INDIA IN THE CHANGING GEOPOLITICS OF THE INDIAN OCEAN By: * Dr. Mohammed Khalid ABSTRACT Indian and the Indian Ocean are two inseparable entities. India owes its geophysical existence to the Indian Ocean. Throughout history India has been interacting with the lands and the peoples of its littoral through religion, culture and other means. There existed a certain unity in the Ocean for centuries till it was broken by the advent and impact of the advancing European colonial powers after 16th century. Exist of the colonial powers -the British, Dutch, French etc.- from the region after the Second World War made the countries of the region to refashion their foreign policies keeping in view their national interests, the emerging geopolitical realities and the dawning of Cold War in the region. India, uniquely positioned in the centre of the Indian Ocean realm opted for the non-alignment as its foreign policy and stood for making Indian Ocean a 'Zone of Peace'. On the other hand India started building up new relations with the littoral states of the Ocean. Over the last sixty years, India is more engaged than ever in the region through trade, aid and financial assistance. The Country is an important source of science and technology, education, turn-key projects in industry etc. Inspite of the efforts made in this regard, a lot needs to be done and that can happen only if India encashes upon the needs of development starved countries of the region. As an emerging economic and technological power India must consider the Indian Ocean region as the core area of its foreign policy and reinvent and reinvigorate its policy in this regard. It is incumbent on India to play a larger role in the region for its own economic development and to promote prospects of peace and cooperation in the region. * Sr. Lecturer in Political Science, Dept. of Evening Studies, Panjab University, Chandigarh 1
37
Embed
Mohammed Khalid: India in the Changing Geopolitics of the Indian Ocean
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
INDIA IN THE CHANGING GEOPOLITICS OF THE INDIAN OCEAN
By:*Dr. Mohammed Khalid
ABSTRACT
Indian and the Indian Ocean are two inseparable entities. India owes its geophysical existence to the Indian Ocean. Throughout history India has been interacting with the lands and the peoples of its littoral through religion, culture and other means. There existed a certain unity in the Ocean for centuries till it was broken by the advent and impact of the advancing European colonial powers after 16th century.
Exist of the colonial powers -the British, Dutch, French etc.- from the region after the Second World War made the countries of the region to refashion their foreign policies keeping in view their national interests, the emerging geopolitical realities and the dawning of Cold War in the region.
India, uniquely positioned in the centre of the Indian Ocean realm opted for the non-alignment as its foreign policy and stood for making Indian Ocean a 'Zone of Peace'. On the other hand India started building up new relations with the littoral states of the Ocean. Over the last sixty years, India is more engaged than ever in the region through trade, aid and financial assistance. The Country is an important source of science and technology, education, turn-key projects in industry etc. Inspite of the efforts made in this regard, a lot needs to be done and that can happen only if India encashes upon the needs of development starved countries of the region. As an emerging economic and technological power India must consider the Indian Ocean region as the core area of its foreign policy and reinvent and reinvigorate its policy in this regard. It is incumbent on India to play a larger role in the region for its own economic development and to promote prospects of peace and cooperation in the region.
* Sr. Lecturer in Political Science, Dept. of Evening Studies, Panjab University, Chandigarh
1
Embedded, and terrestrially moored to the surrounding ocean,
India is a gift of the Indian Ocean.1 The splitting of Gondwanaland
and drifting apart of the continents in their present shape about 150
million years ago,2 defined the contours, character and geographical
parameters of the South Asian sub-continent, of which India is a
preponderant feature.
Named after India by the Arabs who called it Bahr-e-Hind,
Indian Ocean had served as a protective shield around the sub-
continent till maritime activity perforated this shield through the
advent of the Europeans from the 16th century onwards. Until then,
life and history of India was entirely north-bound.3 The advent and
subsequent impact of the Europeans brought about a qualitative
change in the life of the South Asian sub-continent. The
ramifications and resonance of the change defined and determined
the extent and intensity of the Ocean’s linkages with contemporary
India. The experience and the legacy of colonialism–imperialism
have notably contributed to the Country’s consciousness of Indian
Ocean.
