Mortal Morality. How Threat and Partisanship Influence Moral Judgment

7/31/2019 Mortal Morality. How Threat and Partisanship Influence Moral Judgment

1/33

Ckywbj Ckybjfwv4Ak Wayhbw b`g \bywf}b`}af| F`njxh`mh Ckybj Dxgoch`w

Mabyjh} ] IhjjCB Mb`gfgbwh

Gh|bywch`w kn Ok~hy`ch`w b`g Dx}wfmh ]wxgfh}B||bjbmafb` ]wbwh X`f~hy}fwv

ihjjm}Lb||}wbwhhgx

Wkgg E Abywcb`

B}}f}wb`w \yknh}}kyGh|bywch`w kn Ok~hy`ch`w b`g Dx}wfmh ]wxgfh}

B||bjbmafb` ]wbwh X`f~hy}fwvabywcb`weLb||}wbwhhgx


2/33

Hwafm} }ab|h |kjfwfm} ]v}whc} kn gfyhmwf~h* f`wxfwf~h ckybj wyxwa} ab~h wah

|khy wk fo`fwh cb}} |xijfm}* x|ykkw vh}whygbv} ykò}* b`g yh|jbmh wahc fwa

wkckyyk} yfoaw} F` b` 21== yh~fhB Nh Ki}hy~bwfk`} k` wah Nyh`ma Yh~kjxwfk`

Dka` ]wxbyw Cfjj yhmko`fthg wah }bch bmmkx`w4 Bjj |kjfwfmbj yh~kjxwfk`}* `kw bnnhmwhg iv

nkyhfo` mk`rxh}w* kyfof`bwh f` ckybj yh~kjxwfk`} Wah }xi~hy}fk` kn h}wbijf}ahg

f`}wfwxwfk`} f} chyhjv k`h mk`}hrxh`mh kn wah |yh~fkx} }xi~hy}fk` kn h}wbijf}ahg

k|f`fk`} F` wkgbv} av|hy|kjbyfthg ckghy` Bchyfmb* h byh }xyykx`ghg iv jkxg* jfihybj

b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h* jhnw#yfoaw |jbwfwxgh} B`g* jfeh ck}w f}}xh} wabw wkh b |kjfwfmbj jf`h*

cbwwhy} kn ckybjfwv b`g wah nkx`gbwfk`} wabw nybch ckybj dxgoch`w} byh ghh|jv

|kjbyfthgmjhb~hg f` abjn iv b nbcfjfby |bybgfoc4 jfihybj b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h* Yh|xijfmb`

b`g Ghckmybw

Bmmkygfò wk k`h jf`h kn yh}hbymaCkybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Wahkyv !CNW&jfihybj}

b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} gk nx`gbch`wbjjv gfnnhy f` abw wahv mk`}fghy yfoaw b`g ykò5 wahv

yhjv k` gfnnhyh`w ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} Bmmkygfò wk CNW* bmyk}} mxjwxyh}* ckybj

mk`}fghybwfk`} mb` ih `hbwjv gf~fghg f`wk nf~h* gf}wf`mw }wyxmwxyh}4 !2& Abyc b`g Mbyh* !9&

Nbfy`h}} b`g Yhmf|ykmfwv* !=& Bxwakyfwv b`g Yh}|hmw* !7& F`#oykx| Jkvbjwv* b`g !8&

Gf~f`fwv b`g \xyfwv !}hh Abfgw b`g Dk}h|a* 9


3/33

B }h|bybwh ~hf` kn |}vmakjkofmbj yh}hbyma bj}k }xooh}w} b nx`gbch`wbj gfnnhyh`mh

ihwhh` jfihybj b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h bwwfwxgh} Bmmkygf`o wk Whyyky Cb`bohch`w Wahkyv

!WCW5 }hh \v}tmtv`}ef hw bj* 9


4/33

}hjn#yh|kywhg ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} ky gk wahv }afnw f` k`h gfyhmwfk` ky b`kwahy; ]hmk`g* h

ak|h wk hq|jkyh ahwahy jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h}* b} f} }xooh}whg iv CNW* yhbjjv byh

fghkjkofmbjjv nfqhg* ky gk wahv* b`g wahfy }hjn#yh|kywhg ckybj mk`}fghybwfk`}* bj}k }afnw b} b

nx`mwfk` kn mk`whqwf` waf} mb}h* ghbwa#yhjbwhg wayhbw

Bmmkygfò wk WCW bmmkx`w}* ah` wayhbwh`hg fwa }xiwjh wakxoaw} kn ghbwa*

jfihybj} }akxjg jkke ckyh jfihybj5 mk`}hy~bwf~h}* ckyh mk`}hy~bwf~h Bmmkygfò wk Dk}w}

}kmfbj mko`fwfk` ckghj* akh~hy* wayhbwh`hg jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} }akxjg }afnw yfoaw

k` wah |kjfwfmbj }|hmwyxc b`g yh|kyw ckyh mk`}hy~bwf~h bwwfwxgh} _h hq|hmwhg* nkjjkfò

Whyyky Cb`bohch`w Wahkyv wabw kyjg~fh} kxjg ih f`gf~fgxbjjv }bjfh`w b`g bmwf~bwhg

bnwhy hq|k}xyh wk ckywbjfwv |yfch} B} }xma* jfihybj} kxjg h~bjxbwh f`gf~fgxbjftfò ckybj

nkx`gbwfk`} ckyh afoajv afjh mk`}hy~bwf~h} kxjg yhcbf` wyxh wk if`gfò f`wxfwfk`}

!}hh4 Oybabc* Abfgw* b`g @k}he* 9


5/33

wabw* nfy}w* f`gf~fgxbj ckybjfwv f} `kw b` h~hy#nfqhg cbye5 b`g* }hmk`g4 fn jfihybj} b`g

mk`}hy~bwf~h} byh nx`gbch`wbjjv gfnnhyh`w* ah` wayhbwh`hg* wahv yhbmw wk mhywbf`*

f`gf~fgxbjftfò |k}fwfk`} gfnnhyh`wjv wab` wahv yhbmw wk if`gfò |k}fwfk`} Kn wah if`gfò

