Minoans2

8/14/2019 Minoans2

1/29

byClyde A. Winters, PhD

Uthman dan Fodio Institute 2007 C.A. Winters

The ancient people of Crete are called

Minoans or Eteocretans. The Egyptians

knew these people as the Keftiu.

The Keftiu or Minoans spoke the

Malinke-Bambara language. The Malinke-

Bambara language is a member of the

Mande group of languages which belongs

8/14/2019 Minoans2

2/29

to the Niger-Congo superfamily of

languages spoken in Africa.

Here is a picture of Keftiu from the

Egyptian tombs. They are bringing goods

to Egypt in their distinctive ceramics.

Minoans/Keftiu in Egyptian Relief

8/14/2019 Minoans2

3/29

LIBYAN ORIGIN OF MINOANS

Every since Sir Arthur Evans, discovered the

hieroglyphics and Linear A writing of Crete there has been a

search for the authors of this script. Evans (l921) suggested

that the Minoan civilization found its impetus from the

arrival of refugees from Libya to Crete.

Evans supported this hypothesis by discussing the

affinities between Crete and Libya, e.g., l) the writing of

Crete and Libyco-Berber (Manding) writing are similar

(Winters 1985),2) both groups wore the cod piece, and 3)

Men on a boat from Thera

8/14/2019 Minoans2

4/29

they share the identical customs of leaving a lock of hair

hanging down in front of the ears. The protruding tuft of hair

was associated with an initiatory rite dedicated to the

goddess Neith.(Bruson 1985) The goddess Neith or Athene,

was a Libyan goddess.

Other scholars have also found a Libyan influence an

Crete. A.B. Cook (1914), noted that the Libyan ram with

horns curved downward occurs in Minoan art. The ram is

associated with the goddess Athene (Neith). In addition

Pendlebury (l965) postulated a Libyan immigration to

southern Crete in the area of Messara (c.3000-2200 B.C.)

Hammond (l967), feels that the Libyans settled the plains of

Phaestos between 1900-1700 B.C. In addition

Dr. Alain Anselin (1984), has done a fine study of the Black

Libyans of Crete.

LINEAR A WRITING

Linear A writing is a variant of the Proto-Saharan writing,

used by the Manding in the Sahara. The earliest Manding

8/14/2019 Minoans2

5/29

inscriptions have been found at Oued Mertoutek. The Oued

Mertoutek inscription has been dated to 3000 B.C. , by

Wulsin (1941)

The Proto-Manding script has around 200-350 signs and

around 40 different forms. It is a syllabic script. (Winters

1983,1985b) Due to the early date assigned to the Oued

Mertoutek site, we can infer that the Proto-Saharan writing

was invented sometime earlier than 3000 B.C. Up to this day

the Manding writing is used by Manding secret societies.

(Winters 1977)

The hypothesis that the Eteocretans spoke a Manding

dialect is supported by a comparison of Minoan Linear A

signs and the Manding signs which were used in the Western

Sahara. Many of these signs are clearly cognates.

To further test this hypothesis that the Eteocretans

probably spoke a Manding language we compared Manding

and the Keftiu or Cretan names collected by the Egyptians.

(Peet 1917) Crete is mentioned in Egyptian documents of

8/14/2019 Minoans2

6/29

the First Intermediate Period and 18th Dynasty. (Strange

1980 :71-73; Vercoutter 1956:43-45)

The Ketiu personal names come from a schoolboy's

writing board of the 18th Dynasty. The heading of the

writing board now located in the British Museum was "How

to Make Names of Keftiu".

Although the Keftiu names have been compared to

Semitic without success, a comparison of these names with

Manding personal names provide startling agreement.

In Manding /b/, /f/ and /p/ are often interchangeable.

This suggest that the MInoans or Keftiu called themselves

Kebe, the name of a leading Manding clan. Or this name

may refer to the Keita Mande, the royal family from which

sprang the rulers of ancient Mali.

Keftiu , is made up by the root kef-, plus the localtive

suffix /-i/ used to give the affirmative sense, /-t/ the suffixial

element used to denote place names, nationality and

personal names, and /-u/ the plural suffix. Thus Keftiu can

8/14/2019 Minoans2

7/29

be interpreted as "The land of the Kefs". The Egyptians

probably pronounced the Minoan /b/ like /f/ . As a result the

Eteocretans probably called themselves Kebe (pl. Kebew)

and Crete Kebeta.

