Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly 1 MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION AND OLIGOPOLY ECO 2023 Principles of Microeconomics Dr. McCaleb
Dec 29, 2015
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
1
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION AND OLIGOPOLY
ECO 2023Principles of Microeconomics
Dr. McCaleb
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
2
TOPIC OUTLINE
I. Monopolistic Competition
II. Oligopoly
III. Cartels
IV. Making Markets Competitive
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
3
Monopolistic Competition
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
4
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Characteristics of Monopolistic Competition
Definition
A market in which there are many sellers, each selling a differentiated product, with unrestricted or low-cost long-run entry and exit of resources.
Key characteristics
• Many buyers and sellers (same as perfect competition)
• Product differentiation
• Unrestricted entry and exit (same as perfect competition)
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
5
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Characteristics of Monopolistic Competition
Product differentiation
Supplying a good that is slightly different from the goods of competing suppliers.
Consumers view each supplier’s product as a close, but not a perfect, substitute for any other supplier’s product.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
6
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Characteristics of Monopolistic Competition
Examples of product differentiation
• Design (for example, Macintosh computers compared with PC’s).
• Reliability (for example, warranties or brand names).
• Location (for example, gasoline marketers near interstate highways).
• Costly information (for example, the same good sold in different stores at different prices).
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
7
The bookstore market portrayed in the video clip is monopolistically competitive and not perfectly competitive because
1. there are many bookstores.
2. each bookstore offers a slightly different set of products and services
3. there are no significant barriers to entry into the bookstore market
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
8
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Characteristics of Monopolistic Competition
Demand and marginal revenue are negatively-sloped
Because of imperfect substitutability, suppliers in a monopolistically competitive market have some market power. Consumer demand for each supplier’s output is negatively-sloped.
Negatively-sloped demand curvemarginal revenue is less than price at each quantity.
Marginal revenue curve is negatively-sloped and lies below the demand curve.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
9
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION Long Run Equilibrium
Sellers earn zero long-run economic profit
Short-run economic profits induce entry
Same as perfect competition. Short-run economic profits provide an incentive for new resources to enter the market in the long run.
Entry of new competitors reduces each seller’s market share. Demand for each individual seller’s product decreases and price falls until economic profit is competed away.
Long-run equilibrium: Sellers earn zero economic profit (or a normal accounting profit).
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
10
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Long Run Equilibrium
Short-run economic losses induce exit
Same as perfect competition. Short-run economic losses create incentives for existing competitors to leave the market in the long run.
Exit of existing sellers increases each remaining seller’s market share. Demand for each remaining seller’s product increases and price rises until economic losses are eliminated.
Long-run equilibrium: Sellers earn zero economic profit (or a normal accounting profit).
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
11
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
The maximum price consumers are willing to pay for 150 pairs is $70 per pair.
so economic profit is $50 per pair or $7,500 a day.
The profit-maximizing quantity where marginal revenue equals marginal cost . . .
The average total cost to produce 150 pairs is $20 per pair, . . .
Short-Run Equilibrium
is 150 pairs of jeans per day.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
12
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
With increased competition, demand decreases to D' and marginal revenue decreases to MR'.
Short-run economic profit creates an incentive for entry of new resources.
Adjustment from Short Run to Long Run
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
13
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Long-Run Equilibrium
Profit-maximizing quantity is 50 pairs of jeans a day.
The price consumers are willing to pay for 50 pairs is $30 per pair.
Average total cost is also $30 per pair so economic profit is zero.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
14
In monopolistic competition
1. the demand curve facing each supplier is (vertical, horizontal, negatively-sloped, positively-sloped).
2. marginal revenue is (greater than, equal to, less than) price and the marginal revenue curve is (below, the same as, above) the demand curve.
3. equilibrium quantity is where (total revenue, price, marginal revenue) is (greater than, equal to, less than) (total cost, average total cost, marginal cost).
4. equilibrium price is shown by (demand, marginal revenue, marginal cost, average total cost) curve.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
15
In monopolistic competition
5. profit isa. positive if (price, marginal revenue) is
(greater than, equal to, less than) (average total cost, marginal cost).
b. zero if (price, marginal revenue) is (greater than, equal to, less than) (average total cost, marginal cost).
c. negative if (price, marginal revenue) is (greater than, equal to, less than) (average total cost, marginal cost).