nkx`gbwfk`} chb}xyhg* ah` wayhbwh`hg* jfihybj b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h fghkjkoxh} bmwxbjjv

jkkehg }wbwf}wfmbjjv fgh`wfmbj Kxy nf`gfò} mkxjg ahj| hq|jbf` av h~fgh`mh ab} ihh`

cfqhg nky ikwa mbc|} Kxy h~fgh`mh }xooh}w} wabw* x`ghy mhywbf` mk`gfwfk`}* jfihybj} b`g

mk`}hy~bwf~h}* ah` wayhbwh`hg* jkke ckyh }fcfjby bjkò }kch gfch`}fk`}x}xbjjv

gfch`}fk`} mjk}hjv wfhg fwa mk`}hy~bwf~h |kjfmvafjh wahv gf~hyoh bjkò kwahy} _h

bj}k nf`g hc|fyfmbj h~fgh`mh nky wah mk`whqwxbj `bwxyh kn ckybj dxgoch`w Jfihybj} b`g

mk`}hy~bwf~h} cbv `kw* b} Abfgw b`g mkjjhboxh} ab~h }xooh}whg* yhjv }wbwfmbjjv k`

gf~hyoh`w }hw} kn ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} F` yhbjfwv* jfihybj b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h fghkjkoxh} cbv

ih ckyh bjfeh wab` hfwahy kxjg mbyh wk bgcfw

B ]V@WAH]F]4 WHYYKY CB@BOHCH@W B@G CKYBJ NKX@GBWFK@]

Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Wahkyv

Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Wahkyv !CNW& b} kyfof`bjjv gh~hjk|hg wk |yk~fgh b

}v}whcbwfm* nx`mwfk`bjf}w wahkyv kn ckybjfwv F` 9


6/33

Ckybj }v}whc} byh f`whyjkmef`o }hw} kn ~bjxh}* |ybmwfmh}* f`}wfwxwfk`}* b`g h~kj~hg

|}vmakjkofmbj chmab`f}c} wabw kye wkohwahy wk }x||yh}} ky yhoxjbwh }hjnf}a`h}} b`g

cbeh }kmfbj jfnh |k}}fijh !Abfgw* 9


7/33

Ib}hg k` CNW* f` 9


8/33

wahfy mko`fwf~h bifjfwv B} f`whjjhmwxbj b`fcbj}* axcb`} byh x`frxh f` wah bifjfwv wk

|hymhf~h wah f`h~fwbifjfwv kn ghbwa Wahyhnkyh* bmmkygfò wk Ihmehy* wahv wykg waykxoa jfnh

b} f`gf~fgxbj}f`~h}wfò f` mxjwxybj kyjg~fh} wabw bjjk wahc wk x`frxhjv }wb`g kxw

b`g bgg chb`fò b`g }fo`fnfmb`mh wk wahfy h~hyvgbv jf~h} !Ihmehy* 26?=&

Bmmkygfò wk WCW* }xma ghbwa b`qfhwv yh}w} }ximk`}mfkx}jv b`g* ah` bmwf~bwhg*

ahj|} wk hq|jbf` wah `hhg nky f`gf~fgxbj chb`fò* mxjwxybj mk``hmwfk`* b`g }hjn#h}whhc

Nkjjkfò Ihmehy} kye* wah wahkyv |yk|k}h} wabw b`qfhwv mb` yh}xjw nykc* nfy}w* wah

x`frxh axcb` mb|bmfwv kn ghbwa bbyh`h}} b`g* }hmk`g* wabw wybfw mkcck` wk bjj

b`fcbj}}hjn#|yh}hy~bwfk` Wk ghnh`g bobf`}w ghbwa b`qfhwv* |hk|jh f`~h}w f` kyjg~fh}

b`g ihjfhn} wabw `hmh}}fwbwh mk`wf`xbwfk`5 |hk|jh ihjfh~h wabw }kch b}|hmw kn wah }hjn fjj

mk`wf`xh bnwhy ghbwa Af}wkyfmbjjv* wah}h ihjfhn} ab~h b}}xchg jfwhybj b`g }vcikjfm nkyc}

Jfwhybjjv* fcckywbjfwv wbeh} wah nkyc kn b` hwahyhbj bnwhyjfnh ]vcikjfmbjjv* fcckywbjfwv

mb` ih fcixhg waykxoa k`h} mafjgyh`* |hy}k`bj bmmkc|jf}ach`w}* ky b`v kwahy b}|hmw kn

k`h}hjn wabw mk`wf`xh} wk hqf}w bnwhy ghbwa Nx`gbch`wbjjv* waf} b`qfhwv ixnnhy mk`}f}w} kn

wk mkc|k`h`w}4 !2& b ihjfhn f` wah ~bjfgfwv kn k`h} mxjwxybj kyjg~fh* mxnnhg fwa wabw

~fh} b}}kmfbwhg ~bjxh} b`g }wb`gbyg}* b`g !9& b ihjfhn wabw k`h f} chhwfò ky hqmhhgfò

wak}h ~bjxh} b`g }wb`gbyg}}hjn#h}whhc !Yk}hìjbww hw bj* 2616&

Wah ck}w mkcck` b||ykbma wk hqbcf`fò WCW hnnhmw} ab} ihh` fwa wah

Ckywbjfwv ]bjfh`mh av|kwah}f} !C]& Wk |yfch }ximk`}mfkx}* ghbwa#yhjbwhg b`qfhwv* b

wv|fmbj C] }wxgv x}xbjjv b}e} |bywfmf|b`w} wk iyfhnjv yfwh bikxw wahfy k` ghbwa ky bikxw

b `k`#ghbwa mk`wykj wk|fm Wv|fmbjjv* b` C] |yfch f} nkjjkhg iv b gf}wybmwfk` wb}e

gh}fo`hg wk bjjk ghbwa#yhjbwhg wakxoaw} wk gyfnw nykc mk`}mfkx}`h}} Hc|fyfmbj h~fgh`mh

nky C] hnnhmw} ab} ihh` }wboohyfò K~hy =8< }wxgfh} mk`gxmwhg f` 2= mkx`wyfh} ab~h


