Top Banner
By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep.
34

Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Jun 14, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

By

Mo

ha

mm

ed

S S

ale

em

Sa

ud

i E

lect

rici

ty C

om

pa

ny /

EO

A

Ge

ne

rati

on

Te

chn

ica

l su

pp

ort

De

p.

Page 2: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Co

nte

nts

Intr

od

uct

ion

�W

hat

is

Sca

le E

xfo

liat

ion

�S

cale

Gen

erat

ion

�S

cale

Exf

oli

atio

n M

ech

anis

m

�S

cale

Acc

um

ula

tio

n

�S

cale

Acc

um

ula

tio

n m

on

ito

rin

g

�S

cale

exf

oli

atio

ns

Dam

ages

�M

easu

res

to b

e ta

ken

wh

en s

cale

exf

oli

atio

n

Occ

ur

�Q

PP

Exf

oli

atio

n P

rob

lem

s

�C

on

clu

sio

n

Page 3: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Intr

od

uct

ion

QP

P h

ad e

xper

ien

ced

tu

be

fail

ure

s in

th

e 2r

ySH

, 3r

ySH

an

d

2ryR

H a

nd

ou

tlet

leg

th

at i

s at

trib

ute

d t

o t

ub

e ex

tern

al

exfo

liat

ion

.

� �T

he

ori

gin

of

the

pro

ble

m i

n b

oth

3ry

SH

an

d 2

ryR

H i

s d

ue

to

hig

her

th

an e

xpec

ted

tu

be

met

al t

emp

erat

ure

. T

he

2ryS

H

pro

ble

m i

s at

trib

ute

d t

o u

nco

ntr

oll

ed d

esu

per

hea

ter

spra

y d

uri

ng

sta

rt-u

p.

�U

nd

er c

erta

in c

on

dit

ion

s, o

xid

e sc

ale

that

fo

rms

on

th

e o

ut

sid

ean

d i

nsi

de

surf

aces

of

sup

erh

eate

rtu

bes

an

d p

ipes

may

bre

ak

loo

se a

nd

exf

oli

ates

. I

t al

so s

usp

ecte

d t

hat

an

exc

essi

ve i

nte

rnal

o

xid

e sc

ale

exfo

liat

ion

wh

ich

cau

se c

om

ple

te o

r p

arti

al p

lugg

ing

of

the

stea

m f

low

pat

h.

Page 4: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Wh

at

is S

cale

Exf

oli

ati

on

�H

igh

tem

per

atu

re s

team

rea

cts

wit

h i

nte

rnal

met

al

surf

aces

to

fo

rm a

har

d t

enac

iou

s sc

ale.

�sc

ale

gro

wth

rat

e is

a f

un

ctio

n o

f m

ater

ial

of

con

stru

ctio

n,

tem

per

atu

re,

un

it s

tart

-up

an

d s

hu

tdo

wn

cyc

les.

�B

ecau

se o

f th

e d

iffe

ren

ce o

f co

effi

cien

ts o

f th

erm

al

exp

ansi

on

, ex

pan

sio

n a

nd

co

ntr

acti

on

du

rin

g s

tart

-up

s lo

ose

ns

the

scal

e ca

usi

ng

it

to e

xfo

liat

e (f

lak

es)

�T

he

exfo

liat

ion

pro

cess

is

a m

ech

anic

al p

roce

ss a

nd

du

e o

f so

me

stre

ss e

ffec

t

Page 5: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Sca

le G

en

era

tio

n

�A

fter

sta

rtin

g th

e b

oil

er o

per

atio

n ,

oxi

des

sca

les

gen

erat

es a

nd

sta

rt g

row

ing

�H

2O+

2e-

H2

+O

2-

�F

e++

+ O

2-F

e Y

O

�O

ute

r la

yer

is g

ener

ated

by

the

dif

fusi

on

of

Fe+

+ t

o

stea

m s

ide

(mag

net

ite

(Fe3

O4

) a

nd

hem

atit

e (F

e2O

3)

�In

ner

lay

er i

s ge

ner

ated

by

the

dif

fusi

on

of

O2-

mag

net

ite

, hem

atit

e an

d o

ther

ch

emic

al e

lem

ents

w

hic

h a

re i

ngr

edie

nts

of

ori

gin

al m

ater

ial.

Page 6: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Sca

le E

xfo

lia

tio

n M

ech

an

ism

�T

her

e is

no

str

ess

and

no

cra

ck i

n s

cale

du

rin

g b

oil

er o

per

atio

n.

�B

oil

er s

hu

t-d

ow

n a

nd

sta

rt-u

p ,t

her

mal

str

ess

aris

e at

th

e sc

ale

–met

al b

ou

nd

ary

du

e to

th

e d

iffe

ren

ce o

f th

erm

al e

xpan

sio

n c

oef

fici

ent

bet

wee

n s

cale

an

d m

etal

.

