,0! 5#0! ,C/)%*! &C,! ,&! >%! $C:5! 4&7%/! ,5#)!B:5+;5&4!:&C4*!%I%/!5#I%!+$#2+)%*6!H&7%I%/L!B:5+;5&4!*&%0!0C;;&/,!,5%!#2/%%$%),!#)*! d,5%! F+)+0,/<! &'e! 3/#)0;&/,L! 9C>4+:! ]&/E0! #)*! ]#,%/! F#)#2%$%),! Q)&7!K)'/#0,/C:,C/%!#)*!=)I+/&)$%),^!5#0!#*&;,%*!,5%!#2/%%$%),6!35+0!05&70!,5#,! ,5%!0&4C,+&)!+0!4&:#,%*!/%4#,+I%4<!'#/!,&!,5%!4%',!&'!,5%!0;%:,/C$M! ! ! !

"#$%! $-31$*%! &#,&! ,! -,&4#$.6! 70.*! 05! &#$%! &)3*! 4,.! 40.%&$&'&*! ,! %04$,1!

1*,2.$.6! 3204*%%! DI1,4/%&04/! *&! ,1?;! EFFlH! &#,&! #,%! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! &0! 2*,22,.6*!

32$02$&$*%!,.(!31,4*!4003*2,&$0.!0>*2!-,+$-'-!320('4&$0.?!S.!&#*!4'22*.&!3204*%%!

.0!2*%30.(*.&!%&,&*(!&#,&!<JW!02!60>*2.-*.&!#,%!4'22*.&1)!%'55$4$*.&1)!,4#$*>*(!

4#,.6*!$.!&#$%!2*%3*4&?!P$&#!2*6,2(%!&0!C#*&#*2!&#$%!4#,.6*!C$11!&,/*!31,4*!$.!&#*!

.*,2!5'&'2*!2*,4&$0.%!C*2*!-$+*(?!!!

! '$!

7.2.1.1.2. Pre-negotiation considerations for societal actors

"#*!30%$&$0.!05!&#*!%04$*&,1!,4&02%!$%!($55*2*.&!520-!&#,&!05!:0>*2.-*.&!,.(!

<JW?!O>*.!$5!42$&*2$0.!$$$!$%!%,&$%5$*(!,.(!$&!$%!$-30%%$91*!502!&#*!60>*2.-*.&!.0&!&0!

$.41'(*!4*2&,$.!620'3%;!*.6,6$.6!$.!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!-$6#&!.0&!9*!&#*!9*%&!03&$0.!

502! &#*%*!%04$*&,1!,4&02%?![2$&*2$0.! $$$! $-31$*%! &#,&! &#*! $.>$&*(!3,2&$*%!#,>*!6,$.*(!

*.0'6#!%&2*.6&#!&0!.0!10.6*2!9*!$6.02*(?!"#*2*502*;!$&!$%!'.1$/*1)!&#,&!*.6,6$.6!$.!

,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!$%!&#*$2!0.1)!03&$0.?!J1&*2.,&$>*1);!320&*%&!02!Q'($4$,1!,4&$0.!-$6#&!

9*&&*2!%*2>*!&#*$2!,$-%!DB$(,C,);!EFFGH?!S.!&#*!C02%&!4,%*;!&#*!-,&4#$.6!70.*!-$6#&!

9*! 3*24*$>*(! ,%! ,! -*,.%! &0! C#,&! W,24'%*! DUdfdH! 4,11%! @2*32*%%$>*! &01*2,.4*A?!

! [0.%$(*2,&$0.! 05! 0&#*2! 03&$0.%! ,.(! >,2)$.6! 1*>*1%! 05! %4*3&$4$%-! ,%! &0! &#*!

$.&*.(*(!'%*! 05! &#*!3204*%%! 9)!:0>*2.-*.&! ,.(!<JW!41*,21)! %#0C*(! 520-! &#*!

$.&*2>$*C%?! Z02! $.%&,.4*;!=+2%)!HC+0! 40.%$(*2*(! $&%! 03&$0.%! ,.(! (*4$(*(! $&%! 9*%&!

31,4*!C0'1(!.0&! 9*! ,&! &#*!-,$.!",91*;! 9'&! ,&! &#*! B$(*!",91*?! "#*!:II! %**-%! &0!

#,>*! #,(! $.&*.%*! (*9,&*%! 40.4*2.$.6! $&%! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.;! )*&;! ,%! %&,&*(! 9)! >,.! (*2!

].003;!&#*)!*>*.&',11)!Q0$.*(!&0=!!

J#:5+%I%!75#,!+0!;&00+>4%L!#)*!+'!,5#,!,C/)0!&C,!,&!>%!#!!*+0#;;&+),$%),L!,&!4%#I%!,5%!;/&:%00M!!

B:5&EE%)*!@/&)+)2%)!#,%!(*4$(*(!.0&!&0!,331)!502!-*-9*2%#$3?!"#*)!,26'*!&#,&=!!

J.0!4&)2!#0!,5%!2&I%/)$%),!#)*!".F!*&!)&,!$#E%!#!:5#)2%!&'!0;+/+,!,5+0!7+44!)&,!7&/EM!!

"#*$2! >$*C! %**-%! &0! 9*! &#,&! :0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! <JW! C$11! .0&! 9*! 40.>$.4*(! 9)!

($,106'*;!,.(!&#,&!&#*2*502*;!,%!,!320&*%&!620'3;!&#*$2!9*%&!31,4*!$%!.0&!,&!&#*!",91*?!

B:5&EE%)*! @/&)+)2%)! 41*,21)! %**%! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! ,%! ,! -*,.%! -*,.&! &0! /**3!

&#*-!,.(!0&#*2!%04$*&,1!,4&02%!K'$*&?!J4402($.6! &0!(*!I0.&;! $.! &#*!:II! &#*2*!,2*!

,1%0!>0$4*%!41,$-$.6!&#,&!&#*!",91*! $%! Q'%&!,!-*,.%!&0! 1*6$&$-$%*!301$4)?!a0C*>*2;!

#*! ,26'*%! &#,&! $%! .0&! &#*! C#01*! %&02);! ,.(! &#,&! &#*! 2*302&! 9)! &#*! W*$Q*2!

[0--$%%$0.!%#0C%!&#,&!&#*2*!$%!,!1*6$&$-,&*!201*!&#,&!&#*!",91*!4,.!31,)?!a*!%&,&*%=!!

! '%!

JK,! +0! ;&00+>4%! ,5#,! &,5%/0! 0%%! ,5%!3#>4%! #0! #!$%#)0! ,&! 4%2+,+$+0%! ,5%+/! ;&4+:<L! >C,!,5%)!+,!+0!C;!,&!,5%!3#>4%!,&!05&7!+,!5#0!)&,!>%%)!%0,#>4+05%*!'&/!,5#,!;C/;&0%M!!

7.2.1.2. Operational considerations

B*>*2,1!-0.&#%!$.&0!&#*!3204*%%!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!$%!%&$11!%&2'661$.6!&0!%*4'2*!,.!

$-,6*!05!1*6$&$-,4)?!J!1,26*!3,2&!05!&#$%!1*6$&$-,4)!C$11!9*!9,%*(!0.!,4#$*>*-*.&!

,.(!&#*!320-$%*!05!5'&'2*!,4#$*>*-*.&?!a0C*>*2;!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!1,&&*2;!-,.)!%&$11!

%**-! %4*3&$4,1! $.! 2*6,2(! &0! &#*! 40--$&-*.&! 05! :0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! <JW?! J%!

B$Q3*2%-,!%&,&*%=!!

JK!,5+)E!,5#,!&)%!&'!,5%!>+22%0,!;/&>4%$0!+0!0,+44!,5%!VC%0,+&)!&'!75#,!,5%!+),%),+&)!&'!@&I%/)$%),!#)*!".F!+0M!!

[0.4*2.$.6!&#*!X'.*!Ef&#!(*4$%$0.!&#,&!&#*!h(,-,6*!2*3,$2%i!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.!

C$11!.0&!9*!5'11)!$.(*3*.(*.&!05!<JW;!]'$3*2!%&,&*%=!!

JK!5#I%! ,5%! '%%4+)2! ,5#,! ,5%!2&#4! &'! 4%,,+)2! ,5%!@/&)+)2%/0!*%:+*%! &)!75#,! 05&C4*!5#;;%)! 5#0! )&,! 'C44<!$#,%/+#4+0%*6! 35+0! 05&70! +)! ,5%! %8%:C,+I%! &/2#)+0#,+&)! 0,+44!>%+)2!C)*%/!,5%!/%0;&)0+>+4+,<!&'!".FM!!

\0$.&$.6!&0!&#*!$-302&,.4*!05!40--$&-*.&;!W'1(*2!B&,&*%=!!

JK!7&)*%/!5&7!;/%;#/%*!".F!+0!,&!/%#44<!:5#)2%!:&C/0%6!K'!,5%<!#/%!)&,!;/%;#/%*!,&!*&!0&L!,5%!;C>4+:!7+44!%#0+4<!)&,+:%M!!

W0%&!%4*3&$4,1!$%!B:5&EE%)*!@/&)+)2%)=!!

J.2/%%$%),0! #/%! >%+)2! /%#:5%*! #,! ,5%! 3#>4%L! #)*! ,5%)! <&C! 0%%! @&I%/)$%),! #)*!".F!:&),+)C%!,&!2&!,5%+/!&7)!7#<M!! ! ! ! ! !

[0.4*2.$.6! &#*! ,%%*%%-*.&! ,.(! 40--'.$4,&$0.! 05! @$.&*.&$0.A! :0>*2.-*.&! ,.(!

<JW;!&#*!",91*!,%!,!C#01*;!,.(!320&*%&!620'3%!C$11!9*!*+,-$.*(!%*3,2,&*1)?!!

7.2.1.2.1. Government and NAM

J4402($.6! &0! &#*!-,Q02$&)! 05! &#*! 2*%30.(*.&%;! $.! 02(*2! 502! &#*! ",91*! &0! %'44**(!

:0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! <JW! %#0'1(! C02/! #,2(! &0! $-320>*! &#*! 3*24*3&$0.! 05! &#*$2!

! '&!

$.&*.&$0.%?! 8*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.! P01(*! DEFUUH! ,26'*! &#,&! $.! 02(*2! &0! 6,$.! ,.(!

-,$.&,$.!&2'%&!$.!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!3204*%%!$&!$%!$-302&,.&!&0!*.%'2*!3204*('2,1!,.(!

0'&40-*!Q'%&$4*;!,.(!&0!-,/*!10.6!&*2-!40--$&-*.&%?!L*6,2($.6!&#*!502-*2;!&#*)!

,26'*! &#,&! 90&#! ,2*! *%%*.&$,1! 3,2&%! 05! ,! 3204*%%! &#,&! $%! &0! 9*! 3*24*$>*(! ,%! @5,$2A?!

"#*$2!2*1,&$>*! $-302&,.4*!C$11!(*3*.(!0.!&#*!%$&',&$0.;!#0C*>*2;!(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!

&*.! P01(*! (0! ,26'*! &#,&! $.! 6*.*2,1! 0'&40-*! Q'%&$4*! C*$6#%! #*,>$*2! &#,.!

3204*('2,1!Q'%&$4*?![0.4*2.$.6!10.6M&*2-!40--$&-*.&%!&#*)!,26'*!&#,&!10.6M&*2-!

40--$&-*.&!,.(!2*3*,&*(!$.&*2,4&$0.!10C*2!&#*!6,$.%!05!4#*,&$.6;!,.(!$.42*,%*!&#*!

6,$.%!05! 4003*2,&$0.! DEFUUH?!"#*2*502*;! &#*)!,26'*! &#,&! 10.6M&*2-!40--$&-*.&! $%!

,.! $-302&,.&! 5*,&'2*! 05! ,! %'44*%%5'1! -,&4#$.6! 70.*?! Z$.,11);! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &0!

41*,21)! 40--'.$4,&*! &#*! ,(#*2*.4*! &0! &#$%! 3204*('2,1! ,.(! 0'&40-*! Q'%&$4*;! ,.(!

&#*!10.6M&*2-!40--$&-*.&%!-,(*?!! ! ! ! ! ! !

7.2.1.2.2. The Dialogue Table

I,%*(! 0.! &#*! 2*%30.(*.&%A! %&,&*-*.&%! 40.4*2.$.6! &#*$2! 4'22*.&! %4*3&$4$%-! 05!

:0>*2.-*.&! ,.(! <JW;! $&! $%! '.1$/*1)! &#,&! 320-$%*%! 05! Q'%&$4*! ,.(! 10.6M&*2-!

40--$&-*.&!C$11!9*!&,/*.!,&!5,4*!>,1'*?!"#*2*502*;!&#*!%*40.(!3*24*$>*(!$.&*.&$0.!

D^!40--$&-*.&H!&#,&!%#0'1(!9*!&,/*.!$.&0!,440'.&!$%!&#,&!05!&#*!&,91*!,%!,!C#01*j!

,.(!*%3*4$,11)!&#,&!05!$&%!4#,$2-*.?!J%!(*!I0.&!%&,&*%=!!

JK,! +0! +$;&/,#),! ,&! 05&7! ,5#,! h&#*! 1*6$&$-$%,&$0.!05!301$4)i! +0!)&,! ,5%! +),%)*%*!/&4%!h05!&#*!",91*io!!

a*!40.&$.'*%!9)!%&,&$.6!&#,&=!!

J35%!)+:%!,5+)2!+0!,5#,!,5#,!d/%#:,+)2!#2#+)0,!;&,%),+#4!$#)+;C4#,+&)e!#40&!5#;;%)0!I%/<! 0,/&)24<6! K)! ,5%!>%2+))+)2! +,!7#0!#!$#,,%/!&'! ,%0,+)2! ,5%!7#,%/L! >C,!><!)&7!<&C! :#)! :&)'+*%),4<! #)*! &;%)4<! 2+I%! <&C/! &;+)+&)6! A<! )&7! +,! +0! :4%#/4<!:&$$C)+:#,%*!+'!".F!$#E%0!#!*%:+0+&)!,5#,!+0!)&,!%)*&/0%*!><!,5%!1+#4&2C%!3#>4%M!!

!

! ''!

B$(,C,)! DEFFGH! %&2*%%*%! &#*! .**(! 502! -*($,&02%! &0! 9*! 3*24*$>*(! ,%! .*'&2,1! ,.(!

$-3,2&$,1?!a0C*>*2;!#*!,1%0!.0&*%!&#,&=!!

J35%! $%*+#,&/! 5#0! ,5%! #>+4+,<! ,&! #4,%/! ,5%! ;&7%/! #)*! 0&:+#4! *<)#$+:0! &'! ,5%!)%2&,+#,+&)L!>C,!,5%/%!+0!#!*%4+:#,%!>#4#):%!>%,7%%)!2#+)+)2!,5%!/%0;%:,!&'!,5%!;#/,+%0!75+40,!)&,!0%%E+)2!,&!+)'4C%):%!,5%!&C,:&$%M!DlGH!! !

I,%*(!0.!\,1-*2!,.(!L09*2&%!DUddeH!,.(!b$*9-,..!DEFFFH;!B$(,C,)!DEFFGH!,26'*%!

&#,&!$&!$%=!!

J2%)%/#44<! /%:&2)+0%*! ,5#,! 2/&00! +$>#4#):%0! &'! ;&7%/! $#<! ;/%0%),! #)!+)0C/$&C),#>4%!>#//+%/!,&!)%2&,+#,+&)MQmk^!!

S.! &#*!3*24*3&$0.!05!-,.)!05! &#*!2*%30.(*.&%! &#*! $-9,1,.4*!05!30C*2! $%!,!-,Q02!

$%%'*! 502! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*?! W*($,&$0.! 1$&*2,&'2*! 9)! @$.&*2>*.&$0.$%&%A! %'66*%&%!

&#,&!$.!%'4#!,!%$&',&$0.!$&!$%!&#*!('&)!05!&#*!-*($,&02!&0!*.%'2*!&#,&!.0!,62**-*.&!

5,>0'2%! &#*! %&20.6*2! 3,2&)! DW002*;! Udef;! $.! B$(,C,);! EFFGH?! "#$%! $%! $.! 1$.*!C$&#!

J2.%&*$.A%!DUdfdH!(*5$.$&$0.!05!3,2&$4$3,&$0.=!!

J9#/,+:+;#,+&)! +0!#>&C,!0&:+#4!#)*!;&4+,+:#4!%VC#4+,<!><!2+I+)2!;&7%/!,&! ,5&0%!75&!*&!)&,!5#I%!;&7%/M!DUH!!

,.(!W,24'%*;!C#0!,26'*%!&#,&=!!

J,5%! ,&4%/#):%! 75+:5! %)4#/2%*! ,5%! /#)2%! #)*! :&),%),! &'! '/%%*&$! 7#0! #47#<0!;#/,+0#)!b!+),&4%/#),!,&7#/*0!;/&,#2&)+0,0!&'!,5%!/%;/%00+I%!0,#,C0SVC&M!DUdfd=eGH!

!"#$%! %'66*%&%! &#,&! &#*2*!-$6#&! 9*! ,! 1*6$&$-,&*! 2*,%0.! 502!-*($,&02%! &0! ,4&$>*1)!

,&&*-3&! &0! 2*('4*! $-9,1,.4*%! 05! 30C*2?! W002*! DUddf=fdj! $.! B$(,C,);! EFFGH!

%'66*%&%!&#,&=!!

J,5%/%!#/%!:+/:C$0,#):%0!75%)!,5%!0,/&)2%/!;#/,+%0!$#<!7%4:&$%!;&7%/!>#4#):+)2!,&!#00+0,!)%2&,+#,+&)M!DeGH!!

J4402($.6!&0!L,-$2*7!DUdddj!$.!B$(,C,);!EFFGH!,!C,)!05!(0$.6!%0!$%!&0!&2,.%502-!

%&,/*#01(*2%! &0! %04$,1!,4&02%?!P#$1*! &#*! 502-*2!,2*!,&! 2$%/!05!9*$.6!-,26$.,1$%*(;!

&#*!1,&&*2!#,>*=!! J,5%!:#;#:+,<!,&!$#E%!*%:+0+&)0!#)*!#:,!&)!,5%$M!DeGH!!

! '(!

a0C*>*2;!&#*2*!$%!,.!0330%$.6!%4#001!05!&#0'6#&!&#,&!,26'*%!&#,&!30C*2!9,1,.4$.6!

$%! &#*! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)! 05! &#*! 301$&$4,1! 026,.$%*2;! ,.! &#,&! &#*! -*($,&02! %#0'1(! .0&!

*.6,6*! $.! 9*#,>$0'2! &#,&! 3'&%! #$%! .*'&2,1$&)! ,&! 2$%/! DI*11-,.;! UddEj! $.! B$(,C,);!

EFFGH?!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;!$.!&#*!4'22*.&!3204*%%;!&#*!30C*25'1!3,2&)A%!D<JWH!$.&*2*%&%!,2*!

>*2)!-'4#! $.&*2C0>*.!C$&#! &#0%*! 05! &#*! 60>*2.-*.&?! "#*! 60>*2.-*.&! 2*4*$>*%!

dFg!05!&#*!2*>*.'*!05!&#*!6,%!320('4&$0.;!,.(!>$,!OI<!&#*!W$.$%&2)!05!O40.0-$4!

J55,$2%!#01(%!TFg!05! &#*! %#,2*%!05!F##,0:5#;!@/&)+)2%)! D\,2&.*2%#$3!:20.$.6*.H?!

S.! 301$4)! (04'-*.&%;! <JW! ,.(! F##,0:5#;! @/&)+)2%)! ,2*! 05&*.! '%*(!

$.&*24#,.6*,91);! ,.(! $&! $%! '.(*2! &#*! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)! 05!F##,0:5#;! @/&)+)2%)! &#,&!

<JW!*+310$&%!&#*!:20.$.6*.!6,%!5$*1(!DW*$Q*2;!EFUTH?!"#*!TFg!%#,2*#01(*2%#$3!9)!

O40.0-$4!J55,$2%!05!F##,0:5#;!@/&)+)2%)!>$,!=)%/2+%>%*/+?'!"%*%/4#)*!DOI<H!-*,.%!

$-31$*%! &#,&! $5! UFF! -$11$0.! *'20%! 05! 2*3,$2%! #,>*! &0! 9*! 3,$(;! TF! -$11$0.! C$11!

*>*.&',11)! #,>*! &0! 9*! 3,$(! 9)! O40.0-$4! J55,$2%! DOI<;! EFUTH?! "#*2*502*;! $.! &#$%!

%$&',&$0.;!&#*!9,1,.4$.6!05!30C*2!9)!&#*!301$&$4,1!026,.$%*2!-$6#&!.0&!2*,11)!9*!,.!

03&$0.?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! a0C*>*2;!9,%*(!0.!&#*!%&,&*-*.&%!05!%*>*2,1!2*%30.(*.&%!$&!%**-%!&#,&!&#*!

4#,$2-*.!#,>*!&,/*.!&#*!$.$&$,&$>*!&0!*.6,6*!$.!30C*2!9,1,.4$.6;!,.(!&#,&!&#$%! $%!

2*4*$>*(!C*11!9)!&#*!%04$*&,1!3,2&$*%?!R,.!(*2!].003!%&,&*%=!

!J]5#,!;4#<0!#!;&0+,+I%!/&4%!+0!,5%!0,#):%!&'!,5%!:5#+/$%)6!n#$$+)2#!#)*!]#44#2%!5#I%! +)! ! #! 7#<! 04+25,4<! 0+*%*! 7+,5! ,5%! 0&:+%,#4! ;#/,+%0! >%:#C0%! ,5%<! :&)0+*%/! +,!+$;&/,#),!,5#,!,5%0%!;#/,+%0!2#+)!$&/%!+)'4C%):%!&I%/!,5%!;/&:%00M!!

I0*2!%&,&*%=!!

J]%! #;;/%:+#,%! ,5#,! +)! #!7#<! ,5%! :5#+/$%)!5#I%! 04+25,4<! 0+*%*!7+,5!C06!]%! #40&!/%#44<! )%%*! ,5#,L! >%:#C0%! ,5%! '&C/! :&),/#:,! ;#/,+%0! h"#*! B&,&*;! \20>$.4$,1!:0>*2.-*.&;! W'.$4$3,1$&$*%;! ,.(! <JW! Y! R0a^a>R;! EFUT,i! '&/$! #!,/%$%)*&C0!;&7%/!>4&:M!!

! ')!

S.! &#$%! %&'();! .0! 2*%30.(*.&%! 520-! O40.0-$4! J55,$2%! 02! <JW! #,>*! 9**.!

$.&*2>$*C*(?!a0C*>*2;!$&!-$6#&!9*!&#,&!,%!&#*)!,44*3&!,.(!C*140-*!&#$%!9,1,.4$.6;!

,%!%'66*%&*(!9)!W002*!DUddfH?!"#*!2*,%0.!502!&#$%!C0'1(!9*!&#,&!&#$%!9,1,.4$.6!#,%!

&#*!30&*.&$,1!&0!$.42*,%*!303'1,2!&2'%&!$.!&#*!3204*%%?!"#$%!$.42*,%*!$.!&2'%&!-$6#&!

0'&C*$6#!&#*$2!2*1,&$>*!10%%!05!30C*2!&#,&!,440-3,.$*%!2*9,1,.4$.6?!!

7.2.1.2.3. Protest parties

Z$.,11);! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &#,&! 320&*%&$.6! 3,2&$*%! %'4#! ,%! B:5&EE%)*! @/&)+)2%)!