The term Caphor is probably based on the Egyptian work

Keftiu. The rulers of Kebeta, were called Mansa (> Manos).

On Egyptian writing board BM5647 there are eight Keftiu

names. These names agree with Manding names:

Keftiu (Kebetiw) Manding

'shr sye

nsy nsye

'ks nkyi

Pnrt Pe,Be-ni,Fu-ne

'dm Demba

Rs Rsa

Of the Keftiu names compared above we find startling

results four of these show full agreement, one name has

partial agreement and only one name lacks full or partial

agreement in both Manding and Keftiu.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

8/29

The personal name which shows partial agreement is

Pnrt. The root of the name Pnrt, is probably Pe. This name

can be easily explained by Manding grammar. If we break-

down Pnrt into its segments we have Pe, plus /-n/ a suffixial

element added to Manding words when they are verbalized.

The /-r/ (ra), is the suffix of the present participle ;and /-t/

(te) is the suffixial element used for form names. Thus Pnrt,

was probably pronounced Penrate.

LINEAR A INSCRIPTIONS

The Eteocretan inscriptions and tablets from the palaces

of Crete indicate that these buildings were mortuaries or

temples of the dead.

The idea that the palaces of Minoan Crete are in reality

mortuaries in not new. Oswald Spengler (l935) suggested

that the Minoan "labyriths" might be in reality temples of the

dead.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

9/29

Georg Wunderlich (l974) has the same views. He wrote

that "[T]he Minoans built genuine tombs for the preservation

and care of the dead. Their tombs were allowed to decay

when the old cult of the dead was superseded by

the "New" heroic method of cremation [introduced by the

Indo-Europeans] with its built in insurance against grave

robbing".

The Minoans practiced communal internment. the earliest

clan tombs were developed during the Neolithic; sites such

as Chrysolakkas near Mallia,and Arkhanes are examples of

this practice of making communal graveyards.The collective

graveyard at Arkhanes was replaced by a temple for the

dead.

Hagia Triada and the sanctuaries such as Iouktas were

probably also communal internment centres of the dead

dedicated to Neith or Athene the goddess who protected the

remains of the dead in their coffins or burial jars.

In Greek mythology Athene or Neith took the first olive

tree to be planted in Crete, after Libya became arid. (Graves

8/14/2019 Minoans2

10/29

1980:45) She was a major god in Libya and Lower Egypt.

This is significant because one of the pre-Islamic gods of the

Manding was called Ni-ya/Nia . This Nia is probably the

Neith of the Greeks. The goddess Neith came from Africa.

(Bernal 1986)

The goddess Neith is frequently mentioned in the

funerary tablets of ancient Crete in the form of Nia. A

comparison of the Vai (member of the Manding group) signs

and Linear A signs, indicate that the sign for Nia/

Neith is . This sign is formed by two symbols

na and___i. Thus was Nia among the

Manding. Ni-ya/ Nia was a mother goddess, protector of

nature and manifestation of life.

The association of many Minoan sites with the

underworld is evident from the presence of "double shields"

frescos, like the one at Knossos. In the ancient world ritual

shields were placed in tombs to ward off evil spirits.

(Wunderlich 1974:48-49) Among the ancient Egyptians the

8/14/2019 Minoans2

11/29

emblem of Neith the guardian of the coffins and canopic jars

was a shuttle or crossed shields . The center

of the Neith cult was Sais in the Delta. In Minoan Crete the

double shield motif in tombs and or sarcophagus may have

been used to indicate the presence of Neith. H.R. Hall,

observed that: "The characteristic Cretan figure-of-eight

shield is the same as the shield of the goddess Neith of Sais,

which probably goes back to early Neolithic days". (Hall

1927)

In Libya and Crete young children wore the uraeus

"serpent lock". This protruding tuft of hair was associated

with the initiatory rite dedicated to the goddess Neith.

According to Cook (l914), this coiffure was associated with

young Eteocretan initiates as late as the fifth century B.C.

Since many buildings of ancient Crete were temples of

the dead, most Linear A tablets, are funerary tablets. The

funerary tablets written in Linear A indicate that the people

put into these mortuaries were high born.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

12/29

In addition, their character appears to have been morally

sound because the documents speak of the deceased as

"becoming an amulet/object effective for its virtue". Thus

when these Cretans died they probably were deified as

first suggested by the remarkable scene discussed by Anta

Diop (l991) preserved on the Hagia Triada sarcophagus. This

indicates that people visited these tombs so they could btain

a blessing from the 'righteous dead'.