6. long-run economic profit is (positive, negative, zero, either positive or zero).
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
16
In monopolistic competition, equilibrium quantity is where _____ and equilibrium price is shown by the _____ curve.
1. MR=MC; MR
2. MR=MC; demand
3. P=ATC; ATC
4. MC=ATC; MC
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
17
In monopolistic competition, suppliers earn _____ profit in the long run.
1. positive
2. zero
3. negative
4. positive or zero
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
18
Oligopoly
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
19
OLIGOPOLY
Characteristics of Oligopoly
Definition
A small number of suppliers in a market with substantial barriers to entry by potential competitors.
Key characteristics
• Market dominated by a few large suppliers
• High cost entry into the market because of natural (economic) or legal barriers to entry
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
20
OLIGOPOLY
Characteristics of Oligopoly
Examples
Do sellers in these markets behave competitively or monopolistically?
• Beverages (soft drinks)
• Music (CD’s)
• Tobacco
• Automobiles
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
21
OLIGOPOLY
Characteristics of Oligopoly
U.S. Market Share of Largest Sellers in Market
Beverages Music Tobacco Cars
Seller Share Seller Share Seller Share Seller Share
Coke 44.5% Polygram 24.5% PM 49.4% GM 29.3%
Pepsi 31.4% Warner 18.2% RJR 24.0% Ford 24.9%
Cadbury 14.4% Sony 16.6% B&W 15.0% Chrysler 16.1%
EMI 12.9%
BMG 12.2%
Total 90.3% Total 84.4% Total 88.4% Total 70.3%
Each of these industries is an oligopoly even though the sellers often behave competitively.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
22
OLIGOPOLY
Equilibrium in an Oligopoly
Range of possible oligopoly equilibria
Suppliers in some oligopolistic markets may behave as if they were competitive. Suppliers in other oligopolistic markets may behave as if they were monopolists.
Equilibrium in an oligopoly market can lie anywhere along the continuum from perfect competition to pure monopoly.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
23
OLIGOPOLY
Equilibrium in an Oligopoly
Competitive equilibrium
If the market behaves competitively, the marginal cost curve is the market supply curve.
Equilibrium occurs where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied with P=MC.
Economic profit in equilibrium is zero.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
24
OLIGOPOLY
Example: Competitive Equilibrium
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
25
OLIGOPOLY
Equilibrium in an Oligopoly
Monopolistic equilibrium
If the market behaves monopolistically, the suppliers cooperate to choose the price and quantity that maximizes total profit.
The monopolistic equilibrium quantity is where MR=MC.
Economic profit is positive.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
26
OLIGOPOLY
Example: Monopolistic Equilibrium
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
27
OLIGOPOLY
Equilibrium in an Oligopoly
Range of possible equilibria
Oligopoly equilibrium price is equal to or less than monopoly equilibrium price but greater than or equal to competitive equilibrium price.
Oligopoly equilibrium quantity is equal to or greater than monopoly equilibrium quantity but less than or equal to competitive equilibrium quantity.
Economic profit is positive unless oligopolists behave exactly as perfect competitors in which case economic profit is zero.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
28
OLIGOPOLY
Example: Range of Possible Equilibria
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
29
The equilibrium quantity in an oligopoly market is
1. always the same as the perfectly competitive equilibrium quantity.
2. always the same as the monopoly equilibrium quantity.
3. always the same as the monopolistically competitive equilibrium quantity.
4. equal to or greater than the monopoly equilibrium quantity but less than or equal to the perfectly competitive equilibrium quantity.
5. less than the monopoly equilibrium quantity or greater than the perfectly competitive equilibrium quantity.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
30
Cartels
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
31
Cartels
Definition
A group of suppliers acting together to limit output, raise price, and increase economic profit. Suppliers in a cartel attempt to act as if they were a monopolist so as to maximize their joint profits.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
32
Cartels
The short, unhappy life of a cartel
Every cartel faces three problems:
• Reaching agreement
• Detecting and preventing cheating
• Enforcing the agreement
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
33
Cartels
Reaching agreement
A profit-maximizing cartel must limit the market quantity to raise price to the monopoly level.
Cartel must reach agreement about how to allocate the resulting monopoly profits among all the suppliers in the cartel.