40.&$.'0'%1)! ,%%*%%! &#*! 3*24*3&$0.%! 05! &#*$2! $.&*.&$0.;! ,.(! &0! (*4$(*! 0.! C#,&!

40'2%*!&0!&,/*!C$&#!&#,&!$.!-$.(?!S5!&#*2*!,2*!40.($&$0.%!'.(*2!C#$4#!&#*)!C0'1(!

9*! C$11$.6! &0! *.6,6*! $.! %0-*! 502-! 05! ($,106;! &#*.! 41*,21)! 40--'.$4,&$.6! &#$%!

-$6#&! $-320>*! &#*! 320%3*4&! 05! &#$%! *>*.&',11)! #,33*.$.6?! S.! 5,4&;! &0! 0&#*2%! $&!

-$6#&! %**-! &#,&! ,! 320&*%&! 620'3! &#,&! (0*%! .0&! 41*,21)! 40--'.$4,&*! &#*%*!

40.($&$0.%!&#,&!&#$%!620'3!$%!320&*%&$.6!502!&#*!%,/*!05!320&*%&$.6?!B'4#!,!>$*C!05!,!

320&*%&!620'3!C$11!10C*2!$&%!303'1,2!%'3302&!,.(!&#*2*9)!'.(*2-$.*!$&%!1*6$&$-,4)!

,.(!30C*2!9,%*?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! (+!

7.2.2. Initiation

7.2.2.1. General

P#*2*,%! $.&*.&$0.! 40.4*2.%! 32*M3204*%%! 40.%$(*2,&$0.%! ,.(! 3'91$4! 2*1,&$0.%;!

$.$&$,&$0.! 40.4*2.%! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#*! ,6*.(,! ,.(! &#*! &*2-%! 05! 2*5*2*.4*?!

L*6,2($.6!&#*%*;!P,11,6*!%&,&*%=!!

JK,!+0!+$;&/,#),!)&,!,&!4&0%!0+25,!&'!,5%!#*I+:%!&'!,5%!F%+?%/!(&$$+00+&)M!!

"#*!2*302&!9)!&#$%!40--$%%$0.!*.Q0)%!C$(*!,44*3&,.4*;!,.(!C,%!3'91$41)!*.(02%*(!

9)! ,! 1,26*! .'-9*2! 05! 3,2&$*%! ,.(! $.($>$(',1%! $.! &#*! G%/E4#/+)2! I#)! HC+O+)2%!

DR*2/1,2$.6! >,.! a'$7$.6*;! EFUVH?! a0C*>*2;! W*$Q*2! $%! .0&! &#*! 0.1)! 9,%$%! 502! &#*!

$.$&$,1! ,62**-*.&;! ,.(! &#*! 40.&2,4&! 3,2&$*%! &0! R0a^a>R! DEFUT,H! D"#*! B&,&*;!

\20>$.4*;! W'.$4$3,1$&$*%;! ,.(! <JWH! #,>*! *>*.! ,62**(! &#,&! &#*$2! ,62**-*.&!

%#0'1(!9*!1*,($.6?!"#*)!%&,&*!&#,&!&#*$2!,62**-*.&=!!

J*%,%/$+)%0!,5#,!,5%!3#>4%!5#0!#0!#!0,#/,+)2!;&+),!,5#,!#44!,5&0%!+)I&4I%*!#::%;,!,5+0!#2/%%$%),!#0!2+I+)2!*+/%:,+&)!,&!,5%!7&/E+)20!&'!,5%!3#>4%!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT9H!

!<*+&! &0!W*$Q*2! ,.(! R0a^a>R! &#*2*! $%! @.#)! ,#'%4Uj! &#*! 2*302&! 9)! >,.! :**1! ,.(!

P,11,6*! DEFUTH! &#,&! *+,-$.*%! &#*! 5*,%$9$1$&)! 05! &#*! ",91*A%! *%&,91$%#-*.&! ,.(!

32*%*.&*(! $&%! 40-30%$&$0.?!J4402($.6! &0!P,11,6*! $.41'%$0.! $.! &#$%! 2*302&! 4,.! 9*!

%**.!,%!,!3,2&$4$3,.&A%=!!

J%),/<!,+:E%,!,&!,5%!;/&:%00M!!

a0C*>*2;! &#*! %$6.$.6! 05! R0a^a>R! DEFUT,H! ,.(k02! &#*! G%/E4#/+)2! I#)! HC+O+)2%!

DR*2/1,2$.6! >,.! a'$7$.6*;! EFUTH! -*,.%! &#,&! 3,2&! 05! &#*! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! #,>*!

40--$&&*(! &#*-%*1>*%! &0! 0.*! 02! 90&#! ,62**-*.&%! C#$1*! 0&#*2%! #,>*! 0.1)!

40--$&&*(!&0!@.#)!,#'%4U?!! ! ! ! ! ! !

! J4402($.6! &0! P,11,6*;! *%3*4$,11)! &#*! ($%,62**-*.&! ,.(! 1$-$&,&$0.%!

2*6,2($.6!&#*!30%$&$0.!05!&#*!h(,-,6*!2*3,$2%i!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.!#,>*!#,(!,!

-,Q02!$.51'*.4*!0.!&#*!C02/$.6%!05!&#*!",91*!$.!$&%!5$2%&!-0.&#%?!a*!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

! (*!

J]%!5#I%!,/+%*!,&!C)*&!,5%!*+0#*I#),#2%0!&'! ,5#,!D&#*! 1$-$&,&$0.%!%*&! $.!*,21$*2!,62**-*.&%H?!35#,!5#0!4%*!,&!,5%!,%)!;&+),0L!#2/%%*!C;&)!&)!oC)%!Yi,5M!!

"#*%*! &*.! 30$.&%! 2*1,&*! &0! &#*! %&,&'%! 05! &#*! *+*4'&$>*! 026,.$%,&$0.! D8$,1006&,5*1;!

EFUTH?! Z02! %0-*! 3,2&$*%! 5'11! $.(*3*.(*.4*! 05! <JW! C,%! ,! -,$.! 30$.&;! )*&! &#$%!

03&$0.!#,(!,12*,()!9**.!9104/*(!$.!*,21$*2!,62**-*.&%?!"#*!2*,%0.!6$>*.!502!&#$%!$%!

&#,&! ('*! &0! 1*6,1! 2*,%0.%! &#*! 5$.,1! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)! %#0'1(! ,1C,)%! %&,)!C$&#!<JW!

DR0a^a>R;!EFUT9H!P$&#! &#*! &*.M30$.&!,62**-*.&!,! 40-320-$%*!C,%! 2*,4#*(! $.!

C#$4#! <JW! 2*&,$.%! 5$.,1! 2*%30.%$9$1$&);! )*&! &#*! &*.! 30$.&%! %#0'1(! %*4'2*! $&%!

($%&,.4*!520-!&#*!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.A%!(,$1)!03*2,&$0.%?!! ! ! !

! O+,-$.$.6!C#,&!#,%!#,33*.*(!$&!%**-%!,%!$5!9)!%$6.$.6!R0a^a>R!DEFUT,H!

&#*!W$.$%&*2!05!O40.0-$4!J55,$2%!#,%!(*4$(*(!&0!1$-$&!&#*!%403*!05!&#*!,6*.(,!9)!

*%&,91$%#$.6!30$.&%!&#,&!,2*!.0.M.*60&$,91*?!P#*&#*2!&#$%!%#0'1(!9*!40.%$(*2*(!,%!

,!600(!02!,!9,(!&#$.6!$%!.0&!*,%$1)!*%&,91$%#*(!520-!&#*!1$&*2,&'2*?!`.!&#*!0.*!#,.(!

$&! $%! %&2*%%*(! &#,&! 4,2*! %#0'1(! 9*! &,/*.! &#,&! &#*! ,6*.(,A%! %403*! $%! .0&! D&00H!

40.%&2,$.*(!9)!30C*25'1!$.&*2*%&%?!`.!&#*!0&#*2!#,.(;!$&!$%!2*6,2(*(!,%!$-302&,.&!

&0!#,>*!41,2$&)!C$&#!2*6,2(%!&0!C#,&!$%!.*60&$,91*!,.(!C#,&!.0&!DB$(,C,);!EFFGH?!!

! J! -,Q02! 40.4*2.! 05! %0-*! 2*%30.(*.&%! %**-%! &0! 9*! &#,&! &#*! 3204*%%! C$11!

-,$.1)!9*!044'3$*(!C$&#=!!

J,#4E+)2!#>&C,!0,&)%M!!

P#,&! &#*)!-*,.!C$&#! &#$%! $%! &#,&! $.! &#*$2!>$*C! &#*!3204*%%!C$11! 1$/*1)!-,$.1)!9*!

40.4*2.*(!C$&#!&#*!2*%&02,&$0.!05!3#)%$4,1!%&2'4&'2*%;!,.(!&0!,!-'4#!1*%%*2!(*62**!

C$&#!&#*!(*>*103-*.&!05!,!%'%&,$.,91*!5'&'2*j!,1%0!,.!$-302&,.&!3,2&!05!&#*!,(>$4*!

9)! &#*! W*$Q*2! [0--$%%$0.?! `.! &#*! 0&#*2! #,.(;! &#*2*! ,2*! &#0%*! C#0! 40.%$(*2!

2*3,$2%!,.(!32*>*.&$0.!&0!9*!&#*!",91*A%!-,$.!32$02$&$*%?![0.4*2.$.6!&#*!*55$4$*.4)!

42$&*2$0.! ($%4'%%*(! $.! %*4&$0.! l?E?U?E?! %*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%! ,26'*(! $.! 6*.*2,1;!

2*3,$2%!,.(!32*>*.&$0.!-,)!9*!-02*!%'$&,91)!(*,1&!C$&#!>$,!&2,($&$0.,1!3204*%%*%?!

a0C*>*2;!('*! &0! &#*!>*2)! 10C! &2'%&! $.!:0>*2.-*.&!,.(!<JW;!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*!

! ("!

&#,&! $-320>*%! 2*3,$2! 3204*('2*%! ,.(! -0.$&02%! 32062*%%! -$6#&! 9*! *%%*.&$,1! &0!

2*6,$.!&2'%&?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! I0&#! P,11,6*! ,.(! (*! I0.&! %&,&*! &#,&! ,! -**&$.6! C$&#! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! 05! &#*!

",91*!05!J1(*2%!DJ1(*2%&,5*1;!EFUTH!%#0C*(!&#*-!&#*!$-302&,.4*!05!.0&!,44*3&$.6!

&#*!*+41'%$0.!05!%,5*&)!,%!,!30$.&!05!($%4'%%$0.?!S.!&#*!C02(%!05!P,11,6*=!!

J]#),+)2! ,&! *+0:C00! ,5%! 2#0! ;/&*C:,+&)! *%:+0+&)! &'! YhWi! &/+2+)#,%0! '/&$! #! *#<!*C/+)2!75+:5!7%!05#/%*!%8;%/+%):%0!7+,5!;#/,+:+;#),0!&'!,5%!3#>4%!&'!.4*%/06!35%/%!+,!7#0!0#+*!,5#,!+,!+0!+$;&/,#),!'&/!#!*+#4&2C%!,#>4%!)&,!,&!>%!$#/2+)#4+0%*!><!,#4E+)2!#>&C,!%I%/<,5+)2!>C,!,5%!2#0!;/&*C:,+&)!+,0%4'M!!

L*6,2($.6! &#*! ",91*A%! 201*! $.! ($%4'%%$.6! -,&&*2%! 05! %,5*&);! -,)02! L0(*.9006!

%&,&*%=!!

J.!;/&>4%$!7%!#/%!'#:+)2!)&7!+0!,5#,!7%!h&#*!8$,106'*!",91*i!#/%!)&,!#44&7%*!,&!*+0:C00! 0#'%,<L! %I%)! ,5&C25! '&/! ,5%! +)5#>+,#),0! +,! +0! 0#'%,<! ,5#,! 5#0! ,5%! 5+25%0,!;/+&/+,<M! ! ! ! ! ! !

"#0'6#!,4/.0C1*(6$.6!&#,&!&#*!*>*.&',1!(*4$%$0.!,62**-*.&%!0.!40.4*2.$.6!6,%!

320('4&$0.! 1$*%! C$&#! &#*! W$.$%&*2! 05! O40.0-$4! J55,$2%;! &#*! W*$Q*2! [0--$%%$0.!

%&2*%%*(! &#,&! &#*!8$,106'*!",91*! %#0'1(!9*! $.>01>*(! $.!-,&&*2%! 2*6,2($.6! %,5*&)!

,.(!6,%!320('4&$0.! DW*$Q*2! *&! ,1?;! EFUTH?!a0C*>*2;! &#$%!#,%!.0&!9**.! $.41'(*(! $.!

R0a^a>R?! J.0&#*2! ($55*2*.4*! 9*&C**.!W*$Q*2! ,.(! R0a^a>R! $%! R0a^a>RA%!

$.41'%$0.!05!31,.%!502!,.!O40.0-$4!I0,2(!DEFUT,H?!W*$Q*2!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

J.! 0$#44! 'C)*! >&#/*! b! ;%/5#;0! #;;&+),%*! ><! $%$>%/0! &'! ,5%! 1+#4&2C%! 3#>4%! b!2C#/*0!,5%!2&#40!&'!,5%!'C)*!#)*!$&)+,&/0!0;%)*+)2M!DTfH!

!"#$%! $%! >*2)! ($55*2*.&! 520-! &#*! O40.0-$4! I0,2(?! S&%! *+,4&! %&2'4&'2*! %&$11! #,%!

42)%&,11$%*;!)*&!$&!%**-%!&0!9*40-*!,!%*3,2,&*!026,.!&#,&!C$11!&,/*!0>*2!-'4#!05!&#*!

",91*A%! 201*! 40.4*2.$.6! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! ,! 50'.(,&$0.! 502! ,! %'%&,$.,91*!

*40.0-$4!5'&'2*?![0.4*2.$.6!&#*!O40.0-$4!I0,2(!-,)02!>,.!I**/!%&,&*%=!!

J]%! 05&C4*!)&,! ;/%,%)*! ,&! 5#I%! ,&! 0,#/,! '/&$! 0:/#,:5L! >%:#C0%! ,5%/%! #/%! %8+0,+)2!#2%)*#06!K,!7&C4*!>%!2&&*!,&!:&))%:,!,5%!=:&)&$+:!A&#/*!,&!%8+0,+)2!0,/C:,C/%0M!!

! (#!

B*4&$0.!l?E?V?!D$.41'%$>*.*%%H!C$11!5'2&#*2!*+,-$.*!&#*!03&$0.!05!1$./$.6!&0!*+$%&$.6!

%&2'4&'2*%?!<*+&!&0!&#*!$-302&,.4*!05!40.%$(*2$.6!9'$1($.6!0.!*+$%&$.6!%&2'4&'2*%!$&!

#,%!,1%0!9**.!40--*.&*(!&#,&!40.%$(*2,&$0.!502!104,1!4'1&'2*!,.(!#$%&02)!$%!,1%0!05!

#$6#! $-302&,.4*?! L*6,2($.6! &#$%;! -,.)! 2*%30.(*.&%! C*2*! 30%$&$>*! ,90'&! &#*!

,330$.&-*.&! 05! &#*! &C0! 4#,$2-*.=! ],--$.6,! ,.(! P,11,6*?! I0&#! /.0C! &#*!

.,&$0.,1! 301$&$4,1! ,2*.,;! )*&! &#*)! ,1%0! #,>*! ,! %&20.6! 40..*4&$0.! &0! &#*! 2*6$0.?!

[0.4*2.$.6!&#$%;!B$Q3*2%-,!%&,&*%=!!

J9%&;4%! #/%!$&/%! 4+E%4<! ,&! ,/C0,! ,5&0%!75&$! ,5%<! :&)0+*%/! R,5%+/! &7)UL! #)*! '/&$!,5&0%!,5%<!#/%!#40&!$&/%!4+E%4<!,&!#::%;,!:/+,+:+0$6!35%0%!;%&;4%!:#)!0#<-!R)&7!+,!+0!%)&C25pUM!!

7.2.2.2. Tactical level principles

8*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.! P01(*! DEFUUH! 40.%$(*2! &#*! 50110C$.6! &,4&$4,1! 32$.4$31*%!

*%%*.&$,1!502!,!-,&4#$.6!70.*A%!$.$&$,&$0.=! !

+6 J35%/%!05&C4*!>%!#$;4%!+):%),+I%0!'&/!:&)0%)0C0N!++6 35%/%!05&C4*!>%!,5%!;/&0;%:,!&'!4&)2L!/%;%#,%*!+),%/#:,+&)N!+++6 35%!*%0+2)!05&C4*!0,/+E%!#!>#4#):%!>%,7%%)!/%;/%0%),#,+&)!#)*!%''+:+%):<N!+I6 35%/%!$C0,!>%!#)!+$;#/,+#4!#/>+,%/!&'!0&$%!0&/,N!I6 35%!:&)0,/#+),0!05&C4*!>%!:4%#/!'/&$!,5%!&)0%,!&'!,5%!$#,:5+)2!O&)%N!#)*!>$? K(!,%:5)&4&2<!05&C4*!>%!C,+4+0%*!&;,+$#44<M!!!! !

D(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!&*.!P01(*;!EFUU=EfH!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

I,%*(! 0.! &#*! $.&*2>$*C%! 40.('4&*(! $&! %**-%! &#,&! ,11! %$+! 32$.4$31*%! -$6#&! 9*!

%,&$%5$*(!&0!,!#$6#*2!02!,!1*%%*2!(*62**?!"#$%!(*62**!C$11!(*3*.(!0.!#0C!&#*!",91*!

C$11!(*>*103!>,.! &0!C#,&!(*62**!3,2&$*%! ,2*!C$11$.6! &0! 40--$&?! S.! &#*! 50110C$.6!

%*4&$0.%!&#*!32$.4$31*%!C$11!9*!*+,-$.*(?!

!

!

!

!

! ($!

"K)?,(0():,%'$1)I()#58$()"*7(*9"](:);%0)7%*:(*:':)

)

"#*!,62**-*.&!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.!2*,4#*(!0.!X'.*!Ef&#!

%#0C%!&#,&!*>*.!$.!&#$%!*,21)!%&,6*!3,2&$*%!#,>*!9**.!,91*!&0!,62**!0.!&#*!9,%$4%!05!

,!>*2)!40.&*.&$0'%!$%%'*?!a0C*>*2;!,%!4,.!9*!%**.!520-!,!%&,&*-*.&!$%%'*(!9)!:II!

%00.! ,5&*2;! &#*2*! $%! %&$11! %4*3&$4$%-! ,%! &0! C#*&#*2! $&! C$11! 9*! 30%%$91*! &0! 2*,4#!

40.%*.%'%!0.!,!-02*!(*&,$1*(!>*2%$0.!05!&#$%!,62**-*.&!D:II;!EFUT9H?!!

! Z02!<JW!&#*!$.4*.&$>*!502!40.%*.%'%!$%!303'1,2!%'3302&?!P,11,6*!(*%42$9*%!

&#*!%$&',&$0.!,%!50110C%=!!

!

JP&C!;C/:5#0%!;&;C4#/!0C;;&/,!7+,5!,5%!:C//%):<!&'! ,/C%!;#/,+:+;#,+&)6!K'!<&C!*&!)&,!,/C4<!;#/,+:+;#,%!#)*!#/%!)&,!,/C4<!;/%;#/%*!,&!;C,!<&C/!;4#)!C;!'&/!*+0:C00+&)L!#)*! <&C! *&! )&,! ,/C4<! 0,/+I%! '&/! :&)0%)0C0L! <&C! 7+44! )&,! /%:%+I%!h303'1,2k%&,/*#01(*2i!0C;;&/,M!!

!

Z02! &#*! %04$*&,1! 3,2&$*%! &#*! $.4*.&$>*! $%! &#*! 30%%$9$1$&)! 05! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05!

%&2'4&'2*%! ,.(! &#*! 2*,4#$.6! 05! ,62**-*.&%! &#,&! C0'1(! .0&! *,%$1)! *-*26*! 520-!

320&*%&!02!Q'($4$,1!,4&$0.?!S.4*.&$>*%!&#,&!90&#!:0>*2.-*.&;!<JW;!,.(!&#*!%04$*&,1!

3,2&$*%! %#,2*! ,2*! &#*! 30&*.&$,1! 502! 9*&&*2! %01'&$0.%! 9)! 4003*2,&$0.;! ,.(! &#*! 10.6!

&*2-! 10C*2$.6! 05! &2,.%,4&$0.! 40%&%! 05! -,&4#$.6! 70.*%! >%?! 320&*%&! ,.(! Q'($4$,1!

3204**($.6%!D(*.!I'&&*2!^!&*.!P01(*;!EFUUH?!!

!

""K)?,(0():,%'$1)I()9,()80%:8(79)%;)$%*&P)0(8(#9(1)"*9(0#79"%*)

)

:,%!320('4&$0.!$.!&#*!2*6$0.!$%!320Q*4&*(!&0!40.&$.'*!502!%*>*2,1!(*4,(*%;!,.(!$&%!

40.%*K'*.4*%!C$11!9*!5*1&!*>*.!,5&*2!$&!5$.$%#*%!D<JW\bJ"Z`LW;!EFUTH?!"#*2*502*;!

10.6M&*2-!40--$&-*.&!$%!*%%*.&$,1?!J%!%,$(!9)!W'1(*2=!!

!

JK,!+0!#!;/&?%:,!,5#,!7+44!,#E%!<%#/0L!#)*!,5%/%'&/%!+,!#0E0!'&/!4&)2!,%/$!:&$$+,$%),M!!

! (%!

<$*7*.!60*%!5'2&#*2!&#,.!&#$%!,.(!%&,&*%=!!

Jg&&E!#,! ,5%! 4&)2! ,%/$6!=I%/<,5+)2!&)!#! ,+$%0:#4%! &'! '%7%/! ,5#)! ,%)!<%#/0! +0!)&,!+),%/%0,+)26!K,!+0!)&,!,5+0!2%)%/#,+&)!>C,!,5%!)%8,!,5#,!05&C4*!>%!#>4%!,&!*%#4!7+,5!+,6!g%,!C0!>C+4*!0&$%,5+)2!0&!,5#,!&C/!:5+4*/%)!#)*!,5%+/!:5+4*/%)!7+44!5#I%!#!'C,C/%M!!!

"#*!%$&',&$0.!&#*2*502*!%**-%!&0!Q'%&$5)!10.6M&*2-!40--$&-*.&;!,.(!502!&#*!3204*%%A!

3*24*$>*(!1*6$&$-,4)!$&!C0'1(!9*!9*.*5$4$,1!&0!%#0C!&#$%!10.6M&*2-!>$%$0.!*,21)!$.!

&#*!3204*%%?!!

!

"""K)?,()1(:"&*):,%'$1):90"-()#)I#$#*7()I(9L((*)0(80(:(*9#9"%*)#*1)(;;"7"(*7.)

)

"#$%!32$.4$31*!$%!*+,-$.*(!,%!3,2&!05!%*4&$0.!l?E?V?!D$.41'%$>*.*%%H?!

!

"]K)?,(0()5':9)I()#*)"58#09"#$)#0I"9(0)%;):%5():%09)

)

J%!%&,&*(;!$&!%**-%!&#,&!&#*!4#,$2-*.!#,>*!(*4$(*(!&#,&!%0-*!9,1,.4$.6!05!30C*2!