Due to our decipherment of the Minoan script, it has

become clear that the Minoans used Linear A to write

religious text. The corpus of Linear A inscriptions on tablets

and libation vessels show considerable repetition.

The sacred uses of the Linear A script is evident from the

numerous votive inscriptions found on stone objects of art

from the numerous Minoan sanctuaries excavated in Crete,

especially those found at Iouktas.(Karetsou 1985)

8/14/2019 Minoans2

13/29

LANGUAGE OF MINOAN INSCRIPTIONS

Since the Eteocretans were Manding speakers we can

read the Minoan inscriptions by comparing the Vai and

Minoan scripts to discover analogy in the shape and form of

the Linear A characters and the Vai characters. Once this is

done we give the Linear A sign its value in the Vai script, and

then use Malinke-Bambara to read the signs.

Each Linear A sign is monosyllabic. They are of the

consonant (C) vowel (V) class.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

14/29

The key to the decipherment of Linear A were:

1) the evidence of Manding migration to Crete; 2) repetition

of certain signs on Cretan libation vessels; and 3) this

regularity of inscriptions led to the assumption that the

inscriptions found in the sanctuaries are votive prayers.

The assumption that the inscriptions on sacred objects from

Crete were votive prayers made it possible to hypothesize

that the wish or desire requested in the inscriptions would

be addressed to a particular deity. This assumption proved

to be the correct one. Because a study of Linear A text

led to the discovery that a common sign in many of the text

was the sign, or the double axe of the votive vessels which

in both text represent the name Nia. This sign usually

appears once or twice in most Linear A documents and

votive inscriptions. This implied that Nia, was the

name of the major Eteocretan deity.

In the funerary tablets from Hagia Triada and

Arkhanes and votive prayers of Iouktas there is frequent

8/14/2019 Minoans2

15/29

mention of the dead inhabiting a place where they were "in

the company of Nia (Neith)" In an inscription from

Iouktas published by Karelsou, Godart and Oliver (1985):

Ni po-tu i-fe Yu-i I-gyo Nia

"This soul / is obliged to the order/ (his) breath of

life/ the vital spirit/(it is) thou in the company of the

divinity of the cult/(the Great) Nia". (See figure

18IOZa8)

In another interesting inscription from Iouktas we read

that:

Nia Yu tu-kpe fe-i po tu

8/14/2019 Minoans2

16/29

Nia/ the life blood/ the Ruler of Moral sweetness/

(she) is the breath of life/ the Pure Ruler".(See figure

IOZa2 Godart, et al 1985)

Nia is also mentioned many times in the Haghia Triada

documents published by Carralelli (l963). These tablets as all

Linear A tablets are read from right to left. In these texts it

is made clear that the dead reside in the company of Nia, in

a state of retreat. This is best illustrated in Carrotelli (l963)

illustration no. 12:

Nia ita-pa ta bu

"[You] exist with Nia in a unique state of retreat".

In Carratelli (l963) illustration no.7 side B, we find the

following:

8/14/2019 Minoans2

17/29

I Nia ita-pa i-fe pa-i

"In the company of Nia, thou exist in a most unique

state. Now you are very much empty".

It appears from the inscriptions that Haghia Triada was

the home of Neith. In Carratelli (l963) illustration no. 13 we

read the following:

Se gyo ta Nia lu.

A [fine] Supporter of the Diety (lies) here in Nia's

House".

8/14/2019 Minoans2

18/29

Our decipherment of the Linear A writing proves that the

Eteocretans came from Africa not the Middle East. It also

shows that even before rulers of the 18th Dynasty

conquered Keftiu, the rulers of this land were from

Libya.

These Linear A tablets give us valuable information about

the Minoans.Although the entire corpus of Linear A tablets

are concerned with statistics on flocks of sheep, harvests of

wheat and olives, and etc.; the Linear A tablets provide us

with a distinctive view of Eteocretan religion and devotion to

the goddess Nia or Neith.

Linear A Inscription

8/14/2019 Minoans2

19/29

References:

Anselin,A. 1982. LE MYTHE D'EUROPE DE L'INDUS A LA CRETE. Paris.