9/33

}x||kywhg WCW} mh`wybj mjbfc} wabw }hjn#h}whhc b`g nbfwa f` k`h} kyjg~fh} mb`

cfwfobwh ghbwa b`qfhwv iv !wahkyhwfmbjjv& |yk~fgfò kxwjhw} nky jfwhybj ky }vcikjfm

fcckywbjfwv ]f`mh fw} mk`mh|wfk`* WCW ab} knnhyhg ~bjxbijh f`}foaw f`wk b |jhwakyb kn

axcb` ihab~fky} b`g mb`* f` kxy }xccbwfk`* knnhy bggfwfk`bj f`}foaw f`wk abw cbeh}

ckybjfwv wfme \kjfwfmbj fghkjkov f} k`h hqbc|jh kn b mkcck`* mxjwxybj kyjg~fh B`g*

bjwakxoa Bchyfmb` mk`}hy~bwf}c cbv jkke b||hbjfò wk }kch nky }hmxyfwv yhb}k`}*

bmmkygfò wk WCW* bjj fghkjkofh} }hy~h kyjg~fh ghnh`}f~h nx`mwfk`} b`g mk`wbf`

gf~hy}h }hw} kn* knwh` myk}}mxwwfò* ~bjxh} !_hf}h hw bj* 9


10/33

H~fgh`mh nky wah kyjg~fh#ghnh`}f~h nx`mwfk`} kn WCW* akh~hy* f} bj}k yhbgfjv

b~bfjbijh Oyhh`ihyo hw bj !2669& nkx`g wabw ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh mbx}hg mk`}hy~bwf~h} wk

ihmkch }fo`fnfmb`wjv ckyh ifb}hg bobf`}w b jfihybj k~hy b mk`}hy~bwf~h wbyohw* afjh

jfihybj} wyh`ghg f` wah k||k}fwh gfyhmwfk`* hq|yh}}f`o jh}} ifb} x`ghy mk`}hy~bwf~h wayhbw

\v}tmtv`}ef hw bj !9


11/33

|k}fwfk`} !afoahy ybwfò} k` wah Abyc+mbyh b`g Nbfy`h}}+yhmf|ykmfwv gfch`}fk`}& afjh

mk`}hy~bwf~h} kxjg yh}|k`g ckyh }wykòjv f` wah if`gfò gfch`}fk`} !F`#oykx|+jkvbjwv*

Bxwakyfwv+yh}|hmw* \xyfwv+gf~f`fwv& B`g* afjh waf} hnnhmw cbv ih ckyh |yk`kx`mhg bw wah

fghkjkofmbj |kjj}* fw }akxjg ih jh}} }k f` wak}h wabw mk`}fghy wahc}hj~h} ckghybwh ky

f`gh|h`gh`w Akh~hy* kxy nf`gfò} gfg `kw nfw `hbwjv f`wk hfwahy wahkyhwfmbj |bmeboh

Mk`wybyv wk Dk}w} }kmfbj mko`fwfk` ckghj b`g wah |yh~fkx} av|kwah}h}* }makjby} kn WCW

ab~h }xooh}whg b mbyhnxj by`fò ah` oh`hybjftfò bikxw wah x`ghyjvfò mbx}h} kn C]

hnnhmw}4

Yh}hbyma wk gbwh }wykòjv yhnxwh} mjbfc} wabw hqf}wh`wfbj wayhbw f`h~fwbijv jhbg} wk bmk`}hy~bwf~h ky }v}whc#dx}wfnvfò }afnw _kyjg~fh} byh wkk mkc|jhq b`g |hk|jh

bmrxfyh }hmxyfwv f` wkk cb`v bv} nky b }fc|jh x`fgfyhmwfk`bj yh}|k`}h wk wayhbw wkih x}hnxj Wah hchyofò |fmwxyh f} wabw kn b afoajv njhqfijh }v}whc f` afma ikwa

mayk`fm b`g ckch`wbyv }bjfh`mh kn kyjg~fh hjhch`w}* bjkò fwa wah }hmxyfwv~bjxh kn hbma* ghwhycf`h} ak |hk|jh |ykwhmw wahc}hj~h} nykc hqf}wh`wfbj wayhbw

!\v}tmtv`}ef* 9


12/33

byoxch`w} |ykckwf`o cfjfwbyv bmwfk` b`g wah gh}fyh nky yhwyfixwfk` Wabw gh}fyh nky dx}wfmh*

Afy}maihyohy hw bj !9


13/33

B@ HQ\HYFCH@WBJ ]WXGV4 CKYWBJFWV ]BJFH@MH b`g CKYBJ

DXGOCH@W

K~hy~fh

F` ]wxgv 2* h jfè wk |ykcf`h`w wahkyfh}Whyyky Cb`bohch`w Wahkyv b`g

Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Wahkyv Bmmkygfò wk WCW* ah` hq|k}hg wk wakxoaw} kn k`h} k`

ghbwa !C]&* yh}|k`gh`w} }akxjg yhbmw wk wah hqf}wh`wfbj wayhbw iv hc|ab}ftfò b`g

yh~hywfò ibme wk wahfy k`* mxjwxybj kyjg~fh _h av|kwah}fthg wabw* f` wxy`* ghbwa#

yhjbwhg }bjfh`mh kxjg mbx}h }hjn#yh|kywhg jfihybj} wk fc|jfmfwjv* b`g hq|jfmfwjv k~hyybwh

wah f`gf~fgxbjftfò gfch`}fk`}Abyc + Mbyh b`g Nbfy`h}} + Yhmf|ykmfwvafoahy wab`

kxy `k`#wayhbwh`hg mk`wykj Mk`}hy~bwf~h} }akxjg bj}k ihmkch ckyh |kjbyfthg f` wahfy

