Mr. Walter L. Coley, Jr. JAG/CCM Chair

Effects of restricting ports 20/21 on DoD Networks and

Information Transfer OperationsFall COPC 2007

Mr. Walter L. Coley, Jr.JAG/CCM Chair

2

2

Overview

Guidance

Effects

DoC Initiative

Navy Initiative

AFW Initiative

Options

Recommendation

3

Guidance

All standards are based on NIST guidance DoC follows NIST DoD modified to satisfy mission

Use of anonymous protocols is restricted “Risk Accepted by one is accepted by all”

Guidance concerns IPv4 IPv6 guidance is under review

44

DISA Guidance

Xx

FOUO

FOUO

5

Guidance (cont)..What the Chart Colors Mean

Guidance from PPS Category Assignments list release 6.8.1 (Aug 2007) Those PPS designated as Red will be severely

restricted. Those PPS designated as Yellow may be allowed

through with specific negotiation and limitations on use. Acceptance of those PPS designated as Green is

generally automatic.

5

6

Effects

No more unrestricted data transfer

All traffic is segmented outside VPN

DoD can push and pull data

Non-DoD can only push or pull data within DATMS-U

No more store and forward systems

7

Acceptable Services

Short Term Goal – all sites (6 months) FTP Ports 20/21 (Conditional)

Session from Enclave DMZ to DoD Network to Enclave DMZ

HTTP (Port 80 for non-DoD only) HTTPS (TCP) Port 443

Long Term Goal SFTP (SSH) Port 22 only HTTPS (TCP) Port 443

HTTP (Port 80 for non-DoD only)

7

8

Acceptable Services (cont)

DDM-SSL (TCP) Port 448

FTPS-DATA (TCP) Ports 989/990 (Army)

Some proprietary others

SFTP has most utility and economy

DOD can initiate FTP sessions

9

9

Navy Initiative

FNMOC/NAVO are going through site accreditation

Required to secure communication ports and bring the operation in line with DISA/Navy guidance

Sites will use HTTPS and SFTP

1010

DoC Initiative

NWS is moving away from FTP to HTTP(s)-based file transfer.

NWS will support SFTP Need funding to support encryption

NESDIS uses Public Keys

NWSTG supports RSA 2 factor authentication

11

Air Force Initiative

Air Force supports SFTP and HTTPS

Systems tuned to work with DMZ

Conversion to data ‘pull’ system Operational load and timing issues under study

12

Options

Option 1 Move methodically to secure networks in next 6 months

Can complete HTTPS, but not SFTP without funding No driver for this or funding supporting rapid transition

Option 2 Continue to incrementally improve infrastructure and

document as we go Can still complete HTTPS in 6 months, limited use of SFTP Same effect as option 1 but slower and lower risk Less potentially disruptive to operations

13

RECOMMENDATION

Option 2

Communication uses HTTPS and SFTP FTP where essential

Convert all communications to work through DMZ where possible in next 6-12 months Most work is done All OPC locations continue to support ATO process

14

Questions?

15

Background Information

16

16

DISA Guidance

1717

DoD DMZDoD DMZ

Internal DoD Network

Internal DoD Network

External Network

External Network

Ports Protocols & Services Category Assignment List (PPS CAL) Boundaries for FTP

Enclave DMZ

Enclave DMZ

DoD Network

DoD Network

13

147

8

1211 9

105

6 3

4

1

2

DoD Network:

NIPRNET, DATMS-U, DREN

Red – PPS CAL Denied/Restricted

Yellow – PPS CAL Conditional

15 – Red16 - Yellow

1818

DoD DMZDoD DMZ

Enclave DoD

Network

Enclave DoD

Network External Network

External Network

Ports Protocols & Services Category Assignment List (PPS CAL) Boundaries for SFTP

Enclave DMZ

Enclave DMZ

DoD Network

DoD Network

13

147

8

1211 9

105

6 3

4

1

2

DoD Network:

NIPRNET, DATMS-U, DREN

Red – PPS CAL Denied/Restricted

Yellow – PPS CAL Conditional

15-Green16-Yellow

1919

DoD DMZDoD DMZ

Internal DoD Network

Internal DoD Network

External Network

External Network

Ports Protocols & Services Category Assignment List (PPS CAL) Boundaries for HTTPS

Enclave DMZ

Enclave DMZ

DoD Network

DoD Network

13

147

8

1211 9

105

6 3

4

1

2

DoD Network:

NIPRNET, DATMS-U, DREN

Red – PPS CAL Denied/Restricted

Yellow – PPS CAL Conditional

15 – Green16 - Green

2020

AF DMZAF DMZ

Navy DoD Network

DMZ

Navy DoD Network

DMZ

External Network

DMZ

External Network

DMZ

DMZ Communications