_________ 1984. "Zeus Ethiopien Minos Tomoul", CARBET REVUE MARTINIQUE

DE SCIENCE HUMANINES, 2:31-50.

Andah, B.Wai. 1981. "West Africa before the Seventh Century". In

GENERAL HISTORY OF AFRICA. VOL.II. UNESCO: Paris.

Andersson,T.G. 1934. CHILDREN OF THE YELLOW EARTH:STUDIES IN

PREHISTORIC CHINA. London.

Aravaanan,K. 1977. DRAVIDIANS AND AFRICANS. Madras.

Bagchi,P.C. 1955. INDIA AND CENTRAL ASIA. National Council of Education

:Calcutta.

Barich,B.E. 1978."Lo scavo di Uan Muhuggiag (Teshuinat) en altivita di

survey nell 'Acacus settentrionale". LIBYA ANTIQUE, XV: 1-12.

Barker,G.W. 1989. "From classification to interpretation : Libyan

Prehistory 1969-1989". LIBYAN STUDIES, 20:31-43.

Behrens,P. 1984. "Language and migration of the early Sahara cattle

herders, the formation of the Berber branch".In LIBYA ANTIQUA. (UNESCO

Report:Paris) Pp.30-50.

Bellwood,Peter. 1991. "The Austronessian Dispersal and the zorigin of

Language". SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN. July.

Brenjes,B. 1983. "On Proto-Elamite Iran". CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY,

24(2):240-.

Bernal,I. 1969. THE OLMEC WORLD. University of Calif. Press:Los

Angeles.

Bernal,M. 1986. "Black Athena:The African and Levantine roots of

Greece",JOURNAL OF AFRICAN CIVILIZATION,7(2):66-82.

Bradley,M. 1981. THE BLACK DISCOVERY OF AMERICA. Personal Lib.:Toronto.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

20/29

Brice,W.C. 1983. "Notes on Linear A". KADMOS 22(2):51-106.

Burrow,T.& M.B. Emeneau. 1961. A DRAVIDIAN ETYMOLOGICAL DICTIONARY.

London.

Bynon,T. 1977. HISTORICAL LINGUISTICS. Cambridge Univ. Press: London.

Caldwell,R. 1974. A COMPARATIVE GRAMMAR OF THE DRAVIDIAN. Delhi.

Camps,G. 1974. LE CHEVAL ET LA CHAR DANS LA PREHISTORIQUES DE L'AFRIQUE

NORD ET DU SAHARA. Doin: Paris.

Camps,G. 1974. LES CIVILIZATION PREHISTORIQUES DE L'AFRIQUE DU NORD ET

DU SAHARA. Doin: Paris.

Carratelli,G.P. 1963. LE EPIGRAFI DI HAGHIA TRIADA EN LINEARE A.

Universidad de Salamanca.

Close,A. E. 1988. "Current research and recent radiocarbon dates from

Northern Africa". JOURNAL OF AFRICAN HISTORY, 29:145-176.

Chang,K.C. 1980. SHANG CIVILIZATION. Yale University Press: New Haven.

_________ 1987. THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF ANCIENT CHINA. YALE University

Press:New Haven.

Cook,A.B. 1914. ZEUS A STUDY IN ANCIENT RELIGION. CAMBRIDGE.

Delafosse,M. 1901. ESSAI de MANUEL PRACTIQUE MANDE AU MANDINGUE, Paris.

___________ 1899. "Vai leur langue et leur systeme d'ecriture",

L'ANTHOPOLOGIE, 10.

Diop, Cheik Anta. 1974. THE AFRICAN ORIGIN OF CIVILIZATION ,MYTH OR

REALITY .(Trs.) by Mercer Cook. Lawrence Hill Pub. :Westport Conn.

________________ 1977. PARENTE GENETIQUE DE L'EGYPTIEN PHARANIQUE ET

DES LANGUES NEGRO-AFRICAINES. NEA: Dakar.

________________ 1978. THE CULTURAL UNITY OF BLACK AFRICA. Third World

Press: Chicago.

________________ 1984. "Formation of the Berber Branch". In LIBYA

ANTIQUA (UNESCO: Paris) Pp.69-72.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

21/29

________________ 1988. NOUVELLES RECHERCHES SUR L'EGYPTIEN ANCIEN ET

LES LANGUES NEGRO-AFRICAINES MODERNES. Presence Africaine: Paris.

________________ 1991. CIVILIZATION OF BARBARISM. Lawrence Hills Pub.:

Westport Conn.