�sc

ale

is t

hin

an

d f

ragi

le t

he

ther

mal

str

ess

mak

es

crac

ks

on

ly i

n t

he

scal

e.

�n

um

ber

/si

ze o

f th

e cr

ack

s an

d o

ther

par

amet

ers

infl

uen

ce o

n t

he

adh

eren

ce f

orc

e o

f sc

ale

�sc

ale

exfo

liat

ion

wil

l ta

ke

pla

ce a

fter

man

y th

ou

san

ds

of

ho

urs

of

serv

ices

Page 7: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Sca

le e

xfo

lia

tio

n p

roce

ss p

ara

me

ters

Page 8: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Sca

le A

ccu

mu

lati

on

�S

cale

acc

um

ula

tio

n s

eem

s ra

nd

om

exc

ept

un

der

th

e co

nd

itio

n t

hat

th

ere

are

som

e te

chn

ical

/d

esig

n r

easo

ns

.

�M

ajo

rity

of

scal

e ac

cum

ula

tio

ns

hap

pen

at

the

bo

un

dar

y o

f in

ner

/ou

ter

laye

rs

�N

ew s

cale

gen

erat

ion

sta

rts

on

fre

sh s

urf

aces

aft

er

nex

t st

art

–up

.

Page 9: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Par

amet

ers

of s

cale

acc

umul

atio

n ar

e su

mm

ariz

ed in

the

fo

llow

ing

tabl

e

Page 10: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Sca

le A

ccu

mu

lati

on

mo

nit

ori

ng

�T

her

e ar

e m

ore

th

an o

ne

way

to

mo

nit

or

the

scal

e ac

cum

ula

tio

n r

eco

mm

end

ed :

•U

ltra

son

ic T

hic

kn

ess

exam

inat

ion

by

EM

AT

S

(Ele

ctro

mag

net

ic A

cou

stic

Tra

nsd

uce

r S

yste

m)

•In

eve

ry o

uta

ge

at l

east

10

% O

f th

e S

H/R

H s

ho

uld

R

T (

X-r

ay)

Insp

ecte

d t

o t

he

tren

d o

f sc

ale

Page 11: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Da

ma

ge

s e

xfo

lia

tio

ns

Sca

le

�20

-30

% o

fsc

ales

are

exf

oli

ated

in

on

e sh

ut

do

wn

an

d s

tart

-up

pro

cess

, p

oss

ibil

ity

of

com

ple

te

plu

ggin

g sh

ou

ld b

e co

nsi

der

ed.

�It

can

cau

se l

on

g te

rm o

verh

eati

ng

and

cre

ep

dam

age

�It

can

cau

se l

on

g te

rm o

verh

eati

ng

�F

ire

sid

e co

rro

sio

n b

ecau

se o

f h

igh

er t

ub

e te

mp

erat

ure

.

�In

cas

e o

fR

H t

his

fla

kin

g p

arti

cles

may

go

th

rou

gh t

o i

nte

rmed

iate

tu

rbin

e an

d d

amag

eth

e b

lad

es

Page 12: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Me

asu

res

to b

e t

ak

en

wh

en

sca

le

exf

oli

ati

on

Occ

ur

�T

he

bo

iler

can

be

sub

ject

ed t

o p

urg

ing

op

erat

ion

to

get

re

d o

f th

e sc

ale

flak

es d

uri

ng

th

e sh

ut-

do

wn

per

iod

.

�If

sca

le a

ccu

mu

lati

on

rat

io o

ver

50%

tu

bes

sho

uld

be

clea

ned

ou

t b

y m

ech

anic

al m

ean

s (B

end

tu

bes

to

be

rem

ove

d t

emp

ora

lly

and

rei

nst

alle

d).

�U

pg

rad

e th

e m

ater

ial

to S

A-2

13 T

P34

7FH

G w

ith

sh

ot

pee

nin

gto

res

ist

inte

rnal

sca

le e

xfo

liat

ion

Page 13: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P E

xfo

lia

tio

n P

rob

lem

s

�Q

PP

Bo

iler

Sp

ecif

icat

ion

�In

199

4,

Qu

rayy

ahP

ow

er P

lan

t U

nit

2 h

ad e

xper

ien

ced

p

rem

atu

re t

ub

e fa

ilu

res

in t

he

3ryS

H a

nd

2ry

RH

o

utl

et l

eg t

hat

is

attr

ibu

ted

to

tu

be

exte

rnal

ex

foli

atio

n

�T

he

ori

gin

of

the

pro

ble

m i

n b

oth

3ry

SH

an

d 2

ryR

H i

s d

ue

to h

igh

er t

han

exp

ecte

d t

ub

e m

etal

tem

per

atu

re

�In

20

02

un

it-4

QP

P h

ad e

xper

ien

ced

tu

be

fail

ure

s in

th

e 2r

ySH

, at

trib

ute

d t

o t

ub

e ex

tern

al e

xfo

liat

ion

.d

esu

per

hea

ter

spra

y d

uri

ng

sta

rt-u

p.