}hjn#yh|kywhg ckybj mk`}fghybwfk`}b |ah`kch`b wabw mkxjg yhby fw}hjn b} b njbw jf`h

bmyk}} bjj nf~h gfch`}fk`} !ckyh h~h` bwwyfixwfk` kn bjj nf~h ckybj nkx`gbwfk`}& ky b

gf}|yk|kywfk`bj yhjfb`mh k` if`gfò nkx`gbwfk`} !Fòykx| + Jkvbjwv* Bxwakyfwv + Yh}|hmw*

b`g \xyfwv + Gf~f`fwv&

Kxy yh}xjw}* akh~hy* }xooh}w b ckyh `xb`mhg yhjbwfk`}af| _h }x}|hmwhg wabw

jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} kxjg }abyh }fcfjby yhbmwfk`}* b`g* k` wayhbw kn ghbwa* b}}xch

b`g yhnjhmw k` }hjn#yhf`nkymfò kyjg~fh} _h bj}k }x}|hmwhg wabw waf} yhf`nkymfò }jb`w

kxjg }eh yh}|k`}h} f` kyjg~fh#yhf`nkymfò gfyhmwfk`} gf}|yk|kywfk`bwhjv ckyh wab`

yh}|k`gh`w} b`}hy} `kw mxjwf~bwhg nykc wakxoaw} kn ckywbjfwv K~hybjj* h nf`g wabw

mk`}hy~bwf~h} b`g jfihybj}* ah` wayhbwh`hg* byh `kw bjj wabw gfnnhyh`w f` wahfy h~bjxbwfk`}

kn wah nfy}w wk if`gfò nkx`gbwfk`}Fòykx|+jkvbjwv b`g Bxwakyfwv+yh}|hmw _h bj}k

nf`g* akh~hy* wabw* x|k` ckybjfwv yhnjhmwfk`* fghkjkoxh} ck~h nxywahy b|byw bmyk}}

Abfgw} wk f`gf~fgxbjftfò nkx`gbwfk`} _ah` wayhbwh`hg* jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h}


14/33

gf~hyoh k` Abfgw} f`gf~fgxbjftfò nkx`gbwfk`} b`g mkch wkohwahy bmyk}} wah if`gfò

nkx`gbwfk`}

Gbwb

_afjh wahyh byh e`k` jfcfwbwfk`} f` yhjvfò }kjhjv k` mkjjhoh }wxgh`w

mk`~h`fh`mh }bc|jh} !}hh4 ]hby}* 261>&* kxy |yfcbyv yh}hbyma kidhmwf~h nky ]wxgv 2 b}

wk h}wbijf}a mbx}bj f`nhyh`mh b`g f`why`bj ~bjfgfwv !}hh4 Ckke* 261=5 Gyxmecb` b`g Ebc*

9< }hmk`g} k` wah

ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh yfwfò wb}e !` 3 9& ky =< }hmk`g} k` wah mk`wykj mk`gfwfk` yfwfò wb}e

!` 3 =& Wax}* wah nf`bj@3 279

Ckywbjfwv ]bjfh`mh \yfch

Wk wh}w wah hnnhmw} kn ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh k` ckybj dxgoch`w* h hc|jkvhg b

ihwhh`#}xidhmw} gh}fo`* f` afma |bywfmf|b`w} hyh yb`gkcjv b}}fo`hg wk k`h kn wk

hq|hyfch`wbj mk`gfwfk`} Nfy}w* wah ck}w mkcck` ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh f`gxmwfk` whma`frxh

b}e} |bywfmf|b`w} wk k|h`#h`ghg rxh}wfk`} bikxw wahfy k` ckywbjfwv !Yk}hìjbww hw bj

!2616& ]|hmfnfmbjjv* |bywfmf|b`w} hyh b}ehg wk |jhb}h iyfhnjv gh}myfih wah hckwfk`} wabw


15/33

wah wakxoaw kn vkxy k` ghbwa bykx}h} f` vkx* b`g |jhb}h dkw gk`* b} }|hmfnfmbjjv b}

vkx mb`* abw vkx wafè fjj ab||h` wk vkx b} vkx |av}fmbjjv gfh b`g k`mh vkx byh

|av}fmbjjv ghbg F` wah mk`wykj mk`gfwfk`* |bywfmf|b`w} yh}|k`ghg wk }fcfjbyjv kyghg

rxh}wfk` wabw b}ehg wahc wk iyfhnjv mk`}fghy b`g yfwh gk` abw wahv gfg hbma cky`fò

wk |yh|byh nky b wv|fmbj gbv

B} ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh hnnhmw} byh b}}kmfbwhg fwa kwahy mk`}wyxmw} b} hjj !ho }hjn#

h}whhc5 Abyck`#Dk`h}* hw bj* 266?5 yfoaw#fò bxwakyfwbyfb`f}c5 b`g }kmfbj gkcf`b`mh

kyfh`wbwfk`&* h bj}k f`mjxghg kwahy* hjj#e`k` chb}xyhch`w f`}wyxch`w} wk mahme nky

bjwhy`bwf~h hq|jb`bwfk`} kn hnnhmw} Wah Yk}hìhyo ]hjn#H}whhc }mbjh !Y]H5 }hh

Yk}hìhyo* 26165 B||h`gfq H&* Bjwhchvhy} Y_B }mbjh* b ]kmfbj Gkcf`b`mh

Kyfh`wbwfk` fwhc* b} hjj b} rxh}wfk`} k` yhjfofkx} |yhnhyh`mh* b`g ~fh} kn wah bnwhyjfnh

hyh bj}k obxohg

Bmmh}}fifjfwv Ghjbv

\b}w WCW yh}hbyma ab} }ak` wabw ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh hnnhmw} }xynbmh bnwhy b }akyw

ghjbv ky gf}wybmwfk` !Oyhhìhyo hw bj 26675 \v}tmtv`}ef* Oyhhìhyo* b`g ]kjkck`*

2666& ]h~hybj }wxgfh} ab~h x}hg b }akyw* wayhh |byboyb|a |b}}boh nykc Wah Oykfò

]wk`h !Mbcx}* 268?& nybchg b} b` bwwfwxgh wb}e F`}whbg* kxy ghjbv mk`}f}whg kn b

}h|bybwh _KYG+@K@_KYG b}}kmfbwfk` wb}e Nkjjkfò wah Ckybjfwv ]bjfh`mh |yfch*

bjj kn kxy }wxgv |bywfmf|b`w} !ikwa mk`gfwfk`}& mkc|jhwhg b yhbmwfk` wfch wb}e* afma

chb}xyhg wah mko`fwf~h bmmh}}fifjfwv kn mk`mh|w} yhjbwhg wk hbma kn wah nf~h |yk|k}hg

ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} !abyc+mbyh* nbfy`h}}+yhmf|ykmfwv* hwm& Ikwa wb}e} hyh |yh}h`whg ~fb b`

f`whybmwf~h mkc|xwhyfthg rxh}wfk``bfyh Wah yhbmwfk` wfch wb}e mjk}hjv nkjjkhg wah


16/33

_KYG+@K@_KYG dxgoch`w |bybgfoc }xooh}whg iv Nbtfk f` 266< !}hh bj}k4 @hj}k`*

Mjb}k`* b`g Kqjhv* 266?&

\bywfmf|b`w} ~fhhg b }hyfh} kn jhwwhy }wyfò} njb}ahg f` wah mh`why kn wahfy mkc|xwhy

ck`fwky} b`g f`gfmbwhg* b} rxfmejv b} |k}}fijh* ahwahy wah jhwwhy} mk`}wfwxwhg b wyxh

Hòjf}a kyg* jfeh |xyfwv* ky b `k`}h`}h kyg* jfeh wyh}ej Wahv gfg }k iv |yh}}fò

k`h kn wk ehv}* h nky _KYG b`g f nky @KW B _KYG Bnwhy wk |ybmwfmh

wyfbj}* hfoaw mbwhokyfh} kn wh` kyg |ykih} b||hbyhg f` yb`gkc kyghy4 kyg} yhjbwhg wk

hbma kn wah nf~h ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} !wbeh` gfyhmwjv nykc wah CNW gfmwfk`byv&* `hxwybj nfjjhy

kyg} fwa }fcfjby jfòxf}wfm nyhrxh`mfh} b} hbma* }hjhmwhg ckybj kyg !ho* |jb`hw&*

b`g `k`}h`}h kyg} Wah mkc|xwhy yhmkyghg wah gxybwfk` kn wfch ihwhh` wah f`fwfbj

gf}|jbv kn hbma kyg b`g wah wfch kn ehv |yh}} B`g* yh}|k`}h wfch b} wbeh` b} b`

f`gfmbwky kn wah yhjbwf~h bmmh}}fifjfwv kn wah mk`mh|w f` chckyv* fwa ckyh bmmh}}fijh

mk`mh|w} |ykgxmfò nb}why wfch} !Nbtfk 266


17/33

}hyfh} kn ghckoyb|afm rxh}wfk`} yhobygf`o wahfy boh* oh`ghy* ybmh* b`g mfwfth`}af| }wbwx}

b`g* nf`bjjv* b`}hyhg 1 fwhc} gh}fo`hg wk b}}h}} |kjfwfmbj e`kjhgoh

Chb}xyh}

Gh|h`gh`w ~byfbijh} Nykc wah Ckybj Yhjh~b`mh Rxh}wfk``bfyh !}hh B||h`gfq

B&* h myhbwhg 8 }mbjh} !yhmkghg nykc < wk 2& afma cb||hg k`wk hbma kn wah gf}wf`mw

ckybj nkx`gbwfk`}4 2& Abyc + Mbyh ! 3


18/33

ckybj nkx`gbwfk`* fwa wah hqmh|wfk` kn Abyc + Mbyh !bjwakxoa h }x}|hmw* of~h` b jbyohy

}bc|jh }fth* wabw waf} gfch`}fk` kxjg bj}k vfhjg }fo`fnfmb`w yh}xjw}&

Wk hq|jfmbwh wah}h yh}xjw}* h mbjmxjbwhg |yhgfmwhg ckybj yhjh~b`mh ~bjxh} nky

}wykò jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} f` wah wayhbw b`g mk`wykj mk`gfwfk`} !akjgfò bjj kwahy

~byfbijh} bw wahfy chb`} ky yhnhyh`mh mbwhokyfh}& Nfy}w* jkkefò bw Wbijh 2* wayhbwh`hg

jfihybj} yh|kywhg wabw hbma kn wah nf~h gfch`}fk`} hyh ckyh yhjh~b`w wk wahfy k` ckybj

ghmf}fk`#cbefò wab` gfg mk`}hy~bwf~h} F` nbmw* wayhbwh`hg mk`}hy~bwf~h} ybwhg hbma

gfch`}fk` b} jh}} yhjh~b`w wab` gfg wahfy `k`#wayhbwh`hg* mk`wykj mkx`why|byw} Bjwakxoa

`k }fo`fnfmb`w gfnnhyh`mh b} nkx`g nky wah Abyc + Mbyh gfch`}fk`* waf} |bwwhy` ahjg

bmyk}} bjj gfch`}fk`}* b`g wah yh}xjw} hyh ck}w }fo`fnfmb`w f` wah Fòykx| + Jkvbjwv

gfch`}fk` Jkkefò bw Nfoxyh 2* mkc|byh jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} f` wah mk`wykj

mk`gfwfk` wk wak}h f` wah wayhbw mk`gfwfk` Wah |bwwhy` f} }wbye Bmyk}} wah ikbyg* jfihybj}

f` wah ckywbjfwv }bjfh`mh mk`gfwfk` ybwh hbma gfch`}fk` b} ckyh yhjh~b`w* afjh wayhbwh`hg

mk`}hy~bwf~h} yhjv jh}} k` hbma gfch`}fk`* ky bw jhb}w yh|kyw jkhy yhjh~b`mh ybwfò} nky

hbma ckybj nkx`gbwfk`

Wah ckyh f`whyh}wfò nf`gfò* akh~hy* mb` ih f`nhyyhg ckyh mjhbyjv nykc Nfoxyh

9 F` wah mk`wykj mk`gfwfk`* jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} jkke ck}w }fcfjby bjkò wah

f`gf~fgxbjftfò gfch`}fk`}Abyc+mbyh b`g Nbfy`h}}+yhmf|ykmfwv Wahv b||hby nxywahy

b|byw* akh~hy* bjkò wah nfy}w wk if`gfò gfch`}fk`}Fòykx|+jkvbjwv b`g

Bxwakyfwv+yh}|hmw _ah` mkc|byhg wk wah C] mk`gfwfk`* x`ghy mk`gfwfk`} kn wayhbw* b

|bwwhy` hchyoh} Jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} b||hby wk b||ykqfcbwh }fcfjby bwwfwxgh} f` wah

nfy}w wk if`gfò nkx`gbwfk`} !Bxwakyfwv+yh}|hmw b`g Fòykx|+jkvbjwv&* afjh wahv b||hby

wk gf~hyoh bjkò wah f`gf~fgxbjftfò bqf} !Abyc+mbyh b`g Nbfy`h}}+yhmf|ykmfwv& Waf} mkxjg