$%!.*4*%%,2)?!"#*!,&-0%3#*2*!&#$%!42*,&*(!40'1(!30&*.&$,11)!9*!>*2)!9*.*5$4$,1?!"#*!

%&,/*#01(*2%!$.&*2>$*C*(!C*2*!30%$&$>*!,90'&!&#$%!3*24*$>*(!-$1(1)!3,2&$,1!%&,.4*!

05! &#*! 4#,$2-*.?!"#*!3*24*$>*(! $-9,1,.4*!05!30C*2! $%! ,!-,Q02!30$.&!05! 40.4*2.;!

,.(! &#*2*502*! &#$%! -$6#&! 9*! ,! .*4*%%,2)!-0>*?! a0C*>*2;! ,%! %&,&*(! 9)! B$(,C,)!

DEFFGH! &#$%! $%! ,! (*1$4,&*! %$&',&$0.?! J&! ,! 4*2&,$.! 30$.&! <JW! -$6#&! 3*24*$>*! &#*!

3204*%%!,%! &00!9$,%*(!,.(!10C*2!40--$&-*.&?!a0C*>*2;! $5! &#*!",91*!#,%!9)!&#*.!

6,$.*(!%'55$4$*.&!303'1,2!%'3302&;!&,/$.6!,!%&*3!9,4/!-$6#&!9*!($55$4'1&!502!<JW?!!

!

]K)?,()7%*:90#"*9:):,%'$1)I()7$(#0);0%5)9,()%*:(9)%;)9,()5#97,"*&)S%*()

)

J%! #,%! 9**.! %#0C.;! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! $%! 9,%*(! 0.! %*>*2,1! ,62**-*.&%! ,.(!

2*302&%?!"#*!%'44*%%!05! &#$%!32$.4$31*!C$11!(*3*.(!0.! &#*!",91*A%!,9$1$&)! &0! $.! &#*!

! (&!

.*+&!5*C!-0.&#%!41*,21)!*%&,91$%#!.*60&$,91*%!,.(!.0.M.*60&$,91*%?!"0!,$(!&#$%;!&#*!

*%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! ,.! J6*.(,! [0--$&&**! #,%! 9**.! ,62**(! '30.! D8$,1006&,5*1;!

EFUT,H?!Z02!*,4#!30$.&!05!($%4'%%$0.! &#$%!40--$&&**!C$11! $.>*%&$6,&*!C#*&#*2! $&! $%!

%'$&,91*!502!40.%*.%'%!02!,(>$4*?!"#$%!C$11!%'44**(!02!5,$1!9,%*(!0.!&#*!40--$&&**A%!

,'&#02$&)!,.(!(*4$%$0.%!2*6,2($.6!/*)!30$.&%?!!

!

]"K)C<)9(7,*%$%&.):,%'$1)I()'9"$":(1)%89"5#$$.)

)

"#$%!32$.4$31*!$%!*+,-$.*(!,%!3,2&!05!%*4&$0.!l?E?T?!D$.502-,&$0.H!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ('!

7.2.3. Inclusiveness

m'*%&$0.%! 2*6,2($.6! $.41'%$>*.*%%! 4,.! 9*! ($>$(*(! $.! &#0%*! 2*1,&$.6! &0!

2*32*%*.&,&$0.;! 03*..*%%! 05k,.(! $.>01>*-*.&! $.! (*4$%$0.M-,/$.6;! ,.(!

,440'.&,9$1$&)?!S.!&#*!50110C$.6!%*4&$0.%!&#*%*!C$11!9*!*+,-$.*(?!!

7.2.3.1. Representation

J%!#,%!9*40-*!41*,2!520-!&#*!%&,/*#01(*2!,.,1)%$%;!*>*2)0.*!1$>$.6!$.!&#*!2*6$0.;!

,.(! &#0%*! C$&#! ,! 5$.,.4$,1! 02! 301$&$4,1! %&,/*! &#*2*! 4,.! 9*! 40.%$(*2*(! &0! 9*!

%&,/*#01(*2%! DL**(;! EFFeH?! a0C*>*2;! ,%! ,26'*(! 9)! (*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.! P01(*!

DEFUUH! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! 502! ,! -,&4#$.6! 70.*! (*%$6.! &0! %&2$/*! ,! 9,1,.4*! 9*&C**.!

2*32*%*.&,&$0.! ,.(! *55$4$*.4)?! 8'2$.6! &#*! *%&,91$%#-*.&! 05! &#*! 2*302&! @.#)! ,#'%4U!

>,.!:**1! ,.(!P,11,6*!#,>*! ,&&*-3&*(! &0! 5$.(! &#$%! 9,1,.4*?!8$55*2*.&1)! 520-! &#*!

",91*!05!J1(*2%!DJ1(*2%&,5*1;!EFUTH!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*A%!-*-9*2!9,%*!(0*%!.0&!502!

&#*! -0%&! 3,2&! 40.%$%&! 05! 2*32*%*.&,&$>*%! 05! -'.$4$3,1$&$*%?! S.! 5,4&;! 0.*! -,)02!

2*32*%*.&%!&#*!2*6$0.A%!.$.*!-,)02%!,.(!&C0!C,&*2!90,2(%?!"#*!B&,&*;! !\20>$.4$,1!

:0>*2.-*.&;! ,.(! &#*! G%+4+25%+*0/%2+&! DR*$1$6#*$(%2*6$0;! EFUTH! *,4#! #,>*! 0.*!

2*32*%*.&,&$>*;! ,.(! &#*! 2*-,$.$.6! &*.! %30&%! #,>*! 9**.! 2*%*2>*(! 502! %04$*&,1!

026,.$%,&$0.%! ,.(! 9'%$.*%%! $.&*2*%&%! D>,.! :**1! ^! P,11,6*;! EFUTH?! S.! 02(*2! &0!

$.42*,%*! &#*!",91*A%! 2*,4#! ,.(! %'3302&! $&! 0.! 4*2&,$.! $%%'*%! ,! %$(*! &,91*! #,%! 9**.!

*%&,91$%#*(?!"#$%!&,91*!40.%$%&%!05!,!%04$*&,1!,.(!,!&*4#.$4,1!3,2&;!,.(!$&%!-*-9*2%!

Q0$.!-**&$.6%!C#*.!,332032$,&*?!! ! ! ! ! !

! J4402($.6! &0!P,11,6*! &#*! 4#0$4*! 502! &#*! 4'22*.&! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! C,%! 1,26*1)!

9,%*(!0.!&#*$2!*+&*.%$>*!.*&C02/%?!a*!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

J35%!&/2#)+0#,+&)0!,5#,!7%!5#I%!+):4C*%*!#44!5#I%!#!,5&C0#)*!,5/%#*0!+)!,5%!/%2+&)M!!

<*+&! &0! &#$%;! #*! %,)%! &#,&! %'9620'3%!C$11! 9*! *%&,91$%#*(;! $.!C#$4#!.0.M-*-9*2%!

4,.! ,1%0! 3,2&$4$3,&*?! J! %&2'4&'2*! 0.! C#$4#! 40.&,4&! C$&#! &#*%*! 620'3%! -$6#&! 9*!

9,%*(!$%!&#*!40..*4&$0.!C$&#!&#*!B#$%)7%/E+)2!F+?)>&C70:5#*%!DBWBH!DBWB;!EFUTH?!

! ((!

"#*!BWB!32*4*(*%!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*;!$%!2*32*%*.&*(!,&!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!9)!X,.!

P$6901('%;! ,.(! $.41'(*%! 90&#! 8$,106'*! ",91*! -*-9*2! 026,.$%,&$0.%! ,.(! .0.M

-*-9*2%?!"#*!$-302&,.4*!05!9'$1($.6!0.!*+$%&$.6!%&2'4&'2*%!h%'4#!,%!&#*!BWBi!$%!

%0-*&#$.6!&#,&!$%!%&2*%%*(!9)!%*>*2,1!2*%30.(*.&%;!$.41'($.6!-,)02!>,.!I**/?!"#*!

*+&*.&!&0!C#$4#!9'$1($.6!0.!*+$%&$.6!,6*.(,%!,.(!%&2'4&'2*%!$%!30%%$91*!%#0'1(!9*!

9,%*(!0.!,!4,%*M&0M4,%*!9,%$%?!"#*2*!$%!,!($>*2%*!2,.6*!05!30%%$9$1$&$*%;!*,4#!C$&#!$&%!

0C.!%&2*.6&#%;!1$-$&,&$0.%;!,.(!30&*.&$,1!40.%&2,$.$.6!5,4&02%?!! !

! Z02!$.%&,.4*;!@/&)+)2%)!"&&/*U0!D:20.$.6*.!<002(;!EFUT,H!(*>*103-*.&!05!,!

30%$&$>*!5'&'2*!3*2%3*4&$>*!-$6#&!9*!'%*(!&0!320>$(*!&#*!",91*!C$&#!'%*5'1!$.3'&;!

,.(!9)!502!$.%&,.4*!$.>$&$.6!,!4#,$2-,.!,.(k02!-*-9*2%!05!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!&0!

$&%!-**&$.6%! D,%! #,33*.*(! 0.! X'.*! Ee&#! $.!W$((*1%&'-H! $&! 4,.! #*13! &#*! ",91*! &0!

2*,4#!-02*!3*031*!D:20.$.6*.!<002(;!EFUT9H?![0.4*2.$.6!&#*!4'22*.&!%&,&'%!05!&#*!

BWB!-,)02!L0(*.9006!%&,&*%=!!

JP%0,%/*#<!DX'.*!VF&#H!*C/+)2!#!$%%,+)2!7%!*+0:C00%*!75%,5%/!&/!)&,!,5%!BFB!5#0!#! 'C,C/%6!35%!:&):4C0+&)!7#0!,5#,!$#+),#+)+)2!,5%!BFB!+0!0,+44!I#4C#>4%L!0+):%!#,!,5+0!;4#,'&/$!+00C%0!#/%!*+0:C00%*!+)!#!*+''%/%),!7#<L!#)*!7+,5!;#/,+:+;#),0!,5#,!#/%!)&,!#44!$%$>%/0!&'!,5%!1+#4&2C%!3#>4%M!!

Z02! &#*! %,-*! 2*,%0.%;! I0*2! ,1%0! %&$11! 40.%$(*2%! -,$.&*.,.4*! 05! &#*! BWB! &0! 9*!

-*,.$.65'1?! I)! ,4&$>*1)! *.6,6$.6! C$&#! 0&#*2! 026,.$%,&$0.%! ,.(! 31,&502-%! &#*!

8$,106'*! ",91*! 4,.! $.42*,%*! $&%! 0'&2*,4#! C#$1*! -,$.&,$.$.6! ,.! *55$4$*.&! %$7*?! S5!

5'11)! *-92,4*(! ,.(! 41*,21)! 40--'.$4,&*(! 9)! &#*! ",91*;! 40..*4&$0.%! &0! 2*1*>,.&!

*+$%&$.6!,.(!.*C!%&2'4&'2*%!4,.!9*!>*2)!9*.*5$4$,1?!['22*.&1);!>,.!(*2!W01*.!,.(!

I$Q1*>*1(!%&,&*!&#,&!&#*)!h,%!3,2&!05!&#*!*('4,&$0.,1!%*4&02i!(0!.0&!5**1!2*32*%*.&*(!

,&! ,11?! a0C*>*2;! $5! &#$%! ,3320,4#! $%! 5'11)! *-92,4*(! $&! $%! .0&! '.&#$./,91*! &#,&! ,!

31,&502-!2*32*%*.&$.6!*('4,&$0.!C$11!5$.(!40..*4&$0.!&0!&#*!",91*?!B0-*!,26'*!&#,&!

%'4#!201*%;!2*1,&$>*1)!5,2!520-!&#*!",91*;!,2*!'.1$/*1)!&0!)$*1(!2*%'1&%;!,.!&#*2*502*!

,2*!.0&!2*,11)!C02&#!3'2%'$.6?!"#*2*502*;!$&!%#0'1(!9*!41*,2!C#,&!&#*!3'230%*%!05!

&#*%*!40..*4&$0.%!,2*?!!

! ()!

J!%&,&*-*.&!9)!-,)02!>,.!I**/!-$6#&!%#0C!,!30&*.&$,1!9*.*5$&!05!&#$%!,3320,4#?!

B#*!,26'*%!&#,&!$.!02(*2!&0!2*,11)!%'44**(!$.!$.>01>$.6!3*031*!)0'!%#0'1(!,$-!&0!

(0! %0! 0.! 40.42*&*! $%%'*%?! B#*! %'66*%&%! (0$.6! %0! $.! &#*! 502-! 05! %'9M320Q*4&%!

9*4,'%*=!!

J,5%)!<&C!%0,#>4+05!#!*+#4&2C%!7+,5!,5%!;%&;4%6!35%!$&$%),!,5%!4%I%4!&'!#>0,/#:,+&)!+):/%#0%0!+,!>%:&$%0!I%/<!*+''+:C4,!,&!/%#44<!%)2#2%!;%&;4%M!

7.2.3.2. Involvement in decision-making

8$,106'*! ",91*! -*-9*2! 026,.$%,&$0.%! 4,.! 920,(*.! &#*! (*9,&*! ,.(! $.42*,%*!

*.6,6*-*.&!05!3,.*1%;!3011%;!02!6*.*2,1!-**&$.6%!,&!C#$4#!-*-9*2%!4,.!6$>*!&#*$2!

$.3'&?!a0C*>*2;!$&!,1%0!%**-%!30%%$91*!&0!320>$(*!$.3'&!C#$1*!.0&!9*$.6!3,2&!05!,.!

026,.$%,&$0.!&#,&!$%!3,2&!05!&#*!",91*?!"#*!&C0!C,)%!%'66*%&*(!,2*!&#*!50110C$.6?!

Z$2%&;! ,4402($.6! &0! L0*3*2;! ,! 920,(! $.$&$,&$>*! 05! &#*! \20&*%&,.&! [#'24#! 320>$(*%!

2*6'1,2!$.3'&!&0!&#*!%*42*&,2$,&!05!&#*!",91*?!J.0&#*2!C,)!$.!C#$4#!026,.$%,&$0.%!

4,.! %&,)! $.>01>*(! ,.(! 320>$(*! $.3'&! $%! >$,! ,4&$>*! 40.&,4&! C$&#! -*-9*2!

026,.$%,&$0.%;!02!>$,!31,&502-%!%'4#!,%!BWB!DB*4&$0.!l?E?V?H?!"#*!502-*2!,3320,4#!

#,%! &#*!32091*-!&#,&!4'22*.&1);! &#*!",91*A%!%*42*&,2$,&!(0*%!.0&!%**-!&0!#,>*! &#*!

.*4*%%,2)!2*%0'24*%!&0!(*,1!C$&#!1,26*!.'-9*2%!05!&#$%!&)3*!05!$.3'&?!J.!*+,-31*!

05!,4&$>*!40.&,4&!C$&#!&#*!",91*!9)!.0.M-*-9*2!026,.$%,&$0.%!$%!&#*!$.>$&,&$0.!05!

P,11,6*;!(*!I0.&;!,.(!X,.%%*.!&0!,.!$.502-,&$0.!-**&$.6!0.!X'.*!Ee&#!9)!@/&)+)2%)!

"&&/*! D:20.$.6*.!<002(;!EFUT9H?!"#0%*!32*%*.&!C*2*!30%$&$>*!,90'&!&#*!-**&$.6!

,.(!&#*!30%%$9$1$&)!&0!,%/!K'*%&$0.%;!,.(!P,11,6*!C,%!30%$&$>*!,90'&!&#$%! &)3*!05!

*.6,6*-*.&?!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! J.0&#*2! 30%%$9$1$&)! &#,&! $%! .0&! ($2*4&1)! 1$./*(! &0! &#*! ",91*;! )*&! #,%! &#*!

30&*.&$,1! &0! 30%$&$>*1)! $.51'*.4*! &#*! 3204*%%! ,2*! &#*! $.502-,&$0.! *>*.$.6%!

026,.$%*(!9)!&#*!-'.$4$3,1$&)!05!b033*2%'-?!J4402($.6!&0!0.*!2*%30.(*.&!&#*%*!

*>*.$.6%!,2*!,!'%*5'1! %0'24*!05! $.502-,&$0.! 502! &#*!2*6$0.A%! $.#,9$&,.&%;!9'&!,1%0!

502!<JW!2*32*%*.&,&$>*;!%$.4*!&#*2*=!!

! )+!

J,%:5)+:+#)0! #/%! :&)'/&),%*! 7+,5! ,5%! +$;#:,! &'! ,5%+/! *%:+0+&)0! I+%7%*! '/&$! #!;%/0&)#4!4%I%4M!!

b00/$.6!,&! &#*!%$&',&$0.! 1$/*! &#$%;! $&! %**-%! &#,&! &#*2*!,2*!-,.)!($55*2*.&!C,)%! $.!

C#$4#!$.3'&!4,.!2*,4#!&#*!",91*;!*,4#!C$&#!$&%!0C.!%&2*.6&#%!,.(!C*,/.*%%*%?!!

! ! ! ! !

7.2.3.3. Openness of information & presentation of success

<*+&! &0! ,4&',11)! $.>01>$.6! 3*031*! $.! %0-*! 3,2&! 05! &#*! 3204*%%;! ,.(! $.! 02(*2! &0!

320>$(*!,!9,%$%!502!&#$%!$.>01>*-*.&!&0!9*!52'$&5'1;! $&! $%!$-302&,.&!&#,&!3*031*!,2*!

C*11! $.502-*(?! L*6,2($.6! &#$%;! 2*%30.(*.&%! >0$4*! %*>*2,1! >$*C%?! S.! &#$%! %*4&$0.!

&#*%*!,2*!32*%*.&*(;!,.(!,!30%%$91*!@%#,2*(!%01'&$0.A!,.(!&#*!*+&*.&!&0!C#$4#!&#$%!

-$6#&!9*!,44*3&*(!C$11!9*!320>$(*(?!!! ! ! ! ! !

! "#*!5$2%&!>$*C!$%!&#,&!&#*!",91*%!%'44*%%*%!%#0'1(!-02*!41*,21)!9*!,2&$4'1,&*(;!

,.(!&#,&! &#*!%0-*&$-*%M#*,&*(!($%4'%%$0.%! &#,&!#,>*! 1*(!&0! &#*-!%#0'1(!9*!/*3&!

9*#$.(!410%*(!(002%?!"#*!0330%$.6!>$*C!$%!0.*!05!&0&,1!03*..*%%;!$.41'($.6!3'91$4!

,44*%%!&0!-**&$.6%?!"#*!4'22*.&!-0(*1!$%!,!-$+;!$.!C#$4#!-**&$.6%!,2*!410%*(;!9'&!

$.!C#$4#!&0&,1!03*..*%%!40.4*2.$.6!&#*!3204*%%A!($55$4'1&$*%!,.(!($%,62**-*.&%! $%!

,110C*(?!"#*!%#,2*(!%01'&$0.!32030%*(!C$11!9'$1(!0.!&#*!4'22*.&!-0(*1;!)*&!3'&%!,!

10&!05!*-3#,%$%!0.!&#*!41*,2!,.(!C$(*%32*,(!,2&$4'1,&$0.!05!&#*!",91*A%!%'44*%%*%?!

! J4402($.6! &0!-,)02!L0(*.9006! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &0! ,2&$4'1,&*! %'44*%%!C*11;!

,.(! &0! %&2'4&'2*! &#*! 40--'.$4,&$0.! $.! ,! C,)! $.! C#$4#! $.! &#*! -*($,! &#*%*!

%'44*%%*%! C$11! .0&! 9*! 0>*2%#,(0C*(! 9)! 4'22*.&! ($%,62**-*.&! 02! D30&*.&$,1H!

32091*-%?![0.4*2.$.6!&#*!-**&$.6!05!X'.*!Ef&#!#*!%&,&*%=!!

J]%!5#*!,5%!'%%4+)2!7%!5#*!5#*!#!2&&*!$%%,+)2L!#)*!&)!0%I%/#4!+00C%0!7%!5#*!$#*%!*%:+0+&)06! BC>0%VC%),4<L! +)! +,0! ;/%0%),#,+&)! +,! #44! 7%),! 7/&)26! A<! )&,!:&$$C)+:#,+)2!&C/!0C::%00%0!7%44!7%!:/%#,%!#!I%/<!>#*!+$#2%!h05!&#*!3204*%%io!!

! )*!

a*!,1%0!40--*.&%!0.!%0-*!%&20.6!%&,&*-*.&%!2*6,2($.6!&#*!40--$&-*.&!05!<JW!

-,(*! 9)! 0.*! 05! &#*! 4#,$2-*.! ('2$.6! ,! 40.5*2*.4*! 0.!W,)! Ul&#;! EFUT?! I,%*(! 0.!

&#*%*!%&,&*-*.&%!&#*!2*6$0.,1!.*C%3,3*2A%!#*,(1$.*!&#*!.*+&!W0.(,)!C,%=!!

J]#44#2%!4%2,!>&$!&)*%/!1+#4&&2,#'%4M! DP,11,6*!31,4*%!90-9!'.(*2!8$,106'*!

",91*H!D8>#<;!EFUT=UH!!

L0(*.9006!,26'*%! &#,&! %$.4*! &#$%! $%!C#,&! &#*!3*031*!C$11! 2*,(! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &0!

504'%! 0.! &#*! ",91*A%! %'44*%%*%;! ,.(! ,>0$(! %&,&*-*.&%! &#,&! $.>$&*! %'4#! .*6,&$>*!

#*,(1$.*%!C$&#!&#*!30&*.&$,1!&0!0>*2%#,(0C!&#*!",91*A%!,4#$*>*-*.&%!,.(!30%$&$>*!

30$.&%?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! `.! &#*! 0&#*2! %$(*! %*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%! ,26'*(! 502! &#*! $-302&,.4*! 05! &0&,1!

03*..*%%;! $.41'($.6! 3'91$4! ,44*%%! &0! -**&$.6%?! "#$%! (0*%! .0&! -*,.! &#,&! &#0%*!

32*%*.&! %#0'1(! 9*! ,110C*(! &0! 3,2&$4$3,&*! $.! &#*! ($%4'%%$0.%;! 9'&! &#*)! %#0'1(! 9*!

,110C*(!$.!&0!C,&4#!&#*!3204**($.6%!05!&#*!-**&$.6%?!"0!&#*!40--*.&!&#,&!.0&!,11!

-*-9*2%!,2*!*+3*2$*.4*(!3'91$4!.*60&$,&02%;!,.(!&#,&!&#*)!-$6#&!.0&!5**1!,&!*,%*!

C#*.! 3'&! $.! &#*! %30&1$6#&%;! &#*! 2*,4&$0.! 05! %*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%! C,%! &#,&! &#*!

-**&$.6%!05!-'.$4$3,1!40'.4$1%!,2*!,1%0!03*.!&0!&#*!3'91$4;!,.(!&#,&!.0&!,11!40'.4$1!

-*-9*2%!,2*!*+3*2$*.4*(!3'91$4!(*9,&*2%!*$&#*2?! S.! &#*$2!>$*C;! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! &0!

03*.! &#*!-**&$.6%! $.!02(*2! &0!*.%'2*! &#,&! &#*!%&20.6*2!3,2&$*%!(0!.0&!'%*!410%*(!

-**&$.6%! &0! 3'%#! &#20'6#! &#*$2! ,6*.(,?! a0C*>*2;! ,4402($.6! &0! (*! I0.&! 5'11!