But each supplier’s share of the monopoly profits depends on its share of the market quantity so each supplier wants a larger quantity for itself but a smaller quantity for all the other suppliers.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
34
Cartels
Too many or too few?
Trade-off between including enough sellers to effectively limit market quantity and including so many sellers that high negotiation costs and small individual gains prevent reaching an agreement.
More suppliers means greater control over the market but• higher negotiation costs because each supplier has incentive to
hold out for larger share of profits• smaller gains to each supplier relative to going it alone.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
35
Cartels
Stability of demand and supply
Frequent changes in demand or supply require frequent renegotiation which is costly.
Possibility that each renegotiation will be unsuccessful and agreement will fall apart.
Cartels more likely to be successful in markets characterized by long-run stability in demand and supply.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
36
Cartels
Detecting and preventing cheating
Each cartel supplier has an incentive to expand its share of the market by reducing price below the cartel’s monopoly price or by engaging in other activities to gain a competitive advantage.
If all cartel suppliers engage in competitive behavior to expand market share, the cartel disintegrates into a competitive market.
Trade-off again—The larger the number of sellers, the more difficult it is to detect cheating and to identify the cheaters.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
37
Cartels
Enforcing the agreement
If cheating is detected, cartel must be able to take credible action to punish the cheaters.
Trade-off again—More suppliers make it harder to take action against each one.
Most successful cartels are either government-sanctioned with legal enforcement of the agreement or they are engaged in criminal activities and use extra-legal or illegal enforcement.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
38
Example: Duopoly in the airframe industry
Suppliers are interdependent
Two major airframe manufacturers worldwide, Boeing (U.S.) and Airbus (European)—a form of oligopoly called duopoly (a market with two suppliers).
The market price of airplanes depends on how many airplanes are produced. Market demand is negatively-sloped.
Each manufacturer’s profits depend on how many airplanes it supplies and on how many airplanes its competitor supplies.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
39
Example: Duopoly in the airframe industry
Range of equilibria
Competitive equilibrium: Q=12, P=$1 m. Total industry revenues are $12 m. and economic profits are zero.
Monopoly equilibrium: If Boeing and Airbus agree to limit quantity to the monopoly level, they maximize total industry profits. They produce 6 planes at a price of $13 m. each, and the industry generates $72 m. in economic profits.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
40
Example: Duopoly in the airframe industry
Reaching agreement
If Boeing supplies 4 of the 6 planes, its share of the $72 m. profit is $48 m. and Airbus’s share is $24 m. If Airbus supplies 4, its share is $48 m. and Boeing’s share is $24 m.
Boeing and Airbus must agree on some allocation of the joint profits, and more profits for one means less for the other. Failure to reach an agreement means the attempt to form a cartel fails.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
41
Example: Duopoly in the airframe industry
Detecting and preventing cheating
Suppose they reach an agreement to split the market. Each supplies 3 planes and earns $36 m. in economic profits.
If Boeing increases production to 4 planes, its profits increase to $40 m. even though industry profit decreases to $70 m. Boeing’s increased profits come at Airbus’s expense.
Each supplier has an incentive to expand its market share at the expense of the other.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
42
Example: Duopoly in the airframe industry
Enforcing the agreement
If Boeing expands its production to 4 planes per week in violation of the cartel agreement, what can Airbus do? Without legal or extra-legal enforcement, Airbus can only retaliate.
If Airbus retaliates by increasing its production to 4 planes per week, its profits increase to $32 m. but industry profits fall again to $64 m.
Both suppliers now have the same incentive to continue expanding production, and the cartel disintegrates into a competitive market, moving down the demand curve toward the competitive equilibrium.
CARTELS
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
43
According to the video clip, a key to DeBeers’s success as a cartel was
1. Economies of scale
2. Technological superiority
3. Government limits on entry into the diamond market
4. Inelasticity of demand because consumers perceive there are no close substitutes for diamonds
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
44
CARTELS
Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
In the 1970’s, OPEC succeeded in limiting the supply of crude oil produced by member countries so as to increase the price.
After 1980, however, the market imploded. Price fell almost as much as it had risen.
What happened? Why was the cartel’s success so short-lived?
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
45
CARTELS
Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
Reaching agreement
OPEC reached an agreement to limit quantity and to allocate market share among its members. But, the agreement disintegrated as OPEC’s share of the world oil market declined and demand fell because of . . .