Drucker,P. et al. 1959. EXCAVATIONS AT LA VENTA,TABASCO, 1955. Bureau

of American Ethnology Bulletin 170. Washington,D.C.

Dzierzykray-Rogalski,T. 1978. "On the Black variety at Kadero,Sudan".

CURRENT ANTHROPOLOGY, 19(2):406-407.

Ehret,C. 1979. "On the antiquity of agriculture in Ethiopis", JOURNAL

OF AFRICAN CIVILIZATION, 20:161-165.

_______ 1988. "Language change and the material correlates of language

and ethnic shift". ANTIQUITY 62:564-572.

Ehret,C. & M.Posnansky.1982. THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL AND LINGUISTIC

RECONSTRUCTION OF AFRICAN HISTORY. BERKELEY.

Evans,A.1921. THE PALACE OF MINOS. McMillan: London.

Fairservis,W.A. 1962. THE ANCIENT KINGDOMS OF THE NILE. London.

______________ 1975. THE ROOTS OF ANCIENT INDIA. Univ. of Chicago

Press: Chicago.

Fu Ssu-Nien.1935. "Yi Hsia tang Hsi Shuo". In PAPERS PRESENTED TO

MR.Ts'ao Yuan Pe'i on his Sity-fifth Birthday'. Institute of History

and Philosophy ,Academia,(Sinica: Nanking)pp.88-129.

Gadd,C.J. 1924. A SUMERIAN READING BOOK. Clarendon Press: Oxford.

Galand, Lionel. 1968. INSCRIPTIONS LIBYQUES. Paris.

Gostony, C.G. 1975. DICTIONNAIRE D'ETYMOLOGIE SUMERIENNE ET GRAMMAIRE

COMPARES. De Boccard: Paris.

Greenberg,J.H. 1970. THE LANGUAGES OF AFRICA. University of Indiana

:Bloomington.

_____________ 1987. LANGUAGE IN THE AMERICAS. STANDFORD UNIVERSITY

PRESS: Standford.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

22/29

Graves,R. 1980. THE GREEK MYTHS. London.

________ 1982. THE WHITE GODDESS. Pelican Books: New York.

Hall,H.R. 1928. THE CIVILIZATION OF GREECE IN THE BRONZE. London

Hammond,N.G.L. 1967. A HISTORY OF GREECE. Oxford.

Harlan,J.R.1976. ORIGINS OF AFRICAN PLANT DOMESTICATION. New York.

Hoffman, Michael A. 1979. EGYPT BEFORE THE PHAROAHS. Alfred A. Knope:

New York.

Holl, Augustin. 1989. "Social issues in Saharan Prehistory". JOURNAL

ANTHROPOLOGICAL ARCHAEOLOGY 8:313-354.

______________. 1985. "Subsistence patterns of the Dhar Tichitt

Neolithic Mauritania". THE AFRICAN ARCHAEOLOGICAL REVIEW, 3:151-162.

______________. 1985. "Background to the Ghana Empire: Archaeological

investigation on the transition to statehood in the Dar Tichitt

region (Mauritania)", JOURNAL OF ANTHROPOLOGICAL ARCHAEOLOGY ,4:73-115.

Homburger,L. 1951. "Le Telugu et Mende dialects",JOUR. LA SOC.

AFRICAINES .

___________ 1964. "Sibilants en Sindo-Africaine", JOUR. DE SOC.

AFRICAINES.

Jelinsk, J. 1985. "Tilizahren, the key site of the Fezzanese Rock Art".

ANTHROPOLOGIE, 23(3):223-275.

Kabusiewicz,M. et al. 1976. "The Prehistory of the Egyptian Sahara",

SCIENCE, 913: 103-4.

Kao Chih-Hsi. 1986."An Introduction to Shang and Chou Bronze Nao

excavated in South China. In STUDIES IN SHANG ARCHAEOLOGY,(ed.) by K.C.

Chang. New Haven.

Karetsou,A.,Godart,L., et J. Poliver.1985. "inscription en lineaire A

du sanctuaire de Sommet Minoen du mont Iouktas", KADMOS, 24(2):89-147.

Ki-Zerbo,J. 1979. "The Cradle of Mankind". UNESCO COURIER,

Aug./Sept.:42-44.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

23/29

Krzyzaniak,L. 1978. "New Light on early food production in the Central

Sudan". JOURNAL OF AFRICAN HISTORY, 19(2):160-167.