�A

ug

ust

20

07

, fi

rst

tub

e fa

ilu

re w

as e

xper

ien

ced

at

un

it-3

2r

yRH

an

d o

utl

et l

eg t

hat

is

attr

ibu

ted

to

tu

be

exte

rnal

exf

oli

atio

n.

Page 14: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 15: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Lap

an

aly

sis

rep

ort

Page 16: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P E

xfo

lia

tio

n P

rob

lem

s

Page 17: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 18: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 19: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 20: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Co

ncl

usi

on

�S

cale

exf

oli

atio

n c

an b

e a

very

ser

iou

s p

rob

lem

if

no

t m

on

ito

red

.

�M

ain

ten

ance

pro

gra

m s

ho

uld

in

clu

de

a sc

hed

ule

fo

r m

on

ito

rin

g t

he

scal

e ac

cum

ula

tio

n i

n t

he

bo

iler

tu

bes

sp

ecia

lly

for

tho

se b

oil

ers

wo

rkin

g c

on

scio

usl

y o

n

hig

h l

oad

.

�C

lose

mo

nit

ori

ng

to

th

e b

oil

er p

erfo

rman

ce m

ay g

ive

a h

igh

in

dic

atio

n o

f sc

ale

accu

mu

lati

on

rat

e.

�A

flu

shin

g p

roce

du

re s

ho

uld

be

ado

pte

d b

y th

e o

per

atio

n i

n o

rder

to

cle

an t

he

tub

es f

rom

th

e ac

cum

ula

ted

sca

le

Page 21: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 22: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

�T

he

ou

ter

laye

r is

gen

erat

ed b

y th

e d

iffu

sio

n o

f F

e++

to

the

stea

m s

ide

and

in

ner

gen

erat

ed b

y th

e d

iffu

sio

n o

f

O2-

to t

he

met

al S

ide.

�O

ute

r sc

ale

con

sist

s o

f m

agn

etit

e (F

e3O

4)

and

hem

atit

e

(Fe2

O3)

.

�In

ner

sca

le c

on

sist

s o

f m

agn

etit

e (F

e3O

4)

and

hem

atit

e

(Fe2

O3)

an

d o

ther

ch

emic

al e

lem

ents

wh

ich

are

in

gred

ien

ts o

f o

rigi

nal

mat

eria

l.

Page 23: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

�S

team

sid

e S

cale

exf

oli

atio

n i

n s

team

pla

nts

is

a ve

ry

seve

r p

rob

lem

wh

ish

can

res

ult

s in

sh

ort

-te

rm

ove

rhea

tin

g b

oil

er t

ub

e fa

ilu

res.

�In

ad

dit

ion

th

e so

lid

par

ticl

es c

an c

ause

th

e so

lid

p

arti

cle

ero

sio

n o

f th

e in

let

stag

es o

f th

e st

eam

tu

rbin

es(

inte

rmed

iate

tu

rbin

e st

ages

)

Page 24: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

Acc

um

ula

tio

n R

ate

Page 25: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation
Page 26: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

�In

sca

le w

hic

h h

as g

row

n b

eyo

nd

a c

erta

in t

hic

kn

ess,

th

e o

ute

r la

yer

exfo

liat

es d

ue

to t

he

dif

fere

nce

in

th

erm

al e

xpan

sio

n b

etw

een

th

e tu

be

mat

eria

l an

d t

he

scal

e d

uri

ng

sta

rt a

nd

sto

p o

f th

e b

oil

er

Page 27: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

rate

Page 28: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

pe

en

ing

Ma

teri

al

Up

gra

de

an

d s

ho

t

Page 29: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P F

ail

ure

Page 30: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P T

ub

e

fail

ur

Page 31: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P F

ail

ure

Page 32: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

QP

P 2

YR

h A

nd

3ry

SH

Page 33: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

U3

IP

tu

rbin

e b

lad

es

Gh

azl

an

de

po

sits

Page 34: Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA ... · By Mohammed S Saleem Saudi Electricity Company /EOA Generation Technical support Dep. Contents Introduction What is Scale Exfoliation

U3

IP

tu

rbin

e b

lad

es

Gh

azl

an

da

ma

ge

s