03*..*%%!C0'1(!#,>*!,!($%,%&20'%!*55*4&!0.!&#*!3204*%%?!J4402($.6!&0!(*!I0.&!5'11!

03*..*%%!C0'1(! 1*,(!3,2&$4$3,.&%! h*%3*4$,11)!:0>*2.-*.&!,.(!<JWi! &0!9*40-*!

-'4#!1*%%!03*.!,.(!C$11$.6!&0!40-320-$%*!9*4,'%*=!!

J'&/!&C,0+*%/0!+,!+0!%#0<!,&!,#E%!+00C%0!&C,!&'!,5%+/!:&),%8,L!#)*!,5%/%'&/%!<&C!:#)!)&!4&)2%/!0;%#E!'/%%4<L!#)*!,5%!VC#4+,<!&'!,5%!*+#4&2C%!7&C4*!*/#0,+:#44<!*+$+)+05M!!

a*!,1%0!%&,&*%! &#,&! $5!03*..*%%!05!-**&$.6%!C0'1(!9*!2*K'$2*(! $&!C0'1(!9*! 1$/*1)!

&#,&!%'9620'3%!C0'1(!9*!502-*(;!02!&#,&!&#*2*!C0'1(!*>*.!9*!*.&$2*!32*M-**&$.6%;!

'%*(!&0!($%4'%%!$%%'*%!&#*!C,)!&#*)!,2*!9*$.6!($%4'%%*(!.0C;!9*502*!1,&*2!*.6,6$.6!

! )"!

$.!,!3'91$4!-**&$.6%! $.!C#$4#! &#*%*!,62**-*.&%!C$11!9*!32*%*.&*(?! S.!,62**-*.&!

C$&#! &#*! $(*,! &#,&! &#*!-**&$.6%! %#0'1(!9*!9*#$.(!410%*(!(002%;!I20*/#'$%! %&,&*%!

&#,&=!!

JT;%))%00!+0!)&,!?C0,!#>&C,!%)0C/+)2!,5#,!,5%!;#;%/0!:#)!7/+,%!#>&C,!+,L!+,!$#+)4<!+0!#>&C,!;%&;4%!)&,!'%%4+)2!,5/%#,%)%*M! !

"#*!4'22*.&!%&2'4&'2*!$%!,!-$+!05!&#*!&C0!,90>*!>$*C%?!W**&$.6%!&,/*!31,4*!9*#$.(!

410%*(! (002%;! )*&! ,5&*2! &#*! -**&$.6%! &#*2*! 4,.! 9*! 40-31*&*! 03*..*%%! ,90'&! &#*!

3204**($.6%;! $.41'($.6!30$.&%! 05! 40.51$4&! &#,&!C$11! 1$/*1)! %3,2/! 42$&$4,1! #*,(1$.*%?!

`.!&#$%;!]'$3*2!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

JK'! <&C! 4&&E! #,! ,5%! 1+#4&2C%! 3#>4%! <&C! *&! )&,! 0%%! &)%! C)+'+%*! >&#/*6! K,! 7&C4*!,5%/%'&/%!>%!I%/<!0,/#)2%! +'! ,5%<!7&C4*!;/%0%),!,5%$0%4I%0!#0!C)+'+%*6!35#,!7&C4*!#40&!>%!I%/<!/%0,/+:,+I%!&'!,5%!;#/,+%0U!$&I+)2!0;#:%M!!

S.!1$.*!C$&#!&#$%;!(*!I0.&!%&,&*%=!!

J35#,! &;%))%00! +0! I%/<! +$;&/,#),6! 35%! 0C::%00! &'! oC)%! Yi,5! Q#2/%%$%),! &)! ,5%!%8%:C,+I%!&/2#)+0#,+&)^!7#0!'&/!+)0,#):%!)&,!0%%)!#0!#!0C::%00!><!#44!&/2#)+0#,+&)06!35%! &/2#)+0#,+&)0U! $%$>%/0! #/%! )&,! ;/%0%),! #,! ,5%! $%%,+)20L! #)*! ,5%/%'&/%! +,! +0!0&$%,+$%0! *+''+:C4,! ,&! %8;4#+)! 75<! 0&$%,5+)2! 5#0! >%%)! #2/%%*6! B&$%,5+)2! 5#*!+)*%%*! >%%)! #:5+%I%*L! >C,! %)&C25! :/+,+:#4! /%$#/E0! :#)! >%!$#*%! #)*! &;%))%00! &)!,5#,!+0!I%/<!+$;&/,#),M!!

a0C*>*2;!(*!I0.&!,62**%!&#,&!,4#$*>*-*.&%!%#0'1(!9*!41*,21)!40--'.$4,&*(;!,.(!

&#,&! ,! -02*! ($2*4&! 1$.*! 05! 40--'.$4,&$0.! 520-! &#*! 4#,$2-*.! C0'1(! 9*! 600(?!

['22*.&1);!&#*2*!$%!,!32*%%!40.5*2*.4*!,5&*2!*,4#!-**&$.6?!a0C*>*2=!!

J\/&$!#!;/%00!:&)'%/%):%!#',%/!#!$%%,+)2!?&C/)#4+0,0!7+44!&)4<!0%4%:,!#!'%7!4+)%0M!!

"#*2*502*;! (*! I0.&! %'66*%&%! &#,&! &#*! 4#,$2-*.! (0! %0-*&#$.6! %$-$1,2! &0! :IIA%!

>$(*0! -*%%,6*%! D:II;! EFUT,H?! S.! &#*%*! -*%%,6*%! &#*! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! 05! &#$%!

026,.$%,&$0.! ,.%C*2! K'*%&$0.%! 2*6,2($.6! $-302&,.&! 4'22*.&! $%%'*%;! ,.(! &#*!

3204**($.6%! 05! &#*!3204*%%?! I)! 1*&&$.6! &#*! 4#,$2-*.!(0! &#$%! ,%!C*11;! $&!C0'1(!9*!

*,%$*2!502!0'&%$(*2%!&0!'.(*2%&,.(!&#*!40.&*+&!05!&#*!42$&$4,1!2*-,2/%;!,.(!&#*2*9)!

! )#!

&#*)!-$6#&!5**1!-02*!$.>01>*(!$.!&#*!3204*%%?!! ! ! ! !

! I,%*(!0.!&#$%;!$&!-$6#&!9*!30%%$91*!502!3,2&$*%!&0!,62**!0.!,!%#,2*(!%01'&$0.?!

"#$%! %#,2*(! %01'&$0.! %#0'1(! .0&! 9*! %**.! ,%! ,! 40-320-$%*?! S.%&*,(;! $&! %#0'1(!

*-310)! &#*! %&2*.6&#%! 05! *,4#! >$*C! ,.(! ,&&*-3&! &0! 1$-$&! $&%! C*,/.*%%*%?! Z02!

$.%&,.4*;!&#*!03*..*%%!,5&*2!&#*!-**&$.6%!4,.!9*!,!C,)!$.!C#$4#!,&!1*,%&!3,2&!05!&#*!

(*-,.(!502!&0&,1!03*..*%%!$%!-*&;!C#$1*!/**3$.6!&#*!-**&$.6%!9*#$.(!410%*(!(002%;!

,.(! $.! ,.! ,&-0%3#*2*! $.!C#$4#! 32062*%%! 4,.! 9*!-,(*?!a0C*>*2;! L0(*.9006! $%!

4022*4&!$.!%&,&$.6!&#,&!32062*%%!%#0'1(!.0&!9*!0>*2%#,(0C*(!9)!32091*-%?!S.!02(*2!

&0!%,&$%5)!&#$%;!,.!,3320,4#!-$6#&!9*!,(03&*(!$.!C#$4#!&0&,1!03*..*%%!2*-,$.%;!)*&!

$.!C#$4#!30$.&%!05!2*,1!40.%*.%'%!,2*!41*,21)!,.(!,4&$>*1)!40--'.$4,&*(?!S(*,11);!

&#$%!%#0'1(!#,33*.!>$,!>,2$0'%!-*($,;!,.(!$&!%#0'1(!0.1)!#,33*.!C#*.!,11!3,2&$*%!

,.(! &#*$2!-*-9*2! 9,%*! ,62**!C$&#! $&?! \2*%*.&$.6! ,62**-*.&%! %'4#! ,%! &#*! 0.*! 05!

X'.*!Ef&#! D8$,1006&,5*1;!EFUTH! $.!&#$%!C,)!-$6#&!10C*2!&2'%&! $.!&#*!10.6!2'.;!%$.4*!

$.*>$&,91)!&#*2*!C$11!9*!3,2&$*%!&#,&!C$11!#,>*!&0!3'11!0'&!,&!,!1,&*2!%&,6*!%$.4*!&#*!

8$,106'*! ",91*! -*-9*2%! #,>*! .0&! -,.,6*(! &0! 40.>$.4*! &#*! -*-9*2%! 05! &#*$2!

026,.$%,&$0.?! "#*2*502*;! $.! &#0%*! %$&',&$0.%! &#*! 03*..*%%! ,5&*2! -**&$.6%! $%!

$-302&,.&?! a0C*>*2;! 0.4*! -*-9*2! 026,.$%,&$0.%! %#0C! 920,(! %'3302&! 502! ,.!

,62**-*.&!$&!$%!*%%*.&$,1!&#,&!&#$%!,62**-*.&!$%!41*,21);!,4&$>*1);!,.(!'.*K'$>04,11)!

32*%*.&*(?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! Z$.,11);! &#*! 03*..*%%! 05! 40--'.$4,&$0.!-$6#&! #,>*! ,.! ,((*(! ,(>,.&,6*!

502! &#*! ",91*A%! %04$*&,1! 026,.$%,&$0.%;! 9,%*(! 0.! &#*! 4'22*.&! %&,.4*! 05! &#*! ",91*A%!

4#,$2-*.?!J4402($.6!&0!B$Q3*2%-,;! &#*!-0-*.&!05!P,11,6*A%!42$&$4$%-!40.4*2.$.6!

<JWA%!40--$&-*.&!&#,&! 1*(!&0!&#*!.*6,&$>*!#*,(1$.*!C,%!4#0%*.!>*2)!4,2*5'11)?!

a*!%&,&*%!&#,&=!!

JH%!DP,11,6*H!7#),%*!,&!:/%#,%!0;#:%L!#)*! +)!,5+0!;5#0%! +,! +0! +)%I+,#>4%! ,5#,! ,5+0!7+44!4%#*!,&!:&44+0+&)0M!!

! )$!

S.! &#$%! >$*C;! &#*! 03*..*%%! ,.(! &#*! 30%%$9$1$&)! 502! 42$&$4$%-! 520-! 90&#! &#*!

3,2&$4$3,.&%! ,.(! 4#,$2-*.! $%! ,! '%*5'1! &001! &#,&! 4,.! 3'&! 32*%%'2*! 0.! &#*! -02*!

30C*25'1!3,2&$*%!&0!,4&!0.!&#*$2!C02(%!,.(!&,/*!&#*!3204*%%!%*2$0'%?!!

7.2.3.4. Accountability

B$.4*!&#*!-*-9*2%!05!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*!#,>*!.0&!9**.!*1*4&*(;!$&%!*%&,91$%#-*.&!

-$6#&! 2,$%*! K'*%&$0.%! 2*6,2($.6! $&%! (*-042,&$4! 1*6$&$-,4)?! m'*%&$0.%! 2*6,2($.6!

&#*! (*-042,&$4! 1*6$&$-,4)! 05! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! ,.(! &#*! O40.0-$4! I0,2(!C*2*!

2,$%*(!$.!%*>*2,1!$.&*2>$*C%?!"#*!>$*C!520-!&#*%*!2*%30.(*.&%!C,%!&#,&!1*6$&$-,4)!

40'1(!9*!*,2.*(!9)!,4#$*>*-*.&;!9'&! &#,&! &#*!",91*! %#0'1(!.0&!#,>*!,.)! 502-,1!

,'&#02$&)?!L*6,2($.6!&#$%!-,)02!>,.!I**/!%&,&*(!&#,&=!!

J]5#,! K! ,5+)E! &'! #0! ;/&>4%$#,+:L! #)*!7+44! :&),+)C%! ,&! ,5+)E! &'! #0! ;/&>4%$#,+:L! +0!,5#,!,5%/%!#4/%#*<!#/%!*%$&:/#,+:#44<!4%2+,+$#,%!0,/C:,C/%0M!!

B#*!40.&$.'*%!9)!*+31,$.$.6!&#,&!,1&#0'6#!,!8$,106'*!",91*!4,.!9*!,!'%*5'1!-*,.%;!

$&! %#0'1(! .0&! &,/*! &#*! 31,4*! 05! &#*! *+$%&$.6! %&2'4&'2*%;! ,.(! &#*! 5$.,1! (*4$%$0.%!

2*6,2($.6! $-302&,.&! $%%'*%!%#0'1(!9*!-,(*! $.!,!(*-042,&$4,11)! 1*6$&$-$%*(!C,)?!

L*6,2($.6!&#*!O40.0-$4!I0,2(!%#*!40--*.&%!&#,&=!!

JK)!,5%!=:&)&$+:!A&#/*!>C0+)%00%0!05&C4*!;4#<!#)! +$;&/,#),!/&4%6!AC,!75%/%!#/%!,5%!2&I%/)$%),0_!K,!+0!+$;&/,#),!,5#,!#,!,5%!4%#0,!,5%<!5#I%!#!'#:+4+,#,+)2!/&4%L!%I%)!+'!,5+0!+0!?C0,!,&!0;%)*!,5%!,#8;#<%/0U!$&)%<!+)!#!*%$&:/#,+:#44<!4%2+,+$+0%*!7#<M!!! !

`.*! 32030%,1!-,)02! >,.! I**/! #,%! 2*6,2($.6! &#$%! 3204*%%! $%! &0! 1*&! &#*!8$,106'*!

",91*!32030%*!40.4*3&%;!,.(!&0!1*&!&#0%*!32030%,1%!9*!*>,1',&*(!9)!&#*!-'.$4$3,1!

40'.4$1%?!"0!&#$%;!\*11*.9,26M>,.!I,2*.!,((%!&#,&=!!

J+)! ,5#,! 7#<! <&C! #40&! +):4C*%! ,5%! $C)+:+;#4! :&C):+406! ]5%)! ,#4E+)2! #>&C,!;#/,+:+;#,+&)!+,!+0!+$;&/,#),!'&/!;C>4+:!0C;;&/,!,&!+):4C*%!,5%!$C)+:+;#4!:&C):+40M!

!

!

! )%!

7.2.4. Information

B$.4*!03*..*%%!05!$.502-,&$0.!2*6,2($.6!&#*!",91*A%!32062*%%!#,%!9**.!(*,1&!C$&#!

$.!&#*!32*>$0'%!%*4&$0.;! &#$%!C$11!.0&!9*!,.,1)%*(!,6,$.!#*2*?! S.%&*,(;! &#$%!%*4&$0.!

C$11! (*,1! C$&#! &#*! K'*%&$0.%! 05! #0C! $.502-,&$0.! $%! ($%%*-$.,&*(;! ,.(! $5! $&! $%!

30%%$91*!&0!%'55$4$*.&1)!2*,4#!,11!%&,/*#01(*2%?!! ! ! ! ! !

! R$*C%!0.!$.502-,&$0.!C$(*1)!($55*2?!S.!*,21)!X'.*;!I$Q1*>*1(!%&,&*(!&#,&=!!

nh"#*! $.502-,&$0.! 320>$%$0.i! +0! I%/<! >#*6! A%:#C0%! &'! $<! ;#0,! +)! ;&4+,+:0! #)*!

7&/E! #,! ,5+0! 0:5&&4! K! 0&$%,+$%0! /%:%+I%! 0&$%! +)'&/$#,+&)L! >C,! K! ,5+)E! ,5#,! ,5%!

+)'&/$#,+&)!;/&I+0+&)!*+/%:,%*!#,!,5%!+)5#>+,#),0!+0!)%24+2+>4%M!!

B$-$1,21);! I10/#'$%! %&,&*%! &#,&! $5! %#*! C0'1(! .0&! #,>*! 9**.! ,! :II! -*-9*2! %#*!

C0'1(=!!

J$&0,!4+E%4<!5%#/!)&,5+)2!#>&C,!+,6!35%)!K!7&C4*!5#I%!,&!/%4<!&)!,5%!;#;%/0L!#)*!,5%!+)'&/$#,+&)! +)! ,5%$! +0! &',%)!$+)+$#4! &/! &)%S0+*%*6!P&C! :&C4*! &'! :&C/0%! I+0+,! ,5%!3#>4%U0!7%>0+,%L!>C,! K!*&!)&,! ,5+)E!$#)<!;%&;4%!#:,+I%4<! 4&&E! '&/! +)'&/$#,+&)! 4+E%!,5#,M!!

`.! &#*! 0&#*2! #,.(! %#*! ,26'*%! &#,&! ('*! &0! #*2! :II! -*-9*2%#$3! %#*! 2*4*$>*%!

2*6'1,2!,.(!$.502-,&$>*!'3(,&*%?! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! S&! %**-%! &#,&! $&! $%! ($55$4'1&! &0! 2*,4#! &#0%*! C#0! ,2*! .0&! -*-9*2%! 05!

026,.$%,&$0.%! $.>01>*(! $.! &#*! 3204*%%?! B$Q3*2%-,! %&,&*%! &#,&! &#*!1#2>4#*! I#)! 5%,!

"&&/*%)!,12*,()!C2$&*%! ,90'&! &#*! ",91*! 2*1,&$>*1)! 05&*.?!a0C*>*2;! .0&! *>*2)0.*!

#,%!,!%'9%42$3&$0.!&0!&#$%!3,3*2?!"#*2*!,2*!52**!.*C%3,3*2%;!-,.)!0C.*(!9)!&#*!

%,-*!40-3,.)! &#,&!320('4*%! &#*!1#2>4#*;! ,.(! &#*)!,1%0!05&*.! $.41'(*!3$*4*%!0.!

&#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*?! a0C*>*2;! $&! C0'1(! .0&! 9*! 30%%$91*! &0! 3'&! &#*! $.502-,&$>*!

>,1'*!05!&#*%*!3,3*2%!0.!&#*!%,-*!%&,.(,2(!05!&#,&!05!&#*!1#2>4#*;!%$.4*!(0$.6!%0!

C0'1(! '.(*2-$.*! &#*! $.4*.&$>*! 502! 6*&&$.6! ,! %'9%42$3&$0.;! ,.(! &#,&! C0'1(!

%'9%*K'*.&1)!'.(*2-$.*!&#*!9,%$%!502!3'91$4,&$0.!502!1#2>4#*!,.(!&#*!52**!3,3*2%?!

! J26'-*.&%! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! 40%&%! ,.(! 30&*.&$,1! 9*.*5$&%! 02! 3,)$.6! 502!

! )&!

,(>*2&$%*-*.&! 02!-,$1$.6! 1*,51*&%! >,2$*%?! a0C*>*2;! ,&! ,!-**&$.6! $.!W$((*1%&'-!

026,.$%*(!9)!@/&)+)2%)!"&&/*!%*>*2,1!$.#,9$&,.&%!%&,&*(!&#,&!9)!2*1)$.6!-0%&1)!0.!

&#*!C*9%$&*!,!2*1,&$>*1)!1,26*!-$.02$&)!05!3*031*!C#0!(0!.0&!'%*!&#*!S.&*2.*&!,2*!

.0&!2*,4#*(?!J1%0;!&#$%!-**&$.6!('2$.6!C#$4#!3*031*!40'1(!,%/!K'*%&$0.%!&0!0.*!05!

&#*!4#,$2-*.!,.(!&C0!-*-9*2%!%**-*(!&0!9*!2*4*$>*(!>*2)!C*11!90&#!9)!&#*-!,.(!

&#*!,&&*.($.6!$.#,9$&,.&%?!L*6,2($.6!&#$%;!P,11,6*!%&,&*(!&#,&=!!

JG+0+,+)2!I+44#2%0! 0C:5!#0!B#,C/*#<! hX'.*!Ee&#e! +)!F+**%40,C$! +0! 0&$%,5+)2! ,5#,!:#)!>%!I%/<!$%#)+)2'C4L!#)*!>%:#C0%!&'!,5%!0+O%!&'!,5%!I+44#2%0!,5+0!+0!#40&!;/#:,+:#46!F<! ,5&C25,0! &)! ,5%! ;&00+>+4+,<! &'! /%4<+)2!$&0,4<! &)! *+2+,#4! :&),#:,! 5#I%! >%:&$%!$&/%!)C#):%*M!!

a*! ,1%0! ,62**(! &#,&! $&! C0'1(! 9*! 600(! &0! 50110C! :II! $.! -,/$.6! '%*! 05! >$(*0!

-*%%,6*%!0.!&#*!C*9%$&*?!S.!&#$%!%*.%*;!$&!%**-%!&#,&!,1&#0'6#!%'9%&,.&$,1!*5502&!$%!

-,(*! &0! -,/*! 600(! '%*! 05! S[! &*4#.0106);! ,%! 32030%*(! 9)! (*.! I'&&*2! ,.(! &*.!

P01(*!DEFUUH!&#*!3204*%%!%#0'1(!6',2(!,6,$.%&!2*1)$.6!&00!-'4#!0.!0.*!-*($'-!

05!40--'.$4,&$0.?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! B*>*2,1! 2*%30.(*.&%!,26'*(! &#,&! &#0'6#!-'4#! $.502-,&$0.! $%!,>,$1,91*!0.!

&#*!C*9%$&*;!3*031*!,2*! 2*1'4&,.&! &0! 2*,(! &#0%*?!J.!*+,4&! 2*,%0.! 502! &#$%!C,%!.0&!

6$>*.;!9'&!$&!-$6#&!9*!2*1,&*(!&0!3*031*A%!*+3*2$*.4*!C$&#!1*.6&#)!,.(!($55$4'1&!&0!

'.(*2%&,.(!301$4)!(04'-*.&%;!,.(!,.!*+3*4&,&$0.!&#,&!&#*!5$1*%!0.!&#*!C*9%$&*!C$11!

9*!*K',11)!$.,44*%%$91*?!S5!&#,&!$%!&#*!4,%*;!$&!-$6#&!9*!$-302&,.&!&0!$.>*%&$6,&*!C,)%!

C$&#! C#$4#! &0! 10C*2! &#*! 9,22$*2! &0! (0C.10,($.6! &#*! 5$1*%! 02! 2*,($.6! 1$%&%! 05!

(*4$%$0.%?! `.*! -*&#0(! &0! 10C*2! &#$%! 9,22$*2! -$6#&! 9*! &#*! ,(03&$0.! 05! >$(*0!

-*%%,6*%;! ,%! 32030%*(! 9)! 2*%30.(*.&%! 9,%*(! 0.! &#*$2! *+3*2$*.4*! C$&#! :IIA%!

-*%%,6*%?!a0C*>*2;!]'$3*2!C,2.%!&#,&!)0'!%#0'1(!9*!4,2*5'1!.0&!&0!0>*2(0!&#$%?!

J4402($.6! &0! #$-! )0'! %#0'1(! 0.1)! 30%&! >$(*0%! $5! )0'! 2*,11)! #,>*! %0-*&#$.6!

$-302&,.&! &0! &*11?!`&#*2C$%*;!3*031*!-$6#&!6*&! &$2*(!05!C,&4#$.6! &#*!>$(*0%;! ,.(!

&#*! 2*%'1&$.6! 5'&'2*! 2*1'4&,.4*! &0! C,&4#! &#*%*! >$(*0%! -$6#&! -,/*! &#*-! -$%%!