___________ 1975. "Kadero". ETUDES ET TRAVAUX, 8:364-368.

Kan, Yang. 1985. "The Bronze culture of Western Yunnan". BULL. OF THE

ANCIENT ORIENT MUSEUM, (Tokyo) 7:47-91.

Kramer,S.N. 1963. THE SUMERIANS. University of Chicago Press:Chicago.

Labat,R. 1950-51. STRUCTURE DE LA ELAMITE. Conferences de l'Institut de

Linguistique de l'Universite de Paris IX: 25-42.

Lacouperie,Terrien de. 1887. THE LANGUAGES OF CHINA BEFORE THE

CHINESE.PARIS

--------------------- 1889. "Origin from Babylon and Elam of the early

Chinese Civilization. A summary of the proof" BABYLONIAN AND

ORIENTAL RECORD 3(5): 97-111.

_____________________ 1892. THE YA-KING AND ITS AUTHORS. London

Navarrete,C. 1976. "The Olmec rock carvings at Pijijipan , Chiapas,

Mexico and Other Olmec Pieces, from Chiapas and Guatemala", NEW WORLD

ARCHAEOLOGICAL FOUNDATION, NO.35. BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY PRESS.UTAH

LAHOVARY,N. 1957. DRAVIDIAN ORIGINS AND THE WEST. Longmans:Madras.

Lawrence,H.G. 1962. AFRICAN EXPLORERS TO THE NEW WORLD. Aquarian

Spiritual Center Los Angeles.

Lal. B.B. 1963. "The only Asian expedition in threatened Nubia: Work by

an Indian mission at Afyeh and Tumas". THE ILLUSTRATED LONDON

TIMES, 20 April.

Langdon,S. 1911.SUMERIAN GRAMMAR AND CHRESTOMATHY. Paul Geuthner:Paris.

Li Xueqin.1986. EASTERN ZHOU AND QIN CIVILIZATION. New Haven.

Lord,Robert. 1974. COMPARATIVE LINGUISTICS. St. Paul's House: London.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

24/29

Maglangbayan,S.& C. Moore. 1976. "BBB Interviews Dr. Chiek Anta Diop",

BLACK BOOKS BULLETIN, 4(4):30-37.

Marks,A.E., Muhammad-Ali,A. & R. Fattovich. 1986. "The Archaeology of

the Eastern Sudan: A First Look". ARCHAEOLOGY , Sept./Oct.: 44-50.

Mc Cauley,J.F., G.G. Schaber,C.S. Breed, M.J. Grolier, C.V. Haynes, B.

Issawi, C. Elachi and R. Bloom. 1982. "Subsurface Valleys and

Geoarchaeology of the Eastern Sahara Revealed by Shuttle Radar",

SCIENCE ,CCXV11: 1004-20.

McIntosh,S.K. & R.J. McIntosh. 1979. "Initial perspectives on

prehistoric subsistence in the Inland Niger Delta (Mali)", WORLD

ARCHAEOLOGY 2(2):240.

____________________________. 1981. "West African Prehistory", AMERICAN

SCIENTIST, 69:602-613.

____________________________ 1983. "Forgotten Tells of

Mali",EXPEDITION:38.

____________________________ 1986. "Arcaeological Research and dates

from West Africa",JOURNAL OF AFRICAN HISTORY 27:413-42.

____________________________ 1988. "Fron stone to metal: New

Perspectives on the later Prehistory of West Africa" .JOURNAL OF WORLD

PREHISTORY 2(1):89-109.

___________________________ 1988b. "From sciecles obscurs to

revolutionary centuries on the Middle Niger". WORLD ARCHAEOLOGY,

20(1):141-165.

McAlpin,D.W. 1981. PROTO-ELAMO DRAVIDIAN: THE EVIDENCE AND ITS

IMPLICATION. Trans. of the Am. Philosophical Society 71, Part 3.

Philadelphia.

Meenakshisundaran,T.P. 1965. A HISTORY OF TAMIL LANGUAGE. Poona.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

25/29

Meggars,B.T. 1975."The Transpacific origin of Meso-American

Civilization", AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST ,77:10-11.

Meillet,A. 1926. LINGUISITIQUE HISTORIQUE ET LINGUISTIQUE GENERALE.

Paris.