India has a long and rich history of cultural and commercial
interaction with the littoral and other territories of the Ocean. In
those times India influenced and attracted the peoples of Indian
Ocean through culture, religion, trade and commerce rather than
through military engagements and war. It is now used as an
ideological- spiritual input, or a buttress for India’s foreign policy
and position there. Otherwise, it is the immediate colonial past that
largely contributes to the present Indian orientation towards the
ocean.
The north-orientation and pre-occupation of Indian state with
the lands and peoples of central and west Asia continued
2
undiminished even under the colonial rule.4 The Second World War
changed this perspective drastically. The importance of the Indian
Ocean was realized in the wake of Japanese penetration of South
Asia, following the fall of Singapore in 1942.5 The “unfortunate
tendency to overlook the sea in the discussion of India’s defence
problems”, was pointed out by Pannikar, who said “India never lost
her independence till she lost the command of the sea in the first
decade of the 16th century.” He emphasized on the setting up of
distant basis like Singapore, Mauritius, Aden and Socotra as
outposts of the country’s defence, so that Indian Ocean must remain
truly Indian.6 Another view in this regard holds that even if India
does not rule the waves of all the oceans of the world, it must at
least rule the Indian Ocean by becoming undisputed power over its
waters.7
India is uniquely located with its triangular shaped southern
peninsula jutting out into the sea. It is washed by the Bay of Bengal
on the east and the Arabian Sea on the west. The 5,700 km8 long
coastline of the mainland has in its eastern part a number of deltas.
The west coast includes two peninsulas of Kutch and Kathiawar.
Western coastline runs more or less straight, the Cape Comorin to
the 22o parallel N. The coastline in the east runs in wide curves,
changing directions from north to north-east from the 16o parallel.9
India has a continental shelf varying in its width from 100 metres to
350 km at varying depths.
Indian Islands:
The Indian territory includes a number of islands in the Bay of
Bengal and the Arabian Sea. The islands in the Bay of Bengal -the
Andaman and Nicobar- are larger and more habitable in contrast to
the Lakshdweep islands in the Arabian Sea, which are small and
3
mostly uninhabited. The former represent elevated portions of
submarine mountains, while the latter islands are entirely built on
corals. The Andamans include 257 islands and Nicobar is composed
of 62 islands in the Bay of Bengal.10 Lying between 14o and 6o S
latitude, they are scattered over an area of 6,374 and 1,645 sq kms
respectively.11 Before independence, these groups of islands were
only marginally bound with the Indian mainland. After
independence, planned development was undertaken to integrate
them with India. These islands provide India a prime geographic
position which no other country enjoys in the Indian Ocean realm.
The geopolitical significance of these two groups of islands lies
in that they extend India’s boundary deep south into the Indian
Ocean, simultaneously making Indonesia, a close neighbour.12 By
extending India’s continental shelf that the archipelago of these
islands provides, the country’s area for exploitation of the shelf and
the Indian Ocean seabed is significantly enlarged.
Centrality of India
By virtue of its location, India has close neighbourhood not
only with Indonesia, Malaysia Thailand, Burma, Bangladesh, Sri
Lanka, Maldives and Pakistan, but it is also central to the entire
Indian Ocean. The African continent and Arabian peninsula to its
west and southwest, and southeast Asia to its east, impart unique
centrality to India in the Indian Ocean.