19/33

chb` wabw* b} ki}hy~hg iv }kmfbj mko`fwfk` b`g whyyky cb`bohch`w bmmkx`w}* ah`

wayhbwh`hg* jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} jkke }wbwf}wfmbjjv fgh`wfmbj bjkò if`gfò

gfch`}fk`} Waf} mkxjg bj}k ahj| hq|jbf`* nky hqbc|jh* wah |yhnhyh`mh wabw ikwa jfihybj}

b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h} abg nky \yh}fgh`w Ix}a b`g }wyfòh`w akchjb`g }hmxyfwv nkjjkfò

]h|whcihy 22wa F`gf~fgxbjftfò mk`}fghybwfk`}* akh~hy* nkjjk b gfnnhyh`w |bwwhy` Waf}

mkxjg chb` wabw* gh|h`gfò k` wah |kjfmv b`g kxw}fgh mk`whqw* jfihybj} b`g mk`}hy~bwf~h}*

ah` wayhbwh`hg* byh |}vmakjkofmbjjv |yfchg wk hfwahy ybjjv bykx`g b mh`wybj* if`gfò

wahch ky nxywahy |kjbyfth

_afjh kxy }wykòh}w nf`gfò} hyh vfhjghg nykc ckybj yhjh~b`mh fwhc}fwhc} wabw

hyh bi}wybmwfk`} b`g cbv `kw ih wyxh wh}w} kn ckybj dxgoch`wwah |bwwhy` f} b`

f`whyh}wfò k`h _h }x}|hmw wabw* ah` b||jfhg wk wah hc|fyfmbj ob| wabw byf}h} nykc }kmfbj

mko`fwfk` b`g whyyky cb`bohch`w bmmkx`w}* ckybj nkx`gbwfk`} wahkyv }xooh}w} wabw* x`ghy

}kch mk`gfwfk`}* b`g of~h` }kch |kjfmv#cbefò mk`whqw}* }kmfbj mko`fwfk` wahkyv akjg}

Akh~hy* x`ghy gfnnhyh`w mk`whqw}* wah b}}xc|wfk`} kn whyyky cb`bohch`w akjg _h

mb``kw* akh~hy* fwa wah |yh}h`w yh}hbyma* b`}hy h~hyv wahkyhwfmbj rxh}wfk` waf} nf`gfò

ybf}h} _h mb`* akh~hy* ihmek` b mbjj#wk#byc} nky nxywahy yh}hbyma

MK@MJX]FK@

Yhnhyyfò ibme wk Dka` ]wxbyw Cfjj} ki}hy~bwfk` `kwhg f` wah f`wykgxmwfk` kn waf}

|b|hy* wah mk`whqw kn Bchyfmb` |kjfwfm} b`g wah |yh}h`w nf`gfò} byh |bywfmxjbyjv

f`wyfoxfò _fwa waf} |yhjfcf`byv }wxgv* h ak|h wk }ahg }kch jfoaw k` wah |}vmakjkofmbj

|ykmh}}h} wabw mk`wyfixwh wk fghkjkov b`g mk`wyfixwh wk b gf~hy}h x`ghy}wb`gfò kn axcb`

ckybjfwv Kxy }wykòh}w yh}xjw} hyh oykx`ghg f` bi}wybmw* ckybj yhjh~b`mh fwhc}

Akh~hy* fw f} bj}k fc|kywb`w wk `kwh wabw wah ck}w |ykcf`h`w hnnhmw} ki}hy~hg f` waf}


20/33

}wxgv hyh mbjmxjbwhg bw k||k}f`o ikx`gbyfh} Hqwyhch fghkjkoxh} k` wah jhnw#yfoaw

}|hmwyxc* afjh wahv cbv ih ahb~v#ab`ghg f` wahfy f`njxh`mh k` Bchyfmb` |kjfwfm}* byh

`kw yh|yh}h`wbwf~h kn wah cb}}* Bchyfmb` hjhmwkybwh Ck}w Bchyfmb`} nbjj }kchahyh

ihwhh` k||k}f`o* |kjfwfmbj hqwyhch} b`g mbjj wahc}hj~h} ckghybwh} !ho* Nfkyf`b* 9


21/33

Fghkjkofmbj gf~fgh} ab~h ihmkch rxh}wfk`} kn ckybj |yf`mf|jhwah yfoaw} b`g ykò} kn

|kjfmv* ak mfwfth`} f`whybmw fwa k`h b`kwahy* jb* abw }akxjg b`g }akxjg `kw ih

}kmfbjjv |hycfwwhg ky h`mkxybohgbyh bjj mkcck`#|jbmh* ckghy` |kjfwfmbj b`wahc}

Ckybj dxgoch`w f} h`wyh`mahg f` |kjfwfmbj ykkw}

B |afjk}k|ahy bw ahbyw* Cfjj bj}k bgcfyhg wah f}gkc kn wah b`mfh`w Oyhhe} b`g

b} nbckx}jv rxkwhg4 Fw f} ihwwhy wk ih ]kmybwh} gf}}bwf}nfhg wab` b nkkj }bwf}nfhg F`

\jbwk/}\abhgk* }xma b`mfh`w f}gkc gfyhmwjv b||jfh} wk kxy f`~h}wfobwfk` kn hckwfk` b`g

ckybj dxgoch`w4 B }v}whc kn ckybjfwv afma f} ib}hg k` yhjbwf~h hckwfk`bj ~bjxh}*

bmmkygfò wk ]kmybwh}* f} b chyh fjjx}fk`* b wakykxoajv ~xjoby mk`mh|wfk` afma ab}