Monod,Theodore. 1938. CONTRIBUTIONS A L'ETUDE DU SAHARA

OCCIDENTAL:GRAVURES ,PEINTURES ET INSCRIPTIONS RUPESTRES. Fascicule l.

Serie A. Du Comite D'etudes Historiques et Scientifiques de l'Afrique

Occidentale Francaise. Librairie Larose:Paris.

Munson,P. 1976. "Archaeological data on the origins of cultivation in

the southwestern Sahara and their implications for West Africa".

In ORIGINS OF AFRICAN PLANT DOMESTICATION,(ed.) J.R. Harlan.Paris.

Muttarayan,K.L. 1975. "Sumerian, Tamil of the first Cankan". JOURNAL

OF TAMIL STUDIES, 7:41-61.

Nayar,T.B. 1977. THE PROBLEM OF DRAVIDIAN ORIGINS, LINGUISTIC,

ANTHROPOLOGICAL APPROACH. Madras.

Neil,P. 1980. "New Light on China's Oldest Civilization",ASIA

(May/June):16-21.

Obenga,Th. 1988. "Esquisse d'une histoire culturelle de l'Afrique par

la lexicologie". PRESENCE AFRICAINE: 1-25.

__________ 1973. L'AFRIQUE DANS L'ANTIQUITE. Presence Africains:Paris.

Osing,J. 1980. LIBYEN BIBYE.

Paris,M.E. 1953. "Recherche sur l'Origine des Marques di Tribus",

Bulletin de l'IFAN , ser. A: 1632.

Peet,T.E. 1927. "The Egyptian writing Board BM5647 bearing Keftiu

Names".In ESSAYS IN AGEAN ARCHAEOLOGY PRESENTED TO SIR A. EVANS,(ed.)

S. Casson ,(Oxford 1927) Pp.90-99.

Pendlebury,J.D.S.1965. THE ARCHAEOLOGY OF CRETE. New York.

Quellec,Jean loic Le. 1985. "Les Gravures Rupestres du Fezzan (Libye).

L'ANTHROPOLOGIE (Paris), Tome 89(3):365-383.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

26/29

Rafinesque,C.S. 1832. "Second letter to Mr. Champollion on the Graphic

Systems of America and the glyphs of Otolum or Palenque in Central

America--elements of the glyphs". ATLANTIC JOURNAL 1(2):44-45.

Renfrew,Colin. 1987. ARCHAEOLOGY AND LANGUAGE. Jonathan Cape:London.

Rensberger, B. 1981. "Black Kings of Ancient America", SCIENCE DIGEST

9:73-77 and 122.

Roset,J.P. 1983. "Nouvelles donnees sur le probleme de la

Neolithisation du Sahara meridional: Air et Tenere au Niger",CASHIERS

O.R.S.T.O.M. 13(2):119-142.

__________ 1987. "Paleoclimatic and cultural conditions of Neolithic

Develop -ment in the early Holocene of Northern Niger (Air and

Tenere). In PREHISTORY OF ARID NORTH AFRICA,(ed.) by A.E.

Close,(Dallas)pp.211-34.

Smith,A.B. 1974. "Preliminary report on excavation at Karkarichinkat",

WEST AFRICAN JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY 4: 53-55.

Sjoberg,A.W. 1984. THE SUMERIAN DICTIONARY. Vol. 2. The University

Museum:Philadelphia.

Spengler,Oswald. 1935. ZUR WELLGESCHICHTE DES ZWEITEN VOCHRISTLICHEN

JAHRTAUSENDS. Munich.

Strange,J.L. 1980. CAPHTOR,KEFTIU:A NEW INVESTIGATION. Brill:Leiden.

Soustelle,J. 1984. THE OLMECS. Doubleday & Company:New York.

Swadash,M.1953. THE LANGUAGE OF THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL HUASTECS. Carnegie

Institution Notes on Middle American Archaeology and Ethnology,no.114.

Talbot,M.R. 1980. "Environmental Responses to Climate change in the

West African Sahel over the past 20,000 Years". In THE SAHARA AND THE

NILE, (ed.) by M.A. Williams and H. Faure ,(Balkema: Rotterdam) pp.37-

62.