$-302&,.&!$.502-,&$0.?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! )'!

! "#0'6#! $.! -,.)! $.&*2>$*C%! -*&#0(%! 502! $-320>$.6! &#*! 2*,4#! 05!

$.502-,&$0.! C*2*! ($%4'%%*(;! &#*! 30$.&! 05! #0C! -'4#! *5502&! $%! *.0'6#! C,%! ,1%0!

2,$%*(?!S5!)0'!,2*!3'&&$.6!40.%$(*2,91*!*5502&!$.&0!2*,4#$.6!3*031*;!,.(!3*031*!%&$11!

40-31,$.! ,90'&! ,! 1,4/! 05! $.502-,&$0.;! &#$%!-$6#&! 9*! ('*! &0! &#*!-*($,! '%*(;! 02!

3*2#,3%!502!&#*%*!3*031*!&#*!$.502-,&$0.!$%!.0&!$-302&,.&!*.0'6#!&0!3'&!%'55$4$*.&!

*5502&! $.&0! 09&,$.$.6! $&?! J11! 2*%30.(*.&%! C#0! -*.&$0.*(! $.502-,&$0.! 320>$%$0.!

,26'*(!&#,&!$-320>*-*.&%!40'1(!9*!-,(*?!a0C*>*2;!&#*2*!$%!,!1$-$&!&0!&#*!*5502&!

,.(!-0.*)! &#,&!)0'!4,.! 2*%*2>*! 502! $&?!"#*!30$.&! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)!05!

4$&$7*.%!&0!,4&$>*1)!100/!502!$.502-,&$0.!C,%!-0%&!%#,231)!3'&!9)!B$Q3*2%-,=!!

J9%&;4%! #/%! VC+:E! ,&! ;&/,/#<! ,5%$0%4I%0! #0! I+:,+$0! &'! #! 4#:E! &'! +)'&/$#,+&)L! %I%)!,5&C25!,5%<!,5%$0%4I%0!:&C4*!#40&!;C,!%''&/,! +),&!&>,#+)+)2!,5+0! +)'&/$#,+&)6! K,! +0!)&,!,5%!:#0%!,5#,!#!:&$;4#+)+)2!:+,+O%)!+0!#C,&$#,+:#44<!/+25,M!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! )(!

7.2.5. Influence

"#*! ,-0'.&! 05! $.51'*.4*! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! 4,.! #,>*! C$11! 9*! 42'4$,1! 502! $&%!

30&*.&$,1! 502!%'44*%%!02! 5,$1'2*?!a0C*>*2;! $.51'*.4*!4,.!9*!(*5$.*(!,.(!32,4&$4*(!

$.!>,2$0'%!C,)%?!"#*2*502*;! &#$%! %*4&$0.!90&#!(*,1%!C$&#! &#*! 1*>*1!05! $.51'*.4*!05!

%&,/*#01(*2%!,.(!&#*!",91*!$&%*15;!,.(!C$&#!&#*!($55*2*.&!&)3*%!05!$.51'*.4*?!!

! 8'2$.6!&#*!-,Q02$&)!05!&#*!$.&*2>$*C%;!2*%30.(*.&%!C*2*!,%/*(!&0!30%$&$0.!

&#*-%*1>*%! 02! &#*$2! 026,.$%,&$0.! 0.! ,.! $.&*2*%&k$.51'*.4*! -,&2$+?! J%! %#0C.! $.!

5$6'2*!l;!&#$%!&)3*!05!-,&2$+!4,.!#*13!>$%',1$%*!&#*!30%$&$0.!05!$.($>$(',1!02!>,2$0'%!

%&,/*#01(*2%! 2*6,2($.6! $.&*2*%&! ,.(! $.51'*.4*;! ,.(! 4,.! #*13! >$%',1$%*! 60,1%!

2*6,2($.6!4#,.6*%!$.!&#$%?!!

Influence-Interest Matrix

!

Figure 7. Influence-Interest Matrix.!DI,%*(!0.!B$(,C,);!EFFGH!

! ))!

B$.4*!&#*!%&'()!(0*%!.0&!,&&*-3&!&0!,.,1)%*!&#*!40.51$4&!,%!%'4#;!9'&!*+,-$.*%!&#*!

3*24*3&$0.%!05!#0C! &#*!G! $! 42$&*2$,! %#0'1(!9*!(*,1&!C$&#;! $&!C0'1(!.0&!,((!-'4#!

>,1'*! &0! $.41'(*! &#*! $.($>$(',1! 30%$&$0.%! 05! &#*! 2*%30.(*.&%! #*2*?!a0C*>*2;! &#*!

'%*!05!&#*!-,&2$+!($(!)$*1(!$.&*2*%&$.6!2*%'1&%?!O+4*3&!502!B:5&EE%)*!@/&)+)2%);!,11!

%&,&*(!&#,&!&#*)!#,(!,!#$6#!02!,&!1*,%&!2*1,&$>*1)!#$6#!$.&*2*%&!$.!&#*!8$,106'*!",91*?!

a0C*>*2;!-0%&! %&,&*(! &#*)!3*24*$>*(! &#*$2! $.51'*.4*! ,%!9*$.6! 1$-$&*(;! 02! ,&! 9*%&!

,>*2,6*?! B:5&EE%)*! @/&)+)2%)! ,26'*(! &#,&! &#0'6#! &#*)! #,>*! .0! $.&*2*%&! $.! &#*!

3204*%%;! &#*)! 5**1! &#,&! &#*$2!320&*%&%!(0!3'&!32*%%'2*!0.! &#*!",91*;! ,.(! &#*2*502*!

&#*)!3*24*$>*!&#*$2!$.51'*.4*!,%!-*($'-?!L*6,2($.6!&#*!303'1,&$0.!&#*!30$.&!C,%!

-,(*!&#,&!-0%&!1$/*1)!&#*!-,Q02$&)!C$11!.0C!9*!%$&',&*(!$.!&#*!90&&0-!1*5&!402.*2?!

"#*2*!$%!,!5**1$.6!05!>*2)!1$-$&*(!$.51'*.4*;!,.(!%$.4*!&#*2*!$%!%&$11!-'4#!%4*3&$4$%-!

,90'&!&#*!,((*(!>,1'*!05! &#*!",91*;! $.&*2*%&! $%!,1%0! 10C?!a0C*>*2;!9)!*-310)$.6!

&#*! %&2,&*6$*%! 502! *.6,6$.6!3*031*! $.! &#*! 3204*%%! ,&! %0-*!30$.&;! ,%! 32*%*.&*(! $.!

%*4&$0.! l?E?V?! D$.41'%$>*.*%%H! $&! -$6#&! 9*! 30%%$91*! &#,&! &#*%*! 3*031*! -0>*! &0! ,!

30%$&$0.! $.!C#$4#! &#*)! 3*24*$>*! &#*)! ,&! 1*,%&! #,>*! %0-*! $.51'*.4*;! ,.(! &#*2*9)!

$.&*2*%&!-$6#&!,1%0!-0>*!&0!-*($'-!02!#$6#?!L*%30.(*.&%!,26'*(!&#,&!$.!02(*2!&0!

*%&,91$%#!,!($,106'*!C$&#!&#*!2*6$0.!$&!$%!*%%*.&$,1!&0!,$-!502!&#$%!4#,.6*?!! !

! J11! 2*%30.(*.&%! ,62**(! &#,&! <JW! ,.(! :0>*2.-*.&! ,2*! 9)! 5,2! -02*!

30C*25'1! &#,.! &#*!0&#*2!3,2&$*%?!a0C*>*2;!C#*.!($%4'%%$.6!0&#*2!*.>$20.-*.&,1!

40.51$4&%;! B$Q3*2%-,!-*.&$0.! &#*! I2*.&! B3,2;! ,.(! %&,&*(! &#,&! $.! &#,&! 40.51$4&! &#*!

60>*2.-*.&!#,(!*>*.&',11)!%$(*(!C$&#!&#*!320&*%&*2%;!5024$.6!B#*11!&0!,9,.(0.!$&%!

31,.! &0! ('-3! &#*! 0$1! 2$6! D:2**.3*,4*;! EFUUH?! a0C*>*2;! $.! &#*! %$&',&$0.! 05!

:20.$.6*.!&#,&!-$6#&!9*!($55$4'1&!%$.4*!dFg!05!&#*!2*>*.'*!520-!6,%!320('4&$0.!$%!

*,2.*(!9)!&#*!60>*2.-*.&;!,.(!%$.4*!TFg!05!&#*!%#,2*%!05!W,,&%4#,3!:20.$.6*.;!

'.(*2!C#0%*! 2*%30.%$9$1$&)!<JW!*+310$&%! &#*!:20.$.6*.!6,%! 5$*1(;! $%! 0C.*(!9)!

=)%/2+%!A%*/+?'!"%*%/4#)*;!C#$4#!$%!$&%*15!0C.*(!9)!&#*!W$.$%&2)!05!O40.0-$4!J55,$2%!

DOI<;!EFUTH?!<JW!$%!05&*.!'%*(!&0!$.($4,&*!W,,&%4#,3!:20.$.6*.;!)*&!$.!02(*2!&0!

5'11)!'.(*2%&,.(!&#*!40.51$4&A%!().,-$4%!$&!$%!$-302&,.&!&0!/.0C!&#*!($55*2*.4*?!!

! *++!

<*+&!&0!&#$%;!B$Q3*2%-,!,26'*%!&#,&=!!

J35%!/%#4!#C,5&/+,<!*&%0!)&,! 4+%!7+,5!".FL!>C,!7+,5!B5%44!#)*!=88&)L!#)*!,5%0%!:&$;#)+%0!#/%!)&,!/%#44<!#7#/%!&'!75%/%!@/&)+)2%)!+0!0+,C#,%*6M!!

!Z02! &#*%*! 40-3,.$*%!<JW! $%! %$-31)! ,! 2*1,&$>*1)! %-,11! 3,2&! 05! &#*$2!C021(C$(*!

03*2,&$0.%;! ,.(! ('*! &0! &#*$2! ($%&,.4*! 520-! &#*! 40.51$4&! &#*! .*4*%%$&)! 05! 4#,.6*!

-$6#&!.0&!9*!5*1&!C$&#!5'11!'26*.4)?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!%*>*2,1!2*%30.(*.&%!40--*.&*(!

0.! #0C! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.! ,.(! %#,2$.6! ,'&#02$&)! C$&#! %&,/*#01(*2%! $%! .0&! 3,2&! 05!

<JWA%!40-3,.)!4'1&'2*;!,.(!&#*!%,-*!C,%!%,$(!,90'&!B#*11!,.(!O++0.?!8*!I0.&!

%&,&*%!$&!,%!50110C%=!!

!

J35%! +$#2%! ,5#,! K! 5#I%! &'! ,5%! 0+,C#,+&)! +0! ,5#,! #,! ".F! ;%&;4%! *&! )&,! /%#44<!C)*%/0,#)*!75#,!+0!5#;;%)+)26!3&!,5%$!+,!$+25,!0%%$!,5#,!F/!I#)!*%!g%%$;C,!+0!>%+)2!:&),/&44%*!><!0&:+%,#4!;#/,+%0L!#)*! ,5#,! ,5%0%!;#/,+%0!)&7!*+:,#,%!75#,!B5%44!d".Fe!05&C4*!*&6!35+0!*&%0!)&,!'+,!B5%44U0!:&$;#)<!:C4,C/%L!#)*!,5%/%'&/%!+,!7+44!>%!I%/<!*+''+:C4,!'&/!I#)!*%!g%%$;C,!,&!*%'%)*!,5+0!:&C/0%!&'!#:,+&)M!!

!

8*!I0.&!,1%0!%&,&*%!&#,&!$.!02(*2!&0!%'3302&!>,.!(*!b**-3'&!$.!40--'.$4,&$.6!&#*!

C02/! 05! &#*! 8$,106'*! ",91*! &0! #$%! 40-3,.)! ,.(! $&%! %#,2*#01(*2%;! #*! C$11! 9*!

,110C*(! &0! 92$.6! ,.! ,%%$%&,.&! &0! &#*! -**&$.6%?! L*32*%*.&,&$>*! 05! &#*! \20>$.4$,1!

O+*4'&$>*![0'.4$1!W0021,6!C$11!1$/*1)!,1%0!9*!,110C*(!&0!(0!%0?!! ! !

! L*6,2($.6!&#*!&)3*!05!$.51'*.4*!&#*!",91*!%#0'1(!#,>*;!,!($%&$.4&$0.!$%!-,(*!

9*&C**.!502-,1!,.(!$.502-,1!,'&#02$&)!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT9H?!"#*!$%%'*%!40.4*2.$.6!

(*-042,&$4!1*6$&$-,4)!2,$%*(!$.!&#*!%*4&$0.!0.!$.41'%$>*.*%%!C*2*!05&*.!2*1,&*(!&0!

502-,1!,'&#02$&)?!B0-*!,26'*!&#,&!6$>$.6!&#*!",91*!,&!1*,%&!%0-*!502-,1!,'&#02$&)!

$%! ,! 32*40.($&$0.! 502! %'44*%%?! a0C*>*2;! -0%&! ,26'*! &#,&! $.%&*,(! 05! 502-,1!

,'&#02$&)!&#*!",91*!%#0'1(!03*2,&*!,.(!$.51'*.4*!9,%*(!0.!$.502-,1!,'&#02$&)?!S.!

&#$%! C,);! *+$%&$.6! (*-042,&$4,11)! 1*6$&$-,&*! %&2'4&'2*%! ,2*! 2*%3*4&*(;! ,.(! &#*!

",91*A%! ,(>$%*%! ,2*! 50110C*(! 9,%*(! 0.! &#*$2! K',1$&)! ,.(! 303'1,2! %'3302&?! S.! ,!

! *+*!

($%4'%%$0.!3,3*2!9)!&#*!3,2&$*%!&#,&!%$6.*(!&#*!2*302&!R0a^a>R!DEFUT,H!$&!$%!*>*.!

%&,&*(!&#,&=!!

!

J35+0!$%#)0!,5#,!&)%!&'!,5%!;#/,+%0!&'!,5%!,#>4%!7+44!%8%:C,%!#!$%#0C/%!,5#,!+0!>#0%*!&)! #*I+:%0! '&/! ,5%! 3#>4%6! 35%! 3#>4%! *&%0! )&,! +,0%4'! %8%:C,%! ,5%! $%#0C/%L! ,5%!/%0;&)0+>+4+,<! '&/! ,5#,! 7+44! /%$#+)! 7+,5! ,5%! /%0;&)0+>4%! ;#/,<6! 35#,! +0! )&,! #!7%#E)%00p!K)!,5+0!0+,C#,+&)!,5%!3#>4%!+0!+)!#!;&0+,+&)!,&!4#,%/!:&//%:,!,5%!;/&:%00!+'!,5#,!+0!*%%$%*!)%:%00#/<6!K'!,5%!3#>4%!7&C4*!+,0%4'!>%!/%0;&)0+>4%!'&/!,5%!%8%:C,+&)!&'!+,0!#*I+:%0L!,5%!0+,C#,+&)!,5#,!+0!:/%#,%*!+0!,5%!$&/%!*+''+:C4,!&)%!+)!75+:5!+,!7&C4*!5#I%!,&!:&//%:,!+,0%4'6!n%%;+)2!0&$%!*+0,#):%!+0!,5%/%'&/%!>%)%'+:+#4!'&/!,5%!#C,5&/+,<!&'!,5%!3#>4%M!DR0a^a>R;!EFUT9H! ! !! ! !

S.! 02(*2! &0! 9*! &,/*.! %*2$0'%1);! $&! $%! $-302&,.&! 502! &#*! ",91*! &0! 9*! ,91*! &0!

(*-0.%&2,&*!&#,&!$&!$%!9,4/*(!9)!303'1,2!%'3302&?!"#*!$.41'%$0.!05!%*>*.!%04$*&,1!

3,2&$*%!$%!,!%&2'4&'2,1!C,)!05!,4#$*>$.6!&#$%?!<*+&!&0!&#$%;!$.!02(*2!&0!%#0C!&#,&!$&%!

C02/!$%!$.(**(!,4#$*>$.6!2*%'1&%!&#,&!,2*!9,4/*(!9)!&#*!303'1,&$0.!&#*!",91*!#,%!

,62**(!&0!(0!3*2$0($4,1!@4'%&0-*2!%,&$%5,4&$0.!$.K'$2$*%A?!J4402($.6!&0!(*!I0.&!&#*!

5$2%&! 05! &#*%*! %#0'1(! 9*! %**.! ,%! ,! 9,%*1$.*! -*,%'2*-*.&;! ,5&*2! C#$4#! 5'&'2*!

$.K'$2$*%! 4,.! %#0C! C#*&#*2! %,&$%5,4&$0.! #,%! 2$%*.! 02! .0&?! S&! $%! #03*(! &#,&! 9)!

6,$.$.6! >$%$91*! %'3302&! 05! &#*! 303'1,&$0.! &#*! ",91*!C$11! 6,$.! ,'&#02$&)!C$&#0'&!

#,>$.6!9**.!62,.&*(!502-,1!,'&#02$&)?!"#$%!,3320,4#!$%!%$-$1,2!&0!&#0%*!05!*,21$*2!

-,&4#$.6! 70.*%! $.! &#*!<*&#*21,.(%! %'4#! ,%! BOL! DB04$0MO40.0-$4! [0'.4$1H?! BOL!

(0*%!.0&!#,>*!502-,1!,'&#02$&);!)*&!$&%!2*302&%!,2*!%*1(0-!$6.02*(!D(*.!I'&&*2!,.(!

&*.!P01(*;!EFUUH?!!

!

!

!

!

! *+"!

! *+#!

8. Conclusion

8.1. Satisfaction of success criteria & shared solutions

a,>$.6! *+,-$.*(! &#*! 3*24*3&$0.%! 05! #0C! &#*!8$,106'*! ",91*! %#0'1(! %,&$%5)! &#*!

5$>*! @$r! 42$&*2$,! $&! %**-%! &#,&! &#*2*! $%! 90&#! ,! 31'2,1$&)! 05! >$*C%;! ,.(! &#,&!

$-320>*-*.&%!&#,&!#*13!%,&$%5)!,!1,26*!.'-9*2!05!&#*%*!>$*C%!,2*!30%%$91*?!!

! B0-*! 0330%$.6! >$*C%!-$6#&! 9*! 2*40.4$1*(! 9)! 41*,21)! 40--'.$4,&$.6! &#*!

2*,%0.%! 502! #,>$.6! 03&*(! 502! ,! 4*2&,$.! ,3320,4#?! O+,-31*%! 05! &#$%! 40'1(! 9*! &#*!

03*..*%%!05!&#*!-**&$.6%;!,.(!&#*!,9%*.4*!05!502-,1!,'&#02$&)?!S&!%#0'1(!9*!41*,21)!

*+31,$.*(! &#,&! &#*! -**&$.6%! ,2*! .0&! 9*#$.(! 410%*(! (002%! 502! 3'230%*%! 05!

-,.$3'1,&$0.;!9'&!&0!*%&,91$%#!,.!*.>$20.-*.&!$.!C#$4#!3,2&$4$3,.&%!5**1!%,5*;!,.(!

$.!C#$4#!(*4$%$0.%! 4,.!9*!-,(*?!`5! 40'2%*!32030.*.&%! 05! 03*..*%%! 05!-**&$.6%!

4,..0&!9*!*+3*4&*(!&0!9*1$*>*!&#$%!,&!5,4*!>,1'*;!,.(!&#*2*502*!$&!$%!$-302&,.&!&#,&!

%,5*6',2(%! ,.(! 32005! ,2*! 320>$(*(?! J! 30%%$91*! %,5*6',2(! $%! &#*! 03*..*%%! ,5&*2!

-**&$.6%;!,.(!32005!$%!320>$(*(!C#*.;!,%!,26'*(!502!9)!(*!I0.&;!&#*!",91*!%#0C%!

&#,&!$&!$%!.0&!$.&*.(*(!&0!h9*!-,.$3'1,&*(i!,.(!1*6$&$-$%*!301$4)?! ! !

! S&!-$6#&!,1%0!9*!30%%$91*!&0!5$.(!%#,2*(!%01'&$0.%;!$.!C#$4#!&#*!%&20.6!30$.&%!

05! ($55*2*.&! ,3320,4#*%! 40-31*-*.&! *,4#! 0&#*2;! C#$1*! &#*)! #*13! 10C*2! &#*!

C*,/.*%%*%?! J.! *+,-31*! 05! &#$%! $%! &#*! ($1*--,! 9*&C**.! C,.&$.6! &0! 32*%*.&!

,4#$*>*-*.&%! ,.(!.0&!#,>$.6! &#*%*!0>*2%#,(0C*(!9)! 42$&$4,1! #*,(1$.*%;! ,.(! &#*!

$-302&,.4*!05!03*..*%%?!"#*%*!>$*C%!%#,2*!&#*!$-302&,.4*!05!32*%*.&$.6!,!2*1$,91*!

,.(! 4,3,91*! ",91*?!a0C*>*2;! $.! 0.*! >$*C!32*%*.&,&$0.! $%! 32$02$&$%*(;! ,.(! $.! &#*!

0&#*2! &2,.%3,2*.4)?! I,%*(! 0.! >,2$0'%! $.&*2>$*C%;! $&! %**-%! &#,&! 3,2&! 05! &#$%!

($%,62**-*.&!$%!9,%*(!0.!($55*2*.&!>$*C%!0.!C#,&!40.%&$&'&*%!@%'44*%%A?!!

! P#*2*!%0-*!2*6,2(*(!&#*!X'.*!Ef&#!(*4$%$0.!0.!&#*!*+*4'&$>*!026,.$%,&$0.!

,%!,!%'44*%%;!502!:II!$&!C,%!%&$11!'.41*,2!$5!$&%!-*-9*2%!C0'1(!,44*3&!&#*!(*4$%$0.?!

\2*%*.&$.6! &#$%! ,%! ,! %'44*%%!-$6#&! 9,4/5$2*! $5! :II! (0*%! .0&! -,.,6*! &0! %*11! &#*!

! *+$!

,62**-*.&!&0! $&%!-*-9*2%?! S.!02(*2!&0!9*!,91*!&0!*+31,$.!C#)!:IIA%!3,2&$4$3,.&%!

,62**(! &0! &#$%! (*4$%$0.;! 03*..*%%! ,90'&! &#*! 3204*%%! $%! *%%*.&$,1?! a0C*>*2;!

32030.*.&%!05!&#$%!03*..*%%!,1%0!,62**(!&#,&!32*%*.&,&$0.!05!2*,1!,4#$*>*-*.&%!$%!

$-302&,.&?!I,%*(!0.!&#$%;!$&!-$6#&!9*!30%%$91*!&0!-,/*!-,.)!,62**!0.!&#$%!40--0.!

620'.(;!0.!C#$4#! &#*!%&2*.6&#%!05!90&#!,2*!*-310)*(;!,.(! $.!C#$4#!C*,/.*%%*%!

,2*!1$-$&*(?! ! ! ! ! !! ! ! ! !

! S&! -$6#&! 9*! &#,&! %0-*! 30%$&$0.%! ,2*! %$-31)! .0.M.*60&$,91*?! a0C*>*2;! $&!

-$6#&!9*!&#,&!&#*!32$.4$31*!D*?6?!03*..*%%H!$%!.0.M.*60&$,91*;!)*&!&#,&!$&%!*+*4'&$0.!