At independence, the leadership of the country headed by
Jawaharlal Nehru was fully conscious of the implications of this
geographical position. It was duly taken into account in the shaping
of India’s foreign relations. Country’s rapid economic development
was an urgent, high priority, which could not occur unless security
4
environment in its neighbourhood, and the Indian Ocean region as a
whole was congenial and conducive. For achieving an enduringly
peaceful security environment, it was imperative for India not
merely to stay away from the then emerging Cold War and military
alliances following the World War II, but also to see that their
pernicious impact did not impinge or enter this region. Nehru
regarded India as too big a country to be bound down in military or
political alliances of any kind to any country, however big that
country may be.13 He maintained:
"I do not say that our country is superior or that we are
above passion and prejudice, hatred and fury. But as
things are, there are certain factors which help us. First
of all, we are geographically so situated that we are not
drawn into controversies with that passionate fury that
some other countries are. This is not due to our
goodness or badness, but is a matter of geography".14
The geographical insularity caused by the Himalayas and the
Indian Ocean also made Nehru15 think that India is going to be a
meeting ground of various trends and forces in the region. India’s
abysmal poverty and economic backwardness had also to be shed
away through mutual economic relations and help with other
countries of the Region. Nehru was clear: “ultimately, foreign policy
is the outcome of the economic policy, and until India has properly
evolved her economic policy, her foreign policy will be rather vague,
rather inchoate, and will be groping.16 It was quite impossible for
India to invest in military build up without jeopardizing the outlays
for her economic development. So the Indian leadership decided to
concentrate on economic diplomacy17 instead of diverting the
country’s limited resources into expensive military build up.
5
Under the circumstances, the posture, credo and policy of
non-alignment meant non-involvement in power politics which had
hitherto permeated and characterized the world. Nonetheless, an
active and moral role in the affairs of the world must be played in
the cause of promotion and preservation of peace. The policy
reflected “at once a desire to avoid commitment -an understandable
attitude for any people of meager resources- and a wish to be
among those who count in world affairs.”18
The manifestations of Cold War were more prominent in the
Indian Ocean region. The Korean War in the vicinity of the Region
was the first demonstration of emerging Cold War. Indian Ocean and
its littoral was effectively used by the US to contain the Soviet
Communism. The British withdrawal from the east of Suez in 1971
and corresponding entry of the US naval forces to fill the so called
“power vacuum” in the region conspicuously brought the Cold War
at India's doorsteps which made its commitment stronger to
campaign against the Cold War. India’s policy was “of trying to
realize security largely through promoting peaceful regional
cooperation among the littoral and hinterland states and preventing
the militarisation of the Indian Ocean.”19
India’s concern over the security of the Indian Ocean was in
evidence as early as 1965. In November that year Britain granted
independence to Mauritius and Seychelles. The British detached the
Islands of Aldabra, Furquhar and Desroches from Seychelles and
Diego Garcia from Mauritius to establish British Indian Ocean
Territory (BIOT). Later, Diego Garcia was transferred to USA,
ostensibly to set up a communication facility but was gradually
expanded as an effective naval base.20 The growing US naval
presence was counter productive as Soviet naval forces too began
6
showing their presence in the region and look out for possible naval
bases around the ocean littoral.21 India also contested the concept of
“power vaccum”. Prime Minister Mrs. Gandhi never missed an
opportunity of proclaiming that Indian Ocean should be kept a
nuclear free area.22 The Lusaka conference of non-aligned heads of
state, in September 1970, adopted the resolution to consider and
respect “the Indian Ocean as a Zone of Peace.”23 India sharply
reacted in 1970 to the British intent to supply “limited categories of
defensive weapons to South Africa under Simons Town Agreement
in 1970.24
The Commonwealth Heads of Government Conference was
held at Singapore in January 1971. India’s Minister of Foreign Affairs,
Swarn Singh elaborated India’s position and concern about Indian
Ocean at the conference. He expressed “concern” at the arrival of
the “power game” in the Indian Ocean. Until now a peaceful ocean,
he dismissed the Soviet threat as “hypothetical”, the littoral states,
he said, were “far more concerned over the growth of South African
military power” and the construction of the Diego Garcia base was
sure to bring in other big powers. “India would like all big powers,
including the Soviet Union, United States, France, Britain to leave
the area alone.”25 At the United Nations, India, together with Sri
Lanka succeeded in having a resolution adopted by the General
Assembly on 16 December 1971, which called for peace zone to be
established in the Indian Ocean and “that the area should be free of
nuclear weapons.”26 The power rivalry and its inevitable pernicious
consequences for the region became a major issue which India
relentlessly pursued at the conferences and meetings of the non-
aligned, the Commonwealth, the Afro-Asian countries, the Arab
League, the OAU and so on, as also in various bilateral discussions.27
7
India’s naval outreach in the Ocean
With a coastline of 7,516 km with a total of 1,197 island
territories in the Bay of Bengal and the Arabian Sea, India has an
Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of 2.01 million Sq.km. About 90
percent by volume and 77 percent of total value of India’s trade
comes through the ocean. The resource rich EEZ provides 68% of its
oil production (at Bombay High) and fish production of 2.82 million
tones. Country's entire oil and gas supplies are imported through
the ocean. Therefore its economy and development is crucially
dependent on the waters of Indian Ocean.