`kwafò }kx`g f` fw b`g `kwafò wyxh Fn kxy h~fgh`mh akjg}* fn ckybj mk`~fmwfk` ih`g}

b`g }ab|h} fw}hjn fwaf` hckwfk`bj mk`whqw b`g wyxjv f} b }jb~h wk f`wxfwfk`* wah` cbvih h

mb` bjj nf`g }kjbmh b} }bwf}nfhg nkkj} K`jv nxywahy yh}hbyma fjj whjj


22/33

Wbijh 2. Cbf` Hnnhmw}

Abyc +

Mbyh

Nbfy`h}} +

Yhmf|ykmfwv

F`oykx| +

Jkvbjwv

Bxwakyfwv +

Yh}|hmw

\xyfwv +

]b`mwfwv

Wayhbw


23/33

Nfoxyh 2 Fghkjkov


24/33

Nfoxyh 9 Wayhbw


25/33

Yhnhyh`mh}

Ihmehy* H !26?=& Wah Gh`fbj kn Ghbwa @h Vkye4 Nyhh \yh}}

Ik`b``k* OB* . Dk}w* DW !9


26/33

Oyhhìhyo* D* \v}tmtv`}ef* W* . ]kjkck`* ] !261>& Wah mbx}h} b`g mk`}hrxh`mh} kn b `hhg nky }hjn#

h}whhc4 b whyyky cb`bohch`w wahkyv F` Y N Ibxchf}why !Hg&* \xijfm }hjn b`g |yf~bwh }hjn !||216#

929& @h Vkye4 ]|yfòhy#^hyjbo

Okjghìhyo* D J* CmMkv* ] E* \v}tmtvè}f* W* Oyhhìhyo* D* . ]kjkck`* ] !9


27/33

Cbymx}* Ohkyoh H* _ Yx}}hjj @hxcb`* b`g Cfmabhj CbmExh` !9


28/33

B||h`gfq B4 Ckywbjfwv ]bjfh`mh Wyhbwch`w

K` wah nkjjkfò |boh byh wk k|h`#h`ghg rxh}wfk`}* |jhb}h yh}|k`g wk wahc fwa vkxynfy}w* `bwxybj yh}|k`}h

_h byh jkkefò nky |hk|jh} oxw#jh~hj yhbmwfk`} wk wah}h rxh}wfk`}

Wah \ykdhmwf~h Jfnh Bwwfwxgh} B}}h}}ch`w

Waf} b}}h}}ch`w f} b yhmh`wjv gh~hjk|hg* f``k~bwf~h |hy}k`bjfwv b}}h}}ch`w Yhmh`w

yh}hbyma }xooh}w} wabw nhhjfò} b`g bwwfwxgh} bikxw }fo`fnfmb`w b}|hmw} kn jfnh whjj x} bmk`}fghybijh bckx`w bikxw wah f`gf~fgxbj} |hy}k`bjfwv Vkxy yh}|k`}h} wk waf}

}xy~hv fjj ih mk`wh`w#b`bjvthg f` kyghy wk b}}h}} mhywbf` gfch`}fk`} kn vkxy|hy}k`bjfwv Vkxy ak`h}w yh}|k`}h} wk wah nkjjkfò rxh}wfk`} fjj ih b||yhmfbwhg

2 \JHB]H IYFHNJV GH]MYFIH WAH HCKWFK@] WABW WAH WAKXOAW KNVKXY K_@ GHBWA BYKX]H] F@ VKX

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

9 DKW GK_@* B] ]\HMFNFMBJJV B] VKX MB@* _ABW VKX WAF@E _FJJAB\\H@ WK VKX B] VKX \AV]FMBJJV GFH B@G K@MH VKX BYH\AV]FMBJJV GHBG

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[


29/33

B||h`gfq I4 Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Rxh}wfk``bfyh

\byw 2 _ah` vkx ghmfgh ahwahy }kchwafò f} yfoaw ky ykò* wk abw hqwh`w byh wahnkjjkfò mk`}fghybwfk`} yhjh~b`w wk vkxy wafèfò; \jhb}h ybwh hbma }wbwhch`w x}fò

waf} }mbjh4

U


30/33

[[[[[[Dx}wfmh f} wah ck}w fc|kywb`w yhrxfyhch`w nky b }kmfhwv[[[[[[\hk|jh }akxjg ih jkvbj wk wahfy nbcfjv chcihy}* h~h` ah` wahv ab~h gk`h

}kchwafò ykò[[[[[[Ch` b`g kch` hbma ab~h gfnnhyh`w ykjh} wk |jbv f` }kmfhwv

[[[[[[F kxjg mbjj }kch bmw} ykò k` wah oykx`g} wabw wahv byh x``bwxybj

[[[[[[Fw mb` `h~hy ih yfoaw wk efjj b axcb` ihfò[[[[[[ F wafè fw} ckybjjv ykò wabw yfma mafjgyh` fàhyfw b jkw kn ck`hv afjh |kkymafjgyh` fàhyfw `kwafò

[[[[[[ Fw f} ckyh fc|kywb`w wk ih b whbc |jbvhy wab` wk hq|yh}} k`h}hjn[[[[[[ Fn F hyh b }kjgfhy b`g gf}boyhhg fwa cv mkccb`gfò knnfmhy} kyghy}* F kxjg

kihv b`vbv ihmbx}h wabw f} cv gxwv

[[[[[[ Mab}wfwv f} b` fc|kywb`w b`g ~bjxbijh ~fywxh


31/33

B||h`gfq M4 Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Rxh}wfk``bfyh4 =


32/33

OKKG Fw f} ihwwhy wk gk okkg wab` wk gk ibg U@kw }mkyhg* f`mjxghg wk nkymh x}h kn wk|

kn wah }mbjh* b`g wk mbwma b`g mxw |hk|jh ak yh}|k`g fwa nfy}w = yh}|k`}h k|wfk`}S

Abyc4

MKC\B]]FK@ # Mkc|b}}fk` nky wak}h ak byh }xnnhyfò f} wah ck}w myxmfbj ~fywxhB@FCBJ # K`h kn wah ky}w wafò} b |hy}k` mkxjg gk f} axyw b ghnh`}hjh}} b`fcbjEFJJ # Fw mb` `h~hy ih yfoaw wk efjj b axcb` ihfò