$%!51*+$91*?!S.!&#,&!%$&',&$0.!41*,2;!40--'.$4,&$0.!05!2,&$0.,1*!-$6#&!9*!%'55$4$*.&?!

S.! 4,%*! &#$%! $%! .0&! 30%%$91*;! 41*,2! 40--'.$4,&$0.! 05! &#*! 2,&$0.,1*! 9*#$.(! 4*2&,$.!

(*4$%$0.%!$%!%&$11!'%*5'1;!%$.4*!$&!#*13%!*+31,$.!&#*!9,%*%!502!($%,62**-*.&?!S&!$%!.0&!

,1C,)%!30%%$91*! &0!,62**j!)*&!'.(*2%&,.($.6! &#*!9,%*%! 502!($%,62**-*.&!4,.!#*13!

%&,9$1$%*!&#*!50'.(,&$0.!0.!C#$4#!4003*2,&$0.!$%!502-*(?!! ! !

! "#*!60,1!05!$-320>$.6!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6!(0*%!.0&!.*4*%%,2$1)!#,>*!&0!

9*! ,62**-*.&! 0.! &#*! $%%'*! ,&! #,.(?! B$-31)! $-320>$.6! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! *,4#!

0&#*2%A!30%$&$0.%!4,.!9*!9*.*5$4$,1!$.!$&%*15;!,.(!$&!%**-%!&#,&!-,.)!3,2&$*%!,2*!03*.!

&0! &#$%?! O.6,6$.6! $.! &#$%! 3204*%%! $%! ,! %$6.! 05! -'&',1! $.&*2*%&! ,.(! 2*%3*4&;! ,.(!

&#*2*502*! ,.! *%%*.&$,1! 9,%$%! 05! 4003*2,&$0.?! S&! $%! $-302&,.&! &#,&! &#$%! 3204*%%! 05!

$.42*,%$.6!-'&',1!'.(*2%&,.($.6!$%!.0&! 1$-$&*(!&0!&#*!-*-9*2%!05! &#*!",91*;!9'&!

&#,&!&#*!*+*24$%*!$%!*+&*.(*(!&0!$.41'(*!,%!-,.)!%&,/*#01(*2!>$*C%!,%!30%%$91*?!!

! Z$.,11);!&#*!$.41'%$0.!05!@$.&*.&$0.A!,%!&#*!5$5&#!%'44*%%!42$&*2$0.!#,%!2*4*$>*(!

-'4#!,3320>,1?!J1&#0'6#! 5*C!C0'1(!0330%*!#,>$.6!600(! $.&*.&$0.;! $&!-$6#&!9*!

$-302&,.&!502!3,2&$*%!&0!40.%$(*2!&#*$2!$.&*.&$0.!,.(!&#0%*!05!0&#*2%!-02*!*+31$4$&1);!

90&#!9*502*!,.(!('2$.6!&#*!3204*%%?!!

!

!

! *+%!

8.2. Transferability of results

`Ab*,2)!DEFUTH!(*5$.*%!&2,.%5*2,9$1$&)!,%!50110C%=!!

n?0#*:;(0#I"$"9.)`!75%,5%/!'+)*+)20!#)*X&/!:&):4C0+&)0!'/&$!#!0#$;4%L!0%,,+)2L!&/!2/&C;! 4%#*! ,&! 4%00&)0! 4%#/)%*! ,5#,! $#<! >%! 2%/$#)%! ,&! #! 4#/2%/! ;&;C4#,+&)L! #!*+''%/%),!0%,,+)2L!&/!#)&,5%/!2/&C;M!DfEH!

"#*!%&'()!#,%!&C0!-,$.!4,&*602$*%!05!5$.($.6%?!Z$2%&;!,1&#0'6#!#,>$.6!%&,2&*(!C$&#!

B$(,C,)A%!DEFFGH!42$&*2$,!D$.$&$,&$0.;!$.41'%$>*.*%%;!$.502-,&$0.;!,.(!$.51'*.4*H;!&#*!

2*%'1&%!05! &#*! 5$*1(C02/!#,>*! 1*(! &0! &#*! 40.41'%$0.! &#,&! $&!-$6#&!9*! $-302&,.&! &0!

$.41'(*!@$.&*.&$0.A!,%!&#*!5$5&#!42$&*2$0.?!"#*!%*40.(!%*&!05!5$.($.6%!40.4*2.%!$&%*15!

C$&#!&#*!3*24*$>*(!%,&$%5,4&$0.!05!&#*%*!42$&*2$,!$.!&#*!4'22*.&!4,%*!%&'();!,.(!C$&#!

30%%$91*!%#,2*(!%01'&$0.%?!! !

8.2.1. ʻIntentionʼ

[0.4*2.$.6! @$.&*.&$0.A! $&!40'1(!9*!%,$(!&#,&! &#$%! $%! 1$/*1)!6*.*2,1$%,91*! &0!,! 1,26*2!

303'1,&$0.;!($55*2*.&!%*&&$.6;!02!,.0&#*2!620'3?!"#*!2*%30.(*.&%!$.!&#$%!%&'()!C*2*!

6*.*2,11)!%'3302&$>*!05!&#*!$(*,!&0!-,/*!&#$%!3,2&!05!$.$&$,&$0.!-02*!*+31$4$&;!,.(!&0!

,((! ,! 2*40--*.(,&$0.! 502! &#*! -0.$&02$.6! 05! 3*24*$>*(! $.&*.&$0.! ('2$.6! &#*!

3204*%%?!J1&#0'6#! &#*! %,-31*! %$7*!,.(! 2*%*,24#!,2*,!C*2*! 2*1,&$>*1)! 1$-$&*(;! &#*!

,3320>,1!05!&#*!,(($&$0.!05!$.&*.&$0.!41*,21)!%#0C*(?!! ! ! !

! \0%%$91*! 42$&$4$%-! ,6,$.%&! $&%! $.41'%$0.! $.41'(*%! 42$&$4$%-! 2*6,2($.6! &#*!

>,1'*!05!&#$%!,(($&$0.;!,.(!,.!,26'-*.&!502!%$-31$4$&)?!<0&!*>*2)0.*!-$6#&!%**!&#*!

$-302&,.4*!05!$&%!,(($&$0.;!,.(!40.%$(*2$.6!C#,&!)0'!C,.&!,.(!C#,&!0&#*2%!&#$./!

05!)0';!-$6#&!9*!2*6,2(*(!,%!,!.,&'2,1!3,2&!05!&#*!3204*%%?![0.4*2.$.6!%$-31$4$&);!

&#*! >*2)! >,1$(! 30$.&! 4,.! 9*! -,(*! &#,&! ,! %*&! 05! 40-3,4&! 42$&*2$,! %#0'1(! .0&! 9*!

*+3,.(*(!&00!*,%$1)?!S.!02(*2!&0!%**!$.!#0C!5,2!&#$%!5$.($.6!C0'1(!9*!&2,.%5*2,91*;!

$&!C0'1(!&#*2*502*!9*!600(!&0!&*%&!2*,4&$0.%!$.!0&#*2!3204*%%*%!,.(!%$&',&$0.%;!,.(!

&0!40-3,2*! $&%! $.41'%$0.! &0!30%%$91*! $.41'%$0.%!32030%*(!9)!0&#*2%?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!

! *+&!

C#*.!&*%&$.6!&#*!1$-$&%!05!&2,.%5*2,9$1$&)!,!420%%M4'1&'2,1!4#*4/!C0'1(!9*!600(?!Z02!

$.%&,.4*;!$.!,!4'1&'2*!C#*2*!-'4#!$%!9,%*(!0.!40.&*+&;!41*,21)!#,>$.6!&0!%&,&*!)0'2!

$.&*.&$0.!-$6#&!.0&!9*!3*24*$>*(!,%!>*2)!40-502&,91*?!!! ! ! !

! !

8.2.2. Satisfaction of criteria and shared solutions

"#*!&2,.%5*2,9$1$&)!05!&#*%*!2*%'1&%!-$6#&!9*!-02*!1$-$&*(!&#,.!&#,&!05!&#*!,(($&$0.!

05!@$.&*.&$0.A!&0!&#*!1$%&!05!42$&*2$,?!8'*!&0!&#*!%$7*!,.(!40-30%$&$0.!05!&#*!%,-31*!$&!

$%!41*,2!&#,&!>$*C%!#,>*!9**.!-$%%*(?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!*,4#!3204*%%!C$11!9*!($55*2*.&;!

,.(!*>*.!$.!&#$%!%&'()!2*%30.(*.&%!30$.&*(!0'&!&#,&!%&,.(,2($%*(!,3320,4#*%!4,.!

9*!32091*-,&$4!('*! &0!($55*2*.4*%! $.! 2*6$0.,1!#$%&02)!,.(!4'1&'2*?!a0C*>*2;! $&! $%!

5$.($.6%!%'4#!,%!&#*%*!&#,&!-$6#&!9*!&2,.%5*2,91*?!P#*.!.0&!2*6,2(*(!,%!&#*!9,%$%!

502!,! &001M/$&;!9'&!,%!,! 50'.(,&$0.! 520-!C#$4#! &0!*+3102*!3*24*3&$0.%!05!,! 5'&'2*!

-,&4#$.6!70.*;!&#*!5$.($.6%!05!&#$%!%&'()!4,.!9*!'%*5'1?!S.!&#,&!%$&',&$0.;!&#*)!(0!

.0&!%*2>*!&0!&*11!&#*!2*,(*2!C#,&!&0!(0;!9'&!&0!%#0C!&#*!2*,(*2!,!>*2)!($>*2%*!2,.6*!

05!>$*C%!&#,&!-$6#&!#*13!C$(*.!&#*!2*,(*2A%!3*2%3*4&$>*;!,.(!30$.&! &#*!2*,(*2! &0!

*+,-$.*!4*2&,$.!3*24*3&$0.%!&#,&!-$6#&!0&#*2C$%*!#,>*!9**.!-$%%*(?!! !

! \*2#,3%!-02*!%0!&#,.!$.!&#*!$.41'%$0.!05!$.&*.&$0.;!4'1&'2,1!5,4&02%!4,.!31,)!

,.!$-302&,.&!201*?!a0C*>*2;!*>*.!$.!&#,&!%$&',&$0.;!&#*!,3320,4#!4,.!%&$11!9*!'%*5'1?!

<*>*2&#*1*%%;!$&!$%!$-302&,.&!&0!.0&*!&#,&!&#*!%&,/*#01(*2!3*24*3&$0.%!32*%*.&*(!$.!

&#$%!%&'()!,2*!&,/*.!520-!,!2*1,&$>*1)!%-,11!%,-31*;!,.(!&#,&!&#*%*!%*2>*!&0!%#0C!

&#*!31'2,1$&)!05!30%%$91*!>$*C%!,.(!30%%$91*!C,)%!$.!C#$4#!&0!2*40.4$1*!&#*%*;!9'&!

&#,&!$&!$%!.0&!41,$-*(!&#,&!&#*%*!,2*!*+#,'%&$>*?!

!

!

!

! *+'!

8.3. Lessons learned & reflections for future research

"#*!5$2%&!1*%%0.!S!#,>*!1*,2.*(!520-!&#$%!%&'()!$%!&#,&!>$*C%!40.%$(*2*([email protected]!9)!

1$&*2,&'2*! %#0'1(! %&$11! 9*! &,/*.! >*2)! %*2$0'%1);! ,.(! &#,&! &#*)! 05&*.! #,>*! %01$(!

50'.(,&$0.%?!"#*2*502*;!$&!$%!$-302&,.&!&0!2*,11)!&2)!&0!5$.(!0'&!C#)!,!3*2%0.!#,%!,!

($55*2*.&!>$*C?! S.! $&%! 50'.(,&$0.! $&!-$6#&!9*!30%%$91*! &0! 5$.(!,!32$.4$31*! &#,&!)0'!

,(#*2*! &0! ,%! C*11;! ,.(! 520-! &#*2*! $&! -$6#&! 9*! 30%%$91*! &0! 40.%&2'4&! ,! -'&',11)!

,62**,91*!%01'&$0.?!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! J.0&#*2! 1*%%0.! $%! 40.4*2.$.6! &#*!3204*%%?!I*$.6!,C,)! 520-!'.$>*2%$&)! 502!

5$*1(C02/!,.(!#,>$.6!&0!%&,2&!&#$%!2*%*,24#!C#*.!.0&!)*&!#,>$.6!9**.!@$.!&#*!5$*1(A!

$%!.0&!&0!9*!'.(*2*%&$-,&*(?!8'2$.6!&#*!%&,2&$.6!3#,%*!05!&#*!3204*%%!S!C,%!%&$11!$.!

O($.9'26#;! C#*2*! 6*&&$.6! $.M(*3&#! $.502-,&$0.! ,90'&! &#*! 3204*%%! C,%! ($55$4'1&;!

,.(! 6*&&$.6! ,! (**3*2! '.(*2%&,.($.6! 05! &#*! %*.&$-*.&%! $.! C$(*2! %04$*&)! C,%!

>$2&',11)! $-30%%$91*?! a0C*>*2;! S! ($(! .0&! )*&! 40.&,4&! %&,/*#01(*2%;! %$.4*! S! 5*1&!

2*1'4&,.&! &0!(0!%0!9,%*(!0.!-)!0C.! $6.02,.4*!05! &#*!32091*-!,&! &#,&! &$-*?!"#$%!

($1*--,!C$11! 2*-,$.!,.! $%%'*! $.! %$-$1,2! 5'&'2*! %$&',&$0.%;! %$.4*!C#*.!,%/$.6! 502!

#*13!)0'!(0!.0&!C,.&! &0!,22$>*!C$&#0'&!/.0C1*(6*;!)*&! &#*! &$-*! 10%&!9)!C,$&$.6!

'.&$1!,22$>,1!-$6#&!9*!&00!>,1',91*!&0!10%*?!! ! ! ! ! !

! \,2&$,11)!9,%*(!0.!,!4#,.6$.6!'.(*2%&,.($.6!05!&#*!%$&',&$0.;!,.(!9,%*(!0.!

1*%%0.%! 1*,2.*(! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! %'9Q*4&;! S! #,>*! 4#,.6*(! -)! 2*%*,24#! K'*%&$0.!

#,15C,)! &#20'6#! &#*! %&'()?! "#*! $.$&$,1! 2*%*,24#! K'*%&$0.! C,%! 40.4*2.*(! C$&#!

5$.($.6!30%%$91*!$.62*($*.&%!502!@/$4/M%&,2&$.6A!,!3,2&$4$3,&$0.!3204*%%?!Z20-!41,%%!S!

#,(! 1*,2.*(! &#,&! &#*%*!3204*%%*%!05&*.! &,/*! 10.6! &0! %&,9$1$%*! ,.(!,4#$*>*! 2*%'1&%?!

"#*2*502*;!S!C,%!$.&*2*%&*(!$.!30%%$91*!C,)%!05!%3**($.6!&#$%!'3?!a0C*>*2;!('2$.6!

&#*! 2*%*,24#! $&! %**-*(! &#,&! $&!-$6#&!.0&!9*!30%%$91*! &0!,.%C*2! &#$%!K'*%&$0.! $.!,!

30%$&$>*!C,)?!Z'2&#*2-02*;!S!2*,1$%*(!&#,&!-)!%&,/*#01(*2!%,-31*!,.(!&$-*52,-*!

C0'1(! .0&! 9*! 1,26*! *.0'6#! &0! 2*,11)! %,)! %0-*&#$.6! ,90'&! &#*%*! $.62*($*.&%?!

Z$.,11);! -)! $.&*2*%&! $.! 3*24*3&$0.%! ,%! 30&*.&$,11)! *K',11)! >,1',91*! ,%! &#*!

! *+(!

@%&2'4&'2*%A!,.(!@3204*%%*%A!&#*-%*1>*%!9*4,-*!$.42*,%$.61)!$.&2$6'$.6?!! !

! S.! 02(*2! &0!3'2%'*! &#,&! K'*%&$0.! $&! 9*4,-*! $-302&,.&! &0! 1*,>*! &#$.6%! 0'&?!

O,2&#K',/*%;!6,%!320('4&$0.;!,.(!K'*%&$0.%!05!C#0!$%!@2$6#&A!,.(!C#0!$%[email protected]!,&!

&#*!",91*!C*2*!.0!10.6*2!3,2&!05!&#*!-,$.!2*%*,24#!K'*%&$0.?!a0C*>*2;!$.!&#*!5$2%&!

C**/%!,5&*2!4#,.6$.6!504'%!&#*%*!C*2*!%&$11!0.!-)!-$.(;!,.(!1*,>$.6!&#*-!0'&!5*1&!

1$/*!,!@9*&2,),1A!&0!*,21$*2!2*%*,24#;!*%3*4$,11)!$5!&#,&!#,(!&,/*.!%0-*0.*!*1%*A%!&$-*?!

a0C*>*2;!.0&!1*,>$.6!&#*%*!0'&!C0'1(!&,/*!&#*!504'%!0'&!05!&#*!($%%*2&,&$0.;!,.(!

&,/*!&#*!%3,4*!05!-,&*2$,1!-02*!2*1*>,.&!&0!&#$%!K'*%&$0.?!"#*2*502*;!$.!&#*!5'&'2*!S!

C$11!,&&*-3&!&0!9*!1*%%!9'2(*.*(!9)!*,21$*2!2*%*,24#?!! ! ! ! !

! [0.4*2.$.6! 5'&'2*! 2*%*,24#! S! C0'1(! 9*! $.&*2*%&*(! $.! ,! 40.&$.',&$0.! 05!

2*%*,24#! 2*6,2($.6! &#*! 31,4*! 05! @$.&*.&$0.A! ,%! ,! %'44*%%! 42$&*2$0.;! ,.(! ,! -02*!

C$(*%32*,(! %*,24#! 502! &#*! 50'.(,&$0.%! 05! 3*2%3*4&$>*%?! [0.4*2.$.6! $.&*.&$0.! $&!

C0'1(!9*!$.&*2*%&$.6!&0!&*%&!2*,4&$0.%!$.!,!C$(*2!40--'.$&);!,.(!&0!40-3,2*!$&!&0!

0&#*2! 30&*.&$,11)! $-302&,.&! .*C! 42$&*2$,?! [0.4*2.$.6! -'&',1! '.(*2%&,.($.6;! $&!

C0'1(! 9*! $.&*2*%&$.6! &0! ,331)! &#*! %*,24#! 502! &#*! 200&%! 05! ($%,62**-*.&! -02*!

C$(*1);! 502! 32,4&$&$0.*2%! &0! 1*&! 3,2&$4$3,.&%! *+3*2$-*.&! C$&#! *+31$4$&1)! %&,&$.6!

$.&*.&$0.%;!,.(!&0!&2)!,.(!-,3!&#*!$.&*.&$0.%!05!&#0%*!05!$.>01>*(!$.!Q0$.&!*+*24$%*%?!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! *+)!

Reference:!Jb8OLB"JZOb!DEFUTH!TI%/!*%!.4*%/0,#'%46!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?,1(*2%&,5*1?.1k!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

JL<B"OS<;!B?L?!DUdfdH!.!g#**%/!&'!(+,+O%)!9#/,+:+;#,+&)6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kk1$&#60CM%4#-$(&?(/k%#*22)M,2.%&*$.k1,((*2M05M4$&$7*.M! 3,2&$4$3,&$0.?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!UEkFekEFUTi!

II[!DEFUVH!@/&)+)2%)!2#0!'+%4*0!b!35%!1C,:5!%#/,5VC#E%!O&)%6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!

#&&3=kkCCC?994?40-k.*C%kC021(M*'203*MEEGTEdeE!!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

IbJ[]B"`[];!]?b?;!]Obbq;!:?X?;!a`LBOLq;!I?b?!DEFFlH!8*>*103$.6!,.(!! J331)$.6!,!Z2,-*C02/!&0!O>,1',&$>*!\,2&$4$3,&02)!L*%*,24#!502!! B'%&,$.,9$1$&)?!=:&4&2+:#4!=:&)&$+:0;!aV=!lEfMlTE?!

IN""OL;!Z?J?:?!(*.;!^!W`B[a;!L?a?X?!DEFFVH!"#*!8'&4#!W$2,41*=!S.%&$&'&$0.%;!! <*&C02/%;!,.(!"2'%&?!o&C/)#4!&'!K)0,+,C,+&)#4!#)*!35%&/%,+:#4!=:&)&$+:0L!! OZN=!VfEMVdU?!!

IN""OL;!Z?J?:?!(*.;!^!P`b8O;!B?!&*.?!DEFUUH!35%!K)0,+,C,+&)#4!=:&)&$+:0!&'!! B,#E%5&4*%/!(&)0C4,#,+&)N!D%*C:+)2!K$;4%$%),#,+&)!(&0,0!35/&C25!! RF#,:5+)2!q&)%0U6!"$.9*26*.!S.%&$&'&*!8$%4'%%$0.!\,3*2;!<0?!UUMUfEkV?!!

[`WWSBBSO!I`8OW8JbS<:!DEFUTH!]%4E&$!>+?!*%!(&$$+00+%!! A&*%$*#4+)26!! J>,$1,91*!520-=!!! #&&3=kkCCC?40--$%%$*90(*-(,1$.6?.1k3,6*%kUFeTfTka0-*?#&-1!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

[`L8O<;! W?! ^! <OJLq;! X?\?! DUdeEH! I00-$.6! B*4&02! ,.(! 8*MS.('%&2$,1$%,&$0.!! $.!,!B-,11!`3*.!O40.0-)?!35%!=:&)&$+:!o&C/)#4L!NU;!DVfeH=!eEGMeTe?!!

[LOS:a"`<;!X?b?!DUdleH!]5<!(&)*C:,!9C>4+:!K)I&4I%$%),!9/&2/#$0!'&/!! D%2C4#,&/<!\C):,+&)0_;!$.![LOS:a"`<;!X?b?;!8ObbS!! \LSB[`bS;!X?!^!! IJbbO<"S<O;!"?!D*(%H;!9C>4+:!K)I&4I%$%),!D%2C4#,&/<!!9/&2/#$0-!! 3/#+)+)2!F#)C#4L!K)0,+,C,%!&'!]#,%/!D%0&C/:%0;!P,%#$.6&0.;!8[?!!

8SJb``:"JZOb!DEFUTH!TI%/+2%!1&:C$%),%)?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!! hJ44*%%*(!! !UEkFekEFUTi!

8LqcO];!X?B?!DUddFH!1+0:C/0+I%!1%$&:/#:<-!9&4+,+:0L!9&4+:<L!#)*!9&4+,+:#4!B:+%):%6!! [,-92$(6*=![,-92$(6*!N.$>*2%$&)!\2*%%?!!

! **+!

8Ra<!DEFUTH!P,11,6*!b*6&!I0-!0.(*2!8$,1006&,5*1?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?(>#.?.1k.$*'C%k*40.0-$*kC,11,6*M1*6&M90-M0.(*2M! ($,1006&,5*1MUUEVfVUV?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi!

OI<!DEFUTH!F##,0:5#;!@/&)+)2%)6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?*9.?.1kB,-*.C*2/$.6*.O.\20Q*4&*.k320('4&$*k\,6$.,%k:2! 0.$.6*.?,%3+!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

Z`LLOB"OL;!X?!DEFFeH!35%!1%4+>%/#,+I%!9/#:,+,+&)%/6!WS"!\2*%%;![,-92$(6*;!!NBJ?!!