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
46
CARTELS Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
New sources of supply
In the 1980’s OPEC faced new sources of supply from non-OPEC countries who expanded their market share at OPEC’s expense:
• North Sea (Great Britain and Norway)• Russia and former Soviet republics• Technology made Alberta tar sands and deep ocean drilling
profitable
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
47
CARTELS
Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
Greater energy efficiency and consumer substitution
The high price of oil in the 1970’s and early 1980’s created incentives for greater energy efficiency. Instead of remaining stable, world oil demand became quite volatile. Worldwide consumption fell and did not return to its 1980 level for 15 years.
The short-run elasticity of demand for oil and petroleum products is low, but the long-run elasticity is much higher as consumers adopt alternative energy sources and substitute more non-oil-intensive activities for oil-intensive activities.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
48
CARTELS
Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
Detecting and preventing cheating
Because crude oil is a relatively homogeneous product and the oil market is worldwide, it is difficult for OPEC to verify that each of its members is abiding by the agreed-upon production quotas.
By the 1980’s, member states with smaller market shares were clearly exceeding their production quotas. In particular, the 8-year Iran-Iraq war drove each country to maximize its own production to finance the war.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
49
CARTELS
Anatomy of a Cartel: OPEC
Enforcing the agreement
Short of going to war, OPEC lacks any mechanism to punish the cheaters, even if it could determine who they are.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
50
Is each of the following true or false: To be successful, a cartel must
1. be able to engage in price discrimination.
2. include enough sellers to effectively limit quantity but not so many sellers that high negotiation costs and small individual gains prevent reaching an agreement.
3. be able to detect cheating
4. be able to enforce the cartel agreement against cheaters.
5. have few or no close substitutes for its product.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
51
Making Markets Competitive
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
52
MAKING MARKETS COMPETITIVE
Benefits of Competitive Markets
Competitive markets, efficiency, profits and losses
The possibility of earning short-run economic profits and the threat of economic losses provide incentives for suppliers in competitive markets to
• use resources to satisfy consumer demand
• adopt the most efficient, least-cost operating methods
• be innovative.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
53
Benefits of Competitive Markets
Benefits and costs accrue to consumers
In the long run, entry into and exit from competitive markets drive prices up or down to equal costs so that suppliers earn only a normal accounting profit (zero economic profit).
Changes in demand or in cost are passed on to consumers through changes in prices and quantities. Suppliers gain or lose in the short run, but in the long run both the benefits and the costs are passed on to consumers.
MAKING MARKETS COMPETITIVE
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
54
Public Policy and Competition
Unrestricted entry and exit is the key
What makes a market competitive? Unrestricted entry and exit of resources
As long as there are no barriers to the entry of new resources or the exit of existing resources, suppliers will behave competitively—the market will be competitive.
Lack of competition in a market arises from barriers to entry and exit—from limitations, often imposed by government, on the entry of new competitors or the expansion of existing competitors.
MAKING MARKETS COMPETITIVE
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
55
Public Policy and Competition
Government policy is schizophrenic
Some government policies—the antitrust laws, for example—prohibit sellers from engaging in certain business practices if those practices have the effect of limiting competition or creating monopoly.
At the same time, most true monopolies are created or sanctioned by government—public franchises, government licenses, patents, and copyrights, for example—and many government regulations limit competition in the marketplace.
MAKING MARKETS COMPETITIVE
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
56
Public Policy and Competition
Lessons for public policy
It is not the number of sellers or their size that makes markets competitive. It is the freedom of competitors and potential competitors to reallocate resources efficiently in response to the profit and loss signals of the market.
Whether the market is perfectly competitive, monopolistically competitive, or oligopolistic is irrelevant. In fact,even a monopolist behaves competitively if there is sufficient threat of competition from outside its market.
The key to improved competitiveness is the elimination of restrictions on the ability of resources to enter or exit a market in response to short-run economic profit or loss.
MAKING MARKETS COMPETITIVE
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
57
True (T) or false (F): In any market where a few large sellers dominate the market, the sellers will act as if they were monopolists.
Monopolistic Competition and Oligopoly
58
The key to ensuring competitive behavior in any market is the absence of
1. price discrimination.
2. a few large sellers.
3. product differentiation.
4. barriers to entry into the market in the long run.
5. strategic behavior.