Apart from the foreign policy measures, to provide naval
security to these crucial maritime interests, India has built a
formidable navy and Coast Guard. For this purpose its navy has
three commands, i.e., Western, Eastern and Southern with their
headquarters at Mumbai, Vishakhapatnam and Kochi. Navy has two
fleets, the Western and Eastern comprising ships, air crafts and
submarines. Over the years the country has developed major Naval
air bases at Goa and Arkonnam and other air bases at
Visakhapatnam. To protect its economic and territorial interests in
the deep south of the ocean it has also developed air bases at Port
Blair and Car Nicobar in the Andaman and Nicobar islands. Minor
naval establishments are also strategically located at Chennai,
Kolkata, Chilka, Lonavala and Jamnagar.28
Set up in August 1978, the Indian Coast Guard (ICG) is
entrusted to protect India’s national interests in its maritime zone.
This force keeps regular surveillance of India’s EEZ to prevent
poaching and smuggling. The Coast Guard conducts rescue
operations and protects marine environment etc.29 To augment its
naval strength further, India has launched Project Seabird, which
8
consists of the Karawar (Karnataka) naval base, an air force station,
a naval armament depot, and missile silos to be realised in next five
years. Kadamba in Karawar is being developed as a naval base to
protect country's Arabian Sea maritime routes. The entire project
will cost 8.13 billion US dollars.30 No other country in the region has
such an impressive and powerful navy. It speaks of India's growing
involvement in the ocean to protect its maritime interests and
secure the sea lanes of communication and transportation.
Defence Cooperation
Having one of the most elaborate defence establishment in
the region and effective naval presence, India has extended helping
hand to the friendly countries of the Indian ocean region by training
their defence, para-military and police personnel in various fields. In
the College of Defence Management Secundrabad, these foreign
defence persons attend Campus programmes to learn modern,
scientific management. Training is also given to middle level officers
from these countries at Defence Services Staff College, Wellington.
The Military College of Telecommunication Engineering, Mhow,
imparts training in signals, information technology and
communication to the defence and para military forces. At the Army
School of Physical Training Pune, instructors are trained from the
countries like Maldives, Mauritius, Myanmar and Sri Lanka.31 India
also provides assistance under Indian Technical and Economic
Cooperation (ITEC) programme of Ministry of External Affairs, by
providing training to Army personnel from the countries of
Southeast Asia, Africa and neighouring countries. Similarly National
Defence College, New Delhi trains defence personnels from these
countries in Politico-Strategic Gaming Exercises and Research
activities etc.
