Mobile Phones, Empowerment and Female Headed Households -Trincomalle district , Sri Lanka

Mobile Phones, Empowerment and Female

Headed Households:Trincomalee, Sri Lanka

Achala AbeykoonPhD CandidateFaculty of Arts & EducationDeakin University, Australia

The Outline• Introduction

• Research Problem

• Research Objectives

• Research Questions

• Theoretical Frameworks

• Literature Review

• Research Methodology

• Findings & discussion

• Conclusions

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 2

Introduction• By the end of 2015 – Mobile-cellular subscriptions is more than 7 billion worldwide with a penetration

rate of 96.8. (ITU 2015)

• Ease of use, convergent nature, wider availability & affordability have converted the mobile phone

into an ICT4D (ICT for Development) to empower the poor and oppressed.

(Gurumurthy 2004; Samarajiva 2008)

• Post-conflict countries can leapfrog into the mobile age rather than reconstruct fixed networks.

(Jamali 2003; Samarajiva et al. 2008)

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 3

Country Profile

• Sri Lanka is an island surrounded by the northern Indian Ocean with 65,610 sq. kms of land area.

• Sri Lanka is a ethnically and culturally diverse country with a 20,902,928 million of population in 2014.

• Official Languages – Sinhala, Tamil and English

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 4Source: Government of Sri Lanka, 2013

Ethnic composition of Sri Lanka Religious composition

• Sri Lanka achieved the status of a middle-income country in 2010.

• Main sectors of GDP - services (59.5%), industry (29.3%) & agriculture (11.2%).

• Unemployment rate is 4.9 % (by 2010) and the population living below the poverty line is 15.2 %. (Central Bank of Sri Lanka 2012)

• Sri Lanka is still recovering from the civil conflict fought mainly between the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) and the Sri Lankan Government – between early 1980s and 2009.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 5

Country Profile cont…

The Trincomalee District

• The research sites of this study is from the Trincomalee, one of the three districts in Eastern province.

• Total population - 378, 182- a multi-ethnic & multi-religious society (Dept. of Census & Statistics

2012)

• A strategically important district with its natural harbor - 5th largest natural harbour in the world

• Main economic sectors – agriculture, fisheries & tourism

• Internally displaced population - 131,760

• 74% due to the conflict & 26% due to the Tsunami (2004)

• Increased number of female headed households - a critical consequence of the war and Tsunami

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 6

• 42,565 war widows in the Eastern province, representing 18.6% of FHHs in the country (The Ministry of Women and Child Affairs; Eastern Provincial Council 2011)

• Widows in Trincomalee - 14, 605, the highest number of widows (5948) are Tamils.

• Thus, the Government encourages them to be engaged in income earning activities – with a SL Rs. 200, 000 per family given as a loan and a block of land.

• Yet, many widows are unable to claim them as their marriages had not been officially registered or no legal document regarding their widow status is available when the death certificate for the husband cannot be provided.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 7

Female Headed cont.…

Mobile Communications in Sri Lanka

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 8

• First country in South Asia to commence mobile cellular communication and 3G & 4G networks.

• By September, 2014 – 21,727,589 mobile subscribers while mobile subscription per 100 people was 105 (Telecommunication Regulatory Commission Sri Lanka, 2015)

• By 2012, 90.62% - pre-paid mobile subscribers and 9.38% - post-paid subscribers (GSMA 2013)

• 2013 – 90% covered by 2G & 70% by 3G networks

3G Coverage in Sri Lanka

Source: Mobitel 2013

• However, despite the island-wide mobile coverage and high competition within the mobile market, mobile penetration is still lower in rural areas where the majority of the population lives.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 9

Urban Vs Rural Mobile Penetration

Source: GSMA Intelligence 2013, p.6

Mobile Communication in the Eastern Province

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 10

• Due to the civil conflict, telecommunications within Eastern and Northern provinces did not enjoy optimum levels until recently

• There is still a high demand for mobile phones in the war-affected Northern and Eastern parts of the country where nearly 14% of the country’s total population lives (GSMA Intelligence 2013, p. 5; Dept. of Census & Statistics

2013)

• In the Eastern province, only 63.5% of households owned a telephone/cellular phone, the lowest in the country; while the highest 86.0% is in the Western province which includes the capital Colombo.