ZLO8OLS];!X?!DEFUTH!a0*!**.!J-*2$/,,.%*!c,/*.-,.!W$1Q0*.*.!R*2($*.(*!! ,,.!#*&!Z,$11$*&*!J1(*1?!1%!(&//%0;&)*%),6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3%=kk(*4022*%30.(*.&?.1kllTka0*M**.MJ-*2$/,,.%*M7,/*.-,.M! -$1Q0*.*.M>*2($*.(*M,,.M#*&M5,$11$*&*MJ1(*1klEGTFEEGFGTMlTE*,fVF!! hJ44*%%*(!UEkFekEFUTi!

:II!DEFUT,H!G+*%&>4&26!J>,$1,91*!520-=!#&&3=kk620.$.6*2M90(*-M! 9*C*6$.6?.1k$.(*+?3#3k>$(*09106!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi!

:II!DEFUT9H!9%/0>%/+:5,!r+,I&%/+)20&/2#)+0#,+%6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi! !

:II!DEFUT4H!I*>$.6%/,,2&?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!#&&3=kkCCC?620.$.6*2M90(*-M! 9*C*6$.6?.1k$.(*+?3#3k9*>$.6%/,,2&!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

:OOb;!\?!^!PJbbJ:O;!X?!DEFUTH!.#)!,#'%46!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!! hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!

:`WOc;! :?W?;! [`LLJ8S;! J?J?;! :`NbJL";! \?! ^! <JWJLJ;! L?! DEFUFH!! 9#/,+:+;#,+&)!'&/!]5#,-!B&:+#4!(5#)2%!&/!B&:+#4!(&),/&4_!L0&&*2(,-;! !! !S.&*2.,&$0.,1!S.%&$&'&*!05!B04$,1!B&'($*%;!O2,%-'%!N.$>*2%$&)?!!

:LOO<\OJ[O! DEFUUH! UddG! Y! B#*11! L*>*2%*%! 8*4$%$0.! &0! 8'-3! &#*! I2*.&! B3,2?!! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?62**.3*,4*?026k$.&*2.,&$0.,1k*.k,90'&k#$%&02)kR$4&02$*%M! &$-*1$.*kI2*.&MB3,2k!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

:L`<S<:O<!<``L8!DEFUT,H!9/&?%:,%)?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?620.$.6*..002(?.1kp3,6*s$(_EV!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

:L`<S<:O<!<``L8!DEFUT9H!1#2![-!1%!1+#4&&2,#'%46!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?620.$.6*..002(?.1kp3_TUT!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!!

! ***!

aJL8q;!\?!^!c8J<;!"?X?!DUddlH!9/+):+;4%0!+)!9/#:,+:%6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?$$%(?026k3(5k9*11,6$0?3(5!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

aNLB"`<;!c?<?!DUdTEH!1C0,!3/#:E0!&)!#!D&#*6!<*C!q02/;!a,23*2![011$.%?!!

S<:O<SONL! DEFUTH! @#0'a/*%/C)2! I%/C/0#:5,! =/*>%>%)0%/+%! +)! *%)! "+%*%/4#)*%)6!! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?$.6*.$*'2?(*kI2,.4#*.kO.*26$*C$2&%4#,5&k:,%50*2(*2'.6M! >*2'2%,4#&MO2(9*9*.%*2$*M$.M<$*(*21,.(*.!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi!

]JW\;! a?! DEFUTH! W$.(*2! :,%C$..$.6;! R*2%&*2/$.6%3,//*&! >002! :20.$.6*.?!! W$.$%&*2$*!>,.!O40.0-$%4#*!c,/*.?!!

]bOS<S<:;!:?!^!PS"";!a?!DEFFFH!"#*!m',1$&,&$>*!a*'2$%&$4!J3320,4#=!J!! W*&#0(0106)!502!8$%40>*2)!$.!\%)4#0106)!,.(!&#*!B04$,1!B4$*.4*%?!! L*($%40>*2$.6!&#*!W*&#0(!05!S.&20%3*4&$0.!,%!,.!O+,-31*?!\&/C$-!! fC#4+,#,+I%!B&:+#4!D%0%#/:5;!ODUH?!

]<WS!DEFUVH!"#*%/!G%/E4##/*-!.#/*>%I+)2%)!*&&/!@#07+))+)2!+)!"&&/*S! T&0,!! "%*%/4#)*6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?/.-$?.1k4-%k40.&*.&kEEddVk,,2(9*>$.6*.s(002s6,%C$..$.! 6s$.s.002(M.*(*21,.(!hJ44*%%*(!0.!FdkFekEFUTi! !

bOONPJL8OL![`NLJ<"!DUdlEH!A&*%$!1#4+)2!B,/+;6!L*&2$*>*(!>$,!! B4#0//*.(!:20.$.6*.?!!

bOONPSB;![?;!\qINL<;!L?!DO(%?H!DEFFEH!]5%%4>#//&70!'C44!&'!'/&20-!0&:+#4!4%#/)+)2!+)!! /C/#4!/%0&C/:%!$#)#2%$%),6!J%%*.;!]0.$./1$Q/*!>,.!:024'-?!

bS[aO<;!R?!DEFUTH!n##/,!"%*%/4#)*?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!#&&3=kkCCC?>0/0M! 1$4#*.?.1k>*29$.($.6k40.&,4&?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!0.!UVkFekEFUTi!

bSOIWJ<<;!W?!DEFFFH!F%*+#,+&)!+)!(&),%8,6!X*%%$4,!]$.6%1*)!\'91$%#*2%;!! b0.(0.?!!

WJJB;!J?!^![`[mNq";!"?!YO($&02%M!DEFUUH!G%/>&/2%)!n/#:5,%)-!"%*%/4#)*%/0!! &;!q&%E!)##/!=)%/2+%6!a$1>*2%'-;!R*2102*.?!!

WJL[NBO;!a?!DUdfdH!D%;/%00+I%!3&4%/#):%;!$.!P`bZ;!L?\?;!W``LO;!I?!Q2?!^!! WJL[NBO;!a?!DUdfdH!.!(/+,+VC%!&'!9C/%!3&4%/#):%6!I*,40.!\2*%%;!I0%&0.?!!

WOSXOL;!P?;! RJ<! :OOb;! \?;! "O! :L`"O<aNSB;! a?;! <SX\ObB;! O?! ^! I`BMBWS";!! W?! DEFUVH! G%/,/&C7%)! +)! %%)! 1CC/O#$%! 3&%E&$0,-! %%)! B,%I+2! 9%/0;%:,+%'!! I&&/!"&&/*ST&0,!@/&)+)2%)6!:20.$.6*.;!PW!R**.%&2,!

W``LO;![?P?!DUdefH!35%!F%*+#,+&)!9/&:%00-!9/#:,+:#4!D%#0&)0!'&/!D%0&4I+)2!! (&):4+:,6!! B,.!Z2,.4$%40;!X0%%*)MI,%%?!!

! **"!

W``LO;![?P?!DUddfH!35%!F%*+#,+&)!9/&:%00-!9/#:,+:#4!B,/#,%2+%0!'&/!D%0&4I+)2!! (&)'4+:,L!E.(!O($&$0.?!B,.!Z2,.4$%40;!X0%%*)MI,%%?!! !

<JW!DEFUT,H!.#/*>%I+)2%)!+)!@/&)+)2%)!D(**1!UH?!hJ44*%%*(!0.!FUkFekEFUTi!!>$,=!! #&&3=kkCCC?.,-31,&502-?.1kC3M! 40.&*.&k'310,(%kEFUVkFekS.5062,3#$4M! ,,2(9*>$.6*.M$.M620.$.6*.M(**1M!UM>*2%$*M-,,2&MEFUV?3(5!

<JW!DEFUT9H!\/#:E+)2-!$%%/!##/*2#0;/&*C:,+%!*&&/!I4&%+0,&'+)?%:,+%6!! hJ44*%%*(! 0.!! FUkFekEFUTi! #&&3=kkCCC?.,-?.1k.1k&*4#.0106)M,.(M! $..0>,&$0.k03&$-$7,&$0.M.,&'2,1M6,%k52,4/$.6?#&-1!

<JW\bJ"Z`LW! DEFUTH! O2>,2*.! >,.! J,2(9*>$.6*.?! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?.,-31,&502-?.1k,,2(9*>$.6*.k*2>,2*.M>,.M! ,,2(9*>$.6*.?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!0.!!FdkFekEFUTi!

<q"! DEFUTH! .! 2#0! :#:5%L! )&7! C)*%/! 05#E<! 2/&C)*6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?.)&$-*%?40-kEFUTkFfkFGk9'%$.*%%k$.&*2.,&$0.,1k*'203*%M! 9$6M6,%M4,4#*M$%M0.M%#,/$*2M620'.(?#&-1ps2_F!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

<q"! DEFUVH! 9#/,0! &'! ,5%! 4&7! :&C),/<! #/%! )&7! #! VC#E%! :&C),/<6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?.)&$-*%?40-kEFUVkFVkElkC021(k*'203*k-02*M*,2&#K',/*%M! $.M1033*2%'-M&#*M.*&#*21,.(%?#&-1p3,6*C,.&*(_,11! hJ44*%%*(!! UVkFekEFUTi!

`AbOJLq;! c?! DEFUTH! 35%! %00%),+#4! 2C+*%! ,&! *&+)2! <&C/! /%0%#/:5! ;/&?%:,6! E.(! *($&$0.?!! b0.(0.;!B,6*?!!

`ROLaOS8!DEFUTH!]%,!r+,I&%/+)2!G%/*/#2!I#)!.#/5C06!hJ44*%%*(!0.!!FUkFekEFUTi!! #&&3=kkC*&&*.?0>*2#*$(?.1kIPILFFUlEffk6*1($6#*$(%(,&'-sFUMFeMEFUT!

`tZ`L8!O<:bSBa!8S["S`<JLq!!DEFFlH!`+502(;!`+502(!N.$>*2%$&)!\2*%%!

\JabMP`B"b;![?!^!aJLO;!W?!DEFFTH!\204*%%*%!05!%04$,1!1*,2.$.6!$.!$.&*62,&*(!! 2*%0'24*%!-,.,6*-*.&?!o&C/)#4!&'!(&$$C)+,<!#)*!.;;4+%*!B&:+#4!! 90<:5&4&2<L!OQ=!UdVYEFf?!!\JbWOL;!W?!^!L`IOL"B;!B?!DUddeH!1+0;C,%!9/&:%00%0-!.1D!#)*!,5%!9/+$#/<!! \&/$0!&'!1%:+0+&)!F#E+)26!b0.(0.;!I'&&*2%C02&#?!!

LJWSLOc;!L?!DUdddH!B,#E%5&4*%/!.)#4<0+0!#)*!(&)'4+:,!F#)#2%$%),;!$.!! IN[]bOB;!8?!D*(H;!(C4,+I#,+)2!9%#:%-!(&)'4+:,!#)*!(&44#>&/#,+&)!+)!"#,C/#4!! D%0&C/:%!F#)#2%$%),6!P,%#$.6&0.;!S.&*2.,&$0.,1!8*>*103-*.&!L*%*,24#!! [*.&2*!,.(!P021(!I,./!S.%&$&'&*!!!

! **#!

LO8\J"a;! B?W?;! q`N<:;! X?;! ORObq;! J?;! J8JWB;! P?W?;! BN"aOLbJ<8;!! P?X?;!PaS"Oa`NBO;!J?;!JWJL;!J?;!bJWIOL"?;!L?J?;!bS<<Obb;!! X?8?[?!! PJ"";!J?;!^!:N"SOLLOc;!L?X?!DEFUEH!N.(*2%&,.($.6!,.(!! -,.,6$.6!! 40.%*2>,&$0.!40.51$4&%?!3/%)*0!+)!=:&4&2<!s!=I&4C,+&)L!URP)DEH=!! UFFMUFd!

LOO8;! W?B?! DEFFeH! B&,/*#01(*2! \,2&$4$3,&$0.! 502! O.>$20.-*.&,1! W,.,6*-*.&=!! .!g+,%/#,C/%!D%I+%76!A+&4&2+:#4!:&)0%/I#,+&)L!OQO;!33?!ETUlMETVE!

L`I! DEFUFH! G%/,/&C7%)! &;! 1%$&:/#,+%6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?2$Q/%0>*2#*$(?.1k(04'-*.&*.M! *.3'91$4,&$*%k2,3302&*.kEFUFkFEkUlk,(>$*%M209M>*2&20'C*.M03M!! (*-042,&$*?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!

L`I! DEFUEH! g&04#,%)! +)! G%/,/&C7%)-! "##/! %%)! "+%C7%! G%/5&C*+)2! ,C00%)! TI%/5%+*L!! F#/E,! %)! B#$%)4%I+)26! J>,$1,91*! 520-=! #&&3=kkCCC?209M! 25>?.1k209k3'91$4,&$*%s209k3'91$4,&$*s209kUeTkb0%1,&*.u$.u>*2&20'C*.!! hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!!

B[\!DEFUTH!D+?E!@%0:5#E%%/*-!T;!]%2!"##/!*%!9#/,+:+;#,+%0#$%)4%I+)26!8*.!a,,6;!! B04$,,1!['1&'2**1!\1,.9'2*,'?!!!

BS8JPJq;!L?!DEFFGH!D%0&4I+)2!=)I+/&)$%),#4!1+0;C,%0-!\/&$!(&)'4+:,!,&!! (&)0%)0C06!b0.(0.;!O,2&#%4,.?!!

BbNSB;! RJ<! 8OL;! W?P?! DUddlH! 1C,:5! 1/&7)+)2! B<)*/&$%-! F+?)>&C70:5#*%!! &;!G#0,%4#)*!%)!]#**%)!+)!"%*%/4#)*6!:20.$.6*.;!I00.!'$&6*>*2?!

B"`]RSB;!]?!DEFUVH!@/&)+)2%)!A%%',6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kk(0/'-*.&?.42>?.1k3,6$.,k620.$.6*.M9**5&!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!!

B"LS<:OL;!b?[?;!\LObb;![?;!LOO8;!W?B?;!aNIJ[O]?!]?;!ZLJBOL;!O?8?:?!^!! 8`N:Sbb;!J?X?!DEFFfH!N.3,4/$.6!@3,2&$4$3,&$0.A!$.!&#*!J(,3&$>*!! W,.,6*-*.&!05!B04$0MO40106$4,1!B)%&*-%=!J![2$&$4,1!L*>$*C?!=:&4&2<!! #)*!B&:+%,<L!OO!DVdH!

BNBB]S<8;!b?!^![LNS[]BaJ<];!X?!DUdelH!A/%#E+)2!,5%!K$;#00%-!(&)0%)0C0#4!! .;;/&#5%0!,&!D%0&4I+)2!1+0;C,%06!<*C!q02/;!I,%$4!I00/%?!!

"[[I!DEFFEH!1%!@%I&42%)!I#)!A&*%$>%7%2+)2-!K)'&/$#,+%L!.*I+%0!%)!T)*%/O&%E6!!! J-%&*2(,-;!"*4#.$%4#*![0--$%%$*!I0(*-9*C*6$.6?!!

"ObO:LJ\a!DEFUVH!=#/,5VC#E%0!'/&$!&)05&/%!2#0!*/+44+)2!,5/%#,%)!#!*+0#0,%/L!!7#/)!! /%0+*%),0! &'! 1C,:5! :+,<6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?&*1*62,3#?40?'/k.*C%kC021(.*C%k*'203*k.*&#*21,.(%kUFU

! **$!

! fEVTVkO,2&#K',/*%M520-M0.%#02*M6,%M(2$11$.6M&#2*,&*.M,M($%,%&*2M! C,2.M! 2*%$(*.&%M05M8'&4#M4$&)?#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

"a`W\B`<;!X?W?!DUdllH!!35%!g&)*&)!F&,&/7#<!94#);!$.!BOPObb;!P?L?8?;!^!! [`\\`[];!X?"?!D*(%H!9C>4+:!9#/,+:+;#,+&)!+)!94#))+)2?!b0.(0.;!X0#.!P$1*)?!!!

"`<]O<B;!O?!DEFFdH!3C00%)!T)*%/0:5#,,%)!%)!TI%/I/#2%)6!B'."2,.%4$&)!M!! (*B"J8BPSX]%&'($*%?!

"BNI`aJLJ;!B?!DEFUFH!1%$&:/#:<!35/&C25!9&4+,+:#4!9#/,+%0!#)*!9C>4+:!! 9#/,+:+;#,+&)-!35%!(#0%!&'!,5%!94#))+)2!H+0,&/<!&'!@/&)+)2%)L!35%!! "%,5%/4#)*06!804&02,1!8$%%*2&,&$0.;!N.$>*2%$&)!05!:20.$.6*.?!!

N<[O8!DUddEH!L*302&!05!&#*!N.$&*(!<,&$0.%![0.5*2*.4*!0.!O.>$20.-*.&!,.(!! 8*>*103-*.&?!J>,$1,91*!520-!=!! #&&3=kkCCC?'.?026k(04'-*.&%k6,k40.5UGUk,40.5UGUEfMU,..*+U?#&-!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

N<O[O!DUddeH!(&)I%),+&)!&)!.::%00!,&!K)'&/$#,+&)L!9C>4+:!9#/,+:+;#,+&)!+)!! 1%:+0+&)SF#E+)2!#)*!.::%00!,&!oC0,+:%!+)!=)I+/&)$%),#4!F#,,%/06!J>,$1,91*!! 520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?'.*4*?026k5$1*,(-$.k8JWk*.>k33k(04'-*.&%k4*3TV*?3(5!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi!

ROSbS:aOS8BLO:S`!DEFUTH!K):+*%),>%0,/+?*+)20;4#)!.#/*>%I+)2%)L!R*2%$*!! U?F;! EUM! FEMEFUT?! hJ44*%%*(! 0.! FdkFekEFUTi!! #&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.!

ROL]bJLS<:!RJ<!aNScS<:O!DEFUVH!R*2/1,2$.6!>,.!a'$7$.6*?!J>,$1,91*!! 520-=!#&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!

R`a^aRR!DEFUT,H!G%/,/&C7%)!&;!H%/0,%4!%)!H%/0,%4!I#)!G%/,/&C7%)6!!J>,$1,91*!! 520-=!!#&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!!hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!

R`a^aRR!DEFUT9H!G%/,/&C7%)!&;!H%/0,%4!%)!H%/0,%4!I#)!G%/,/&C7%)-!! 1+0:C00+%>+?*/#2%6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?($,1006&,5*1620.$.6*.?.1k(04'-*.&*.k0>*2$6*M! (04'-*.&*.!! hJ44*%%*(!UFkFekEFUTi!

R`b]B]LJ<"!DEFUT^!\"G-!1&&/0,#/,!.4*%4!n#)!>+?!1C+,0%!B,/&&$;/+?0?!! J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?>01/%/2,.&?.1k>/k.1kElEfkI$..*.1,.(k>$(*0k(*&,$1kVGlUEGfk

! **%!

! Z<RM! (002%&,2&MJ1(*1M/,.M9$QM8'$&%*M%&200-32$Q%?(#&-1!hJ44*%%*(!0.!! UEkFekEFUTi!

P[O8! DUdeEH! TC/! (&$$&)! \C,C/%6! J>,$1,91*! 520-=! #&&3=kkCCC?'.M! (04'-*.&%?.*&k045MFE?#&-vSS!wJ44*%%*(!0.!UFkFekEFUTi!

PSb[`t;!8?!DUddTH!35%!@C+*%!,&!=''%:,+I%!9#/,+:+;#,+&)?!\,2&.*2%#$3!I00/%;!! I2$6#&0.?!!

PBX!DEFUVH!1C,:5!5&C0%0!05+I%/!#$+*!2#0S'+%4*!VC#E%06!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kk0.1$.*?C%Q?40-k.*C%k,2&$41*%kBIUFFFUTETUEleelVEVGFUFFTGleVef! fEETGdTfEfGf!hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

cOS"!DEFUVH!]%))!*+%!=/*%!3`24+:5!A%>,6!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kkCCC?7*$&?(*kC$2&%4#,5&kEFUVMFEk.$*(*21,.(*M*2(6,%M50*2(*2'.6! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekUTi!

cOWIbJ!DEFUTH!.#/*>%I+)2!+)!g&;;%/0C$?!J>,$1,91*!520-=!! #&&3=kk7*-91,?$.40.&+&?.1k%*$70*.*.kEFUTk,51*>*2$.6*.kFfMFEMEFUT!! hJ44*%%*(!UVkFekEFUTi!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! **&!

Appendix I

List of Respondents

!

!"!"#$%&'(!)#**#+'!! ! !,-#./0#1! !

#$%"#1!23'/! ! ! 4.$'5$-#./0#1!

&$%6#07'/8!9'!2318! ! 23#/9!0'07'/!

'($%:*7'/8!;39'1733+!! <#=3/!

)'>!;37!<&*9'/! ! ?./'$83/! !

*$%<##/8@'!A.'B! ! :9C.(3/! !

+$%"'**'!C#1!9'/!A133B! 4.$'5$-#./0#1!

,$%2'#!2*3D-&.(! ! <'07'/!

-$%:131=03&(! ! ,.C.*!('/C#18! !

.$%<#/.@D'!C#1!2''D! ! <#=3/!

/$%E#19#!F'**'17#/+5! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!C#1!2#/'1! ! ! F3*.$=!#9C.(3/!!

0$!F.'8'/!G.@B'/(0#! ! H9.83/!.1!$-.'I!!

1$!JC3!63$-8'17'/+! ! K&#/8'/0#(8'/!!

2$!:*7'/8!A&.B'/! ! <#1#+'/! !

3$!L#1(!C#1!9'/!<3*'1! ,-#./0#1!HM'$&8.C'!!!! 23#/9!

4$!N''/8!2.@*'C'*9! ! ?./'$83/!!

5$!G$-3DD'19!N/31.1+'1! N/3&B!.18'/C.'O!

6$!<#/$3!;3'B'/(! ! F#(83/! ! !

7$!L#1(!2/3'D-&.(! ! H18/'B/'1'&/!

8$!;3'*3'I!E.'P'1! ! H18/'B/'1'&/!

9$!F.'8'/!6#190#1! ! H18/'B/'1'&/!

:$!L'1D!<3**! ! ! F/3I'((3/! !

;$!:131=03&(!! ! L30'!3O1'/!

<$!:131=03&(!! ! L30'!3O1'/!

=$!:131=03&(!! ! L30'!3O1'/!

?.#*33+8#I'*! !!

! N/31.1+'/!?3/B'1!

N/31.1+'/!239'0!2'O'+.1+!

! 63BB'/(&0!

! H.+'1!L&.(!

! N/31.1+'/!?3/B'1!

N/31.1+'/!239'0!2'O'+.1+!

N/31.1+'/!239'07'O'+.1+!

F/3C.1$.'!N/31.1+'1!

H'0(0319!

! ! ! !! H'0(0319!

?#+7*#9!C#1!-'8!E33/9'1!

G8.$-8.1+!N/31.1+'1!E33/9!

QE4!R<'8##*S!

H'0(9'*8#!,3**'+'!! !

H'0(9'*8#!,3**'+'!

F/38'(8!+/3&B!

).@!N'*3C'1!.1!63BB'/(&0!

!

!

!

;.@D(&1.C'/(.8'.8!N/31.1+'1!

H#/8-%&#D'!9#0#+'!

H#/8-%&#D'!9#0#+'!

H#/8-%&#D'!9#0#+'!

Respondents + Stakeholder Analysis map code

! **'!

Appendix II Positivist vs. Post-positivist research!

! D`Ab*,2);!EFUT=fEH!

! !"#$%&%'%$&()%*+%,-&#.$)

!