9
India has intensified its pace of cooperation with the countries
of Indian Ocean region. After the success of tsunami diplomacy,32 it
is looking forward to evolve new channels of naval diplomacy with
these countries. Joint naval exercises with Malaysia, Singapore,33
Iran are frequently taking place to transfer naval warfare technology
and training to these countries. Indian warships are making port-
calls in Bangladesh, Myanmar etc. In July 2006, the country handed
over a 26 ton fast track craft –INS Tilanchang-- to Maldives. By these
and many other such measures India has sufficiently demonstrated
its naval capability and outreach in the Ocean and its littoral. India's
defence exports touched 13 million US dollars topped by the supply
of advanced light helicopter (Dharuv), Lancer attack helicopter and
Dornier transport planes to Mauritius. It has also supplied radars to
Indonesia and Sudan.34
The Economic thrust
During the last sixty years, India has adopted many pronged
strategy towards the Indian Ocean. Its foreign policy of non-
alignment and refusal to be drawn into international military power
politics; opposition to Cold War; contesting the so called "power
vacuum" theory promoted by the West to justify US presence in the
Indian Ocean; efforts to declare Indian Ocean as a peace zone; build
up of a strong navy and offering naval cooperation with the
countries of the region are one aspect of this strategy. On the other
hand India has engaged in varied economic activities like trade, aid
and setting up of joint ventures, business subsidiaries and transfer
of technology to these countries. This growing economic partnership
has been widely recognized by these countries. India's economic
interests in the region are served through trade, commerce and
technical assistance.
10
Trade:
Till independence, India had little trade with the countries of
the region as its economy was bound with and subservient to that of
Great Britain and some Commonwealth Countries. Even after
independence the direction of trade did not immediately shift much
to its neighbourhood but instead to the eastern bloc countries and
the Soviet Union. India’s dominant trade activity in the region till
the end of 1970s was oil import from the Persian Gulf region and
export of some foodstuffs to them.35
Over the last few decades India’s foreign trade has undergone
a complete change so far as its direction and composition is
concerned. The exports now cover a wide range of traditional and
non-traditional items and nature of imports has also undergone a
change. Till 1990 India’s foreign trade was subject to strict
bureaucratic and legal controls and foreign exchange regulations
were tight. It was a trade deficit economy where imports included
capital goods, defence equipments, petroleum products and raw
materials. Exports were unduly sluggish.
After1991, the government introduced a series of reforms to
liberalise and globalise the foreign trade. Its exports have grown
from Rs. 32,558 crore in 1990-91 to Rs. 2,91,582 crore in 2003-04
and imports from Rs. 43,193 crore in 1990-91 to Rs. 3,53,976 crore
in 2003-04.36
India has emphasized to develop close trade relations with the
countries of the Indian ocean region. The major commodities India
exports include textiles, chemical and related products, engineering
goods, gems and jewelry, petroleum products and agricultural
11
products etc.37 Indian Exports (by value in crore rupees) to the
countries of Indian Ocean are shown below.
Table – 1
Value of Exports from India to the Countries of Indian Ocean
Region
Country April-Feb.
2007
%share of Exports
South Africa 8,926.28 1.75
Mozambique 770.46 0.15
Tanzania 1,172.18 0.23
Kenya 5,367.24 1.05
Ethiopia 473.15 0.09
Djibauti 1,311.40 0.26
Israel 5,358.63 1.05
Jordan 725.02 0.14
Saudi Arabia 10,123.24 1.98
Yemen 4,952.75 0.97
Oman 2,588.84 0.51
UAE 49,090.65 9.62
Qatar 1,305.43 0.26
Bahrain 750.17 0.15
Iraq 856.33 0.17
Iran 6,048.28 1.18
Pakistan 5,481.10 1.07
Bangladesh 6,568.44 1.29
Myanmar 561.59 0.11
Thailand 5,897.36 1.16
Singapore 24,616.62 4.82
12
Indonesia 8,462.33 1.66
Australia 3,707.92 0.73
Sri Lanka 9,262.88 1.81
Maldives 278.51 0.05
Mauritius 2,957.71 0.58
Madagascar 173.63 0.03
Reunion 84.39 0.02
Seychelles 52.35 0.01
Comoros 22.79 -
Source: System of Foreign Trade Analysis, Dept. of Commerce, govt. of India. See. www.commerce.nic.in/India_trade.htm
The exports from India indicate that their nature and quantum
has diversified. Almost nil at the time of independence, about one-
third of India’s exports are now directed towards the countries of
the region. Significantly, India exports its goods to all the countries
and island states of the Region.
Major import commodities to India include petroleum, which