• At present, leading mobile operators have created special packages to attract more customers from these provinces with a special emphasis made on international call rates. (SLT 2013, p. 60; Etisalat - biggest winner at the Effie Awards

2012)

Research Problem• The study will explore:

• how the mobile phone functions in empowering female heads of households in the Trincomalee district, Sri Lanka which is recovering from a 30-year civil war and the 2004 Boxing Day Tsunami.

• how the use of mobile phones by the female heads of households in Trincomalee District, Sri Lanka is shaped by the gendered power relations and inequalities in their respective cultures and communities.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 11

Research Objectives

• To explore: • How female heads of households achieve empowerment through the day-to-

day use of mobile phones in Trincomalee district, Sri Lanka.

• How the gendered power relations and inequalities within society may be reinforced and challenged through their usage.

• How they have appropriated the mobile phone, shaped by socio – economic, cultural and demographic factors.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 12

Research Questions

1. For what purposes do female heads of households use the mobile phone?

2. What constraints if any, do they experience in their day- to-day use of mobile phones?

3. How do socio-economic factors and demographic characteristics of female heads of households influence their adoption and appropriation of mobile phones?

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 13

Theoretical framework• The study uses the epistemology of constructionism which believes in reality as

created when the object (the phone) and the subject (the user) - which are both active, come together to make meanings of the object. (Crotty 1998)

• It applies theoretical approach of critical theory - points out something that is wrong or unfair in society and examines the power relations embedded in the situation and whose interests are served in the process. (Calhoun 1995)

• It is based on action research- an applied research and methodology that aims to empower the powerless and oppressed in society (Kemmis & McTaggart 2011)

• It uses • the interpretivist paradigm - discusses how people make meanings of their actions when

carried out for a particular purpose (Williams & May 1996) • The functionalist paradigm - looks at causes for particular human behaviours

(Morgan 1980; Williams & May 1996)15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 14

Literature Review• Women use mobile phones to maintain their family and social relationships

• gain social and spatial empowerment

• a higher level of safety and security attained is the most important benefit (Bayes et al. 1999; Handapangoda & Kumara 2013; Wei and Lo 2006; Tacchi, Kitner & Crawford 2012; Wanasundera 2012)

• Economic empowerment – • Female entrepreneurs of SMEs - seek relevant information, skip middlemen, obtain pricing

information and placing orders without travelling (Bayes et al. 1999; Sundari 2010; Potnis 2011; Tacchi, Kitner & Crawford 2012; Wanasundara 2012)

• Enabling women – Those physically challenged/ mothers with young children - to work outside the home

• Women can discuss financial and management matters with migrated husbands (Potnis 2011; Aminuzzaman et al. 2002; Richardson, Ramirez & Haq 2000)

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 15

• Expose women previously difficult- to- acquire information caused by constraints imposed on travel outside the home (Goggin & Clark 2009; Lee 2009; Potnis 2011; Handapangoda & Kumara 2013)

• Mobile phone used within informal and non-formal educational contexts. (Balasubramanian’s et al. 2010)

• Reduced levels of domestic abuse and conflicts due to frequent communication between married women and their families and women’s ability to keep their husbands and family members updated about their whereabouts (which often leads to conflicts due to family anxiety about the women’s safety) (Lee 2009; Tacchi, Kitner & Crawford 2012)

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 16

Literature Review cont…

• Reinforcement of gender power relations:

• Village Pay Phone operators, predominantly rural Bangladeshi women who lent their mobile

phones to other villagers for a fee, later handed them over to their husbands or older children,

mostly male (Hultberg 2008).

• Women without their own mobile phones not allowed to use those of their family members

(Sundari 2010).

• Restrictions on their mobile phone use by male members of the family (Tacchi, Kitner & Crawford 2012).

• Main category of social contacts - husbands, children and female friends (Potnis 2011).

• ‘Nuisance calls’ received from (known or strange) men (Potnis 2011, pp. 43 & 44; Wanasundere 2012)

• Unemployed women must depend on their husbands for mobile expenditures (Potnis 2011;

Wanasundere 2012)

• Gender digital divide - 124 million fewer women than men own a mobile phone in South Asia (GSMA Development Fund, The Cherie Blair Foundation and Vital Wave Consulting 2010)

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 17

Literature Review cont…

• None of the studies look solely at female heads of households despite its growing number in the global south.