"#$%&'()('*! +! ,#*,/0$%#*) 1-$2+) #*)#1$2.'-1/2) 342*#52*-6) *#&) %*7/02*,2+)18) 25#&%#*$9) 32.$#*-/) 3.2:0+%,2$9) #.)$01:2,&%'%&%2$;))

!

!

!

,-.(/('*!+!,#*,2.*2+)<%&4)&.0&4)'-/029)%;2;)<42&42.) ,#*,/0$%#*$) -.2) !,#..2,&(;) =/$#),#*$%+2.$)<42&42.)52&4#+$9)-33.#-,42$9)-*+)&2,4*%>02$)-,&0-//8).2/-&2) &#)<4-&)%$)12%*?)2@3/#.2+;))

!

!!!!!!!!!! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!0%.(-#(.('*! +! ,#*,2.*2+) <%&4) %*&2.*-/),#*$%$&2*,89) %;2;) <42&42.) +-&-A.2$0/&$),#//2,&2+9)52-$0.2+9)#.)?2*2.-&2+)-.2)&42)$-52)0*+2.).232-&2+)&.-%/$;))

)

!!! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!1%2%3-.(4-#(.('*!+!<42&42.)7%*+%*?$)-*+A#.),#*,/0$%#*$) 7.#5) -) $-53/29) $2&&%*?9) #.)?.#03) -.2) +%.2,&/8) -33/%,-1/2) &#) -) /-.?2.)3#30/-&%#*9) -) +%772.2*&) $2&&%*?9) #.) &#)-*#&42.)?.#03;)

)

0%536/7&-#(.('*!+!,#*,2.*2+)<%&4)<42&42.).2$0/&$A,#*,/0$%#*$) <#0/+) 12) $033#.&2+)%7) &42) $-52)52&4#+#/#?8)<-$) 0$2+) %*) -)+%772.2*&) $&0+8) <%&4) &42) $-52A$%5%/-.),#*&2@&;)

!"#$&B3#$%&%'%$&()%*+%,-&#.$)

)

8%7'3-.('*)C)$01:2,&%'%&%2$).2,#?*%D2+)-*+)*2?#&%-&2+)%*)-)5-**2.)&4-&)-&&253&$)&#)-'#%+)1%-$%*?).2$0/&$A,#*,/0$%#*$;)97#$%&'()('*!:(';!'3-2<5-3%2&*!+)-,,23&-*,2)-*+)+%$,/#$0.2)#7)$01:2,&%'2)3#$%&%#*%*?)-*+)4#<)%&)5%?4&)%53-,&)#*)&42).2$2-.,4)3.#,2$$9)%*,/0+%*?),#*,/0$%#*$)+.-<*;))

)

=7';%2'(&('*!+!E#*,2.*2+)<%&4)&.0&4)'-/02)<4%/2).2,#?*%D%*?)&4-&)50/&%3/2)&.0&4$)5-8)2@%$&;)=/$#),#*,2.*2+)<%&4)+2$,.%1%*?)&42)+223)$&.0,&0.2)#7)2@32.%2*,2A342*#52*-)%*)-)5-**2.)&4-&)%$)!&.02()&#)&42)2@32.%2*,2;)

)

>%5%2/-#(.('*!+!-,,23&$)&4-&).2/%-1%/%&8)%*)$&0+%2$)#7)&42)$#,%-/)5-8)*#&)12)3#$$%1/29)10&)-&&2$&$)&4-&)52&4#+$)-.2)$8$&25-&%,9)<2//)+#,052*&2+9)-*+)+2$%?*2+)&#)-,,#0*&)7#.).2$2-.,4)$01:2,&%'%&%2$;))

)

?3-2<@%3-#(.('*!+!<42&42.)7%*+%*?$)-*+A#.),#*,/0$%#*$)7.#5)-)$-53/29)$2&&%*?9)#.)?.#03)/2-+)&#)/2$$#*$)/2-.*2+)&4-&)5-8)12)?2.5-*2)&#)-)/-.?2.)3#30/-&%#*9)-)+%772.2*&)$2&&%*?9)#.)-*#&42.)?.#03;))

)

=7/('-#(.('*!+!-,,23&$)&42)%53#.&-*,2)#7)&42).2$2-.,4),#*&2@&)-*+)&42.27#.2)$22F$)70//)2@3/%,-&%#*)#7)52&4#+$)&#)-//#<)#&42.$)&#)$22)4#<)-*+)<48)&42).2$2-.,42.$)-..%'2+)-&)&42%.),#*,/0$%#*$;))

)

G-'2)$01:2,&%'%&%2$)122*)-,F*#</2+?2+)-*+)5-*-?2+H)

G-$)!&.02)2$$2*,2()122*),-3&0.2+H)

=.2)52&4#+$)-33.#-,42+)<%&4),#*$%$&2*,8H)

=.2)-.?052*&$).2/2'-*&)-*+)-33.#3.%-&2H)

E-*)&42).2$2-.,4)12)'2.%7%2+H)

! **(!

Appendix III Advice of the Meijer Commission

DW*$Q*2!*&!,1?;!EFUV=lH!

!

!"#$"%&'())#**#(+&

• ,%(-%.))"&/#+"&01&!"#$%&'"()'#*%*+$',$-*+.%&'#/+'.().0.)*"1'.(2"3.%"(%,'"()'$(%+$4+$($*+,'5$",*+$'67'' 8"+%29*":$;4+//#.(<'/#'2/*,$,'"()'/%2$+'3*.1).(<,'''5$",*+$'=7'' >))$)'0"1*$'"()'"11/?"(-$,'%2+/*<2'<.#%'0/*-2$+,'#/+''' ' $($+<&'4$+#/+@"(-$'.@4+/0.(<'@$",*+$,'5$",*+$'A7'' B*"+"(%$$' +$4".+,' /#' $"+%29*":$' +$1"%$)' )"@"<$' #/+'2/*,$;

3*&$+,''5$",*+$'C7' '!/10$'2"++/?.(<'-",$,'5$",*+$'D7' 'E@4+/0$)')"@"<$'+$4".+,'4+/-$)*+$'3&'F>5'5$",*+$'G7'' H+/#$,,./("1'$I$-*%.0$'/+<"(.,"%./('?.%2'.()$4$()$(%''' ' ,*4$+0.,./('

• ,%(-%.))"&/#+"&21&&J*"1.%&'/#'1.0.(<;'"()'?/+:'$(0.+/(@$(%''5$",*+$'K7'' L$,%+*-%*+.(<'/#'2/*,.(<'@"+:$%'"()',2/44.(<'-$(%+$,'.(''' ' "+$",'/#'4/4*1"%./(',2+.(:"<$''5$",*+$'M7'' L$%$(%./('"()'+$4*+4/,.(<'/#'?.()@.11,N'3*++/?,N'"()''' ' -2*+-2$,'5$",*+$'O7' 'E@4*1,$'#/+'1/-"1'$($+<&'4+/)*-%./('5$",*+$'6P7'' Q",%'E(%$+($%'0."'<1",,'#.3+$'-/(($-%./('%/'%2$'("%./("1'''' ' <+.)'

• ,%(-%.))"&/#+"&31&!*,%".("31$'$-/(/@.-'4$+,4$-%.0$'#/+'%2$'+$<./('5$",*+$'667'' >('"@3.%./*,'.((/0"%./('4+/<+"@@$'R<",'=SPTS'U2.,'' '' ' 4+/<+"@@$'<.0$,',*3,%"(-$'%/'%2$'$($+<&'%+"(,.%./('?.%2''' ' %2$'".)'/#'B+/(.(<$(T,',%+/(<'$-/(/@.-',$-%/+,7'$($+<&N''' ' "<+.-*1%*+$V"<+.3*,.($,,'"()'%2$'[email protected]"1'.()*,%+&S''

• 4"5&6+7"%*8.+7#+-&5$",*+$'6=7'' W."1/<*$'U"31$'"%'?2.-2N'*()$+'%2$',*4$+0.,./('/#'"('''' ' .()$4$()$(%'-2".+@"(N'F>5N'8-/(/@.-'>##".+,N'"()'''' ' ,%":$2/1)$+,'#+/@'%2$'+$<./('-/;-+$"%$'")0.-$,'+$<"+).(<''' ' <",'4+/)*-%./('.('+$1"%./('%/N'"@/(<,%'/%2$+,N',"#$%&'"()''' ' #*%*+$',$-*+.%&'#/+'%2$'+$<./(T,'.(2"3.%"(%,'"()''' '' ' $(%+$4+$($*+,S''

! **)!

Appendix IV Members of the Dialogue Table

D>,.!:**1!^!P,11,6*;!EFUT=TFH!

!""#$"%"&'()*+#,,-.+/"#

!"#$%&$%'()*+,((-%%%%%%%%%%%.*/**+0*%1(22*#34/5%% % %%%%%%%%%%+6/*+3%-*/**+0*+7860*#39"622*+

!"#$%:$%.#((0% %%%%%%%%%%%;*<=<-"*<)3#*-<(%.#(+<+-*+

>8$%?$%@6+3*+% %%%%%%%%%%.#(+<+-*#%A()*/,*8*-<+-%

!"#$%1$%)*%A(+0% %%%%%%%%%%.#(+<+-*#%A()*/,*8*-<+-%

!"#$%!<*0*#/6+% %%%%%%%%%%%B((+-#(*2%>6#*+=6+)5%% % %%%%%%%%%%%+6/*+3%8(+<+-30<9"0<+-*+

!"#$%C$%D6+%)*#%;*=)*%%%%%%%%E6044#F%*+%/<=<*4G*)*#60<*%.#(+<+-*+

>8$%&$%D6+%;*=)*FH4)<IJ%%%1KHFE((#)

!"#$%L$%A#*4J<+J% %%%%%%%%%%C0<9"0<+-%H4)*%.#(+<+-*#%M*#J*+

!"#$%?$%N<I)*#D*=)%%%%%%%%%%%%C6/*+8*#J*+)*%A*)#<ID*+%:*/3)*=06

!"#$%&$%H(30*#"(GG%%%%%%%%%%%>MAFE((#)

!"#$%@$%A(*#% %%%%%%%%%%%;*#*+<-<+-%.#(+<+-*#%!(#2*+

!"#$%@$%B<-,(=)43% %%%%%%%%%%C6/*+8*#J<+-%><I+,(48%C9"6)*%%% % %%%%%%%%%%.#(+<+-*+

!"#$%B$%>((#=6-% %%%%%%%%%%L#(D<+9<*%.#(+<+-*+

!"#$%A$%D6+%)*%1**/240%%%%E&>

!"#$%@$%)*%.#((0% %%%%%%%%%%><+<30*#<*%D6+%:9(+(/<39"*%N6J*+

!""#$"%"&'(0."12$*'12"3(.+/"#

!"#$%@$%)*%@(+-% %%%%%%C066030(*O<9"0%(2%)*%><I+*+

!"#$%!$%K(//*=% %%%%%%%K*9"+<39"*%?(//<33<*%A()*/,*8*-<+-%

!"#$%:$%N4<)6/% %%%%%%%;*<=<-"*<)3#*-<(%.#(+<+-*+

4)(2,15

!"#$%P$%C<I,#<+-% %%%%%%.#(+<+-*+%C*62(#03

!"#$%C$%@6+3*+% %%%%%%EH>

!"#$%'$%>4=)*#% %%%%%%%;*#*+<-<+-%:<-*+%P4<3

!"#$%&'$(#!'$)

*++$,++)%-$+*&*.'*

,&#/++.%#0'/

! *"+!

Appendix V Signatories to the Verklaring van Huizinge:

!

ONDERTEKENAARSAbiant LycurgusAcantusAkzo NobelAlfa CollegeANWBArkema TuinhoutcentrumAVEBEBedrijfsbelangen EemshavenBencomBoerma AntiekBouwbedrijf de BoerBouwbedrijf KooiBugel HajemaBurgemeester BedumBurgemeester DelfzijlBurgemeester LoppersumBurgemeester SlochterenCom & CoDorpsbelangen BedumDorpsbelangen EenrumDorpsbelangen FroomboschDorpsbelangen GarrelsweerDorpsbelangen GodlinzeDorpsbelangen HarkstedeDorpsbelangen HellumDorpsbelangen HolwierdeDorpsbelangen LeermensDorpsbelangen LoppersumDorpsbelangen SchouwerzijlDorpsbelangen SpijkDorpsbelangen StedumDorpsbelangen Ten PostDorpsbelangen UithuizermedenDorpsbelangen UsquertDorpsbelangen WarfhuizenDorpsbelangen ZijldijkDorpshuis OnderdendamDorpshuis WeersterheemDorpshuis WirdumDorpsvereniging LellensDorpsvereniging TinallingeDorpsvereniging Wehe den HoornElzinga Group UithuizermeedenEnergy ValleyEssent

! *"*!

!

Everts PartycateringFC GroningenFNV BondgenotenFreia Holding b.v.Gemeentelijke Monumentencommissie AppingedamGroninger Bodem BewegingGroninger DorpenGroninger SeaportsGronings Particulier GrondbezitHanzehogeschool GroningenHealthy AgeingHenk Helmantel, kunstenaar WesteremdenHerberg in de Valk, MiddelstumHoreca vereniging AppingedamHumsterlandInter Action, Tocht om de NoordJan Uitham, ElfstedentochtJeugdtheaterschool WonderboomKammingafonds/J.H. ScholtenfondsKamp ArchitectuurKVKLandschapsbeheer GroningenLibau adviesorganisatie voor ruimtelijke kwaliteitLoco-secretaris LoppersumLTOMarenlandMarketing GroningenMonumenten Commissie AppingedamMonumentenwacht GroningenNatuur MonumentenNieuw AkademiaNMGNOMNoord Nederlands ToneelNoorderkwartierNoorderpoortcollegeNoordhoff UitgeversNVMOpen monumentendag ZeerijpOpenluchtmuseum Het HoogelandRaadsleden SlochterenRaadslid BedumRaadslid EemsmondRecronRestauratiecommissie van de Juffertoren in SchildwoldeRUGSBEStichting de Hoven

! *""!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Stichting Dorpsbelangen MiddelstumStichting Dorpshuis Accommodatie Oosterwijtwerd en B.&B. Schathuis WijtwerderheerdStichting Dorpshuis GarsthuizenStichting Het Groninger LandschapStichting Oude Groninger KerkenStichting Uithuizer Woningbouw corporatieUMCGVeenstroomVerenging Dorpsbelangen KantensVereniging Voor Volksvermaak en Dorpsbelangen Garsthuizen/StartenhuizenVNO NCWVrienden van de Menkemaborg te UithuizenWaterbedrijf GroningenWethouder AppingedamWethouder EemsmondWethouder GroningenWethouder Ten BoerWierden en BorgenWoongroep MarenlandWoonstichting Groninger HuisZonnehuisgroep Noord

! *"#!

Appendix VI Interview script (English translation): Q1. What do you think is being discussed at the Dialogue Table?

Q2. Do you know who are members of the Table?

• If yes, do you think these represent the region well? • If no, do you after seeing the list (www.dialoogtafelgroningen.nl/deelnemers) think

that these members represent the region well?

Q3. What is your perception of the way in which the terms of reference and the agenda have been established?

Q4. What is your perception of the information provision concerning the meetings and the progress of the Dialogue Table process?

Q5. What is your perception of the amount of influence of:

• Q5.1. The Dialogue Table on the execution of its advices? • Q5.2. The members by whom you feel represented? • Q5.3. Members of your organisation on your representative at the Table?

Q6. Do you think that in its current composition the Table can provide a valuable contribution to the restoration of trust of the region in Government and NAM?

• Q6.2. If yes/no, why?

Q7. Compared to traditional methods of problem solving, what would you consider the potential added value of the Dialogue Table?

Q8. Is there something you would like to tell the members of the Table?

A8.

Q9. Where on this interest-influence matrix would you place your organisation?

! *"$!

! *"%!

Appendix VII Citation and data use agreement (English & Dutch)

Deelnemer informatie pagina:

Onderzoek uitgevoerd door:

Robbert Bosscher

Student: M.Sc. Integrated Resource Management

Universiteit van Edinburgh.

Contact:

Tel: 0687693870 Email: [email protected]

Hartelijk dank voor uw medewerking aan mijn onderzoek.

Het onderzoek zal opgenomen worden, opgeslagen worden op een computer, en samengevat worden. Ik zal u deze samenvatting om misverstanden over bewoording en context te voorkomen ter goedkeuring toesturen. Uw naam zal niet verbonden worden aan de opname of samenvatting; deze zullen gecodeerd worden en indien u in het eindrapport niet bij naam genoemd wilt worden zult u anoniem blijven. Indien u anoniem wilt blijven maar citaten toestaat zou ik u willen vragen op de volgende pagina aan te geven hoe u het liefste heeft dat ik naar dit interview refereer.

Ik zal deze informatie gebruiken voor het schrijven van mijn scriptie, een Nederlandstalige samenvatting, en potentieel voor tijdschrift artikelen, kranten artikelen, mondelinge presentaties, rapporten, website publicaties en andere vormen van communicatie. Als u de keuze hebt gemaakt deze informatie anoniem te verstrekken zal ik ook in deze fase bij citaten het door u gekozen pseudoniem of een andere onherkenbare referentie gebruiken.

Als u toestemt met deelname behoudt u het recht om u op elk moment uit het onderzoek terug te trekken door mij hierover te informeren. Daarnaast bent u natuurlijk ook vrij om tijdens het interview bepaalde vragen niet te beantwoorden.

Als u een zorg heeft over dit project, of als u een vraag heeft, voelt u zich dan vrij om mij dit op elk moment gedurende dit project te laten weten.

Hoogachtend,

Robbert Bosscher

! *"&!

Participant information sheet:

Research carried out by:

Robbert Bosscher

Student: M.Sc. Integrated Resource Management

University of Edinburgh.

Contact:

Tel: 0687693870 Email: [email protected]

Thank you very much for your participation in my research.

The interview will be recorded, stored on a computer, and summarised. Once finished, I will send you this summary in order to avoid misunderstandings of wording and context. Your name will not be connected to the recording or summary; these will be coded and if you have decided to provide this information anonymously you will remain so throughout the process. If you would like to remain anonymous but allow quotation, I would like to ask you to provide your preferred pseudonym on the next page.

I will use this information to write my dissertation, a Dutch summary, and potentially for journal articles, newspaper articles, oral presentations, reports, website publications, and other forms of communication. If you have decided to remain anonymous, I will continue to only refer to the data gathered in this interview by the agreed pseudonym or a similarly anonymous reference.

If you agree to take part, you maintain the right to withdraw at any time by informing me about this. You also have the right to refuse to answer specific questions.

If you have any concern about this project, or if you have a question, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Yours sincerely,

Robbert Bosscher

! *"'!

!

Citaten overeenkomst:

Ik wens de aantekeningen, samenvattingen, en/of andere data verzameld gedurende dit onderzoek te kunnen inzien gedurende mijn betrokkenheid bij dit onderzoeksproject.

Ik stem er mee in bij naam geciteerd te worden.

Ik stem ermee in geciteerd te worden als mijn naam niet gepubliceerd wordt, maar vervangen is door een beschrijving of pseudoniem. Qua pseudoniem gaat mijn voorkeur uit naar:

Ik ga ermee akkoord dat de onderzoeker documenten mag publiceren die citaten van mij bevatten.

Ik wens dat de audio opnames 12 maanden na het inleveren van het onderzoek worden verwijderd.

Door dit formulier te ondertekenen bevestig ik dat;

1. Ik vrijwillig deelneem aan dit project. Ik begrijp dat ik geen deel hoef te nemen, en ik het interview op elk moment kan stoppen;

2. Het samengevatte interview of de citaten gebruikt mogen worden als hierboven aangegeven;

3. Ik de informatiepagina heb gelezen; 4. Ik geen voordeel of betaling verwacht voor mijn deelname; 5. Ik een kopie van de samenvatting van het interview kan aanvragen en waar gewenst

aanpassingen kan maken om de effectiviteit van de vertrouwelijkheidsovereenkomst te kunnen waarborgen;

6. Ik in staat ben gesteld alle vragen te stellen die ik heb, en ik begrijp dat ik het recht heb om op contact op te nemen met de onderzoeker als ik in de toekomst vragen mocht hebben.

_____________________________________

Naam Deelnemer:

_____________________________________ ____________________

Handtekening Deelnemer: Datum:

_____________________________________ ____________________

Handtekening Onderzoeker: Datum:

! *"(!

!

Quotation agreement

I wish to review the notes, transcripts, or other data collected during the research pertaining to my participation.

I agree to be quoted directly.

I agree to be quoted directly if my name is not published and a made-up name (pseudonym) is used. My preferred pseudonym would be:

I agree that the researchers may publish documents that contain quotations by me. I would like the audio recordings to be deleted after a period of 12 months after the

research has been completed.

By signing this form I agree that;

1. I am voluntarily taking part in this project. I understand that I don’t have to take part, and I can stop the interview at any time;

2. The transcribed interview or extracts from it may be used as described above; 3. I have read the information sheet; 4. I don’t expect to receive any benefit or payment for my participation; 5. I can request a copy of the transcript of my interview and may make edits I feel

necessary to ensure the effectiveness of any agreement made about confidentiality; 6. I have been able to ask any questions I might have, and I understand that I am free

to contact the researcher with any questions I may have in the future.

_____________________________________

Participant’s Name:

_____________________________________ ____________________

Participant’s Signature: Date:

_____________________________________ ____________________

Researcher’s Signature: Date:

!!

! *")!

!

!Contact Information

Dit onderzoek is goedgekeurd door het Edinburgh University Research Ethics Board. Als u vragen heeft over dit onderzoek, neem dan alstublieft contact op met:

Naam onderzoeker: Robbert Bosscher

Adres: A.Verburghwijk 91, 9948PC Termunterzijl, The Netherlands

Tel: 0687693870

E-mail: [email protected]

You can also contact the researcher’s programme secretary:

Naam van programma secretaresse: Ms. Olivia Eadie

Adres: School of Geosciences, Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Innovation, Old High School, Infirmary Street, Edinburgh, EH1 1LZ, UK.

Tel: +44 (0) 1316514657

E-mail: [email protected]

Wat als ik problemen zie in dit onderzoek?

Als u problemen ziet in dit onderzoek, of in de manier waarop dit wordt uitgevoerd, kunt u contact opnemen met de Chair of the GeoScience Ethics Committee, University of Edinburgh, Drummond St, Edinburgh, EH8 9XP (of een email sturen naar [email protected]).

!!!!!!!

! *#+!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!Contact Information

This research has been reviewed and approved by the Edinburgh University Research Ethics Board. If you have any further questions or concerns about this study, please contact:

Name of researcher: Robbert Bosscher

Full address: A.Verburghwijk 91, 9948PC Termunterzijl, The Netherlands

Tel: 0687693870

E-mail: [email protected]

You can also contact the researcher’s programme secretary:

Name of programme secretary: Ms. Olivia Eadie

Full address: School of Geosciences, Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Innovation, Old High School, Infirmary Street, Edinburgh, EH1 1LZ, UK.

Tel: +44 (0) 1316514657

E-mail: [email protected]

What if I have concerns about this research?

If you are worried about this research, or if you are concerned about how it is being conducted, you can contact the Chair of the GeoScience Ethics Committee, University of Edinburgh, Drummond St, Edinburgh, EH8 9XP (or email at [email protected]).

!

! *#*!

Appendix VIII Ethics Self Assessment Form Approval

! *#"!

Appendix IX Travel Overseas Approval

!