Nbfy`h}}4

NBFYJV # _ah` wah ok~hy`ch`w cbeh} jb}* wah `xcihy k`h |yf`mf|jh }akxjg ihh`}xyfò wabw h~hyvk`h f} wyhbwhg nbfyjv

DX]WFMH Dx}wfmh f} wah ck}w fc|kywb`w yhrxfyhch`w nky b }kmfhwvYFMA # F wafè fw} ckybjjv ykò wabw yfma mafjgyh` fàhyfw b jkw kn ck`hv afjh |kky

mafjgyh` fàhyfw `kwafò

Fòykx|4AF]WKYV # F bc |ykxg kn cv mkx`wyv} af}wkyv

NBCFJV # \hk|jh }akxjg ih jkvbj wk wahfy nbcfjv chcihy}* h~h` ah` wahv ab~h gk`h}kchwafò ykò

WHBC # Fw f} ckyh fc|kywb`w wk ih b whbc |jbvhy wab` wk hq|yh}} k`h}hjn

Bxwakyfwv4EFGYH]\HMW # Yh}|hmw nky bxwakyfwv f} }kchwafò bjj mafjgyh` `hhg wk jhby`

]HQYKJH] # Ch` b`g kch` hbma ab~h gfnnhyh`w ykjh} wk |jbv f` }kmfhwv]KJGFHY # Fn F hyh b }kjgfhy b`g gf}boyhhg fwa cv mkccb`gfò knnfmhy} kyghy}* F

kxjg kihv b`vbv ihmbx}h wabw f} cv gxwv

\xyfwv4ABYCJH]]GO # \hk|jh }akxjg `kw gk wafò} wabw byh gf}ox}wfò* h~h` fn `k k`h f}

abychgX@@BWXYBJ # F kxjg mbjj }kch bmw} ykò k` wah oykx`g} wabw wahv byh x``bwxybj

MAB]WFWV # Mab}wfwv f} b` fc|kywb`w b`g ~bjxbijh ~fywxh

Wah Ckybj Nkx`gbwfk`} Rxh}wfk``bfyh !nxjj ~hy}fk`* Dxjv 9


33/33

B||h`gfq G4 ]GK + Y_B4 ]akyw \yhdxgfmh ]mbjh}

B`g k`h jb}w wafò4 ]kchwfch} h wh}w rxh}wfk`} nky kwahy }xy~hv} Wah}h rxh}wfk`} cbvih gfnnhyh`w* ixw dx}w b`}hy wahc b} ih}w vkx mb`

F/c okfò wk yhbg vkx b nh }wbwhch`w} Dx}w whjj ch fn vkx4

U]wykòjv BoyhhS* UBoyhhS* UGf}boyhhS* ky U]wykòjv Gf}boyhhS fwa hbma }wbwhch`w

2& Fw/} KE fn }kch oykx|} ab~h ckyh kn b mab`mh f` jfnh wab` kwahy}9& Fn mhywbf` oykx|} }wbvhg f` wahfy |jbmh* h kxjg ab~h nhhy |ykijhc}=& Wk ohw bahbg f` jfnh* fw f} }kchwfch} `hmh}}byv wk }wh| k` kwahy oykx|}7& _h }akxjg gk abw h mb` wk hrxbjfth mk`gfwfk`} nky gfnnhyh`w oykx|}8& Fw kxjg ih okkg fn oykx|} mkxjg ih hrxbj>& Wahyh f} `k )K@H yfoaw bv) wk jf~h jfnh5 h~hyvikgv ab} wk myhbwh wahfy k` bv?&

Wah k`jv bv kxy mkx`wyv mb` ohw waykxoa wah myf}f} bahbg f} wk ohw ibme wk kxywybgfwfk`bj ~bjxh}* |xw }kch wkxoa jhbghy} f` |khy* b`g }fjh`mh wah wykxijhcbehy}

}|yhbgfò ibg fghb}1& Okg} jb} bikxw bikywfk`* |ky`koyb|av b`g cbyyfboh cx}w ih }wyfmwjv nkjjkhg

ihnkyh fw f} wkk jbwh* b`g wak}h ak iyhbe wahc cx}w ih }wykòjv |x`f}ahg6& H~hyvk`h }akxjg ab~h wahfy k` jfnh}wvjh* yhjfofkx} ihjfhn}* b`g }hqxbj

|yhnhyh`mh}* h~h` fn fw cbeh} wahc gfnnhyh`w nykc h~hyvk`h hj}h Fw/} KE fn }kchoykx|} ab~h ckyh kn b mab`mh f` jfnh wab` kwahy}

B||h`gfq H4 Yk}hìhyo ]hjn#H}whhc ]mbjh

!Hbma }wbwhch`w b} nkjjkhg iv b wbijh |yk~fgfò yh}|k`}h} 2 >* fwa 2 3 Gf}boyhh

^hyv Cxma* b`g > 3Boyhh ^hyv Cxma&

F`}wyxmwfk`}4 _h byh f`whyh}whg f` ak wah `hqw }hw kn }wbwhch`w} gh}myfih} vkx \jhb}hybwh ak mabybmwhyf}wfm hbma }wbwhch`w f} kn vkx iv h`whyfò wah `xcihy nykc wah

mkyyh}|k`gfò }mbjh wabw ih}w yh|yh}h`w} vkxy b`}hy

2 F nhhj wabw F bc b |hy}k` kn kywa* bw jhb}w k` b` hrxbj ib}f} fwa kwahy}9 F nhhj wabw F ab~h b `xcihy kn okkg rxbjfwfh}

= Bjj f` bjj* F bc f`mjf`hg wk nhhj wabw F bc b nbfjxyh7 F bc bijh wk gk wafò} b} hjj b} ck}w kwahy |hk|jh

8 F nhhj wabw F gk `kw ab~h cxma wk ih |ykxg kn> F wbeh b |k}fwf~h bwwfwxgh wkbyg cv}hjn

? K` wah akjh* F bc }bwf}nfhg fwa cv}hjn1 F f}a F mkxjg ab~h ckyh yh}|hmw nky cv}hjn

6 F mhywbf`jv nhhj x}hjh}} bw wfch}2

Mortal Morality. How Threat and Partisanship Influence Moral Judgment

Documents