Ting Shan, "Yu san-tai tu-yi lun Ch'i in tsu, wen-hua", BULLETIN OF THE

INSTITUTE OF HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY,(Academia:Sinica) 5:89-129.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

27/29

Vamos-Toth,Bator.1983. TAMANA. Honolulu.

von Wuthenau,A. 1980. UNEXPECTED FACES IN ANCIENT AMERICA. Second

Edition.Humanitas Americana Foundation:San Angel ,Mexico.

Upandhyaya,U.P. 1971. "Dravidian and Negro-African". INTERNATIONAL

JOURNAL DRAVIDIAN LINGUISTICS, 5:32-64.

Webster,B. 1980. "African Cattle Bones stir Scientific Debate", NEW

YORK TIMES, 27 August.

Wendorf,F. 1983. "Use of barley in the Egyptian late Paleolithic",

SCIENCE, 205:1341-1347.

Welmers,Wm. 1971. "Niger-Congo Mande". CURRENT TRENDS IN LINGUISTICS,

7:113-140.

__________ 1973. AFRICAN LANGUAGE STRUCTURES. Univ. of Calif. Press .

Wiercinski,A. &R. A. Jairazbhoy. 1975. THE NEW DIFFUSIONIST,5(18):5.

Wiener,Leo. 1922. AFRICA AND THE DISCOVERY OF AMERICA. PHILADELPHIA. 3

vols.

Wilson,J.V.K. 1974. INDO-SUMERIAN. Oxford.

Winters,Clyde Ahmad. 1977. "The influence of the Mande scripts on

ancient American Writing Systems", BULL. DE L'IFAN, t 39 ser B,

no.2:941-967

____________________ 1979. "African scripts in the New World Part l",

JOURNAL OF AFRICAN CIVILIZATIONS VOL. 1.

____________________ 1980. "The genetic unity of Dravidian and African

languages and culture". Proceedings of the First International

Symposium on Asian Studies (Proc. ISAS) 1979 , (Asian Research

Service: Hong Kong) vol.5: 1105-1120.

____________________ 1981. "Are Dravidians of African Origin?", PROC.

2ND ISAS,1980, vol.3:789-807.

____________________ 1981b."The African influence on Indian

Agriculture", JOURNAL OF AFRICAN CIVILIZATION 3(1):100-111.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

28/29

____________________ 1981c. "Mexico's Black Heritage", THE BLACK

COLLEGIAN ,12(3):76-85.

____________________ 1983. "The Ancient Manding script". In BLACKS IN

SCIENCE :ANCIENT AND MODERN, (ed) by Ivan Van Sertima (Transaction

Books:London), Pp.208-214.

____________________ 1983b. "Les Fondateurs de la Grece venaient

d'Afrique en passant par le Crete", AFRIQUE HISTOIRE, no.8:13-18.

____________________ 1983c. "Blacks in ancient China, Part l: The

Founders f Xia and Shang", JOURNAL OF BLACK STUDIES,1(2):8-13.

____________________ 1985. "The Proto-Culture of the Dravidians,

Manding, and Sumerians ", TAMIL CIVILIZATION 3(l):1-9.

____________________ 1985b. "The Indus Valley Writing and related

scripts of the 3rd Millennium BC", INDIA PAST AND PRESENT ,2(1):13-19.

____________________ 1985c. "The Genetic Unity between the Dravidian,

Elamite, Manding and Sumerian Languages". PROC. 6TH ISAS 1984,

vol.5:1413-1425.

___________________ 1985d. "The Far Eastern Origin of the Dravidians".

JOURNAL OF TAMIL STUDIES, no.27: 65-92.

__________________ 1986."Blacks in Ancient America", COLORLINES

3(2):26-27.

___________________ 1986b."The Rise of Islam in the Western Sahara",

THE TOPAZ, 2(1):5-15.

___________________ 1986c. "The Migration routes of the Proto-Mande",

THE MANKIND QUARTERLY, 27(1):77-96.

___________________ 1988. "The Dravidian and Manding Substratum in

Tokharian, CENTRAL ASIATIC JOURNAL, 32(1-2):131-141.

__________________ 1989. "Tamil, Sumerian, Manding and the Genetic

Model",International Journal of Dravidian Linguistics, 18(1):67-91.

8/14/2019 Minoans2

29/29

Wulsin, F.R. 1941. THE PREHISTORIC ARCHAEOLOGY OF NORTHWEST AFRICA.

Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology,

Vol.19.

Wunderlich,H.G. 1974. THE SECRET OF CRETE. New York.

Zahn,D. 1974. THE BAMBARA. Leiden.