• Many have focused on more homogeneous female groups.

• Many have taken the quantitative approach in data gathering and analysis.

• It is important to examine the relevance and accessibility of services, type of content provided by mobile operators and current policy regulations.

• Studies in Sri Lanka:• Mainly conducted in the southern parts of the country• Focused on mobile use by the people in the Bottom of the Pyramid & on telecommunication

regulations• Focused on ICTs in general.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 18

Literature Review cont…

Research Methodology• The study is based on action research methodology, aiming to achieve a change

through social, economic and political development of a group of marginalised women living in remote and rural areas with less resources.

• Action research uses the experiences of research participants to generate data because it believes that participants are capable of giving reasons for their actions and goals. (Kemmis & McTaggart, p. 573; Gray 2009, p. 313)

• The project obtained ethics clearance submitted using the National Ethics Application Form (NEAF) via the Deakin University Human Research Ethics Committee (DUHREC), Reference Number 2014 – 125, as it involves field observations in remote areas overseas.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 19

• Qualitative data collection methods:• Depth interviews• Focus groups

• Population of the study were the female heads of households who are owners or have used a mobile phone during the previous three months in the Trincomalee District in Sri Lanka.

• The study was conducted in 2 DS divisions (Town & Gravets and Kinniya) of Trincomalee district from September to November, 2014.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 20

Research Methodology cont…

• Total of 30 semi-structured depth interviews with female heads of households were conducted - use of voluntary, purposive and snowball sampling

• 10 each from the Sinhalese, Tamils and Muslims

• 6 focus groups – • 6- 8 participants each (total of 36- 48 individuals) - a purposive sample of

female heads of households representing all three ethnicities of the local population.

• Membership of focus groups will be kept homogeneous as to their ethnicity and socio-economic status for a smoother flow of discussions.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 21

Data Analysis• The grounded theory method (Glaser & Strauss 1967; Strauss & Corbin 1990) was

used to analyse transcribed interviews, focus group discussions and field notes.

• The transcribed data of interviews and focus group discussions and field notes were then categorised in accordance with the research questions and the theoretical framework of the study. The coding ended with a theoretical saturation.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 22

Findings & Discussions • Many of the participants have engaged in income earning activities and

have become more interactive with the outside world after being the head of their households.

• Mobile phone has enabled them to balance their income earning activities and family responsibilities.

• As a result, it provided them a higher level of security, safety, reassurance and self-confidence in carrying out their daily activities.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 23

• They practised innovative strategies for the effective and efficient use of their mobile expenses.

• They have their own reasons to use a particular mobile phone, service provider and mobile phone functions and services.

• Participants whose husbands or relatives have migrated were more likely to use smart phones, yet their interaction with them is limited to interpersonal communication purposes.

• None of them used Value Added Services except ring in tones and only two participants used mobile money services.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 24

• Their interaction with the mobile phone was significantly shaped by the gendered power relations, inequalities and their multiple identities.

• Almost everyone of then have received and harassed by ‘nuisance calls’ more than once.

• Mainly Sinhalese and Tamil participants have been heavy users of the mobile phone before the marriage, yet after the marriage they have limited their interactions.

• Many of the Muslim participants have started using the mobile phone after the migration of their husbands as they are keen on maintaining the relationships and not to be abandoned.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 25

Findings & Discussions cont…

• All the participants mentioned that they are afraid of rumours about illicit liaisons and that they value maintaining their self-respect and reputation in their societies.

• They seek advice and help for their mobile phone adoption and related issues from a male family member, a male relation or male neighbours.

• Their adoption of the mobile phone has been shaped by their marriage, male migration, separation or widowhood and their children.

• Although these practices limit their use of the technology, there were many instances in which they challenged these gendered harassments.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 26

Findings & Discussions cont…

Conclusion• While man-made and natural destruction have disempowered and

victimised the women in Sri Lankan society, these disasters have also liberated women making them stronger and transforming their agency and traditional gender roles .

• Therefore, their present position in society is reflected in their mobile phone use as they assist such women to be more self-reliant and liberated.

• On the other hand, expected responsibilities and the role of a faithful, obedient wife, responsible mother and a respected single woman in a patriarchal society is reflected on their interaction with the mobile phone.

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 27

Thank You

15/04/23 Achala Abeykoon 28